Let's Play REAL OR CAKE? Can You Guess Which One Is CAKE?

[@ChuncheeCat]

I did guess the orange dragon, one reason. The swirly colors were way more mixed than the others, making it stand out. Another way of mixing up the swirls would probably have saved it, or simply using a plainly colored pop-it as one of the real ones in the shots, so you don't have two swirly ones to compare it to, which made it stand out too much.

[@ArishaTalha1]

SAME LOL

[@Thedesertcactus]

Same,the orange one is the imposter.😂😂😂

[@CloverTheWolf]

I guessed the same one for the same reasons! Great minds really do think alike 😊

[@spiritsofwolves]

I guessed the dragon bc i felt like she wouldnt do the easy circle one and the wings looked like they would be tricky to make so idk

[@MajikIsFeral]

i chose dragon because companies would never make such a badass popit 😔 edit: nevermind. i revoke what i said, i had not yet watched the video lmao

[@Shika_]

I knew it was the dragon simply because that one was the most complex-looking and we know you love challenges!!

[@yoniamir]

me too!

[@edgarru4144]

Same but for me it was also because the swirls looked odd, also the texture and the lighting looked different

[@Roni.Animations]

7:45 MOLDING PUTTY! You could have made a mold of it, filled it with some chocolate let it sit and you would have something perfect

[@irotr53]

Playing real or cake with Sideserf is like finding a needle in a haystack💀

[@DuskO-U]

Ikr

[@tiffanyflanders273]

Fr

[@D4vdschild-ps9yg]

Yes! It is 😭

[@totally_not_ryleigh]

So real

[@ZahrarKaiser]

FR THO😭

[@bluesushipanda]

I guessed the right pop it! I'm not exactly sure what tipped me off to choosing the dragon (maybe I could unconsciously tell the texture was slightly different than the others?), but the cake looked very real.

[@CutecatnamedCoco]

Same

[@a.ishchuk5034]

I think it’s colors, other two looked more bright than the dragon, if it had yellow and red in it instead of pink it would fit in the line perfectly. They usually make them really bright!

[@RealGameluxe]

5:45 i was litterly eating Ramen the whole video😂

[@coolguy-t2t]

You know its cool when i call it cool

[@VasileBanu-ts3bo]

Pretty neat

[@kyuuketsukiinu]

@@coolguy-t2t ok cool guy

[@DandyT1990]

I like the nod to Amaury... Such a talented guy, love his videos!

[@breebrat56]

I guessed the dragon pop it from the video thumbnail. The depressed buttons looked different from the other real ones. That’s what gave it away and the overall material finish looked slightly off.

[@justrudystuff9939]

Just a note about the mini verse toys, they got recalled because resin is an extremely dangerous material to work with! Most adults can't use it safely, so imagine how dangerous it is for kids. Stay safe with all those kits, Natalie!

[@Pres_Play]

My sister got one, she is VERY young, SHE DRANK IT

[@Conway_Muzic_Coasterz]

Hey Natalie! I think it would be awesome if you were to make a Fish Bowl cake! It would be really cool to see how you would make the cool rocks and seaweed at the bottom! ❤❤❤

[@DontQuestionMe]

The yellow color of the geleton actually helped

[@jovindsouza3407]

I will never get tired of this series it's so much fun

[@emjayviolinart]

The Amaury Guichon reference killed me 😂

[@LucyBishop-om1vi]

I LOVE your hair!

[@dahlia159]

Ugh never stop posting I’m obsessed

[@jamiewilson9262]

You went all pro-tech on production, Natalie! Wow! This was a great episode! ❤

[@Chilling_withting123]

Hi! I am so happy that you’re finally back! Loved this video so much!🎉🎉

[@Sergeant_Davey_Coterie_Of_Arms]

I don't even have to watch the video, I know for a fact it's going to be good! And what's funny is I guessed the right cake at the beginning!

[@noreenelizabeth6617]

My son guessed the poppit cake correctly and I failed. He would like me to add that he really likes ramen

[@Sergeant_Davey_Coterie_Of_Arms]

Lol good for him! I also love ramen!@@noreenelizabeth6617

[@1EmuFan]

@@noreenelizabeth6617I guessed the pop it cake and I don’t like ramen (im autistic and I don’t like the texture, I like other kinds of noodles though)

[@Genshin_Gurly]

Yes because the texture wasn’t the smoothest

[@samanthadean1083]

I love how you make these cakes your own sometimes!!! ❤️❤️❤️👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@cheyennebaddley1261]

Thank you for referencing Amaury Guichon and Jacques Torres, two of my favorite chocolatiers!😂

[@3breadsticks]

i would love to see more actual cakes and less chocolate moulding!

