Makino/Shan Cai Piano Scene in different versions (Meteor Garden/Hana Yori Dango/Boys Over Flowers)

Piano performances in all versions of Hana Yori Dango except for the 1995 movie version
Inspired content from RPG and Horror Lover Hans
1. Hana Yori Dango comic/anime (Japan) 1992/1996
2. Meteor Garden serials (Taiwan) 2001
3. Hana Yori Dango serials (Japan) 2007
4. Boys Over Flowers serials (Korea) 2009
5. Meteor Garden serials remake (China) 2018
You can also support this channel by donating (Completely optional): paypal.me/acec...
#MeteorGarden #HanaYoriDango #BoysOverFlowers

[@playlistrecap]

You can also support the channel: buymeacoffee.com/?via=tambayansclub Comment down below your favorite scene from the series across different versions and what do you want to see next? Have a good day 😊

[@belleame1249]

How about when dao ming si's mom offered money to shan cai's family to keep dao ming si away from Sahn Cai but the family declined

[@playlistrecap]

@@belleame1249 that's also what I was thinking before. Thank you, I may wait for the Thai version for this scene as well 😊

[@belleame1249]

@@playlistrecap yes pls include the Thai version in ur future videos

[@CrisOnTheInternet]

The 2001 kept the original scene and added the beautiful melody, that's a great balance.

[@jenniferlim1687]

I remember Jihoo taught Jandi how to play the piano piece but I dont remember who taught Sancai? As for Makino, the character really ddnt know how to play...

[@moshimoshimaddie868]

2001 was well executed 🔥 Shancai's words and expressions 💯👌

[@yknowwhutitis9794]

A western philosopher once said this. " Women, dazzling diamonds & glittering jewelry have won you illusionary majesty But what's left around you is only snobbish poison, the odour of arrogance & alluring but fatal fragrance. Women, when you once again salute wealth, hail, fame, & exotal power, please don't ask about the thrush which sang to you. It has flown away because it has sung itself hoarse. It's golden voice has perished for the sake of it's real, dignified & pure soul. " -Dong Shancai [barbie hsu] taiwanese adaptation 2001

[@ClipPerry]

For this scene, 2001 version is the best! San Chai Sarcastic smile is on point 😂

[@anabelpoubeato8054]

I liked how, in the anime, Tsukasa smiled when she didnt know how to play the piano, as if he was proud of who she really was. Thats why I didnt like the 2001 version in which she somehow knew how to do it, even though she is poor and has never taken piano lessons.

[@chowdhuryafifafatema4306]

Yeah ikr I thought so too like she has to save up money to get the bare minimum but heyy she knows how to play the piano

[@user-sq2fo2vn6h]

2D Tsukasa still the best

[@dollymandavi8372]

At last she said n that that's the only tune she knows.....cause she is poor ...

[@princessmimi1586]

i like taiwanese version tho❤

[@alexadyshiii3263]

A lot of them likes every version but for me... JAPANESE VERSION IN UNBEATABLE ... Its so funny and the characters have great chemistry, and a lot of unexpected and surprising plot occured which makes the story beautiful... Especially the ending.. its the most satisfying ending I've watch over watching a lot of dramas.. I hope that when you watch it, it can give you a remarkable experience... In Japanese version it is entitled as HANA YORI DANGO... I really hope that you guys could watch it (Japanese version)... And yess every version are unique so this is just my opinion

[@kimbinge3825]

I liked BOF the best because she was singing it to him but it also got the message through to his mom that she loved him. Plus it was a huge FU to her by her playing the piano well with the sweet song.

[@doctordonnanoble]

The way the 2001 Taiwanese version approached it is pure perfection. Start off with hilarious smashing of keys, evil glare at the mother, followed by simple unpracticed playing while reciting poetry that disses the mother. There's no better response.

[@piapaurillo3634]

I love Shancai and Jandi's version 😍♥️...

[@asyonubanate9802]

2001 Shancai's nailed it..! Her acting ability was superb, and even her eyes can act as well..!

[@mariaman1666]

I love how the Koreans decided to be diferrent from the others.Jan Di was the only one that actually sang something both at piano and her voice...the biggest proof that Hye-Sun is both a good actrice,singer and songwriter. Yes...I got the Point of all the other speeches but în this special scene Jan Di's version wins...not just because if the originality but because of the feeling. Plus she was the only one asked to do it for the boy she loves.All the others we're practicly asked to embarras themselves. Plus...Jan Di came to Jun Pyo's birthday to see him...and have a proper conversation with him.And the song was her way to speak to him and actaually make him listen. In all the others was about proving to the wich bitch that "heart metters most". And was a talk to the mother not the beloved one.

[@mariaman1666]

Also,agreed.Brabie Shu was amazing with her ice-ish speech.So out all,her's is the secound best to me.

