Mafia 3 vs Red Dead Redemption 2 - Physics and Details Comparison

[@danielmccoach1916]

Rdr2 is way more better and realistic game ever

[@PlayTopia11]

I agree

[@ladinos]

what?

[@TheRealMystermaN]

Nice English!

[@haincrixus]

Its a good game but there are have better ones dude stop being a fanboy

[@ladinos]

@@haincrixus bro the english in these comments

[@AMPER_51]

arthur can swim but john no

[@szabolcsmolnar352]

I just completed Mafia 3 and i discovered that the French Ward in Mafia 3 has exactly the same buildings as Saint Denis in RDR2. Great detail from both games in trying to make a fictional New Orleans. Also the Bayou in Mafia 3 has very similar places as the Lemoyne Swamps in RDR2

[@t33thagrt11]

Know what they forgot though one more new orleans gem ac liberation

[@huyanh6782]

Mafia 3 release in 2016

[@berrakoz353]

And when I played Assassin's Creed Syndicate, I felt that this game is similar to RDR2.

[@maxrobinson387]

Saint Denis was originally going to be called New Bordeaux.

[@thepianisthd]

Even making this comparison is extremely silly, as it was so obvious from the start that RDR2 would win decisively, given that Mafia 3 is a big trash game.

[@outlowrobber9814]

Keep in mind that mafia 3 is from 2016 and was made from 2k and hangar 13 meanwhile rdr2 was made 2018 by rockstar which had way more budget so the game was ahead of its time

[@PlayTopia11]

Ya

[@abcdeeeeff]

It's about skills of the artist . What more money has to do with doing your job properly

[@iibreezy2x868]

@@abcdeeeeffthe more money u have the better the pay is for designers. More money= the best designers.

[@Majimasfa]

Another rockstar clown​@@abcdeeeeff

[@gameman256]

Shut up

[@humanshrek1836]

When comparing both the games, you should’ve used Arthur for RDR2, especially for the swimming comparison. John can’t swim, but Arthur can swim in Red Dead 2.

[@PlayTopia11]

True

[@JEPH610]

It’s not true Arthur Morgan can swim but not John Marston !🤨

[@Daniel_editxz]

Is true

[@PlayTopia11]

Yea but I displayed arthur

[@arnoldthegreat4138]

the vehicle explosions is physics related theres no animation.

[@akilkotamarti1000]

The swimming one is pretty unfair given John canonically can't swim.

[@Just2Fake.]

2:48 i love how john drink a stamina fortifiant before to go swimming 😂😂😂 Edit : the player mistaken the fortifiant it wasn't for the stamina it was for the dead eye 🤦‍♀️

[@PlayTopia11]

I thought it was for stamina 🤔

[@PlayTopia11]

I thought it was for stamina 🤔

[@Just2Fake.]

@@PlayTopia11 well actually it aint but its okay that was funny 😂

[@markcecoash]

Don’t have to do this ever again. RDR2’s physics and realism and interaction with other characters and NPC’s is far more superior than every game I have ever played. Smoothest game too. GOAT GAME.

[@Dutch622]

the best answer is rdr2 is the best

[@littleegomaniac4812]

Mafia 3 and RDR2 have many similar places

[@Apexdoor383]

That cause u are playing as john arthur knows how to swim and can swim longer 2:46

[@PlayTopia11]

Ik

[@Al-Pacino-k7v]

A Mafia Game with Rdr 2 graphics would be cool to

[@ShadowCid-t3e]

the only thing that missing in rdr series is diving

[@berrakoz353]

It's an insult to compare a disappointing game like Mafia 3 with the truly legendary game RDR 2.

[@theFedHD]

disappointing my ass lol, it's the best of the three gameplay-wise, best takedown animations, best open world and variety of things to do, yeah Mafia 2 had different features like eating and drinking and the 1st (remake) had better story of course, but the general feeling, the little details and side missions are Mafia 3's strength, in Mafia 2 you have to play DLCs to have some extra things to do, otherwise apart from selling cars or robbing stores there's nothing else to do.

[@ArthurMorgan-rdr2gta]

I got bored of Mafia 3, I player Mafia 1, enjoyed it, I played Mafia 2, enjoyed it, and then I got to mafia 3 and just couldn’t bare to continue playing it, I might reinstall it for the cars though

[@the.real.Deano.]

