LA Noire Remaster - Case #11 - The Golden Butterfly (5 Stars)

[@harshbansal7982]

Man , Captain Donnelly’s line at 3:11 is so badass but also kinda scary lol . He was an amazing character.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

I didn't realize before, but, at 31:37, Captain Donnelly was massaging his knuckle and looking down at it, as he was talking about Eli Rooney. Dude was probably beating up Eli before that exchange with Phelps and Galloway

[@madnomad3861]

@@Joe_Parmesan that's a no brainer

[@alistairwalker2850]

@@Joe_Parmesan He’s a father. Eli preys on children. Makes sense.

[@jackdaone6469]

I love the expression on his face when that reporter belts him with another question. Donnelly looked like he was about to snap and drop that reporter for being such a heathen.

[@arsenal4739]

⁠@@alistairwalker2850t’s not just that he’s a father but that Eli and Donnelly personally know each other. He confesses to trying to stop being a sick fuck but Eli refuses to, so that was the last straw. Not saying him being a father isn’t a factor, just saying there’s more to it.

[@andrewapgar3273]

At 26:20 there's an important clue: The rope is used for boats AND church bells. They then spend a later case fixating on the boating use looking for a sailer, but im the end the killer is found in an abandoned church where he kills the victims.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

I love how they sprinkled bits of the trail back to Garrett Mason and the Christ of Thorns Church. It completely flew over my head during my first playthrough of the game, even the metal bar used to jimmy the window of Antonia Maldonado's apartment

[@WittyOriginalUsername]

@@aidenbrackenlmfao dude this game is like a decade old

[@Chuked]

@@aidenbracken should have played the game already before watching this video LMAO

[@danteferraro23]

yup all makes sense

[@Agent1W]

Oh, but it would never have been a churchman. Let's not dare investigate men of the cloth and see if they had been harboring murderers.

[@Her_Imperious_Condescension]

I love how he always says he wants daily reports, but the cases are solved in less than a day anyway.

[@livecarsonreaction]

"Are you a suspect, Rusty?" was one of the funniest things Cole said

[@benplayzgames4368]

I always had a thought on the final case of homicide instead of the killer what if it was rusty like dude was acting all innocent and wants to lock up the husbands 😂😂😂

[@Luka-ty4qr]

I like the houses and apartments in the game when you go inside them, very cozy feeling especially with the sunny LA environment

[@larixobelievix5954]

Yeach this is cool.

[@jazzmanspriggs6415]

fr

[@Chuked]

Very atmospheric game

[@50.CalFilms]

I completely disagree, this game feels haunting to me. Everything about this era of los angles terrifies me. Rockstar are so incredible

[@BubblyJubbly]

I love the interrogations. It feels so damn satisfying when you prove people are bare faced liars.

[@princesssunsetshimmer9648]

I agree.

[@adagiodazzle3175]

Well it's easy for someone who can see liars in people.

[@nomadjensen8276]

Bold faced liars.

[@aaronkenyon7112]

It's hilarious that they lie straight to your face even though the evidence is right there in the room.

[@Zac4_B7ack]

Yeah, but I hated when he was bad-cop to the little girl, TOTALLY unprofessional, everything else was fine.

[@MegamanNG]

I hated this case. It's one of the few cases where you can actually get a bad ending. I mean it. I hate this case and you really have to be careful with making the right call.

[@winstonyap442]

can you finish this case megaman

[@sergeantjoe]

It's a no brainer on who to chose the father who has a dependent daughter or the child rapist

[@MegamanNG]

I went with the child rapist because a scumbag like him deserves to be in lock-up.

[@Skorm731]

I ask this? Why does Donnelly hate Rooney so much?

[@Skorm731]

Oh ok. Thanks for the info.

[@cherkovision]

This game made me realize I have no idea what jewelry my wife wears, aside from the engagement/wedding rings I bought her. I found a sapphire ring next to the kitchen sink I had no idea existed. She told me that it was a faux-sapphire, gold-plated ring she bought for $35 last year, and hardly ever wore. I angrily told her that if she had been murdered and Detective Phelps had searched my home, he probably would have found it and yelled at me.

[@heysupguys30]

She would say.... get off ur game! U been play too much!

[@Chuked]

Lmao

[@TheUrbancenter]

Amateur. All your jewelry should be related to scenes of spousal abuse.

[@TrickyTalon23]

I cracked up so hard about this

[@phillipwalling7470]

Hope you ain't size 8.

[@erickfalconi2010]

33:50 Eli was the only one that saw Garrett Mason doing the crime, but no one believed him. The question is, why Hugo Moller seemed so sus? the school's parking lot functionary acuses him when he sees Hugo Moller, but why?

[@ArchieSale57]

If you see, Hugo Moller and Garrett Mason are very lookalike, no wonder the janitor accused Hugo

[@matthewriley7826]

Also bad timing and coincidence. Hugo had blood on his shoes from skinning a rabbit, has been violent with his wife before, and it’s hardly a secret they’ve been having issues.

