Mac vs PC Video Editing Showdown ft. iJustine!!

Thanks to ASUS for sponsoring this video! Check out the ASUS Zenbook Pro Duo on Amazon (Paid Link) at geni.us/Y5fgEtw #DoMoreWithDuo
PC vs Mac - Premiere vs Final Cut. What's the best ecosystem for editing video? In this video, iJustine goes head to head against Taran from Linus Tech Tips to find out- with special guest judges Niko from Corridor, Jenna Ezarik, Bitwit Kyle, and Faruk from iPhonedo!
Thanks to iJustine again for hosting us! Check out the BTS video on her channel at • Mac VS PC editing chal...
Thanks to Austin for letting us edit your video. Check out the winner's cut at • Why Does Chrome OS Sti...
Judges:
Niko @ Corridor - / corridordigital
Kyle @ Bitwit - / awesomesaucenews
Jenna @ Jenna Ezarik - / jennaezarik
Faruk @ iPhonedo - / iphonedocom
Buy Apple MacBook Pro:
On Amazon (Paid Link): geni.us/4nZ8k
On Newegg: lmg.gg/pNWNk
Buy Sabrent Rocket XTRM 2TB Thunderbolt 3 External SSD:
On Amazon (Paid Link): geni.us/ADGvzx
On Newegg: lmg.gg/WajlF
Buy Sabrent USB-C 2TB Nano External SSD Drive:
On Amazon (Paid Link): geni.us/CQVV
On Newegg: lmg.gg/mqvDB
Purchases made through some store links may provide some compensation to Linus Media Group.
Discuss on the forum: linustechtips....
Our Affiliates, Referral Programs, and Sponsors: lmg.gg/sponsors
Get a Displate Metal Print at lmg.gg/displat...
Get a 30-day free trial of Amazon Prime at lmg.gg/8KV1v
Linus Tech Tips merchandise at www.LTTStore.com/
Our Test Benches on Amazon: www.amazon.com...
Our production gear: geni.us/cvOS
Twitter - / linustech
Facebook - / linustech
Instagram - / linustech
Twitch - / linustech
Intro Screen Music Credit:
Title: Laszlo - Supernova
Video Link: • [Electro] - Laszlo - S...
iTunes Download Link: itunes.apple.c...
Artist Link: / laszlomusic
Outro Screen Music Credit: Approaching Nirvana - Sugar High / approachingnirvana

[@mkbhd]

Thoroughly enjoyed this

[@A.R.Shahan]

Yo, it's actually him

[@salmank9123]

I know Marques would have voted for Taran. More mature + crisper editing.

[@gonewiththewind837]

nice to see ya in the comment section

[@Koffiato]

nice.

[@OMGBEES]

Right. Most of the recent longer form factor and obviously sponsored videos from LTT have been genuinely enjoyable.

[@austinevans]

Too bad you can't buy Final Cut at the LTT STORE

[@itaintitpewds]

lmao

[@karasawamiko2936]

ah that is a big oof right there

[@nickewanchuk6831]

Austin Evans 😂😂 so true

[@gaminglemonpro412]

Bruh

[@mahinurrahman6505]

Lol

[@GamersGalaxy66]

poor guy, had to spend 4 hours editing and then edit the video of him spending 4 hours editing.

[@DoktorWhatson]

And he had to edit how he lost and relive it over and over again.

[@pineappleboi27]

😂😂😂

[@dooley9621]

Poor guy had to spend four hours with a simpleton like Justine. That's the saddest part in my opinion

[@chasetv3346]

@@dooley9621 poor guy got paid

[@migs6674]

Doktor Whatson Hiiii

[@mashy712]

Taran: Uses macro keys with his 3 keyboards and a mixer DAC box iJustine: I’m just using my trackpad.

[@brandonkey181]

in a way that made it so that justine was in her comfort zone more than he was probably. Only difference for her was the headphones.

[@catfan5618]

@Saprioof Not on a Mac.

[@sgtpepper54321]

@@catfan5618 this times 10. I used the HP spectre and my MacBook Pro from 2012 was still a better experience

[@ayanokoji5594]

@@sgtpepper54321 stop the cap

[@gam3stv]

@@ayanokoji5594 MacBook's trackpads are just different, there's no any windows laptops with this kind of trackpad..

[@MadAboutTutorials]

"Try unplugging it and plugging it back in" - ultimate tech tip from Linus.

[@zoki.to974]

what solves 99% of issues with your computer? re-start... or simple unplug and plug again...

[@MadAboutTutorials]

@@zoki.to974 yup, I tell clients "I had to initiate a technical cycle" aka, turn it off and back on again.

[@solepanic6583]

and it works

[@gaunterodimm8120]

You know what works even better?Smashing the thing just like i do with my remote

[@jonasgrill1155]

He probably forgot to disable the USB Hibernation feature in all honesty.

[@reDQlas]

Linus is acting like those Discovery channel guys who explain what animals are doing

[@red_boum]

That is offensive yet Hilarious

[@wembley636]

Yeh well you would have to do it when you have iFAKE... sorry sorry I mean ichar.. what's her name again?

[@jsweizston5410]

The word you're looking for is David Attenborough.

[@devaraft]

@@wembley636 lmao who hurt you

[@josephs.7960]

Tru tru

[@gormygorm]

"He left in a lot of long rants" of course he did, he edits for linus. Half the channel is rants lmao

[@Whitey23]

Trueeeee 😂

[@kpeteho6ot]

The rants are my favorite part, so that is a legit way of doing things.

[@gormygorm]

@@kpeteho6ot yeah I love the rants too, one of my favorites is the first red camera video which in itself is just a rant

[@justinyhc3057]

@@gormygorm too bad some people don't. honestly if no one rants enough then companies cannot improve their products entirely.

