Lisa Eldridge Rouge Experience Refillable Lipsticks | Lisa & Ashes Of Roses

[@limaso306]

I got Lisa, Medici and Romy and am IN LOVE with this formula. Quite possibly my favorite out of all of them.

[@mariam.a.]

Wow!! Happy to hear you love them so much. ♥️

[@DreamingCimderella]

haha, I have to say proudly that I watched the reveal video and didn't buy it!!!! I deserve applause, thank you :D, true was nanometers close to making a purchase but managed not to buy anything, mainly because none of the colours were calling to me. Let's see if this remains the case after watching your video though....

[@mariam.a.]

A round of applause, a walk down the red carpet!! We bow down at your feet our Say-no-to-Lisa guru!!! 🙌 😂😂😂

[@arwabagerlmhc2589]

Same ! Honestly, also not in love with the lipstick case- looks like a peanut to me (I do applaud her making the inner component recyclable!)

[@JustAnEmptyCageGirl]

Haha, congratulations.

[@mariam.a.]

@@arwabagerlmhc2589😂 peanut!

[@arwabagerlmhc2589]

@ haha thank you! I literally feel so accomplished!

[@romana.in.wonderland]

You are so right about her release videos! I could not hold back and ordered Romy and Ashes of Rose. I enjoy the formula and I think this is the most comfortable one Lisa has created yet. Not drying but quite lasting and the shades I ordered are very everyday. I am happy about the refill system in her range. I see me using up Romy quite quickly (really cool toned like the ones I used back in the 90ties) and I hit pan on one of her eyeshadows already.

[@mariam.a.]

Romy looks like the nude everyone with cooler tones has been asking for. It would look friggin dreadful on me but I am so happy for everyone who loves it.

[@kefinkamed]

I know exactly what you mean about the launch videos being an excellent hook 😂 At first, I was just mildly interested in the concept. Afterwards, I practically sprinted to Selfridges on the very first day of my trip to pick one up. And, of course, I ended up with three shades 🤷‍♀️🤦‍♀️😂 I've got Ashes of Roses, Romy and Simone, and they're all absolutely beautiful ❤️

[@mariam.a.]

How do you like Simone??

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Lisa is completely compelling. I finally bought from her! I love the concept and I’m excited to receive it. I love to see the fusion of past and future. The colours are quite beautiful and I am sure I’ll love the formula.

[@mariam.a.]

YAY! What did you buy? I can't wait to hear your thoughts after you try the items.

[@Eternelspotlessmind]

I must say your makeup looks stunning on you! 🎉🎉

[@mariam.a.]

Thank you! 💗

[@verenaweisz1713]

Great comparison, thank you! I really like both shades on you! For my own security I don't watch her reveal videos. This woman can literally sell me anything 😅 I will definitely get some, but I don't know when 😉

[@mariam.a.]

Wise attitude my friend! Keep that going. She said more colours would be coming in January so let’s see what those will look like.

[@verenaweisz1713]

@mariam.a. excellent! Waiting for more shades to come 🤩

[@vwiccy]

You described the formula perfectly! I didn’t even realize it until after you said it, but yes, the formula is like a more substantial version of the balms - her formulations are always so unique from anything else in the market - I’m not sure how she works her magic- and yes, her charisma is at 100% - I can never say no to at least try a new release once I’ve listened to her video - I’m always charmed by her 💖😍 - I got ashes of roses and Medici and the cooler tones are perfect for me as everyday nudes ❤

[@mariam.a.]

As soon as I put them on I thought, baumes💡 ! I have to say having tried many a cream/satin lipstick formulation, this one truly is different.

[@tamipie]

I got Audrey. I love a coral lip. Wonder Wheel is one of my absolute favorites. I am thinking of getting Ribbon and Simone and the cherry one when it comes out... and yes, if she did the velvets! 🤩🤩🤩

[@mariam.a.]

Ooohhh the cherry one has me thinking about it too….

[@chinchillin6280]

Thank you! From California I bought Medici and Ashes of Roses…..definitely preferred Medici over Ashes. Ashes was too warm toned on me.

