Mann Jogi & Jafaa Raise Bar | Radd Continues To Disappoint | Tamasha Picks Up A Little | Noor Jahan

[@abeerahhilal5844]

JAFAA: Firstly, Zara is not a doctor but a wife in this relation hence we mustn’t expect her to be the therapist here... secondly, the fact she was kept unaware of Hasan’s condition is another reason why she shouldn’t have taken all this drama so lightly and let it go in the name of realisation or understanding or perhaps love whatever... her protest to the sick behaviour is very much needed and fair because why does she get to pay for his childhood traumas or anger issues... had she been informed earlier and still decided to get married would have been a totally different ball game altogether...Kudos to Mohib’s acting but Zara’s split in the morning was disturbing, she needs her fair time to heal and deal I believe!

[@itshasan2687]

This 💯💯💯 and before Ppl comapre it with dr.numair,who is a doctor and healing his wife, he knows pretty much what he's getting into!!zara has no idea

[@gerryburntwood9617]

Also Zarah is not a psychiatrist,I think she is an obstetrician! Her husband would need to be referred for appropriate therapy!

[@adeelasailm6237]

Agreed!

[@Sehri58]

i think they shouldve shown she took some time and then decided to return. I don't like they instantly allowed her to be understanding, as if nothing really happened. this wasn't a small fight, this was a very dangerous and triggering situation.

[@SAMINAHASNAIN-ft5vj]

Jafaa. Although I am enjoying the show but I feel both Andaleeb and Zara track are problematic. In Andaleeb track they are going to show that her parents forcing her to marry nomair was justified and correct In Zahra track they are showing that hiding Hassan condition was justified. And his crazy behavior is accepted due to his childhood trauma. Zahra should be more scared and concerned at this point. Plus it's not her job to fix her husband

[@Meriya9749]

Jafaa:I noticed the way the grandma stared at Zaara after revealing..I feel something is still wrong and full truth has not been revealed..I feel very sad for Zaara,....The grandma looks scary by the way

[@nkhan8933]

Yeah I noticed it too, hassan watching at 1.5 speed missed it.😂

[@shank3553]

I think there is more to the story too she is definitely hiding something maybe it was not the moms fault and the daadi did something but they blamed the mom

[@tazmeenzubair6938]

Yeah i also noticed it.

[@pammibhullar3205]

I think they have killed Hassan's mother's character in Jafaa

[@afraiqbal1019]

@@nkhan8933yea i felt the same even after watching at 2x speed as i do with literally all the dramas

[@itshasan2687]

Safeena having breakfast without any care of the world was funny 😂😂😂😂 she is like 'yeh to inka roz ka hai ,pait pooja zaroori hai'

[@zainabchaudhary5933]

In Islam its actually not preferred that women change their surname after marriage case in point Hazrat Fatima who is always introduced as Fatima bint Muhammad. Actually its a Christian/western practice and not part of our religion or culture.

[@gerryburntwood9617]

So true! It’s something we women in the west had to fight for in recent times to retain our maiden name after marriage, yet Islam gave this right some 1400 years ago!🌹 awesome!

[@MiraasbyMariyamDawood]

Thiss. I always think of this. Even the wives of Prophet saw, they married the greatest man of all and still didn’t take his name. And then his daughter married another great and honourable man like Maula Ali AH and still she didn’t take his name.

[@freyasheart9527]

I’m curious. Why isn’t it preferred to change their name

[@homeschoolindianmom]

​@@freyasheart9527it isn't preferred to change the name because in Islam, the identity of the woman is not dependent on who she marries. Both children are known by their fathers and continue to be known by their father before or after getting married. Marriage or divorce doesn't change your name.

[@zainabchaudhary5933]

@@freyasheart9527 According to Hadith every person must put their father’s name as their surname

[@beenishtauseef8262]

Hassan noticed the lock of the door in jaffa but missed the strange expressions on dadi!s face😂

[@Uniquo3777]

Guys please for your own good, change ur editor. Its really annoying that u mention a scene and the editor doesn't even bother to include a screenshot related to it. Very underwhelming:( #feedback

[@urducartoons007]

Yes #Hassan and #Amna plzzz notice this

[@amca2421]

Agree. The show needs many more screen shots and clips to liven the discussion

[@sabah_mystic]

