New Criminal Laws Worse In Matters Of Arrest, Remand & Bail? Sibal, Rohatgi & Singhvi

[@vinodpunj3102]

Being grateful to the trio of discussion on the criminal justice system in India, I wish a brightly successful future for the Live Law channel. It’s a noble idea to enhance the know how of common people as well as the practitioners and students of law, justice, and public order. Special Thanks to stalwarts (all esteemed people) (such as) Hon. Kapil Sibal, Hon. Mukul Rohatgi, and Hon. Abhishek Manu Singhvi. Regards also to all those who are watching, analysing and commenting here. It’s a wonderful idea !!

[@BharatSrivsatav]

rather than coming to the crux, vinod punj's take away is success of the channel. Col Purohit was in jail for 9 long yrs, went through several coercion & tortures to admit the crime, which he never committed. This is well documented in this book & Mr Sibbal and P Chidambaram were at the helm of affairs

[@vinodpunj3102]

@@BharatSrivsatav Thanks for interaction. Before I go ahead with a reply, please Identify yourself for a convenient dialogue !

[@raravamudan4002]

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused.

[@kratisaran417]

Very fruitful discussion, I have myself experienced how conspiracy,false arrest can impact a person's life, one does not get a lawyer especially if you're poor to help and that false arrest not only affects the person but the lives of people associated forever damaging more lives.

[@sushantkumar4255]

I request to conduct more discussion alike with the legal giants ❤

[@subhudadhich8548]

Very good points. People are arrested easily, denied bail easily and years of harrashment in the name of investigation 😢

[@anjalipandeymishra1545]

I am not a lawyer, but I still watch legal content to gain clarity on how to interpret something.

[@jhakku1401]

It affects all of us.

[@ramkanwargulia8205]

Very interesting and enlightening group discussion on crucial Legal aspects of the draconian Legislative amendments made in the Criminal laws in the recent past interalia. Vidusham vasham vadah. Swasti Om Sham

[@abhishekyadav-de9jj]

when you people talk, i feel relaxed in terms of intellectual peoples like you will take us out from the worst phase(Which is the current phase) the country is facing , may god provide good to all of you who are trying to make the change and make things right

[@toufiqueuddin9997]

Very much relevant and eye opener about faults and damages.

[@pps1223]

Beautiful! even a novice to legal matters can understand and relate to. Thank you!

[@omprakash-tq1pd]

Commendable Debate, it ought to be in public domain most probably in the larger interest of citizen.

[@mundranageswararao9330]

🙏 thanks to all. Kapil seibalji is doing good for country.

[@Vedangi_]

Beautiful explained why the burden of judiciary is not decreasing in our country.

[@devilbaba.....]

Excellent discussion Legal luminaries like you who really concern about law and fare judgement is the hope of innocent people. Great work ❤❤❤

[@vidurann2193]

Thank you very much sirs for the great effort to clear the loop holes and fog in the system...🙏

[@gurlaldhillon9836]

Very good discussion it is very necessary legal system to be discussed

[@drsubhankhan7736]

Bahoot badhiya programme, thanks to eminent advocates including Kapil Sibble je, Singhvi je and Rohatgi je.Indian feel proud of you people -Dr Subhan Khan Ex Chief Scientist CSIR-NISTADS Govt of India and Founder Patron MDSIndia

[@KanchhiSingh-ky6ov]

Thanks for keeping us update.

[@prakashlaxman1144]

Excellent knowledge sharing helpful to layman End of the day how do we make sure an innocent is not harassed

[@raravamudan4002]

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused.

[@aayushsahay1]

This trio Very well apprised everyone with the prevailing judicial system and the structural change in the criminal justice system

[@pathtohappiness4711]

These legal luminaries are giving the best to the public at large is great. Thanks from Lanka Dr Jayantha Pathirana a Lawyer

[@raravamudan4002]

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused.

[@avq512h]

Excellent initiative by Kapil Sibbal for bringing up the issues plaguing our justice system. Good discussion and great panelists... More power to you guys!

