MAMAMOO LIVE! "MY STAR" and "I LOVE TOO" Reaction!

One song is a certified bop, the other is so beautiful I almost cried! I LOVE MAMAMOO!

[@SinghReacts]

One song is a certified bop, the other is so beautiful I almost cried! I LOVE MAMAMOO!

[@melindaa2950]

❤️❤️❤️

[@raprilc2]

"Never letting go" is special to us Moomoo's. The fact that they put it in the lyrics to us is beyond anything. Mamamoo forever!

[@SinghReacts]

Just heard about this! So beautiful!

[@wheeinspiration6391]

i will always love the way Hwasa's parents said ''our daugthers'' referring to both Hwasa and Wheein. Their friendship is so wholesome, I always cry no matter how many time I've watched it.

[@SMILE-mx9hp]

I really appreciated how Hwasa's dad said "our daughters" meaning Hwasa and Wheein. Knowing how much pain Wheein went through because of her biological father since a very young age. She's very strong mentally. As Solar said once Wheein had the hardest time out of all of them. From debut till now considering her leg injuries in their early years and anxiety nowadays.

[@SinghReacts]

She’s been through so much 😭😭

[@altyngoal]

i think her anxiety is gone nowadays. She is ok now and you can see it from her recent comebacks) especially after 2018-2019 when they could finally rest well from their tough schedules

[@SMILE-mx9hp]

@@altyngoal Do you remember when she didn't go with the members to Kcon 2019 I think it was between September and November. She felt some dizziness at the airport then went straight to the hospital. That's when RBW said that the doctors said she had anxiety. But I really hope she's doing well now 🙏🏻

[@altyngoal]

@@SMILE-mx9hp yes it was in august 2019 and also she did Goodbye solo release then they had Queendom on August-September-October period then in November their comeback with Hip

[@katchu5555]

7:31 When Solar parents said: "My lovely daughter Solar, Congratulations on your first concert. I hope Mamamoo will be the best girl group. Mamamoo fighting!" Then Solar : "😭😭😭" * It really means a lot to her* Because Solar parents doesn't support her to be singer before and they thought it was bad idea that's why they were against it.

[@SinghReacts]

Wow that’s so crazy! But look at her now, one of the best vocalists I’ve ever heard!

[@martinschafer7404]

Everyone knew there would be videos but only Wheein knew what was coming. She carries everyone's part until they each recover enough to start singing again. Her walk down the front of the stage is her checking on them. One small but significant thing is that Hwasa's parents congratulate their daughters, plural. Wheein's from a broken home and once she an Hwasa became friends in middle school she became like a daughter to them.

[@SinghReacts]

Wowwww so beautiful!

[@ELmayberry]

Wheein tends to do that whenever they're preforming and members are crying

[@kattyen4782]

Wait I thought none of them knew about their family's surprise VCR? I recall a comment mentioning that Moonbyul asked Whee In if she knew and she shook her head No... at 8:22 (in this video). I mean I think they knew there would be a VCR since they were prepared, I think at rehearsal their staff showed them another VCR and this threw them off..... I know WheeIn is always ready to sing the members part if they're crying and vice versa- if stable. But I think she got ahold of herself a lot quicker than the others, might be due to her childhood, she might of taught herself to get it together fast and move on when in public. That must certainly be true if she's where she's at right now. I can't imagine how strong she must be, I'm lucky to have both my parents love. ....I could be wrong though, I only based this on a comment and her early days.

[@graceababan]

MMM's debut stage was attended by only 3 Moomoos (Wheein & Byul's sister & friends). Just look at how the fandom grew in 2 years. When you ask Mamamoo on their most memorable moments, they always say it's their first win and this first concert.

[@watchtherandomzz]

"my star" is one of my TOP TOP B-SIDE and then they dropped this band version for this concert and i just lose my shit😳

[@SinghReacts]

I definitely lost it LOL such a bop!

[@keli2128]

Anyone else waiting for him to put up the MAMAMOO poster on his wall? Lol Since Wheein is definitely your bias, you should add her 3 dance performance videos to your list. I must warn you, she is on fire in those videos so be prepared.

