Lost Puddle Fish Surfboard Review

Trip Forman reviews the ...Lost Puddle Fish Surfboard.

[@rpentecost]

I just bought one of these boards in carbon wrap, absolutely amazing. I was surfing 4-5 ft today with Chris Christenson keel fins only, goes so fast and holds and drives out of turns and makes all sections. Keep up the great reviews Trip!

[@RasKitchen]

Thanks for the great review Trip! Just got this board and realized my quad fins are all damaged, so good to know will still work with a thruster setup 🙌

[@denilsonbasilio8332]

Estou feliz de ter essa pranchinha muito boa!! Tmj sempreeeeeeeeeeeeeee 🏄😎

[@michaelkoonjy6978]

Hey guys, great review, helps a lot! How would you compare the puddle fish vs the puddle jumper squash tail in the way it rides? I'm deciding between these 2. And would you recommend the lib tech version or pu for each

[@michaelmcgrath5383]

Hey. Love your review vids. Lots of useful info. I'm 190lbs/86ish kg am in decent shape and have been surfing for 15+ years but now can go weeks without a surf. I have a 6'2" v3 rocket and was wondering what size puddle fish would be good for me to compliment the v3 as groveller. Any words of wisdom?

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Michael, thanks for commenting. Coming off of your 6'2 V3, you would be stoked on the 5'10 Puddle Fish. It has slightly more volume than your V3 and the foam is more condensed in a shorter board for better paddle power, speed, and maneuverability in small surf. We have a few in stock but check this one out www.realwatersports.com/lost-puddle-fish-pu-poly-5-10-39503

[@freedom_Jesus]

Hi team. I have a Puddle Jumper squash tail - best board ever. What would be the diffrence between this compared to the fish and also the round pin. Thnaks for your great videos

[@REALWatersports]

The Puddle Fish's wider tail creates more speed, while the tail creates less drag to give the Puddle Fish more speed and more acceleration out of turns than the standard and round tail puddle jumpers. The Round Tail features a little more rocker, more foiled rails, and the round tail to make this one work better in big surf.

[@Niko661]

Love the reviews. I've been watching them trying to figure out what board I need. Sounds like you're familiar with Puerto Rico. I live in San Juan, surf 3-5 days a week and need a board for la 8. Super slow, mushy wave most of the time, but I end up surfing it before work because it's 5 minutes from the house. I have a Lost V3 Rocket with a lot of volume (38L). It just doesn't get into the waves for me there when it's less than chest high. I switched with my buddy and rode his fish with the same volume and it was so much easier with the wide nose to paddle into the wave. What board would you suggest for that kind of wave without going full on longboard? I have the V3 for going out West to the faster hollower waves. (Machuca, Wildo, Domes Etc) I am 37, 5'7", 180lbs good shape, intermediate surfer. 🤙🏻🇵🇷🌴

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Niko, Thanks for writing in. We love surfing Puerto Rico and have surfed La 8 before. The Puddle Fish is a great call for that wave when it's under head high. You can ride the same volume as your V3 but if you really want to maximize small wave performance I would add a liter or two. All of our Puddle Fish with color and all other boards are $100 off today only: www.realwatersports.com/surfing/surfboards/lost/puddle-fish

[@juliennevers9943]

Hi guys, Firstly thanks for doing all this reviews that are very helpflul ! It helped me a lot for choosing my boards, even I though I cannot but it at yours since I m bases in south west France ... I am an intermediate surfer, 40 years, 6'3 225 lbs riding a "winter waves" board 6'8 at 45L. I usually surf 3-4 times a week I am looking for a board for summer waves and puddle fish looks great. What size would you recommend for me ? I hesitate between 6'1, 6'2, even 6'3, I did not go that shorter but heard the board has a great paddle power ...

[@REALWatersports]

Julien, the 6'1" at 43L would be a lot of fun if 45 L is your winter wave board, and would still give plenty of foam to catch waves easily. The 6'3" at 45L may feel a little more difficult to maneuver around at all. We don't have the Puddle Fish right now but we do ship to France, let us know if you ever need anything. Cheers!