[@harrisongrant8558]

Eli is also a child molester and a pervert, so it's not surprising nobody listened to him.

[@blastermaster5039]

33:50 This is the moment I realize that Eli is not only innocent but also saw the true killer.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

Not exactly innocent, but he was not guilty of the murder. I like how Mal gave a hint at 26:24

[@bpheavyrocker1]

Eli Rooney Is played by Courtney Gaines. He was Malachai in Children Of The Corn by Stephen King

[@ElectroNukeMods]

1:22 Should ease down on those drinks, Galloway.

[@suavemidnight5873]

The first case in the game that I actually found quite hard, I feel like Team Bondi was purposefully trying to throw me for a loop.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

I struggled on my first attempt too. Missed cutscenes and evidence because of going to the wrong location first, and then convicting the wrong choice, against Cpt. Donnelly's suggestion

[@operation1968]

Yeah I agree. I also remember struggling with this one. For some reason I've always remembered cole asking Hugo about rope. I guess because it's a bit of an odd question. It wasn't easy for me either the first time

[@matthewriley7826]

And you’re not sure what to do at the end. The evidence and motive majorly point towards Hugo doing it, but that also means letting a violent pedo go free.

[@LegendaryGamer1947]

this case was so hard

[@princesslaravincenzo9596]

I like hard missions.

[@mr.peanutbutter6969]

@@princesslaravincenzo9596 you like it hard?

[@princesslaravincenzo9596]

@@mr.peanutbutter6969 Yes

[@princesssunsetshimmer9648]

That's why I like this case.

[@TAMPIM]

@@princesslaravincenzo9596 ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)

[@bigshuga6842]

is anyone else really bad at this game?

[@jmckail152]

Danny McDowall im not too good at interrogation but the game its self is great

[@XxLew]

I find it hard sometimes to read the faces between bad cop and accuse

[@mida9124]

Arthur Morgan Based on pure observation, the Bad Cop option is basically giving out threats. The Accuse option is accusing the person of having done it and giving out evidence straight from the notebook.

[@josephscaduto9971]

I don’t think most people are that bad. Some of these cases are that hard

[@Celisar1]

Joseph Scaduto I think the game is often poorly written and the answers often don’t fit the questions at all but after the “answer” you cannot use the question or evidence anymore. That doesn’t make any sense.

[@MagnumDB]

I don’t like when this game shows you the crime in the beginning. You play as a detective who never witnessed the crime so you as the player should not be able to witness it. BECAUSE THE ANSWER IS THERE IN THE FIRST 5 SECONDS AFTER THE TITLE! You see the build of the killer, and you see the paper boy hat. There’s only one suspect who looks like that and wears that hat - ELI. What I do like is how much the game convinces you it’s the husband and the case takes a long time to complete so you may very well forget what the killer at the beginning looked like. Still, always try and remember every detail of the opening in a case of the game shows you the crime!!

[@GreatExtended]

MagnumDB thank you, there are people still think it was the husband because of the evidences.

[@GreatExtended]

Oh btw, neither Eli nor husband is the killer

[@aztec0996]

But eli isnt the killer. If you remember the bartender from the first case, his face and build matches the profile of all the killers.

[@squidstone8399]

You haven't played the game. Eli isnt the killer. I dont wanna spoil who is. But the starting cutscene has nothing to do with the killet

[@evandetwiler2810]

I agree. I stopped playing years ago because of this case. I finally decided to pick it up again though lol

[@SadCatMkII]

Loving the series, makes me wanna play the game too

[@agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818]

Shark Boy Shannon even tho he arrested the wrong guy hugo moler killed his wife

[@SadCatMkII]

Major Arthur Crowley wait, you get 5 stars even if you arrest the wrong guy?

[@agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818]

Shark Boy Shannon if you arrest the wrong guy 1 or 2 i remember in 2011 i got 2

[@drift_boitn1454]

You only live once so play it.

[@puffer_frog]

"What would we do if another country denied us the gas to run our cars?" *PREQUEL FORESHADOWING INTENSIFIES*

[@mikkelnpetersen]

"Deliver them some FREEDOM"

[@Mr1930s]

More foreshadowing: the ropes are sometimes used as bell ropes in churches.

[@CaptainJZH]

Tbf Cole kinda glosses over why the US embargoed Japan in the first place, i.e. their imperial expansion into Asia and the Pacific

[@appxrtionlxve4718]

Phelps runs like Niko lol

[@GiganticPyro]

Both of them are my favorite characters.

[@ManpreetKaur-ry9gs]

Appxrtion Lxve ,,,,,

[@princesslaravincenzo9596]

@@GiganticPyro Arthur, Cole, Niko, the best characters and CJ.

[@rainbowdashandsonicftw4792]

@@princesslaravincenzo9596 Cole it's Roman let's go bowling

[@tracyrae4854]

@@princesslaravincenzo9596 I Would Replace Cj With John Cj's Pretty fucking overated

[@JessiD618]

If you complete both interrogations without accusing either on and just step out into the hallway, the janitor shows up and tells you it’s the husband.

