Reacting to BTS | Tiny Desk Concert - We are Bulletproof: The Eternal - Seesaw Live Performance

[@psychokitty71]

We Are Bulletproof: The Eternal was part of Festa 2020, when they were missing us and we were missing them. Using the video to take us through a journey of their entire careers up until Boy With Love made nearly every ARMY extremely emotional. This video literally had millions of people around the world in tears. This song and Louder Than Bombs are two of my favorite BTS songs ever. Also, the video is full of Easter eggs. When Yoongi is appears, he's holding his left shoulder. RM is drowning when the lights of ARMY first appear and help him to the surface. JK is washed away by a black ocean. A black ocean is when, as a gesture of disrespect, the audience turns off or hides their light sticks so, instead of a sea of lights, they see nothing but darkness. They've been subjected to that once or twice. They're standing in a circle, facing outward, like when they performed Born Singer. They're on stage, with J-Hope holding a trophy and all of them crying, like for the 2018 MAMA acceptance speech. They do something similar for the MV for Yet To Come, except it's live action instead of animated. All kinds of references in that one, too, but different. Like the statue that Jin interacted with in Blood, Sweat, and Tears, the train from Spring Day, and them sitting in chairs like they did in Just One Day. That one is a very emotional video, too, if you haven't seen it. I'm sorry, I've watched every BTS video that you've posted, but I lost track of which videos that you've reacted to.

[@johnnyblaze1098]

The whole point of TIny Desk is to showcase an artist's raw vocals and true talent. It's purposefully stripped down to do just that. What you're hearing are their raw vocals. Lil Jon's Tiny Desk is another example of this. BTS live vocals are THAT good. If you listen to their Coldplay's cover for Fix You, you'll see what I mean. GOD TIER VOCALS.

[@X5J2UY]

That's factually wrong. Tiny Disk also have plenty of sound engineers that touch up the overall vocals (and instrument sounds) afterward. There is a reason why TIny Desk performances sound extremely crisp. Why do you think that none of those videos can be watched live?! So while singers sing their songs live, there is still post-processing being done.

[@v.vlenmf05]

@@X5J2UY Yeah, in some of them but it's not these case, you can hear their breathing and change of techniques while singing, it's totally live. If the microphones have a filter it doesn't mean it's not live, it's just for the style of the song or the sound they want to bring. BTS is always live, the only times they weren't is because in the Kpop channels like inkigayo, m countdown, etc... they prefer PEEFECT shows and they edit their videos, some Idols talked about that, because people hate on them for that, but they don't have a choice of how loud it's going to be the BackTrack or if they need to do playback. The tiny desk, live performances, awards shows and concerts tours are always live in BTS content :)

[@X5J2UY]

@@v.vlenmf05 Again, I am not saying that it isn't live. Those just aren't their actual unfiltered vocals. An engineer/producer touches the performance up and cleans up any messes. Tiny Desk does it for every artist. BTS isn't the exception. That doesn't mean that the artists can't sing, but there is definitely some auto-tune or pitch-correction going on at certain points. You can even hear it in some instances with Jimin.

[@kailara3342]

@@X5J2UY Especially for Dynamite there's an effect on their mics for almost every performances of it but that's for the vibe/style of the song

[@pencraft3179]

Yoongi did an acoustic version of seesaw at his concert and it was like the highlight of my life.

[@SA01095]

Mics are always on. You can tell when the guys do adlibs in the songs. I love Yoongi’s Seesaw performance. It’s so cute! And I’m in love with his singing voice. 😍

[@Djlullaby22]

I loved this reaction! And maybe Seesaw wasn't that mentioned because it's so incorporated in our nature, I don't kow why I didn't recommend it either since Suga is my ultimate bias 😅 But I wish you could have seen army's reaction when Seesaw was presented live in a concert to us. We couldn't believe our ears and eyes! Yoongi was not also singing but dancing as well all by himself. Everyone was so shocked 😂

[@rafaelsmith5737]

Suga is really such a unique idol. Cause in Kpop you'd automatically expect Kpop idols to sing and dance. But when Suga do it, it's very surprising.

[@ardiansatria2952]

Bulletproof the eternal always makes me cry,this songs for army ...