[@SinghReacts]

Yup their already there planning to get to them soon when I find a large enough water bottle 😅😂😂😂

[@watchtherandomzz]

i never cry hearing any song and "I LOVE TOO" and "I MISS YOU" were the first ever songs to make cry, i felt it as a die hard fan of mamamoo, and not only this the fact that mamamoo mostly compose, write songs thinking of their fans and byul always write her rap making it more special for us JUST TOUCHES MY HEART😭

[@abrilvp298]

"Never letting go" that's what the moomoos wrote on a poster in one of his first presentations. Pd: sorry for my english, i don't speak.😊

[@adesunja1659]

wheein has been through a lot of sad things .. she knows what loneliness is before finally getting a family on mamamoo, she doesn't have any family photos, that's why she recently made it with mamamoo .. hwasa really loves wheein, she even tricked wheein to get baptized .. so that they can be together even when they die .. her baptismal name is gabriela..

[@bananagomm]

i'm a moomoo even from pre-debut but all these informations are new to me o_o

[@SinghReacts]

Wowww my heart hurts for her! She’s amazing and I’m so glad she has Hwasa with her

[@adesunja1659]

@@bananagomm OMO!!!!! am i the real moomoo than?? ㅋㅋㅋㅋ kidding!!! saranghanu👍❤️

[@altyngoal]

but she had grandmother with whom she was at her young age, and also she loves her mother and stepfather and i think stepbrother too)) She is not lonely, yes she had tough period but how she was lonely?

[@adesunja1659]

@@altyngoal her grandmother passed away when wheein about 17 or 18 because cancer..

[@mikemabrey2182]

My Star is one of my favorites of theirs. I wish it would've gotten more support from the company. No idea why it was a "b-side."

[@SinghReacts]

Legit a whole bop

[@altyngoal]

@@SinghReacts you should listen 4х4 ever another not title bop too))

[@ReapTheWhirlwind]

I Love Too is a tribute to the fans. During their early days the fans created a project called "Never Letting Go" and gathered together at a show to let Mamamoo know that they were loved and appreciated. Here's a video of that day and how Mamamoo responded: kzbin.info/www/bejne/bKqvmKiLndmWr68 . 🥰😭 I actually heard this song before seeing the MV because I was listening to their discography and it stood out from the other songs on Memory. Even though I didn't understand the words or even the context of the song it still touched my heart. I think that everyone with a soul tears up or cries when they first see the MV for I Love Too so don't feel bad.

[@SinghReacts]

Gonna watch that like right now lol

[@SinghReacts]

Omg wowwww what a beautiful moment! Love the moos for this!!!

[@ReapTheWhirlwind]

@@SinghReacts For greater context, this happened during Mamamoo's debut year. It's hard for new groups to make a name for themselves and sometimes it can be tough to keep going. By the looks of everyone this was during the Piano Man era. 🥰

[@SinghReacts]

Even better wow! Yea that’s so early on and they’re already beloved ❤️ love to see it

[@alicealiencat]

@@SinghReacts i remember i saw in a video, solar said they only have 3 audience in a performance in the early beginning (forget what event it is), one is wheein's friend and the other 2 is moonbyul's sis, but look at the radish farm now ! they are talented and hard working , unique , one and only one mamamoo

[@chieh0501]

mamamoo everyday, keep doctors away

[@SinghReacts]

So true

[@graceababan]

The video you watched for I LOVE TOO is the "official MV" for this song... live vocals... official mv... only MMM.

[@markkevinbaylon3604]

I rarely watch “I Love Too” bc I always end up crying especially when I see Solar is crying. Imagine out of 50 auditions, she was only accepted in 1 company which is RBW. Every company declines her because of her age. I think she was 20 when she starts on auditioning on companies unlike other kpop idols who starts at a young age. Her parents tell her to give up and they will give Solar a las chance. If she still wasnt accepted, she will pursue her studies and become a flight attendant instead. And then a good news came. She was accepted in RBW. After that video, Moonbyul tells her feelings. That she’s a little jealous of other members because every performance, all 3 members are singing while her, she was just waiting and standing until her parts came. And its sad because she auditioned and trained to be a vocalist but rbw tells her to rap to debut. It was really hard for moonbyul to fit in Mamamoo. On Hwasa’s part, she was also declined by many companies due to her appearance. As we all know that Hwasa does not fit in “Korean beauty Standards”. But that doesnt stop Hwasa to achieve her dreams. She practiced everyday and perform on events just to showcase her talents. Even in their early days, korean wants to have a petition to kick Hwasa on Mamamoo. Wheein was always there for Hwasa. Theres a video where Wheein is telling a story about her experience with Hwasa. Many people on that company doesnt want Hwasa and tell in front of Wheein that they want to kick Hwasa on the team. Wheein says that if they want to kick Hwasa on the team, She will also leave from the team.