[@ann-official9506]

2009..Got my ❤ jandi is the best she can sang and playing a piano..the best

[@marycrisalbe6322]

2001 is the best the fierce of Sanchai is inimitable

[@yknowwhutitis9794]

Does the nature of a person's soul depend on the playing of a tune? Or does it depend on his family background? So what if a person wears branded stuff & plays the piano? This is the only tune i can play, But so what? -Dong Shancai [barbie hsu] taiwanese adaptation 2001 I loved her attitude! instead of being a coward like other poor girls & hesitating - she wasn't afraid ~! i haven't watched taiwanese, thai, & japanese adaptations but i loved her! her smirk & cheeky smile 🤧

[@anjaligautam315]

Bays over flowers my favorite drama

[@coolNerdnextdoor]

Boys*

[@yknowwhutitis9794]

The moment you stood next to me I liked the way your eyes looked Though i cried yesterday Today because of you My tomorrow will be happy Neither his face, Nor his style I just needed his tender love To forget all the time That has passed Without you i can't nothing but love I know nothing but love -Geum JanDi [gu hye seon] korean adaptation 2009

[@chowdhuryafifafatema4306]

It's actually very strange they decided to improvise and add that Shancai or Guem jandi can SOMEHOW play the piano when they are like so pooorr barely making it through. Even most rich people don't know how to play the piano but guess what she does because she is the female lead, the best of the best. Even so out of the adaptations I would say 2001 Shancai was very satisfying to watch.

[@kimbinge3825]

I think they explained it by having Jandi spend a lot of time with Jihoo while he played the piano. I thought her playing was rather simplistic. Like he showed her some stuff.

[@carolinamunoz3357]

es que le enseño varias veces lee

[@carolinamunoz3357]

2018

[@jazmin737]

The 2001 Taiwan version is lit damn Shancai in this was so savage Btw looking forward to F4 Thai on how they would pull this scene

[@yknowwhutitis9794]

" Humans. When you put more importance in the clothes they wear than the wisdom they possess. When you put more importance in the jewelry they wear than the righteousness, kindness, & bravery. When you're easily fooled by illusory comparisons & couldn't see the pure heart that's burning & beating right in front of you. You lost the right to have real human emotions. '' Tagore once said, '' Set the bird's wing with gold & birds won't fly over. " A person's value isn't decided by his social class & status. I don't come from a well-known family. I can only play this song. But so what? My heart is open & honest -Dong Shancai [ Shen Yue ] Chinese adaptation 2018 As an Indian, i'm so happy that Rabindranath Tagore Quote: “Set the bird's wings with gold and it will never again soar in the sky.” is mentioned in my most favorite chinese drama ~!!! i've watched the Meteor Garden 2018 thrice & i'll still be absorbed in its episodes if i watch it again !

[@freedom-qm5wj]

Meteor garden 2001 piano scene will always be the best!Shan chai slayed it!

[@belleame1249]

I'm so excited to see how they're gonna do this scene in Thai version

[@belleame1249]

@@dontforgqt gmmtv actors won't disappoint us 😉

[@princessmimi1586]

@@belleame1249sad to day but they dont have😢

[@vanespasco2333]

Sarap ulit uliting panoorin ANG F4 2001/2009/2018

[@Emma88178]

Japanese 2007 version was the best and the funniest!

[@alexadyshiii3263]

I agree

[@yanethdz428]

I loved Shigeru’s reaction 😂

[@Amelia-vc2cb]

Meteor Garden 2001🖤

[@nurangelnur9887]

Ok the best play piano is original 2001 because shan chai so amazing fight with dao ming feng........that brave skill....rest is so boring not keep like fire feel......🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥 in melody...........

[@sagittariux]

Boys over flowers!❤

[@chowdhuryafifafatema4306]

2001 Shan cai was a VIBE

[@swamigiri5491]

My favourite scene is the 20o9 k drama scene this scene is a really very emotional I cried that I am Indian but I like Korean drama 😭😭

[@rigomaulana656]

Boys Before Flower ❤️

[@hildaaguirre8052]

Shen Yue es la mas linda natural y tierna de todos estos remakes

[@senoritaartistica1999]

I like the sweet Melody versions! AS a piano player myself, I tried to find (BOF) version for yrs on tutorial w/o success.

[@camilaagresot5392]

Meteor garden con Shen Yue, mi reina asiática hermosa 👏😍

[@seventeencarat6284]

Boys over flowers was the best

[@UrInMyZone]

no one can surpassed the acting of Barbie Hsu 💯✅ she perfectly suits the character of the lead female character of F4 and all the female cast of F4 2001 are really good and the rest of the version after that are just so so. Thai F4 kinda confused whom im going to ship Bright Tu or BrightWin well to be honest i dont see chemistry with BrightTu only BrightWin...just saying😎

[@BlueCircle22]

Anime is the best

[@mueart4778]

2009 :) Ji Hoo :)

[@jenlolo8902]

So the Korean change the personality of the female lead? And she could play and sing lol, the other kinda keep that essence of the character that was stubborn and fierce

[@danielenriquez6421]

Anime is really the best

[@kaisarantonn7225]

the japanese one has this scene on season 2. why did you not know this?