[@susanhill2110]

Nope they are 100% live, they are just that good 😁😁💜 We are bulletproof:the eternal is the song that made me Army. 💜💜

[@marinal.]

yep yep

[@elizabethlalnunthari7248]

Seesaw is one of my fav. Suga songs......and the shy dance is so cute to me i just love him so much💜💜💜💜👑🔥

[@yoonjlnkook]

id love it if you reacted to the seesaw acoustic version yoongi performed during his d-day tour! he plays the guitar and everything.

[@LilMeowMeow-cp9lk]

I love your reactions to BTS so much😭💗.. I hope you will watch the son "Dear my friend" and "snooze" in the live performance on the last day of Yoongi's world tour. It is very emotional and Yoongi cried during the performance..The last day of Yoongi's world tour is something no ARMY can forget. We cried a lot during it 🥹

[@eiman23_27]

Coming after bts last live Already crying and we are bullet proof the eternal makes me crying more 💔😭

[@geekyreader34]

Seesaw is one of my favorite Suga songs. It’s so unlike Suga. The words to this song are awesome

[@lovemaze777]

Omg you should definitely watch Yoongi’s Dear my friend and Snooze performances on D-day tour final concert😭 but prepare for a lot of emotions

[@lunapigeon]

Its totally on my listtt, hope i can make the video soon😭😭

[@laurakubickova8777]

@@lunapigeon also, if u want to listen to more vocals of Suga, i HIGHLY reccomend People pt. 2, he is singing with IU, amazing vocalist😍 Suga singing is purity

[@patriciamurashige6879]

I was so touched when I first heard we are bulletproof eternal and saw the cute mv!! I tear up everytime too!! I feel their thoughts while going through everything they had to go through.

[@anggeeeee5390]

Please do react to 'Snooze' and 'Dear my friend' by suga..im so sure you would love this too.. thank you💜💜💜

[@ceres1snow]

27:00 I can’t wait for you to react to suga’s d-day tour. It’s a must need if you wanna hear seesaw acoustic live and more amazing vocals from him

[@lunapigeon]

Omg, i will do it as soon as i free myself up from work T.T it has been on my list for so longgg

[@ceres1snow]

@@lunapigeon no pressure! I love your reactions either way 💜💜 you work so hard to bring us amazing txt and bts content

[@v.vlenmf05]

I love this reaction, I identify with you so much in the reactions We are bulletproof: The Eternal is SO wholesome, I always get emotional listen to that song and BTS also, they cry so much in the On: E online concert in the pandemic :( They all really care, we are a family, they made sure to remember us that and they never ever broke their promises, they make sure that we understand the situations, feelings and everything behind, even when they feel like it can't be totally sincere (because that's how it works the industry). I feel they are the artist who most spent time in the fandom, Tae likes to watch ARMY vlogs in YT, Jungkook is always doing lives of 5 hours long, Jin is leaving monthly messages and letters that he recorded the last year to make sure he's with us in 2023, etc efc... I can put so many examples of them being our family and support💜😭 being an ARMY is really the best that could happened to me and your right, don't feel sorry for not being there before, because they find us when we need them, it really was like that to me💕💕💕

[@zaraa3803]

Yes it's LIVE, BTS hardly ever lip sync and they can also sing live when dancing. Jungkook is known for being the most stable and having good control.

[@reinranko]

I’m a recent ARMY but I have a friend who was ARMY since 2017, so I was aware when bulletproof eternal came out, and I really really liked the song. I told my friend, after having a quick listen to the top 50 BTS songs for her that We Are Bulletproof: Eternal was my favourite. And now that I’m ARMY the song is even more extra special.

[@davidaditya535]

Yeah this is live, you can hear their breath. BTS such a good performer that's why they won America music award with reason

[@sava9e266]

BTS GOATS OF KPOP Btw this was live like all their stuff

[@hind-l3i]

Yes please more BTS I love your reaction ❤💜

[@ssev4026]

The last song hits different after today's BTS live 🥺

[@nicolenelindholm6157]

You should see Serendipity and Like crazy of Jimin live. You are in for a treat. As well as Tony Montana of Suga ft Jimin. Rapping Jimin is awesome. JK's Time Square concert, Hobi's Lollapalooza, RM and Suga Strange live. V's Jazz night. Jin's Astronaut live with coldplay as well as his song Moon. Borahae.💜🪷

