Lowepro Protactic 450 AW II Review vs Peak Design Everyday Backpack | Why I Upgraded

[@DavidMinhTRA]

One of the best video I found on KZbin about testing professional video/photo bag. Thank you

[@BrendanvanSon]

Thanks dude. Good review. Just ordered it.

[@kieranlehane]

How you liking it? Maybe do a video on it :)

[@richhughes2225]

Thanks. Good review, clear and complete - I need a pack for my DSLR and want to upgrade from my 400AW. The feature that sold me on LowePro is the rear access. Kyle, I always use the waist strap because I don't have to take off the pack and set it down. I simply get out of the shoulder straps, slide the pack around and open the back panel to access my gear. I also appreciate the integrated rain cover.

[@Justin_tech]

Great vid! Will it fit the new 16" Macbook Pro?

[@NickMango]

+1 I’d like to know this too.

[@spirosfilmmaking]

me too!

[@spirosfilmmaking]

I think it will. Laptop Compartment Dimensions:2.2 x 37 x 29 cm: mb pro 16 inch dimension: 1.62 x: 35.79 x 24.59cm

[@JonasReichert1992]

Yes

[@quantgenius]

Love the Lowepro. If the laptop pocket were bigger so I could fit a 16inch Macbook Pro and a 12.9 inch iPad plus some space for a file folder or notebook, it would be my perfect backpack.

[@nygmaa]

Great video! 3 and a half years old but you really helped me for this summer! Also it's pretty deep compared to other bag, so much space!

[@metalmick99]

Very nice review, although the Lowepro weighs-in at almost 3kg according to their website whereas the 30 litre PD weighs almost 1kg less (with dividers). In Australia at least, airlines are very strict on total weight limits of carry-on luggage, so with the Lowepro, it might incur extra expenses or the user be obliged to check it in, or alternatively, some equipment might have to remain at home. I do like the Lowepro in principle though, and your reasons for preferring it were quite compelling

[@metalmick99]

@@robertlee6338 I think it's obvious that you weren't in Terminal 4 of Tullamarine when I was, or you'd have seen airline staff checking carry-on baggage for weight, except those who were carrying things like laptop bags.

[@CosmiqueVlogs]

Great video! I just got the 350 AW II, but I'll be returning it for the 450. It's also cheaper too

[@KylePugliese]

It’s a great travel bag!

[@ellavarkumnamaskaram]

Just got my 450 aw II bfre 2hrs. Gonna do almost similar organisation as yours. Bought the 350 aw II first but returned coz of less space. Thanx for the video.

[@SuperBlaustern]

Thank you very much for this nice review! Answered all of my questions and I will definitely order this one 😊

[@Shaneword99]

I just bought this bag cuz of your video... was thinking about getting the 350 but didn't know and after seeing how much space the 450 has I went ahead and bought it. thanks for the info!

[@deezuschrist]

Great review. I got the Peak Design Travel bag and found some similar issues with functionality....you can't open the front compartment when you've got the bag lying down with the main compartment open, so it renders the front compartment useless. I also don't like how they don't have have those zipper pockets on the inside flap the way the LowePro bag does...I love being able to access everything all in one place. I don't want to have to close everything up, and flip the bag over to reach the zipper pouches in the front compartment. I waited too long to return my Peak Design bag so I'm probably just going to keep it for other purposes, because it still is a really nice bag, but I recently bought the LowePro Protactic for my videography purposes.

[@KylePugliese]

I've been traveling this week and can definitely confirm the convenience of the lowepro over the peak. You have some good points, I like the peak and it's a great looking bag and well built. But functionally Lowepro has worked out some kinks to make it a better bag. At least for us videographers.

[@praxis-cat870]

You can use the pass-through zippers on the divider compartment to reach anything in the front compartment provided you're not using the large camera cube. I love my PD Travel Line, but it's a travel bag first and a camera bag second, with the lowpro being a camerabag first and a travel bag nowhere.

[@Burritosarebetterthantacos]

Had the peak immediately returned it. Got a Wandrd camera cube and use it with my travel bag. Might grab a protactic just for work but it’s a little intense for my everyday stuff

[@TheFaustianMan]

This was very insightful and well done!

[@v-0448]

Ive outgrown my 350 AW II and probably will be switching to the 450. Thanks for the review.

[@nickgorham5964]

Great review! I just ordered this pack along with several of the pouches and cases. I'm glad I came across your channel. Keep up the good work! Subscribed!

[@TheCicada007]

Good review dude! Do you think it will fit a Mac 16"? I am a frequent flyer. how heavy is the bag?