[@Gildaaaaaaas]

Cut all the rants and you've just cut the whole channel away

[@iJustine]

Taran redeemed himself by editing this incredible challenge video 😂 so much footage was shot this day... it turned out awesome 👏🏻

[@kr19569]

"I've edited more than a billion views on my channel" Yeah, not the right answer. LOL

[@jdmnissan]

Well u know what they say. Mac is much easier to use for not very professional users. But you showed it's not

[@MinistryOfMagic_DoM]

Well he also won the original competition by existing. Rematch where he uses his full power of macros. Would love to see full power Taran against this representation of iJustine full power.

[@tobor.]

Hello

[@chrishaselden]

Great job, this looked like a lot of fun.

[@ashikchowdhury1001]

This was actually a fun and interesting video to watch that was edited by TARAN.

[@maheshkankanige]

hell yes

[@oghenekaro]

Ashik Chowdhury no time limit this time

[@WinterElectro]

hell yes my dude, edited by our GOD TARAN

[@imnotwhitebutimwhite]

GOD TARAN

[@ThunderBlastvideo]

lol i knew that he edited it, he threw in justines own transitions when cutting on the judges

[@BarakaGitari]

Judge: Overall good video Taran: Thanks Judge: *gives Taran a 5/10*

[@BigCat315]

You mean the guy whose channel is basically a big IPhone advertisement liked the Final Cut video more? Shocking.

[@Mightbemil]

@@BigCat315 not even close. Have you seen his edits? I highly recommend you to check out his channel.

[@alperen1168]

@@BigCat315 His channel is not like that, it's just the name of the channel.

[@Denis-hk8he]

I didn't like the judge too

[@RowenStipe]

It's a German judge, they're notoriously hard to please.

[@sejongtakenaka]

Taran is a giant amongst dwarves

[@jedigrandmaster1773]

Damn, he's tall AF

[@officialspaceefrain]

It's all in the genes baby.

[@AsphaltAntelope]

@@jedigrandmaster1773 He's normal sized. Linus Sebastian is only as tall as a washing machine.

[@xali2008]

he is 6'3" which is tall.

[@AsphaltAntelope]

@@xali2008 >>LAUGHS IN DUTCH

[@curcapsicum]

The excessive transition effects when Justine was talking about getting her new transitions had me dying.

[@thepgo666]

They had me dying when watching the final video too. Really bright and eye piercing.

[@alwayscreatingio]

How does she edit on a trackpad lol

[@NischalD17]

It’s actually not hard

[@PursuitOfShutter]

Just shortcut cheatcodes! I often do the same!

[@Shinobimc]

How do u not edit with a trackpad using a mouse is horrible

[@nikewray]

it's actually good when you're doing that on a Mac, i edit with trackpad when i'm on my bed or something because the huge trackpad tho

[@bryankahfi6886]

i'm editing with trackpad, it's not that hard.

[@zdawgdawgdawg9204]

Taran's back is straighter because of the massive back muscles he got from building his treehouse.

[@pxelguyplays]

Zdawg Dawgdawg Taran, not Tarzan! 😂JK.

[@geraldhng8774]

Conclusion: It depends on the editor and not the software?

[@vigneshanand7696]

You have achieved nirvana

[@entitledOne]

Yes, also depends on the goal. One style is for educational videos and fits more for tech videos the other is for pure entertainment and fits for more general purpose videos.

[@BigClaudia]

and from PC power because some programs causes little troubles with lags

[@MirekFe]

Or... Just use Blender on Linux. _Linux Master Race._ Lol.

[@simmerke1111]

Conclusion: this had nothing to do with the title. It was just a goofy collaboration and nothing more. As if Mac vs PC would be a realistic question in any case. Got money to burn? Buy a mac.

[@jimmywen2258]

At 17:45 Taran cuts out Justine's pauses as she talks about cutting out other people's pauses lol

[@lucasleite694]

Jimmy Wen he also zoomed in on the 4th judge when he complained about the comedic zooming

[@karmanyaahm]

@@lucasleite694 21:36

[@venkate5hgunda]

Subtle. Niceee

[@thanosmitsis8322]

well played

[@Alex-us2vw]

Lucas Leite they shoot in like 8k raw at LTT on those red cams so they have the pixels to do the comedic zooming. He’s not going to stop just like that after one hater, how else can they justify those 30k cameras and 1000000TB media servers to Linus

[@private-lurkingcluelessnes1740]

Justine: brings a bunch of comfort items(I think that’s what they would classify as) Taran: brings computer stuff

[@verficationaccount]

And a cardboard box. For comfort!

[@private-lurkingcluelessnes1740]

@@verficationaccount why didn’t he just bring a computer stand though?

[@syaliishi914]

@@private-lurkingcluelessnes1740 He loves boxes

[@RKBock]

@@private-lurkingcluelessnes1740 maybe he brought all the stuff in the box and then used the box as well?

[@nobody7817]

So...basically they both brought a bunch of comfort items!

[@jthoward]

I love that they edited down taran’s height. EDIT: I did notice that Taran was the one who edited the video.

[@jdmnissan]

Me 2

[@guichardalex]

also me

[@bas_de_beer]

I love how taran edited down taran's height.

[@ReyaadGafur]

@@bas_de_beer yea it's very funny.

[@theroyalcam]

he literally just bent his knees lmao

[@sysonic917]

Judge: Your video has too many zooms and therefore people would click away. Him not knowing Taran also edited this video and so far no-one has clicked away.

[@stevejobs7989]

Bro, they edited that in 4hrs, didn't have the time to watch it.....

