Momcozy S12 Pro, M5, V1, and V2 Wearable Breast Pump Comparison

[@maribelgomez914]

I purchased the V2 and I had to returned it. The motor stopped working after 2 months. I was using it every day. Thankfully I was able to get a full refund. The cup has a tiny hole so it still leaks when bending forward. It also depends how much you move. I recommend to read carefully about refunds/returns in case the motor stops working. Amazon has a longer period to returned it than the actual company. Hope this helps.

[@MadisonLoethen]

O so glad you were able to get a new one!

[@joahnnurse7209]

So glad to find this review.. I’m using m5 (works great, it’s just heavy and I have a small breast), so I’ve been wanting to get another one that is more lightweight. And i’m so torn between v1 and v2.. will definitely get v2 now. Thanks so much for this video!

[@MadisonLoethen]

so glad it was helpful!

[@aditi1117]

Hi. Your videos are super helpful! ❤ I need help deciding which wearable pump to go with that doesn't require me to walk around with bottles attached. Im currently using the Baby Buddha, and it's very powerful, but ever since i started doing the fridge hack, i noticed that its suction power has become less, and my output has therefore decreased. I like that it's strong, easy to use, and lightweight, but i dont like that it's not discreet, and i can't do much with it on. I need to be able to hold my infant and tend tend to my toddler which is impossible with a pump on that has bottles and tubing even though its electric and doesnt require wall plug in while in use. Also, i have to keep readjusting to get output as the flange size is not big enough, so my whole breast does not get a full massage for output. Looking for an easy insertable pump that massages the whole breast to help with output and is easy to clean and put together. Which pump do you recommend for a 36C cup with the requirements I've listed and maximum output and ease of use as top priority to use several times throughout the day?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think you'd be happy with the S12 pro or the V2! Not sure what you mean by massages the whole breast though. You could deff slip a little massager in the bra while you are wearing them.

[@aditi1117]

Thank u.

[@jennylai811]

Thank you for your videos. They are very informative. I am stuck between the momcozy m5 and the Elvie stride. I know you said that momcozy v2 is similar to the elvie stride but insurance gave me those options. Which would you prefer? Thanks in advance. 😊

[@MadisonLoethen]

The Elvie stride will be a little stronger than the M5 if you need that. The M5 is a nice pump though if you don’t want to mess with tubes ❤️

[@jennylai811]

Thank you for your advice!

[@olaide1521]

Thank you for the video. My S12 just lost suction after using it for barely 2 months and both motors within a week. I wasn't sure if i should repeat buy or get another model or another brand entirely.

[@MadisonLoethen]

Have you tried replacing your duckbills? Those are really cheap and need to be replaced every couple months

[@rifshanfathmath6645]

Loved this video but really wished you were wearing any other color. It Wasn’t very clear in the black. But loved everything else. ❤❤❤answered all my questions

[@MadisonLoethen]

o good point. I'll keep that in mind in future videos.

[@OluwadamilolaHontonnu]

Hi, thanks for the video Which would you recommend? M5,S9 Pro or S12 Pro

[@OluwadamilolaHontonnu]

Or is there a more affordable wearable breast pump you can recommend?

[@MadisonLoethen]

Prob the S12 Pro from those three.

[@MadisonLoethen]

Yes their new M6 and M9 are super nice.

[@shoraalsaleh9010]

I keep going back and forth on the m5 and v2. I love that the v2 has the one control and is super quiet. On the other hand, i love that the m5 has no tubes, but it does seem to be bulkier since the motor is on top. Which do u recommend to use when in meetings with other people or out in the mall? Edit: grammar

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think the V2 would be a lot easier to manage in public!

[@Leighanng5]

@@MadisonLoethen Also deciding btw the m5 and v2...although I havent looked into the m6. Does the v2 have an easy fridge hack too?

[@MadisonLoethen]

@@Leighanng5 Yes! It's deff easy to do the fridge hack with too

[@SayraOraha]

Hi, I got my 12 pro breast pump and used your code, thank you! Do you have any videos on sterilizing parts. I have the babybreza can I use that ?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I just boiled before first use and then hand wash daily and occasionally run the washable parts through the dishwasher

[@kareninavasquez8037]

Hi. Thank you so much for sharing. I am currently using the Spectra and the Zoomee. The Spectra works great but the Zoomee is horrible. Would you still recommend the MomCozy to me? I would like to have a Handsfree one.

[@MadisonLoethen]

The S12 Pro and the V2 are my favorite Momcozys. I think you'd be happy with either!