[@djvillan]

No one from RBW wanted to kick Hwasa out of Mamamoo. It was a joke played on Wheein on her birthday by Solar and Moonbyul, with Hwasa outside listening behind the door.

[@markkevinbaylon3604]

@@djvillan im not saying its rbw tho

[@user-jq2jv2zl8y]

Also the hard side for Wheein is her family problems ; - ;

[@Bongi344]

It was a prank on Wheein's birthday, done by Byul Solar and Hwasa herself 😂 Yeah to be Mamamoo is their fate.

[@alicealiencat]

Hi , if you want to know more abt. their journey, how to fight together from promoting their songs on the street to the top , I always recommend these : "Mamamoo’s Journey", this one shows how the song 'i love too" formed. "Mamamoo's story" more abt. how they come together despite obstacles or " this is mamamoo, (road to success).

[@SinghReacts]

Awesome thank you! Added!

[@uunuuliebeleben9323]

Their concerts are unforgettable as always. I was super excited about My star too. Also, Moomoos held up banners with the phrase “Never letting go” during their first event/fan meet. Our girls burst into tears. 😭. So Solar, Moonbyul, and Hwasa wrote this song for their fans.

[@SinghReacts]

Wow that’s so beautiful! Love them and all the moos! ❤️

[@alicealiencat]

@@SinghReacts you can watch they cry when they saw Moomoos holding those banners in "Mamamoo's Journey"

[@SinghReacts]

Yea someone just linked me the video and I just watched it! So beautiful! 😭😭😢😢

[@michwns]

honestly i love too always makes me cry, moomoos are so lucky for having them right?! they're the sweetest girls this was the first song solar wrote for us as a response after seeing fans put up banners with the words "never letting go" as an event at a concert the day before her birthday in 2016. i recommend you to react to some of the solarsido acapella covers (believer, speechless, aya) and to "please listen to this in the evening" that is the song solar gave us on her bday this year btw you're one of my faves mamamoo reactors, it's kinda late in brazil (2 am) but i'm so happy with so much content today hahah (sorry for my bad english lol)

[@SinghReacts]

Great English! I just watched the video of that concert it’s so beautiful! ❤️ yea solarsido is definitely on the to do list! Aw thank you so much!

[@michwns]

@@SinghReacts 💕💕 yesss!! this one was actually at a fan meeting in 2014 and "never letting go" has been a meaningful phrase since then bc it was used in the first event moomoos did for mamamoo but this is the concert i talked about kzbin.info/www/bejne/mXKZiYJ6hpV8kM0, after this she composed the song as a thank you and released it through fancafe on her birthday (here is the first version kzbin.info/www/bejne/rp6xd3-Khr-WmJY), later moonbyul and hwasa added their parts and the mv you reacted to was the first time they performed it

[@pleasesubscribetomychannel2446]

Wheein literally the backbone of Mamamoo

[@jenmoomoo5771]

omg now I really want to see you react to MAMAMOO’s Words don’t come easy - live!! I was out of breath the whole time I was watching it 😭😭

[@SinghReacts]

Added to the list!

[@jenmoomoo5771]

@@SinghReacts OMG THANK YOUUU I’LL BE WAITING ❤️😭

[@jenmoomoo5771]

@@SinghReacts omg sorry i accidentally deleted my other comment ajdhwjs but here’s the link so u could easily find it ❤️❤️ kzbin.info/www/bejne/en_Kf4Wkm6djebc

[@keshiaarimbay3608]

even when i have already watched i love too for a lot of times already, i still cry because i know that that song is offered for us, moomoos, and that we too, are never letting them go, no matter what T.T

[@ChimeraPearl]

I just adore how everyone is crying and wheein is just laughing while checking up on her unnies and covering their parts for them while they're incapacitated with tears

[@User-wm6ef]

Aaaww so many mamamoo contents for today 😭❤️ best day ever!! Thank you so much brandon~ stay healthy ✨✨

[@pievancl5457]

Not going through all the comments to check, so not sure if anyone mentioned, but aside from writing the lyrics for the Never Letting Go, solar also had her hand in the composition (on piano). Also, the band Onewe wasn’t their touring band at the time “my star” was filmed, I think. They were being promoted as Onewe at that time.

