al-Hallaj: Mystic Martyr of Sufism

[@ekejiubam6002]

Subhanallah! For 4 days now,I have been thinking about an al haqq, now I found this.Alhamdullilah

[@naeemulhoque1777]

Sufism is deviancy! Don't fall for it. The truth about Allah is what Allah attributed to himself, not some assumptions of men. Watch this video made by *The Muslim Lantern* kzbin.info/www/bejne/e3y0o5iYaJelma8

[@yaseenmiah64]

Casually dropped a gem

[@jeffersenpierrelouis7053]

❤

[@notadane]

Your consistency is astounding. Congratulations, Filip.

[@teamcrumb]

Well said. We're so damn lucky to have found him. Nothing of this quality is being broadcast on any official TV channels that I know of. I also love Simon Roper's channel here on KZbin, a gifted linguist, have you seen any of his videos?

[@ShanSinghR]

Sheikh Mansur Al-Hallaj is highly respected within the Sikh tradition as well, as someone who figured out the Truth of Reality, of Allah, and His relationship with the world. He is accepted as a true disciple of God within the Anandpur Durbar of Guru Gobind Singh (the 10th Guru). Beautiful video.

[@arifal-yousif]

They were 100% correct. There are many paths to the Truth. After all, a monkey was Buddha once and the gulls saved the Ka'abah from the elephants from the Hijaz, maybe it will happen again soon for Al-Quds

[@ansh_u_r]

​@@arifal-yousifchange your qibla towards Jerusalem and everything will be good for you.

[@arifal-yousif]

@@ansh_u_r But it is by YOUR hand that Allah shall punish them

[@ansh_u_r]

@@arifal-yousif God loves peace and when just a slight turn of your head can bring peace...God certainly put peace over punishment...

[@arifal-yousif]

@@ansh_u_r Yes but what if Allah never once meant "God" but the literal "Concept of time"?

[@arifal-yousif]

The Missing Piece is "Allah" is LITERALLY "the concept of time". I was raised amongst my people and I saw them suffer. And Filip, you helped me realise it. Thank you, my friend, for actually taking the time to learn. We are not Takfiri, only the Shahadah is required. Legit, your video on Coltrane was one of the final links for me. Your truest of friends, throughout all time, Sayed Arif Mahmood Nasser Sayed Mohammed Al-Yousif of Bahrain, the Two Seas, descendant of Prophet Muhammed and Imam Hussein, may peace and blessings be upon their name.

[@Boss-313]

What do you mean only the Shahadah is required and Allah is the concept of time? Do you have any Reference for your points from the Qur’an and Sunnah?

[@eeeqqq7582]

​@@Boss-313The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Allah said: "The son of Adam hurts Me by abusing Time, for I am Time; in My Hands are all things and I cause the revolution of night and day.' " (See Hadith No. 351, Vol. 6) Bukhari 7491

[@steveryder1174]

"History is complicated" is how I start most conversations when talking about people, events and beliefs. If only people knew

[@thenyaiofficial]

7:55 beautifully explained ! “Intoxicated” is a phase made well known in the journey of sufism…a secret must remain a secret …Hallaj…similar stories with Syeikh Siti Jenar …Hamzah Fansuri….thank you for this beautiful video ❤

[@omidfarshi]

Such an excellent video. I was frozen in some parts when you were reading the poems. Love from Turkey and Iran

[@Gpenguin01]

Talk about a gem and serendipity. I have been reflecting on the Buddha and the term “Tathagata” (or “Thusness” and “Suchness” or “Thus Come” and “Thus Gone”). This term or state of being sounds like what you are saying about al-Hallaj’s “al haqq” moment. An ultimate truth or understanding of the nature of reality - which is the state of dissolution of the self, ego, and permanence (e.g. anatta, anicca, and sunyata in Buddhism) - where one becomes all and nothing all at once. Al-Hallaj’s “I am the Truth” moment sounds similar to the Buddha’s Enlightenment or Tathagata state of “Thusness” and “Suchness” (having already “Thus Come” and Thus Gone”). This form body isn’t important anymore after you experience “al-Haqq.” I always learn something new when I watch your videos - but this is a true gem. Thank you! 🙏

[@AliA-im7xx]

Ohhhh my. the timing on this one. Allahhhhhh. really been looking into Hallaj but haven't found much info outside of the actual incident of his crucifixtion. so excited to watch it

[@NM-me4kn]

Thank you Filip for your amazing work Also a big thank you to the producers who are including such amazing old paintings to your videos

[@kasturiswami784]

The illustrations of Egypt and other places are beautiful.

