美国声乐老师对华晨宇《虚幻与现实》的真实反应及点评【中英字幕】 Nikki’s Reaction to Chenyu Hua

[@maychan2029]

花花是全方位的音樂奇才！永遠支持他！謝謝你對花花音樂的反應！❤

[@DahliaKuo]

Thank you for sharing your feedback. However, I’m not sure how you managed to find a video with all the instrumental arrangement parts removed. This song is a grand musical piece, and Hua Chenyu’s music is characterized by the fact that each of his songs feels like a short musical drama. He’s someone who knows how to tell a story through music. Beyond the instrumental arrangement, the stage and visuals are also an essential part of his work. So, if you feel uncomfortable or scared, it's one of the messages he wants to convey. Perhaps you should find a complete video with English subtitles and appreciate it again. If you're simply looking to analyze his vocal ability, I suggest listening to his performance of "孩子" (Child). You can search for this title on KZbin to find videos with English subtitles. " [ENG Sub] Hua Chenyu《Child》Singer2018 - EP5 华晨宇《孩子》歌手2018 "

[@monskiethemonsk6461]

Thank you for your reaction. I find Hua Chenyu an absolutely fascinating singer. He composes music and uses his voice as one of the instruments rather than just using the instrumentation just as backing, so for much of his work it is about the whole sound. Hua has a broad variety of styles he draws on in his music, depending on what he is portraying, so, although (I think) he has a unique and distinctive voice he often surprises with the style of song, or rearranges a song from one style into another. I love how his performances are not all the same old stuff that was written for "generic singers" to perform in set style :) 🌺🌺

[@watermelon6201]

One of the reasons his voice may be drowned out in the middle is because the background vocals are also his voice, which he recorded himself.

[@siewhwawo3395]

Hua Chenyu always so amazing ❤

[@vijandrav.6095]

Why is there no music? You are missing the whole point of his composition and music without the instumentation 😅. His compositions are so amazing, interesting and great. Plus he is an amazing singer and artist. 😊 I was at his amazing Mars concerts. They are awesome. Best concerts I have ever been to. And I have been to many.

[@lilyi7598]

The king of the stage❤

[@karenwtho9137]

Glad that you're reviewing Hua Chenyu. As the commenter fifihh3214 wrote, when you listen to him you have to consider why he sings a certain part this or that way, and why he has a loud chorus accompanying him at certain part. He wasn't dancing because that song's subject is about something deep rather than frivolous content. Of course, you can opine that he should have and shouldn't have sung it this or that way. Just keep in mind that he doesn't sing the same way as here in all of his songs. Hope you'd look at more of his work. Thank you for your effort.

[@Nikki4China]

Will definitely keep an open mind! The comments help with perspective and appreciation as well, so thanks for sharing!!

[@karenwtho9137]

@@Nikki4China It wasn't my intention to imply that you don't have an open mind. He used to leave all of his songs opened to listeners' interpretation, without giving the background of his work. That's one of the reasons he refrained from making MVs for most of his songs. He said that each person will feel differently based on their own life experiences so, he didn't want to hijack their imagination. He only started sharing his thoughts in his 5th album called "Hope". His 6th album "Tipping Point" was just published digitally on 10 Jan, selling one million units under 24 hours. The amazing thing is that he had performed all the ten new songs, one after another at his concerts in 2024 before release of his new album. He said this song "Illusion and Reality", the first part was like a self-dialogue and he deliberately made the lone voice dry while the part where his voice was drowned in his own pre-recorded 100-track chorus was like a huge crowd lecturing or preaching to listeners or him about how one should live their life and how the world should or shouldn't be. He wrote a long "thesis" about this song and we get to see his thought process when composing. Sorry for this lengthy reply. I wish you the best of luck and good health. Cheers!

[@fifihh3214]

First of all, you’re reacting to a comprehensive artist, not just a vocalist. If you’re only focused on hearing something that highlights vocals, you’re missing the essence of Hua Chenyu’s artistry. He’s not about showcasing his voice for the sake of it, he’s actually against that idea. His musical concept is that every sound in a song serves the story and emotion, not just the vocals. While he’s known for his powerful voice and does have songs that highlight it, he only does so when it truly serves the music. In the track where you think his voice wasn’t prominent, it was actually him layering his own voice a hundred times to create the sound of an army marching, symbolizing cyberbullying voices. All the "background vocals" are all him. This level of effort goes far beyond simply showcasing vocals.I hope you can appreciate the depth and creativity of his work, rather than expecting vocal highlights alone

[@wuliwuli241]

哥们你骂的真脏啊，这和直接说“他唱的就是一坨，你多看看别的部分”有什么区别

[@cheche8565]

@@wuliwuli241歌曲是整體的，不應單為特顯聲音而創造，華晨宇這首歌我超級喜歡，他的歌唱能力絕對超班❤

[@fifihh3214]

@@wuliwuli241 你是理解能力有什么问题吗？只靠vocal部分判断音乐是片面和低级的。华晨宇的音乐是整体的，他的和声复调编曲每个配器设计都很复杂。虽然他的vocal很强大，但vocal不是用来炫的（虽然他完全有炫的资本），但它更应该是为作品和情感表达服务的。品音乐要听里面每一个设计，而不是简单粗暴的追求vocal亮点（再次强调他的vocal本身就强大，但不能为了炫而炫）。没有艺术表达的声音炫技就等同于耍杂技罢了。

[@wuliwuli241]

@@cheche8565 我喜欢他写的歌，但是他这几年唱功下降的太厉害了，根本没法听。而且他粉丝太傻逼了

[@Nikki4China]

Thanks for explaining that! That perspective is very helpful and I can appreciate that!

