MAISON MARGIELA WHISPERS IN THE LIBRARY FRAGRANCE REVIEW | WHISPERS IN THE LIBRARY PERFUME

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

😍Watch Favorite Maison Margiela Fragrances Video here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qnqUgX2Dfax7ptE 😍

[@cyber6sapien]

Sebastian, your channel is both entertaining and depressing for me at the same time. The entertaining part is obvious, because you do such an excellent job with your reviews. But it's also depressing because I have thought about starting my own fragrance review channel as well. But you do such an awesome job that you've set an impossibly high standard ! LOL!

[@beelarehman5992]

I want this based on the name alone

[@Flosseveryday]

I know, right? I read so much, so the name caught my attention. ✌️

[@hayleysmith5077]

The Name and scent is Georgeous 🌷

[@UnknownChap]

The replica line is quickly turning out to be one of the most consistent lines releasing high quality fragrances one after another. Great to see a high standard maintained 👏

[@stefgyzels5977]

Which ones do you got :D?

[@UnknownChap]

@@stefgyzels5977 I own jazz club , by the fireplace, sailing day and beach walk but I've tried a few others two.

[@Symphony85p]

Imo whispers maybe the best in the line the smell is really good.

[@roseandjones8390]

I've just sampled this for the first time, and it's knocked By The Fireplace from the top spot. Absolutely love it, it's like nothing else I own. I agree that it's a soft experience but it also has a lot to say but not in a bold way. I'll certainly be purchasing it 🖤

[@aaronvelazquez5599]

I love reading and old libraries I can't wait to smell this one. Edit: I finally smelled it and I have to say I'm a little disappointed, it mostly smells like a sweet vanilla and slightly woody but mostly sweet. Which in consequence it tends to incline into the generic side.

[@Flosseveryday]

Thanks for the update man!

[@brian95240]

I've got Under the Lemon Tree, Jazz Club, By the Fireplace and just yesterday, Whispers in the Library. It was like at 1st sniff. I too smelt the booze. For minute I almost smelled a hint of mint and very light, raw leather, behind the Tonka. To me, it is more complex than Jazz Club. It will take some time, to see where it ranks, within the lineup. Lemon Tree is a love so far.

[@stayfreshproductions]

Sounds fantastic. Great review.

[@sharbelabuwarda5216]

Hey Sebastian love your review this fragrance is amazing! it smells niche & expensive Gives me Chanel vibes!!! I literally get the old library, full of books and papers with non-scented candles burning and dripping on them. so high quality, very well blended it’s unique, it’s soft and There’s nothing that smell like this one! Simply amazing

[@MrPmoore10]

Whispers in the library my favorite one so far

[@fatbrad412]

It’s a cold day in Pittsburgh and I’m wearing By The Fireplace! One of my favorites ever. Such a delicious fragrance. I can’t wait to smell this one!

[@witch13itch]

Hello neighbor. 🖤💛

[@Tomatohater64]

I love this entire House. Will definitely try this one.

[@jjimenez8430]

This house is really becoming one of my favorites.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

It's certainly got some winners for sure! :)

[@IAmCharliemouse]

Lol. I just bought this yesterday in Harrods. It definitely smells of some old book shops I know in London, and even a little bit of my own library. I bought it for my wife who is definitely a bookworm and she loves it. Also own Music Festival and By the Fireplace.

[@InfinitegardenbyBethK]

I just tried it tonight for the first time. I bought a travel spray size of this and Beach Walk. It’s gorgeous. Warm, dry and even a little sunny in the dry down. Really nice on my skin.

[@kilipaki87oritahiti]

I wish they had this in an intense version or EDP. I stopped using it solely due to the fact that it’s longevity is very poor. For the price point which isn’t even bad for a 100 ml, I expected more in terms of it lasting longer than it does. I love woody, sweet, spicy scents. This one is to die for. That’s how good it smells...love everything about it, the theme, the the bottle, except no cap, which means I can’t travel with it. Even though I like sweet (vanilla, orange blossom, neroli, tonka beans etc) scents, I don’t care for overly sick, bubble gum, synthetic shit. This one is luckily not like that!