[@playlistrecap]

I include that

[@playlistrecap]

Hi! Stay tune for the new Hana Yori Dango Compilation 😊 What scene would you like to see next?

[@tiannaspence9671]

The modeling scene

[@playlistrecap]

@@tiannaspence9671 oh before when she got kidnapped?

[@playlistrecap]

@randompasserbyontheinterne9195 Hi, apologies for that. I'm still looking for a great scene comparison. Stay tuned :)

[@playlistrecap]

@randompasserbyontheinterne9195 thank you so much for these suggestions ❤

[@lucreciarosero3892]

Me gusta mucho la interpretación de jandi tocando el piano 🍟🎂🎁

[@lnmemories8295]

Jan Di is 👑👑👑👑👑

[@swarawagh9762]

2018 is last one best 💯👍

[@linhlinhngea4218]

I think so

[@ariah3128]

Same😀😃

[@man-fi9qj]

Anime and jandi🔥🔥🔥

[@pommichodai7]

I like Gem Jandi's version, the song and the lyrics are very sad, Like the feelings he felt for Goo Jun Pyo 😢

[@princessmimi1586]

2024 ❤whos anyone after watching anime/manga at netflix

[@lauranufio7020]

en la de Corea la chica si toca el piano

[@meikohan3630]

Anime one is the best for me

[@ms.a7196]

Jandi BOF is the best

[@madalenaandana6488]

2018 o melhor ❤️❤️

[@Candydice26]

2005 JAPANESE DRAMA ON TOP

[@danicafacun2990]

Meteor garden Chinese version for me 🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰

[@jonathansibay2431]

2001 ❤

[@bluemoon6092]

2001 original F4 fever. the best

[@moumitachowdhury5911]

the best singer is goo hey sun 💜💜💜💜

[@pasiondegavilanes287]

Oye la de 2005 si tuvo una escena del piano

[@firdamadu3833]

Dao ming shi and sanchai 2001.....

[@AdrianaLopez-ci2qf]

2005 ❤

[@adrianatrujillo7012]

CONFIRMADO!!!!! LA VERSION DE COREA ES LA MEJOOOORRR!!!! JANDI Y LOS F 4 IRREMPLAZABLES!!!!

[@maggiegoodvibesllc2393]

MY version

[@marlonmenicable-lr5ix]

Still jan di😊👍

[@goddesstheexplorer3167]

Why she look like jandi korean version?

[@user-lu1fn6cl4z]

Зуби зауереш кыз жегиттер сарыбазы ким чайынадай

[@mluisafernandezfernandez8355]

a Kaede Domyoji solo le preocupa su dinero y sus hoteles y el amor x sus hijos pues a la vista esta el proceder de Tsukasa sus actos de violencia y maltatrador pero cada pg que vas leyendo del manga la unica y si digo la unica que cuido y mimo a Tsukasa fue Tana eh hay su caracter de maltrato hasta q conce a Tsukushi ella apesar de la tarjeta roja y el intento de violacion por parte de Tsukasa Domyoji se va conciendo su parte bondadosa y dulce xq el se va enamorando de ella como un tonto ❤ y el sentido del honor cuando fue al gimnasio y en el parque de actraciones cuando van los cuatro y al ver al supuesto novio d Yuki que esta ligando con otras le surlta ese derechazo Xq desde la hamburgueseria ya le estaba calentado a vase de preguntas que cuanto media etc y creo q hay demostro ser todo un caballero por eso yo al manga y solo por eso me gusta leerlo q x por cierto ya solo me quedan el n19 q saldra el 22 / 11 / y el n 20 q sale el poxiomo 10 / 1 / 2024 desde aqui yo amo este maravilloso manga

[@rushalighosh8028]

hey, what the this is seriously toxic i am so sorry dear author but to me this story is unhealthy and toxic it would be toxic too if this was made in Ancient Japanese story but have made more sense because some royals used to see others as low lives but this doesn't make sense in here then you should have added some or few real life scenarios then that would have made this look great because unnecessary bullying with a red card tourturing less rich by the more richer umm i don't know what kind of fantasy world were you living in to write such a story , so sorry not for me though not hating this but not to my taste i would have written this story either in a Royal Settings or people like the Zamindars aka entitled rich and i would have made a warning symbol or issued a warning letters to the low lives that might have made more sense then just a Red paper with F4 written on it. Just my opinion i know no one wanted it but if someone dares to write against me you people are no less than these rich bratty people reprented in this Anime 😏 K.O