[Live on Air] NCT U - WITHOUT YOU, NCT U (도영, 재현, 태일) - WITHOUT YOU [정오의 희망곡 김신영입니다] 20160421

[@constanzamm1678]

Taeil doesn't even try. It's like whenever he opens his mouth he just sings.

[@alijbara9600]

omg so true 😢😢😍

[@arafadhwang4119]

omg true

[@indyaldasavitri5974]

Yes, girl

[@pakkadartidthayaporn2634]

AGREED

[@LilyBlooms0912]

I think the same things

[@pinksausage8631]

poor Jaehyun if i can hug him

[@sannea5696]

not an alien its ok since he says 'im with you'

[@noora950]

doyoungs shifty eyes, jaehyun singing even tho hes sick, taeil just looking generally scared. so cute. so sad. but so cute.

[@kzs5839]

noor a what was wrong with jaehyun???

[@bobthetaco1057]

@@kzs5839 pretty sure he had a cold or something

[@SSSS-wq4vn]

WhY was Doyounng looking at? Did they not know what camera?

[@loewelim]

@@SSSS-wq4vn pretty sure he was nervous, this was their debut i think, or at least when they first started off

[@ra7il4728]

they still did really good!

[@tawanswife5365]

i wanna hug jaehyun so bad

[@monikagurung6180]

Kristin Bailey me too

[@carolynsautter7402]

same

[@madeleyarias6029]

same

[@ra7il4728]

me too bro

[@seulver]

me too

[@danibarnayha]

Baby jaehyun, please take care of your health and your vocals too... Saranghae ♡

[@형민-k1s]

신인 김도영 미쳤나 존나 귀여워서 대가리 깨고싶다싯파ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ뭔가 긴장한것같은게 존나 귀여웟 글구 울 재현이 이 날 목 안좋았나ㅠㅠㅠ너무 걱정된다ㅠㅠㅠㅜㅠㅜ

[@vennicemonterde2447]

Their voices are cleaner than my room

[@iwantyourdirtywateronmyfac6438]

you killed it gurl 😂😂😂😂😂

[@animemangaluv13]

this comment changed my life

[@vennicemonterde2447]

+Kpopluvr94 im glad it did. bless u

[@gabytornay]

Vennice Monterde xD

[@ag-dr1df]

That's something I could never say.

[@user-wf1ud7dk2e]

목상태 안좋은거 누가봐도 아는데 열심히 불러주는 재현이 ㅜ ㅜ 아프지만 말자 ㅜ

[@SMTOWNELF]

THEIR HARMONIZATION IN THE CHORUS PART IS NO JOKE; doyoung's crystal clear voice plays as the main vocal part, Taeil complement it perfectly with his angelic voice and lastly accompany with Jaehyun's smooth and calm harmonization. Indeed, it is never dissapointing.

[@minhyuksgayness6840]

SMTOWNELF even tho the song’s chords are generic and boring af they slayyyyy

[@clayia6684]

Minhyuk's Gayness huh?

[@jonfilip4039]

@@minhyuksgayness6840 like you?

[@htxuyym-7901]

1:12 도영 눈 안절부절 못하는거 왜이리 귀엽냐 ㅣ진짠ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ큐ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@jennieyen]

표정은 신인인데 목소리는 음원 그 자체ㅠㅠㅠ 도영아 노래해줘서 고마워

[@protect_NCT]

이 영상 유독 맘 아파서 못보는ㅜㅜ 재현이 본인도 얼마나 불안하고 속상했을지 ㅜㅜ 완전 신인때라 긴장많이 됐을텐데 맴찢 ㅜㅜ

[@yellowkai247]

Taeil: *opens mouth* Me: DONT PLS IM NOT READY Taeil: -sings beautifully- Me: -walks away bald-

[@caroyeon3953]

Is Taeil your bias?! this comment and the other one... looks like you love Taeil hahahaha...

[@nurulhusna251]

Taeil stansssss 😍 his singing was so natural n effortless ❤️

[@watchsaikikrightnow6439]

Nakamoto Yuta i’m here!!💚

[@iputtenshairintheclosetdon3536]

OMG FINALLY TAEIL STANS. MY FRIENDSSSS😭

[@Doyoung_AGungppang]

재현이가 얼마나 속상하고 불안했을까.. 하다 못해 도영ㅇ이 표정에서도 다보이는데 목소리가 저지경까지 됐는데 라이브 시키면 어쩌냐고 ㅜㅜ 그러다가 목 잘못되면 보물같은 목소리 잘못됐으면 어쩔뻔 했냐궁.. ㅜㅜ

[@Aaa-tz4nv]

이 날 왜 컨디션 안좋았는지 아시나요?