[@nu-agegamer3548]

Correction: If you FAIL both interrogations.

[@NFS4LFE]

I love that little shove Phelps does @ 20:44

[@duglife2230]

This case whooped my tail on my first playthrough.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

Same here. I had to go through this case at least 3 times to link it correctly.

[@DABOSSMAN-lj8pr]

I dont get how it's the pedo , for me it all pointed towards the husband

[@busterthebear6756]

DA BOSSMAN2245 You need to arrest the kiddie rapist to get five stars, I arrested the husband and got three

[@XxLew]

Buster The Bear if I remember correctly doesn't the captain kick a bin at you if you arest the dad lmfao

[@RamdomView]

Because the captain values good press over justice. Bringing down a pedophile makes for better news.

[@standupscarab5418]

The bloody rope and bloody tire iron

[@GreyOverlord74]

SPOILER: Well, technically, none of the guys you put away did any of the homicides. The Black Dahlia aka the bartender you meet in the first homicide case, was the real culprit of all the murders

[@thebowler5506]

To me it was pretty clear the husband wasn't the killer, one of the many rules of detective stories is that when the first suspect seems without a doubt like the perp, there's usually another one with a worse alibi and a better motive

[@kambandi1788]

Just realized and looked up the guy who played Hugo Moller (Greg Grunberg) has also played Police Investigator Ethan Thomas From Condemned: Criminal Origins, who has the power of precognition, among other things.

[@EightThreeEight]

He also went on to play a character called Snap Wexley in the Star Wars sequel trilogy. (inb4 somebody starts complaining about that trilogy again)

[@servebotfrank4082]

@@EightThreeEight Yeah he's one of JJ Abram's regulars. He's in a lot of his films.

[@Shay-ne3bo]

This case really fucked me up pretty hard. The truth is, neither of those guys murdered her. It's just a matter of the pride and prestige of the precinct.

[@justsomebloke460]

10:32 damn that she sure stopped crying quick 🤨

[@mleak1076]

Nah rs 😭

[@boundedsleet6262]

She's obviously the mastermind behind all these killings.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

I can picture Grosvenor McCaffrey getting pissed at her "the UTTER AUDACITY of the bitch!"

[@drift_boitn1454]

Hold up wait a minute something's wrong I can feel it.

[@drift_boitn1454]

@@boundedsleet6262 no its Garrett Mason the bartender.

[@Poxell91]

21:52 is my favorite exchange in the entire game.

[@50.CalFilms]

It was so masterfully done, the zoom in to reveal the butterfly was so good

[@rtcp2020]

I like how Rusty punched Eli.

[@larixobelievix5954]

Me too. But I would punch him at least 36 times.

[@boundedsleet6262]

It was more of a backhand than a punch, both of which are equally satisfying in the case of pedophiles.

[@rtcp2020]

Goddamn I don’t remember this comment XD

[@moviemetalhead]

"Because I'm about to break your fuckin' skull, Eli." ~Finbarr "Rusty" Galloway

[@user-yf1qt8uz3c]

I like that in every homicide case there is always a slight hint that Garrett Mason is the killer and he is found at a church in the end

[@ghostasian9807]

Weird i charged eli and it showed moller getting thrown in the cell

[@ozymandiasmagno]

Surely my favourite case. It took me like half an hour to decide who was the killer, and, at last, I chose the father because all evidence pointed to him. I was pretty dissapointed with the bad ending, although I did the right choice for that situation.

[@laurelllobo5297]

It was ruined for me from the previous case video, I was going through the comments and few people told who was the actual killer, so when I started this case, I lost all the interest, cuz I knew all were innocent. But I did chaarge Eli cuz rusty suggested arrest him cuz he can be a problem again for kids, if he comes out again. I am hoping his women murder things wraps up quickly cuz I already know who the killer is, and go to something fresh where I can use my thinking n hav fun, n get surprised when I find who the killer is.

[@erickfalconi2010]

one thing i think no one realizes is that when Mason kills Deidre Moller, he is using the same clothes he used when he was working at the bar in Celine Henry's case

[@Edgar_Allan_Foe666]

On my second play through, I felt like an idiot for not seeing the outfit was clearly familiar

[@mida9124]

Poor Michelle...

[@rezaryanomuhammad8626]

08:20 : "But don't tell me your eye don't bend" Well said Rusty. Gotcha Phelps

[@aztec0996]

What does this mean?

[@Robsonski96]

@@aztec0996 Foreshadowing, son.

[@aztec0996]

@@Robsonski96 I meant like the actual saying "don't tell me your eye don't bend". What does it mean if your eye does "bend"?

[@bernardosantos8020]

@@aztec0996 in this context it means looking at another woman

[@Agent1W]

@@Robsonski96 LOL I call it that normal shadowing! That had already started happening with the first subsequent Blue Room visits after clearing the Traffic desk. Good instinct on Rusty's part. He just didn't know it was for a "certain German junkie whore".