[@Forest4877]

These are REALLY good - but they don’t have cake in them. 😔 I really enjoyed that your old videos had the added challenge of them actually being cakes inside and not just cake hidden behind them in an “illusion”.

[@LIlfr0g_.]

I agree though, some of her old videos also didn’t have cake in them sometimes it’s just to tough to put cake in these things. Like the pop it where would she fit cake actually on the pop it?

[@Forest4877]

@@LIlfr0g_. Making it larger or making something else. It’s just a bit weird to me to call it “real or cake” and have no cake. I’m not hating on her or anything, she’s super talented, but it’s just drifting further and further away from cake videos it seems.

[@3breadsticks]

i agree!

[@sendmasso6334]

@@Forest4877she just had a baby a few months ago it would be hard to take care of a baby and make hyper realistic cake ,she’s doing her best appreciate it

[@3breadsticks]

@@sendmasso6334 her cakes haven't been cakes since before she got pregnant. everything is jello or gelatine or chocolate only.

[@namig1990]

I am OBSESSED with her nails like that color is so pretty

[@salmafadel5851]

Love it !please make a chessboard cake!❤

[@Joy.Elizabeth]

that would be awesome!!

[@randivierich1314]

hi can you make a mermaid theme cake? by the way those were really good cakes I didn't guess either of them!

[@matthewsander5887]

Tweezers. It's easier if you grab with a tool that's relative to the size rather than your hands

[@makemyworldmini-dm8rg]

That was amazing!!😊 Loved it!👏👍

[@Eve-Ted]

Your videos are awesome ❤❤❤

[@Genshin_Gurly]

Saying pink with a purple background lol😂

[@TheProfessor-TB]

3:14 the poppet gets greenscreened

[@LemonZest]

I know stuff like this gets popular and makes for good shorts but I miss the style of the older videos in the channel. I know everything is produced "for the algorithm" these days. Just miss cakes with actual cake in them. And bigger cakes with more hand sculpting over using molds.

[@carolineobregon9096]

Fr I getchu

[@LemonZest]

@@carolineobregon9096 Thanks pal

[@samanthapentz3347]

She's a mom now, I bet she's super busy!

[@cristaljem4111]

I highly doubt that this comment would ever be seen, but I’m genuinely curious if you can make an edible MOVING peppers ghost cake, Maybe of a horse running or a chicken scratching and plucking the ground, whatever the scene is I wonder if you can make it.

[@ellie-4747]

Love your videos, Natalie! How do you not have more subscribers? Also you should make a spumoni 🍨 cake!

[@evashaw124]

please make a realistic ramen noodle bowl full sized!!

[@zGirl-Kawaii4]

With the bowl you coulda done Rice paper cuz it’s durable and it’s also used in many Japanese foods

[@fsheee3458]

She’s so beautiful and her hair is stunning

[@Finny-3]

Luv ur hair!

[@PinkCat135]

Today is my bday and knowing that you would post today made it 100x better!

[@AveryRattray]

9.34 to 9.40 brooo hahahahahahahahahahahh

[@sophieholbrook5249]

Can you make a flower cake, please? I’m a big fan!❤

[@Ur_Crafty_Artist]

I guessed it right At first I was thinking which one would Sideserf do. And I instantly knew she wouldn’t do the simple one. So then I was left with the sloth and dragon I decided the dragon because the swirls were imperfect but on the sloth they looked factory made.(It also looked less plasticy)

[@JasonFoo1653]

2:11 Edit mistake Husband Dave put in Purple instead of Pink

[@annmarieganeshdath2513]

Hi, can you make a cake of a lego person?

[@eekshithacherukumalli6118]

Ramen bowl didn’t look like cake it can be differentiated easily

[@ASHLEYGAILABINAS]

You should totally create a show about real or cake!!😮

[@palmosmostlyminecraft]

I feel like the dragon one doesn't count because the only cake in it was the cake holding it up

[@zGirl-Kawaii4]

I vote Orange poppet

[@HatersLoveM3]

the only reason i choose the dragon was because the other ones were transparent! 😂

[@TheUltimateChunkyBoi]

haha i think it'd actually be funny to make a realistic pie cake and trick everyone

[@heatherlutz2102]

I used to think the fish cake was a swirly radish when I was a kid 😅

[@allthingsmini1992]

The first one was easy to guess!