[@aadisahni]

@@stevejobs7989 what. Is this actually Steve Jobs. Omg I'm a fan*ahhhh*

[@peteblue8828]

@@aadisahni um what

[@aadisahni]

@@peteblue8828 he is steve jobs. Hes back

[@privatepoe2603]

@@aadisahni I don't think it's him.

[@sridhars1576]

I loved the way Taran expressed his thought on Justine's work. Great thing to acknowledge opponents talents, he has exhibited a great sportmanship......👍❤️

[@iMrParker]

The real punishment is having to edit an Austin Evan's video

[@austinevans]

I agree

[@el1f0]

@@austinevans lol

[@spla5h627]

@@austinevans the highest level of humor, when you can laugh over yourself. Good job

[@snowzZzZz]

Evans Austin Agree I

[@loreaver3882]

I used the Austin Evans to destroy Austin Evans

[@theindoorcat2634]

Normal People: Hells Kitchen Nerds: LTT Editing Showdown.

[@itsraf.3860]

Im both lmao

[@lorenzowyman4052]

Lmao I literally thought of this

[@wopwopkross]

Enjoyed this way more

[@BOLOYOO]

"Normal" is wrong word.

[@dextersilva4411]

Oh shit I just watched hells kitchen before this video

[@UKYusei]

Justine: who uses scripts ewww Linus: *sweats nervously*

[@marktaormina779]

UKYusei This is on LTT so Justine was probably reading that line off the script

[@Locutus]

I think Justine was exaggerating. While she might not have a script, she probably makes notes on what to talk about. Since she's a one woman band, that's ok! Whereas at LMG, it's really important to have a script, if there is no script, there is no video. 🙂

[@blackfistdeath1]

Locutus I think many people forget that LTT is practically its own media company at this point, with each employee having his own role. The person writing the script isn’t the same person reading off it in front of the camera, which in turn makes a detailed script all the more crucial. Being a one-woman army, iJustine likely has her own notes on what to say in her videos, but she can afford to wing it more compared to LTT.

[@curt8806]

so they gave her a lollipop so she can lick it on screen? Was that their plan? Ugh. Men. Am i right?

[@oali2478]

@@curt8806 lol that's sarcasm right?

[@maxh7085]

I love how in the beginning, Taran is so much taller than both Linus and Ijustine that his hair is out of the frame.

[@rayvinkrossing]

"Your video was better on a technical level." "Your video didn't have the production quality of Justine's." Me: Huh?

[@Pastas666]

I mean its 2 different things

[@KaelDenna]

as a video editor i totally understood that. let me explain: i can watch one of my edits 10 times over and make it more seamless, getting "technically" better each time but if i'm not inspirred and in the mood, i can make a technically perfect video that seems soulless and boring. on the other hand some days i get footage that i love editing and have that spark of creativity which results in an engaging high quality final video, but i'm so over excited i miss technical problems like uneven horizon or inconsistent audio levels or jerky camera motion etc.

[@rayvinkrossing]

@@KaelDenna eh, i don't really get it. As somone who's been editing videos and studying the art of production for years at this point, i genuinely do not understand how they came to that conclusion.

[@arjunarun3033]

@@KaelDenna well then her loving the video shes editing has nothing to do with having production quality does it

[@adrian_hook]

I think they may have been referring to the aesthetic value

[@regal_7877]

Taran's edit was probably more "the engineer" and Justine's edit was probably more "the entertainer". Depends on the crowd, LTT viewers come for the details and specificity, Taran is here to deliver. Can't really comment on Justine's viewers though, I'm not one of them.

[@Quarknjaguar]

that's cute if you really think that LLT is not the other side of the road, it's just one foot off justines curbside

[@dragone521]

Personally. I liked tarans the best because his video wasn't corny.

[@SealedKiller]

I'm pretty sure Austin's crowd watches for detail and specificity, so I think Taran nailed it. Its an informative video, It should let the viewer know of all the features of the device.

[@dovecat]

@@dragone521 Accurate, I loathe the effects that justine used in her video.

[@SealedKiller]

@Simple Tech At least they don't put flashling lights as their transations lol

[@RadicalZack]

This is just a contest between two editing styles more than the platform

[@teh_m8]

Thats one point of this video i think. Linus says some words at the end to this topic.

[@nntflow7058]

Raw footage from people like Justine who are comfortable in front of the cameras would be more polished even before editing. Hence why the she got a challenge editing this particular raw footage she was given.

[@freakofnature9580]

Coming back after he announced he’s quitting… 💚 Taran will always be iconic and I hope we can see what he does in the future!

[@aatiq7]

[@kena4977]

The truth has been revealed where Teran is going.

[@cst256]

Why does Taran look like he has an inside joke with himself and is gonna burst out laughing at any second but he tries really hard to contain it?

[@martinlutherkingjr.5582]

Because if anyone saw both of the videos uninterrupted side by side again and again they would be thinking the same thing. The point of an editor 99% of the time is to make unobtrusive editing decisions.

[@rep-vile]

Justine edits as if it's her own video where it fits more to show her "personality in the edit", but Austin Evans is completely different. I actually would enjoy watching iJustine but her editing is just unbearable to me, especially the music.

[@bebehasbebehas2287]

you should try it yourself - take a puff before meeting with clients. You will know that you could not laugh, but some barriers would have gone.

[@jaypandya913]

That’s true

[@Bbeavis]

This video immediately went up a notch when I noticed Niko from Corridor Digital.

[@4951-----]

I know perfect judge !!

[@sonbrother6167]

big ups for corridor

[@JeffreyBoles]

Ikr? The video kept my attention partially because I just wanted to hear what Niko had to say.