[@TurboPikachu]

Absolutely astounding to see this game running so well on Nintendo's new tablet

[@thebandit0256]

Are you suspect Rusty- Cole Phelps 2011

[@luh_cracker6406]

TheBandit025 -Cole Phelps 1947

[@amazingtrick5886]

Hugo: Yes I do what my best. Hugo: Also Hugo lying the whoooooole time!

[@atlasreborn7221]

"Turn out your pockets, Eli." "Now why would I do that?" "Because I'm about to break your fucking skull, Eli." The way I wheezed.

[@TVelde]

The people and vehicles in this game look quite realistic but the environment in comparison to GTA 5 looks like GTA 3 or so

[@ondraspendlik9759]

Yeah, looks kinda terrible, same as in old PC version. Would love to know if it atleast runs better now, because PC optimalization was even worse than in GTA IV

[@maskhyruken5965]

Ondra Spendlik cause it's on switch

[@MrDLJ5]

I actually think the game looks great. Especially for being around 9 yrs old. Looks better than some current gen games 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@VITAS874]

@@maskhyruken5965 true

[@Tsumami__]

@@MrDLJ5 they did a fantastic job with the characters themselves, and the vehicles, but the environment is definitely a little lacking.

[@failuretolaunchdrums]

So far it’s been challenging but always did well but this case really shook it up and got one star. In a sense it’s perfect for the noir everything’s gray vibe but I was disappointed in myself. Both of them really seemed like they could be the killer.

[@timoplays478]

On 2:55...the guy behind the camera man has a really realistic emotion,just have a look,he looked pissed of lol

[@peternehemiah1606]

TimoPlays the devs threw it all away for facial animations only the rest of the animations are very generic

[@cushpnk]

@@peternehemiah1606 That's what matters in this game. You need to be able to read faces.

[@ferdinandpurczeld234]

11:18 Cole: "Can you describe her things?" Girl: "I never paid much attention to that stuff." 11:37 Girl: "A rose gold wedding band and a matching diamond and ruby ring, a yellow gold Elgin watch" Me: WTF, why did you not answer this to the previous question? xD

[@KurtisC93]

She just learned that her mother died. Naturally, it's going to be harder for her to think clearly under those circumstances.

[@thekivster]

I shouldn’t have “lost” for punishing Moller. He had way more evidence against him.

[@Yoghurt_UK]

I can swear Rockstar has added in extra dialogue for Cole Phelps with an entirely different actor. Sounds more like the Postal guy. Lmao.

[@HairyBetch]

Yogs you’re right lol

[@il-onaga-il2788]

13:36 Always been true in my experience 😂😂😂😂😂

[@Lolander14]

21:21 is the sound effect when you get shot in Goldeneye for the N64.

[@JavierMartinez-xb4ki]

Michelle: X,A,X, Mr Moller: Y Size 8 shoes,Y husband alibi,X,Y butterfly broom, Mr Moller police station: A,X,Y bloody tire iron,Y overalls, Eli R: X,A,X,X, charge

[@major7thsmcgee973]

Phelps: "So, are we looking for a sailor or a minister?" Carruthers: "Well in my experience sailors seem to have the greater libido..." The Catholic Church: Am I a joke to you?

[@Lucas02000]

This made me laugh more than it should've and now I feel bad lol.

[@Hellhammer___666]

Lmfao

[@Agent1W]

That's the dumb part. Carruthers conflated libido with propensity to commit a sexual crime. Just because you have a high libido doesn't mean you're more likely to commit one. I think anecdotally those who are more likely to do so are of the LOWER persuasion of libido.

[@major7thsmcgee973]

@@Agent1W That's an interesting point!

[@Brotherjoe1996]

“Answer the goddamn question Rooney, before a brain you”. 😂😂

[@tml1999]

21:55 the best response in this game period

[@TristanGarciaOfficial]

Love the sountrack when youre heading to deirdre Moller house

[@odini5881]

I felt bad when acting a question like a bad cop to Michelle :"(

[@TheBoostedDoge]

I arrested the Hugo based on evidence, kinda felt bad though, seemed like an honest guy

[@_Paul_N]

Boosted Doge Hugo was innocent lol. The bloody uniform and everything belonged to the pedophile . This was the toughest case in the game so I can’t blame you .

