Maison Margiela REPLICA Fragrances Ranked - Top 10

My opinion on the best Maison Martin Margiela fragrances from the Replica collection.

[@290revolver290]

I love your videos a lot. So genuine.

[@shueuejekeke4457]

Man I don’t know what about you but I could listen to you talk for hours. Great video!

[@JT-rx1eo]

I have a bottle of Jazz Club and a sample of At the Barbers. I wore Jazz Club once or twice before the warm weather hit, but what I remember was the unique, almost "raunchy", tobacco. I thought the unique raunchiness of tobacco was appropriate for a jazz club vibe. As I remember it, it's a good scent. Need more wearings this coming fall though. At the Barbers is a pretty decent "barbershop" Fougere and I'm really into fougeres. In fact I have a big wall-mounted display vitrine full of nothing but barbershop fougeres, each one sort of lined up by ranking as to my favorites and fidelity to the "barbershop" vibe. So ahead of At the Barbers are: Tom Ford Beau de Jour Penhaligon Sartorial Tom Ford Fougere D'Argent MDCI Invasion Barbare YSL Rive Gauche then maybe At the Barbers. It's pretty good but I thought the perfumer maybe over thought it just a bit. I mean, adding leather because the barber's chair is leather? Is that necessary? I think the ones I've sat in are maybe vinyl anyway. Lol. It's not that the leather is too prominent or really detracts from the overall barbershop vibe at all. Just the thought of adding it. Why not metallic to replicate the scissors? Or linoleum for the floors? Aquatic for the water they spray? Lol. Anyway, pretty good and I'll have to pick up a full bottle. I have a ways to go to build my Replica line, but it's on the agenda. Thanks for the informative review.

[@UrbanDwellerNYC]

Thanks for the detailed insight! Love your choices for barbershop scents. I haven't tried all of them.

[@EggWafflehea]

You might like Music festival from the line, it has apple and earthy patchouli so the scent has an interesting edge.

[@renrenkung]

I am in decision making of jazz club and by the fireplace after a few chance of trying both of them at the store. (I do have g&g the one which is quite familiar but i do like jazz club more than the one.) Thanks for your video to decided to choose me by the fireplace and i buy it immediately after watch this 😆

[@joeslacker1020]

Do you think jazz club is too popular it has a few thousand reviews on fragrantica

[@TheGrelots]

How would you compare the one and jazz club? I really like the scent of the one but the company not so much.

[@skylarchon]

you’re the best :D

[@AlexBakkerthevloglife]

Just bought by the fireplace 2 days ago. Love at first sniff too, such a unique fragrance. Love the 30ml bottles as well. How do you think about lipstick being discontinued?

[@UrbanDwellerNYC]

I haven't smelled that one or looked into the notes. Any good?

[@cachapoy]

I like Jazz Club, i can't relate with you cause i dont own the perfumes you just mentioned. For me its unique as i dont really go for scents like this

[@chrisscentsillage5321]

By The Fireplace is a super great frag but...my heart stays with Lipstick On!

[@aromafh2486]

Very nice video/aroma from heaven

[@semzip8558]

Great vid! Would you say you prefer JV Vintage or At the barbers more?

[@UrbanDwellerNYC]

JV Vintage is definitely more unique and my pick, also a lot cheaper(!) but At the Barber's is a lot fresher of course, and perhaps a bit more versatile (like as a safe work scent)

[@semzip8558]

@@UrbanDwellerNYC thank you friend!

[@suzannetaylor6285]

No more lipstick on! Whispers in the library and I’ve heard at the barbershop may also be discontinued 😢

[@marielang9474]

Irish Tweed is probably one of the first modern fougeres

[@marielang9474]

I don't get Irish Tweed AT ALL from Jazz Club. Irish is so much more fresh and green. lol

[@marielang9474]

True! BTF is sooo unique. Hyperrealistic. People ask if I smoke tho when they smell this, but still compliment it hahahha

[@CH-yp5by]

Wow you're getting through the fragrance houses.

[@UrbanDwellerNYC]

I couldn’t find a good overview for myself so had to!

[@joeslacker1020]

​@@UrbanDwellerNYC Have you reviewed Hanae Mori "HM" (in frosted white bottle edt or edp) or Ungaro Pour L'Homme III. I see you have some heavy hitters you've reviewed and I'm curious to see what your honest opinion on these two would be.

[@UrbanDwellerNYC]

@@joeslacker1020 I haven’t reviewed it but I own HM and mentioned it in one of my lists!

[@UrbanDwellerNYC]

Good fragrance, I gotta pull it out again

[@joeslacker1020]

@@UrbanDwellerNYC Yeah you should review that one, man.

[@marielang9474]

I love tropical scents and beach walk ain't it. Soleil Blanc is better (but more exp). We seem to have opposite tastes haha

[@M.Moadeli123]

I bought a sample pack of them all. Longevity is so weak I can't even take them seriously enough to buy a bottle (especially at the price it's retailed for a weak perfume). Shame. Otherwise I liked lazy Sunday morning, jazz club and fireplace

[@jankocian9659]

! Jazz Club !

[@rabbit5000]

can I just say that you are cute af hahahaha

[@NurKurt2706]

Great review, are you on Instagram?

[@xvvan9662]

Hello Doc, I love your videos, You make great contents, what do you think of the Hermes eau de Cologne collection ? They are very natural Smelling and in some of your videos you said that you love the natural smelling over the chimicals, my favorite from this collection is « Eau d’orange verte » it’s really a masterpiece go check this one and maybe an idea for you of reviews videos !

[@UrbanDwellerNYC]

Thanks! I'll be honest I have to try that collection.