Male vs. Female Sitting in Salah | Hanafi Madhab

Full video: • Salah of Man vs. Woman...

[@IslamAnswers]

Please read full answers: islamanswers.co.uk/question/why-do-the-hanafis-adopt-the-iftiraash-sitting-posture-in-salah islamanswers.co.uk/question/is-it-true-that-the-prayer-of-women-is-the-same-as-men

[@MK..1558]

According to The Prophet's Sunnah, there is no difference in men's and women's Salah

[@Joker-pb9cz]

accept your arrogant behaviour and delete this comment

[@alfesiddique9557]

0 knowledge person u are 💀💀

[@buzzing.bizz1]

Both are Sunnah of prophet..

[@ibnmuhammad9027]

Yeah where does it say that oh u mean "pray as u see me pray" ? Yeah he was speaking to the male companions. Did u read the many other ahadith where the messenger ﷺ ordered the females to pray differently? Yeah no i didnt think so coz u learn ur deen from tiktok?

[@noamaansiddique7157]

​@@ibnmuhammad9027i know mens and women prayer is different but can you pls tell me the references plss

[@Jennfriel]

Everyone shouting how salaah is the same for men and women… study the books of fiqh in all four madhahib and get back to me. I know for a fact the Hanbali and Shafi’i madhhabs also say the salaah of a woman is supposed to be more tucked in/concealing. Arms closer to sides etc… All four madhhabs look at the evidences from the Quran and sunnah. Hanafis are also from ahlus sunnah wal jama’ah. Relax you don’t know everything. And the more you start learning the more you learn just how little you knew…

[@divinely0]

{ إِنَّ ٱلَّذِینَ فَرَّقُوا۟ دِینَهُمۡ وَكَانُوا۟ شِیَعࣰا لَّسۡتَ مِنۡهُمۡ فِی شَیۡءٍۚ إِنَّمَاۤ أَمۡرُهُمۡ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ ثُمَّ یُنَبِّئُهُم بِمَا كَانُوا۟ یَفۡعَلُونَ } [Surah Al-Anʿām: 159] This is a clear verse that proves we shouldn't divide into sunnah or shia. We should be only Muslims, like the prophet pbuh

[@_itsnor_1603]

Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) did tawaruk for first three rakats and tawaruj for the last rakat

[@Jennfriel]

@@divinely0 the schools of fiqh are schools of jurisprudence… not sects

[@saifullahmuhammadi_salafi3993]

In Sahih bukhari 828, sunan abu dawood 730 it's not mentioned that tawarruk is for females only and men won't sit in tawarruk position. There's no difference between men and women's salah.

[@saifullahmuhammadi_salafi3993]

Iftirash is the 1st tashhud sitting and tawarruk is the 2nd tashhud sitting after 4 th rakaat for both males and females

[@misterbk1791]

Yes

[@remabalabaran4049]

I have a question if 3 rakaa. If magrib how to sit pls thank you.

[@YoYousuf]

Exactly 😑

[@YoYousuf]

After 3rd rakaath thawarruk

[@minhajisminhaj]

May allah guide you to WHAT IS SUNNAH !!

[@naeemagrace2425]

Allahuma Aameen

[@user-fu4eg5qo3m]

Modern day ignorants not knowing the differences in madhaid and how imam abu hanifa got knowledge from companions yet barking in the comments after reading hadith on Google without any background knowledge..have some shame..

[@Salma_xx]

Oops they'll come after you This comment section is a good example of how everyone thinks of themselves above imam Abu hanifa, shafi and other imams. But will gladly call omer Suleiman, Yasir qadhi an imaam, and follow them blindly.

[@IbrahimKhan-ri6qx]

@@Salma_xxfacts, they follow people who came at least 1000 years after the Prophet ﷺ instead of the salaf. Yet some of them call themselves salafis

[@malkaarif412]

Listen brother I'm not against any imam... I respect them greatly but still as woman I do want to know where the idea of these differences originate? Certainly there has to be a base for these ideas? Did our Imam decided them on his ijtehad only or was there any sahabia performing Salah with this changed method and our Prophets agreed or encouraged or did not object? Or did any sahabi taught this exact method to women?? I really really want to know but don't have much insight in this area

[@_itsnor_1603]

​@@malkaarif412 sister did you find an answer because I have the same question. If there was difference in salah why did our scholarly sahabias not mention it in Hadith?

[@sadia8057]

Fear Allah . You are not more worried about women than Prophet Muhammad (SAW) Please stop misguiding people . Remove this video. Theres no difference between male female salah

[@sherifaiza11mbtc16]

Correct bro

[@Izumi-ahh]

Yes this is correct, women should pray just like Muhammad SAW prayed but in women's prayer (they need to read the Qur'an and Hadiths to know the rules of their Prayer). But women should not copy the prayer of a man, even if it is Hazrat Muhammad SAW they can't follow a man's prayer, just like men should not follow the prayer of a woman. Both men and women should have separate rules of Prayer and they should follow these rules of Prayer so their Prayer is accepted.