Dear All. In comment section some are saying Iddat is 4 months 10 days. That time period is when husband dies ow after divorce it is 3 womans cycles. Details of all kinds of Iddat periods: 1. Divorce: - 3 menstrual cycles (approx. 3 months) for women who menstruate. - 3 months for women who don't menstruate due to age or illness. - Pregnant women: until childbirth. 2. Husband's death: - 4 months and 10 days (approximately 130 days)

[@hibuhhhh67]

I find Jafaa problematic. Zara is not supposed to be Hassan's therapist. In the next promo she says to the Dadi, "I will take care of him so much that he forgets all his childhood traumas". Seriously? That is not how trauma works I don't know what they're trying to show here. Hassan needs to go to proper therapy and the drama makers should promote that message, not that his wife will come and magically 'heal' him. 55:05 yes I also noticed that evil expression. The Dadi is definitely hiding something and not telling the full the story.

[@aymalahtazaz]

Couldn’t agree more. I am married to a person who has childhood traumas and I didn’t know until 2 years ago. Ever since I got married, I have been struggling to understand his behaviours. We have had a a very problematic relationship. We are still together after 4 kids but I wish I knew earlier and had the courage to leave. We as wives, are not supposed to fix our husbands. Parents should not get their sins married and get them help that they need. Unfortunately, in our society our parents think shadi is the ultimate solution to any problem and shadi k bad sab thek hojaey ga 😔.

[@mangakuray8580]

Totally agree with you! I dont understand why Hassan and Amna keep singing praises of this highly regressive drama and keep criticising Radd where childhood trauma and psychological issues are dealt with sensitivity and wisdom.

[@nawalamjad6970]

Hassan & Aamna, I'm SO disappointed of the fact that how can you call Jafaa a solid watch despite indisputably solid performaces & the writer's vision behind talking openly about childhood traumas affecting adult relationships, because when Dr. Zara says nonsensical dialogues like, "Daadi sey baat hui aur mujhey pata chala k mujhey tum sey pyar hogya jaisay Juliet ko Romeo sey hua tha..." I mean, woman, you are an experienced gynecologist, and you're willing to take up your partner as a project by being a therapist --- What? How? Why? Why don't y'all call out the dadi to have hidden such profound details of a supposedly educated guy from such a solid woman who was about to marry him for life? She gets traumatized the whole night (and this is not even having for the first time), and the grandma is guilt tripping into not leaving her grandson without giving him a closure... Without the grandma sahiba with the bobby pins realizing how seamlessly she ruined a beautiful, educated girl's life by hiding pertinent facts from her of her traumatized; disturbed grandson? Dr. Numair would also, and is already ready to be a therapist --- & the whole idealism & romance is about successful doctors taking up their partners as projects? Are they able to successfully normalize/and or justify it because Dr. Zara & Dr. Numair are doctors respectively so everytime we'd want to question their rights, they'd say, "We are doctors toh yeh toh humara farz tha logic" lol And Aamna what absolutely baffles me is as to why you're drawing this unreasonable distinction between toxic & problematic people? Hassan's character is toxic 101 & no woman even not an inch as educated or as a package like Dr. Zara's character deserves that. I really appreciate y'all repeatedly calling out Andaleeb's mother's enabler behavior towards her --- abandoning her & make her daughter doubt her sense of self, let alone self-worth... But PLEASE refrain to glorify and or joke upon Dr. Numair eventually falling for Andaleeb, when earlier, he was running away from marriage like a busy bee, and now he's over-extending himself to a girl he low-key liked since forever but agreed to marry, only because his mother gave him a chocolate smoothie shake to remind him of their childhood nostalgia lol And even if Andaleeb rightfully moves on with a guy who is willing to parent him, using his medical background, in Dr. Zara's case, it's beyond dangerous on how this drama is putting women putting up with unhealed men on a pedestal. When Hassan, and his grandma knew that he had traumas, why did he not go to the therapists before? Why did he need a woman to give him this enlightenment -- & fill/fix his mother's void? And I'm NOWHERE saying that partners can't/shouldn't be emotionally available for each other or mustn't have each others' backs' --- I mean, why does one even need a union/marriage to begin with? However, partners are NOT projects PERIOD.

[@dumblydoor3741]

100% agreed

[@sabahat987]

Exactlyyy

[@samraz6958]

Well said!! Zara does not need to take on a project! She won’t even be able to be the best therapist for him! She deserves better.

[@saratee5207]

Kitna time hay apkay to review that drama 🤦‍♀️

[@asimh69]

Very aptly explained.

