Boy, the Wahhabi/Salafi hivemind is gonna lose it now! 😂 Religions, like societies, evolve. This is only news (not to mention heretical innovation or "bid'ah") to fanatical literalists within the Islamic fold. It is the exact job of Muslim jurists ("fuqaha") to make fatwas based on applied scripture and its evolutionary history. For example, cigarette use was ridiculously common in the Muslim world until recent scientific studies showing its overwhelmingly bad attributes, making cigarette a "self harm" habit and easily moving into "haram" classification for a numerical majority of fuqaha worldwide. Common Muslims may debate amongst each other freely about the deleterious effects of this or that cultural product, but when the fuqaha speak it is now a matter of religious law.

This video is actually incorrect in its analysis, the Hanafi school did not allow alcohol consumption, there are many verses they use that come together. This guy did a trick by only mentioning one verse and telling hanafi understanding of it to mean grape alcohol which is right but did a wrong analysis by saying therefore allowed other alcohol, totally incorrect. There are many verses and sayings of the Prophet is also law, taken together about alcohol that makes consuming any amount of alcohol, selling it, making money from it, buying it, manufacturing it even selling your fruits to the people who make alcohol unequivocally prohibited and violating Islamic law. Do not get your understanding of Islam from this channel.

Up

You can't give a deductive computational argument about God which is majoritarily based on knowing by participating.

You are a lying hypocrite Abu Hanifa never said that alcohol is Halal in Islam because it is written in quran that alcohol is haram.

Thanks for this brilliant overview of Jewish mysticism! It's amazing the fundamental similarities mystics have across nearly all traditions!

Wow, so many Ahmed, Mohammed experts in alchol in the comments... It is incredible!!!

Worst form of Islam, by far.

Always forbidden but as human, there is always people who looking reason or exception from something forbidden from god, even all history of religion in the world there always movement to change rule or law in their own religion so they wont feel guilty when doing it 😊 but Al Qur'an law will never change!!! It's already proven until TODAY!!! AAMIIN 🤲🤲

the stance of tyson definitely shows the way people generally think of muslims. kinda hard not to look at it as islamophobic. the man clearly upheld rationality and math but no if tyson says that al-ghazali was anti-rationality/anti-math then we have to agree with him. the west is stupid.

Must be mentioned to that Muslim extremists at his time saw him as an apostate and wanted to kill him.

I noticed that these pop ups are displayed whenever someone mentions the annunaki in a video, similar to how the same phenomenon occurred whenever people spoke about jovid 19. Maybe the annunaki are copyrighted like the virus is.

yep cuz there is a strong Hadith in that matter "Every intoxicant is Khamr (alcohol), and every intoxicant is Haram (forbidden).", I think that Hadith didn't get to Abu Hanifa and many other Islamic scholars so they ruled with as much as the verse stated since that was the only valid evidence they had back then, which is not the case later, but ofc this is just based on my very limited knowledge on the matter

In sindh we had sufi malamatis like watayo faqeer

I think this is the one thing that makes someone islamic imam/figure that pray himself? 😅 I forgot a lot, but instead of pray "subhanallah" : great o the god, he said "subhani" : great o me. 😅 Is it?

Its more in Sunni Islam. He will be a leader and unite all muslim believers.

The Gazan Martyrs, the children, their mothers and fathers and grandparents (RA) have nothing to worry about now. Are we crying for them when they are crying for us? They passed their tests with flying colors; and what about us? We are still here, getting tested *every..................... single............... day.*

The use of the word probably instill wisdom in uncertainty.. also that, alot of what is claimed to be known isn't

There are many fake copies of it. My father has an original hand written copy of it

Going from "there must be something at the beginning" to "therefore the islamic god is real" is a huge leap that doesn't make sense.

Any lindu here😂

We don't base any evidence from schools of law, we take our laws from the prophets lifestyle and the quran and the way the prophet explained the quran. The matter was settled long before any group decided anything because our prophet told us every intoxicant is khamr and every kind/nature of khamr (meaning any form, denotation, category etc) is haram. So I don't understand why and when a school of thought became any source to attain islamic laws from

No Forms of alcohol are allowed only the Vinegar

Really Bad Alcohol never touch👎🙂

Watching this you realize Muhammad was a corrupt opportunist who used religion to conquer and steal land from other people.