[@kalaksed]

Wow, what a pair of songs to put together... at least you see the range they pull off in their concerts "My star" tends to hit people that way...it very much sticks with you once you've heard it and makes you want to get up and dance. ...and speaking of dancing, don't look up wheein "my star" fancams, esp the "hip" era ones. Her dancing is deadly And there's a reason the other title for "i love too" is "tears". Virtually everhone in the fandom cries when they see/hear it, and it's often suggested as an initiation for new moos once they've started getting to know the girls as people as well as amazing singers. That was indeed their first concert and no, they didn't expect their families to be in that video. They were told it would be messages from fans (and it was every other day), so still emotional but not...that. Others mentioned the highlights already, solar's parents originally being against her desire to become an idol so their message hitting her hard, hwasa's parents including wheein with their 'our daughters' and yeah, that was wheein's mother (some think it's her grandmother since she was mostly raised by her grandmother, but she had already passed years prior). You could tell how shocked both wheein and hwasa were when wheein's mom appeared, but the puppy regained her composure way too fast and took up the support role, taking each members lines if they looked like they wouldn't be able to continue. I still hate her father (and the k media and knets) for making her so good at bottling her emotions. And it really is crazy how the other three managed to still sound so good even while crying. It def wasn't their first time crying onstage, nor their last, and often enough, wheein joined in on the tears, if she was just too surprised or overwhelmed

[@SinghReacts]

So dam emotional! My goodness! Almost cried my dam self

[@InfinityX00]

Like the intro graphics, short and sweet (and outro) (edited after finished watching)

[@SinghReacts]

Thank you! Something my partner has been working on for the business!

[@wheeinspiration6391]

omg I can't until you react to their solo stages, I just can imagine your reactions to every single one of them lfmaslkfma!!!

[@SinghReacts]

I’m legit already nervous for those lol I’ve been hearing the rumors! Some are spicy!

[@wheeinspiration6391]

@@SinghReacts yup yup, u ain't ready

[@bananagomm]

wheein is always killing me with THAT solo stage... every. darn. time.

[@wheeinspiration6391]

@@bananagomm exactly

[@gonosoi]

This reaction it's leterally split in two one it's the super awesome live performance of my star the other it's the super beutiful and emotional live performance of i love you too 😭😭 you know what this incredibile performance have in common it's always Mamamoo concert 😂 so much feeling 😭😭

[@SinghReacts]

Yessss I kinda forgot you all told me I love too was for us moos when i decided to do these 2 😅 but I loved the rollercoaster I just went on lol

[@Diwagg]

I think you are ready to react mamamoo word's don't come easy

[@trickydickie72]

Great reaction. I cried on "I love you 2" when I first saw it.

[@shaunmather999]

Wow what an amazing suprise they got of their families just amazing

[@SinghReacts]

Yea I wasn’t ready for the feels!

[@shaunmather999]

@@SinghReacts yh that was even more touching

[@teeenahbeeenah]

Ooooooo new fancy video intro!

[@chadol_doenjang_jjigae]

Never letting go MAMAMOO

[@SinghReacts]

Never ✋ 🤚

[@shaunmather999]

Wow i love too is just amazing not even half way through and im tearing up ots just beautiful

[@SinghReacts]

Imagine not even being a full moomoo and almost crying like we both did to this song lol. So touching!

[@shaunmather999]

@@SinghReacts yh ikr just an amazing song

[@martinschafer7404]

The band on this isn't Onewe. Onewe is their band on the rock version of Gogobebe that they did on one of the music shows.

[@SinghReacts]

Oooooo ok lol got it mixed up

[@uunuuliebeleben9323]

Hahaha. I really enjoyed it. I just freaking love them. The meaning of these songs is so beautiful too.

[@theAllycat797]

I thought I've never clicked on the others videos faster. I was wrong ... I love how they can go from having headbangers to legit needing tissues @_@ im so glad you enjoyed them

[@SinghReacts]

LOL seriously tho such a wide variety in their discography!