[@TheSeveer123]

I love how you tackle the topic so maturely

[@someonerandom7796]

This is amazing! Thank you so much, Filip, for introdusing al hallaj. I truly enjoyed it. I have been curious about Al-hallaj ever since you introduced "Ana al-haqq" in one of your videos. He is undeniably controversial. I was even more shocked by his other writings, far more than 'Ana al-Haqq.' It was his views on Satan that truly unsettled me. I do understand why he is such a controversial figure. It makes me wonder whether he reached a deeper level of annihilation (if there are levels to it), or if his experience is commonly shared and he was simply more vocal about it. That could explain why so many figures have been defending him. I wonder if the Sufi community were more open about their spiritual experiences, perhaps he wouldn’t be seen as so controversial.

[@colingallagher1648]

been looking forward for this one thanks

[@Yippee_Ki_Yay]

All mystics, from all over the world speak the same when they meet God.

[@wrathford]

Husayn Ibn Mansur al-Hallaj was a very profound man.

[@bouztkanehafsa2631]

تدهشني دائما باختياراتك للمواضيع محتوى أكتر من رائع كل الشكر والتقدير

[@wisdom6486]

An astonishing presentation again....! I would love to watch a episode dedicated to the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH).

[@ansh_u_r]

😂

[@zacharyowens6664]

That would be a great idea.

[@lotusisme21]

Especially his marraige to his daughter in law that's quite a forbidden love story for even a common man let alone a prophet of God😂

[@MohamedEHK]

⁠@@lotusisme21 bro! I think You even don’t know what’s do you talking. Educate yourself and cousin marriage is only allowed in kin marriage from islam, i love how you give claims on Muhammad Pbuh without proofs.

[@MohamedEHK]

@@lotusisme21you should get best job instead of being keyboard warrior on internet

[@roberttarquinio1288]

These videos are well done I’m currently watching this one on Al-Hallaj

[@zaubergarden6900]

hey, I am currently watching the same video, wow! :)

[@laylaali5977]

Excellent program as a nondenominational Sufi Muslim I have a great respect for this man may god bless him.

[@alaaalssadi6786]

My heart start beating when i read thw title ❤ i recommend شرح شطحيات for Rozbahan Bagli about Hallaj. I hope u try it if u dont know him already. It will help you with Al-Tawaseen.

[@sagaramskp]

ഹല്ലാജെ കൊല്ലും നാൾ അന്നു ഞാനുണ്ടെങ്കിൽ, അപ്പോൾ അവർകയ് പിടിപ്പേനതെന്നോവർ This is a lyrics from an arabi Malayalam song about Sheik Abdul Kadar Jeelani r.a , titled as Muhiyideen maala written on 17th century by Qazi Muhammed of Kerala. It says as the quote of Sheikh Jeelani r.a saying ' If I was present on the day when Hallaj was killed I would have hold their hand ( from killing him).' This song Muhiyideen maala used to be recited by mothers of every orthodox Sunni malayali household and is still famous. So Hallaj's name was familiar from my childhood. Thanks for this insights into his life.

[@fabelworks]

Whaat! My favorite guy doing a thing about my favorite guy❤

[@TerribleShmeltingAccident]

as a western born human this history is unknown to me. ty my friend for your passion, we all benefit from it!

[@ruchiyadav2014]

Not sure if there is any other resource as good as this one available anywhere on Mnsoor al hajaj, the legend is reborn here today.

[@wasiashah5867]

Another great one. Thank you🙏🏻❤️

[@Musafir-t3s]

I was waiting for this

[@kaisersozay99]

Love the effort especially around the visuals u use

[@nsbd90now]

"No-Self" "No-Thing"... people today talk about "non-duality"... in Islam the "Tawheedian World-View" is a real thing. So good!