[@dawnf2z1]

I’m loving this fragrance and it lasts beautifully on me and my clothes. I have worn it with Not a Perfume (from Juliette Has a Gun). Lots of compliments, so its great that other people enjoy it.

[@aaronbrown0417]

Sephora got a package deal for 0.34ml travel sprays of jazz club, by the fireplace and whispers in the library.... for 66 bucks so you get 3 fragrances in the package. By the fireplace n jazz club was in my wishlist so I'll see how it smells Wednesday

[@hayleysmith5077]

I study philosophy at the university And simply adore the smell of books , I have bought the fragrance few days ago , the fragrance is just magic makes you jump back in time you immediately feel Victorian mood , look forward to purchase the fresh margiela fragrances you suggested in your adorable PRO videos ! I live in Tuscany sir come over to Florence and visit “ acqua flor “ close to basilica is Santa Croce , they produce their niche fragrances the store is such a vintage place full of wooden furnitures , try my favorite “Corp diplomatique” Thanks for sharing 💐

[@djsilent01]

I purchased there sample pack at Sephora. And I LOVE this dry down. But I also blend it with a small spray of Jazz Club and it’s just delicious. So smooth and chill fragrance for a person like me. I really want to buy a bottle.

[@kilipaki87oritahiti]

I just got this on a whim today. Been looking for a new perfume. Initially I wanted the Dior Sauvage, men too bitter. I prefer really musky, spicy and sweet. not much into floral or anything citrusy as it reminds me of dishwashing soap, or cleaning in general. Ironically I wanted a lavender perfume, but can't seem to find anything that is pure lavender. I had a sample from Fragonard which made me hooked, but they didn't sell it on their website. In stores here in Oslo Norway, it was either Malone, or another brand, but none of them smelled lavender to me. Today I just happen to go to the same store again with some friends. I just happen to see this particular one, sniffed it, and fell in love. Exactly what I was looking for. Besides lavender lol. My all time favorites are: Jean Paul Gaultier 2, Dior Homme Eu de Toilette, and Gucci Pour Homme II.

[@MehdiScent]

Great unique names they have 👍 thank you for sharing

[@petbull7038]

This house has so many fragrances that interest me but I've yet to try any. I plan to smell library, beach, fairgrounds and bubble bath. Great review!👍

[@carrotlyn]

Beach walk is one of the few 3.4oz bottles I’ve emptied. Absolutely gorgeous scent!

[@petbull7038]

@@carrotlyn since i wrote that comment I've purchased beach walk, at the barber and lipstick on for my wife. I really like BW and LO but I don't care for Barber's that much.

[@patriciaburroughs]

I got this as a sample from Sephora. The vanilla and sweet struck me as the opposite of what I'd expect from an old library, and thus I really didn't like it. But I just spritzed it on myself [instead of the air] and will give it a chance.

[@1976LFonseca]

I’ve been waiting for this review! 😍

[@hafsabegum9316]

I just blind bought it and I can't wait to smell it

[@stuntmanjohnny]

I just picked up a bottle from a estate sale. It was still in a sealed box and wasnt sure if I was going to like it. I checked out your video and now I am excited to wear it. I wasnt blown away at the first smell, but I didnt spray it on. I am glad to hear the magic happens on the dry down. I'll throw it on tomorrow to get a full feel for it thnx.

[@thehiddenabditory3168]

How do you feel ab it now?

[@stuntmanjohnny]

@@thehiddenabditory3168 I enjoyed it. It does dry down to a more manageable scent. It’s a winter wear for me. So I’m not wearing right now during this summer heat.

[@marymccullough377]

Yay for the unisex! I'll be checking this one out. Thanks!

[@televisionhasafever7921]

Im gonna save my money and buy that because i love the smell of library smells elegant

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Great!

[@Farfignewton29]

I bought under the lemon trees for my wife about a month ago. She loves it and was wearing it every day until her hands started randomly breaking out in hives. I think she may be allergic to something in it, perhaps the lime. Looks like I’ll be taking new ownership of it lol

[@Symphony85p]

Juste got my bottle WOW didnt expect it to be that good. This is up there with by the fireplace maybe even better. Much better smelling than jazzclub imo. Great vid 👍 thanks

[@lisanguera1492]

This fragrance is so unique and beautiful! Thank you for videos, they are very helpful and informative for me when I’m looking to try different perfumes for myself and others. 💕

[@sirchucky9067]

I really like this one! I got a decant of it, might get a full bottle after I get done with the sample. I also got all three of Robert Graham on a discounter site. I really like all three, smelled them after your suggestion...