[@blacksh33p_end]

My favorite song ❤ My Star 🌟 And the song that makes me cry every time i hear 👌 Thank you so much ❤

[@leesvees7668]

I love watching people fall in love with mamamoo 🥰

[@yatinadz]

Just a suggestion, maybe you would like to check on “Mamamoo story” by What Girl . It’s about their journey throughout their careers as an artist. I believe after watching it you will appreciate Mamamoo even more. That’s what happens to me as far as I know. I can’t go to sleep without listening or watching Mamamoo for every single night since I became a Momoo ❤️🥰

[@jjl2910]

Eyooo finally a reactor who appreciates Wheeinnn

[@SinghReacts]

My bias! Love her so much!

[@GwenNicoli8811]

Their so amazing!! If you learn more about their story of becoming mamamoo I’m pretty sure you’ll at-least shed a tear 😅. But yes dreamcatcher and mamamoo are literally my comfort groups!! Mamamoo Fighting!! Dreamcatcher Fighting!!

[@SinghReacts]

Are there videos and such on the forming of Mamamoo?

[@candolitacoi9302]

yes there is, like a documentary.there are some in yt!

[@alicealiencat]

@@SinghReacts you can read the interview of Kim Do hoon ,RBW's co CEO, if you have patient and interest . some is abt. how he put these girls as a group , the concept etc. He is a genius who know them well , respect, encourge and trust them.

[@ELmayberry]

MooSomnia 🥰

[@kalaksed]

There are a few versions floating around, but i think 'mamamoo's story' by what girl is pretty much considered the gold standard. She's also got a few similar ones, as well as more humorous stuff

[@tfk7112]

Aww thank you for reacting to my request. I was saying exactly the same as you when I watched I Love Too MV, Mamamoo is part of my life now, I can’t imagine my life without them 💕

[@purplishnavy192]

Do you guys noticed how wheein checking everyone if they are ready to sing their part while covering the parts for them? :((

[@misherulee]

hi! I found you late and i just binged watch 23 videos on your mamamoo playlist up until this one. I just wanna say that i really love your reactions because it seems like you have a genuinely love for mamamoo and watching you felt like i was watching mamamoo with a friend! I love too always makes me cry when i watch the MV for it. I was late to knowing about Mamamoo, only got to know them last year in September and i've always felt sad how i couldn't be there from the beginning or even wayyy earlier on to journey with the girls. But nevertheless, i'm glad i'm here now...And like what you mentioned, i can't imagine my life without seeing them every day. Well i'm gonna continue to binge watch your videos!! Thank you for doing all this!!

[@rayneechen8002]

You need to hear the official version of “My Star”，Wheein has F6 whistle notes

[@SinghReacts]

We did! White wind album listen ☺️☺️

[@autumneagle]

Your outro. Man stans talent. Im in the same boat

[@SinghReacts]

Me and my business partner are cooking up some dope stuff 👌 appreciate you!

[@graceababan]

Mamamoo's B-sides are no joke. I feel like they choose title tracks based on what's the most catchy and what will sell the most to the general public, which is acceptable from a business standpoint. However, it doesn't necessarily mean that it's the best song in the album #IsaidWhatISaid. Another thing I noticed is songs produced by Cosmic Girl & Cosmic Sound usually don't get chosen as title tracks (My Star & Mamamoo CF songs, among others). It's usually the songs of their CEO, who is also MMM's producer, that gets chosen as title tracks. That's why you should listen to Mamamoo albums in its entirety because there are a lot of hidden gems in there :) PS. As someone who requested for MY STAR, I'm so happy that you reacted to this one. I knew you'd like it :)

[@aaronaustria1273]

HOLY SHIT FINALLY SOMEONE REACTED TO MY STAR

[@SinghReacts]

Such a bop!

[@ayaalmashhadani5731]

Yes my Star😭😭😭😭

[@joycastaneda8947]

Please react to that one time they showed up at an awards show in Teletubbies costume, while everyone are in gowns and suits. Its hilarious and the girls are super having the times of their lives.

[@sheilaviovicente9532]

even how many times i watch ' i love you too' it makes me cry everytime

[@Bongi344]

Right? Mamamoo + live band is something else 💙 I love their band too.