[@MJBAKANemoStrong]

Non-duality, Duality; it's all just too much. Monotheistic is a complicated idea; Duality, God is everything? The Truth is, Superior, inferior; if you believe in a monotheistic God, there can be no separation from God, only a state of being in favor or out of favor, and everything in-between? I'm a Monotheist, yet I believe in you, while I'm also subject to you, and you me, in the Natural world. Which God rules the heavens? I imagine many.

[@MJBAKANemoStrong]

Duality in relation to Humanity with Monotheism, is a Dichotomy. Duel implies equal parts, playing on each other. The Duality of God in Monotheism, is not inherently a Dichotomy; the reason being, God when applied to the totality of everything, that is Duality. Individuals, in a Monotheistic structure like Islam, cannot say the Duality of Humanity and God, because they are not an Equal part.

[@MJBAKANemoStrong]

When I say Duel implies equal parts, I'm talking about two independent parts, that are together performing a function. They don't have to be physically equal, though without either one, the function cannot be performed; that's the criteria?

[@MJBAKANemoStrong]

You could say individuals with a Monotheistic belief can hold to the idea of Duality; the Function being all that comes with an individual existence. So you're not wrong, even with Islam, Duality is a thing; the Question is, do you believe you are an integral part to that Function? You can't logically take away, from any other individual's relationship to it. I believe in the Duality of Life and God. I'm not trying to take that away from you; I couldn't if I tried, only you could do that.

[@epicmercury333]

Fascinating. شكرًا لك. 🙏🏻☀️❤

[@PARSA.Korosh.Ardashir1]

Mansori Hallaj was a Persian from the Pars province of Iran we're also the Great Persian poet's and Sufi's (Hafiz shirazi) and (saadi shirazi) came out of.... And Yes! During their time they all spoke and wrote in their original Persian language which their books today are still teached about in college's across the world.. while during ancient times the Arab khalifa's we're completely against Iranian philosophers, Sufi's, poet's and academic teachers who were killed, tortured and ridiculed because of their works and ideology which started many legendary campaigns from different regions of iran against the arab khalifa's and directly the reason iranians kept their ancient identity and language.. unlike neighboring Assyrians, Babylonians, Levantine, Egyptians etc

[@SapientSaga]

The greatest living prophet in the world - Psilocybin ❤.

[@jaybird6905]

it’s just another realm. but it can show you things. think of psychadelics as a key that can unlock a door. but you need to open that door and step through it in your own life. if you keep just jiggling the key over and over, you will break the key, and the lock, and you will be stuck crying before the door for what could have been

[@SapientSaga]

@@jaybird6905 nope , think about it. Spiritual people would say mystical experiences are not the result of some chemical reactions . Then how can psychedelics do so ? Those are chemicals and when consumed, it interacts with the chemicals in our body and produces those mystical experiences.

[@teamcrumb]

@@SapientSaga psilocybin is an entity that helps us step outside of our egos, it doesn't produce a mythical experience it enables us to be in the world in a way we weren't before we drank 'the potion', it improves our chances of taking note of what is mystical and it allows us to experience new foundations and a higher, lower, deeper, wider vantage point

[@stoicforall]

I can hear you recite Sufi poetry all day long ❤

[@chrispecora6223]

Fantastic timing cause this was a great beach listen and some watch💨🌹

[@LaurenBerns]

Wonderful, as usual. Thanks so much for creating these wonderful lectures.

[@wwondertwin]

His mistake was revealing his experience to people who could never understand it because they hadn't experienced it (yet, or at all, depending on the individual). You need to be very delicate when talking about experiences like that, because it can come off as very arrogant and people will misunderstand any words uttered in the joyous ecstasy of that kind of mystical spiritual experiences.

[@SamathaVipassana93]

Finally you talk about hallaj. He was the Jesus of Islam

[@brunokiraly7121]

Thank you so much for this video! I like and watch every video in your channel, but the sufi ones I wait with great enthusiasm!