Da Universe IS God,God is da Universe,the Holy Spirit of da Bible bein' da energy of da Universe,there......🫡

The external Existent could also be a contingent from another dimension could it not? This is a proof? It seems more of a theorem?

GODLINESS IS THE ACKNOWLEDGEMENT, LOVE, FEAR, SACRIFICE TO, WORSHIP AND SERVING OF YEHOVAH ALONE AS GOD AND NOT THE ABOMINABLE MAKING OF IDOLS AND IDOLIZATION OF PERSONS AND HEROES AS GOD BESIDES YEHOVAH THE TRUE GOD ALONE. A HERETIC IS THE ANTILAW, ANTICOVENANT ANTIYEHOVAH AND THAT CAN BE A PERSON OR A CHURCH OR NATION. AN OPPOSER OF AN ANTILAW ANTICOVENANT ANTIYEHOVAH PERSON OR CHURCH IS A RIGHTEOUS MAN BEFORE YEHOVAH THE RIGHTEOUS GOD BUT MAY BE DECLARED A HERETIC BY AN UNREPENTANT PERVERTED CHURCH. Jeremiah 23:18,35-37 ASV For who hath stood in the council of Jehovah, that he should perceive and hear his word? who hath marked my word, and heard it? [35] Thus shall ye say every one to his neighbor, and every one to his brother, What hath Jehovah answered? and, What hath Jehovah spoken? [36] And the burden of Jehovah shall ye mention no more: for every man's own word shall be his burden; for ye have perverted the words of the living God, of Jehovah of hosts our God. [37] Thus shalt thou say to the prophet, What hath Jehovah answered thee? and, What hath Jehovah spoken? Psalm 119:165 ASV Great peace have they that love thy law; And they have no occasion of stumbling. Psalm 19:11 ASV Moreover by them is thy servant warned: In keeping them there is great reward.

Thanks!

Wow! this video is excellent! Here the obscure Qumran community is more clearly & scholarly explained than I have seen elsewhere, with great images that illustrate it beautifully. Thank you

Many apologists (professional and YTers) will fall back to philosophy as a means of showing the existence of God is necessary. Relying on philosophy has at least two problems. First, from reviewing PhilPapers surveys, you will find that the majority of academic philosophers are atheists. These people spend their academic career reviewing, and pondering about different metaphysical and philosophical ideas, including the arguments for God, but are not enough to convince the experts in the field. Second, even if the majority of academic philosophers are wrong, the arguments only lead to theism, not Islam. Separate arguments are necessary to show the Abrahamic God is true. There are specific problems with the contingency argument. 1. The conclusion to the argument is a necessary agent, not a God. 2. Appealing to a non-contingent agent is special pleading, as an infinite regress isn't a logical contradiction. 3. Matter is anything that has mass and takes up space. With E = mc^2, energy and mass can change forms. Law of Conservation of Energy states energy cannot be created or destroyed, but can only change forms. Our universe reduces down to a gravitational singularity, so intense that spacetime itself would break down. Since spacetime breaks down, the beginning of our space and our time didn't start until the expansion of the singularity (Big Bang Cosmology). Our universe is contingent on energy, and that energy is the necessary agent.

It's good that you answered but you're not answerable to us at all. Just be there. ❤🇮🇳❤

Let’s be intellectually honest Islam or not avoiding alcool is the best thing you can do for yourself

Thank you for this video! I love watching your content.

Alcohol in therapy( drug) is permitted but if you have alternate better avoid the alcohol

You are wrong, Khamr is not specific to grape wine. The root word خمر mean to cover up that’s why the other word for hijab is khemar or خمار. It was call that name because is cover up your mind thus the name khamr is for anything consumed to reduce mental capacity.

The Qur'an mention alcohol in many forms and referring to it not only by what it is but also by what it causes and prohibited it in the different forms and references. Aka it's haram in all school of thought

