None of the covers can even match Jay Chou's, but i would rather listen to Sara Liu's rendition than the other one.
@softerhaze29 күн бұрын
Liu Xijun’s version is absolutely stunning, she sang the vicissitudes of life, if she had also included the Chinese opera part at the end it would’ve been perfection. The focus of Chinese instruments in her version as well made it all the more beautiful
The first one did a better job simply because this was the perfect song for her, imo.
@weewahgan692222 күн бұрын
Who need opinions of those commentaries preferring the suitability of voice of other singer on this songs over 单依纯? In my opinion, I can say 单依纯 sings better than Sara Liu. But again i did it on the commentaries here with due respect to the artist singing here. Just listen to the tonalities of the singing is enough. 单依纯 is another class. You can't compare. I heard Sara Liu singing in Cantonese before. Honestly 单依纯 singing in Cantonese very well though Cantonese is not her dialect.
@synsam8073Ай бұрын
虽然刘的版本更符合这首歌的两位创作者(方和黄)的创作初衷,但这两人都表示更偏爱单依纯的版本
@erickong6490Ай бұрын
我本人也覺得單的版本比較特別,因為她真的用心加入了一些新元素,不會墨守成規
@PaulNewman-h6cАй бұрын
Sara can sing the phone book. Drop the Mic 🎤 despite being underrated. The other one mediocre but yet overrated a bit, imo.
@xiaoshan6232Ай бұрын
👍💐
@auact2013Ай бұрын
刘明显更自然流畅。单太刻意运用技巧。
@TrioSupervocalАй бұрын
Agreed. Good singing is not just about techniques it's about feelings
@stevey9282Ай бұрын
Liu Xi Jun - so SO lovingly sweet 😘
@networm78Ай бұрын
Liu Xijun's rendition suits the tempo of this song more. Shan Yichun's rendition is a tad too sorrowful.
@風拂塵峰望晨Ай бұрын
這首歌還是適合先給男聲
@adaxiao4728Ай бұрын
这歌除了周杰伦,别人唱都不好听
@hollyloo1183Ай бұрын
那除了杰倫作品 誰你也別听就好了!
@kongsumlau17218 күн бұрын
单这次这有点谭晶的感觉😊
@kezhu248427 күн бұрын
刘惜君的情绪节奏要饱满些,而单依纯版本声音完美,但好像单纯靠声音来表达,节奏也好像拖了半拍
@WTWong-t3fАй бұрын
For real everything Sara Liu does is from the soul, while the other one’s warble tones didn’t suit the song, sorry.