Mac DeMarco - This Old Dog ALBUM REVIEW

[@helpineedwater8192]

real dudes watch the review then dip right before fantano says the score

[@padilla11230]

Here's a man saying the right things

[@Joela393]

David Espiritu "real dudes"

[@alejacome356]

David Espiritu that makes as much sense as men having nipples.

[@Neel-ff4mn]

Excuse me melon, but I keep getting Late Shows, CaseyNeistat, and Gaming Walkthroughs in your recommendations feed next to your videos. CAN U PLS STOP IT!?

[@elstupido2233]

nazittt i want to argue with you but you're completely right

[@MightyAmygdala]

Mac DeMarco is basically my dad. This album is a 9/10 for me.

[@chandlermyers9719]

Daniel Hughson shush

[@OrangSSBM]

Daniel Hughson i second this. But it's so strange, deciding, how to feel about it

[@Bandstand]

Is it strange forming your own opinion about an album?

[@MiLkzzzMaN]

Jiro are those lyrics?

[@OrangSSBM]

yup from moonlight on the river

[@charlielane-field39]

0:12 Mac Demarco was a singer songwriter >was What do you know that we don't, Fandango?

[@LegitimateJuice]

Salad days are gone ):

[@JoshTheGreat33]

Hold this W

[@ariorojas2901]

I heard they later found the pick up his ass

[@стрелок-ч7р]

hes joining the 27 club in a few months

[@dirtyhatemachine]

yevrey he better becomea legend soon

[@kanetraxxas]

*checks description* *watches video*

[@Unonuffinjonsnew]

Kane Scott never

[@christianbravo505]

I used to not know that the rating was in the description, so i would jump around until I found it, and then watch.

[@Starman256]

*checks description *reads comments *watches video

[@dimitrimavrakis6085]

me: hi mac demarco: hello

[@JK-is4bz]

Mac demarco: wasuuuup *

[@mrMatti200]

Mac Demarco: "Hey fogman, may I grip a cig?"

[@brandonedwards1181]

I bleached it demarco

[@annebannan9817]

Gruaehgufaeg What did u do to me

[@PuddingAtheist]

Hahahaha-hahahahaha-hahahahahahaha.

[@KelpYT]

How in the world did he not even MENTION Still Beating? That track is beautiful.

[@rainewoods]

I agree, easily one of my favorites on this album

[@basementhippo]

Cinco DeMarco

[@rosetheghost453]

Tyler Holloway Happy Cinco DeMarco

[@NoTodoEsArte1]

Ok, I'm going to take it as an 8, light 8

[@gmeenew12345]

If Kendrick wrote this album you probably would have given it a 7/10

[@jorge666]

Gabe Mead-Newton I remember people used to say this for every rap album lmao before melon betrayed us

[@CalvinNoire]

7 years later, and this is still (somehow) his comment section format..

[@Dylan.Gmusic]

Kendrick did not write it

[@gmeenew12345]

@@Dylan.Gmusic wrong, he did

[@Dylan.Gmusic]

@@gmeenew12345 ohhhhhhh okay

[@1joe000]

This Old Melon was better

[@TriFoxu]

the beautiful and bold melon

[@clockworkman4482]

+TriFox the good Mood melon

[@josephranieri8839]

My Beautiful Dark Twisted Melon 6/10

[@theannoyinggeek156]

Don't like the new melon

[@conwuzere]

I don't mind if you keep your shirt unbuttoned, Anthony.

[@federicolinares1442]

yeah too much clothes baldie show us them crazy na nas!

[@judeforrester6641]

The picture goes great with the comment

[@LuisRodriguez-zs5tt]

Me neither, still waiting for his only fans

[@nicovastagh4610]

I personally don't agree that his previous albums were feel good. I guess it is up to interpretation but I have always heard Mac's music as melancholy.

[@sale9667]

my guy are you serious

[@nicovastagh4610]

@@sale9667 Yes. No substantial change in opinion over the past 3 years about it.

[@vDomMusic]

As a new fan I gotta agree.

[@veryscarygoat]

I don't know how you can say his old stuff was 'happy'. Mac's the king of bitter sweet in my eyes. Sweet melodies with introspective lyrics

[@JyGhAa]

Review World War 2.

[@Lortenerfrisk]

6 million/10?