[@Bren.30]

Gracias por la reacción, Luna! A mi también me conmueve y me encanta We Are Bulletproof: The Eternal, es una canción preciosa 💜

[@biru-kelabu-0821]

I wish I were already ARMY for this performance, but I wasn't unfortunately. Hearing stories from older ARMYs, it sounded like the whole fandom had a meltdown when Suga performed the song live for the first time, hearing his vocals and seeing that there was choreography for the song! Even his members were fans of the performance. Suga has two songs where he sings, "Seesaw" and "Life Goes On" (Suga's version, not BTS's version). He performed "Life Goes On" while playing the piano (BTSPurpleYou). I love love love Suga's high notes in then opening verse of Life Goes On, especially in the live performance. This song has a special place in my heart. In BTS concerts, he sang "Seesaw" with choreography, but in his solo tour he performed an acoustic version with him playing the guitar (yzerfan25 or dltmdgh). Actually, there's one more time he sang a song, which was his cover of "It's Not Love if It Hurts Too Much" by Kim Kwang Seok in a livestream (emerson_army).

[@dchen8874]

it's definitely live! you can hear all their adlibs going on too there might be post processing on the video audio done to clean up the sound by tiny desk but overall it is live live. and yeah i can definitely relate with the standing up and dancing thing lol, i think i learned some of txt's chasing that feeling and bts' idol choreo before and whenever i hear the part i know i want to dance it lol yeah this was released september 2020 so during the pandemic and pretty much when you realize that covid was not gonna disappear during the summer like some people had expected it to. we are bulletproof the eternal is so beautiful and emotional, like an entire journey full of hardships along with army and promises of beautiful future to come...

[@LalaH-23]

Suga is my bias so it was fun to watch you react to seesaw. I am also a huge fan of we are Bulletproof eternal so I loved this reaction so much.

[@anitaherbert1037]

They are singing live but there is a live band and the premise of Tiny Desk is its live. There are various artists do Tiny Desk.

[@StephenTMK6203]

Love your reaction Luna❤ Note-crystal snow,best of me dance practice,magic shop live ,answer love yourself.

[@Frrr_al]

You can see live performance of we are bulletproof the eternal

[@kazishahedurrahman9926]

Spring Day is the song every time it hits so hard. If you didn’t listen Song So Hee’s cover of this song, you must listen to that. I am sure you will cry while listening it. She is a traditional Korean singer.

[@roundegotrip]

TXT just did their own tiny desk concert and it is amaaaazing

[@marinal.]

sweet

[@JuniChoice]

Don't just take recommendations. Look for it There are so many treasures hidden! 🤭💜

[@suzannahmontreal1051]

Luna! When you cry you look like Rudolf the little Reindeer ❤ Thank you for reacting to Suga Seesaw and the Tiny desk, what a good energy they give out 🎉. Buongiorno Bella 🪄✨️

[@lunapigeon]

Omgg Buongiornoo ahah, and thank you, my nose gets so swollen😭🤍 you are so sweettt

[@bethp12]

I would have to say Seesaw is one of my favorites 💜. Just love it! We are Bulletproof: Eternal is just that song to sing loudly in the car💜

[@dollykelley8098]

Thank you Luna. Beautiful reaction. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜

[@lunapigeon]

🤍🤍🫶🏻

[@bangtansonyeodan5217]

Can we just appreciate that even if u don't have time ur making time to put out content just for us ...ty ❤

[@coachyaya7006]

Jhope song MAMA live performance at wembley and RM song LOVE live performance at wembley mushlt watch too. Its epic 😍💜

[@Sunset553]

Hi, This tiny desk was my first tiny desk concert, too. I’m familiar with NPR, the US National Public Radio, though, so I understood what was happening quickly. Spring Day and We are Bulletproof No 1 also get me crying. I started with BTS with MOTS 7, so I recognized the Boy with Love but not most of the videos in between. Sorry, Idk what BTS to recommend.

[@hobiiiswifey3624]

We are Bulletproof eternal is my top Fan song from BTS, but all of them are beautiful but this hits different

[@lunapigeon]

I swear it's on another level T.T I still have to listen to the new one you all told me about, Take Two (?) Maybe, can't waittt

[@beanism12]

SEESAW!!!🥺🥺🥺 One of my favorite Yoongi songs. And yes WAB: The Eternal is just... wow. I know that song WILL be hitting different in 2024. I ALWAYS get emotional watching that music video.