[@AndreaSmedley-ti6zt]

Where can you find inserts for the V1 or V2 pumps

[@MadisonLoethen]

They come with them!

[@AndreaSmedley-ti6zt]

@ and what if I need extra where can I find them

[@MadisonLoethen]

@@AndreaSmedley-ti6zt here you go! amzn.to/4iNNcth

[@AndreaSmedley-ti6zt]

@@MadisonLoethen thank you 😊

[@sar3dge]

Hi, I’m expecting in May, first time Mum, and I’ve just spotted that Momcozy are giving 25% off to healthcare workers. I’ve been researching pumps but I wasn’t planning on buying one until baby was here and I knew more about my pumping needs but as this discount is on I’m keen to not miss out. Your videos have been super helpful thank you. I’m just wondering if you would recommend waiting to buy or if there is a particular one you would recommend for first timers? Other ladies in my family haven’t had any difficulty breast feeding although I know that’s no guarantee, we are planning to try and combi feed so Dad can get involved and I’m a 32F, just to give some context. Thank you :)

[@MadisonLoethen]

I'd recommend the V2 if it's going to be your only pump and the S12 pro if you also have a traditional pump and you're just looking for a hands free option. The tubeless wearable pumps are awesome but some women pump a little less with them so that could hurt your supply if you exclusively pump

[@Ho.C]

Thank you for this video Have the M5 and I’m thinking of buying the V2 Because the M5 leaks went I lean forward plus the fact that that the motor is quiet and not in the chest Should I buy it ?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think you'd love the V2!

[@AndreaSmedley-ti6zt]

What pump is good for maybe a C or D cup women

[@MadisonLoethen]

Any of these would work well! If you have elastic nipples, I wouldn't recommend the V1 or V2.

[@alexboccaletti2941]

how much time to fill a pump dispenser?

[@MadisonLoethen]

Every woman is different. I usually do a 15 min pump.

[@mariamfaried5035]

Have you reviewed bellababy??

[@MadisonLoethen]

Yes! I did review a version on those on my channel

[@tarshy95]

Hi there I’m a new mum and looking to see which pump to get, I want to be hands free, I’m on a bit of a budget too. I’m a 12F in size. Which one would you recommend?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I'd go with the V2! It's portable and light in your bra.

[@evdokiyamazneva4966]

Hello. My supply is not great so every drop is important to me :) Which of these pumps do you recommend in order to get the best possible output? I have s12 pro but i am wondering if m5 or v2 for example will provide better output? Also the motors of s12 pro are not very comfortable and thats why i consider m5...

[@MadisonLoethen]

Their new M6 is really nice. I'd do the M6 over the M5. The V2 and S12 pro are great pumps. I think all have a nice strength. Having the right insert can really help with output too. With all wearables I'd recommend pumping for a little longer than you would with a traditional pump.

[@evdokiyamazneva4966]

​@@MadisonLoethen, thank you! Is M6 suitable for heavy and a bit larger breasts? My nipples are not elastic and i am using additionally inserts of 15 mm.

[@MadisonLoethen]

@@evdokiyamazneva4966 Yes! I think it would work well for that.

[@samiayeh]

Ugh! I am so torn between S12 pro and V2. I want to fully breastfeed but want to have a pump just in case. I should be staying home most of the time so being discrete and noiseless arent on my top priority. I am also on the bustier size...which one would you recommend for me to buy?Did you have trouble with the V2 being just 1 motor instead of 2? xx

[@MadisonLoethen]

If your bigger chested you may like the V2 because the cups are just lighter in the bra. Both are great pumps though!

[@maygenburrell2547]

I have the s12 pro and one of my motors quit working. I also have the M5 and not a fan of it at all. I’m thinking about the V1 or V2. Which would you recommend? Which one is closest to the s12 pro. Because I loved that one. I would get 12 oz total per pump compared to the 3-5 oz total with the M5.

[@MadisonLoethen]

The V2! I just love it. It’s super quiet and easy to use.

[@northwestkitten61]

I got the v1 by accident should I return it? Get the v2 ?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I would! I like the V2 a lot better.

[@natashagarcia8567]

Thank you for the video. I'm expecting baby #3 and I am going to try a hand free pump this time around. I feel really stuck between the S 12 Pro and the V2. I heard really good things about them both. I am a little hesitant about the V2 because of the tubes. I am a big chested woman and produce a lot of milk. The remote and how quiet the V2 pump is what is getting me drawn in but, i worry about the tubes getting twisted, bent etc. while wearing them. Do you have any advice or recommendations on which one I should get? Thank you for your time.

