Madewell Transport Totes Comparison

[@AndiHester]

4:28 in, I'm already like, "She's so nice, I want to be her friend." You have a such a sweet, relaxed way of describing things--such a nice change of pace from KZbin vids that practically scream at you.

[@laurabirdie7]

I have the Transport Tote as my work bag and I carry my laptop back and forth everyday. I've had the bag since June and haven't had any issues with the handles. Just for reference, I have a Lenovo ThinkPad and it's fairly light. I generally have a full water bottle in it and I've also used it to carry my personal laptop (MacBook Pro) and haven't had any issues. :-)

[@HeyJessica]

My Madewell Transport tote has carried a 15" Retina MacBook Pro for 2 years and I haven't noticed any issues or wear. In fact, it still looks beautiful! I even use a padded slim laptop sleeve for added protection and can still fit everything I need in the bag. I've used the Madewell Transport Tote since your "What's in my bag" video a coupe years(?!) ago. Like you, I was on the hunt for a beautiful bag that can be used for work. The moment I saw your video I know it was the one. I love the simplicity and find it works well with every outfit. Thanks again! I love your videos. 😊

[@vsb000]

Hey Jessica which specific bag do you have?

[@liliaseventeen]

You have the loveliest voice ever!! Also I was so shocked to see that you don't have hundreds of thousands of subs! Lovely video.

[@dianapascucci9498]

I bought the cross body bag off your earlier recommendation and I absolutely love it! I wouldn't change a thing about it and that says a lot, I'm pretty picky about handbags. Thank you so much, your videos are so helpful and you're a joy to watch!

[@mamapod2]

I have the satchel, and I love it! Because it does conform to your body, it does not feel as heavy as other bags.

[@LaurenJohnson]

This was so helpful! I've considered getting the original Transport Tote for a year or so, but just haven't committed to it yet! I love the look of the crossbody!

[@WonderlandAdventurez]

They all look very simple yet chic at the same time. Definitely seem like you could use anyone of them with what you are wearing without clashing. I to have a tendency to over pack my bags because they can fit so much. Just never know what I might need. ❤

[@marie-evelegault156]

I bought the crossbody about 2 years ago and I looooooooove it ! I wore it so much. Now I really want the satchel !

[@Laura-mv1eb]

You are so lovely! Thanks so much for making such an in depth comparison

[@makeupTIA]

You are so welcome, Laura! Thanks for watching. 😀

[@BeeDeeLite]

You're def right! They get better the longer you have them. I had mine for 2 yrs now and I still love them so much. I've got 2 of their satchels as well. I just love Madewell bags. Great quality! ☺️

[@user-lh4vh8lv7k]

Great comparison and the way you set and break details. Makes Madewell job easy.. thank you!!❤

[@halfpastsunday]

I've had my Transport Satchel for almost 3 years now. It's very slouchy now, but the leather still looks great. I didn't baby that bag at all either!

[@makeupTIA]

That's great to read!

[@jmg102090]

This video couldn't have come at a more perfect time! I wanted to use my birthday money on finally investing in one of these gorgeous bags and have officially decided on the cross body tote! ❤️

[@susanwright134]

Madewell gal here also! I have the Transport Satchel, in True Black with English saddle handles, the older Bucket bag with the drawstring and leather handle in English Saddle, several post earrings ( after seeing them on your channel) a couple of necklaces that I found on sale and a few tops that were also on sale. Oh yeah, I also have the crisscross sandals in English saddle. And all of this began with seeing it on your channel Ashley ! lol

[@brittanywilson1706]

I have been eyeing these bags forever! Thank you for this video! It definitely helped me pick although I think I might need all three!

[@sarahmarinkovich-durfee4509]

this was such a helpful video! Especially since you loaded the bags down. I feel like the small bag can fit more than I thought when I looked at it online. Thanks!!

[@doyourememberanna]

Wow! This is such a great, in-depth comparison. Madewell makes the best bags and shoes. I haven't bit the bullet with shoes yet, but I bought the transport crossbody, in large part, because of you! I really want the other two sizes you have as well, haha! One day (: They're a great investment!

[@beckyfredenburg9518]

You are my zen videos- so calming yet informative. Thank you :). I've been really trying to compare which made well bag I want and this video was super helpful. Thanks again!!

[@makeupTIA]

You are welcome, Becky! ☺️

[@greylilycalligraphy]

Very helpful review, it's helped me decide between two of them. I REALLY wish the mid-sized one came in all black!

[@bstrong5016]

I love the transport tote and I have to agree that a laptop fits but is too heavy for the straps. The English saddle colour is beautiful and does go with so much. The mini crossbody is tempting.....