[@saadia3588]

Mann Jodi is going very strong. They did use body doubles for the bicycle scene. There is a BTS of it.

[@afraiqbal1019]

where can i see that bts

[@ayshcandy7155]

But man that fall was soo scary.. jesy wo giry thy me to tab se larki ki kamar k bary me soch rahi thi k uska kya bana hoga.

[@nkhan8933]

Jafaa: hassan could have easily been a character we hate, but he feels so broken and hurt. Hats off to Mohib for performing it so well.

[@sejalmeshram5456]

One more thing about that motor repair scene he was not attracted or something by her beauty he was in aww with the fact that the girl is repairing it all by herself which is more evident when she was gone and he stood their and checked if the motor was working properly or not and gives a reaction as well.

[@shehzaadiammu2689]

Exactly 💯👍

[@zizo8737]

Exactly amna misunderstood it…he was wondering ke autein bhi aisa km krsakhte hain qke unse aise ni dehka life mein

[@arpithareddy3384]

Exactly 👍

[@banchan9oo]

yes .. but she said if it were not to be a pakistani drama, there could be some skin showing, etc, and it could be used as some spark inducing scene .. because I also thought the same way while watching .. even though it was clear that he was in awe that the girly knew how to work a water pump .. which is also very cool .. somehow, that's also added as her charming point to him .. Drama mein to abdullah ko bilkul pure dikhaya hai to obviously him being attracted to a woman (in 'that' way) that too someone else's wife won't be justified .. it's just how a viewer can view it.

[@zizo8737]

@@banchan9oo true

[@prettydreamer93]

Man Jogi: So glad Hasan and Amna discussed the scene where Aliya is repairing the motor and later making chai. Aliya's POV is that she is completely unbothered by Ibrahim's presence (it is apparent in her dupatta as she did not care to sit in a proper manner when he arrived). She only saw Ibrahim as a servant subordinate of the house. While Ibrahim looked subtly impressed by her and very much aware of her even to a point of slight discomfort. Now I am really interested in knowing what kind of dynamic did Ibrahim and Aliya have before their marriage. Was Ibrahim already attracted to her? Eager to see how the writer would play this out.

[@mitthosaleh2172]

Mann Jogi is becoming very interesting ❤ Acting Bilal and Sabina is great But Gohar's acting is very, very, very great 👍 ❤❤❤❤

[@avantikasaraswat2253]

Jaafa: I'm actually very disappointed with Jaafa, i really had high expectations. But sorry to say, Zara continuing to stay with Hassan is NOT AT ALL a wise thing to do. If they wanted to show Zara as a big-hearted person trying to help, they could have shown her trying to help him out even after separating from him. Or atleast they could have shown a temporaray separation and then returning with some help. Because it so evident now that Hassan is no ordinary case. No woman, no matter how qualified she is, should be with someone who is a threat to her physically. If i was in her place i would have carried a pepper spray in my own house and taken up Kung fu Classes. I think you guys are just being biased because Jaafa high views and audience back up. Show it to the western critics and im sure they will slam Jaafa and someone as educated as Dr.Zara to stay with a lunatic.

[@mangakuray8580]

I think they praise Jafa because they know some of the actors personally (Hassan used to be Mawra's agent). They also really like Seher. I think its just personal biases that make them 'unsee' the issues with Jafaa. I totally agree with you. I said the same that it would have made more sense for Zara to leave Hassan and later agree to continue the relationship on certain conditions like 'him getting professional treatment and getting better'. Honestly! It was so scary the way he drags her and locks her up. I would have smashed the window with the lamp and escaped during the night ..instead we see Zara peacefully falling asleep...who can sleep with a psycho across the door. :)

[@karachionwheels3121]

Noorjahan: You both missed an important point.. when kubra said to her manager: "muraad ko jitna business mai involve kia hai,kaafi hai" So she is using him

[@gerryburntwood9617]

Smart woman!

[@Mandy-vj9if]

#MannJogi : Bilal doesn't need any dialogue to express his feelings & emotions. His insane mastery in body language & facial expressions do all the magic. The subtlety, the timing, the movement of eyes, the posture, the positioning of hands, the walk, the pauses, It’s pure artistry. Ibrahim is finely curated character. It demanded a refined actor like Bilal ! No one could've aced it like he did.

[@HBZ17]

True. That’s makes me wonder.. where is Wahaj these days? Has he disappeared?

[@mangakuray8580]

So true! This is the level of acting only the best of actors can achieve.