[@cheche8565]

Love hua hua❤❤

[@elisifuentes6551]

Sorry .. no offense.. i get that you are a vocal coach….. but what you say doesnt make much sense here. I dont even know where to start. Hua Chenyu is not a vocalist song singer.. he is a composer.. he creates music. Though he is always in total control of his voice and breath…. focusing on vocals skills only is completely missing the point of his music

[@tgraf66]

I am sooooo mad at myself right now! I wrote out a huge post and it was up for a few hours, and then I went in to edit something and accidentally delted the whole thing! AAAGGGHHHH!

[@karenwtho9137]

I thought I wrote a lengthy one but here you are with a well-thought out and excellently framed explanation. Hua Hua actually hummed the vocal melodies like in "Seek" and "Miles Away from Loneliness" although in gibberish, he only needed words from lyricists. Cheers for the information I gleaned from your comment.

[@elisifuentes6551]

I feel for you, Tim 🤗

[@altg4044]

Your video sounds weird. Why can't i hear the background music!

[@schizo2709]

I am honestly confused. Why would you react to a song and remove the music????? If you just want to listen to someone's singing voice, why not react to a cappella songs? Why would you choose any pop, rock, etc. song consisting of instruments, vocals, lyrics, i.e. a whole composition, and remove one vital part of it? This is not an a cappella song, so it's not supposed to be listened to without its instrumental accompaniment. That's just weird. Thank you, regardless, for reacting to Hua Chenyu!

[@lcalvin151]

比周深有特色多了

[@wuliwuli241]

这就很难评

[@HuaChenyuEnglishSubs-HCYES]

@@wuliwuli241 非常好评啊，华是创作歌手，歌声变化比男身女腔多太多了！华出身音乐家庭，专业的音乐训练比去乌克兰的奇怪野鸡大学可好太多了！他不用在舞台上假装弹吉他，也不用带著一张皱巴巴的乐谱上台去弹钢琴，一切旋律都在他的脑中从指尖自然流出，简直太好评了！更不用说只要参加过的音乐相关节目不是第一就是第二，拿来跟那种各种决赛都打不进去的人相比，那真是云泥之别啊！ 太秽气

[@wuliwuli241]

@ 噗，真是倒翻天纲

[@kenken8981]

到了外網還來?

[@continentzero7572]

I would like to point out that there are ALSO huge voices of real singers in China, such as Han Hong, Huang Qi Shan, Gong Lin Na, Gong Shuang, Daiqing Tana, Tan Jing, Shang Wen Jie, Li Yu Gang, A Yun Ga, Gao Tian He, Cai Cheng Yu, Terry Lin, Ping An, Chang Shi Lei, Zheng Yun Long...

[@黃方成]

推薦老師 龔琳娜:小河淌水、忐忑、戲曲忐忑、成為詩人 黄绮珊:我的美麗、等待、燈塔

[@continentzero7572]

100% agree ! They are two fabulous female singers who are worth reacting to.

[@Nikki4China]

Thanks!!

[@weilun0099]

React to the duet between david tao and jj lin "who do you love" plss

[@bounlathchantamart1873]

Huahua and zhoushen are different types of singer , musician will more like huahua and Vocal coach will more like Zhoushen that's all

[@HuaChenyuEnglishSubs-HCYES]

I don't think so. Richard from Throga said he would use Hua Chenyu's "Qi Tian" as an example for his students. Also, many vocal teachers have said that Hua Chenyu's "Child" is the perfect model for vocal teachers.

[@elisifuentes6551]

Zhou Shen is a vocalist only.. a song singer. Hua Chenyu is a complex artist .. a composer and artist. Hua Chenyu is always in full control of his vocal chords, using his voice as an instrument. Its all about conveying emotions. If he sometimes distorts it.. its on purpose.

[@imhim2000]

His singing is AWFUL

[@Nikki4China]

Oh Wow! I can understand why you wouldn't be a fan though

[@HuaChenyuEnglishSubs-HCYES]

Your ears are AWFUL!

[@barbarakangas3255]

​@@Nikki4China There are fans of other singers, who haven't quite reached the level of Hua Chenyu in China, who come onto reactions just to say negative things about Hua Hua. They believe that pushing him down will raise their idol up. One singer in particular, whose fans do this, has a very beautiful voice but no creativity. No dimension. Hua Hua asks that we ignore them but you'll see them on here.

[@vijandrav.6095]

Hua Chenyu has us (millions of martians). We were right in choosing him.😊 He is amazing and deserves all the love he gets from us. We are here. We always will be here.💕And those 🐜🐜🐜 will never be able to change that !!!! @@barbarakangas3255

[@阿怒特]

SO bad!!!

[@vijandrav.6095]

He is SO good!!! ❤

[@elisifuentes6551]

SO good!!!

[@lila1957]

Love Hua Chenyu

[@Cátia薇yu]

he is so good！