Well.. apparently.. the United States of America Government and Many American citizens are Anti-Christs that will have to be Dealt with... and Jesus was not the Christ. Course, many think I am here to Heal people because of the false prophets (preachers, teachers, etc) and Jesus the Pseudo-Christ thst has caused me great suffering and I have basically been tortured because of what individuals believe since I have existed here on Earth, and many have tortured me intentionally and unintentionally because of how they are or what they believe. I am the Anointed ONE of Prophecy, also the Messiah, I was Anointed November 1st, 2014. My SOUL and Spirit to be, to be, to be day when my Soul and Spirit came to be in this physical vessel my body while in my mother's womb which my parents and whom I pray now "took part" in creation of, that day my SOUL and Spirit came to be was November 1st, 1974. I was birthed from my mother September 25th, 1975 on 2 holidays of 2 of the world's major Religions, Ramadan 1395, and the Jews Feast of Booths Sukkot 6. Course, many Prophecies from many cultures on Earth foretold I would Exist. I am NOT here to Heal everyone, or to be their Sacrificial Lamb, I am the Anointed HOLY LORD GOD on Earth, it's MINE, I was Gifted planet Earth by whom I pray. I pray to "Who has NO NAME, NOT male or female, created many and took part in creation of All, and Anointed the Anointed". Any individual can pray to whom I pray and communicate with whom I pray, seek answers in the sky around you, the largest yes or no, false or truth, depending on how whomever recieves those answer from whom I pray that in truth it is whom I pray that answers because their are tricksters... and NO, I am not like Jesus of those that forced or persecuted or persecute individuals fir not praying to whom they pray, and no one will have such done to them for not praying to whom I pray. NO individual or entity, God or Goddess or Creator or group created "Everything", for whom I pray also DID NOT create everything. Just a simple example, with Male and Female that have Sexual Intercourse, tje Male Sperm Fertilizes the Female egg during the process of Sexual Procreation, so tje Male and Female "take part in the creation of that child or spawn", and whom I pray, that energy or such that exists everywhere also takes part in the creation of that child or spawn. That such energy exists everywhere connected to all that exist, the simplest of basics to understand, a Great Mystery but the best that I can explain that I understand and know about how whom I pray exists. Anointed HOLY LORD ERIC EC4 Ps... maybe the dating time period due to the Psuedo-Christ Jesus of the New Testament of the Roman Catholic Bible... should be 1000 BPC (Before Psuedo Christ), and ADPC (After Death of Psuedo Christ),for a interpretation of time and dates with TRUTH of whom Jesus is instead of LIES. Course, I am the TRUE Mashiac, Messiah of the Hebrew and Islam Prophets, and I was Birthed September 25th, 1975 at 02:00 hours Central Standard North American Continent on Earth Standard 365 Day a year Military Time.

Persians are not Muslims.

Or you and your weird video

Alhough Khamr is fermented grape wine any form of intoxicant drinks are forbidden. Fermented grape wine was the common wine at that time that is why the word Khamr is widely used.

I was so excited for this video but it's not very accessible. I have a fairly sharp mind, background in science and maths but this video felt like a dense bunch of jargon. unless your primary aim was to prepare a rigorous expression of this philosophical argument, it does poorly in communicating the essence of this idea. thank you for putting this much effort into the video but if your target audience was general public, this needs refinement, simplification. have a good day. and do let me know if you ever decide to refine this video.

Sufism is not only islamic. It's universal humanity for the whole world.

ive just found out channel this month!! thx for the great work, ive always been interested in theology. I was wondering if you were planning on visiting "Ibadism"? ive always been interested in the history of judaism and islam in the southern Arabian peninsula + north Africa.

Is this the best argument for the existence of god? Maybe. But still, there are no good arguments for god. None. Because the 100 percent lack of evidence for such is the overriding argument. The first cause argument is the leamest of all.

The point of it all is that creation is perfect, you cant change it, you cant escape it, its all a circle. Every wisdom leads u back to the start. Everything is a paradox. You keep conventional wisdom because it is wiser than enlignement. The light is just the knowing. You do everything you do, just like before. You just know but you dont need to. Being ignroant is perfectly wise.

As a Hindu, I’m not sure if I should be glad or not that he didn’t become emporer instead of Aurangzeb. On the one hand; Aurangzeb was evil, but he did cause Hindus especially the Marathas and the Sikhs to rise up and destroy the Mughals. If Dara became emporer, likely Hindus would have been fine under the Mughal Empire, and they would have never rose up, slowly converting and Islamisising the country. So, it may have been worse for us in the long run to have a ruler who was good and respected us, and didn’t want to destroy our religion. Ironic.

He's said to be a descendant of ali through the idrisid dynasty his full name is Abd al qadir ibn muhieddine al hassani al jaza'iri Al hassani comes from hassan ibn ali ibn abi talib

Alcohol is prohibited but after you die you will get unlimited alcohol 😂😂😂😂😂 What a load of bullshit

Avicenna ? His name is IBNO SINA