[@okami_eddy]

Putting aside that the murders were actually conducted by the Black-Dhalia-esque killer, Garrett Mason, I think the evidence would still lean more towards Eli than Hugo. Let me explain: 1.) Eli had the golden butterfly brooch, and since the Elgin wrist watch and wedding ring were not in their proper casings back at the Moller residence and markings were found on Diedre's body for those items, it's likely that Eli would've taken those as well, probably to pawn them off for extra money. 2.) Eli held an occupation at Hennessy Marine, a boating company. The rope used to strangle Deidre was a triple braid, which Galloway points out are commonly used on boats and mooring lines, and Carruthers mentions are also used for bell ropes in churches at times. None of these occupations matches up with Hugo's job as a mechanic. It's also worth pointing out that, while Hugo did learn to strangle people with rope through the Army, and that triple braid would be his choice of rope, if he were to strangle someone, his preferred tool would be wire. 3.) Another tie to Eli's job at Hennessy Marine would be the bloodstained coveralls, which had a large imprinted "H.M." on it. It would be easy to assume that the coveralls belonged to Hugo, as "H.M." matches the initials for his name (Hugo Moller) and coveralls would be common attire for a mechanic. But Eli mentions that the work clothes given to him by Hennessy Marine were green coveralls, much like the one covered in blood in the trunk of Diedre's car. It's more likely that the "H.M." on the coveralls stand for Hennessy Marine, as Eli mentions that the building location has a sign that also uses the abbreviated "H.M." on it. If the "H.M." really was Hugo's initials, it would make more sense that it would be placed on a name tag rather than in bold diagonal print, nevermind that fact that it would be just his initials. 4.) The one piece of evidence that legitimately implicated Hugo to be the killer was the Chrysler tire iron. Now, I'm no expert on the mechanical workings of mid to late 40s cars, so I can't say for certain whether or not tire irons would be the same for all Chrysler models of that era. Assuming that they are not, there was nothing that suggests the tire iron used to knock out Diedre specifically came from a Chrysler Airflow, the car that Hugo drives. The only connection would be that it was made for use on Chrysler cars. The only point of contention for this piece of evidence to be placed on Eli is where he got the tire iron to begin with. 5.) Belmont High School is a common haunt for Eli, as it is suggested that he is a repeat offender on cases of sexual violence towards minors. He does not go out of his way to deny this when pressed about it during his interrogation. Assuming that events like a school dance would take place at that school district's high school, that would mean Diedre would have to go there to pick up her daughter, Michelle. This put her in a prime position to be mauled and then strangled by Eli, though the motives for assaulting her could be called into question as Eli preferred young teen girls over older women, and her autopsy revealed no traces of semen, meaning the intent was not sexual. His testimony that he saw Hugo walk out of the car to remove his coveralls and place them in the trunk along with the brooch is faulty due to the fact that he would be referring to Diedre's car, a Chevrolet, when in actuality, Hugo drove a Chrysler Airflow as mentioned previously. 6.) If Hugo had not attempted to burn his bloody size eight shoes in the incinerator, they likely would have been taken to Ray Pinker for a forensic inspection. This would have revealed whether or not Hugo's later confession to helping his coworker skin rabbits held any water, as the blood would have been traced. The fact that the shoes were size eights implicates both Hugo and Eli, although Eli might be a lot looser with his shoe sizes, and matches with the shoe prints found at the sight of Diedre's corpse.

[@AmandaVieiraMamaesouCult]

@@okami_eddy Yes, I caught the HM overalls being from his workplace. And he had the brooch, which means he at the very least was in contact with the victim after her death.

[@omaralsaadi1751]

36:40 I'm amazed Phelps is a multilingual , can someone translate the dialogue they spoke in Japanese?

[@EightThreeEight]

I don't know what the Japanese soldier says, but Phelps asks for their name and their unit, then says "Who the hell do you think you are?!" after he slaps him.

[@lukeskinwalker922]

@@EightThreeEightHe says something like “I won’t answer you, pig!”. I’ve seen that in another post.

[@starguy321]

I remember charging the husband because if the motive was murder, then why wasn’t money taken from the handbag?

[@whitesabbath6581]

R.I.P. Deidre Moller (1909-1947)

[@Caprioly]

Havent completed the game yet, but it was obivous to me right from the beginning that not Eli neither Hugo were the killer. If it was up to me, I wouldnt have charged any of them. However, I wanted to imagine myself into the place of Phelps. There were tons of evidence pointing towards the husband. Eli was indeed a creep, as it was admitted even by him, however he was no killer. Phelps had to make a choice. He knew that he has to bring in someone. He knew he had to close the case in order to perform well. But Phelps is a rational man (at least trying to be). He doesn't act on instinct. Eli had to be charged but not with murder. I made the choice that Phelps would make: listen to the evidence.

[@markbelaligetfalvi7773]

I haven’t charged any of them…but not gonna spoiler it for you if you didn’t do that cuz some funny thing happening there bud 😀

[@AutomaticDuck300]

I agree with Rusty. Husband isn’t a danger to the wider community. Pin the murder on the pedo and he’s in prison for longer. Plus murder has concrete evidence. Harder to prove abuse.