[@KatieF307]

Great review! Yeah, I want to like the Peak Design bag...but I don't. I bought it twice, and returned them within a day. I am still debating which bag I will move to from an older Think Tank bag.

[@deetoxvengeance]

Could you tell if a 17" LG Gram (very slim) would fit?

[@idrissamorehouse5776]

Great video - i agree -love PEEKs design ethic but the new wave of bags using the tactical molly system + back flap creates so much more frictionless possibilities -

[@Mikri90]

My feelings about Peak Design is that it's a company that makes great products overall in terms of quality but they are lacking the "photography-sense" in terms of functionality with their backpacks. They play on the card of being trendy. Their backpacks are nicely designed in terms of esthetics and are well made but they are also design as if the team designing them have next to no experience of using camera gear in the field. This video really highlights the issues well. The access points are weird, and on top of that it is also a hazard in the making if you don't check if the sides are zipped up. They don't offer much in terms of organization and they seem like they only work if you use few large lenses in order to maximize the volume of the bag. There's not enough dividers and the options to customize the layout. They also offer very little in terms of additional pockets and storage areas. As if they are meant to carry just the cameras and lenses, ignoring that both photographers and videographers need so much more. It sucks to see that because the company has so much potential. I am a very satisfied user of their Slide strap as well as the capture clip. But I don't see myself ever using their bags unless they do a complete 180 with their design philosophy for the backpacks.

[@Tiigerific]

Thanks for the review, definitely getting a pro tactic now!

[@MarkThomasBuilder]

Great review. I'm looking to upgrade to the Lowepro 450. Are you still using it today? Can you bring it on an airplane, either put up above or under a seat? Thanks.

[@KylePugliese]

Still love it for long trips and flights. It's a bigger bag so I don't use it as much around town or day trips but for a few days it's great. The padding it offers for gear is top notch. It fits under a seat but just fits. If you need to put it in overhead it's a bit tight but also works.. it's been a while I don't think it works facing toward the door on overhead so it would sit length wise.

[@MarkThomasBuilder]

@@KylePugliese Thanks for all your advice Kyle, I ordered one and it just arrived today. I can't wait to move all my gear over to it. I'll probably keep my smaller Lowepro bag for flights if I only need to bring minimal gear. Have a great day!

[@KylePugliese]

Glad you’re enjoying it!

[@AndreiDinTheHouse]

I had the same dillema so between the 450 and peak design .... I went with the 350. I found Peak Design not great for me because even the "30L" version is actually 22, but if you extend it via the magnetic latch, on the 3rd and 4th bracket it creates some "holes" where rain and dust goes in easily.

[@rogalaphotography]

I’m a HUGE fan of LowePro bags! I have 3 camera bags (Protactic AW, Powder and the Sling). Currently I am using the Powder but I may switch back to the Protactic for summer.

[@DanHelton]

Good review 👍

[@brandonlaymanfilms]

Great video! Super helpful.

[@bukytaiwo9500]

Just purchased the bag

[@yuqin405]

A series question, id it deep enough for a D4 standing?

[@rapaent]

Thank you for the awesome review!! Looks like it would be perfect for my use. I have a question if you don't mind? 1) Could you give the width & length dimensions of the side zippered opening for access to the interior of the bag? I'd like to use it for my Sony PXW-X70 camcorder. Thanks again.... Great job.

[@mascmedia_]

Good review and comparison. I've got the PD20 and it's a great bag, but it's a bit small for me these days. I think I'm going to make the change

[@danieltan9999]

Hi! Great review! I was just wondering if the dividers and inserts can be fully removed to convert this into an everyday backpack if I need to. Thanks!

[@KylePugliese]

Yep, absolutely. You can take all of them out and put the exact amount, if any, back in one by one.

[@mjfalcon007]

Hi Man, nice review. I am in a similar situation myself. I have had the smaller Peak Design everyday since release and I have been looking at either the 350Aw or 450aw. My only concern is if 450 might be a little too big. I tend to carry a Fuji X T1 with a 35 and 85, an X100F and a Leica M4 and maybe a drone. I’ll have to see them in person. I guess having extra room for some clothes or a jacket might be a good thing too.

[@joelsmtb3511]

Hi, I can’t choose between the Lowe pro and peak design, I’d be using it for dog walks or sometimes hiking, I would also use it for daily commuting to school.

[@Hoppy100]

Just got the lowpro.… great bag.

[@FabrizioZago]

Nice in-depth review! What do you think about this backpack nearly one year after the review?