[@Greendogblue]

I just finished watching a Corridor video before this so it took me a bit to realize that he was out of place lol. I was just like, "Yeah, Niko, of course."

[@excep.5800]

Nice miata

[@UncleCatfish]

as a music producer and DJ I would LOVE to see a similar video with music production and/or DJ software. everyone gets so defensive about what they use but like it was said in the video, "a bad carpinter blames his tools"

[@joshjenks3715]

honestly tho, it's all about opinion, one community could like one video more than the other just because they like that type of video, so I don't think this was a video about final cut vs premier or mac vs pc, it was more like whos editing style does this group of people like.

[@Moejoe647]

Which is exactly the conclusion of the video imho. That in the end its not about the tool.

[@kiwicami287]

That's true, i think i would've liked Taran's video better from the few clips i saw

[@sasakanjuh7660]

Taran, is that you?

[@finnmk9937]

Yup Teran's vid was very LTT

[@SappeREffecT]

I booted this up, saw the brief on the face-off and was like 'yep this is just going to conclude about editing styles for the audience...'

[@couldntunlock]

This is like a cooking show but for editing

[@stardust8173]

lol ikr

[@mauriciom2121]

Was thinking that

[@JacyNinja147]

I wanna like this comment but it's on 666 and I don't wanna mess that up

[@ReadySelectStart]

I agree. I wish there was more videos like this. They should do this again but DaVinci Resolve and Premiere Pro

[@krisskuli]

Haha so true 😄

[@steezedwolf]

The fact justine got up to change the temperature herself, stopped to look at snacks, let her dog out, all while poking at taran, while Still editing, just goes to show how confident she feels w her edits after editing thousands of her videos for years, even though theres a time limit.

[@apodexse]

So true

[@destituteanddecadent9106]

Yeah I’m a PC user but she’s cool.

[@christinam2805]

She was NOT sweating those 4 hours lmao

[@manwithstds7503]

He was not taking it very seriously tbh, he did say that he was not using PR pro as a pro tool but master the basics, of course it would be amazing in a normal youtube video, but judges are usually very picky.

[@steezedwolf]

@@manwithstds7503 oh forsure, i wasnt trying to talkbad about him, i just was pointing out her confidence in her skills. She could have stayed in her chair but she felt good about it & had fun all around. Both outcomes were great.

[@DanFrederiksen]

Well, sounds like it ended up being a directorial competition rather than which setup is best for editing. They were judged on creative skills, not the effectiveness of the tool. So I'll give the judges a 2 out of 10 :)

[@TimothyFish]

I noticed that as well. But ultimately, it really comes down to communicating the message making the talent look good. I use Sony Vegas for editing. Just comparing what it does with what I see them doing with the software they are using, the basics of what the tools do are pretty much the same. The additional features are different and there may be some shortcuts that make one better than the others, but I think I could use any of the three and come out with pretty much the same video without pulling my hair out.

[@sp3llc4ster3]

I give the judges a 0.3457 becuase i think that doing it right is more important than doing it wrong in a better way. Right?

[@JethroRose]

justine did seem to finish a lot earlier... despite snacking, letting the dog out, etc...

[@SloOMv2]

the sec they said it's KZbin video so it must be entertainer I knew they were bad

[@HippieP629]

That's funny. Didn't realize that. So true.

[@mbvglider]

20:03 "The zooming was a little bit too much for me." I see what Taran did there.

[@MyTraveliciousStories]

Austin should've got a chance to judge as well. I feel like Taran's video was more similar to the type of content Austin uploads

[@TaimatCR]

Agreed

[@Achllyss]

for me I like Taran's vid than iJustine, its just my taste of vid btw, is taran edited this video?

[@ha_ks799]

agreed

[@MyTraveliciousStories]

@@Achllyss Yes. Taran did edit this video

[@your_average_cultured_dude]

@@iamaduckquack because Taran is the LTT editor.

[@kennethjagroop4590]

Taran's first browser tab: "Nyan Cat - 10 hours" Ah, a peak behind the LTT curtain reveals a man of culture.

[@belyrical4631]

😂

[@tylerdurden3722]

So he was listening to that for 4 hours to speed himself up?🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@anton5688]

4:04 - 4:10

[@razor_turbo_0072]

He Is a man Of Culture i see... I always feel so happy whenever i spot these type of people (no sarcasm)

[@jpxyUA]

it's like white noise, but 100% more annoying

[@anrew1000]

I have a huge amount of respect for Taran being as humble as he was. It takes a very strong person to be able to critically self evaluate like he did- especially in-front of the judges and everyone.

[@NeedingSleep]

Twist ending: This video was edited on a PC

[@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος]

By Taran

[@NeedingSleep]

@@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος lol

[@NeedingSleep]

@@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος so I guess which one do you like better between the vid that you are seeing and ijustine's Austin Even's vid.

[@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος]

​@@NeedingSleep Both were great, but I believe Taran's was more professional.

[@NeedingSleep]

@@ΦιλιπποςΚουμπάρος yea ijustine is more on the funny and entertaining side of editing while Taran is a very professional editor.

[@deckarddwizardd1909]

IJustine: Quirky youtube edit Taran: Information youtube edit

[@Nyarlathotep_Flagg]

@@quicktoreason2722 How very true. The focus was wrong, and the things it was judged one was wrong. It's not who made the most attractive youtube video, but which was the most effective at dealing with technical solutions.

[@mannycalavera121]

basically

[@BulletMagnetMan]

Gamers Nexus: Boooooring KZbin edit.