[@isam1bushra919]

انا لم اسمع بالحلاج من قبل لكن عمل جميل منك و يشرح كثير ❤❤❤

[@tahayassine7435]

Beautiful work as always ! I would like to provide a precision, the correct translation for the last verse in this poem 23:36 would be : And in my annihilation, you were found. Which emphasizes that after the annihilation , there is no « I » to find god.

[@aviksblog8145]

Looking forward to this one and hope for more Sufi videos

[@suhailqasim6522]

Great Explanation 💙

[@Shiyam-h7g]

Beautiful work

[@ligiasommers]

Undoubtedly fascinating with many points to think : I am the truth versus I am from Christ . The execution by political and keeping the power reasons . Finally , the horrific execution of someone that talked about God and Love . His teachings are very inspiring as are many other martyrs’ 🙏🏻

[@Turkistonkanal]

Thank you brother 👍

[@iesureloaded6139]

Wow that was awesome ❤

[@minicineaste]

I enjoy your sharing of your experience of the debt we owe to the mysticism of the Sufis. I'd be interested in your assessment of the journey of the tribal mind toward a truth beyond form as expressed by Idries Shah, whose clan arguably seems to have sided with the English in their fool's errand in Afghanistan. Or even better your reading of "The Mouse-proof Kitchen" by a living Sufi. I fear we sometimes devote too much of our presence to a debatable past and not enough devotion to the future.

[@ezreality]

Another great podcast... Thank you...

[@skram1000]

Love it as always

[@zacharyowens6664]

Amazing video! Would love to see a video on Yarsanism in the future.

[@ministryofgnosis]

Awesome work, thank you!

[@yafayafa9601]

Thank u for this.❤

[@devangel2]

It almost sounds like he talks of God like a part of his consciousness. Very interesting 🤔

[@bolatm22]

Not part, but the consciousness itself😊

[@shambo-rm8ql]

God is The pure consciousness. In Hinduism, God is called 'Sat Chit Ananad', which literally means true blissful consciousness. If a person deconditions himself and gets rid of all ego and dogma, what remains is sat chit ananad. The person experiences true blissful consciousness

[@shattered_lightsb8381]

The statement “Ana'l-Ḥaqq”. Reminds me of a famous 2 word saying: Ahaṁ Brahmāsmi It’s interesting that the primary period of his teaching was after his travels to India, I wonder if he had been influenced by any groups there

[@SapientSaga]

If I am not wrong, Sufism was influenced by the syriac Christian mysticism and the greek spiritual ideas which had parallel to Indian ideas .

[@ashishmantri3684]

​@@SapientSagayes you r right, infact that's the reason western and indian cultures are called indo-european. Lots of ideas floating around in gospel of john wherein you u see similar utterrances were based on greek mystical traditions as well. So many similarities are most likely due to Christian tradition which itself borrows a lot from neoplatonism, greek philosophy and mysticism and combines it with jewish idea of God.

[@sagaramskp]

Every religion was based on same principle. Time just made rusts. Right Veda has same concept as Islamic monotheism right, but most people don't know. People are blind in hearts. Sages of past had seen the truth and written it down at different parts of the world. We Muslims believe God has send one lakh twenty five and more Prophets during different time periods to different parts of the world to lead people back to him, from Prophet Adam to Prophet Muhammed. The teachings of these enlightened rightly guided men were written down and later when time corroded their teachings people just forget who they really were. Just like what they did with Prophet Jesus. So what I was saying was yeah, there is common thread on basic principles everywhere but we had to dig deep.

[@SapientSaga]

@@sagaramskp was guru nanak and guru govind singh also prophets ? are sikhs the people of books ?

[@miguelatkinson]

​@@sagaramskpno rig veda does not teach islamic monotheism

[@juliusnovachrono4370]

Honestly ive never heard of this man so this video is amazing.😅

[@flutiyama]

It baffles me how we have had so many people get to this truth (Nibbhana/Fannah/realization/Moksha) throughout history, and nevertheless we are as far from spiritual union as we were in the times of Buddha/Jesus/Mohammed. Wish more people are able to get the message without being prejudiced by so many dogmas.