[@ByAnnaRaya]

Thank you for finding that essential oil bag in Rifle Paper Co. fabric! What a find! And thanks so much for the comparison of three styles. I recently ordered the crossbody style during the 30% off sale, but I couldn't tell how big/small it was on the mannequin in the photo on Madewell's site. Well, it arrived and was way too small for my needs. Next time the sale comes around I'm getting the satchel. I guess I could've just checked the dimensions in the description. Now I know, but your packing examples are much more helpful!

[@karennadherny7615]

Great video! I have the transport large tote in both black and the tan. I love these bags!

[@rachelesparza7833]

Hi Ashley, loved your video! I was so wishing you would make a video on your favorite fall essentials. I love your fall favorites every year!

[@ski1777]

Because of your first video of the transport tote, I bought one! I absolutely love it!! Love the review and love this video too. I might want to get the real small one now 😳😊👍🏼

[@nbeganovic96]

can you do a review on the dagne dover mini tote?

[@triciaprieto478]

Hi Ashley! This is just a super random message since I had no where else to put it lol! I know you get this a lot, but your videos are so well made and organized...The way they are edited and the way your personality reflects on camera is just such a pleasure to watch. This is my favorite channel by far, it's just so genuine, I feel like friends! I trust your opinion and would love to know if you plan on doing any favorite fall/early winter lip favorites? I have been really into matte liquid/creme lipsticks but I also have the dry lip problem ocassionally. A cold weather lip routine (chapsticks, lip treatments, scrubs) and lippy favorites would just be lovely... Thank you, Holly ♡

[@DeborahSutherlandDebinPei]

Madwell rocks, one of my fav shops but strangely I've yet to get a bag.............of course I want all 3 of these lol. Thanks for the great comparison.

[@noelleenns9661]

Just wondering if you can fit a 13" laptop (with a soft case on it) in the transport satchel?

[@ourdreamscollide]

I use the Satchel as my daily commuting bag and it's really perfect for it. I'm so glad to see that they reinforced the satchel's carry-strap--I got the satchel when it first came out, and it's a little too flimsy for me to functionally carry it on the long strap. I was thinking about getting the Tote, but I think when my bag wears out, I'm going to stick with the satchel! Thanks for helping me decide :)

[@TwoOnlyChildrenxoxox]

I've been waiting for this 5ever! It was the perfect way to end the longest day ever. I love everything, and will certainly go broke on Etsy, now.

[@Kennedyc07]

I have truly beat the crap out of the original Madewell Transport Tote. I carry my 13" work laptop in it and use it as my work bag... mostly. 8 months strong and no issues. I have to carry a lot stuff for work, like scales, thermometers, notebooks, and other office-y shhhhhtuff (I work for the corporate office of a large coffee chain and travel to stores often). No signs or any damage. LOVE MADEWELL BAGS!!

[@ashbammerlin]

These bags are so stunning!! And I'm definitely going to be doing some Etsy searching things made out of the Rifle Paper Co fabric! 😍

[@jesscurrierstudio]

And yes, SUCH a helpful video!! I have the original transport tote (partially due to your past review!) and love it.

[@anuheamontiho8387]

Since you were the inspiration behind me purchasing the Transport East West tote, it's only fitting that now after this video I have the satchels on my Christmas list lol. Thanks for being such an amazing person! ❤️❤️

[@AOmega84]

Perfect review of the madewell bags! I've been waiting fort his video for a long time! But now it seems like I might have to buy two of them lol not great for my wallet. Also love all the cute stuff you put in your bags!

[@katieswitzer7256]

Hey Ashley - when you do your planner haul can you show us how you store all of your stickers and planner accessories? I know I've seen you use a zipper pouch that fits into your A5 binder - I am looking for sticker storage ideas for my bound planner

[@IsabelVelazquez]

So informative, Ashley! Only recently did I realize that there were differences between these 3 bags, so this video was very useful. I still can't decide between all 3, but at least I have more information on each of them to base my decision off of. :)

[@SummerLovesGlitter]

This is the best handbag review I've ever seen.

[@jemmagibson4177]

What a review! thank you for this video, exactly what i was looking for.. and presented so incredibly well.. Looking forward to seeing more of your clips

[@dreamanddwell]

So so helpful, Ashley!! Thank you very much! Love the cross body and satchel!!

[@makeupTIA]

Thanks, Hannah! And I'm happy to see you back on YT. Hope you've been well. : )

[@joellechiara]

phew! I thought I was the only one with the obsession with 'if it works, get many in different sizes and colors.' I wish you had the East West Tote - I am dying to see what you would think of that one.