[@dystopia384]

Jafa: None of us said that you said drama makers shouldn't show domestic abuse. What we said was that you always raise your voice how bad depiction of domestic abuse may influence people and normalize this so why wouldn't problematic themes like lgbtq relationships shown on screen wouldn't have an impact.

[@sanarauf8195]

Zara is a very frustrating character. We've been told that she's an intelligent, educated gynecologist who knows how to stand up for her rights. However, she has consistently done some very naive things throughout the show. 1. Didn't take a stand for Andleeb as she was forced into marriage against her will. 2. Did not tell Numair (her best friend, mind you) that his wife-to-be is being forced by her parents to marry him. 3. Failed to recognise that she was being manipulated by Dadi into staying. Dadi kept saying that she understood and supported Zara's decision to leave, but very conveniently chose that exact time to reveal Hassan's traumatic past to her. The first thing she should've questioned was why Dadi chose to marry her grandson off, knowing that he was mentally unstable. 4. Chose to forgive Hassan despite the fact that he constantly lost his temper with her, broke her phone, put restrictions on who she could meet, 'accidentally' hit her, followed her and LOCKED HER IN A ROOM FOR AN ENTIRE NIGHT. This 'I can fix him' attitude wasn't something I expected from her. A sad, tragic backstory does not mean that she has to forgive him for his anger management issues. It's not her responsibility to be his emotional support doll. And her giving him all the love and care in the world won't make his abusive and controlling habits go away. THERAPY WILL. 6. Let alone simply forgiving him, she promised to stay by his side FOREVER. What good do you get out of chaining yourself to someone with obvious mental problems? What if a situation arises due to which she needs to inevitably leave? Hassan will have a meltdown and it won't be pretty. On the other hand, Andleeb's track isn't enjoyable outside of her scenes with Numair. It's boiling down to a typical saas-bahu melodrama. And don't get me started on the parents. Numair's mother should be blaming the parents, NOT the girl who was forced to marry a stranger. And you know what? She should also blame herself for rushing into the marriage and deliberately ignoring warning signs from Andleeb's side. After all, Andleeb was her choice - not her son's, who was coerced into accepting her. Andleeb's parents don't give me the impression that they truly care about her happiness. If you loved your daughter, you wouldn't have gone against her wishes in the first place. You wouldn't have made her marry the first adequate suitor you found. You wouldn't have turned her out of your house and told her to go back to a place where you know she would be ostracized and unhappy. A DIVORCED DAUGHTER IS BETTER THAN A DEAD OR UNHAPPY DAUGHTER. I'm almost dissatisfied with the fact that Numair turns out to be a good guy because this essentially redeems the poor decisions taken by Andleeb's parents. They gambled her fate just to save their honor. Nothing can change that. I'm sorry for the long rant, but Jafaa genuinely seemed promising at the beginning. Now, it sets dangerous precedents and is a painful watch, owing to all the toxicity. I was quite surprised and disappointed when I saw the title because I expected you guys to critique the direction it had taken more harshly.

[@indeliblestrories9555]

Amazing

[@nawalamjad6970]

@@sanarauf8195 PREACH!!!! 🙌👏💪💫🙏

[@drsympathy6488]

This needs to be in top comments. Zara's reason for staying after hearing Hassan's backstory could have been elaborated better. She should have pointed it out to Hassan " dude you need to trust me.. our relationship cannot work if you keep doubting me and thinking that I will take your mother's route.. mutual trust is important." Also she should have taken a promise from him that he will go for therapy to heal himself from childhood trauma, and then she can promise to stand with him in difficult situations until he heals completely.

[@amna_islam]

Thoroughly enjoyed your rant!! Not a single stone left unturned 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼…start your own review channel already lol

[@sanarauf8195]

@@amna_islam Aw omg this made my day! And actually got me thinking about starting a blog of my own - because God knows I should do something productive for once 😭

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

Mann Jogi: art design … the whole template is shades of blue and yellow (similar to Kabuli P) and a lot of shots of people’s feet … Bilal’s muddy sneakers, Sabeena’s hennaed feet in her dulhan scene, Bilal straightening their shoes, Sabeena’s khussas … top notch😊

[@abdulrafaykhokhar7579]

Idk but I found man jogi color palette full of dull and warm colors on the other hand KP color palette included peacock colores, blue, green floral patterns. Its was refreshing.