[@michaelbullock8011]

Great review and I enjoyed it and I'm gonna try it have a blessed day

[@boyetperez169]

Yep! Agreed. At the end of the day, it’s all bout the dry down.

[@d.s.6221]

Are you aware of their two latest offerings? Coffee Break & Springtime in a Park? They keep up they may rival Tom Ford in the niche/not niche fragrance space lol

[@GEORGIA385]

The best in this range for me is by the fireplace and springtime in a park but whispers sounds very nice too

[@caseyplunkett6083]

Maison Margiela is my favorite designer house followed by Velentino. Sailing Day from Margiela smells much better than the much more expensive 40 Knotts from Xerjoff, which happens to be my favorite niche house.

[@bryancastater2337]

Thanks for the review. I like several of the fragrances in this collection. I have by the fireplace and I’ve been trying to figure out which one I want to get next. So many people like jazz club over this one and I just don’t agree. I 100% agree with you...I’ve been trying out both of them and like you I like this one better. I love the notes for jazz club but I just don’t really get them when I smell it. I’m really disappointed with jazz club not that it smells bad. It just doesn’t smell like you would think based on the note breakdown. Where as this one I do get the booziness along with the woods and the vanilla even though it doesn’t have it in the note breakdown. The dry down is great! I think I’m going get whispers in the library first and probably across sands and then maybe jazz club.

[@hannahyalea]

I like the scent, it’s pleasant, but it doesn’t wow me and doesn’t particularly give me any library or bookish vibes. It also seems to have very poor longevity on my skin. I love the concept and the bottle, however. I know this is discontinued but it’s still for sale on some discounter websites… still torn on whether I want to buy it or not.

[@apartirdelos50s32]

I need this in my collection! So I already order it 🎊 😊 Thanks!

[@Dania.x.x.x]

im for sure getting this soon!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Bummer I believe it’s discontinued

[@Dania.x.x.x]

@@ThePerfumeGuyactually it’s still available in Germany :)

[@otejiriagbodoroba]

A very unique brand. Nice to see you Sebastian.

[@burningStereo]

I love the line and am thinking about blind-gifting this to my bff who is a librarian 😁

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

That's awesome. It would make a great gift! :)

[@discoveringnewt]

I Love love love jazz club. If this is close , maybe I’ll give it a whiff. Heading to Sephora today! I only wish it was a EDP

[@Symphony85p]

Smells much better than jazzclub imo.

[@appuscheri5587]

reminds me guerlain tonka imperial. good one but reduntant with that similarity

[@Kalima1231]

Sebastian, I have By the Fireplace, which I love and my wife doesn't unfortunately, but I haven't tried any of their other offerings. Was a little disappointed by BTF performance. Is it similar with their other fragrances? Am a huge reader so Whispers really appeals to me and from what you said the longevity is good. And the soft experience is fine too. Thanks for reviewing it and will have to check it out. Yet another enjoyable and informative video!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

These are EDT so the performance is all over the place similar to other fragrances. I would suggest testing first.

[@abdelsarkis3854]

Love the house. Prefer Jazz club over by the fire place. Maybe I have to revisit fireplace. The only thing I don't like about the house it's the size of the bottles. The pricing it's all right, but I have only seen 100 ml and 10 ml. A 100 ml it's a lot for some of this fragrances. I would like to see 50 ml or even 30 ml. Speak to them Sebastian 😏.

[@witch13itch]

I was just thinking the same thing when I was fragrance shopping online. The best is when a brand offers 10ml, 30ml, 50ml, and 100ml, 200ml. Atelier Cologne does. Probably why I own more from them than any other house. Other brands should take note.

[@jonathanjosephbernard5468]

love your reviews Sebastian !!