[@jeremias-serus]

Sorry, but logic will always triumph vibez my friend.

[@hunglikehorse4339]

@@jeremias-serus 100 % agreed

[@turkceogreniyorum-ex5xt]

@@jeremias-serusyour heart was in your body months before your brain even started developing.The heart is the first Organ. Thats a huge sign for people who „think“.

[@naeemulhoque1777]

You cannot made up things abou God. He is a deviant. And he did not knew the truth about Allah. The truth about Allah is what Allah attributed to himself, not some assumptions of men. kzbin.info/www/bejne/e3y0o5iYaJelma8

[@estellewarren62]

You don't think we've moved at all?

[@cameo777]

Truly remarkable presentation.

[@scrobblesbyDJGunbound]

I'm not able to watch it right now but I wonder if you have read the huge work of Louis Massignon about Al-Hallaj. In any case, great content as always!

[@sagaramskp]

Yes he mentions that book and the work of Louis Massignon in the video

[@ishqnoor]

JazakAllah Khayrun 💚

[@mkmd555]

Mysticism and Sufism often attract individuals with a tendency toward unusual and eccentric thinking, sometimes described in psychological terms as having schizotypal personality traits. These individuals may struggle to navigate the complexities of everyday life, leading them to create alternative realities that provide a sense of purpose and identity. This self-constructed reality can bolster their self-esteem and offer a coping mechanism. However, this perspective can sometimes verge on delusional thinking or, at the very least, become an overvalued belief system that disconnects them from more practical and grounded ways of understanding the world.

[@michaeldillon3113]

Thank you Filip 🙏🕉️

[@ITX-HUR]

قَالُوْا سُبْحٰنَكَ مَا كَانَ یَنْۢبَغِیْ لَنَاۤ اَنْ نَّتَّخِذَ مِنْ دُوْنِكَ مِنْ اَوْلِیَآءَ وَ لٰـكِنْ مَّتَّعْتَهُمْ وَ اٰبَآءَهُمْ حَتّٰى نَسُوا الذِّكْرَۚ-وَ كَانُوْا قَوْمًۢا بُوْرًا(18) وہ عرض کریں گے:(اے اللہ!) تو پاک ہے، ہمارے لئے ہر گز جائز نہیں تھا کہ ہم تیرے سوا کسی اور کومددگاربنائیں لیکن تو نے انہیں اور ان کے باپ داداؤں کو فائدہ اُٹھانے دیا یہاں تک کہ انہوں نے (تیری) یاد کو بھلا دیا اور یہ لوگ ہلاک ہونے والے ہی تھے۔ Or وہ عرض کریں گے”پاک ہے آپ کی ذات، ہماری تو یہ بھی مجال نہ تھی کہ آپ کے سوا کسی کو اپنا مولیٰ بنائیں۔ مگر آپ نے ان کو اور ان کے باپ دادا کو خوب سامانِ زندگی دیا حتٰی کہ یہ سبق بھُول گئے اور شامت زدہ ہو کر رہے۔“ Or They will say: “Glory to Thee! not meet was it for us that we should take for protectors others besides Thee: But Thou didst bestow, on them and their fathers, good things (in life), until they forgot the Message: for they were a people (worthless and) lost.”

[@mirwanimuiz7840]

Thanks Filip

[@alimirzabeg]

When a believer is able to READ his Nafs (Being) It is the Book (Al-Kitab) Alif Laam Meem So, He is granted the Khirqa (Dress) n When He travels the Sirat-ul-Hameed He reaches to Sunnah of Knowledge of this Book so was given the Turban (Dustar-Qulla) n When a person receive all that delivered on Station of Muhammad (The Praiseworthy) - AL INSAAN AL KAMAL - Al-Hallaj only tread the path of Knowledge (Sirat-ul-Mustaqeem) similarly to Budda & Guru Nanak. Where Knowledge of God is the Truth (as knowledge is no other than Him) But Life also is Al-Haq n that's the path of Praise - So, from His Knowledge & Life (Intellect) to Create His Praise n Man is such Creation. Either Blameworthy or Praiseworthy. وَيُرِيدُ اللَّهُ أَن يُحِقَّ الْحَقَّ بِكَلِمَاتِهِ وَيَقْطَعَ دَابِرَ الْكَافِرِينَ

[@brunokiraly7121]

Great video!