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think the V2 could be great for you! In my experience the tubes just kinda hang there and don’t really get twisted or anything ha

[@silvymehta]

Still confused on which one to get btwn the V2 & S12 pro as my secondary pump. I’d like to use it anytime I need to be hands on with my baby, possibly overnight, and when we’re out and about. We do plan to travel soon so would want it for that as well.

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think the S12 pro may be the one to go with for you since you’d like to hold the baby while pumping. I think the V2 tubes could get a little in the way for that.

[@sharonengland5768]

This video was so helpful! Thank you very much. I’m expecting baby #2 with a 6 year age gap and things have changed so much. I exclusively pumped with baby #1 and am expecting to do the same this time around. So many more options! I ordered an S12 pro (I have a spectra for home use) and am thinking I’ll get the v1 or v2 as well. I’m an RN so pumping discreetly would be great. Might go for V2 if you feel the suction is similar to v1?

[@MadisonLoethen]

Yes! I think you’d like the V2 more than the V1 ❤️

[@lindasantoso4225]

I am deciding between V2 or S12 Pro. I read your response below in the comment that mentioned if pumping in the car, s12 pro would be easier. But I thought V2 is discrete and easy to move around. What makes u say that s12 pro is better to use it outside?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I thought the V2 tubes may be a little more difficult with a seatbelt but I haven’t actually tried. It could be fine! Both are great pumps that are easy to move around in

[@sohadiamonds3732]

Between S9 pro and S12 pro what are going to choose? It’s difficult for me to know

[@MadisonLoethen]

I'd do the 12 because I like having the timer

[@elizabethguzman1777]

Madison, I bought the V1 & V2 on sale because I wanted the options to be handsfree with going back to work, but unfortunately, I'm getting less than half the output from my Spectra. Any ideas outside of adding time and checking sizing? I'm so disappointed, especially since they don't take back/allow returns for used products.

[@MadisonLoethen]

so sorry to hear that! Some women do just respond not as well to wearables for some reason. Besides sizing and wearing them longer I'd suggest maybe trying them with a semi snug sports bra. It could be possible you're not getting a good vacuum depending on the nursing bra you're wearing.

[@Dee-zx3fd]

Hi! Thank you for your video. I am between the S12 and V2. I am 2 months post partum and make around 4-6oz total using medela pump in style. I returned to work and need something I can move around in more. I don't mind it having some noise but worried about supply. Would definitely want to increase supply and plan to pump during the day (using wall pump once early morning and once at night) and breastfeed overnight. Which would you recommend?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think I'd go with the V2 if I were you. It's a little quieter, and there's just one motor to mess with. The single motor with tubes may be better for supply too.

[@nadaezz8091]

What would you recommend elvie stride or v1 or v2, I already have the lansinoh double electric pump

[@MadisonLoethen]

The V2 and Stride are very similar and are both awesome!

[@alliesparr9971]

I’m debating between the v1 and v2 because I’m due with twin boys in September. When I pumped with my previous daughter, I made just enough for her. I was not an over supplier by any means. So I’m just wondering if I should go with the hospital grade so I can keep up with feeding twins or would the v2 be able to do the same? Also, what plug in pump (the ones usually covered by insurance) would be good to use for the twins as well. I work as a therapist in an outpatient and home setting so the quiet one seems better but I want to choose the one that’s going to be able to feed my boys the best. I appreciate any feedback during this stressful time of trying to pick out a pump for the two boys!

[@MadisonLoethen]

I like the V2 much better because it’s so much smaller, more portable, and quieter. To me the strength on it is great too. For a traditional pump, I love my Lansinoh. My girls loved the Lansinoh bottles so it was great to just throw a cap on the bottles and then they could feed with them later

[@JuanDanyGarAgui]

Hi! I've been trying the Spectra S1 since my first baby, now with the 2nd one im ready to try another one... between s12 pro or m5 which one will be more similar to spectra s1 ? Im worried that the s12 being so stronger that it could hurts. Thanks for your vídeos, a truly guide in this journey.

[@MadisonLoethen]

I haven't tried the Spectra but I think you'd be ok with the S12 pro. The pro version is a little more tamed down than the original S12 that people were having pain with.

[@genitamerizalde-adams4888]

Does the v2 have a timer?

[@MadisonLoethen]

Yes!

[@kayladryden]

First time mom here. I was set on m5 but now i don't know as it seems most recommendations i don't see m5. Help! Lol

[@MadisonLoethen]

I actually like their new M6 and M9 better than the M5!