[@ShiQ-gc5tx]

@@abdulrafaykhokhar7579you’re right about the shades but seems like a Kashif Nisar signature, blue doors, yellow walls, but very cohesive design elements for sure

[@MoeezMufti]

Mann Jogi: My only complaint for this drama is, which is common for all Kashif Nisar’s dramas, the sound mixing; it sometimes becomes difficult to listen what the actors are saying and have to rewind. I like the Standup Girl couple but the bhabhi being negative here was unwarranted. However, Asma Abbas was brilliant in this episode as the broken mother and interesting thing is how she covered this up in front of Aliya’s friend by keeping her captive and how there is regression in the family which lead to this point which could also reflect Shabeer’s upbringing. Bilal looking at Aliya for validation or the next command was adorable and how he hesitated momentarily when giving her a hand. Brilliant storytelling and direction.

[@gicnusrat2734]

#MannJogi - Ep 2 was so intense .I love the way they unfold story from present to past. Performance, Direction, BGM & story telling was top notch. Ibrahim express through his eyes he is clueless as of now. Aliya is devastated but she is strong & Angry Shabbir is too good. Bilal does not leave his character for a second also . His body language is so good. Kaasif Nasir is one of the best director you got. So enjoyable drama .

[@jannat65514]

No drama should go beyond 30 episode.. Ary need to stop ruining their good dramas like this..jej to radd..its irritating

[@nkhan8933]

Manjogi: did you guys miss that Shabbeer says all the dialogues that Shahbaz Shareef and Zardari have said to each other😂, I found it funny.

[@amnaqureshi4501]

😅💯👏

[@mahwishzahra3547]

He said all that dialogues in Imran Khan's style 😅

[@aquariunsana]

Exactly. 😂 ​@@mahwishzahra3547

[@naginasafdar5429]

Yessss

[@someoneelse5415]

Mann Jogi: That motor repair scene was extention of the thing Shabbir mentioned where he said to Alia that I know you wanted to be an engineer. It showed that she has the potential to be an engineer.

[@alishaaslam8954]

Speaking of education, good luck to all O and A level students who are getting their results tommorow! Less than 12 hours left. Inshallah, we will see the fruits of our hard work!

[@amnaqureshi4501]

AAMEEN INSHALLAH AAMEEN 😊BEST WISHES FOR ALL

[@afraiqbal1019]

yayy ameen ⭐️

[@sumerakhalid9159]

Ameen! Good luck.

[@nazia887]

Thanks for your best wishes

[@arpithareddy3384]

Mann Jogi : What Bilal is doing in this show is not easy .. It’s easy to act in good scenes with well written dialouges but Bilal doesn’t have anything to say through dialouges, he should convey through his expressions, eyes, body language and he is brilliantly doing the job. What a transformation from Shahmeer and Fazal ( here also he played two contrast characters ) and now Ibrahim…The range he has, outstanding performer.

[@SaiPriyaSingh]

Please review the last episode of shiddat. What a regressive ending. Would love to hear amna and hasan criticizing it

[@afsheenali110]

#somethinghaute I finished my schooling in Karachi, where we had the same boring routine every day with the same subjects like Urdu, English, Math, etc. My kids, born and raised in the USA, attend school for 8 hours and have so much to do, like music, arts, sports, library time, and more. They even have a one-hour lunch break. They have so much fun that they actually want to go to school and enjoy it at the same time. Here, kids also get the chance to explore their skills at a high level and take advantage of opportunities to compete, such as in robotics, which is a major part of their education.

[@nkhan8933]

Exactly, my kids wanted to go to school on the weekends too.

[@ai172]

Ditto. I am involved in the public education system in the US for the past 25+ years. The key difference is the way teachers create a bond with their students. The teacher - student relationship is one based on mutual respect, joy of learning, routine and discipline compared to teacher -student relationship based on fear and dictatorial control.

[@asimh69]

I had my education also in Lahore and was involved in teaching for quite some years. Now my kids are being educated in Germany. There is a huge difference in the system of education here as compared to Pakistan. There its all about learning by rot and grading. Here the schools are from 8 to 4 pm. The teaching system is more research and practical approach interspersed with sports, drama, music, technical, clubs. Also kids do during the school year short internships in different fields of work to get hands on knowledge. That helps them decide what to study later at university level.

[@arpithareddy3384]

MannJogi : Again a nice episode. Everything about the show is very intriguing and it’s becoming very interesting. Bilal what an actor.. His body language, posture was spot on . He doesn’t need any dialouges .