[@sadia8057]

@@Izumi-ahh sis you know wrong . There is no difference in the Salah of a man and a women . Please check your sources .

[@Izumi-ahh]

@@sadia8057 If there is no difference then why should a man and woman stand in separate rows in the Mosque in the prayer? Also, if there is no difference then why are the rules of the prayer (sujud and ruku) different? I have checked my sources which are Qur'an, Hadiths and many Islamic Scholars. I can give you the names of scholars, if you want.

[@Izumi-ahh]

@@sadia8057 There are many Islamic Scholars who talk about this issue, some of them are: - Sheikh Al Albani - Sheikh Ibn Uthaymeen - Sheikh Ibn Baz - Sheikh Bin Baaz - Sheikh Ibn Othaimeen - Sheikh Mustafa ibn Sahnoun

[@nidhikhan9975]

Thank you!

[@aynajamal8140]

No difference between male and female

[@raqibshairzai8244]

There’s difference of opinion, the fact you say that means you have no knowledge

[@vkak1]

​@@raqibshairzai8244there is no difference. Ahadeeth are clear

[@Salma_xx]

​@@vkak1Islam has differences in opinions, it's the beauty of Islam, it's the flexibility that makes us to practice easily. please stop misguiding people with your words, intentionally or unintentionally.

[@farooqrashid24]

There is no difference in salah between male and females...prophet pbuh said pray as you have seen me pray

[@truthseeker3293]

There is no difference in man and woman salah. These madhab’s just cause division we must follow the Quran and the sunnah not any other teachings !!

[@IslamAnswers]

What do you think Imam Abu Hanifah, Imam Shafi, Imam Malik and Imam Ahmed bin Hanbal and all the other scholars of the Madhab were following?

[@vkak1]

​@@IslamAnswersyou should know that they were not infallible, and had errors. They also told their students to follow the Sunnah if they say anything contradicting. Today, after we have so much available information about the chains of narration and the people within those chains, as well as multiple various a hadith, we see that these errors exist. It is not default of these imams, as they worked with the knowledge and information that they had, however, it is important to realize that as knowledge keeps growing, so too has the ability of the muhaditheen to carefully, scrutinize these ahadith for authenticity. So any ahadith that speaks of the differences between how a man and a woman praise, we do see that they have weaknesses in them. I advise you, Oh brothers, to listen to the imam's you claim to follow as well, and follow the sunnah, Even if a specific action contradicts what your school of thought says. This would in fact be following your imam much more closely than what you're doing right now.

[@IslamAnswers]

Feel free to join our next live Q&A where we can discuss this in length.

[@xkhanz777]

@@vkak1you have music playlists and a picture of a woman half naked in ur profile pic. What opinion do you follow that allows you to do that? Imam Abu hanifa is from the 3 golden generations which the prophet peace be upon him also spoke about. He spent time with the sahabah may Allah be pleased with them. He imitated them. You think he didn’t know? You think you or your teachers who tell you otherwise know better than imam Abu hanifa who spent his entire life with the sahaba learning and spreading the deen?! You think he didn’t know about the Hadith you mentioned? You think he spoke from his own whims and desires? There’s a reason why Allahs elevated his rank so high in this deen and his name is still echoed around the world 1300 years later.

[@remabalabaran4049]

Shukran

[@Dadi-ku7ce]

Mard aur aurat ki namaz alag bilkul nahi hai

[@Dadi-ku7ce]

Same hai

[@sk_.afridi]

​@@Dadi-ku7ceKonsi hadees me hai?

[@antonygoodman8595]

Modern people lay in beds, walk around in shoes, learn the same language in the same class..

[@Jennfriel]

?? Sorry what? What are you trying to say? 😂

[@biyaahmed16]

Stop misguiding people the salah position and everything is same for both genders there isn’t any difference

[@NasimaBegum-te1iw]

this looks so painful😢 will my namaj not be accepted if i keep my legs like men ?

[@THAT_BAKAGURL]

JAZAKALLAH KHAIR!!

[@TH-oo9ww]

Youre definately brelvi. Am i correct?

[@shahadathussain5774]

Completely wrong no difference between men and women praying. The prophet pbuh said pray as you have seen me pray

[@alameen1190]

Not only in hanafi mazhab but also in Shafi mazhab also same...

[@nadew.02]

Thank you so much I understood very well

[@Browneys4U]

this is according to what?

[@TH-oo9ww]

"Trust me bro"

[@sbibibb5722]

I can't sit like that it's hard.

[@Bawn.Meedoh]

What did our beloved mother aisha say on how women pray?she’s the wife of the prophet and a female mother to Islam,what did she say?

[@mutashimgamer7308]

Assalaamu alaikum as a woman i really cannot sit with toes facing qibla. Plz advice me

[@DedicatedFor_ALLAH]

Wa alaikum assalam wa rahmatullahi wa barakatuh, watch sheikh Assim al hakeem video on how to pray. You will understand everything inshaALLAH 😊

[@mutashimgamer7308]

@@DedicatedFor_ALLAHjazaakillah khair I watched the video n am practicing hard to do my swalaat with sunnah. May Allah reward you

[@DedicatedFor_ALLAH]

@@mutashimgamer7308 aameen. alhamdulillah, we all must try our besttt. May ALLAH ﷻ make everything so easy for you and us all aameen.