[@Hbora0613]

Bts blue and gray and your eyes tell live performance are amazing 💜 please watch those too

[@user-cpaOT7]

En su concierto D-Day SUGA canta Sesaw tocando la guitarra. Es un momento muy emocionante!

[@kararamos7598]

jimin's vocals is no joke...❤

[@dopaminish2099]

Seesaw is so deep…and it’s kind of my relationship anthem 💜🥰

[@ninawahyuni3886]

You must react Room Live, there probably some songs you've never heard before 😊

[@Department_of_Justice]

Completely without trying, I named over 100 BTS songs by the first few notes. I had no idea I knew all those songs!

[@marinal.]

sweet

[@user-cpaOT7]

Sesaw stage mix! Esta vez te encantará, ver los diferentes outfits de los conciertos! Esta guapo y carismático!

[@user-Niine]

Bts blue &grey this song is amazing

[@자전거인생]

예쁜 여자가 우니까 맘이 아프다. 진심으로 공감하는 듯 해요! 화이팅~

[@rqw90]

Omg. From your tears I can tell how a beautiful and clear soul you have inside and outside you really made me in love with you thank you so much I enjoyed every minute of the video keep going and stay save 🥺🤎🤎🤎🤎

[@Strangering-i6x]

I can't believe people still won't believe they're singing live. They have long proven they sing just as well live.

[@shootingstar-f5r]

Hope you can reaction seoul seesaw live because that oufit is kill every yoongi bias❤

[@user-cpaOT7]

Y has pasado con sobresaliente la prueba de ser auténtico Army, con We are bulletproof! Tan emocionada. Los nuevos Armys nos identificamos contigo, q desearíamos hacer estado ahí desde el principio acompañando a BTS en su duro viaje al éxito! Pero como dicen BTS te encuentra a ti! Así q ese era nuestro momento!

[@Ween4ever]

Thank you so much for your reaction Luna! Tiny desk, they were all vibing to the music, and please react to Suga Snooze Live at his concert D-Day in Korea last day. He was so nice and had JK sing on the 1st day, Jimin on the 2nd day and RM on the final day where Jin and J-Hope got permission to leave their military post to go watch and return. V also attended to watch but his singles were not out yet. BTS Live Room Festa has a short medley of a bunch of songs and styles if you’d like to see what you would react to next. If you want a good hype Suga, you should watch his August-D Haegum MV! It’s the 2nd part of the trilogy starting with Daechwita, Haegum, Amygdala from his solo album. I love it and all have so much meaning he really showed himself in these too! 💜❤💙You are full ARMY now I and all the feels BTS gives. Seesaw is beautiful! I hope you can see all the videos they put in Bulletproof: The Eternal. Also melancholy after hearing the news of the rest of the 4 going to the military very soon. 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜🫶🏼👏👏👏🥹🥹🥹

[@wmproduction9472]

BTS don't lip sync let that sink in

[@user-cpaOT7]

Si Dynamite fue en el 2020 el año de la pandemia. Y yo descubrí a BTS gracias a esta canción q sonaba en las radios de España y al escuchar q eran surcoreanos me interesé porque llevo unos años viendo K-dramas y soy muy fan de la ola coreana, pero me faltaba conocer el K-pop . Y me contagie de covid y tuve q estar una semana aislada en mi habitación para no contagiar a mi familia y me acorde de ese grupo surcoreano y busqué en KZbin “My Universe” q ya sonaba en la radio. Y de ahí entré de cabeza en el pozo sin fondo de BTS, literalmente estuve día y noche viendo MVs y actuaciones en vivo y cada vez flipaba.más! Me hice Army en dos dias y ya no pude parar de verles y oírles! Así que esa referencia de RM a Spring day como el final de la pandemia me lleva a esos días que deboré KZbin cosa que nunca había hecho, por culpa del covid. Si no hubiera tenido q pasar tantas horas sola y aislada, quien sabe si me habría dado por investigar a esos chicos q cantaban tan bien en la radio.