[@scottsmith8162]

erik bundersen nice Juan

[@jogbon]

erik bundersen NEIN

[@daviddidonato9765]

Nein/10

[@PsychoticSmith]

Third Reich/10

[@sneedfeed7204]

Anthony fantano the type of nigga to use the word "Greetings" to start an email

[@somalipirateslonglostgaylo777]

Somali Pirate Who Pirated Your Girlfriend L

[@payne8623]

Greetings, traveler.

[@alejacome356]

Somali Pirate Who Pirated Your Girlfriend HEY!! it's you again ,how the hell do u always get top comment?

[@sneedfeed7204]

Ale Jacome I come early type some funny shit reply to my comment and then dip. The rest doesn't matter it's either people like it or dislike it lol

[@alejacome356]

Somali Pirate Who Pirated Your Girlfriend thank you for teaching me the ways, I shall use my newly granted power for the good of humanity.i bow down to you. you beautiful somalian man.

[@henrytedds5585]

Real bois just listen to what Anthony names himself at the beginning of the video then dip😤💯

[@muhammadabiyyu8528]

Anthony, you should smoke Viceroy

[@alejandro3702]

Viceroys are actually nasty

[@jesuscrust727]

Muhammad Abiyyu But what if i prefer Marlboro?

[@muhammadabiyyu8528]

samson Don't worry, i'm not smoking :D

[@ComedicPause]

Viceroys are shit. Even Mac said they're terrible.

[@MrFireyFusion]

smoking gives you strength

[@whybegin1285]

Did you know logic is both amphibian and mammal?

[@Kenny-xy5cc]

Yeet Sack no he's black and white how many times does he have to say it

[@TelecastPropellor96]

Rap-platypus. Raplatypus.

[@whybegin1285]

Positive Comment plathany pustano here

[@prod6mill.512]

he's actual half marsupial and half corn on the cob

[@reggie9841]

I like men now

[@sundaes_9609]

I Always liked melons, and men...

[@tomsmith8453]

Regan Killington I AM TRANSGENDER RESPECT ME BITCH

[@feljemuro]

I do tho but I'm not bragging about it

[@kat2605]

still beating is my favorite song off of the record it's a bop!

[@isiahhodge333]

word!! still beating is lit af! I really thought fantano was gonna give this a strong 9, I'm shocked!

[@april3534]

Isiah Hodge I'm not surprised, the album is really good; but idk if it's a Nine. I feel like it a 8. Songs like wolf in sheep clothes and my old man bogged down the album

[@1nautica]

@@april3534i am coming to this comment 6 years later to say i could not agree less with this take

[@jaystink]

The Baby You're Out donk is probably my favourite sound on the album. It's so deliberately obtuse and atonal on a record that's quite a bit more serious than his previous work. The song's about regrets that don't need to be regrets, and I think that cowbell may at first sounds regrettable, but it totally makes the track for me.

[@Georges_IV]

Him putting baby youre out as his least favourite is a horrific take

[@thetalkingfly]

Anthony- Just discovered your channel and I just discovered Mac DeMarco - It was good listening to you react to this album. I am head over head in love with Mac, haha! Dig your passion, I will dig deeper. cheers, Steve aka The Talking Fly

[@ethanbarrett2430]

anthony looks like an italian car dealer

[@chrilborn4138]

He sold me my first car it's true

[@jeffmangum8877]

Review Viceroy cigarettes

[@bencarson7771]

I think that high synth in Baby You're Out, while it isn't complex in any way, sort of compliments and adds to the vibe of the instrumental half of the song. If juxtaposes the tone of the lyrics which I think is what he was going for with the instrumentals that backed it up. It sort of showed a benign take on the topic of regretting the past that I got from the lyrics

[@denissemolina6559]

Today turns 5 months since my father's passing. We didn't have the best relationship because of his alcoholism, but we were slowly moving into the right direction before he passed. This album hit so close to home it made me feel like he did it just for me. The feeling of unresolved business with a parent, of never really getting closure or an honest apology, etc. This album continues to help me cope with all these feelings, making me feel less guilty and alone. Even if it's not all perfect, you can just tell everything Mac composes comes straight from his heart and soul. And idk i rather have something real than something grand

[@TheBonkINC]

Still no Persona 5 soundtrack review...you slacking melon

[@sergeyshabay6835]

Sadly we'll never see it coming.