[@davidanderson911]

In your description of Hallaj's concern with God, over God's relationship with Adam, I couldn't help but be reminded of the Parable of the Periodical Son from my culture. Of how the older son felt when the Father accepted the sinful son back with such celebration. The older may have indeed figured himself better and more worthy of a relationship with his Father. Crazy, huh?!

[@davidanderson911]

After thinking about the matter, as Satan was related by your presentation regarding Hallaj, there also seems like an element of Judas. Especially as he is described in the Gospel of Judas, as I generally understand it.

[@Abdullah_0083]

i was so confused when i read the title as Al Hajjaj

[@nsbd90now]

Al-Hallaj is one of my favorite people.

[@teejay9388]

Thank you 🙏💐

[@Wordsareloud]

When someone reaches the Destination of Higher Spirituality You make him voice, "I am the Truth" Then you make the verdicts of infidelity against him Then you yourself send Mansoor to the crucifix Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan

[@khaldrogo4460]

Say it in urdu

[@Wordsareloud]

@@khaldrogo4460 Jazb-o-masti Ki Jo Manzil Pe Puhanchta Hai Koi When someone reaches the Destination of Higher Spirituality Baith Kar Dil Mein An-al-haq Ki Sada Dete Ho You make him voice, "I am the Truth" Khud Hi Lagwatay Ho Phir Kufr Ke Fatway Uss Par Then you make the verdicts of infidelity against him Khud Hi Mansoor Ko Sooli Pe Charha Dete Ho Then you yourself send Mansoor to the crucifix

[@PradeepKumar-bh6ly]

Next cover Sarmad (a Jew converted to islam and then Hinduism and then crazy and behaded)

[@ibrav7979]

Full name?

[@PradeepKumar-bh6ly]

@@ibrav7979 Sarmad Kashani

[@destitutewayfarer2901]

Sarmad remained a Muslim until his execution. He was executed mainly due to political reasons as he was a spiritual guide to Dara Shikoh. There's no evidence of him accepting Hinduism.

[@Sajad_70073]

@@ibrav7979 Sarmad Kashani

[@ibrav7979]

​@@destitutewayfarer2901 From what I am reading on Wikipedia, he was accused of being atheist, could be wrong tho

[@ashishmantri3684]

Hallaj making a makelike of the kaaba in his house aftr his visit to india looks like just how we hindus make gods temple in a place and start circumbulating it. We even have such things inside our houses wherein our mothers ask us to circumable it.

[@beyonder7817]

There is also a book based on him named "Ana al-Haq", that means "I am the Truth"

[@Ismedeo]

I suggest you respell it to "ana Al-Haq". The way you wrote it would be good material for trolls.

[@desimujahid]

Anal truth

[@michaelshelton5488]

Your comments about religious mystics often being very conservative reminds me of Hasidic Jews, who are considered "ultra Orthodox", but are also very committed Kabbalists

[@leoshamar88]

Thanks!

[@kamishbhamani5364]

I am an Ismaili Muslim. Love it. Is there any way for you to share your library books?

[@admoni.]

Adore your videos.

[@tanyashafi961]

Reminds me of Socrates. These men were dangerous - they were vigourously vocal about man's personal connection to truth/the Divine. So they killed them in a way to obliterate, demean and terrify.