[@Phaidrus]

Hey Trip, great board presentation (of your personal board, I noticed the "For Trip" on the bottom)! My groveler is a Bottom Feeder 5'10 x 22 x 2.63 stock dims @ 40lt. How does the Puddle Fish compare to the BF? And if I were to replace the BF with a PF, which size, 5'10 or 5'11? Thanks

[@REALWatersports]

Hello Phaidrus. The Puddle Fish marks more drawn out arcing turns and carries more speed down the line, while the Bottom Feeder likes to make more pivotal turns. If you like your Bottom Feeder and how it paddles you should go with the 5'11 Puddle Jumper at ~40L

[@Phaidrus]

Thanks for replying!

[@mtblues4620]

Hi Guys. Loving the review. I weigh about 200b (91kg) and am 6'0" tall. Currently riding a 6'2" x 21.1/2" x 2.2/5" fish. What size Puddle fish would you recommend for me? I have a 6'0" on order but was wondering wether to down size to a 5'11" (or smaller). Thanks in advance Matt.

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Matt, thanks for writing in. The 6'0 Puddle Fish is a good size as a small wave board at your weight. You could size down but you would need more powerful surf and would need to be in better position on the smaller board.

[@cbb5104]

Hey! Could you give me some insight as to how the Puddle Fish and the RV compare to each other? Looking for a board to add to my quiver that will grovel well in small waves and windy/bumpy conditions. Also, great videos, I'm gonna have to stop by the shop next time I'm in OBX.

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Chase, both work in a similar wave range but make different turns and have a different feel overall. The RV likes to make tighter angled turns, pivoting off the tail, while the Puddle Fish makes more fish style, arced out, carving turns. What other boards have you been surfing? We'd be stoked to get you dialed in on the right shape. Cheers - Ashlon

[@frezhtastic]

hey guys, i would like to extend my quiver. i'm mainly riding a 5'10 v2 rocket, what size would you recommend for mushy french days at 4ft up to good clean days with 5-6ft (181cm-5'11 and 72kg-158lbs)

[@REALWatersports]

Stoked to hear your building the quiver, to fill in below your V2 rocket we recommend a 5'8 Puddle Fish. Cheers - Ashlon

[@ramshoham2224]

What size would you receommend for someone 45 years old, surfing 4 times a year, intermediate and fit (not super fit though). Would a 5'11, 40L be too big? (my height 185cm, 77kg)

[@uluwatu77]

Good question

[@REALWatersports]

Ram, 40L would definitely be a lot of volume, but that could be ok. It's going to give you a ton of paddle power, and help get into waves early. It'll feel big if you are trying to throw some tighter turns, but if you're just looking to cruise the extra volume won't be an issue.

[@uluwatu77]

@@REALWatersports thanks. I definitely need help to get into waves early, but I don't want to compromise pumping and tight turns. What would you recommend? Perhaps a different model or just a smaller board

[@craigsteven5343]

Just wondering about sizing for the puddle jumper range, particularly the puddlefish. I ride a 6'5. 40.9L quiver killer as my alrounder. I can decide between the 6'2 and 6'1. 6'2 seems like a lot of volume at 44L.. but 6'1 sounds short. I've never ridden a board that short.. I still need some paddle power. I'm 6'1 and 240 pounds

[@REALWatersports]

Craig, We'd recommend the 6'1. Riding a shorter board is great when you have this much foam packed in. It will paddle really well with all that foam right beneath you and the shorter rail line creates less drag so the board takes off lightning fast down the line. Hope this helps - Ashlon

[@craigsteven5343]

Thanks so much

[@craigsteven5343]

Just wanted say thank you for your advise on the sizing of this board. I bought the 6'1 in PU. (Didn't purchase from you guys as I live in Australia. But for my weight and height the 6'1 is perfect at 43L. Not too big or too small.. it feel unreal! I absolutely love this board!

[@brunopalmieri3286]

Hey Craig, I’m intermediate and weigh 195. How do you like the puddle fish? Can it handle occasional 4-5’. I cant decide between the fish, the pj or the pjrp

[@jayzwingly8976]

Hey can you all do a review of the Sharpeye Disco Cheater and/or Roberts Metamorph... I'm looking for a new board that I can still ride like a performance board but in mushy waves down in Florida...

