LIVE: FL v. Ashley Benefield, Black Swan Murder Trial - Day 2 | COURT TV

[@CourtTV]

00:00:00 FL v. Benefield Day 2 00:02:19 Ashley Benefield in Court 00:07:19 ON THE RECORD - FL v. Benefield 00:09:42 State witness #9 - Alicia Byers, Defendant’s Mother 00:20:53 State Witness #10 - Dr. Barbara Russell, LCSW 00:36:19 State Witness #11 - Lt. Daniel Dickerman, Manatee County Sheriff’s Office 01:11:48 State Witness #12 - Stephanie Murphy, Family Law Attorney in the Sarasota-Bradenton Area 01:32:49 OJP - Argument over Hearsay 01:52:22 State Witness #12 - Stephanie Murphy Continued 02:22:25 Lunch Break 03:36:33 OJP - arguments on impeachment of witness objections 04:03:31 State Witness #12 - Stephanie Murphy Continued 04:35:14 OJP 04:55:09 State Witness #13 - Det. Chris Gillum, Domestic Violence Investigator, Manatee County Sheriff’s Office 05:32:49 State witness #14 - Det. Brian Moreland, Crimes Against Children (CAC) detective, Manatee County Sheriff’s Office 06:17:14 State witness #15 - Dr. Brad Broder, Clinical Psychologist, licensed in FL and NY 06:59:13 State witness #16 - Dr. Jason Quintal, PhD, LCSW 07:08:47 OJP - Decorum 07:22:55 State witness #16 - Dr. Jason Quintal, PhD, LCSW Continued #CourtTV Catch up on the facts of the case. FL v. #AshleyBenefield | #BlackSwanMurderTrial - MORE HERE: www.courttv.com/tag/ashley-benefield/?

[@Mia-cg9em]

Thanks

[@jmgood2870]

So Alicia NEVER asked Ashley why she killed Doug?? That very odd. I bet because they BOTH were in on this murder plot!

[@jmgood2870]

Did Ashley pay someone to act as if they were a reporter and tell Judge Whyte after lunch in the hall that they had information on Ashley and could give it to him? Judge Whyte stated he told them he could not accept it but they were free to sit in the courtroom. They declined. Sounds like Ashley was setting up the Judge because she will be convicted! Ashley can't take being responsible for Doug's murder!

[@JK-jj9ko]

Ashley was seeing Dr Broader and not a single time she mentioned that dough was abusive to her or her child, even when she was alone with Dr Broader she never made clear statements to the Broader of how abusive he was, she never told him when incidents occured so that he could keep a record of it, all she told broader was that she wanted to get divorced and leave him. Ashley knows that Dr Broader has the authority to tell police if there was any signs of abuse going on . Ashley is like Amber heard, seeing a Dr while claiming to be abused or her child is being physically abused and yet there is not a single photo of brusing, cuts etc being taken. It seems that there are so many rich people who cannot afford a mobile phone with a camera on it to take photos or videos of the abuse or injuries , and so many rich people see Drs for the abuse and yet are telling the Drs a completly different story. She is guilty

[@heidismith1869]

@@CourtTV thank you💯

[@St99748]

I love the acting job Ashley is doing, she’s trying to act so sad and meek and timid in court. And she keeps glancing at the jury to see if they’re watching her. 😅

[@Char_43]

She should stick to dancing her acting is awful.

[@KellyQuinn-eo9qq]

Agree 💯💯💯💯💯 She is guilty!!!!!!!!!

[@tanyalee11.11]

she’s pathetic.

[@steelhurricane4041]

Yikes

[@GooGooGal316]

Sociopath

[@BrookeHays-p6x]

Ashley face is driving me crazy!!She is def trying to put on this poor poor me..but after everything that came out today..there is no doubt she made dougs life hell just for wanting to be a father..He is the victim not her!!

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

Ashley said it herself to Dr. Broder - "I am going to take matters into my own hands" Quite an admission of what she was planning on doing!!!

[@Floridafanatic28]

That's not an admission to violence.

[@GenerationXChick]

Did you watch the footage? Seriously taking things into your own hands AFTER she moved to Maryland establishes a six month residency.

[@haileyarocha4263]

She told the therapist that after she moved to Maryland and established residency she was going to take mater into her hands. No sign of violence.

[@nancyjackson8690]

@@Floridafanatic28 just more cumulative circumstantial evidence.

