Man City 2025 Transfers: KEEP OR SELL?

[@JSGC171]

Purely my opinion here! Who should Man City sell in 2025 from their squad?

[@English_Dawn]

Going off Pep, he doesn't want to sell anybody.

[@TwennyPastFour]

Apparently Man City are offering John Stones a new deal 😂 Ake is homegrown btw

[@andrewheywood9786]

Agree on Ederson, Walker and Stones at the back, KDB, Gundo and Kovicic in midfield. Need competition for Haaland, has lost his edge and is not as clinical. The bigger questions are Lewis, looking very ordinary, too small gets knocked off the ball too easily, Savinho has been very disappointing, maybe another year, but needs to find the goal. Nunez another with average performances. Need creativity and shots on goal, part of the problem right now is we keep possession, but have no threat, teams know if they can nick a goal we are done and can finish us off

[@nickozist.hillaire9198]

I'll sell Grealish and bring in a young winger with end product like Williams or Kvratskelia

[@HerbalMCFC]

Big up mate. Great video. If I had any saying in this I would definitely sell Walker, Kalvin asap. Sell McAtee aswell, because Pep doesn't want to use him. Wilson Esbrand aswell. Besides that we should probably let either Bernardo or Kevin leave. Imo it should be Bernardo. Ederson will most likely leave, so we need a new #1. And lastly, we have to let John go. He's never fit and we need to be a bit ruthless here. I love Stones, I really do and it hurts to even say. It's either him or Ake and Ake is despite his recent injuries, less injury prone than Stones. We have to think about the club here. Alot of players will leave within the next 2 years, have to let the right ones go at the right time, while also getting the right players in. CTID

[@nickozist.hillaire9198]

What are your thoughts on replacing Walker with Bradley if Trent signs a new deal ? Or Porro

[@Epic-Poetry]

Good call about Matt Hudson for Scott. Agreed, except keep Stones, Silva and McAtee

[@Rowan_0161]

City should start showing interest in Tchouaméni, would be great alongside Rodri can cover at Cb or Cdm and Wirtz would be my Kdb replacement

[@stuartsimister5042]

Citys main problems are for me more to do with age and certain players constantly injured and thats a bad mix.Anyone over 30 are more injury prone,we need some young legs especially in the middle where we look terrible with no rodri.

[@IvanSmith-p1n]

Man city should sell kdb and bring Jamal musiala to replace him ❤

[@thecliqueshallsetyoufree8745]

Pep did Kalvin a favour by not keeping him , the amount of internet abuse he would have gotten...🔥🔥🔥. Your list seems reasonable and yes need something to happen in January this team is going to have injury issues the entire season. But in the future , better contracts.

[@DJArifUK]

They need to sell Ederson, Ortega, Matheus Nunes, Rico Lewis and Ake and get a better replacement, in my opinion the defence, midfield and goalkeeper needs strengthening.

[@JerifKhan-pz5ie]

Walker, Gundo , KDB , Ederson.....they should leave at the end of the season. Buy a disruptor ball winning midfielder, a proper strong speedy RB, a KDB replacement (big spending, no more unproven wonderkids) . In January, probably a CDM and that's it

[@OGA_999]

Sandro Tonali (CDM), Nicolo Barella (CM), Wirtz (Leverkusen) (CAM)? Tough for Inter/Newcastle/Bayer letting them go but.. Wirtz maybe end of the season while there's an even chance for the others in January. Central defence, Right back (footballing? Ball playing?) with similar lightning pace as Walker? FRIMPONG?, Another younger (RCB) Right side for if Stones injury situation doesn't improve as back up to Dias/Akanji?. Still need a proper LEFT BACK as Gvardiol needs to start playing in his best proper position LCB, Back up STRIKER for Haaland? Look no further than Liam DELAP (He would sign in a heartbeat), both the club & him know each other well so no issue. He's gained vital EPL experience and the talent is there for anyone to see. C'mon CITEHHHHH For the first time Pep is facing serious 'career' negativity

[@JerifKhan-pz5ie]

Looks good mate ! But Frimpong doesn't have physicality​@@OGA_999

[@John-e8u1x]

Pep the best manager on earth 🌎🥇🥇🥇🥇🏆🔥👍💯

[@jackhulme6873]

Walker has to be sold unfortunately but have to say I think it's disgusting the abuse he's getting online when he's been an incredible player for us he's coming to the end of his career he's getting older give the guy some appreciation he's had the best of the best in his back pocket over years and he's been one of the best RB in Europe in my opinion 🙌🏻

[@danilosilver2432]

Bernardo, Rico, Ederson, walker

[@folaobitayo2678]

Tomas Araujo, antnioo Silva RCB

[@stephenkent129]

Sup bro let Walker go I think it’s only time before his legs go keep stones,Ake bring in another centre back move Gavardiol into defensive midfield can still cover in defence,keep Rico give him time in midfield not a starter yet,gundogan try to convince him to become a coach,keep kova his class yet played out of position,Philips go,defo keep maximo he’s potential gonna be world class remember his age,unfortunately kdb go wurtz in for me,most of the youngsters keep atleast for another year,keep Bernado cos whoever we bring in it will take time it normally takes second season before players get proper ust to our style nunes stays&yeah another striker possibly bring back Delap& give game time as for 👑PEP most definitely stays I guarantee he will get us back to our best there’s no 1 out there yet to replace because Alonso will go Madrid.