[@polisettybalavenkatakotesw3223]

very very good dicussion you are all really asset of the nation

[@rajendhrana5883]

Wonderful discussion you were all assets indian laws long live for the sake of thecountry

[@ajitabhkumar4235]

Something is rotten in the state Indian Judiciary. Where INDEPENDENCE of judiciary has become a shield to protect IMCOMPETENCE of judges. Today, our judges have become more executive minded then the executive. We need to have fiercely independent, morally upright and intellectually competent judges in Supreme Courts and High Courts to serve as role models.

[@libshastra]

Judiciary has essentially become a new Jati. They marry each other, talk big things with each other, select each other to work in positions of powers under their authority. That’s the rotten thing. They tell us to be less castiest and they themselves have created their own.

[@sujitnanda3641]

Very thoughtful Discussion amongst Legal Luminaries, on important provisions ofLaw. Hope, to witness in future.

[@amitpandey7452]

​😊

[@vaishnavigosain7197]

Our judiciary was never a completely independent entity, there is interdependence of all three pillars, also it is easy to sit and criticize a relatively powerless position in an authoritative regime.

[@sameervora8854]

Excellent discussion on a very very important issue. Hopefully, judiciary introspects and does a coarse correction, to not let draconian laws be made and practiced.

[@smarajitbasu9662]

What pleasure listening to great minds! Well done Live Law and Kapil Sibal....fundamental issues of Liberty and Justice were discussed...need more such free flowing conversations where there is more light than heat generated👌👍

[@eshaanwahane3233]

This is thoughtful conversation by the legal luminaries and educative to budding lawyers

[@raravamudan4002]

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused.

[@ratcat07]

Excellently conducted interview, worth watching. Thanks a ton.

[@syedakramulla9304]

Excellent discussion...

[@paulm.k.8740]

We were a liberal democracy. We should remain a liberal democracy and all challenges to it should be pushed away.

[@gopalhembrom8242]

It's a very important discussion on legal implications.

[@osamaaziz511]

Dear Sur, Appreciate you all Learned I do think if its an Application of Mind of Concern as mandated by Law!; might be there is no cognizance in few!! Wish Happiness ahead!!🌺🌺🌺🌺

[@tushararora2699]

The most effective faces of the Supreme Court presently.

[@b.k.choudhary6443]

Very good discussion on criminal jurisprudence. ❤

[@subhudadhich8548]

Why should a person spend even a minute in jail without conviction?

[@rajashashankgutta4334]

Simple reason, they can run away or alternate witness/evidence or pose a threat to society

[@ansarchaudhary8572]

Excellent views and very very beneficial discussion for legal fraternity

[@vishwakantsingha7689]

Dear sir waiting for listening and watching from country great lower and leaders lots of love and respect from our side save India 🇮🇳,

[@drsuratsingh2348]

Great discussion. Let's have more such discussions.

[@surendervaid1445]

Thanks Kapil sir apne itne important issues per discussion arrange kiya..thanks once again

[@AjayVarghese-o2y]

I agree gravity of offence can never be ground for denying bail, and cooperation also cannot be ground for denying. As far as accused does not interfere with investigation and tamper evidence and does not flee then the person is entitled to bail. To get remand police must tell to magistrate what police wants to do with accused. All interrogation must be in camera.

[@BharatSrivsatav]

when these provision of PMLA and Nyay samhita were not there; Mohd Atiq Ahmad, Mafia don, ex MLA & MP from UP got his first conviction for the FIR filed 40 long yrs back; would be happy, if they had address the lacunae of implementation of law there

[@atanuroychoudhury3522]

Great Discussion! Great Panel! Such display will certainly arouse interest in law in young indians also will enlighten normal citizens about whats going on.

[@SanjayBhate-v1f]

Very informative. Thank you Kapil ji.

[@drdipakrmbbs1473]

Respected Sibal Sir, Respected Singhvi Sir, the points raised are absolutely valid, but the question is what have you done when you were part of Government ? What stopped you from amending the CRPC ? Would you like to publish the data regarding implementation of the Hon'ble SC directions in D K Basu, ( in letter and spirit) in the states where your party ruled ?