[@everardomedrano205]

Kind of think it was Hugo

[@hornet6794]

Clatoria Jenkins no it was Eli, he setup the blood on his Hugo's work clothe because car was left behind before dance. Eli also rape victim and took golden butterfly. He have tier wrench on his hand at beginning of the video and Eli has polo cap that he always still wearing at beginning of the video too. I know it was Hugo but Eli plant blood on his clothe to make them people know Hugo kill his own wife but it not true, he been setup by Eli. That all I know

[@hornet6794]

I mean not tier wrench "tire iron" lol

[@agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818]

Ty Graham no its hugo the dept is corrupt just like roy and the chief. But the black dahlia did it anyways

[@agentandrewmiltonpinkerton9818]

Ty Graham also they want you to arrest him because hs is a child mollester.

[@zackeryr97]

Ty Graham how would he plant blood? Also, there were no traces of semen internal or external so Eli didn’t rape her.

[@misfitangel9619]

Wait how do u get the 4th question when interviewing eli?

[@senorkimmich4520]

Go to the central morgue, and find the coroner once again. You might find another clue rather than the rope clue.

[@Louis-Souness]

Golden Butterfly from L.A Noire, just awesome game as a whole but that mission really had me using my brain.

[@gelomartillana335]

35:16 this is why people hate getting arrested by Galloway

[@AbitantedelVault]

The flashback background song reminds me Call of Duty World at War Final Fronts

[@Mr_Maskins]

19:11 who the heck said 🤣 "Oo sister I'm so tight I couldn't walk"

[@crisdebo]

I actually don’t understand, when I was doing this all the clues and questions pointed towards Hugo. When I met with the pedo he just gave me a butterfly thing and that was it.

[@aztec0996]

Cause it's NEITHER of them :0 it's kind of like a head-nod to the Black Dhalia murder in real-life Los Angeles in the 1940s. No one was convicted and there were so many suspects and POIs

[@okami_eddy]

Putting aside that the murders were actually conducted by the Black-Dhalia-esque killer, Garrett Mason, I think the evidence would still lean more towards Eli than Hugo. Let me explain: 1.) Eli had the golden butterfly brooch, and since the Elgin wrist watch and wedding ring were not in their proper casings back at the Moller residence and markings were found on Diedre's body for those items, it's likely that Eli would've taken those as well, probably to pawn them off for extra money. 2.) Eli held an occupation at Hennessy Marine, a boating company. The rope used to strangle Deidre was a triple braid, which Galloway points out are commonly used on boats and mooring lines, and Carruthers mentions are also used for bell ropes in churches at times. None of these occupations matches up with Hugo's job as a mechanic. It's also worth pointing out that, while Hugo did learn to strangle people with rope through the Army, and that triple braid would be his choice of rope, if he were to strangle someone, his preferred tool would be wire. 3.) Another tie to Eli's job at Hennessy Marine would be the bloodstained coveralls, which had a large imprinted "H.M." on it. It would be easy to assume that the coveralls belonged to Hugo, as "H.M." matches the initials for his name (Hugo Moller) and coveralls would be common attire for a mechanic. But Eli mentions that the work clothes given to him by Hennessy Marine were green coveralls, much like the one covered in blood in the trunk of Diedre's car. It's more likely that the "H.M." on the coveralls stand for Hennessy Marine, as Eli mentions that the building location has a sign that also uses the abbreviated "H.M." on it. If the "H.M." really was Hugo's initials, it would make more sense that it would be placed on a name tag rather than in bold diagonal print, nevermind that fact that it would be just his initials. 4.) The one piece of evidence that legitimately implicated Hugo to be the killer was the Chrysler tire iron. Now, I'm no expert on the mechanical workings of mid to late 40s cars, so I can't say for certain whether or not tire irons would be the same for all Chrysler models of that era. Assuming that they are not, there was nothing that suggests the tire iron used to knock out Diedre specifically came from a Chrysler Airflow, the car that Hugo drives. The only connection would be that it was made for use on Chrysler cars. The only point of contention for this piece of evidence to be placed on Eli is where he got the tire iron to begin with. 5.) Belmont High School is a common haunt for Eli, as it is suggested that he is a repeat offender on cases of sexual violence towards minors. He does not go out of his way to deny this when pressed about it during his interrogation. Assuming that events like a school dance would take place at that school district's high school, that would mean Diedre would have to go there to pick up her daughter, Michelle. This put her in a prime position to be mauled and then strangled by Eli, though the motives for assaulting her could be called into question as Eli preferred young teen girls over older women, and her autopsy revealed no traces of semen, meaning the intent was not sexual. His testimony that he saw Hugo walk out of the car to remove his coveralls and place them in the trunk along with the brooch is faulty due to the fact that he would be referring to Diedre's car, a Chevrolet, when in actuality, Hugo drove a Chrysler Airflow as mentioned previously. 6.) If Hugo had not attempted to burn his bloody size eight shoes in the incinerator, they likely would have been taken to Ray Pinker for a forensic inspection. This would have revealed whether or not Hugo's later confession to helping his coworker skin rabbits held any water, as the blood would have been traced. The fact that the shoes were size eights implicates both Hugo and Eli, although Eli might be a lot looser with his shoe sizes, and matches with the shoe prints found at the sight of Diedre's corpse.