[@SP-ny1fk]

The issue with proclaiming these experiences to the common man is that he proposed no method by which others could do the same. He got followers - but no disciples. So his intention to share the experience with the masses was ill-guided and ill-fated. You should talk to a Sahaja Yogi

[@mehboob-e-jahan9929]

I envy you for your knowledge of Islam & Islamic mysticism besides the deep research you undertake on some extremely difficult topics and things. Today, you were looking intoxicated by the annihilation (فنا) of our great Mansoor Al Halaj (peace & honour be upon him) while so was I. What is your faith that you practice or believe in, or are you still in the process of selecting one? 😊 It's wished I could extend monetary assistance. Allah Almighty be with us on all fronts and every time, amen! Our great pol leader, statesman and reformer by the name of Khan e Azam Mahatma Zaigham 🦁 Imran🌹Khan is in jail, like Al Halaj was, for no folly of his; do pray for his total, complete and ultimate victory, please. Mr Khan from Pakistan 🇵🇰 21 Sep 24

[@zaubergarden6900]

whoops - I love it!

[@ParanoidNotAndroid]

22:30 i cant believe your research lead you to prononce arabic correctly, you have my utmost respect! Keep it up your sources are better than any second in every islamic class

[@whatslifespurpose]

Very similar to Advaita Vendanta with The Brahman and The Atman (True Self) which is achieved by annihilation of the mind.

[@mabroukatis]

Would be great if you add names in Arabic letters as well. Latin letters mixes them up

[@Babylon_Fallin]

Kindly requesting a video of what or who amalek is 🙏🙏

[@tessathulien61]

How did you learn to speak Arabic so well? I wish to learn ❤

[@user-dz9yx3et9y]

Rumi said the person whom you are persecuting is not Husayn Ibn Mansur al-Hallaj, Mansur left this plain already.

[@austinmackell9286]

Self abnegation, Nietzsche would say, is a masked will to power. The (current) mainstream perspective in Sunni Islam, as I understand it, pre-empts this insight, reflect that considers the anti-wordly impulse as an "innovation" (which is bad.)

[@erikkhan]

Thnk u for making distinction between liberalism and sufism .Do you why western people think that way about sufism .

[@nawnaw4709]

Excellent Arabic pronunciation

[@craigdelaney8737]

Thank you for This..❤️ I knew Nothing of all this..! Christianity teaches not, this level of thought.. And modern Religion Is Def in the mind concerning what it has left behind. And Even seams to Want to lay waist to the future.. ..And again thank You.🙏🏾💕

[@ashishmantri3684]

Very interesting actually , the early Islam was mostly a secular Arabic expansionist movement whose followers didn't call themselves muslims but rather identified as Mumineen. Evn the islamic proclamation of faith was just La ilaha ilallah ,the muhammad as his prophet was after half or a century after muhammad. And this Muhammad mighnot actually be the muhammad mostly presented by the hadith. The hadith sources are deeply unreliable and infact many Islamic scholars themselves criticised using them in the beginning as many of them were near to caliphs and their sons and early salaf but none had actually quoted the prophet said...any time but many of the boys in Arabia were going around saying that twenty four hours a day 😂. Definitely this Islam we know today is much like christianity which diverged and changed as the followers started to develop a separate identity.

[@sagaramskp]

😂 U learned this B.S from Rss shakas in india? Being ignorant is not a crime, but not knowing u r ignorant and talking bullshit is real jahiliyah

[@InternetetWanderer]

I hope you would cover the topic of Satan in islam more closely. As other scholars did consider Satan to be actually good and a true believer, how would rejoin God's grace in the end times.

[@TheGEOPOLITICIANGUY]

حقّ is ver rarely used as real - both in archaic form and contemporary -- sometimesss authentic - yes - but when the definitive form ال is used - its used as true, truth, correct

[@LetsTalkReligion]

That which is True is that which is Real

[@kassimtufail9061]

Beautiful work great impressive information. I’m really grateful for this kind of unique knowledge!

[@asifvomit]

tq

[@Andreh.T]

Hi everyone,can we say that all teachings of spiritual schools are fragment of old Egyptian thoughts of enlightenment?

[@shambo-rm8ql]

If Advaita Vedanta is the PhD in Sprituality, Sufiism is Masters Christianity is Bachelors Islam is anti Spirituality

[@ibrahimelmasry-z3k]

رحم الله مولاي الحلاج

[@gaslitworldf.melissab2897]

He was "brutally" executed. Is there a way to execute sans brutality? Even most poisons entail some degree of suffering before death. *Anyway, I love your videos, excellent content.*