[@shiningglory5414]

Noor jahan is going great, and for that, the director deserves full appreciation It is one of those rare dramas where you can see that the director has put a lot of effort Every scene has some meaning, and every character holds importance When I’m watching this serial, I don’t even skip it for 10 seconds One of the most engaging dramas after khae

[@sabahatmazhar6056]

I also love NJ, but some of the scenes are a little dragged out…

[@drsympathy6488]

Musaddiq is an intelligent director.. same was the case with HABS, it was not a very unique script but musaddiq's direction made it an engaging watch.

[@mahnoorqureshi3281]

For Munn Jogi, I can only say that it came and it conquered. For me, two works of perfection, gems are ZPKB and MJ. Two most outstanding joris, performance wise and well written , for me, are of Hania Fahd and would be of Bilal Sabeena in the coming episodes. Talking about individual performances, I was blown over by Sajjal and Saba Hameed, and of course, Bilal Abbas. 👏👏 Also adding Ali Tahir as Afzal chacha and Adnan Siddiqui as Rehmati to the list. All well written characters, performed brilliantly.

[@gerryburntwood9617]

Mann Jogi: I think this arrangement of marrying another man, and divorcing him to re marry your ex husband rather shocking, simply because divorces are not meant to be pronounced so lightly ( in anger),for a start, but this arrangement is awful, and I don’t understand this concept either!I just see potential problems for women in this situation, eg if the man she marries refuses to divorce her, or if the ex husband claims she ran away with the other man, and living in ‘sin’, and lie about the second Nikkah, surely the woman will yet again be victimised and pilloried? I’ve heard of temporary ‘marriages’ happening in Iran from watching an exposé documentary of this practice! Is this a common practice in Pakistan too? I’m glad the drama is bringing this to our attention !

[@noorulain87]

​@@gerryburntwood9617the marriage arrangement as they have shown in the drama is not lawful in Islam. A divorced woman should never remarry with the intention to get back to the first husband. That is wrong which is why Ibrahim is shown in extreme guilt. His monologue in the first episode where he is literally crying and saying he has committed a huge sin is because this practice is against shariah. Since the storyline is non-linear, we are yet to discover why they all agreed to this arrangement. And also, as far as I know, this is not a common practice in Pakistan (I could be wrong though).

[@gerryburntwood9617]

@@noorulain87 thank you for enlightening me on this! I rewatched that scene with Bilal, and could now appreciate why such a pious man was ridden with guilt and why I think Sabeena’s character tried to commit suicide, on the night of the Nikkah! This drama thus is a great social issue commentary and I’m looking forward to watching the rest of the drama to see how they handle it!🌹

[@rakshindasaifi6189]

Mann jogi and Jafaa just blow my mind..... literally yar Specially Mann jogi I just loved the drama and all the performances and Bilal Abbas he's a wonderful actor and with this type of character he proved it.... looking forward to the next episode.... lot's of love from India 🇮🇳🥰

[@OptimisticPanda]

Why do our drama writers forget that they are writing a drama and not a novel. Why couldn’t Radd stay on one track.. the writer got so excited and jo koi story un k mind me thi they added all of them in Radd. Koi 3 different dramas can come out of Radd…

[@naimashaheen3631]

About aqeel I don't think he's annoying but the final cut that's uploaded on KZbin makes it a bit because the references of some scenes are cut,which makes the latter part of the conversation annoying. In the uncut version you can easily observe that aqeel is the only one who is actually entertaining everyone

[@mariaamjad99]

and honestly when he talks he is very precise and come across as very strong personality

[@umer597]

If anyone is annoying, it's Saima.

[@HK-cb6jd]

yes he is entertaining! rooting for him

[@AmyKhan123]

Inko arslaan acha laga because usko pehly se janty hn

[@UniqueAsmrmysterycorner88]

Aqeel is not annoying plz

[@mitthosaleh2172]

Jafa .. this drama is becoming very good 👍 👌 👏. Mohib Mirza and Mavra are doing great 👍

[@ushadubey8615]

Bilal is fantastic Bina dialogue bole eyes expression aur body language se Sara Kam kr jate hai hr trh ke role me Kamal karte hai chuchap bohot versatile handsome cute actor hai and aik Nadia Madom hai first episode ke liye 6 marks diye she is of course jealous

[@urvashiverma9585]

I feel the flashbacks in mann jogi showed how their connection developed over time.

[@beenishtauseef8262]

Mann jogi jaffa n zard paton ka bun masterpieces i m only enjoying. Did anyone noticed the mysterious expressions on dadi face when zara decided not to leave hassan.