[@djveitch]

Excellent review Kyle! Really good insight to the Protactic AW II. I'm in a similar situation having the Peak Design V1 20L backpack and looking to upgrade to a bag with more capacity. Narrowed down to either the PD 30L V2 or the Protactic. Love the rear access and prefer the dual side access of the Protactic, presume quicker access when using 2 camera bodies at weddings. I find the PD works well for day to day travel as well as being tidier with its loose straps and IMO better looking 🤔 How does capacity compare? Which bag do you think you could fit more into?

[@mattbrowning8624]

How do you feel about the 450 as of now? I'm debating between that and the Everyday Backpack V2 30L. Will be using it for GoPro & accessories as well as an EDC and as a carry-on travel bag. Guessing with either one I'd still need an actual case for the GoPro stuff instead of sticking all of it directly in the bag?

[@djveitch]

Hey Matt I'm in the same boat as you with deciding between those two. Did you make a decision?

[@mattbrowning8624]

David Veitch I ended up getting the V2 30L but because of COVID haven’t been able to use it much. Just the look and feel though, it’s amazing.

[@mithinwilliam8453]

Will I be able to squeeze in a macbook pro 16inch?

[@TreasureCorals]

Yes, I tried it - works great.

[@mauriciohernandezz-conjuga2430]

Thanks for great content. Will the Lowepro stay "up" when put on the floor? Peak design's never stays up

[@mikecall2057]

Do you think the 450aw2 will fit the 16”MacBook Pro?

[@Best_Chuansatien]

Yes

[@TomatenDK]

Does anyone know where I can order the bottle pouch ? Rly strugling to find that one in the video :/

[@8b0i21]

I'm quite short, 5.4 to be exact. Do you think the lowepro is too big for me?

[@BackpackeRom]

what is the capacity/volume of the bag?? pls

[@tuahajawaid671]

Solid review. Do check out Wandered Provoke. Been looking into that. A better option for mirrorless imo. I like how I can use it as an everyday bag with my camera gear.

[@KylePugliese]

Now I want another bag haha

[@maximvonjosefsson8872]

Great review man, I love the army design to it! Watching you from Stockholm, Sweden 😏💪

[@KylePugliese]

Thanks, yeah it has a great stealth look to it. Nice, I bet it's a bit colder there this time of year, haha.

[@siriusrha]

Does it work for the DJI FPV? I can't decide whether to buy this or the PGYTECH OneMo?

[@BenSake]

Thanks for all the info, seems like the right backpack for me. One question, how tall are you?? Just trying to imagine how big this would look on my back.

[@SmokinBuddha]

I got my Lowepro 450 AW II today and I'm 5'8". This bag is actually cheaper than the smaller Lowepro 350 AW II

[@NicoManansala]

are all these accessories included on the 450AW?

[@innsvp]

I have both and they are very good backpacks. Lowepro I use when I have more stuff to carry and Peak for lighter set up which is more convenient. Both are great!

[@jamojones8217]

what are in internal dimensions of the main compartment? Looking on amazon the cases that your putting in the bag don't seem to add up with the dimensions of the internal main compartment of the backpack.

[@calopepapi4744]

Amazing review! I’m currently using the incase dslr pro and I’ve been looking around for a new bag as I want more flexibility with what I can pack stuff in. Because with the incase, the dividers are 2 long ones and a bunch of short ones, the main compartments are vertical... which can waste a bunch of space. I’m looking for a way to set up my camera stuff vertical and use the rest of the space for a packing cube and put some travel clothes in. I’m a minimal packer and use minimal photo gear. The review you did was amazing, and I feel I’ll get the lowepro, one question I did have was, for the water bottle pouch, does it fit and Nalgene 1L bottle? And I’m also wondering if this bag is compliant with European domestic carry on dimensions (without the pouch attached).

[@jordentan]

Is the lowe considered cabin size?

[@KylePugliese]

I fly with it regularly and have never had issues

[@nooons3190]

would my gears fit in it? 16" macbook laptop a7iv sigma 85mm 1.4 sony 70-200mm f2.8 gm II tamron 28-75mm g2 godox v1 godox transmitter godox flash accessories 2 batteries 4 chargers (phone, flash, battery, laptop) powerbank gopro cleaning kit

[@cagdasdmr]

Thank you for the review. I am planing to order one but I have just one question. Can we pack full size tripod (Manfrotto 055 for exm.) on the front with the tripod pouch. That is really important for me and if you can answer me that would be a great help. Thanks

[@KylePugliese]

I haven't tried but given it's using molle panels you should be able to strap it on, it may just stick above the height of the backpack a bit.

[@cagdasdmr]

@@KylePugliese Thank you for the reply. That is no problem as long as straps and pouch can hold the weight.