[@RanaDabaja]

Hello! I’m deciding between the s12 pro and the v2, I’m a first time mom, still in my third trimester. Im on the smaller chested size (B36) - I worry that the motor with the S12 might weigh down the pump (if that makes sense), and I won’t be able to get good suction. Is that a concern I should take into consideration? Which do you think would be best?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I am a C cup and do fine with the 12 pro motor but if your preference is for lighter cups the V2 is great! They are both super nice pumps 💕

[@aliciamitchell6028]

I’ve seen so many reviews of the s12 only working for a few months and then quitting! I want to try it so bad because I had the s9 a few years ago and loved that but that only lasted me 4 months ☹️

[@MadisonLoethen]

O sry to hear that! My s12 pro has lasted me quite a while but I didn’t use it to exclusively pump. I used it mainly for weekend outings

[@Dee-zx3fd]

Hi! Thank you for your video. I am really stuck between the S12 and V2. I currently use the medela pump in style and make around 4-5 ounces in total. I just returned to work after 2 months and need something with more mobility. I don't mind it have a little sound. My concern is supply, I would want to build it up over time. Ideally I would like to bottle feed during the day while I pump and breastfeed at night. I need a little more freedom and mobility but plan on using my wall pump for the first pump before heading to work and at night before bed. Which would you recommend?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think the S12 pro may be easier for car pumps! Both work well. ❤️

[@mrssousuke]

How does the fridge hack actually work? Do you rinse it then place in fridge or just empty and place in fridge?? I just bought an m5 for my baby due in march, very interesting and looks great.

[@MadisonLoethen]

I just place the parts directly in the fridge without rinsing between pumps and give them a nice scrub once at the end of the day!

[@naomicalvert1287]

I have low supply which would be better the v2 or Lansinoh 2.0? Thanks

[@MadisonLoethen]

Ah I love both. Probably the Lansinoh though because plug in pumps tend to be better for low supply

[@naomicalvert1287]

@@MadisonLoethen Thank you 😊

[@jessicaaghavian1332]

I am fairly big on top 38H. Dec 6 i will be 3 mos PP. I think i have elastic nipples but im not sure. I may just have the wrong flange sizes but wtvr size i try its the same thing. Maybe i still have wrong size. I breastfeed and formula feed but majority formula. I BF knowing ill formula right after. I dont consistently pump, i dont consistently BF. When i use wearble (lansinoh) or wall pump (spectra) i get maybe 2 oz to 3 oz MAXXX. I pump for minimum 15 minutes each side and max 30min. Still max i get is 3 oz I will be going back to work and need to start consistently pumping. Which pump do you recommend?

[@MadisonLoethen]

If you may have elastic nipples I'd go with the S12 pro, or the new M6 or M9!

[@justdoit827]

Hey there. I have only tried the Spectra and I like how strong it is but I’m looking to be able to move while pumping keeping the suction level or maybe even increase it if possible. Which one do you recommend? I also would like to increase my production cause that’s been hard. Thanks!

[@MadisonLoethen]

I think you'd be happy with either the new Momcozy Mobile Style, the S12 pro or the V2!

[@justdoit827]

@@MadisonLoethen Thank you! I will try it :)

[@ritupatel583]

I’m due in Jan 2025. Looking forward to buy only one kind of breast pump. Which one shall I get?

[@MadisonLoethen]

If you're only going to have one I'd probably just stick with a traditional plug in pump. I love wearables but some women don't produce as much with them and you wouldn't want to hurt your supply if you ended up exclusively pumping.

[@feistybunni1630]

Hello! Thank you so much for the videos I’ve been watching them to compare and order which breast pump I want I’m wondering if you can help me I have the spectra gold synergy as my main pump but now that I have a toddler I want a wearable this time I’m really stuck between the M5 and 12S Pro because with my first my milk supply didn’t really come in and make me a very low supplier due to complications but this time I’m hoping it will be different Thank you! 💗

[@MadisonLoethen]

I’d do the S12 pro if I were you because it’s stronger and can help with that supply

[@carmenchu536]

Hi, I’m using Mandela swing flex at home to pump exclusively on one boob as my baby doesn’t like taking from that side 😢. Milk supply is good. I just wondering M5, V2, or S12 when I just want a pump to be out and about when I’m in a restaurant or outdoor to pump some milk to avoid engorged breast. Which would you recommend ?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I'd do a tubeless one since you just need to pump on one side. The S12 pro can hold the most milk of these if you are an overproducer. :-)

[@jennanicole7785]

I’m debating on getting the v1 or v2, i have the baby buddha and spectra but they just don’t empty me efficiently, i have a set of wearables from kissbobo that empty me out better im looking for something : one to take to work and two efficiency with emptying me which would you recommend

[@MadisonLoethen]

I'd go with the V2! It works just as well and is much quieter and more portable.