[@user-ud1ks6jy1m]

He doesn't like weebs

[@fullmoonofus2683]

Still waiting for it

[@angelsilva7207]

@@user-ud1ks6jy1m I don’t even play Persona or into anime shit. I checked out the Persona 5 album out of curiosity after hearing so much hype about it and honestly, it’s pretty damn good

[@jamezz41]

fucking knew this was going to be a 2/10.

[@nyankittycharliedude]

Everyalbumthony isa7tano

[@BRANDONTURNERShandyB17]

Finally!!!!! I personally thought Mac smashed this album.:-)

[@LucasofMaine]

Logic: Anthony Fantano here Anthony Fantano: Lil Boat gets a 2/10 while Blank Face gets a classic/10???

[@TheSkoneczny117]

You're very metabeta.

[@prod6mill.512]

Lucas CALLISTO Deely I think im getting Alzheimers

[@JoeyNoChill]

Macthanoy Demarctano- This Old Melon

[@SuperGameGenie]

can you review TPAB

[@SnoozeTheRecluse]

That's J Cole's best album

[@africanpublicholiday3989]

You gave this album a "I'm black and white" out of Logic? WTF?!

[@ThatShittyGamer]

Quietly said yes and clicked that notification

[@risengrind8059]

moonlight on the river makes me feel an indescribable sensation

[@rileywalsh5564]

Couldn’t of said it better

[@kalaynamay]

Mac Demarco completely writes and produces his music for him. He likes his music a certain way and he doesn’t conform to what other people think. He just lets the right people who like his style come to him. I always admired how he doesn’t change his music style.

[@muhammadabiyyu8528]

You should add 'On The Level' and 'This Old Dog' in your fav tracks

[@TheMarkoPolo2011]

Muhammad Abiyyu On The Level is sick.

[@mihedas]

Oldthony Dogtano

[@cyberjunq]

mihedas lol I thought your profile pic was an eyelash on my phone

[@Michael-ks3rl]

The keyboard part in Baby You're Out is my favorite!! So fun, and it absolutely enhances the groove imo!

[@HumansFreshlyBorn]

Fav tracks My old man This old dog Baby you’re out For the first time One Another Still beating Sister Dreams from Yesterday A wolf who wears sheep’s clothes On the Level One more love song Moonlight on the river Watching him fade away Least fav track Wolf who wears sheep’s clothes if I had to pick 10/10

[@1nautica]

i know im like 3 years late but wolf who wears sheeps clothes is at least top 3 on the album

[@quinnrenz5462]

NEW SLOWDIVE PLS

[@Stookvogel]

That album is so much better than I expected

[@realitybites_]

I love this album, but i think he will give it a 6 at best

[@adriennes7739]

Quinn Renz No chance that album's getting more than a strong 6, Slowdive didn't do anything they didn't do in the 90s.

[@Lucols4]

Still wouldn't change anything about that album.

[@narrowlightbulb]

Great album, but you already know Fantango will not like it cause everytime he mentions Slowdive it's in the most monotone way ever. He doesn't care for the band.

[@Jettmingin]

i see that nonagon infinity on the right, MOTU leak review when?

[@jonasvm]

That beep beep on “baby youre out” makes the song bro

[@whatthefuckishappeningomgw3548]

i love that song

[@samdavies3248]

What beep beep?

[@bobbymalone2039]

@@samdavies3248 the percussion

[@bobbymalone2039]

@@paterickbrennan you may think it doesn't fit the vibe but it's perfectly on tempo if you're speaking from a musical standpoint though

[@paterickbrennan]

@@bobbymalone2039 I listened to it again and the beep beep kind of slaps

[@somalipirateslonglostgaylo777]

button your goddaym shirt up melon! you tryna make me feel guilty for not liking fruit

[@somalipirateslonglostgaylo777]

L

[@somalipiratessecondaccthat968]

Somali Pirate's Long Lost Gay Lover L

[@Bandstand]

You are the most dedicated meme commenter I've ever seen. Papa bless you.

[@somalipirateslonglostgaylo777]

Bandstand lol i really like commenting. I get this great feeling from getting likes on my shit posting lol and making people laugh for whatever reason.

[@wwxxww6289]

"I like commenting." If that comment is irony its funny, If its sincere its funny for a whole other reason

[@sicemdawgs47]

Wow am I the only one who loves Baby You're Out??

[@Nicohusss]

Reid Best in my opinion.

[@antonioaguiar5071]

No

[@kikigarbage]

No

[@jackfarris5498]

No

[@kaded_]

I just think the comment of it being one of the worst uses of synths on the album is dumb because the sound is a sequenced cowbell

[@MagickFlavour]

I'm not gonna say the score, but DAMN it was a higher score than I thought.