[@yihchang]

Great review and comparion

[@niknnaik]

Hey man, great video. I have just purchased one and it has arrived today but the stitching is not perfect and is coming apart in various places, do you think its a fake? Also in my country, the product is not officially available in store so had to pay a premium for it around $300 so want to make sure it is an original.

[@KylePugliese]

Thanks! That sounds like a fake to me, this is definitely a quality bag and I've put mine through a beating the last six months and it still looks practically new. It should be between $250-300 new so that's not too bad. I'd return it and try another vendor if possible

[@niknnaik]

@@KylePugliese Yes I've sent it back. Thanks for the heads up. Gotta find one in retail to get the real deal. Cheers

[@musclerambo1]

Great bag! Do you know how deep the bag is? I need one for my 1DX Mark II, but wondering if it's deep enough for it? How about the dimensions of the topload (1:44)? I am thinking of using this bag for my camera with EF 100-400mm II attached, but not sure if that hole (1:45) is wide enough for my camera?

[@dasklima5751]

I own the older version, even a Nikon D810 with a 24-70 2.8 is not easy to get out and in. And the f...ing raincover is not rainproof. After a heavy rain.... new camera. Best shoulderstraps ever. Even with 12kg is 30km hicking no problem. Actionsports like running or mountainbiking ...no problem, the bachpack is glued on the back. But the raincover...

[@PaulFeinberg]

Great video.....have you used the lowepro on a plane? Will it fit under a seat for flights like frontier?

[@KylePugliese]

It’s tight, depends which seat and if there’s a power brick but it’ll squeeze

[@gsmoothcoffee]

Hi, what is the brand watch that youre wearing in this video?

[@KylePugliese]

Garmin. Fenix 5x in that video

[@gsmoothcoffee]

@@KylePugliese Thank you.

[@NKAZBEKOV]

I had lowerpro backpack, not same model, so after two years of use shoulder straps are gone. I wonder how good is this model, but straps look almost the same

[@Armantomato]

really good review! your video made me easier to decide that peak backpack is not good enough for me )) because everyone else is just praising this backpack from peak design and you've said as it is: it's not that usable ))

[@takeoff2explore]

Can I put D500+200-500 attached at the bottom horizontally...

[@NZD95]

Nope won't work, you will have to go vertically

[@kroghhejl]

Hey. Thanks for a solid review👍🏻 One question: do you use the Peak Design capture clip, and does it fit on the straps of the Lowepro bag?

[@KylePugliese]

Thanks, yeah I do use them. There's a few ways to attach it but I found that the one strap on the shoulder works perfectly for it and can support the weight of the camera with a lens no problem. It's an inch or so strap, so it's not as rugged as where you attach the clip on the peak Everyday bag, but I've had no actual issues with it working.

[@axlecagalingan5018]

does it fit with the Feiyutech AK2000?

[@KylePugliese]

Yeah that actually breaks down very well inside this pack

[@whunderwhoiam2489]

Does it fit under plane seats?

[@Parrothed5150]

Which bag were you using for the Mavic? Do you think this is a good combo solution for both Camera & Drone? Would you be able to fit under a seat on a plane or would it have to go in an overhead?

[@KylePugliese]

I was using the GearUp Case Large - amzn.to/2t7wrBO but honestly I wouldn't recommend this standalone outside of the Lowepro Protactic bag as it really doesn't offer much padding. It comes with two padded pockets but you have to remove them to fit the Mavic. I put my Mavic in a padded sleeve then inside this bag with chargers, remote and spare battery. The Protactic will fit under a plane seat I recently did this on a trip. It is tight but it fits.

[@intrinsicimagery]

Will it fit under the seat on a plane?

[@gevandian9112]

Will the ronin s fit in the lowerpro 450 aw

[@prathsawant2157]

Reply please ?

[@KylePugliese]

Broken down yes but not comfortably. It would have to lay flat so it takes up a lot of space.

[@Thunder1976NL]

I have the PD 30L at the moment, but will buy the Protactic 450 II along side it. Both are great bags and suit their own need. The PD has quirks and need another mindset when packing. Have a question though, you are quite a broad guy too, do you find the PD a bit small where the straps meet the bag and how does it compare to the Lowepro?

[@KylePugliese]

Just tried both on for comparison. Because the peak has the swivel mechanism where it attaches I'm only seeing maybe a half inch more width on each shoulder with the Lowepro. That being said the Lowepro straps are significantly more comfortable, especially with a fully loaded bag. They have much better padding, the Peak is very dense in comparison. I'm a big peak fan, I just think Lowepro has done a better job at this time, I'm excited to see what Peak's next iteration of their bag is.