[@naziakhan1019]

Bilal Abbas is a brilliant actor of this era. He’s one of the few who has the guts to take on such a low-key character after portraying a heroic role in Ishq Murshid that garnered a billion views. I’m in awe of his performance-hats off to him. He has raised the bar for good actors in the industry at this moment. Current leading actors need to step out of their heroic roles and take on more authentic characters like him. Brilliance, brilliance, brilliance!

[@nkhan8933]

Ratta system needs to end in Pakistan. That’s the only way to go. Anyone who does good in exams due to his/her memorizing skills, is not truly an educated person.

[@PancakeRights]

I disagree because true education is not about knowing content of subjects rather being a good person and helping people and doing your work properly

[@juveriaroses]

Im sorry but the hadith says : you will be called on the day of judgement by your name and your father's names , so therefore keep good names -abu dawood

[@3Crumbs]

Exactly, thanks for this. Sunnah and Hadith tell us we will be called by our father’s names. al-Bukhaari included a chapter entitled “Chapter: The people will be called by their father’s names, in which he quoted hadeeth no. 6177 from Ibn ‘Umar (may Allaah be pleased with him), that the Prophet (peace and blessings of Allaah be upon him) said: “A banner will be raised for the betrayer on the Day of Resurrection and it will be said: This is the betrayer of So and so the son of So and so.” This hadeeth was also narrated by Muslim (1735). That which was narrated saying that people will be called by their mothers’ names is da’eef (weak). Ibn al-Qayyim (may Allaah have mercy on him) said in Tuhfat al-Mawdood bi Ahkaam al-Mawlood (p. 147):

[@shamamalik3463]

@@3Crumbs Yes Amna and hasan plz correct this in next review

[@sameerasiddiqi4277]

Yes. We will be called by our father's name on the day of judgment.

[@sidraferoze3474]

Oh, thank you for sharing this. This information is new to me as well

[@madmudd100]

@@3Crumbs where is father or mother mentioned in Hadith you quoted???? I m copy pasting the Hadith u quoted When Allah will gather together, on the Day of Judgment, all the earlier and later generations of mankind, a flag will be raised (to mark off) every person guilty of breach of faith, and it will be announced that this is the perfidy of so and so, son of so and so (to attract the attention of people to his guilt). حَدَّثَنَا أَبُو بَكْرِ بْنُ أَبِي شَيْبَةَ، حَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ بِشْرٍ، وَأَبُو أُسَامَةَ ح وَحَدَّثَنِي زُهَيْرُ، بْنُ حَرْبٍ وَعُبَيْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ سَعِيدٍ - يَعْنِي أَبَا قُدَامَةَ السَّرَخْسِيَّ - قَالاَ حَدَّثَنَا يَحْيَى، - وَهُوَ الْقَطَّانُ - كُلُّهُمْ عَنْ عُبَيْدِ اللَّهِ، ح وَحَدَّثَنَا مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ عَبْدِ اللَّهِ بْنِ نُمَيْرٍ، - وَاللَّفْظُ لَهُ - حَدَّثَنَا أَبِي، حَدَّثَنَا عُبَيْدُ اللَّهِ، عَنْ نَافِعٍ، عَنِ ابْنِ عُمَرَ، قَالَ قَالَ رَسُولُ اللَّهِ صلى الله عليه وسلم ‏ "‏ إِذَا جَمَعَ اللَّهُ الأَوَّلِينَ وَالآخِرِينَ يَوْمَ الْقِيَامَةِ يُرْفَعُ لِكُلِّ غَادِرٍ لِوَاءٌ فَقِيلَ هَذِهِ غَدْرَةُ فُلاَنِ بْنِ فُلاَنٍ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ Reference : Sahih Muslim 1735a In-book reference : Book 32, Hadith 10 USC-MSA web (English) reference : Book 19, Hadith 4301 (deprecated numbering scheme)

[@cabeekafarooq9789]

Mann jogi: In the first episode, It was actually Bilal Abbas who called out Adhan? 😱

[@NabihaIrfan-w2g]

@Mann Jogi, love it , all actors are fab but Gohar 🔥he is brilliant , tell me if anyone can point out any of his characters he played , which seemed loose . Any new drama with his name in it, I know it’s going to be a treat to watch .