[@firex148]

Me: Did you know i'm black AND white?? Logic: Hi

[@twxvybeatz5796]

firex148 my head hurts

[@rashotcake6945]

firex148 like that one Marshall lamar song white the berry

[@JoshTheGreat33]

This got me dead 💀 😂

[@Molteniceee]

Black: Did Logic know I'm and WHITE I? Hi: AND

[@Blue-vd6bv]

firex148 wrong video nigga lmao

[@bradleyharrison7901]

David Bowie - Worst To Best!

[@ProgEnjoyer397]

Bradley Harrison he did like 26 albums it would be so long

[@harrisondykhoff]

“This album is not a 2” Gave 2 a 6/10. Gave this a Strong 7 to Light 8.

[@CheckeredFedora]

Excited to hear this - there's a soft spot in my heart for "Salad Days," which I know you didn't care for. I'm excited to hear what he does on this one.

[@muhammadabiyyu8528]

This Old Dog not in fav track, that track is amazing!!

[@TheSkopionV3noM]

Muhammad Abiyyu A Wolf Who Wear Sheep's Clothes is the best track tho, dawg

[@holben27]

moonlight on the river is Mac's best track period.

[@Bandstand]

For The First Time is baby making material.

[@TheShittingtonPost]

Hey melon are you going to review the Eurovision Song Contest this year? It's a big thing in non-mérica and absolutely NOT GAY at all. SURE YOU'LL LOVE IT ANTOINE

[@SwishEx]

Pixies Worst to Best

[@lortomcon]

Swish Swosh dew it

[@Mgirald]

They only ever made like 6 albums and the list would mostly just be in chronological order

[@axes3562]

Wise Guy r u sayin that last album would be numero uno? U gay?

[@194decibels]

Wise Guy you mean reverse chronological you mons pubis

[@TelecastPropellor96]

IT'S EDUCATIONAL

[@beebee404]

Nice fucking JPEG album art on the wall

[@kenny.bender]

notbenny is on a green screen thing he does it for every album

[@Bandstand]

kenny, welcome to the needledrop comment section.

[@epsohapshiro]

best thumbnail from recent reviews. Good job Fantano.

[@HeyIntegrity]

"I need Anthony to review ___________ so I can tell everyone my opinion"

[@savagemcflurry9082]

Kinda gutted you didn't mention anything on Still Beating. My personal favourite on this album, it's got that more emotional and patient feel the album delivers, while having a vibe that incorporates that classic Mac sound. Not to mention the wonderful guitar in this track. Just my opinion! Great insight on the track my boyo

[@MrDiprock]

I really liked the "bip bip"

[@soqquadro7672]

I read this while he said that. Yes, now

[@RegularRyy]

hope mac uses more electric guitar on the next album

[@DihStyle69]

let's not forget fantano loved the two new hairy styles tracks. he lowkey a directioner

[@joeybrickz5468]

I don't listen much non-rap... and even then, it's mostly RnB. This album is so fucking good I never thought I'd enjoy white folk music this much

[@unviversalyhappy]

Honestly this was the album that introduced me to mac demarco and I hope he never goes back, 8/10

[@redzeroism]

Pond??? The Weather?? Melonhead

[@snoun7933]

The last three tracks are legendary

[@GRUNTOP]

I liked this album quite a bit. it seems much more mature than his previous releases

[@tennisracket166]

0:23 he has officially quit smoking as of summer of 2023

[@Somewhereinthisuniverse]

He quit smoking

[@tennisracket166]

yup

[@holliesongbird]

Anthony I love watching your videos because it gives such a great introspective about music we listen too. You always make me second listen and really understand what I am hearing. I also write about music and post things on my blog and i'm starting to do album reviews and you have inspired me first hand. This is great! I love your channel!

[@adamnerd1236]

I'm loving this new album. been a Mac fan for a good few years now and this definitely beats 2 by a long shot.

[@alqaedaswag]

do u still like it?

[@haller1999]

Holy shit 'Baby you're out' was one of my favourite songs on the album just before you spoke about the synth stuff in the background which my ears somehow completely faded out. Now I can't hear it anymore Thanks. A lot.

[@JK-is4bz]

Maximilian Haller I didn't notice it til he mentioned it as well. I still think it's a good track though. It does kinda clash weirdly though.