[@못살아-s2l]

K J 감기걸렸었어요 ㅠㅠㅠㅠ . 그래서 계속 기침하고 목 상태가 안 좋았어요 ㅠㅠ

[@김나영-q1f1w]

감기걸렸을때 노래시키면 더 안좋아지는데 .. 게다가 노래도 높고 재현아 수고했었어 ㅠㅠ

[@alice12788]

@@krkrkrkrkrkr210 말 참 예쁘게도 한다 그리 꼬여서 어찌 살려고ㅠ

[@waveintoyou]

@@krkrkrkrkrkr210 온라인이라고 말 막하네 ㅋㅋ 님이 뱉은말 되게 별거 아닌거 같죠? 근데 그 말이 누군가한테는 얼마나 기분나쁠지 생각 좀 하고 말하셈여~

[@bekahbabie]

aaawwwwww poor Jaehyun he looked so discouraged after his voice cracked T_T I hope he knows that we love him to death and anything he does is perfect in our eyes, no matter what his perception of himself is

[@bekahbabie]

sameee T_T

[@beadenise]

he was coughing at the start of the video, he was sick here

[@bekahbabie]

Bea Denise Yeah. I wish they didn't make him sing when he was clearly sick :'(

[@beadenise]

They work these boys so hard, he should've been resting if he wasn't well enough to sing

[@bekahbabie]

Bea Denise truuuuuu

[@ikrann2345]

TAEIL IS SOOOOOOOO CUTE & HIS VOICE IS UGH 😭😭😭😭😭❤️❤️ *i cant breathe taeil*

[@emirdanial2244]

omg bambam😂that is from their homerun dance practice right?😂

[@ikrann2345]

+emir danial yessssss it is hahaha! 😂😂🙌

[@pesopaku8750]

i feel the same

[@xiumer5810]

I wasn't ready

[@rockbergema5210]

I think so 👏👏👏

[@emily3202]

*patiently waits for the day Taeil can finally be considered one of SM's vocal powerhouses*

[@usagimaud]

Emily Xiang waiting for these 3 to be part of it. They have the potential to be like KRY.

[@milktea2021]

I am new to NCT. Who is NCT 2018 vocal line?

[@taemojkmt4369]

ana pudding32 Nct have many main vocalists spread across all units. NCT 127: main- Taeil and Doyoung, lead- Jaehyun and Haechan. NCT Dream: main- Haechan and Chenle, lead- Renjun. NCT U doesn't have a fixed main vocal line cause it can change each comeback (however it usually is either Taeil or Doyoung with Jaehyun in lead). Kun (not fully debuted) is also a main vocal with Jungwoo possible being a main or lead. The best NCT vocalist so who would be main in NCT 2018 is Taeil.

[@yaizaananda7293]

@@taemojkmt4369 jungwoo is lead vocalist

[@binnie127]

He is

[@mallory6579]

doyoung is the cutest thing in this universe.

[@sonexarmy97]

Do young looks so cute and his pretty looking eyes keeps darting around 😂😂

[@shanafaith259]

noticed that too! so cute. hihi! looks like he's unsure of the surrounding but he did so well like it's nothing at all lol

[@rinyunicorn4882]

he's looking for inspiration for vroom vroom 3.0

[@Starfishxoxo]

The third guy is so cute and his voice is ugh

[@mayonnaise9074]

Apir

[@dandychiki]

Moon taeil

[@pororocakeu1279]

It's *Moon Taeil* *He's the oldest in NCT he's the Main Vocalist* I know it's been 3years but hi welcome to the future lol

[@choppachoppa1515]

😗💅Lol that was 4 years ago I think they know now just saying...