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Jay, Thanks for writing in. We don't stock Sharp Eye, but may be demoing the Metamorph in the future. You should check out the Lost Puddle Jumper. It's an excellent small wave board that rides on rail and turns like a performance shortboard. Cheers - Ashlon

[@eduardolarraz6510]

Hi guys! I have a lost v3 Rocket and I want to complete my quiver with puddle fish, is it a good option? or could be better Puddle Jumper Round Pin?. What would you pick having a V3 Rocket. Great channel!

[@REALWatersports]

Eduardo, the Puddle Fish will have more low end. If you're looking for a groveler to complete your quiver then that would be the way to go. If you want more of a hybrid shortboard feel, with a bit more range, the Puddle Jumper Round Pin would be a good fit

[@savanschaick]

I used to have a v3 and loved it! I'd go carbon wrap for the really small days if you do go with puddle jumper. The PU Puddle Jumper wasn't an amazing groveler to me. Otherwise that puddle fish looks loose and fun no matter the construction.

[@mitchel3580]

Hi! Thanks for the review. Really consider buying the puddle fish next summer but i'm not sure what size will suit me the best. I'm 6'0 ft tall and weigh about 77 kilograms. Currently riding an 6'4 hypto krypto shape (43 L). Most waves we get to surf in the Netherlands vary from knee to shoulder height so with that information, is it doable for you guys to give me any indication about which size puddle fish would be great for me for endless fun :) Thanks in advance!

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Mitchel, Thanks for commenting. How do you like your 6'4? If you are looking to keep the same paddle power you can size it the same but if you don't mind working harder you will experience more speed and maneuverability from a smaller board, in the 5'9-5'10 range,

[@mitchel3580]

Thanks for the quick response! Well, I do like my 6'4. It catches waves quite easily but isn't super maneuverable to be honest. I was already thinking about going smaller but the waves we get here most of the time are not very powerful. I don't wanna make the mistake about going to small and having the risk of missing too much waves. What do you reckon for something in between like a 5'11?

[@REALWatersports]

I think sizing down will be a lot of fun for you and the 5'11 is a good compromise.

[@ryantherock7664]

Hi guys...im 6'3 and 220lbs...i currently ride a 6'4 shortboard at 39L...which puddle fish would suit me?Im scared to go too short as i dont want to lose paddle power and wave catchability

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Ryan, The 5''11 at ~40L will be a great size for you. If you want even more paddle power go for the Carbon Wrap construction, its light weight and floats more, also faster down the line and through turns.

[@barnabyflynn965]

Did you try the MR twin plus tiny trailer?

[@IIIxwaveIII]

is this model also available in carbon wrap?

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Guy, We can have any shape from ...Lost made in Carbon Wrap. Just let us know the dims and any special color or construction preferences so we can get a quote for you. Give us a call [phone] or write [e-mail]

[@timosborne8174]

Another great review. Any chance you can review the new Lib-tech RNF?

[@REALWatersports]

Glad you're stoked Tim! We will be reviewing the Lib Tech RNF redux once we get enough time surfing it. Keep an eye on REALwatersports.com or subscribe to our channel so you are the first to find out.

[@timosborne8174]

REAL Watersports already subscribe. Watch most videos 2-3 times. Obviously have too much time on my hands. I currently have the 6'0 Lib-tech Short Round so was thinking of getting the 5'10 RNF. Do you know what the difference is in outline 12" down from the nose and 12" up from the tail so I can get an idea of shape. Thanks again for sharing your videos. Kind regards Tim, from South West Cornwall, UK 🇬🇧

[@REALWatersports]

Stoked to hear you are tuning in regularly. We'll get the dimensions and reach out via email shortly.

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Tim, looks like the RNF Redux by Lib Tech is 16" on the nose and tail. Drop us a line [e-mail] anytime with more questions.

[@mattyv75oc]

My everyday board I ride is around 29liters. I'm 5'11" 174. What size puddlefish off the rack would you guys recommend in this model?

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Matty, Thanks for writing in. Are you intending to surf this as your groveler in small surf below your 29L board or are you chasing the same waves? Where do you surf and how much of waves do you intend to ride this Puddle Fish in?