[@Stargazer7279]

She was apparently engaged to someone else

[@GabbyJackson-nc4gn]

I think she premeditated the murder , hopefully the jury delivers justice

[@CountessKitten]

Agree wholeheartedly

[@deb-77d]

Something I can’t get out of my mind from yesterday when police was on the stand and said body was cool to the touch. I didnt think that would happen that quickly.

[@GabbyJackson-nc4gn]

@@deb-77d I nosed that , excellent point 👏🏾

[@mickeyd8273]

@@GabbyJackson-nc4gn i thought the same thing but i don't you think the prosecutors would've brought that up if they thought something was there?

[@GabbyJackson-nc4gn]

@@mickeyd8273 they honestly don’t have concise evidence, it’s circumstantial. That’s why

[@jenw7344]

I do not like that defense atty whatsoever

[@Tinks82]

I Don't think he's losing sleep over it because he doesn't care

[@lovepet4565]

That face & voice so gravely makes me think he's smoking that bad stuff too. He was so obvious with that comment , then steaming mad after.

[@TheOtherBoleynGirl336]

He sounds like he smokes road flares, and his style is obnoxious!

[@ReinaLovesLaw]

Oh man, I dig him. He is like a bulldog. I love his conviction.

[@mickeyd8273]

@@ReinaLovesLaw he's fighting like hell and trying to make something out of nothing, but i don't think its gonna win points with the primarily female jury. he has no finesse and is too aggressive.

[@deb-77d]

How embarrassing for defence att to have to be reprimanded in front of a full court. He’s had it coming for a while imo. Well done judge.

[@debiharmon7240]

This judge is an absolute breath of fresh air compared to judge Beverly over the Karen Read trial. He is absolutely non biased, fair, polite to witnesses, defendent, attorney's, etc. Very professional. Beverly was HORRIBLE!

[@Slyredfox75]

I was thinking the exact same thing!

[@steelhurricane4041]

Judge Auntie Bev is a nightmare.

[@Jess-qy6pm]

I cannot believe the defence counsel actually said to a witness “Oh you have no idea”. Shocking behaviour. I knew as soon as he said it the judge was gonna rightly shake him down.

[@deb-77d]

Same as yesterday calling witness a creep. Very unprofessional

[@KellyQuinn-eo9qq]

Great judge 👏👏👏👏👏

[@michelero4297]

@@KellyQuinn-eo9qq The judge just PREVENTED the defense from asking further questions that may assist in Ashley's defense. The judge has a grudge against the attorney and the attorney isn't fond of the judge either BUT the life of Ashley is on the line here and she deserves a fair trail. The judge clearly has given great leeway to the prosecution and has held the defense to the line.

[@sherrydmyterko-tramp8654]

For some reason, I think she believes she will be free. I think that day was the last day to prevent him from moving near her. Planned a head of time to tell him after he helped her. She said something to make him angry such as I’m seeing someone else, I don’t want you moving near me, etc….. then once he reacted she had an excuse n went to the bedroom, knowing he would follow her. When he came in she just shot him. Not warning him. She is telling g some truth n leaving the rest out. Maybe he wouldn’t let her leave after she said something. He wanted to talk… also being turned around n slapped, if it did happen, is not an attack, IMO.

[@deejane40]

That's what I'm seeing. I'm not an attorney so I don't understand why certain people can explain for prosecution but not for defense. It seems the point of Doug shooting the gun in the ceiling can't be talked about. If Ashley told her therapist that and he says what she said in their meeting how is it different from anyone else saying what Ashley said to them?

[@tamaravasselin8978]

That blink rate is through the roof

[@taylorjoshd]

This judge is FANTASTIC!!! I just finished the Karen Read trial where that judge was COMPLETELY unprofessional. This is fantastic

[@guntrader5652]

Open & shut case. Off to Lowell Annex for 50+ Years

[@staceyevans8558]

Defense attorney is an idiot, like his strategy is to make the entire room mad

[@lovepet4565]

Hes super creepy too. Like his client.

[@Kareyn2]

I know I’m annoyed with him

[@guadalupelazar2384]

I HOPE THE JURY DONT GET FOOL BY ASHLEY LOOK SO INNOCENT

[@NancyBriant-wr9vo]

Ashley played Doug.. GUILTY LOCK HER UP!! 2 daughters without their father. Some women are just manipulators!! Ashley is one of them. Judge is awesome.