[@Portiayuu]

@@choppachoppa1515 lmao for real HAHAHAA they’re out here replying when the persom commented probably know more now😂

[@빵포뇽]

도영 왤케 귀엽냐 진짜 ㅜㅜ

[@miyyojimiey]

i love taeil's voice too much. i just cannot help myself

[@patheticmen4800]

jaehyun take care yourself bro

[@PinkPopcorn999]

Taeil looks like he is singing so effortlessly

[@mayonnaise9074]

Alwayss huhu

[@Jay-rc5cy]

처음에 도영이 목소리 녹는다 녹아

[@yoonacouples3015]

Doyoung voice is like angel and he looks like a bunny, jaehyun is so handsome no doubt. And ofcourse our cheerleader and grandpa taeil is so cute

[@그립굥]

도영이 눈치보면서 하는 거 왤케 기욥냐 ㅋㅋ

[@kimtaeyeonismyeverything]

The chours make me want to break into Taeil's "cheerleading dance"

[@ayeshadaniacalvi7599]

OMG LOL 😂

[@leneishaa7127]

STITCH Ohana hahhahahaha samee

[@dawnoh4466]

HAHAHAHAHA

[@0011e8]

김도영,.......데뷔초떠는찐토끼왕자님

[@issaortiz9136]

Ok so nobody is going to talk about Doyoung's beautiful voice so I will- he has the voice of an angel I'm- im so in love with his voice I swear-

[@shinysanie]

everyone is talking about Dodo tho... kkkk

[@배겨파-p5i]

02:54 태일이 고음 잘하니까 도영이 웃는거 왤케 귀여웡 ㅜ

[@yellow2to3]

와기 토깽이...ㅠ

[@bemybrowniee9870]

Doyoung's voice is one of the sweetest things I have ever heard

[@sumspingZ]

They looked so nervous, doyoung's eyes were looking everywhere, but they still sounded great. hope jaehyun feels better😁

[@KukaPopKukaPop94]

moon taeil your voice is perrrrrrrrfffffffffecccct

[@yongyongiety9470]

get well soo uri Woojae 😭😭

[@yongyongiety9470]

*soon

[@hunhanbaekyeol1016]

Woojae?

[@May-qq4cv]

+HunHan Baekyeol101 woojae (우재) = woori/uri jaehyun (우리 재현)

[@yongyongiety9470]

+HunHan Baekyeol101 Jaehyun nicknames^^.. Woojae = Woori Jaehyun. you must watch *NCT on air show eps 1*

[@강솔-p2o]

태어나서 이렇게 보기 짠한 라이브는 처음본다

[@aikofarella3973]

Taeil do a high note so relax

[@resuri_]

Skills.

[@doyochity9408]

Doyoung's beautiful and technically amazing voice never fail to impress me. The talent and amount of hardwork he put~ he is so passionate about singing

[@P_onewe]

재현이 표정을 보니 마음이 아프다...ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ목 아픈 거 같은데...ㅠㅠㅠ

[@onyourhaechan]

ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅇㅈ 맴아파!!!

[@coolhellu]

what is my child doyoung wearing..

[@julianeilson8062]

looks like smth an old person would wear golfing

[@khristinedaniel145]

OMG i laughed so much at that lol

[@winniec9197]

I made the same question

[@catalinacaneloolivares4340]

That's fabulous fashion. I want his clothes in my closet rai nau!

[@gadizajasmineramadani8177]

Lol so you are my mother in law

[@elainemedina9558]

Whenever Taeil finishes that note, I always let out a really long exhale because apparently I was holding my breath. Hahahaha. Look at what you do to me, Taeil, and you're not even my bias.

[@annecruz7039]

Oh girl i feel the same way! Like i get nervous for them too esp w this hahaha my bias is Mark but then its just that way i think bc i really do love & support all 18 of them

[@mac_kys0000]

RELATABLE 🤟🏻😍

[@진주별-o3q]

도영이 진짜 멋있다

[@mayishuni]

정재현 뽀글머리와 위닷츄는 매번 옳아.... 나 맨날 보러 올거야

[@som7281]

아니 라디오로 자세히 보는게 훨씬 잘생겼고 음원만큼 라이브 똑같이 너무 노래잘한다. 심지어 열심과 열정이 듬뿍 담겼네... 흥해라 엔씨티

[@mikah451]

I love jaehyun's harmonization during the chorus! Fighting oppa ❤❤

[@user-pz9rj9or5z]

아유.. 애기다 애기.. 다들 보송보송하네 진짜ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@amorechiquitos6990]

Is jaehyun having sore throat? His voice cracked quite a lot 😭

[@meorichan218]

Prob!! 😭😭😭😭😭

[@shendy1331]

+amore chiquitos yes. if you watch the full video, jae drank a lot of water

[@amorechiquitos6990]

can you give me the link?