[@makeupTIA]

Haha! You are not alone! If I love something, I usually have it in at least one other color. ; )

[@oddsendsandfriends8264]

Any chance you could make a video to show how you tie that scarf on the transport? Thank you!

[@mocha1886]

Thank you so much for this helpful video Ashley, you already inspired me to purchase the satchel in a navy blue. I use it for school and I absolutely love how comfortable and spacious it is. That camel color is gorgeous though, I might just have to ask for another one for my birthday 😉

[@almatoledo1608]

Have you an opinion on Madewell vs Whipping post vintage?¿ beautiful voice and presentation.

[@sarapalomino4198]

This video helped me so much. I now know what bag I'm going to purchase!!!!

[@eaSophia]

Isn't it about time for a November Plan with Me video?? :) Love every video you make Ashley:)

[@augusthippie2768]

Did you re-buy all of it because the mini and large tote were brown in the what's in my bag videos?

[@Eeellddee]

Yep, thanks to you, I have all three 😀😀 and they are exactly the same as yours! 😁

[@makeupTIA]

Twins!! 😀👯

[@livepoorgetrichdietrying4815]

Hi, love your video! One question about the black Post Wallet-- when you use it with your black tote, is it hard to see it in your bag? I have the same bag and want to get that wallet too, but I'm afraid it will blend in too much....

[@fatiher1]

I've used my totes as diaper bags and now that she's toddler they're perfect for our everyday. Love them!

[@makeupTIA]

That's an awesome idea! Stylish too. 😃

[@gracearnold3250]

i bought a bandana from made well after i saw this and i can not figure out how to tie it on my bag AGH do you have a video on how to?

[@jesscurrierstudio]

Completely unrelated to this video content, but I have that exact same "all you need is love... and a cat" sign on our kitchen window sill right now and that just made my day 👌🏻😸

[@bonnieshapiro3511]

I bought the medium transport bag a few years ago but it seemed to bend in half so I returned it. I’ve been watching a few videos again and it seems like the medium I’ve seen in these videos don’t do that. Do you think I just got a bag that was slouchier. I like it to have some form. Maybe I should check it out again.

[@edcataldo]

This is such an informative and thorough video! A lot of the reviews on the madewell site have complaints about the dye staining their clothes. Have you had any problems with the dye bleeding or staining?

[@cselenee90]

OMG Tia! I got the Transport Crossbody in The brown color and I love it ! And right away they came out with the Medium Transport Tote 😔😔 hahaha! I need a coupon to buy it ! Lol

[@KMan-ye2kp]

Thank you for this video. I came across your video while searching totes. Now that you've had your madewell totes for a while how do you think they are holding up? Do you use them every day? I'm trying to decide between the Madewell and the Whipping Post tote. I was on the madewell site the other day and they now have a zippered version of the regular sized tote.

[@pEAcEgrL8]

Thank you for such a great video Ashley! Would a packed lunch fit in the transport satchel?

[@almatoledo1608]

Ladies and gentlemen, why...why am I so in love with such a simple tote?¿ I need to decide if Whipping post or Madewell and such a charm I love to adorn a simple tote, bag or valise.

[@shermrey]

Ashlee, I miss your vlogs. Nice to see you on YNAB but I want more. 🤪

[@melindacasino2114]

Whoa - what video software are you using? I'm loving the text & graphics that you're using to open your video...

[@leahmacev11]

Have you had issues with the underside of the crossbody straps "roughing up" your clothing? I've been eyeing the satchel, but I've read so many reviews saying that the leather on the underside is unfinished and has a tendency to catch on or snag more delicate fabrics.

[@BashfulBeautyy]

Hi! Thanks for the comparisons. Have you had an issues with your bag (inside and outside) staining things?

[@Bee0273]

I always look forward to your videos. They're lovely 😊

[@ruestinteriors]

Gah, that essential oils bag!! Genius! I need.

[@makeupTIA]

So cute, right?! 😀

[@VeronicaGarcia-od4ce]

Love your bag collection. Wondering how your new work bag is comparing to the madewell?

[@makeupTIA]

I only use the Madewell bags as purses (this video was just to contrast them and give ideas on how to use them). The Dagne Dover is my sole work bag - I love it! : ) I carry all my work gear in the DD and my purse/personal items in one of the Madewell bags to work each day.

[@marissasuperstar]

The cat is my favorite lol. Thanks for the comparison video.

[@karenmessineo2222]

What is the longest length the strap can be extended to on the Satchel? I have a very long torso and the crossbody was extremely short on me. Thank you!

[@rachelfew3762]

Did you spray your bags?

[@Stefsaurus83]

Omg I love your marble case for the lab top where is it from? It's so lovely thank u!!