[@MooYT_]

I'm not sure if anyone mentioned (and I didn't wanna go through so many comments lol) but at the end of my star there is actually some whistle notes/high notes done by wheein. they didn't do this live because it took wheein several attempts to get them right in the studio, and all the belting at the end might be the reason this song wasn't the title track but im not sure! (since they have to perform title tracks way more often especially right when they release)

[@iQiLefty]

My 2 favourite b-sides are My Star & Words Don't Come Easy.. just wanna say it..😏

[@J85kyo]

I'm just glad that it's never too late to get into the raddish cart 😁😁

[@hwalionchannel4419]

Now this is my huge request...plzz...plzzz....plzzz....react to Don't touch me...plzz....this song is made by 4 queens of their generations...Hwasa, Jessi, Lee Hyori, Uhm Jung Hwa....Uhm Jung Hwa is now about 50 years old, Lee hyori 40, Jessi 30 and Hwasa 25...Just imagine 4 queens of their generations....you should react to it...plzzzzzzzzzzzzz....× infinity..lol..😅 But I'm serious...I would be very grateful to you..😍😍 They also made their group known as Refund sisters...😍

[@SinghReacts]

I’ll add it to the list 👌👌

[@teeenahbeeenah]

The project/idea came from Lee Hyori who specifically said she wanted to create a group with these 4 women (so specifically choosing Hwasa). Each bad ass and each iconic in their era... Um Jung Hwa even did a comeback after this with a song feat. Hwasa.

[@klevisstava4734]

maybe woohoo live or wheein's candy (cover) for the future? anw, great reaction! i always enjoy seeing the journey of a new converted moomoo :D

[@catrosa7662]

I’m gonna keep recommending things because I love them so much! React to Words don’t come easy by them please.

[@VonChoker]

I love my star, It may be currently my favourite song of theirs and it's incredible how it's just an album track - the whole of White Wind is fire btw

[@user-ht3qc3vw1o]

You have to listen to ONEWE!!!! They are amazing too. Regulus!!

[@bananagomm]

and "Reminisce About All"! gosh that song always gets me ;_; or just react to them chronologically: - Reminisce About All (u____u) - Regulus - Q (ft. Hwasa) - End of spring - Parting (personal favorite ;_;) - A Book in Memory And how about a peek into ONEUS hehehe: - Valkyrie - Twilight - Lit - A Song Written Easily (personal favorite uwu) - Come Back Home - To Be Or Not To Be (personal favorite!!!) - No Diggity And then PURPLE KISS' pre-debut MVs: - My Heart Skip A Beat - Can We Talk Again i'll save Vromance and all the b-sides for another time :))

[@user-qm1nw3gs8q]

My Star, the best B-side track.

[@kudgeond755]

My Star is one of MMM's many b-sides that other groups would kill to release as a title track. Imo RBW's decision to bury a number of great songs as album b-sides is one of the main ways they've failed to promote MMM properly. My Star wasn't performed with their label mates Onewe. For their concerts MMM uses a big band that often includes horns, strings and backup singers besides keys, bass, guitar and drums. Onewe has done year-end events with MMM as the backup band for rock versions of Decalcomanie and Gogobebe and they also did a Queen medley with Hwasa. Be prepared to have your mind blown again when you get around to checking out Onewe. I tear up every time I hear I Love You Too. The vid title is incomplete and the song is aka Tears and Never Letting Go but everyone calls it I Love You Too rather than I Love Too. As you may have heard Solar posted the main lyrics on the fancafe as a poem to moomoos after fans surprised them by holding up signs reading Never Letting Go while they were singing Love Lane during a fanmeet. They broke into tears and were barely able to finish the song. My guess is that RBW co-CEO Kim Dohoon urged them to turn it into a song so Moonbyul & Hwasa added their rap verses to complete the lyrics. KDH has done that a number of times, resulting in songs such as Sleep in the Car and Hwasa's I Do Me. Agree - I don't know how you can sound so good while crying and singing at the same time. Not sure whether you noticed that Solar cried throughout the rest of the song after the surprise parental videos. Even when the camera isn't on her you can hear her breath catching as she sobs while singing. I've heard that Wheein was the only one who got advance warning, which is probably why she's the only one who kept her composure. Wheein sang the others' lines until they were able to join in again.

[@SinghReacts]

Yea I watched the clip of that performance when someone linked it to me. Such a beautiful moment I love the moos so much for that!