[@cocoshort6528]

@@BulletMagnetMan but informative, would you rather learn first aid from a guy who knows what he's doing, or a guy who only sorta does and is slightly funny

[@marks4553]

@@cocoshort6528 ​ @Coco You smell like someone with a sub par PC hating on MAC users... get over it, stop with teh MAC vs PC wars, i have both, they have their own pros and cons that PC users will never get... There are always creative people doing creative weird ways, and boring teachers...

[@gamingbros2533]

i edit for electro gamer in final cut pro and i love it but i whould love to see a video enhancing tool in final cut pro

[@jake_lacroix5417]

Justine: Final Cut Taran: Premiere Me: I use iMovie on my iPhone 7

[@kleins0]

next : imovie vs windows movie maker

[@RayyanAshraf]

Me: uses Kinemaster

[@puravidapurelife2905]

Me last month: What’s iMovie? Must be an Apple product! LOL

[@nick-vo9tx]

you will never get a job in hollywood if use Imovie lol

[@jimjamjon2285]

@@nick-vo9tx it’s a phone app. No shit

[@visualaudio22]

They need to give us raw footage and let the subscribers edit it and see everyone’s edit styles

[@MrJleonp]

A nice 2 year long video.

[@arthurg5966]

Should have added a final shot of Taran looking at the sky and walking away like he's leaving Linus Media group

[@harshivpatel6238]

He's not really leaving LMG is he ?

[@xRamm]

This was really well done. I love the contrasts in styles where he is so hyper focused and serious because thats his job. Justine on the other hand before the last bit was using editing to relax, and just chill. He had like 5 things and help directly from Austin while she just ate snacks and just used what was on her system. The styles of editing shows well and really visualize each person perfectly. Justine also proved why she does do her own editing while being an OG on this platform. To me this was less about the operating system or suites used and more about that. I do wish they showed more about both programs cuz some ppl never used a mac or a pc. Fun video as always from LTT, almost as fun as this segway, to the other comments. Lol

[@katnerd6712]

What is better for video editing, Mac or Windows? Answer: Taran.

[@supercoolmunkee]

I would like a Taran OS!

[@zarmaanful]

@@supercoolmunkee With builtin multi keyboard macro support?!

[@astupidlylongnamethatstoolong]

@@zarmaanful That would be heaven

[@ponnannakb]

🤣

[@walidbenkaida1917]

@@supercoolmunkee you nailed it hhhhhhh

[@LinuxZombie]

Tarans editing style is a lot better because for me it's just not as distracting as Justines with all the effects.

[@HyenaFox]

Yeah I mean I think this video showcased their styles and workflows pretty well. Taran comes at it from a content-creation and artistic angle, and he's very aware of the technicalities of the video, so he tends to put a ton of polish on things and make sure the bare minimum looks as nice as possible, even if he doesn't put as much on top of it. Justine tends to come at it from a content-consumption angle, making sure the video is as engaging as possible first and polishing the flow last.

[@catutz1317]

Justines edit looks like something made for kids, the effects, the transitions

[@MinistryOfMagic_DoM]

@@catutz1317 well it was made for Mac people.

[@catutz1317]

Payperheirplain yep

[@catutz1317]

Payperheirplain good point

[@HuzaifaKhan04]

"I used to be a Mac guy, but I got tired of paying double for... hardware!" F A C T S .

[@snofixart]

You know it's true when Nicko himself says it.

[@Olie956]

Fact - Macs are 2x more likely to be infected by Malware than Windows machines.

[@betogzzo3799]

@@Olie956 source: drug abuse.

[@Jasonzvo]

Aaron Garza totally

[@irwanclark3387]

@@Olie956 sources?

[@OLBastholm]

"I require a wrist rest now"

[@abbas23hussain]

Are we gonna ignore the fact that Justine used a freakin' Touchpad to edit the video.

[@brokenlegend23]

Apple touchpads are amazing hahah

[@abbas23hussain]

@@brokenlegend23 they are but they can't beat the gaming mice, especially the high end ones.

[@cantorgauss]

@@abbas23hussain why the hell would you need a gaming mice to edit a video ?!?

[@abbas23hussain]

@@cantorgauss gaming mice aren't just for gaming, they can be used for a variety of purposes. Compared to normal mice they are much better as they have programmable buttons, superior sensors, better DPI and much more. Not to mention the RGB lighting.

[@Trigg3rHippie]

@@abbas23hussain Especially the RGB lighting is ESSENTIAL for video editing. Somebody referred RGB to as cancer (was it Linus?) and I agree.

[@DeinonychusCowboy]

Man this is such a great challenge, especially post covid I'm so glad this happened, great character dynamics in this one

[@baloney_sandwich]

This should be turned into a weekly series like hell kitchen

[@shannendunham8850]

yessssssss we need that!

[@АлексейГриднев-и7р]

That's RAW!!!!

[@timq16]

сэммич

[@chickenlurkinyungchihuahua]

OMG YES!!!

[@sarveshphansalkar_]

Someone once said: "The Best part of winning.........is winning"

[@ayuchanayuko]

Taran was handicapped by being macro-less lol

[@Ufernano]

I'm still relatively new to these type of terms. What does being macro mean?

[@antony1458]

@@Ufernano macro is a sequence of inputs you edit or program to make something you want to. Example you program one key to do (alt + F4) or any sequence you want.

[@relinskii4753]

@@Ufernano a macro is mapping a set of actions to a single key. When you press that key, that set of actions is being made without additional input thus making it faster for the editor.

[@ts_diamond8569]

if he had his macros it would have been obvious.

[@Blargah]

@@Ufernano definitely gotta be one of the things that would have saved him a huge amount of time

[@jeremiefaucher-goulet3365]

Now reverse the roles... Justine on Premiere, Taran on Final Cut Pro

[@CED99]

That's the follow up video!