[@makeupTIA]

Etsy! It's linked in the description box. : )

[@Aymeele]

i'm thinking of purchasing it as my work bag. do you recommend carrying it in the rain?

[@parkyunhee2461]

I really don't prefer madewell bags, but still since its Ashley's video, I'll for sure watch it.☺️

[@makeupTIA]

Thanks for watching!!

[@banditsmia9650]

Hi, Tia, I'm Mia. I want to buy the mini now, but kinda struggling between black and brown, what do you think?

[@angelalovee]

Where are the small scarves from?

[@barbysimmons9635]

Hi. Will your a5 filofax fit in the cross body?

[@makeupTIA]

Hi, Barby! It takes up pretty much the whole bag, but, yes, it does fit in there. : )

[@Melody-dz8ic]

This video does help me to make a choice, thank u very much!

[@RPG0018]

Very nice review. Truly appreciate

[@brittosu7]

Hello! This video is so helpful, which bag is your favorite of the 3?!

[@makeupTIA]

Tough question! Probably the original. 😀

[@Yayashug1]

Wonder how they compare to the Chic Sparrow tote

[@lcastaneda77]

How does the Zip-Top Transport Carryall differ from the Transport Satchel? Apparently the Satchel is not available at the moment and I would like to know if the Carryall functions like the Satchel..Any information would be helpful!

[@krystlekarl7174]

Lenette Castañeda I would like to know as well! I’ve been wanting one for awhile and thought the satchel would be perfect but the carryall looks so different!

[@melissashah3461]

Do you have the original transport tote and the mini crossbody in multiple colors? If so, have you noticed a quality difference in the bags you've purchased more recently compared to your older bags? Loved this video and all of your floral pouches! :)

[@makeupTIA]

Hi, Melissa! The first crossbody I had was the older strap design that was defective. It was pretty annoying. I can't tell you how many times I was walking around, the strap came undone, and my bag fell to the floor. 😣 Happily, they fixed the issue. Also, the leather on the newer version feels stiffer (my old one wouldn't really stand up straight on its own, but I did like how soft it was).

[@melissashah3461]

makeupTIA thanks so much for your reply! What a bummer about your old crossbody strap - I'm so happy to hear they fixed it! This video and your perspective are super helpful!

[@ariannakane6716]

Love your videos - I have 2 of the 3!!

[@makeupTIA]

💃 Thanks for watching, Arianna!

[@naziajalal7332]

Hey Ashley ..amazing review presented and explained so well .. just need a lil more help .. am currently looking for a more structured bag ..medium size ..and madewell has none except the ones you mentioned(not structured) .. any suggestions Ashley .. as am so sure coming from you .. i will love them .. Thank you !!

[@lylarush]

One other comparison point is weight of the bags. Can you please share this information as well?

[@makeupTIA]

It looks like ShopBop lists all the different weights. Just click on the one you are interested in, and the weight it on the right side of the screen. ☺️ www.shopbop.com/actions/viewSearchResultsAction.action?searchButton=Submit&query=transport+tote&searchSuggestion=true

[@lylarush]

makeupTIA thanks!

[@hanciastefanski7860]

I hope Madewell will bring the medium satchel back :-)

[@Summersky95]

I love your videos! You are so sweet!

[@234mara]

hi! do you think my schoolbooks would fit in the satchel??

[@makeupTIA]

Hey, yes, I think so, depending on how many you have, but size-wise you should be good. : )

[@zahral786]

Great video!

[@camzhao]

Does your macbook fit in the satchel? Or a folder/ larger notebook?

[@makeupTIA]

I have a 9.5" x 12.5" document envelope that fits in the satchel. I just tried my 13" laptop. You have to tilt it to get it through the opening, but it does fit (just not a ton of extra space once it's in).

[@sarahhampton6009]

I just love you!

[@makeupTIA]

♥️😘 Thanks, Sarah!

[@julia.no.X]

A great quality video!

[@bibsandbows7200]

Watching while I patiently wait for my zip transport (middle size) to arrive.

[@ggabriella123]

Do the unfinished leather straps get worn in enough so that they do not fray clothing?

[@makeupTIA]

Hi, Gabriella! I haven't noticed any issue with the straps fraying my tops. : )

[@Blove0130]

Did you quit using the Dagne Dover bag? I think the DD tote is so much more practical than the Madewell totes and the Dagne Dover bags look more professional.

[@makeupTIA]

I personally only use the Madewell bags as purses. I was just giving ideas on how much each bag can hold. I carry the Dagne Dover and one of the Madewell ones each day to work. One of my best friends, though, loves the original Transport for her everyday work bag, so it can definitely work for that. : )

[@susanwright134]

AWE...There's Moe Moe!