[@JohnDoe-iu7gt]

I love the line I have by the fireplace, jazz club, At the barbers, under the lemon trees, sailing day. But not a big fan of this one

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Darn it! :(

[@kristenpotter7100]

I love their fragrances so much, but they just do not last on my skin. I wish they’d come out with an EDP. Love your comment about how old books don’t smell like this fragrance, haha. I used to work in a library for years, and though I love the smell, it isn’t something I’d want to wear. I’ll have to check this one out nonetheless.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Darn that they do not last on you! :(

[@edgervantilborg7268]

Got it last week and LOVE it … and your discription is perfect. Still prefer by the Fireplace and Jazzclub.Bought it after seeing your videos. But.. also got beachwalk.. and… find it a really disappointing fragrance.. don't understand the many positive reactions on this one.. However.. I love maison margiela !!!

[@robinbrennan4561]

Thanks Sabastian. I’ll check it out!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

For sure, thank you for stopping by. :)

[@realblackbetty2204]

This and fireplace are my fav

[@OlfactiveStories]

One more on my wishlist ! 😁

[@arezentes]

Great reviews!

[@nassimba1]

very good! would try it out soon. TXXX :)

[@eleanormcdonald615]

Someone described it as the softer version of By the Fireplace. Do you agree?

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

This is more vanilla and woods but I can see that yes! :)

[@annaanna7456]

Thank you❤❤❤

[@ScentitarFragrance]

Sounds fantastic !!!! I have been interested in this and hope to get visit a Nordstrom soon.

[@musicforall1859]

Love that fragrance

[@jesserivera1814]

Gorgeous scent but the worst longevity. I really wanted to love this :(

[@amrmagdy6768]

sounds fantastic can't wait to try it... thanks for the review .... can you do a review of van cleef and arpels bois dore ?!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

I featured Bois Dore in this video but perhaps I'll review it soon. Thanks for suggesting it! :)

[@amrmagdy6768]

Ok thank you very much

[@MsKKae]

I can’t get enough of this line!! 😍

[@TKLalone]

I was so bummed because I had planned on ordering this from Sephora during their Spring/Summer VIB sale, but they pulled it from the website and you couldn't get

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

That sucks, Sorry about that! :(

[@devlin426]

Would u say this is a good scent for a teenager? Like to wear in school ?

[@dheaaugy6206]

Seriously.. im looking for a perfume that similiar with book store's fragrance. Cause i love it.. gonna get this one soon.. and if u have some reccomendation please let me know 🙏🙏

[@sandrasmith1035]

I’m just seeing this vid 10/17/20. I purchased this from Sephora and it arrived Thursday 10/15 This is a twist. It’s rather light. I normally go for heavier or projecting fragrances IT SMELLS SO GOOD!!! TO MY NOSE. It smells like it said, sweet wood and paper👍🏾👍🏾👍🏾 This will be another dumb reach for Me, like Molecule O1 was. I like this better than jazz club also.

[@alexisp.7115]

Which would you say has a stronger woody scent? By the fireplace or this one? I’m torn between getting either one so I’m not sure which pick.

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

This to me is more woods with black pepper and vanilla. I would have to compare the woodiness but I think this is more woody than Fireplace! :)

[@colinhuang2325]

I love the name

[@ullull3831]

for me its smells like a better version of tom ford ff

[@juliefeathers]

Can’t wait to get my nose on this one !!! Wondering how the lipstick one smells as well ! Plus have you tried the fantasies line from them ?

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Here's the Lipstick On review: kzbin.info/www/bejne/rKSlh6ipmLt4r7M

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Here's a video of my 13 favorites ranked featuring the Fantasies collection: kzbin.info/www/bejne/qnqUgX2Dfax7ptE

[@michaelprince7825]

This fragrance sounds really good based on how you describe it...especially since some of the notes aren't listed. I will have to try this one out for sure.