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

I LOVE this judge!!! He knows exactly what he is doing! This is HIS court and can run it as he sees fit and won't take any nonsense from the defense!! Neil just wants to get a mistrial and is trying to aggravate Judge Whyte especially since he wanted the judge removed from this case!!

[@MissteryDiva]

Acting like a 2 year old baby because his ego was hurt does not make a good judge 🤦‍♀️

[@deb-77d]

What was his reason for wanting to remove judge?

[@ruthisaurus8004]

@@deb-77dI believe it was in regards to comments made during the Stand Your Ground hearing when the attorney saw that judge W had apparently strongly implied that he has already decided AB is guilty

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

@@MissteryDiva Bating a judge is not very mature either - very sleazy.

[@deb-77d]

@@ruthisaurus8004 thank you

[@sunshinegal4294]

I was just about to say this judge is not doing a good job by allowing the defense attorney to keep asking and saying things that are objected to for hearsay and he sustains everything. But he just said would you please approach to the bench! FINALLY!!!

[@brandybiscoff9685]

Does anyone else think the murder was less about the psych evals coming out, and more about the move to Maryland? She adamantly didn’t want him coming along, he clearly planned on coming, and she wasn’t having it!

[@LoriMac17]

💯

[@susandyer6624]

I believe it started with the Birth Certificate. There is nothing more disturbing to a human being to not know your parentage on a Birth or Death Certificate. Ashley set this up from conception.

[@steelhurricane4041]

I thought they agreed he was coming along, just living separately.

[@taylorjoshd]

She picked a TERRIBLE defense attorney

[@Joanne-p9x]

Thankyou Judge!! 😎👍⚖️

[@dawn822]

No matter how hard she tries, Ashley can't get that snotty look off her face.

[@kr1s72]

4:12:59 SNOTTY REACTION SHOT.

[@steelhurricane4041]

Stuck up

[@Char_43]

Whatever she paid the Defense Atty, it was too much.

[@loriduffecy9205]

@@Char_43 ...I 👍 agree..I was wondering if he was court 🧐 appointed??..Also do u happen to know if she is out on bail??...

[@LeahJo13]

I really like this judge. And I don't say that very often.

[@celestehutchison709]

I never wanted to meet a judge, but this one I would love to meet. He is awesome!!

[@steelhurricane4041]

No nonsense judge. 👍

[@mygoodness5721]

Seems to me he did everything she asked him to do. She manipulated him from start to end. Guilty.

[@jamesbillington9280]

So far, I find the Ashley Benefield trial is turning out to be the complete opposite of what is portrayed online. No "Black Swan".

[@K9_Queen19]

It's been 2 days. We haven't even gotten to the good stuff yet.

[@jenniferk.7023]

I'm just now watching the trial, but she was a ballerina who used Doug's money to start her own ballet studio. She scammed the people who also contributed to the funding of the studio. Evil Swan is more like it. I've been following this case for a while now, and there's things she's done that may not even be included in the trial. She's deranged.

[@Musicloverrrrrr]

What makes ppl fly off the handle so bad that they do things to risk their freedom and then have the audacity to try to fight it? Like seriously, I have been so angry before that you could probably physically see smoke coming from my ears but never have I ever thought to fight, k*ll or harm someone over anything. The thought of my freedom lying in someone else’s hands is enough anxiety. Idk how ppl do this.

[@steelhurricane4041]

Arrogance

[@EvaLeeanncostlow-xw8iu]

I think Stephanie the attorney was quite nice and lovely

[@steelhurricane4041]

I agree. Professional.

[@lise-lottehelvang3967]

Chris Gillum - well done for your statement - not one to be bullied by the wife or her attorney 👏👏👏

[@lisawinnard5682]

First thing I'd be doing is getting a new lawyer!!! I can already hear the jail door slamming!

[@steelhurricane4041]

He's not that good. You need someone with Passion, this defense attorney is a dud.

[@doragreen3887]

She is guilty as heck!

[@hs5167]

None of this makes sense. Why would he reverse his vasectomy only to try to poison his pregnant wife? Why would she want a pregnancy by an “abusive” husband?