[@alleriodrone]

I really look forward to seeing this one of it comes out, maybe on ijustines channel?

[@Vype_playzz]

The way she took the cookie with her mouth 😂 😂

[@Sibogy]

This actually has nothing to do with Mac vs PC or an editing program... It's creative differences and editing skills.

[@mayuradio]

eh, they needed a hook for people who dont know any of these people to watch the vid

[@aurvaroy6670]

That's right. This video is about who's better at editing, Justine or Taran. Not about which program is better.Justine would've easily won if she used Premiere and if Taran used Final Cut.

[@seank3300]

Sibogy3 yeah, you're right

[@kensg]

So True... #facts

[@shadowswithin702]

Yes that's very true.

[@thechartech]

I am so happy to see Taran in a video again. Please give us more Taran, he has the best personality.

[@The13579097531]

Agreed, I miss his e-bike and robotics videos.

[@coryandrum]

I was digging the tree house video on his own channel

[@7zipx73]

Well if he on the video then who is gonna edit the video :v

[@leogoldberg6014]

@Vizman216 why r u so negative if these people like certain LTT employees the only way for linus to know is is people ask for them, and whats wrong with them supporting people

[@BrilliantDesignOnline]

Hands down, one of your absolutely best videos. Watching two 'unseen' people do what they do best under pressure (and knowing a bit about editing) was incredible: DEFINITELY more content like this. Thank you Justine and Taran, and judges. I felt the pressure.

[@MrOwenTheGreatGaming]

Any Editing Software < Windows Movie Maker

[@mmohsinsiddiquii]

We've all been there! Lmao

[@dejavulinx3295]

@@mmohsinsiddiquii exactly

[@asingha94]

Just no

[@_jn0298]

Those white texts with blue background and rotating transitions

[@ThePashaplaybug]

Everything

[@NuclearCashew]

So Taran lost and then had to edit this video, of him losing, to post it on this channel? Linus is an actual monster. edit: If you liked this comment you have a teeny weeny peeny.

[@rep-vile]

Lost by who's standards? This is LTT so I'd guess by average most of us prefer Taran's editing. I sometimes watch iJustine and I actually really hate her music choice.

[@AwesomeBlackDude]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/d3rRY6Sjiq6LZs0 It's kind of messed up when your outtakes looks better than your final production. 🤬😜

[@maximchintalov8387]

He didn't seem to care.

[@baialein4929]

@@rep-vile Well apparently everyone hates her music choices....

[@markkern8073]

SPOILER SPOILER SPOILER

[@9iMac]

This is the type of review we all need when deciding which application is better. Let the professionals battle it out.

[@hermanstokbrood]

To be clear: this was not a Mac vs PC contest. I really don't know why the title says so.

[@hermanstokbrood]

@Galaxy TS2 I didn't ask.

[@hermanstokbrood]

@Galaxy TS2 hehehe, you are funny. Talking for other people. Grow up man. 🤣

[@cokaoffcoke3667]

guatafak u smart little smurf

[@michaels8597]

to waste people's time/////////////////////

[@paulmichaelfreedman8334]

Yeah thought so, thumb down for clickbait and Im outta here.

[@MaximNightFury]

"my heartrate is 82, it's normally 50!" me: my heartrate is 50, it's normally 82!

[@H1DDENxO]

3:52 "The best part of winning is winning" *Ah yes the floor here is made out of floor*

[@Dont-Watch-My-Vids-U-Regret-it]

Every 60 seconds a minute passes in Africa

[@apathyzen9730]

Here's another one for Russian viewers: "В теннисе мне нравится... теннис." kzbin.info/www/bejne/b5nCqImJbZ6fmKs It's like The best part about tennis is... tennis ...And skirts

[@DE3P_Beats]

Lol The best part of an egg is an egg.

[@DE3P_Beats]

@@fbkensarhd5279 dickheads be you

[@mamaimacriminal2653]

@@Dont-Watch-My-Vids-U-Regret-it was going to say the same thing

[@elijahometz5671]

I still prefer Taran's editing style. I can always tell when an Ltt video is edited by Taran because i'm actually engaged by the content and not the extra fluff in the ijustine video.

[@tihammd]

True

[@NeilRoy]

One of my thoughts is that the content should dictate the style. In the types of videos on this channel, content trumps fluff.

[@akiya9216]

I think Taran is funny and edits better, he is a proper editor so with more time he can properly polish it morr

[@adityabhardwaj1808]

The thing is that it depends on your viewers. A lot of people are saying that they liked Taran’s video better because they are used to these types of videos on this channel.

[@Tuckerslam]

@@akiya9216 Of coursh he`s better, he`s male!

[@rorisxng]

11:46 Justine: “Do you want to come work for me? It’s great, we can all work together. It’d be really lovely.” 😂😂

[@insertnamehere8103]

Judges: I like your music choice Him: thank you Her: (VISABLE ANGER)

[@MaxRovensky]

Final Cut's background pre-rendering is a godsend if you have infinite disk space

[@tophan5146]

how does it work exactly?

[@sjwright2]

@@tophan5146 FCPX is constantly rendering every frame of your video in the background, using CPU cycles that would have otherwise gone unused. As you change the video, all pre-rendered frames affected by that change are discarded. So when you hit export, all it has to do is finish rendering anything that's not already pre-rendered, then save it to a file.