[@winterssong5607]

I respect your opinion but sorry I have to politely disagree with you on your sentence that said "RBW's decision to bury a number of great songs as album b-sides is one of the main ways they've failed to promote MMM properly". Sorry but that sentence just really rubbed me wrong way especially cause I personally think gogobebe was such a perfect choice to be a title track for the "white wind" album. I mean I could see where you're coming from but one of many things why I love RBW and their artist in general is that their b-sides tracks are as strong as or even sometimes better than their title tracks. I see that more as their effort to put such a strong album which consist so many great songs (not only limited to title track only but also their b-sides as well). They didn't want to put "meh" songs into their album b-sides, that's the reason why I love most their b-sides tracks on their albums. Don't get me wrong tho and I'm not talking about kpop only here but it happens also to many western music as well that some groups/artist sometimes put their effort only focused on their title track only and their b-sides are just act only as a complement so that the album seems to have a lot of songs.

[@kudgeond755]

@@winterssong5607 I don't disagree with anything you said and if MMM's album sales were comparable to the most popular kpop groups I wouldn't complain - that would mean RBW was doing a great job and their music was getting the attention it deserves. But that's not the case and I would point to Blue;S as an example of an album full of buried treasure. Their b-sides are so strong I think they could have promoted several singles before releasing each album. To take your example, why not promote Gogobebe, then My Star, then release the album? They sort of did that with Dingga and Aya but that was a case of moomoos pushing Dingga more than RBW getting behind it. I'm not a fan of pre-release singles with little or no promotion other than an MV, basically saying "We're not really serious about this one - it's just a warm up for the main event." They could do it the other way and promote a series of singles after the album release but I think that would be less effective.

[@winterssong5607]

@@kudgeond755 Sure I'd be happy if they could've promoted several singles, heck I even want them to promotes all of their b-sides, like literally all of them should have a MV and their videos should reach 50M+ views just in one day. But I know that I'm just being too greedy then if I'm asking just like that, and imo RBW is also still relatively a small company if you want to compared them to other big companies out there and I very much took that aspect into consideration. Sometimes I just wish that RBW is such a crazy huge and rich company that has power/influence in the music industry in the first place, so that way they can did massive promotions to their artist and having those big companies priviledges. Okay let's cut to the chase here, all in all I feel like we as fans are sometimes demanding too much from the companies and will never get satisfied with what they've done, other fans might say why not promoted "X song" instead of "Y song", etc etc. There'll be no ends to this because each of us has our own preferences, both the company and the artist themselves couldn't satisfied all of us. Well that's my two cents of this our friendly conversations.

[@kudgeond755]

@@winterssong5607 We're just going to have to agree to disagree but here are my final thoughts. The small company excuse should be retired. They built a new building and debuted 3 new groups. They're no longer a poor, struggling startup agency. If anyone has the right to be greedy it's RBW and since they're selling people's talent I would call it an obligation. Failure to exploit your biggest asset for everything it's worth is bad business. When that asset is one of the best girl groups in the world, past or present, then I would call the failure a sin. Finally, so far no artist under RBW has achieved the sales and success their talent deserves. RBW has a great eye for talent and seems to be a good artistic home but that's about all I give them credit for.

[@Hello-cp1eq]

For now, please react to Wheein and Hwasa's song called 'Loving the same person/man' live Also Hwasa's 'In the fall' x Woogie Piano version.

[@jshbrnb]

when you listen to the studio ver you'll hear wheein's whistle

[@aaronaustria1273]

YOU SHOULD REACT TO THE FANCAM OF WHEEIN PERFORMING THIS SONG

[@grandpajim3557]

I don't know if you still read these but to answer your question only Wheein knew about the parent videos. That's why she had tears but didn't cry like the others. Note this song is for the Moomoos when Mamamoo started out their fan base was very small but when piano man came out so did lots of fans not statidum but enough they had signs made saying never letting go. Love these beautiful girls they have loving hearts proud to be a Moomoo

[@SinghReacts]

I do! 👌 I was shared the link to that clip of the fans holding up the signs and the reaction from the girls! Such a beautiful moment! Truly amazing people! Very proud to be a moo too

[@MoomooXOnce]

Can you react to gleam live version please, wheein's dancing is fire.