[@Salma_xx]

​@@mutashimgamer7308wa alaikumus salam sister, you can have your leg touch the ground, like in the video man's right foot was like half standing and faced qibla, you can touch the ground with your leg (ankle) Sorry my English is bad 😂

[@Salma_xx]

​@@DedicatedFor_ALLAHassim Al Hakeem is good, I won't deny that but not everything he says is correct. You'll find contradictions even in his own fatwas, recent few don't match w previous ones. I'd say follow traditional/ Pakistani (deoband/ if you know Urdu) muftis.

[@YoYousuf]

Don’t misguide please!

[@Joker-pb9cz]

this guy is saying the hanafi and shafii school is misguiding. What arrogance

[@vkak1]

​@@Joker-pb9czit is when people blind follow the madhhab

[@Joker-pb9cz]

@@vkak1 you have to blind follow stop listening to this nonsense lol. You literally blind follow every single day its an islamic norm especially for the lay man

[@sherifaiza11mbtc16]

@@vkak1 yeah ur right

[@sfk21]

What a Jerkwhy are you dividing people? The way you sir doesn't validate your prayer but intention of your heart does.Dont add experiments in religion There is no Hanafi Tanafi but only Muslim in the eyes of lord

[@almasakhtar5756]

There is no difference in prayer method of male and female. There is also a haidth .

[@MuhammadMubashir-rb5ny]

❤❤

[@FantaLilt]

How embarrassing. Look at the comments. Every comment You are getting told to stop with your blind following of the 4 Imams and where you can please follow the Prophet Mohammed ﷺ - there is no difference in the prayer of men and women.

[@RiksyPlayer]

Prophet s.a.w himself used to do tawwaruk too. There is no difference of prayer.

[@abdullahsiddiqui4592]

The women sit througout the salah in tawaruk while the men only in last.

[@asifsohaila923]

Please teach the right Islam

[@sajidmahmood4238]

Rubbish, there is no difference in prayer in men and women Prophet Mohammed peace and blessings be upon him said: pray as you have seen me pray

[@IslamAnswers]

Please read full answers: islamanswers.co.uk/question/is-it-true-that-the-prayer-of-women-is-the-same-as-men islamanswers.co.uk/question/why-do-the-hanafis-adopt-the-iftiraash-sitting-posture-in-salah

[@thrallingFRglory]

How arrogant does one have to be to call this ‘rubbish’. That’s quite a strong word choice brother.

[@hamzatalib1551]

​@@thrallingFRglory I do agree it is a strong word but I feel my brother because I am also getting frustrated with all these different things people say. For example, this video confuses me but the comment section has explained that it is not ryt

[@leroyfong7957]

Bro,i know this is not according the way of the prophet. But this is the opinion of imam Abu Hanifa. ,. the hadith of sitting tawrug or iftirash did not reach him until he died. This is his ijtihad. . Abu Hanifa tried his best ability to find the way of prophet,but the information on sitting iftirash org tawarug havent reach him. So pls dont say its rubbish.

[@sajidmahmood4238]

@@leroyfong7957 the person quoting imam Abu hanifa is misquoting him, I’m only saying what he’s saying is rubbish. I respect all the imams, but we should only blind follow one person

[@TH-oo9ww]

Both these mdthods was done by the prophet depending on which rakah it was. So its sunnah for men and women. No difference in men and women salah.

[@affan639]

In the Prophet’s ﷺ Madhab, there’s no difference between the prayer of a male and a female. Also, Tawarruk is for both, not just females. جزاك اللهُ خيرً ا for your efforts.

[@khunshlu1912]

Stop spreading false things without evidence

[@discoveryourchildhood4544]

kzbin.infoWYt0vU5YSrc?feature=share what about the sitting position shown in this video? i am so confused can someone please explain so that we can all perform salah in the right way

[@Salma_xx]

In this video the sister follows the belief that men and women have no difference in style of praying. When there are many including me, who believes there are differences. I follow hanafi mazhab. And if you are Bengali, I can share another video with you

[@discoveryourchildhood4544]

@@Salma_xx tnq for making it clear to me. Please do share the video you wanted to share

[@safinaakhter7677]

My blood circulation would stop😂

[@Anonymous-mi8mm]

What the hell os this men are women are the same our prophet mentioned pray as you see me pray he didn’t say except for women

[@husnamohammad7307]

Wrong !!!!

[@sherifaiza11mbtc16]

In islam there is no mazhabs..stop misguiding

[@Salma_xx]

Omg the allama mufti sherifaiza has spoken 😅

[@sherifaiza11mbtc16]

@@Salma_xx insha allah u will get the rewards for this misguidance brother..

[@Someone12481]

Thank you!