The swimming thing is only with john marston in rdr2 Arthur can swim. John cant.

[@PlayTopia11]

Yea

[@areptumpang]

Its unfair, RDR2 can only be compared with real life.

[@Pb3-Vids]

No company shall compare to Rockstar 4lyfe🗿

[@Mrushman96]

Wow brro comparison video my favourite video

[@Daniel_editxz]

Pls dont scamm me indian

[@pakolxtvcd9835]

Mafia 3 is a fuckin disaster..

[@theFedHD]

lol you guys don't fking know how to judge a product do you hahhahah

[@asd-xx7ub]

if you want to compare , playing as arthur is better

[@PlayTopia11]

Indeed

[@cristianamenadiel9859]

You can’t compare both of this games Mafia is still a developing game and is clear on top for that made fork different company’s

[@GgElite-2023]

I can't save the mafia 3 and the game doesn't make autosave.can someone help me?

[@YonnyardinesCr7]

En qué consola ?

[@ezioauditore8946]

​@@YonnyardinesCr7en ps2

[@injusticemobile2962]

I love both

[@tusjoestar3096]

Hey, only John can't swim :))

[@FARSHAD1997D]

2018 vs 2016 games >>>>> 2024 to feature games

[@alpick9096]

RDR2 vs Mafia 3 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK

[@IdkdjdjKdkdkd]

People are forgeting that rockstar are is a WAY bigger company than 2k so they cant do as much but the mafia games have always been good games just wish the police would still pull u over for speeding im not saying rdr isnt good im saying that the mafia games are good but not as good as rockstar games like if gta had a police speeding pull over thats it it would be soooo cool

[@hugocarvalho8906]

dude comparing mafia 3 hahaha... you need to compare with something the same level (gta v)... all those are from same enterprise, difference is mafia team is little compared with rockstar north and sandiego

[@PlayTopia11]

There's no harm in comparison

[@habibmunsin]

Don't compare just play and enjoy men ❤

[@PlayTopia11]

Ok I will

[@thepianisthd]

Even making this comparison is extremely silly, as it was so obvious from the start that RDR2 would win decisively, given that Mafia 3 is a big trash game.

[@elcanaldele000]

Mafia 3 tenia potencial para ser un juegazo,perdo decidieron hacerlo generico...una lastima..

[@Justlight-88]

Zero comparison... rdr2 ws the best ever game with the best ever script.... rdr3, if made, may beat it only.. no other game can

[@mehedyhasan2436]

Hahaha 😂 lol How can anybody think about to compare RDR 2 ? THAT'S impossible RDR 2 is the best game of all time ❤

[@BhaweshKumar-yl5tz]

Mafia 3 really?

[@PlayTopia11]

Ya

[@pablobarbozacanal]

RDR2 wins

[@Игрыснезыч]

Нету жанцав канбоя топ

[@maav5516]

there ain´t nothing to compare hah this is stupid

[@funnyrailroadcrossing2767]

Rdr always overated

[@Karl_08]

Why?

[@namgunaucao9771]

show me a openworld game better than rdr2 kid

[@hareendrangangadharan6974]

The word is *overrated .. oh sorry You seems less interested in details right... carry with your rail crossing

[@Yourgymrat56]

Nuh uh

[@Carl-edits346]

​​@@namgunaucao9771overrated doesn't mean it's bad. Dumbo

[@ЕвгенАндреев-ц5в]

Тупое сравнение.

[@Knownsky]

you're mad i'm pretty sure. both games are good.

[@Pybik_C3H6O3]

Оно смешное. Как только ты видишь, что что-то сравнивают с рдр 2, сразу понятно, что она победит

[@VTaurus7598]

​@@KnownskyMafia 3 is completely buggy, there are compilations of the bugs in this game... people are making fun of Mafia 3. The game is crap.

[@IrfanKhan-jl5nw]

mafia 3 too much best

[@Flypandaflypanda]

Even comparing the two is an insult.RDR 2 is on another level, Mafia 3 is not even garbage, it's worse

[@PlayTopia11]

No harm in comparing