[@haller1999]

Of course I don't hate it just because of this.. But what definitely bothers me is that I just have my focus on it even if I try not to.. And as Anthony said, it really doesn't fit in or does anything for the song in general.

[@hypnagogue]

L rating unfortunately, this is a 9 and every song is written amazingly, also the instrumentals are insanely good

[@drummercymbalsamples]

Honestly I'm not super invested in the rap/pop tracks you review but I enjoy your descriptions. Whether it's positive or negative I just enjoy the comparisons and color commentary. Keep it up man, great content!

[@Wonderfresh07]

Salad Days was a 10

[@Icewallowcome012]

i am 10

[@natedogsturdikat8538]

My mans really said baby you’re out is the worst song?

[@rhettsvideos]

Wasn't a fan of the repetitive rhythmic synth part on "Baby You're Out" at first listen either but it grew on me after a few days. It sort of keeps the song flowing and such. Instead of letting it bother you, try telling yourself that it's your favorite part. It's certainly worth giving it a shot as Mac certainly added that part for a reason other than to annoy you lol.

[@6tyui]

Crazy... I actually digg "the keyboard part" in Baby You're Out

[@sumtin05698]

bruh honestly fantano doesn’t amuse me anymore cause his opinions are all so low like he even said in this that he loves another one but salad days is too dull, dudes always trippin

[@Metrawolf]

I think the only reason I've subscribed to your channel is to hear all your different Nickthony Nametanos.

[@jackmac527]

Did you know logic was black and white??

[@kgee3]

Didn't notice the repeating synth in Baby You're Out until you pointed it out. Thanks a lot, melon boy.

[@Emdiggydog]

Not mentioning Rock n Roll Nightclub is a paddling

[@nardolombardo5961]

The first time I heard Mac Demarco, I recognized the source of the songs. I would love to hear what you have to say about my debut Album Nardo Lombardo-Kawolomoto on Stoopid Records

[@sonicmonkey2000]

check the score and d- stay for the nice review :)

[@somedudethatchillshard8376]

really like your review of this one, pretty much all of your comments are spot-on. love this album

[@Denisserariana]

As a latin i want you to diss Despacito

[@TMdmup]

I really loved Baby You're Out, but I totally agree with you on the awkward synth beat. Keeps it from being a truly great track.

[@Deadwaverxse]

Thought this was "your old droog"

[@Terminado907]

GoatBoyzKult . Honestly the Packs album cover could be for a Mac Demarco album

[@infinitethink2597]

Moonlight on a river ...its a life experiment especially when you live on hill by a medow river stream

[@salihaha14]

i really like this album and i was super pumped for it to come out. one of my favorites has to be "still beating" because of the SICK guitar in the beginning. super smooth and 👌🏻🔥💯

[@Thebepob]

This is Mac DeMarco's best album. Just go watch the live pitchfork performance. His new sound when playing live, is Fucking amazing!! Mac took his live performance to a new level, no pun intended lol. But I digress, this really is Macs best work!!! And I have seen Mac boy 4 times live and I can't wait to see him again with the new sound he has, he is shredding faces with his vocals alone like never before!!!

[@joshpenn1]

4:14 I have no idea why I laughed so hard at that 😂

[@Maddie-uv6rz]

One more love song is 100% one of my fave songs of all time, I just listened to it and its just so much beauty

[@twisty6621]

this old melon ain't about to forgeeeet

[@dser4455]

I agree with a lot of the sentiments you put forth and like what you said about mac's new lyrical style transitioning well to his unique sound. The only thing I might take issue with is your critique of some throwaway songs on the album. I think a title like "sister" and the relatively cryptic message he put forth is more of a personal message that mac wanted to put on the album to honor his sister and the hardship that she has gone through while still giving the listener a sense of where he is at emotionally. We might've wanted more from that specific tune, but I don't think that was ever the point he was trying to make with the some from its birth. Anyways, good stuff.

[@MissUnderstoodOfficial]

This old dog (song) is perfect the way it is Mac don't listen That and still beating amen oh my

[@J0elPeters]

Nice to see a fellow Edmontonian gaining success!

[@coolbeansko468]

that bip was cool in baby your out

[@RubenFlota]

That LCD live vinyl is a gem

[@scamfan]

hey everyone im trying to get into vaping. any tips?

[@solidsixx8562]

Don't.

[@Furitenma]

Great review man, I'm really enjoying the album. Glad you liked it!