[@LAZYUNICORN]

+amore chiquitos yeaaaaaaaaaaaaah I'm laughed so hard when his voice cracked at the beginning

[@juliett1584]

+LAZY UNICORN ?

[@Naomi-sy9lp]

DOYOUNG WITH HIS PERIWINKLE SWEATER AND REd VELVET BERET AND HIS FACE oMg so precious

[@gabytornay]

Doyoung voice deserve always a lot of attention. His voice is perfect is the sweet to listen his voice.

[@신채원-w5e]

재횬아.. 아프지마 ㅠㅅㅠ

[@jess_xj]

Get better soon Jae 😪❤️

[@유우연]

근데 말 안해도 아픈거 딱 알겠다... 목 상태 너무 안좋은디ㅠㅠㅠ 무리한거같애ㅠㅠ

[@랫서-t8u]

다들 긴장하고 특히 재현은 목상태 안좋은거같은데 다들 넘 잘한다 진짜ㅠ

[@정윤오바보]

한양대 실용음악과 4일다닌 문태일 사랑해

[@수민아-b2s]

Zztzzzzzzz

[@hyojungpark8353]

I think i'm in love 😍 Taeil

[@감자도리-q4h]

1:38 문탤 삑사리 나고 그 옆에 도영이 흠칫 ㅋㅎㅋㅎㅋㅋㅎ

[@eyliaa]

is jaehyun sick... ㅠㅠ

[@baetaeng7485]

Yes

[@beadenise]

he was coughing at the beginning of the video

[@jaehyunscigy8047]

Pity

[@caioxalves]

Apparently he was but this song is too high for him. The coughing was more for "warming" his voice. He is a baritone and this song is just too high, made for tenors (taeil and doyoung)

[@lols3291]

Songhun actually it's a bad thing to cough for warming up your voice it will just damage your vocals more, i think he's just really sick that time

[@u-knowmax136]

hmmm..1 doyong..nice voice ..2taeil soft and clear and 3jhaeyun husky voice...good job....fighting

[@kimbapkidding5413]

Woojae looks like a puppy T____T their vocals on point 😭❤️

[@Peachprince214]

위드아웃유 다시 내줘라 ㅠㅠ 이런 조합 좋아

[@daniellamedrano8886]

Oww Taeil is the cutest thing ever!

[@dokongssi]

노래 너무 잘한다

[@yulsssm3982]

bunny doyoung's angelic voice😊

[@AUTA13]

Taeil, the great of Clean & Clear voice Doyoung, Heavenly voice Jaehyun, very Cute voice, please take care yourself

[@august_shin2618]

22 yrs old boy Taeil 20 yrs old boy Doyoung 19 yrs old boy Jaehuyn At that NCT U Super Rookie They looked super nervous but still slay with live singing😍

[@alysha9842]

They have a freaking amazing vocals,especially Taeil... But Doyoung,he is the one that will always be my favorite ❤ Doyoung fighting!! 😊❤

[@KrisJavier]

Is Taeil the first one to sing?

[@KrisJavier]

Janice L Thanks! Doyoung =) I'll be following him from now on. I'll check if he is in 127 too.... I really loved how he started the song, I'm so in love with it for real!!!

[@yyxy5030]

Doyoung not the members of NCT 127...but i hope the next sub-unit he will be in!! Doyoung is my ultimate bias in NCT!!!! Love him so much...even though im not full NCT stan..hehe but im Doyoung trash for sure..ckckkckckc

[@nrptp690]

+Lemon Tae me to jeje

[@jhopealegria5766]

taeil have a voice very very beautiful oh my ❤❤

[@greenteashavedice]

ㅁㅊ 태일 한소절 부르는데 ㄹㅇ 시디 아니냐고

[@hawaadam784]

taeil voice strike my heart

[@shstay3577]

Taeil voice is very nice

[@아궁-f7g]

도영 데뷔초때 목소리 진짜 맑당.

[@himahime152]

꿀같은목소리태일이!