[@arvindkumarmishra5437]

It is the most welcome stand I found from your discussion that every judge is referring to the higher judge for bail. It is a curse for the judiciary. Very very respect to all you legendary.

[@AyanshPaul-e6f]

Superb discussion on basic need .every body might come across these laws in his life.

[@gurparvinder]

Its wonderful to see the legal luminaries discuss important matters. All are exceptional legal eagles. Wish more such discussions take place

[@raravamudan4002]

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused.

[@kuldeepmansukhani3701]

Excellent discussions touching the roots of the criminal jurisprudence.

[@MysticalLibraries]

Great discussion and learned your esteemed perspectives on criminal proceedings in the judiciary.

[@senthilkumarpanneerselvam6657]

This channel is one of the most Informative , Academic & Useful Channels on KZbin.

[@AbrashidLone-ej4bi]

U r n my opinion historiccally contributing to the reformation f the system.highly impressed.

[@dr.bhimraobandgar2069]

Sibbal Sir , you are doing great work of bringing together best brains for such important legal discussions.

[@gogikarjawahar6907]

Very useful dibet for Indian Judiciary......

[@govindbichile9179]

Excellent and holistic information by the experts in the field Congratulations .

[@aditshrivastava1792]

Excellent Topic & Excellent Views & Discussion. One can only hope that Supreme Court CJI remedies the system, laws.

[@person_x5868]

Highly appreciate this discussion as a young lawyer from the other side of the border.

[@abhaykumarsrivastava7715]

Very informative video and discussion

[@iqbalafinwala9008]

Great feedback on grass roots confusions of 3 new laws. thanks for your support to advocates and people... Advocate Afinwala from Bharuch Gujrat...

[@sumitghosh8141]

Three gems of Indian Legal Profession.

[@rajivbhatti5263]

Its wonderful giants legal conversation 👏

[@gvsobhanadri1596]

Mr. Mukul is right on point. An ordinary citizen of India is not bothered about rights of LGBTQs or Electoral Bonds. He is bothered about his life and liberty. Unfortunately the Hon'ble Supreme Court thinks otherwise.

[@InderjitSinghFGS]

A very good discussion about the rights of people

[@rajkishoretripathy7325]

Insightful and informative discussion indeed.

[@joseeralil117]

Enlightening discussion

[@supersaiyan-goku-san]

Great interview and discussion, i do hope the supreme court stops the new draconian laws from being implemented.

[@vickychaudhary3097]

Kapil Sibal raises crucial issues... and the way he speak is fantastic.

[@alaysheth5023]

Amazing video ! Thank you for sharing this kind of videos ! Love it !

[@kkshukla6303]

Sir ji, Frist chargesheets must be examined before the start of the case ie before going to एसडीजीएम it should be postmortem by one एडीजे,so that error of चारशीट्स must be removed

[@guruprasadshetty4133]

Thank You Sir ,

[@garvitagarwal1447]

Gravity of offence at the time of bail application, is actually tested by courts on daily basis. Difficult faced by each of us in courts.

[@VijayKumar-gm7vt]

Very Informative for every advocate if u want to enjoy the conversation listen in slow motion

[@bafo1912]

Grounds of arrest should only be made in case of person committing a grave breach of law. Arrest & Bail must go hand in hand. Hence, bail must be mandatorily granted immediately after arrest.

[@rajeshkbardhia9013]

Very insightful discussion

[@raravamudan4002]

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused. Liberty for the accused is the priority not the victim. The more comfortable a criminal is with law the more liberal the country. Who is comfortable with courts the criminal or victim just find out .

[@gowherrauf1476]

Kapil Sibal sir, You should also discuss with a distinguished panel about re- organising constitution- few weeks from now??

[@SSharma-fj8vd]

Great 👍

[@Debkumarchatterjee-bj7sd]

Very valuable and having great learning from the legal luminaries!