[@cherissetillman8973]

This is from their 4 seasons concert. You need to see Solar BTS cover Fire. You think this is good. MMM is always full of surprises

[@shaunmather999]

Dam my star live is crazy and its too hot your right toooo much lol

[@SinghReacts]

Wayyyy too hot lol wheein in that white fit too! Yeeeesh

[@shaunmather999]

@@SinghReacts ikr lol

[@gellie865]

I really got emotional everytime I listen to Mamamoo's I Love Too

[@bananagomm]

it's past midnight and i still have tons of work to do but nah lemme watch a grown man being wrecked left and right by mamamoo 😊

[@fourierkaren1192]

I was too much emotional here!!

[@nargesramin8643]

If you want don't block by youtube in live performances you should pause the video more. If you low the volume of the video it would be useful too. Sorry for my bad English

[@michellequang3254]

Words Dont Come Easy is a banger, you should react to.

[@kalaksed]

Oh god, just putting that out there with ni disclaimer at all? But... just make sure you do a live performance of it. They involve audience members...

[@SinghReacts]

OH OK I see haha I’ll get to it! 👌👌

[@bananagomm]

no disclaimer, only "iS a bAnGeR" i'm so proud of my fellow moomoo :>

[@michellequang3254]

@@bananagomm

[@SinghReacts]

As I’ve been told many many times “Mamamoo” is the disclaimer 😂😂😂

[@yooniesluvly6416]

you should watch the wheein fancam of my star >:)

[@SinghReacts]

LOL idk if I’m ready for that 😂

[@2ndKidd]

Whenever My Star comes on, its always a whole ass jam! Stopping just before the beat drop? How you gonna do us dirty like that?? lol joking aside, someone else mentioned it, but you should do Wheein's dance performance covers. Umm, go by newest to oldest. Trust. 1. Lo Lo kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y4PbcoNvfZqZl9U 2. Be Like Me kzbin.info/www/bejne/jJbZnYZ8rZ2dqac 3. Title kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2i3fn95o7OEp9k

[@dudasouza7012]

After aya and dinga, you should react to mamamo's Pokemon OST. Yes, they sang a song about pokemons. It's crazy dude! Spoiler: we got Moonbyul vocals and they're fire bro!

[@SinghReacts]

Ooo ok! It’s been on the list for a while I’m gonna get to it soon 👌👌

[@karenbautista8965]

Please react to Mamamoo's Sting and Girl Crush

[@fifi8736]

Since you like my star you should react to No more drama and 4x4ever next ✨

[@SinghReacts]

I’ve got a bunch of Mamamoo stuff lined up but ill add those! Thank you! 👌👌

[@brossroth9775]

You can reaction An unhelpful Guide to mamamoo.it's so funny.And It's amazing too.😍😍😍 Are you okey?

[@SinghReacts]

I’ve already done the 2 part guide from purple hawke so idk if ppl would be interested in me doing another but I’ll add it to the list!

[@aryaaitipamula6643]

listen to Star Wind Flower Sun!!!

[@SinghReacts]

Already done! Along with Paint me lol check my Mamamoo playlist!

[@Luavyy]

Hi! loveee your reactions as always❤️, can u react to wheein 7 rings cover? Its amazing! Warning: wheein twerking may kill u lol.

[@SinghReacts]

Yea I’m grouping that in with wheeins other dance covers. Might not make it out alive 😂

[@Luavyy]

@@SinghReacts Oh, yeess thank u! Stay safe🥰

[@user-fz6ih1bi6l]

"easy" by wheein plz.

[@SinghReacts]

Done! Check my channel and Mamamoo playlist!

[@elioreIH]

Really hope you will react to these videos, both are emotional videos but eye-opening to better appreciate the struggle these ladies faced. Mamamoo heartbreaking moments kzbin.info/www/bejne/pGWZinqAe8-tqKc Mamamoo story kzbin.info/www/bejne/fX3Lm52mhq2dqsk

[@shaunmather999]

Ayooo

[@SinghReacts]

Just got off work what’s good lol

[@shaunmather999]

@@SinghReacts nm how was work

[@SinghReacts]

Ooof is all I’m gonna say lol glad I recorded reactions earlier because I would’ve been so lifeless on camera 😅 might hold off until Thursday to get back at it

[@shaunmather999]

@@SinghReacts ah ok have a good day or 2 off we will be here when you get back ☺