[@madebyreuben3402]

It was too creamy and sweet on the dry down for me, lost all woody notes

[@itsmebius8092]

I actually just blind bought the by the fireplace scent and unfortunately I am pretty disappointed by it.I smell to much balsam and it really lacks the sweetness that everyone was raving about.Would you still recommend this scent? :)

[@pascalledouven38]

Do you also have a video about more off the new releases from this house

[@piruncute]

Hey, I bought this today. But I am not really sure if it is authentic. I would like to ask if the description at the back of the box are printed in justified texts? Is inside the box has a letter comes along? I checked my friend's Replica "Jazz club" and the description are written in Center alignment and it has a letter inside the box. But I did not see a letter in this Whisper in the library box? Or just because this one had has released long ago that they did not have the letter? Also, the sole of the bottle has a small circle hole and a sticker in the middle with black batch code 62SD0YB and and a carved number 3 in backward style. Please help. I do appreciate that. Thank beforehand.

[@robertpatterson8889]

So should I purchase now or wait till cooler weather. N if I have Chanel Allure Homme Edition Blanche do I need under the lemon tree??

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Lemon is totally different than Edition Blanche. Not redundant! :)

[@janelleroman9575]

But does it last? I loved it but I didn't apply on my skin.

[@erwinhuang7223]

Hey, great review man! A big fan of Margiela replica line here. So far owned 5 of them and planning to get 'Whispers in the Library' next! Have you got your hands on their latest release called 'Bubble Bath'? If so, looking forward for your review. Keep up the good work 👍

[@itsmeeeeeeeeeee]

Please please please get to the Aboslu Pour Le Soir review!

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Sooner than later! :)

[@susieklein7461]

Do yourself a favor and buy it! Do it directly from the MFK site thought. It’s a stunning fragrance!

[@MarcoAlessi]

Very inspired name

[@crashx8576]

For summer only?

[@9ntice]

Anyone recommends something similar to this (not by Margiela)?

[@9ntice]

A year later, I still don’t have a better one.

[@big-gloom]

Maybe diptyque eau delle or allsaints metal wave

[@fallguy6196]

Do you get amen pure malt from this ? I just got a sample from Sephora and man it smells like pure malt to me. I'll have to wait for the dry down but ...

[@fallguy6196]

Ehh dry down reminds me of Tom Ford noir/noir extreme like very powdery. Opening is nice like pure malt although not as good imo then the dry down is kind of blah to me. By the Fireplace is still my fav of the line.

[@hbmob112]

Great juice but definitely not better than Jazz club, slow it down lol

[@Tommelise]

very pleasant but too soft

[@MrAQL]

Love your videos sir i have buy one after watching your beast mode video and I'm so happy thanks for such awesome suggestions 💗👍

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Thank you for stopping by and appreciate the support! :)

[@Spiralnebel_GB]

This one smells so wonderful but the Sillage is so weak 😢 At the beginning there is a note i really enjoy but can not tell which one. How smells Cypriol? Any recommendation for a louder woody pepper vanilla fragrance? Jazz Club smells for me like Toothpaste or Root Beer. I don't get the hype

[@mbecky7414]

Love the unique names of Fragrances 😍 This brand is taking off👍 Love to smell this. Great review 👍 Thank you @maryjeannyc

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

Thank you! :)

[@katianna7306]

I just bought it . Blind buy lol

[@sailaabdullasaleh5278]

Please can you advise me if I would start to collect my first three which ones you advise me to start with advise me with three please if you don't mind

[@ThePerfumeGuy]

If you no experience then this video should help you out. kzbin.info/www/bejne/eH6cdGiCm9hsic0

[@BossBrookeArmstrong]

Only $126??? You say that as if that’s not expensive lol

[@MrPrentissDJones]

barneys new york is gone

[@puertoricanpapi2011]

Waiting for “Snuggle in Bed”

[@brandondac5528]

Angel Diaz Lazy Sunday morning?

[@mr.vlog572]

Do you think a guy could wear this?

[@christinakail]

This is my favorite scent, smells like sex in a museum

[@Flosseveryday]

How do you know wha.. nevermind 😅 Good for you ✌️😉

[@raytang76]

Shhhhhh......

[@shoelady6457]

😁👍

[@yoloswag6242]

spray it! smell it! FEEL IT. stop being so logical

[@Cocoakissedme]

I have “Under the fireplace”, “Coffee break”, and “Music festival” (which is my fave next to Fireplace). I just ordered “Whispers in the library”. I can’t wait 😊