[@mattyv75oc]

Primary use would be as my groveler. Mostly surfing point and beach breaks around North SD county and OC.

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Matty, Go with the 5'6, the extra volume will help in weak surf but it's still low enough to turn well and be seriously rippable. www.realwatersports.com/lost-puddle-fish-pu-poly-5-6

[@mattyv75oc]

Cool, thanks for the info guys! and love all the webisodes! keep em coming

[@kylebraaten6840]

Would you recommend this for a new surfer or a older returning surfer

[@devinthrash]

Kyle Braaten i had an 8 year hiatus and the puddle jumper was absolutely perfect for getting back in the water. the puddlefish should work great, youre going to have a blast with it.

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Kyle, the Puddle Fish can work for either but we would rather see a returning surfer get on this shape and the new surfer get on a longboard for a faster progression.

[@craigsteven5343]

What what size board was Trent riding?

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Craig, Trip is surfing a 5'11 with pumped up dims to match the volume of the 6'0.

[@samuelpoucoen8379]

Hello.. currently i ride a biscuit, decided to buy a puddle.. im 5.6 and 168 pounds.. what size and liters do you recomend for me.. thxs!

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Samuel, What is your skill level, where do you surf, and what size is your Biscuit?

[@samuelpoucoen8379]

+REAL Watersports my biscuit is 5.8 ..20,1/4... 2,3/4 .. im a intermediate surfer .. usually surf 2-4 feet waves in dominican republic .. my height 5.6 and 168 weight... thanxs for ur help

[@REALWatersports]

Thanks for the extra info. If you like how your Biscuit floats and want to match that go with the 5'8. Alternatively if you want something a little more sporty and fast, the lower volume 5'7 is still within your grovel range and will turn faster and carry more speed down the line. Cheers - Ashlon

[@samuelpoucoen8379]

REAL Watersports thnx men!!

[@akinsl45]

Do you think straight up twin keel would work?

[@REALWatersports]

It depends on what feel you're going for. With this tail, it could totally work if you want a fast and skatey feel. If you prefer to have a more locked-in ride for turns that won't be ideal, but if you don't mind that, it could be really fun in smaller surf. Now you have me curious too, I'm gonna ask Trip if we can raid his stash and find this board.

[@akinsl45]

@@REALWatersports Lets go TRIP!!

[@gustgeorge2133]

@real watersports. Could you recommend a future quad fin set up for the puddlefish? I weigh around 175 and surf mushy Texas waves lol

[@REALWatersports]

Thanks for writing in, the Puddle Fish has quite the wide tail, and works great with the Futures Controller Honeycomb Quad's www.realwatersports.com/futures-controller-honeycomb-quad-fin-set-bamboo

[@AdrianRevueltaHD]

Very informative review, I was just wondering what size would suit me, I weigh 64 kg and 5'11 and I tend to tride longer boards (at 6'2 or 5'11) but what is the best size for a board like a puddle fish?

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Adrian, thanks for writing in. Sizing really depends on your skill level, and wave range. What size waves do you intend to surf this board on? And how is your surfing? Are you linking turns well? What sort of maneuvers are you working on? Cheers - Ashlon

[@AdrianRevueltaHD]

REAL Watersports I live really close to the french western coast so I tend to drive up there alot, I struggle the most in summer due to the waves being very irregular and mushy probably max wave size 2 ft

[@REALWatersports]

Hey Adrian. We recommend a 5'10. This is going to offer enough float to help you on those small mushy days, while still being fun to surf and easy to turn.

[@josephwiard6695]

Any in stock?

[@larsspicher2256]

dou you recommend it as one board quiver for indo?

[@REALWatersports]

You could, but it will limit the size and shape of waves that you can surf comfortably. I'd go with the ...Lost Quiver Killer for a one board Indo quiver.

[@larsspicher2256]

Thanks for the answer. I like Fish boards more than shortboards so is there a fish you would recommend me for indonesia?

[@REALWatersports]

@@larsspicher2256 Check out the Lost X MR Cali Twin, ton of fun and lots of speed www.realwatersports.com/collections/mr-california-twin