[@ZoexCheer24]

2:33 haha Mrs. Chocolate from nailed it is there

[@userismearja]

Natalie adding the pic of Amaury was funny to me dont ask me why🤣🤣

[@YSNostalgia]

3:37 Yes i did!

[@alonachiong666]

I guessed the dragon correctly because it's not shiney as the others

[@Okjadehoray]

She is so good at making cakes

[@monaloveme]

11:27 Wheres the cake?

[@RayMichelle]

Ahh the Ramen is so cute

[@SOPHIE_BUNNY_2024]

3:44 yes

[@veggiet2009]

It would have been really hilarious if the Blobby shaped one had been also cake the whole time and you only revealed that at the end 😂

[@yoniamir]

you should make a cake of a board game!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@amyrockett2165]

We want more mini verse! They are so fun!

[@amandawilliams-y4e]

can you please make a basset hound cake

[@kasepap]

Having a stroke 2:23

[@cece3506]

Have you tried making a lynx cake

[@RealGameluxe]

Would be Really cool❤

[@Emilysweetunicorn]

if you look close you can see something off so it’s not hard to

[@escapetv-qv3eg]

Please make a cake of lots of craft supplies and then make a craft out of the cake craft supplies that you made

[@Emilysweetunicorn]

The ramen isn’t cake tho

[@MissMyah37]

(Ichi) Eechee nisan (1 2 3) 5:37

[@AbigailKirsch-md1lj]

I guessed the dragon. I thought “It’s just like Natalie to choose a dragon. It’s so fun!”

[@steampunkgirly24]

I was able to guess which pop-it was cake but I think it still might be one of my favorite cakes you've ever made! I just think it looks so fun and cute!!

[@TocaKitKat]

3:36 got it right immediately somehow🤷‍♀️

[@CapnToad]

I watch your videos so often I memorized your intro and know what you will say

[@addieskousen3393]

Can you please make a music box cake!!!! It would be so cool! You could have a dancer or a ballerina spinning in the middle!

[@Robin-s-weird]

I knew it was the dragon the first time I looked at the cover

[@MissMyah37]

I KNEW IT! I GUESSED FORM THE THUMBNAIL! 😆 (I have watched a lot of videos)

[@Andreamom001]

I did guess the pop it-because it had no white swirls.

[@CherithMarek]

Can you do real or cake skincare next?💚🍰🫶🏼

[@_indie_and_emily_]

Omg love your cakes They are so realistic 😮

[@JamesMcGill-f8v]

Why do people mistake purple as pink it makes me angry. because purple is my favorite color🟣

[@kyokoyumi]

With the dragon, you should have just melted the chocolates separately and poured it like silicone to get the swirly splochy look. It was too mixed otherwise which made it more obvious.

[@zGirl-Kawaii4]

You should do a video about making a hyper realistic cake with MINI HANDS!😂❤pls consider my idea

[@psychotic-turtlezz]

That toot was 👌😫

[@Robel-g3k]

You should make a transformers character or a marvel character

[@dorinkarinkari2197]

Real talent is here... ❤️

[@vannevalentin]

Love your videos

[@Caitlin_RBLX]

👇Who wants a hyper realistic cake challenge with Natalie against Johnny🎂

[@Joy.Elizabeth]

the pop it was prob one of the hardest to guess great job!! 💖

[@juliajohnson4080]

Your mini verse ramen is cute! Can you please make a cake that looks like a sushi roll?

[@Amoon-_-120]

Natalie, I’m not sure if this works but you could use violet food coloring with white to make it like bright white

[@tigerlilystargazer4073]

I think maybe you should try making the ultimate realistic cake that tastes amazing

[@renees766]

That was incredible 👏

[@justmonika3635]

I guessed right on the first one! My kids have so many of these that I could tell by the colouring

[@brendanintheuniverse1910]

Yeah, my guess was the dragon, even though I felt sad.

[@MEacatqwerty]

omg I really wanted you to do another dragon cake :D and I also LOVE ramen!

[@theamazingizzybear5593]

GURL YOU NEED TO GO ON IS IT CAKE!

[@LemonZest]

I believe she was on it as a judge once

[@ihatihsan7303]

The dragon probably

[@Ice_Spice_123]

Can you make a realistic cake of a broom? 🧹 I think this one will be VERY hard! YOU INSPIRED ME TO BAKE AND I LOVE YOU! 💖

[@giadallama]

Please please make a cake of an alpaca in honor of my alpaca quest. He is amazing I love him please

[@amandaburris1854]

So fun! I did catch which pop-it was made of chocolate lol. I think It was the eye that gave it away