[@eduardovega3960]

@@okami_eddy but eli says that his coverall has a big yellow HM and the coverall that we find in the trunk has a white HM on it

[@somebodyontheinternet3200]

@@eduardovega3960 Eli was talking about his workplace having a big yellow HM out of the front, the only time he mentions his uniform is that he says his uniform are green coveralls, he never mentions initials on them.

[@nashlawhon5915]

I don’t like how the game gets mad at the player for arresting the person that all the evidence points to.

[@larixobelievix5954]

Even if he would kill her, he isn't a threat anymore but Ellie is and he needs to be stop, here I understand captain.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

It still openly points to both of them. Eli is never really clear because a lot of the evidence is circumstantial, in my opinion. The green coveralls seem to be misleading too, because I'm guessing Hugo would wear some that have his name on them, rather than his intials

[@CSLFiero]

Why can't we ask about the footprints without having gone to the morgue first or if we missed the plaster mold? that is shite

[@Scottish1996]

Got me 3 trophy’s this guide, thank you.

[@zakapolidis]

“Always been true in my experience.” 😭😂

[@mr.takeoff7625]

One of best game I have seen

[@chinaman1]

Bekowsky and Galloway are my favorite partners in this game.

[@281cu6]

Avg shoe size in those days was 9 (closer to size 8 in our day) for men. Suspect in game: "People make fun of my marginally smaller than avg foot size."

[@281cu6]

@@jeffcarroll1990shock I'm 2' 2" and I wear a size 18.

[@johnmcfirstley6122]

GTA series videos thanks now I'm just waiting on ur next helpful video so I can beat the next one

[@Pedro_Le_Chef]

man , try them yourself , don't underestimate your intelligence

[@AmandaVieiraMamaesouCult]

Do it like me, try it yourself, then watch this to see what you missed.

[@alexandrutirlea4043]

This case makes no sense at all. Most evidence pointed towards Hugo and you have to charge Eli for the 5 stars like what?

[@AmandaVieiraMamaesouCult]

The overalls had the initials of Eli's workplace. That made me accuse Eli.

[@Joe_Parmesan]

A lot of the evidence could've gone either way. Nothing really concrete;y stuck with Hugo, but, the overalls would most likely belong to Eli (or, at least from Hennessy Marine), as it wouldn't really make sense for Hugo to put his initials on the front of his work gear, rather than his first name. Also, I think the major point is that Eli was a known problem, while Hugo had no history of serious crimes (for that point in time. I don't agree with spousal abuse), even though he was acting a bit suspicious.

[@frankmarshall1254]

There's like a double look too. Hugo was the murder but had a kid. Eli didn't kill but he's a pedo and possible rapist. Ill throw Eli

[@mentvltrillness]

Because it's supposed to be a crooked choice. Ofc they didn't do it, but the department/story will look great in the papers.

[@blastermaster5039]

@@mentvltrillness Basically this. It wont look good in the papers at all if the morning people read their news and saw that the department imprisoned a father while letting a convicted child rapist go. No amount of evidence nor explanation to the public will satisfy their anger at the department for doing this, even if all the evidence shows that the father(yeah I know he didnt do it) is the likely suspect of the murder. So yeah, it is one of those crooked cases in the game and shows that being a police and/or detective is not all black and white choices.

[@ondraspendlik9759]

Hey guys, anyone here played the remaster? How is the optimalization? The old one was terrible on PC, funny thing is that when I played the game for the second time, first time on my new PC, it felt like it's running even worse than on my old PC with lower performance. It was just so laggy, felt like constant 20 FPS, especially when driving

[@ramonaragondiaz9258]

Ondra Spendlik I have it on the ps4 and it looks more detailed than on ps3. I'm my opinion it runs at 60 fps. More suits and get to wear your patrol outfit being a detective. Its more optimized than on PC hope they make a better PC version.

[@0x00Fyou]

If you ever find the game lagging reload the level by changing costumes that forces the game to re load all files while keeping your progress and the lagging will be fixed I picked that trick up from the lowspec gamer

[@AmandaVieiraMamaesouCult]

@@0x00Fyou thx, I reinstalled the game bc I thought my PC had problems, it turns out the PC port is just shit

[@desert6975]

@@AmandaVieiraMamaesouCult like gta 4

[@sauceontoes3457]

Run them with V patch it should be good i get 60+ fps with high quality settings

[@drift_boitn1454]

Damn those soundtracks. It is scary af.

[@kriskurti7497]

I agree, especially the one that plays out when you are looking for clues on the crime scene

[@HellhammerSS]

Wow, mom got 4 seconds of grief tears. Lol

[@matthewriley7826]

I love how the evidence majorly points that Hugo did it, yet Captain Donnelly gets angry if you convict him instead of Rooney. (And yes I know he didn’t actually.)

[@magmta976]

That smack tho

[@supermariofan03]

Other than The Quarter Moon Murders, this is the only Homicide case where you don’t go to a bar.

[@thesiselchannel]

I don’t understand why the LAPD couldn’t lock them both up at the same time... what? Are the cells too crowded?