[@steelhurricane4041]

Now you're thinking 🤔

[@jenniferk.7023]

She's a liar, and she's a psychopath. The way she treated Doug's daughter from his first marriage was disgusting. She was so jealous of his daughter she didn't want him talking to her on the phone, spending time with her, giving her any money, and wpuld sreech at Doug if he did any of things. She's nuts.

[@Stargazer7279]

She lied about EVERY THING!

[@SharonM-b1g]

Does anyone know that when she shot him in the leg could she have not run out the house instead of shooting him again in the chest

[@delightful640]

Great judge!!!!

[@heatherclayton-callaghan4270]

So in this case the Defence Solicitors are holding people over on subpoena simply to stop anyone talking to the media or on social media while the case vontinues. NOT bcos they are going to be recalled for further questioning !!!!!! Really am DISGUSTED with Accussed MURDERER and HER LEGAL team. !!!!!!!!!!!

[@nblack2867]

S Tier Judge so far. I've seen judges get frustrated and yell at attorneys outside the presence of the jury. This judge kept his cool. That's an S Tier moment imho.

[@kathleenhanbury8151]

Ashley expression is very strange...

[@gingerpullin4933]

ASHLEY needs to get a better Lawyer...in my opinion

[@loriduffecy9205]

I was wondering if he was court appointed???... OMG...bad bad bad...

[@nancyjackson8690]

I have no idea of her guilt or innocence, as no one should at this stage. Her attorney is doing his job. As what should happen , the judge will handle him as appropriate. My only complaint is, with all the objections, by both sides, this trial will go on way too long.

[@TrailHandBill]

Way top many objections. But then again, it's not my life and freedom on the line.

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

I was recently on a civil case jury and there were just as many objections in that case as there is here!

[@girlfromsouth214]

I'm still wondering where the bullet hole in the kitchen came from.

[@jenniferk.7023]

I'm just now watching the trial, but she was a ballerina who used Doug's money to start her own ballet studio. She scammed the people who also contributed to the funding of the studio. Evil Swan is more like it. I've been following this case for a while now, and there's things she's done that may not even be included in the trial. She's deranged. You can find more about her from 48 Hours, and other videos on KZbin.

[@jenniferk.7023]

Her attorney is an idiot.

[@HeatherChavez-zi3yw]

Ugh I wish I had EDB to zoom zoom for me

[@ritasantana9572]

@@HeatherChavez-zi3yw my thoughts exactly

[@LeahJo13]

@@HeatherChavez-zi3yw YES indeed!!! That would be extremely helpful!!!

[@brandyurban9415]

Doug’s attorney is so arrogant and her behavior is so unprofessional!! I am appalled by her giggles and smiles. She is a witness for a murder trial!!!

[@debiharmon7240]

I agree! She and Stephanie were acting like mean girls! Stupid

[@ryanblow5260]

BR I’m shocked a person with all your degrees , didn’t see through all the drama, lies and BS?? JS

[@TrailHandBill]

2:10:24 this chick is so phony. She damn near makes me want to believe Ashley.

[@GenerationXChick]

I don’t know if she’s guilty or innocent however the prosecution has a weak case. Witnesses are saying things that benefits the defense. Do we have another case of an overzealous prosecutor?

[@debbiejohnson7025]

Wow did you see the evil eye from Ashley towards the Witness Doug’s Attorney!

[@foxylady9110]

If he was my defence attorney I’d be very worried…..😬😬

[@sandrabrislin4526]

Defense attorney is awful

[@Girlmom4]

Her mother was most likely subpoenaed by the prosecution I’m sure she’s not testifying to go against her daughter! People seem to be shocked in the live chat that she is being called by the prosecution. Not sure why lol it’s definitely a common thing in cases where prosecutors call family members from the defendant.

[@Girlmom4]

I also find it funny the prosecutor decided to keep her under subpoena meaning she can’t sit in the court!! 🤔

[@traciphillips6595]

@@Girlmom4 I think mom is considered a hostile witness, and therefore is being punished by the State by keeping her from sitting in the courtroom.

[@wandab.933]

How can mother and daughter who have such a close relationship not speak about what happened that day?? You’re under oath ma’am !