[@Artist-x6k]

I love all your reactions❤❤,,also love your reaction to suga singing,, if you want to hear him sing now listen to he's new album,, he's song with IU 🎉

[@lunapigeon]

Will do, thank you so muchhh, u are the sweetesttt😭🤍

[@antonellopez3916]

Luna reacts to BTS 'I NEED U' and BTS 'RUN' are the main songs from the album The Most Beautiful Moment in life. And one of my favorites on the album. I love your videos ❤

[@Bangtan.sh7]

Please more content for BTS 💜💜

[@LisaMT1218]

NPR Tiny Desk is always live.

[@srlkshmi9764]

You need to watch seesaw acoustic version 💔

[@zoie6171]

Your reaction is so nice Luna. We're bulletproof together is such an amazing song . i also became a part of army few months ago and I can proudly say that BTS brought light in my life which was missing . I stopped hating myself after I came to know about them I started to love every phase of my life I started to work hard for the problems which I'm facing right now . I learned from them Struggle always makes you strong and one day you'll achieve what you want . This song is very close to me because when I started my journey with BTS I was like that in different world where I got seven angels to save me from falling apart ❤❤❤❤ People may say That what's the use of this but I know How my life find solace because of them . How I started to cheer up again ❤❤ we may have different religions and nations but as A part of army we're forever bulletproof 💜💜💜

[@ahmadedits786]

luna this song is always special for m it shows m howw much difficult they have faced which i m facing now well tbh u r my favourite

[@glorygloriana369]

Happy jin day💜

[@毛玉毛糸]

I Love BTS❤ I love your reaction for them❤

[@lunapigeon]

💜💜

[@Jin0e0]

오늘도 너무 이뻐용❤

[@lunapigeon]

Always my hype mann🫶🏻🤍

[@Isaba1009]

Zero o clock is nextttttt❤❤

[@user-cpaOT7]

Deseaba que llegaras a Sesaw! Ver a Yoongui cantar tan bien y bailar, a mi bad boy en modo romántico es genial. Tienes que ver el Stage mix ! SUGA es mi bias aunque todos me encantan, porque la voz que captó mi atención cuando les oí en la radio fue la de Jk, en My Universe me daba por pensar si sería el Justin Bieber coreano y que risa ciando descubrí que JK era muy fan de el!

[@ewilan24]

your reaction to wab:the eternal was so lovelyyy i love this song so much (also u got it right, it was in celebration of their 7th anniversary!)

[@lunapigeon]

Thankkk youuu, and yes its such a masterpiece 😭😭🫶🏻

[@adilazzoun2700]

Louder than bombe is a master piece 🙌🏻

[@lunapigeon]

Definitely next song that i will listen tooo

[@lisax1514]

thank you for your reaction 🤍 love you, luna!!

[@lunapigeon]

🥹🥹🤍

[@d.a.y2161]

The boys' voices live are wonderful, they are incredible, and I'm sad that just when Suga could dance freely he had to go to the army, before he had to avoid lifting his arm because his shoulder was injured and he felt pain

[@davidaditya535]

Yes is it live, they never lip syny, also the solo member never did, JK has live performance in time square and he didn't lip sync, v and rm has tiny desk concert to, and Jimin has acoustic jamming. They really hard work for this, that's why they are number one group not only in K-pop but in the world according to billboard. And RM said for Asia men we faved the way.

[@oozecloud4511]

watch the live version ptd concert of we are bulletproof

[@inesmagalhaes7339]

It's live for sure

[@lunapigeon]

I was shocked😭

[@lizruork7877]

Have you ever watched the people pt 2 MV … I think you will love that Suga too… he raps he sings he looks amazing and there’s a dog… perfect And feat. IU

[@lunapigeon]

I havent! I will, thank you so muchh🤍

[@태양-l4z3l]

what? You singing in Korean :) so good!! 입 모양 :) 너무 잘 불렀어요!

[@darrenraffan7804]

Oh Luna, you really are Army now, as no true Army can listen to ‘We are bulletproof: the eternal’ without being touched deeply, so much so that it hurts, as we know that we mean as much to the boys as they do to us, if not more so 💜💜 P.S. Please, please, please, please, please, please, pretty please react to ‘First Love’ by Yoongi. It’s my joint favourite Yoongi track, alongside ‘Snooze’ 💜

[@hakmo568]

루나 너무 귀여움

[@thestarred3417]

No one ever mention but you are becoming beautiful day bay day :)

[@Danial3346]

V soo good 👌🇦🇫

[@dahliaChiara]

Hey Luna i loved your reaction as always, maybe you could react zo Yoongis Accoustiv Version of Seesaw from hos revent xinxert tour D Day

[@shootingstar-f5r]

❤yes more yoongi agustd!