[@Thunder1976NL]

Kyle Pugliese thanks for the quick answer and the test. Appreciate that a lot. 🤙

[@donwanthemagicma]

note you can get the same back on aliexpress

[@Burritosarebetterthantacos]

Still happy with it? Anything new catching your eye? I was gifted Peak EDB for valentines but found it very uncomfortable on straps...

[@dasklima5751]

I own the older version. Raincover is not rainproof. Minus a Nikon D810. Shoulderstraps are perfect. Quickacces with a fullsize DSLR with 2.8 lensess? Nooo, the openings ars to small.

[@arijitghosh6378]

since it has the waist strap can it be used as a flipside bag?

[@KylePugliese]

I haven't used the flipside bag personally, but it looks like it has some extra support straps for that manner. You could probably use it quickly to get something out but I don't think it would stay in that position without some handholding.

[@mirsadmesinovicphotography7346]

Thank you for good explain about these bags! Sub +

[@Murk.mp4]

6:50 to those who want the comparison

[@joshboyd493]

Oh my god, did not know the waist strap was detachable!

[@martee4]

Great video! Do you think it would be usable to pack half of camera equipment and other for storing miscellaneous items? Planning a trip later this year to Japan so a pack where I can also store warming layers and random items.

[@KylePugliese]

Absolutely. I just travelled from the US to Lithuania for a week and did just that. About 2/3 gear and the rest was general travel items. Because it's so modular you can build a layout exactly the way you need to store stuff, it's very efficient.

[@martee4]

Kyle Pugliese Thanks for the response! Would be awesome if you made a video of how you packed it on a trip!

[@KylePugliese]

One step ahead ;), check it out. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rZyQiWWeerRnqMk

[@martee4]

Kyle Pugliese 🙌. Subscribed! Would like to see your input on a Mindshift Backlight! Keep up the work

[@grossadam]

What kind of watch is that Kyle? suunto?

[@KylePugliese]

Garmin Fenix

[@darkknightwithanidea1845]

Sweet !!

[@EthanBares]

Awesome review man! Really enjoyed it. I have the v1 and am looking at getting the v2. Quick question. When you travel can you use the Lowepro as a backpack/personal item and put it under the seat or do you check it as a carry on?

[@KylePugliese]

Thanks! I've travelled twice with it so far, once domestic and also international and have carried it on along with a rolling bag that was larger. It fit under the seat or in the overhead no issues (a bit tight under the seat). Granted different airlines have different policies but I doubt you'd have an issue based on my experience.

[@EthanBares]

@@KylePugliese Awesome thank you so much!

[@FrankNeulichedl]

@@EthanBares If you can can carry it on your shoulders it's will never be checked ... even on small planes they let you keep it ... it's more a mental thing I guess - but with all the roller-carry which are more boxy they are almost ignore backpacks in my experience. They can't even imagine how heavy they can be :D

[@TJuice1986]

Hey, how tall are you? I’m debating the 350 or 450. I’m 6’2” 225lbs.

[@KylePugliese]

5’ 10”

[@TJuice1986]

Kyle Pugliese okay, I just ordered the bag thanks to your video & response. 👍🏻 thanks for helping me making my decision!! 😊

[@אלוןאנגל-ה9ש]

listen man you are very talented I'm going to use one of your shots in this video to help me make one of my videos and I will live a link to your description to your channel and it will be different language I ask for permission in advance because I expect you have a way of filming you are have great potential keep making great videos I subscribe to your Channel

[@Daleyeeah]

I'd like to see a protactic review where someone actually fits two cameras in it!

[@Son4m]

Is it waterproof ?

[@ponkasss]

Could this fit GH5+BMPCC4K+Mavic Pro+DJI ronin SC? :D

[@KylePugliese]

The Ronin SC is my biggest worry. It could fit the rest and an AK2000 gimbal as I've fit similar setups

[@DiogoCostavideography]

So the million dollar question, it fit a Moza Air 2?

[@KylePugliese]

I put my ronin s on the outside. It would fit inside but take up a lot of space due to the size

[@daniellefernandes8423]

Does it for under an airplane seat?

[@KylePugliese]

Barely. It would in the middle seat but it's right on the others or may not depending on the plane.

[@kjakan79]

Empty bag🙈

[@Booyamakashi]

is this an ad?

[@aussie8114]

Practical but a bit ugly

[@madcat1007]

Slow down man. I am exhausted listening to you. Just talk slower. Good review though!!

[@MadBarrister]

Is it waterproof??