[@Umm_yeah]

I tried both and bought ashes as my everyday, medici is an absolute mood though I look how they both pop but are good for everyday harmonious make up!

[@mariam.a.]

Haha yay California!! Oh how interesting!!! Ashes does not look at all warm on me…almost even has a coolness to it.

[@alisonfox6136]

Lovely helpful video.I havent purchased yet.I like Painterly,so might try something similar.Im glad the refillable xould be used alone,making it a more affordable option.Miriam you so deserve more subscribers.Come on You tube and viewers.You have put alot of thoght into your video,which I appreciate, x

[@mariam.a.]

Thank you for the your kind words! ♥️ I am glad you found the video helpful.

[@lydiakirkham3414]

I agree with everything you said about these :) the colours look amazing on you!! I did see Lisa say she would bring her other formulas to the refills, but she did say that the Velvets wouldn't be coming to it :( Lisa is my fave out of the shades I picked up (Lisa, Ashes of Roses, and Romy) - it's very close to Velvet Petal which she discontinued, and also Sunday Matinee, but I like the shade/formula of Lisa more!!

[@Eternelspotlessmind]

I am sad she discontinued Velvet Petal, I love that shade! Maybe i should also buy Lisa...

[@mariam.a.]

I think the formula of the velvets might be the reason they would not fit in this format. I look forward to the new shades reveal next year. Ohhh that makes me happy because I have neither of the ones you mentioned and now I know I don’t need Sunday Matinee (have considered it a few times). How do you like Romy?? I’m sure the shade would look dreadful on me 😅.

[@lydiakirkham3414]

@@mariam.a. I'm unsure about Romy on me, kinda looks a bit greyish 😅 Ashes of Roses I'm still deciding whether I like on me too..

[@mariam.a.]

@@lydiakirkham3414 Oh man if Romy looks greyish in you, I would be full on Corpse Bride in it haha. Why are you undecided about Ashes?

[@Umm_yeah]

I just bought the refill because I don't like the peanut. I had to put it into a holder (like the kind with a mirror) because the cap isn't the tightest , but the refill on its own is wonderful to use and still has that vintage feel!

[@mariam.a.]

I am quite pleased with the look of the refill. I was also not enamored with the outside component at first but it has grown on me. Not every lipstick needs to be a straight cylinder some variety is good. Hmm I have not noticed the cap being loose…🤔

[@Eternelspotlessmind]

I bought Audrey and i love it! I do think it's very similar to Dance Card and Go lightly but i am fine with that! I can absolutely relate to "Lisa made me buy it" phenomenon! But i must say i really love her lipsticks mostly the Velvet Matt and the Saturated formulas! I am on my second round of Rainbow Spill and Strawberry Shock! I do have a quick question regarding the new Rouge Experience packaging. My top lid is coming off extremely easily is this normal? Someone else has experienced that? 💄💄

[@vwiccy]

I don’t think the top should come off easily - are you talking about the main case or the temporary top of the refill - I heard some of the temporary refill tops are not always tight - but the pretty main case should click in tight and secure - make sure you push down to hear a click - a click putting the refill in the base and a click when putting the top on - otherwise I’d call customer service - mine is super tight and secure

[@josefajosefa00]

I had that. I made a video and sent it to Customer Service and they replaced it for me. It was really loose and if I shook it, it came off. So there's definitely a flaw in production somehow. I'm not sure if it's the refill that's the problem or the case itself (can't see it can be the case as it's just two pieces - thinking it must be something to do with the grooves on the refill.) I haven't got my replacement yet so I can't see the difference. Hoping the new one is tight - I haven't seen any reviews saying they've had loose lids.

[@Eternelspotlessmind]

Thank you! I will contact costumer service!!

[@mariam.a.]

Let me say I am SO impressed that you have finished Rainbow and Strawberry!!! Good for you they are gorgeous shades.

[@ceconoosh]

Mariam, i love your eyeshadow in this video. Could you please share which one it is? Looks beautiful on you 🌸

[@mariam.a.]