[@maryestadurtche9452]

@@Girlmom4I think great job prosecutor who almost let her off bc then mom could sit in & Watch trial when defense did the same thing to Doug’s daughter! Why would he do that? Bc he didn’t want her sitting in court maybe for sympathy

[@LoriMac17]

This defense attny is a bully. He can't will witnesses to say what he wants them to say. No amount of manipulation can make this psycho look innocent

[@loricollicott2408]

Amber Heard ain't got nothing on this Black Swan!! 😂

[@gingerpullin4933]

There is 2 sides to every story HIS ...HERS... IT sounds like a cluster F relationship...both wanting the control

[@michelero4297]

I love how Deborah in chat was keeping track of the sidebars. 6 and we are not even an hour into the video. LOL Gillum will only respond with an arrest AFTER the offender kills the victim and not before then no matter how fearful the victim appears to be. These cops won't do a damn thing.

[@edwinacaparelli9911]

The witness made out the fact that the baby was born early like it was so early. The due date was April 8th, being born March 19th is not that severe.

[@steelhurricane4041]

Ashley's demeanor is arrogant and unremorseful. She really needs an attitude adjustment. Guilty as charged.

[@Makeeverydayyourbestday]

I have a question? What the dynamics would be in a relationship between a 24 year old girl and a 54 year old man? Just wondering??

[@paulafinnegan429]

Money most likely

[@paris6963]

“Gimme a minute “

[@loriduffecy9205]

Is Ashleys attorney a court appointed one?... another bad choice for her..

[@bellestar777]

Hi Vinnie, I find it really frustrating that I can't comment on Court TV KZbin live video’s unless I become a member. It feels like my voice and engagement are being restricted unless I pay for it. At this time I have chosen to unsubscribe to court tv. Everyone should have a voice unless they’re truly saying nasty, hateful and hurtful things.

[@michelleh8064]

I don’t pay and I can comment

[@holly_kay5570]

It doesn't cost anything to be a subscriber

[@BOSSYtexasCHICK]

@@michelleh8064 I think y’all misunderstood what that person meant it cost money to comment in the live chat

[@ginallorah]

Bye

[@joshturner7203]

That lawyer in the pink on the stand,😂 she’s great, to he!! With hiring her I wanna marry her! She knows what she’s doing!

[@josephbrito6436]

Seems to me this judge doesn't like Mr Taylor

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

He disrespected the judge on purpose in front of a jury and tried to get him removed from the case.

[@Stargazer7279]

Why did she want his baby if he was such an abuser do tell?

[@kathyviglione4226]

It will take 6 years with the defense attorney jc

[@snozua21]

I cant even listen to this. Theres an objection every 30 seconds. Wtf

[@Girlmom4]

23:24 Of course she’s not going to talk about the shooting lol 😂 she had an attorney! This prosecutor is asking stupid a$$ obvious questions!!

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

OMG!!!! I can't stand all of the fake crying!!!!

[@jessicapulizzano4228]

This is… not going well.

[@rachaellynn4147]

Ashley’s actions all indicate that he was abusive to her, and this explains her behaviors towards this man. He was violent, and extremely emotionally abusive to her. Doug’s lawyer was enjoying her stance a little too much on the stand…. I don’t like her!

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

@@i4j11j2do5 And still is nuts!! To have her daughter parade around a courthouse with a sign in 100 degree weather and have her on a megaphone is child abuse!!

[@FOLLOWINGTHETRIAL]

@@Slyredfox75 It was on a couple of news stations last week. You could look through those You Tube videos. Also, Barbara Russel was interviewed by one of the stations.

[@kathyviglione4226]

Man the mom is a See you next tuesday

[@paulafinnegan429]

Who is the fella in the suit sitting behind her? Is it her boyfriend?

[@girlfromsouth214]

The comments here condemning the defendant based on her looks are simple minded. Maybe she did it out of spite. Maybe it was self defense. There is reasonable doubt. Why did the state not clear up where the bullet hole in the kitchen the daughter testified about came from? The state has not proven its case.

[@brandybiscoff9685]

I’m sorry but family law attorney Stephanie Murphy was obnoxious!!

[@Gabriel-hf1yy]

Why cause she told the truth shes dougs voice he can't speak for himself...

[@brandybiscoff9685]

No, I’m on Doug’s side here. But she was being difficult, not giving direct answers to questions, seemed to be smirking a lot. She’s an attorney, she knows the rules of evidence and would be a much better witness for Doug if she acted more professionally.

[@maryrose7842]

@@brandybiscoff9685I actually thought she was a good witness but she was constantly being interupted

[@christinao522]

She was trying to get her 2 cents out in front of the jury before she was shut down by the court. She knew exactly what she was doing, and it was obviously to defend Doug & help the prosecution

[@ReinaLovesLaw]

She was so obnoxious and should know better.