[@josephinevilaikeo8629]

I have paid for V1 breasts pump and I have used it for a while but there is no breasts milk coming out of my chest

[@MadisonLoethen]

O no! Could it be time to replace the duckbills?

[@gulljaan4697]

Hey! I have a question with you plz suggest me which momcozy breast pump is good for me becaue my chest is smaller (36) and i also want that pump from which good milk supply plzz recommend me

[@MadisonLoethen]

A smaller chest shouldn’t make a difference and I think all of these have good suction! The S12 pro is my favorite without tubes and my V2 is my favorite with tubes

[@gulljaan4697]

@MadisonLoethen Thank you so much 💓 but plz suggest me which one I use I'm new🙂

[@KarolinaObara-fs5wy]

I have rather large breasts ( 36 ddd before pregnancy now even larger I’m not sure the size). I had very little milk with my previous baby, I need something powerful for large breasts and which gives as much freedom as possible what would you recommend?

[@MadisonLoethen]

I’d go with the V2! It has light cups and great strength

[@saidaharle3637]

What do you mean insert?

[@MadisonLoethen]

It’s the silicone sizer that goes in the flange. The size of it will depend on your nipple size

[@worldlydelicious]

Which one would you recommend for travel? I have a Dr. Browns breast pump already, but we are travelling abroad soon to i troduce baby to family so thought about getting the M5 but am just so unsure on which would be best.

[@MadisonLoethen]

I’d recommend the S12 pro or V2!

[@rashell282]

Hi, I’m deciding between the m5, s12 pro, v2 or Elvie stride. The tubes don’t bother me. I just want to make sure I can get maximum milk out. I use the spectra as my wall plug-in pump. And I’ll still use it in the morning and night. But need a pump to be able to walk around the house and get things done while baby naps. Also for when I return to work. I can get 3-5oz per pump just depending on time of day with spectra. Which one would you recommend?

[@MadisonLoethen]

For maximum output the S12 pro, V2 and Elvie stride are all pretty strong. The Elvie has an app if that's something you like. The s12 pro is probably the easiest to do the fridge hack with. It can be kinda nice that with the V2 and Elvie stride you only have one motor to mess with (turning it up and down, switching modes).

[@zaainrajpoot9364]

Superb performance 😍 love you u 🔥 baby Beautiful lovely sweet ♥

[@braydaestrada9256]

Which one do you recommend for beginners am a second time mom but with my first baby breastfeeding was not a good experience and I give up. He end up drinking Rx formula.

[@MadisonLoethen]

Probably the 12 pro or V2!

[@sydneychapman8143]

I'm trying to decide on a wearable pump to use at work. I like the s12 pro but i'm stuck on whether I should get that one or the m5. I work at Dollar General so I have to move around a lot so I need something that won't leak or move around in my bra so much. My baby is also starting to eat more so I need something that holds more than 5 ounces. My current wearable pump only holds 4 ounces and it moves around way too much in my bra and i'm always worried that its slipped out of place and isn't pumping right. would you recommend the s12 pro the m5 or another pump that isn't momcozy for me? thank you

[@MadisonLoethen]

I’d maybe look at the V2! The s12 pro is great it’s just not the quietest. Idk that the M5 would hold enough milk for you. If you don’t mind the tubes, the V2 is very quiet and can hold a lot.

[@sydneychapman8143]

@MadisonLoethen I really don't mind if my pump is loud cause the coolers at work are pretty loud that you can't really hear anything over them plus the customers that come in are always talking loud. I'd worry that with me moving around so much that the tubes on the V2 would get in the way so I'd rather not have tubes. so do you think the s12 would be better for mobility and volume?

[@MadisonLoethen]

@@sydneychapman8143 If you don't mind a tad loud then yes! I'd go with the S12 pro.

[@srividhyamohan300]

Hi I have a good supply. But my nipples will get sore. Please suggest one which best suits me

[@MadisonLoethen]

The M5 is probably the gentlest. I’d check your sizing! Sometimes an insert can cure the sore nipple problem.

[@hennarawoot-hx9mb]

Hey I am from India and I am having someone buy this for me !! How do I then decide the nipple size ? Are the pumps diff for different size of nipples ???

[@MadisonLoethen]

You’ll measure your nipple and use an insert according to your size. The pump comes with a measuring tool!

[@hennarawoot-hx9mb]

Does it come with different inserts or I’ll have to buy?