Mostly Rose Tulle from Dior with Anjelica by LE on top. I used a tiny bit of brown from the VBB Signature quad too but it is mostly the pinks that are doing it here. I love Anjelica!

[@ceconoosh]

@ absolutely gorgeous mix. One of my favorite eye looks from you. Suits your eyes so much. Thank you for sharing!!

[@mariam.a.]

@@ceconoosh I wear them together a lot and Anjelica is my favourite liquid lurex, possibly even liquid shadow.

[@ceconoosh]

@@mariam.a. Usually İ don’t like liquid eyeshadows but I recently found the new Sisley No 9 Plum. So gorgeous too. Thank you for mentioning Anjelica. Will check it out & love it already :) Thank you dear 🌸

[@ems_h.eartnotes]

Hmm I thought Lisa was a bit more neutral reddish in her video. Ashes of Roses looks like the one for me 😍 thank you for the video, Mariam

[@mariam.a.]

Oh no definitely a neutral deeper pink, super pretty but not reddish. I think Lisa's lighting is too harsh and tends to misrepresent colours sometimes. Ashes is awesome...like a rosewood brown but throw some cool tones in there for good measure.

[@cynthiafroning7678]

I’ve been waiting for this video.

[@mariam.a.]

❤❤❤

[@deisyfernandes1991]

Yayyy, I was going to ask in the last video if you're going to buy the Lisa lipstick 💄🎉

[@mariam.a.]

Well, I wasn't going to...but Lisa made me! HAHAHA

[@olzhena9681]

Thanks for reviewing LE’s lipsticks. Honestly I’ve got just one LE lipstick “Dance Card” and I didn’t like it at all. It turned out very orange on my skin tone and it is very runny on my lips and doesn’t have any longevity. Am I the only one who has this issue with it?? 😢

[@mariam.a.]

Hmmm hard to say. I don’t have Dance Card precisely because I suspected it would not be my favorite in terms of performance. It’s the kind of colour that has a lot of white pigment and those always perform worse. Maybe give another colour or formula from her range a try?

[@vjean04]

😂 yup don’t watch her release video haha. I actually got one of these with my initials then ordered more refills. I got Medici the texture is lovely.

[@mariam.a.]

😂😂 Agreed the texture is absolutely dreamy.

[@gw7067]

Do the refills fit into any other cases that you own? For example, I know my Hermes and Guerlain are compatible with each other but not the Dries Van Noten.

[@mariam.a.]

No they will not. The refill is really only suited to her own line. The big ring shape of the refill completes the entire component and would not match any other component.

[@peachstereo]

I kinda want Ashes of Roses…but I need Lisa to come out with some dang brown shades. Not red-brown. Not purple-brown. Brown. I need some - no brown lipliner to make it work - colors from her 😢😂😭 I’m hoping the shade extension will have those colors. Then I’ll pick up for sure. Thanks so much for the review!! The colors look beautiful on you~ The case still looks like a fancy golden peanut to me 😂😂😂😭 it’s cute haha

[@mariam.a.]

Oh my gosh you are the second person to mention the 🥜 shape 😂. I totally didn’t see it. But I do now. Hmm I can kind of see what you mean. Have you tried Meet me in Berlin? Ashes tends to pull differently. On Martina (Lily) it looked almost like a red brown and on me it’s definitely more of a balanced brown with a hint of coolness.

[@evakalan4504]

Haha, the life hack 🤣. I have to remember it for next time, since I have the same problem. That is great news that you can get a refund for the customs fee. Both shades look great on you. Now I want them 🤣

[@mariam.a.]

I too need to follow my own wise words LOL.

[@carmentxu4740]

Thanks for the swatches! I bought both Lisa and Ashes of Roses as well, but haven't arrived yet. How would you compare these two shades to Spirited Away?

[@josefajosefa00]

or to Kitten Mischief?

[@mariam.a.]

Ashes is much more neutral and brown, Spirited Away has very strong terracotta ruddy hues.

[@mariam.a.]