[@cami6473]

I CANNOT BELIEVE I DIDNT SEE ANY COMMENT ABOUT HOW DOYOUNG VOICE IS LIKE A FREAKING ANGEL AND HOW HANDSOME THAT MAN IS BECAUSE HE CAN FUCKIN STEP ME HE IS THE REASON WHY IM INTO NCT IN THE FIRST PLACE

[@istp-618]

그 와중에 정재현 맨처음에 목소리 한 번 갈라지고 조금 시무룩해진 것 같은 게 귀엽게 느껴지는 나.. 비정상인가요.. 안쓰럽게 느껴져야 되는데 자꾸 귀엽게 보이네

[@hanlafleur]

taeil looks good with that hair😍 btw get well soon to our woojae

[@happinessislife5627]

Taeil is effortless. He has naturally pretty voice.

[@풀썬엄마]

신인 라이브가 너무 좋네요!! 정재현씨 당시 목 컨디션이 안 좋아보이는데 이러는데 내가 재현이를 어떻게 못 좋아해요

[@김정우만의레시피로만]

재현이 저 때 유난히 목 상태 안 좋아 보이네 도영이도 걱정하는 게 보이고... 태일이는 워낙 목 관리 잘하니까 괜찮은데 재현이 저 때 감기 걸렸나?

[@user-lm7ib6dx4n]

@@user-hj2fu2jp1l 뽀로로케잌 먹고 감기 걸렸다는줄..

[@sydsivo]

Oh, no, Jaehyun, you poor guy. I'm sure he wasn't feeling well during this recording. He shouldn't be forced to sing if he's sick. It's the same for other artists, as well. Nevertheless, he delivered the best performance he could. :) I am still gushing over how amazing Taeil sounds. His vibrato is superb!

[@mac_kys0000]

It’s already 2020 and I am still here haha. Watching this for like more than a hundred times now. Moon Taeil, you are the best! Hwaiting!!!

[@tasya_925]

We fall in love with taeil bcs this song😭

[@justney7927]

Doyoung is on point

[@bluebyunggon3979]

TAEIL SLAAAAAYS, NOTHING CHANGES FROM THE AUDIO (SONG), TO PRE RECORD, TO LIVE

[@cristinerafaelrefuerzo1469]

I love Doyoung's voice. Jaehyun is my bias. But I don't know. I have this weird feeling everytime I hear Taeil's voice. He's a bias wrecker, he's a heart melter 😂

[@sehunbubble8591]

Doyoung and taeil really consistent . taeil can high note like nothing . he's gifted

[@jeonkisan]

TAEILS VOICE OMG ♡♡♡

[@4r4n3lm4l74]

i'm just watching it in 2023 🥺 JAEHYUN, you did well! eventhough his throat was not in good condition, but he’s so professional, trying to perform his best. 💕

[@SuperBubblegumgirl99]

Taeil is an angel 😍😭

[@yordankavo]

Today is 22th May 2023. I'm so proud of you, boys. You're doing great! To the world!

[@jenniekrystal197]

my three bias babies :333333 the live is just so damn perfect. Doyoungie is a boo thang, and poor Jaehyunie please take care, i just wanna give him a hug. Taeilie is rocking them high notes like no others. i can't describe my love for them

[@shrwa.7704]

I’m so proud that Jaehyun is so much confident about his vocal abilities 🥺

[@lanah.1568]

Our taeil is so small yet his voice hits the PEAK OF THE MOUNTAINNSSSS

[@제볶]

얼마나 긴장 됐을까 ㅠㅠㅠ 내가 다 조마조마하다

[@faintsmile1308]

Doyoung and Taeil ate their CDs. As for Jaehyun, no need to worry 'cause NCT stans know what you're capable of. 🙂🙂🙂

[@k0okie878]

JAEHYUNS VOICE CRACKING AT THE START GIVE ME LIFE 😍😍

[@resuri_]

K0okie SAME

Taeil is awesome, he's singing and hitting high notes literally putting any effort, he's just that good! He's a real singer

[@dorafengy]

I hearrr Jaehyun harmonisinggg in the chorusss!!! Sooo greattt 😁😁😁❤️❤️

[@Linaaaa1104]

I think I made a mistake listening to this song with earphones on with high volume. Doyoung's high pitch blasted my ears... BUT I LOVE THE SONG AND THEIR VOICES ❤️

[@ambadyrkumar]

Jaehyun is a baritone. This song is in the tenor range means it's out ouf his comfort zone but yet he still killed it despite being sick... I only stan talented people.❤️❤️

[@진주별-o3q]

도영이 목소리 너무 이프다

[@암흑과설탕]

Moon Tae-il.... His voice is like moon tale~