[@aronseptianto8142]

@@tophan5146 it render parts of your videos that you haven't really touched for a while, even when you are editing other parts of the video You see Taran biting his nails for that render to finish? Yeah, won't happen with final cut As a purely technical stand point premiere sucks, it crashes often also, but again, it's more the Craftsman than the tool

[@tophan5146]

thanks ;)

[@yellowflash7696]

Godsend?? It’s a bit overreach

[@nicryan7621]

OK let's be real, Niko from Corridor would thrash anyone else in this video.

[@lilmario0]

Any other obvious takes?

[@SemiOmni314]

@@lilmario0 People die when they are killed

[@joshuaanderson6609]

@@lilmario0 You have internet access

[@MrClauried]

@@nightowler672 whats a lazer?

[@itchypit6413]

@@MrClauried a long light

[@mejiamedia7693]

Ijustine: Final Cut Pro Taran: Adobe premiere pro Me: iMovie on Mac 💻

[@mejiamedia7693]

@@TheTechTopTips 😄

[@oakleyhasafoot7878]

Everyone: I make edits and run a KZbin channel Kyle: hi I’m Kyle

[@5staruzzy]

Why is Linus talking so calm and slowly like he's David Attenborough😂😂😂😂

[@harbl99]

So he doesn't spook the editors. They are very highly-strung creatures.

[@PotatoNinja101]

He was observing editors in their wild habitat

[@-SundayWolf]

Wow! You remember David Attenborough? I have not seen him since late 1980-thies

[@Smedleydog1]

This is about editing styles, not the Mac vs Pc business.

[@joelsletten3386]

Smedleydog1 final cut and premiere is both great. So yeah its more about editor vs editor

[@oswaldogarcia5358]

Lol I use adobe premiere pro on my Mac for my school projects

[@jonasgrill1155]

I personally use DaVinci Resolve on an upgraded Dell G3.

[@dat1boi800]

Smedleydog1 yeah I just writ that in my comment

[@matusgerbiark3622]

So is mac better for editing? i wanna try edit videos but got just zenbook 14 with i7 16gb ram and MX geforce nvdia

[@julianhinrichs171]

I like the sentence: "A poor carpenter blames his tools" It summarize how more should work

[@TitusM7]

that's ancient bullshit. good tools are essential.

[@michaelfrisch118]

I agree; this was a great comment, but I do not think this is necessarily 100% true. Yes, as a "Carpenter, "you have tools, and it is your job to use the tools. When given the choice of tools, a resourceful person will choose the best tools for the job. It doesn't matter what your profession is; if your a surgeon, software developer, editor, photographer, or pilot, you want the best tools. Sometimes you are limited by resources such as money, so you have to be innovative For example, I have seen surgeons that have operated on patients in third world countries with less than ideal conditions and less than perfect tools and have had equal outcomes as those whose surgeries were performed in the United States. Personally, I feel that tools do you play a role, but a good Carpenter can still produce with less than ideal means.

[@romanbaranovichi5375]

Meanwhile Alex: I don't have the tools for that

[@Silent_Shadow]

As a carpenter I disagree. If you have shit tools or the wrong tools it can make simple tasks that much more difficult. Or can even make some things impossible. So its not an accurate statement.

[@faiz_tidak_bisa_terbang1470]

@@Silent_Shadow found the poor carpenter

[@will16320]

iJustine better be one of Tarans private clients after all the banter in this edit

[@justjack8909]

19:10 you can’t hide that Kitchen Nightmares sound effect from me Taran

[@MrSmitheroons]

Holy cow, this got serious at the end. "One of you will be leaving the island today."

[@stephen.app.youtube]

no it really did get serious ahaha, i was getting a little stressed wondering who was gonna win lol

[@constantine4357]

Macro King got nerfed so bad without his macros... jokes aside tho, while he did say even with his macros he would've lost, I'd beg the differ, if he had his macros, he could've save quite some time in the editing and then spent those extra time on adding *flavors* unto his vid... at the very least, his vids would've been more competitive, or perhaps even edge out Justine's THIS IS MY OPINION Taran is more of a business-oriented editor IMHO, like what an editor would do when a client asked for something while Justine seems more creative, which considering that she's usually edited videos for herself, that's why it seems much more _personal_ ... Props for both of em tho, GGWP

[@checkit352]

Well said, totaly agree, also as Dark Legionnaire said ''it was a test of sofware. so the fact she used her own prerendered stock footage and graphics and taran edited the stock footage with nothing but what he was handed'' might have been partially responsible for the end reslult, but hey they're both great at editing. also love the profile pic.

[@amiryousefi5374]

Pro comment

[@lol-pt2hi]

dude can you imagine justine with macros ?

[@TheHammerGuy94]

To be fair, yes, Taran is editor only in terms of role in the production team. Try comparing this to when he writes the scripts of his own videos. Notable examples: LTT’s hassu USB converter video Taran’s open letter to corsair video (on his channel) In these videos, he knows what to put in there instead of the ideas getting outsourced.

[@jonascobra9883]

24:09

[@DhananjaySharmaofficial]

Niko's opinion is the only thing that matters here....

[@XeonW]

True

[@arluuwie]

Dhananjay Sharma exactly

[@daritter]

I don't like his work, and he seems pretentious as a person.

[@DhananjaySharmaofficial]

@@daritter Yeah but you can't ignore the fact that he is creative and talented 😁

[@illzzu]

@@DhananjaySharmaofficial Everyone is in their own way 😁

[@MetalMan1245]

This was definitely more of a Taran vs. Justine video instead of Mac vs. PC video, but still entertaining.

[@CrispymexicanDUCK]

"Mac vs PC video editing showdown!" Nothing about this video compared the two software or hardware configurations, it ended up being a "who can appeal to the subjective taste of the judges better" video. A longer time limit would have produced better results to boot. Hopefully they revisit this topic and ACTUALLY see what advantages and disadvantages of going with either software holds.