@@josefajosefa00Kitten is a light peach pink, Ashes is much more brown.

[@annelierunge1869]

Do the lipsticks smell funny like the balm embraces?

[@rydenbowen253]

No. There’s no scent 🎉

[@mariam.a.]

Not that I have noticed.

[@mariabroberg8887]

I wasn’t going to buy… the only one I felt like I wanted was the one that didn’t arrive. Then I saw the release video. 😂 I got one of the holiday kits and the Medici plus engraving and it is currently assessed in customs.

[@mariam.a.]

😂😂 join the club!! Hope you love everything you ordered!!

[@v.blanchard6487]

Lol, you are right. I saw it and had no interest. 😑 I watched her video, and I picked it up with my initials engraved on it plus a refill, a lip pencil and liquid silk liquid eyeshadows. 😆😃

[@mariam.a.]

Exactly the problem! 😅

[@ivaja2393]

Its hard to say no to LE....my credit card always know it will be used when Save the date mail comes in no matter what it is 😅...but, the products never dissapoints me, I ❤ all that I bought and is most used in my collection....so no regret ;) ...I actually can't wait for early next year already to new shades and CONCEALER

[@mariam.a.]

Her lipsticks are my most used in my collection so that says enough. 7 out of 10 times it’s a LE lipstick ❤.

[@minazohradalagerjensen]

I’m so tempted but everything always turns warm and pink on me and I don’t like that😂 I think I have to contact their customer service so I don’t buy yet another lipstick I won’t use😅 The formula looks awesome 🎉

[@mariam.a.]

Ohhh really tough. Depending on your own lip colour and skin tone, some tones will come out stronger than others. Did they give you some recommendations??

[@nanal1964]

I didn't have any contact with custom in my country (I am in EU) and there wasn't any additional cost. This formula is much better than Balm and I am so pleased because I threw Balm away. Its taste is awful.

[@mariam.a.]

I think it will depend per country. Sorry to hear you hated the balms so much. I love to use mine as lip care.

[@nikibowe]

honestly if the sentiment behind this refillable lipstick is eco-friendliness, i feel like the actual lipstick component should be interchangeable between brands. to me this is just another brand release. also the issue with something as frivolous as makeup is human nature. people want to explore new beands, try different products, play with different packaging, the act of purchasing and the anticipation of waiting for you purchase to arrive is part of the fun so i don't really see this working, also how often do people actually finish a lipstick or want to wear the same colour everyday. it would just be a 49 quid ornament sitting in your drawer

[@mariam.a.]

I think if you buy into the refillable idea, you need to still keep your feet on the ground. I do think the outside component is beautiful and I only need 1 (not one for every new colour), the rest of the lipstick can be re-cycled, but of course I don't suffer the delusion that part of the reason I want it is because it is new and shiny. You would be surprised, many people here have gone trough LE lipsticks. I am close on 1 velvet and several lucents. I hope ideally she will transfer the lucents in this format too since they can go fairly fast. By the way some of the other brands refills are interchangeable...Dior, Hermes and Prada fit into each other's components. However, they are not recyclable. In conclusion, right now recycling makeup packaging is an afterthought and a marketing ploy for most brands. We gotta start somewhere though and I think LE has her heart in the right place. And finally, it is entirely up to the customer, as I mentioned, to actually recycle properly.

[@handsomebynatasja2947]

Same😆🤣🤣💄💸💸

[@mariam.a.]

😂😂😂

[@yocelinelin8408]

Ashes of rosess=Lisa+Simone; Lisa= Milani matte lipstick(discontinued old packaging) +any clear balm; Simone= Velvet Affair + any clear balm to sheer out. I am quite disappointed about the new release,except the aluminum package which feel bit too heavy in my purse, when I drink coffee ,the whole color marked on my coffee cup is so embarrassing.Adore Lisa's artistry,however sad to say the new shades of rouge experience didn't convince/impress me .

[@mariam.a.]

Too bad you are disappointed. They are cream lipsticks though, being transfer proof is not among the claims of this formula.