[@TrailHandBill]

4:03:13 She is so phony

[@lorigene]

This whole comment section is awful! Definitely where All the vitriolic sad people congregate… NONE of you are waiting until this case is over to make your judgement; It’s obvious NONE of you are watching this trial…and have your small minds made up. honestly I pray she walks out of that courtroom a free woman.

[@laurengoulding5458]

Hi Ashley

[@ReinaLovesLaw]

👏

[@carolinskeep8106]

Go away little girl she is old news

[@ReinaLovesLaw]

How are you all giving a man who punched a dog unconscious and shot a hole in the ceiling whose own daughter confirmed his behavior so much credibility? I'm not saying she's innocent, it's too early to tell, but the quick loyalty to an abuser is scary.

[@mickeyd8273]

she lured him there. he didn't see his daughter for 6 mos. didn't know she was born until weeks after. he left her alone but he did want to see his daughter. why was she pretending to reconcile? bc she didn't want to share the child and when cps & the family court judge didn't believe her, she chose to kill him. the family court judge said she didn't find a scintilla of credibility in her testimony. it's clear as day. if she truly was a victim, wouldn't she speak to her mother or her close friend? its not evidence but her actions aren't those of an innocent person. nope...this was all coordinated by her.

[@kathyviglione4226]

I xant wait till shes convicted

[@MrWeepies]

Stephanie Murphy rocks👏👏👏!

[@kathyviglione4226]

Hazmat for a teaset

[@helenj7812]

O yes her rolling her eyes and silly smiling mmmmm not good talking about woman in hot pink dress.

[@ukgraffitiwalker8846]

Great job thanks

[@susandyer6624]

WTF is this music?

[@Char_43]

Hello G and Mods, question, has someone blocked me from Chat? I tried to comment all morning and nothing! Box wouldn’t open, can you check or help with this? Thank you.

[@PiaTalks]

The live chat was only open to members today. So only people who pay the monthly membership fee were allowed to type in the live chat today

[@Char_43]

@@PiaTalks I am a paid subscriber, have been for 14 months. It was fine next day, some glitch I guess.

[@michelero4297]

The problem I see with judge snacks is that even though there is a process of appealing his rulings that takes years. Years of Ashely's and her daughter's life where Ashley would be in prison and her daughter growing up without a mother. So a judge to disregard any of his lordship's questionable rulings with the idea they can be corrected on appeal is just horrible practice from the bench. If I lived in that county I would not vote for this guy ever, if he is elected to his seat.

[@MissteryDiva]

Doug admitted to shooting a gun at the ceiling & threw a loaded gun & punched Ashley! Allegedly gave her poisoned tea! Punched a dog & threw a cat! Ex-wife, "you kicking me so hard on our honeymoon"!

[@laurengoulding5458]

Read the evidence 🙄

[@tanyalee11.11]

7:29:43 the faces are pathetic

[@MikeHansen-sv2lj]

Pink dress lady talks way too much! How irritating!

[@suzannemarchitelli5893]

On day 2, I have no idea if he poisoned her, or if she planned it, but he sounds like a real prince. Punching holes in walls, shooting the ceiling, PUNCHING A DOG UNCONSCIOUS??? Doug would have been gone a lot sooner if I was his wife.

[@jenw7344]

Are they done for the day

[@haileyarocha4263]

I dislike family lawyers. They are so shaddy like the one that worked for Doug.

[@bethmccrae2714]

This judge is astoundingly biased against the defense. How does he get away with this?

[@maryturula7620]

Counterpoint: no he isn't.

[@RDFitzwater]

I’m watching this on delay so I’m sure this has been covered, but it is obvious that Doug was doing his lawyer.

[@musicmaniarat]

wow, what a wild accusation.

[@RP_76]

Lord 😏

[@RDFitzwater]

@@musicmaniarat That woman was way too angry about the death of a client in a custody battle. Professional lawyers do not get that emotionally attached to a client. This woman acted as if she had lost a lover not a client. You know two things can be true at the same time. Ashley planned and executed that plan to kill Doug and Doug was a manipulative, narcissistic abuser. Most older men who want a young woman want someone they can control. Most young women who marry old wealthy men are gold diggers. These not a new things in society.