[@anandrakesh]

Exactly.. thats what he meant.... everything comes down to who is doing the work

[@sergis6924]

Uh.. duh? Are you gonna make a boring 1 hour video, or a entertaining yet short 10 minutes explaining the crucial stuff?

[@frydac]

Also, a 'mac' has been a PC for many years now, and how do you call a PC with linux installed? I understand where it comes from and clicks and stuff, but you're a technical yt channel, also appealing to more technical ppl who appreciate a bit more correct terminology/acknowledgment/education. It was a fun video, and the conclusion was fine, but was indeed hoping for more depth

[@iwolfman37]

They have done that before. Actually, Justine was in that video too

[@brandonnesfan]

"Also, a 'mac' has been a PC for many years now, " So what? You do realize that PC's are called "PC'S" because their technological roots are to the IBM PC. And guess what the IBM PC was running? MS-DOS. That's why all windows pc's are called "pc" The "Macs are PC's because they're personal computers" excuse just makes you look like smartass contrarian that doesn't know shit about pcs. " and how do you call a PC with linux installed?" If it's a desktop you would call it a "linux desktop" but, if it's a laptop, it'd be called "linux laptop"

[@PuneetkBajaj]

3:51 Taran hiding his water bottle with LTT water bottle overlay 😂😂😂

[@niccologravili2840]

I Justine: final cut Taran: premiere Me who edits in Vegas: *sad Vegas stopped working noises*

[@simkortele1072]

Same :D

[@fedor3000]

Taran - We love you.

[@arsolrhmn]

one of the greatest memories with Taran

[@ericarnold1739]

What I took away from this is the iJustine has an impressively low resting heart rate.

[@dancecentralYESXD]

I actually felt related. Mine is 50 during rest as well and it gets 42 when I’m asleep. XD

[@stepito]

@@dancecentralYESXD Well.... Yeah .... I think, we can have a club... mine´s 42 resting, 34 when I´m asleep... lol

[@dancecentralYESXD]

@@stepito I’ve been having my low heart alert notifications triggered. It goes from 36-40. When in deep sleep. Our club may need a cardiologist 🤣 just in case.

[@stepito]

@@dancecentralYESXD I can share my own one! 🤣 But seriously, I have to take my watch off for my sleep. Otherwise it wakes me up with a notification because my heartbeat is too low 🤣

[@dancecentralYESXD]

​@@stepito I’ll be taking their number! JK. But really, my heart rate drops the lowest when I’m in deepest sleep, so my watch could only dream of waking me up at that time. XD I only notice the notifications when I’m up and going about the day. Hopefully all will be well friend!

[@venkat2277]

"The best part about winning is winning" -iJusting 2020

[@burgunbeerd]

Moving Taran down in the intro is an instant like

[@andrewkelly1093]

Ijustine: “the best part of winning is probably winning, but I’m not competitive”

[@sodiboo]

when

[@EikottXD]

Rofl 🏆

[@griffin8062]

Why does iJustine always look like she crushed up a bunch of apple products and snorted it

[@seanpalfy6355]

Found this video 2 years after the fact and it was absolutely amazing. Loved the two editors and judge style scoring. Extra kudos to Teran for the amazing genuine humbleness at the end. Would love to see more content like this!

[@evancrazyerror]

Linus: Today you will fight to the DEATH two go in and one leaves WHO WILL TAKE THE CROWN? iJustine: 8:03 “Ooh what kinda snacks are over here”

[@Filip-_-._.]

0:28 when he positioned himself on the same level as the other two LMFAO x'D

[@deViant14]

Then dragged himself into frame. Meaning the frame was actually taller than he was using.

[@Trazgazm]

@@deViant14 I always record in a higher resolution than the intended outcome when I can, it makes fixing things way easier.

[@hhectorlector]

I've seen Taran in like 10 videos and never had I seen him stand next to someone like at 0:25. HOLY SHIT HE'S TALL!!!

[@MichaelAndersson-aaaaa]

Nice cut making him "lower", though!

[@d0uble_O]

I wang HIM!

[@yourcommenterliker8780]

lol you love him gayboy hahaha

[@castor9907]

@@yourcommenterliker8780 i can tell you're fun at parties

[@TheHammerGuy94]

considering the camera is pointed at linus like in 80% of the channel's videos pretty much a lot of people would be surprised at taran's height. and we know linus is short considering he's like only a few inches taller than justine

[@maxzlydar]

Great contest! Do more of it. But it wasn't PC vs Mac (except that thing with the LUT). It was Taran vs iJustin. And it was interesting to compare their approach to video editing. Thanks!

[@JoshChristiane]

Every editor ever: "How many times is he going to say the same thing over and over again". 🤣

[@sim789936]

Taran I know that this comment will probably never be read by you, but I want to say thank you for the years of hard work you put into LTT to make it a channel which I enjoy thoroughly. I feel that the editing is usually not really touched upon, but you are truly a king! Thanks for everything

[@TaranVH]

Nice try, but I did read it! I do read the comments for videos I script or host. Thank you for your kind words ^_^

[@StefanThePro]

Taran Van Hemert thank you so much for the effort you put into sharing your craft and making editing easier and more appreciable for outsiders and new editors. You need more recognition, more courses, more publicity! This was a great video!

[@sinenomine5921]

"The best part of winning is just winning"

[@takeru51]

iJustine: "Is there anything else we should know?" Linus: "No. Not really?" 😂😂😂

[@t-sch.3597]

たつかん tatu kun つてるくん tuteru kun つてる！ TUTERU! つてるーーー！

[@DungNguyen-ti9dk]

yim0Skyz ART Lại