[@cushpnk]

They have to prove that they collaborated in the killing for a double murder charge on one person..?

[@InvestedGman]

@@cushpnk that’s a good point

[@kalel015]

You cannot charge more than 1 people unless proven conspiracy maybe?

[@thesiselchannel]

@@cushpnk charge one for murder and the other for child molestation …

[@SunsetAssassin]

This is actually what happens after this case is finished, it's also why choosing Rooney is the correct choice. Like Rusty mentioned it's important to take Rooney off the street, and Hugo can always be arrested for something else later. This is why in the next case you hear that Hugo has been charged for the murder, while Rooney is still arrested for something like sexual deviancy. Technically both subjects are arrested after this case, the priority is who is a bigger threat to the public.

[@DanielSan17]

One rule I noticed is the most likely suspect is the least likely is there is evidence pointing at a particular person of interest too early in the case it ain’t them

[@mrowley7300]

I remember I messed up the case and the janitor said they husband parked the car and he drove off

[@TheShapeshifter]

I'm missing a clue on this case. I didn't get the question for footprints at the scene for Eli Rooney. Still managed to get 5 stars though.

[@ryanrandall8883]

What's BUGGING me is that my PS4 version doesn't have the last question to Eli "Footprint at the Crime Scene" Like why was this taken out???

[@Lone_Coyote]

You didn't gather enough evidence for it to show up.

[@ryanrandall8883]

​@Lone_Coyote I literally went back on this case a day before this comment funny enough.. And yeah, you're right!.. I completely missed the Footprints at The Central Morgue after looking at the ropes of witch strangle the victim.. literally next to it aswell 🤣 So after looking at the Footprints before up and leave, that when the question shown up on my notebook.

[@Lone_Coyote]

@ Lol, that was a great coincidence. So I hope you got your 5 stars rating on this case. This game is highly addictive I may play it again today, and then next month and so and so. I love it, wish there was another LA NOIRE or some police/detective game similar to this.

[@jtnkenyan_yt]

21:55 Didnt have to do Eli like that lmfao

[@skateboard4zero]

I never got the option to go to the morgue… only reason I could think of was because I didn’t use the cop car when I drove and missed something on a radio call?

[@TaufikWiradarmo]

so is the apparel is from Hugo Moller or Eli's workplace?

[@PlittHD]

This case cannot be solved wrong, it's likely that Hugo killed his wife. They could have gone the extra step and find out if the type of overall is used at hugo's workplace, or if the blood on the shoe is rabbit or human blood. On the other hand he first said his overall is in the locker at work and after that said it's in the laundry in his house.

[@zygas25]

I remember this case. I was using a guide boom for this game, in order to get the full 5 stars, u have to pick rooney. Granted he had nothing to do with this case but I wanted the achievement for getting max stars on all cases

[@Braylon1997]

To the police, charging the parolee with a record is more believable than a husband reporting his wife is missing

[@Joe_Parmesan]

Eli Rooney had nothing to do with the murder, but he was the last known person to see Deidre Moller alive (aside from Garrett Mason), and he had a significant piece of evidence, along with a record. Along with what Itachi said, charging Hugo Moller would result in Michelle being moved away (that's one of the ending messages, if you charge Hugo).

[@notDaBestBoii]

@@Joe_Parmesan who tf is garret Mason?

[@gelomartillana335]

5:38 people will get to see it at the first 3 cases on homicide

[@alicialandis3288]

35:15 Rusty how dare u?!😡

[@thatpredsguy2965]

0:25 GOOD GOD ALMIGHTY GOOD GOD ALMIGHTY THAT KILLED HER

[@fabiodelazzari4653]

12:35 Action!

[@JamesJohnson-nm5pu]

Yeah that's interesting

[@paulofernando7858]

@@JamesJohnson-nm5pu what

[@MohammedMahdi8005]

My man better get a drink in this one and not like last time

[@ドナドナマン]

I guess Michel E Moller is one of the most poorest character in entire of this game. Her mom was brutally killed, and soon after her dad was arrested, and ends up as an orphan... too heavy for 15 yo girl :-(

[@quetixio8996]

I got every clue ,every question correct, interrogated both correct and arrested Eli and I got 4 STARS. What the hell is this game? Edit Nevermind I saw the problem:I went too late to the high school since I went to the Morgue first after caching Hugo. I think that affected it

[@Calvin_Coolage]

Could have been your driving.

[@davidhiggins3116]

Yý6⁶6

[@Darren-lb3rx]

18:51 they were in sync with words

[@gingataisen]

Peppers come from trees?!

[@JCarey1988]

Actual black pepper, like the kind you shake on your food, really does come from trees! They're little berries that start off green then turn black when ripe like olives do. The tree looks a bit like a weeping willow.

[@thewisemobRJ]

Despite the Captain congratulates you for this ending , Hugo is the true murder !!! If you don't do his interrogation right he tries to escape and the janitor recognizes him.