[@ironcrusader728]

My 5 year old son could put together a more coherent paragraph than this, Embarassing

[@lawrie3448]

Other City bloke thinks nine players in for 200m ! Not happening - not the Pep way . Think you are right one or two panic buys to shore up midfield - aim is cup run and top four ! Sad but thats practical . Spine is both keepers ( both decent and 30 is no age for keeper ) , Diaz and Guardiol ( he’s not a left back ) Rodders , Foden , Haaland . Keep Doku ,Savinho , Lewis , Ake ( play him in Rodris role ) Akanji as squad - rest are expendable in summer . KDB , Gundo , Kova , Grealish etc get rid . Buy quality - de Jong , Musiala , and please buy a sodding left back ( and a younger right back )

[@ChrisRobertshaw-r9c]

What about a left back...

[@ogungbayiolayinka560]

City should sell Walker in January and get a replacement for him immediately. Ederson should leave at the end of the season. Stones can be kept till end of the season but if his injury persist, he should be sold. Other players can be kept but we need players to complement Rodri and Debruyne in January and also a backup striker for Halland at the end of the season

[@HerbalMCFC]

Pretty much spot on here

[@candymonster9320]

Gundo and Bernardo should be moved on as well

[@ogungbayiolayinka560]

@@candymonster9320 both players are still relevant. Though they may not be the most physically strong players but their creativity is never in doubt. The players can still be kept in the team till the end of the season and play more in the advance role and not in the defence role. If one of the players must give way at the end of the season, may be Gundo cuz age is not on his side.But Bernado can be kept for an additional season when his contract expires or sell him at the end of the season for a reasonable amount to get a younger and quality player that can replace him. Although, there is need to rebuild the team but the process must be gradual and not total overhauling. I believe the issue with City lies more in the defence and defensive midfield. The major culprits in defence are Walker and Ederson that do commit unpardonable mistakes atimes. Absence of Rodri also exposed Gundo and Bernado that are atimes drafted to his role. Rodri is physical, faster and more defensive whereas same cannot be said of Gundo and Bernado

[@GestonePhiri]

I think for me walker, kdb, ederson, gundogan and stones they should leave this transfer window

[@Les-i7e]

Doku running around in circles

[@tettehdoku4360]

Walker, Stones, Ake, Gundo, should leave as soon as possible

[@olabiyiseyi504]

Man city should sell, walker, stone, Gundogan, Guardiol

[@dashawnballard52]

You need to stop watching if you think gvardiol needs to be sold

[@KOTPGAMING]

Fr

[@DezloneGoenha]

Not gvardiol

[@oliviergarnier3548]

What are you on 😂 gvardiol? Are you crazy??

[@English_Dawn]

👉 Most important factor today was the announcement of near record financial results! 👉 Without capital all else is dust! 👉 Pep just wanted his players back. He must rue they are not like Bernardo who is made of kryptonite and God be thanked never gets injured. 👉 Pep says their biggest enemy is the "schedule". Too many games. Going to the well once too often. 👉 He said "It will be expensive but he needs a squad of 25-30 players to compete". The two take home points are therefore FINANCIAL & SQUAD SIZE.

[@attiavebenjamin3656]

Akanji

[@Parlaypicks.]

Grealish sell bring in Kvratskelia Sell walker bring in Robinson

[@Neerajsingh_26]

Sell walker buy Frimpong.

[@IvanSmith-p1n]

Looking at Manchester City's squad for the 2024/2025 season, we can see that they have a strong and deep team ¹. However, there are a few players who have seen limited playing time or have not been performing at their best. Here are a few players who could potentially be sold in 2025: - *Scott Carson*: The goalkeeper has not made any appearances for Manchester City this season, making him a potential candidate for sale ¹. - *Josh Wilson-Esbrand*: The defender has also not made any appearances, which could indicate that he's not in Pep Guardiola's plans ¹. - *James McAtee*: With only two appearances this season, McAtee might not be getting the playing time he needs to develop, making a sale a possibility ¹. - *Oscar Bobb*: As a midfielder with zero appearances, Bobb might be considered for sale or loan to get more playing experience ¹. Keep in mind that these are just potential candidates based on limited information and may not reflect the actual needs or plans of Manchester City's management.

[@ironcrusader728]

Definitely just used chatgpt to write this, Bobb has been injured all season and is not able to play

[@THE_CITY_BLUE]

Get shut of... Kdb. Bernardo. Phillips. Walker. Ederson. Stones. Gundogan.

[@Ua9]

No keep kdb

[@stuartsimister5042]

Agree. All have had their best days unfortunately and se are constantly injured.

[@THE_CITY_BLUE]

@@Ua9 Kdb his time is up. Keeping kdb will stop city buying new players... He has to go.

[@Ua9]

@@THE_CITY_BLUE I think they should buy a new attacking midfielder and keep kdb as a super sup because he is still amazing and I don’t think they can get a ton of money out of selling him so keeping him would be a better idea

[@professorb3843]

Sell Walker Sell Grealish Don't extend Gundogan's contract Sell Stones

[@MerubaBaptist]

What could they tell the funs about winning Premier league

[@brandonstewart7854]

Sell the whole lot of them.

[@lakshmibhunia9087]

Sell with in january and summar walker, stone, kdb, gundo, kova,Grealish (0goall 1year),Banado, Nunes, Phillips,

[@daltonduce6248]

Until we and and the rest of the world know where City stand with the 115 verdict I struggle to see how we can sign anyone of quality this Jan or even the Summer. Who wants to sign for a club who might have all the trophies stripped away. Possible relegation and a team who might not even make Champions league football next season???

[@hitchsaid]

JSJC. EXCELLENT analysis

[@ChrisRobertshaw-r9c]

What about a left back....