[@tigervixa3472]

Thank you it's a high time things n rule be amended also if petty matters be quashed at the complaint stage itself Sr officer hope goes through the diary everyday n is aware of the matter in its jurisdiction n keep an eagle eye on crucial / severe case matters also if I may suggest ever police station is clubbed together as our bank system where one deposits a cheque

[@heera8122]

Excellent sir and good conversation

[@tejashwani6402]

Gr8 discussion cant wait for next episode .mr sibal lately hav became a great podcaster with a string of latest interviews n discussions... when wil in india the judgement time of cases will be fixed ...

[@asaithambi6291]

Individual's liberty is not considered by courts- I like Rothaki sir's observation

[@raravamudan4002]

Cases run for 30 to 40 years no judgement only dates and fees for lawyers your discussion is not for common man but for accused.

[@EngineerGamer]

Need the three to discuss again, it is very informative

[@dbasannar]

Respected degnatries, if a group of thoughtful individuals like you were apolitical, I believe India might become the most powerful nation on earth. You lose value if you align yourself with a certain political party. The moment has come, in my opinion, to take up arms against these political parties, whose influence has grown beyond our wildest dreams. Since independence, things have developed to the point where we have become obedient to these formidable forces.

[@mohanrambha4763]

Being the Seniormost Advocates of Apex Court, Indian Bar Council thrust upon Apex Court to comply the Doctrine of Basic Structure of Constitution while Amending Criminal Justice Administration laws.

[@venkateswararao9440]

Live law is organising great debates which would be beneficial to legal community and all interested in law. But these three legal luminaries always differ in supreme court in their cases on behalf of clients, 😀

[@shivangjain773]

Wonderful pure treasure. Thank you sir.

[@kkshukla6303]

Discussion are fruitful but who will start the process of doing so

[@lovenishthakur8254]

Thank you all for this wonderful du Discussion

[@majorchandrashekharkaushik3244]

Why criminal laws be relaxed to suit the criminals rather tightening them to reduce crime rates.

[@sandeepshah105]

Laws should be based on fairness, not punitive until the crime is proved.

[@JEWELSOFSATARA]

Oh what a delicious treat to have Thanks live law

[@Gamingmx-f3j]

When you're culturally uprooted, you might become a lawyer, a doctor, engineer or a bureaucrat but you never become a civilised human being. And that's when, tyrants become the leaders and fools occupy the position of commanders.

[@aakankshakambli7714]

Enlighting subject with this kind of trio💯

[@subhashwasnikar4088]

Good discussion

[@brown_bread_]

I really like these converations. Both per cntent and around the 45 minute mark in duration

[@adityaprakashdevdogra8657]

Excellent discussion. Raises and makes aware of somr very worrisome shortfalls in our laws. Among the foundational changes required in the indian law structure n laws.

[@Rajat0607]

Great discussion, highly informative.

[@honourableadvocate3499]

India needs a revolution.

[@samirbhuyan6830]

Very nice discussion, thanks a lot

[@balasankaralingam946]

I feel that the constitutional benches should have the strength of 50% from eminent Sr. Advocates from Supreme court Bar and also a separate wing need to be formed with appointment of Addl. Judges only to dispose off the cases referred to constitution benches without any delay.

[@LegalAdvisor-w4q]

Nice to see 40 minutes debate over some important issues!

[@a2g484]

To be honest, Mr. Rohatgi appears to be a man with good intentions at heart, with bonafide he became the attorney general during the first term of the government, but having seen what was coming in the next four years, he declined becoming solicitor or attorney general and went back to private practice. His legacy wouldve been tarnished by the cases Tushar Mehta is presently fighting for the government . But there are some invisible strings still at work on him. He appeared for the election officer in Chandigarh. Has anyone asked , how an election officer could afford Mr. Rohatgi to represent him when his fees is 10 lakh plus? Of course he was paid by the government to do damage control. But watching him come out on a neutral platform to say what he thinks is specifically wrong with the laws and the misuse of it speaks volumes.

[@nikhilspeaking]

A notable case changes the law or its practice. It is understandable that a notable lawyer would appear in such a matter.

[@VenkateswararaoAla-ke9en]

Those laws are applicable to our beloved leaders MOSHAH