[@LitsarisangSang]

Don't pause tooo much , give commentary after watching the video lmao 😂

[@azrosundunyas2673]

LUNA LOUDER THAN BOMBS LEGENDARY PLEASE

[@lunapigeon]

Will do loveee🤍

[@azrosundunyas2673]

@@lunapigeon Please Luna is a song made by BTS for ARMY .The Iyerics are very beatiful and very meaningful.Jimin's high note and the members voice will give you goosebumps,I hope you get a reaction as soon as possible ,thank you Luna

[@azrosundunyas2673]

Hello Luna,thank you for the BTS video. Evet though I don't understand what you are saying,you have suçu sincere and sincere reactions that youare very sweet.I am writing to you again please 2022 Busan concert RUN BTS song and dance choreography are amazing, I give you a 100/100 guarentee ,you will be amazed by the legendary performance and MIC DROP song .I really want you to react to these two songs in the concert were also very beatiful and it was a completely free concert for the fans and it was their Last concert together. BTS put a lot of effort into this concert

[@logo5950]

I will miss you in Bangtan, I am dying to see you in 2025 💔💔😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@alinnesantana2997]

Hello Luna, please react to BTS's Magic shop live, you will love it. Kisses

[@prateeksuga172]

Suga 💜

[@zoie6171]

Luna I'll love to see your reaction on louder than bombs . I swear you'll gonna love their voice and message in that song . And also Boy meets evil of Jhope Please a little request from your subscriber 💜💜

[@lunapigeon]

Hii, omg yess Louder than bombs has been on my list for so long, cant wait to listen to itt, and noted the Jhope one, thankss🤍😭

[@zoie6171]

@@lunapigeon it's my pleasure Army 💜💜💜 waiting for your reaction ❤️

[@monochromedout]

I'm sure they sang live in the room but post-effects, pitch correction, vocal tuning are used heavily in this performance. I'm sure it was a Big Hit production and not done by NPR. NPR Tiny Desk is live and mixed by NPR. Tiny Desk at home is basically a performance video from the label. Fans will be fans and talk about how "raw mics only...vocal kings etc." but that's just what fans do. Fun performance, great energy.

[@azrosundunyas2673]

LUNA also asked,"Would you react to Jimin's song VIBE ,which he sang with BIGBANG member TAEYANG ? also ,about TAEYANG ,JİMIN said TAEYANG is my idol 10 years ago and said that he was his fan at every opportunity. 10 years later they sang together with his idol .This was very happy .The song is also very beatiful and JİMİN' s angelic voice is mesmerizing

[@wualtergamarra1519]

You should react to funny BTS moments, they are very funny

[@MsStageact]

Regarding Tiny Desk concert. There was no audience because it was during the pandemic. An it's funny that you've mentioned that you couldn't sit still during Dynamite. It's obvious who are the introverts of the group (Jin, Suga, JK) ;)

[@ssev4026]

They're all I except RM and jimin who are extrovert they took their mbti in run bts

[@MsStageact]

@@ssev4026 mbti results change with circumstances. Everyone of them has already 5 different results. :) But the true introverts from birth are Jin, Suga and JK. RM is ambiverted and Hobi, Tae and Jimin are extroverted.

[@hobkive]

I feel you.. spring day makes me cry every time too... Even bts always mentions that spring day is their THE legendary song!! Bulletproof eternal is in mots7 apbum which was supposed to be their last album befor their now cancelled mots world tour and military enlistment, so this was supposed to be bts's heartfelt last fan song for armys but everything changed due to covid 😢😢.. by the way do you know rm v jimin and jungkook are going to military in December mid.. I'm so sad now after hearing these songs😭😭

[@Patchalaporn-d1v]

enhypen mama performance 2023🥹🙏🏻💖

[@tuana_dogan]

your hair looks so cute omfg 😭😭💗

[@anitaherbert1037]

This was during lockdown so skeleton crew. Distanced.