[@shank3553]

I was laughing so hard at the twist in Radd what the heck has this drama become🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️There is no hippa or privacy laws bw dr and patient?!? who the heck calls spouse and tells all the patient traumas they must be so bad at their job need the wife to take part in treatment - what the heck is their job what has the dr been doing😂😂😂😂 Also regarding Mann jogi def excellent episode really thrilling!! but I thought you guys would comment on how the divorce happened. There has been some discussion about how instant three times talaq on the spot is not valid. I thought that along with iddat it woukd also be addressed. I was disappointed that maulvi saab didnt say anything like that and said yes you are divorced now and nothing else. Do all the maulvis in Pakistan believe this school of thought because I don't think this is correct the way divorce is done in Pakistan. There has to be some time between each talaq - I was hoping you would discuss this maybe you missed it

[@skrskr8957]

True i didn't think that way about it before, but there is confidenality between dr and patient.

[@HibaAisha]

Jafaa: Zara was wearing an Apple Watch she could have still called someone

[@renugangwar7787]

Hehee correct.. same thoughts

[@sabazeee5341]

May be it was not connected to the phone at that time..mohib k character k pas phone tha or ho skta h us ne bluetooth off kr diya ho

[@ayshcandy7155]

😂

[@maira3304]

I love radd but your review on it is soo funny🤣😭 46:09 watched it almost 5 times to laugh again and again😂

[@anaya-sheikh]

The most depressing thing was when Zara didn't even protest in front of Dadi that why she or Hassan didn't tell her about his anger issues or traumas.she is a doctor but still she had the right to know k usky husband k Sath kia issues hain or agr pth chalny k bad b wo us se shadi krny ka decision Leti tw smjh me ata.

[@gicnusrat2734]

Bilal does not have much dialogue but his body language was enough to express the situation. When Ibrahim was calling Aliya ji i remember Salman used to call Aliya in KA & it sound so different from this time. Direction & BGM was top notch. #BilalAbbasKhan #MannJogi

[@Thatonekid954]

What hassan is saying is not out of this world...this is a a real discussion these days...are school relevant ?the learning methodology and curriculum needs serious changes.after primary education every thing needs to be altered.

[@nkhan8933]

Radd: thank god it’s ending. Our dramas have a way to ruin itself. It is all over the place now.

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

To me, Radd drama has really gone downhill. It's not just the storyline and how it's being executed; the lead actors' performances aren’t doing it for me either. I'm actually glad it's wrapping up next week! I’ve pretty much lost hope in our drama makers because it seems many of them get sidetracked midway, ultimately ruining projects that started with such great potential.

[@prettydreamer93]

Radd: Good to see that they are discussing impact of PTSD, but it could have been somewhere in between the story and not in the end, where already so much is happening. Also, the doctor's diagnosis scene with Emaan was super filmy, it legit reminded me of Bhool Bhulaiya where Akshay tells Shiney Ahuja about Vidya balan😂😂😂

[@sejalmeshram5456]

Also those freakin eyes that bilal holds my god kyaa bole ab... Please next time when you guys talk about performances naa highlight the small details thaat these man put on his character like the hesitancy he showed before hepling her in motor repair and when he fall down. Not even making a single eye contact with her bro kyaa detailings par kaam kiya hai inhone ✨

[@nsa807]

I’m soo happy Aamna watched Tamasha! Thank youuuu Aamna!!! ❤️❤️❤️

[@afifaahmed7394]

Hassan on schools: my four yr old started his preschool today, I m so overwhelmed. On the same day it’s my fifth grader’s first day of homeschooling. Education is way beyond schooling and of course schooling can be a part of it. It’s high time we must teach character before academics.

[@sairabilal4060]

husband name is purely societal thing. in islam a person should be called by their parents name. I specifically told my daughters never to change surname after marriage

[@Sum-5]

Islam doesn’t permit you to change your father’s name to husband’s, it’s forbidden

[@marycan5064]

Ur right @hassan Humna in Tamasha is very annoying. I mean if you can't do anything then why are u even in the Tamasha house 🤔

[@nkhan8933]

Man jogi: I’m just loving this drama. I wish it was on twice a week.

[@mishalbaig616]

Oh how i wish I could show your intro to my parents.. I kid you not I as a high-schooler attempted 3 suicides because of not being able to cope with my parents expectations.. now that I'm in uni independent, I feel do much better but still feel bad for my siblings

[@mishalbaig616]

Oh and the best part is that I didn't have the choice of choosing my career

[@afraiqbal1019]

i genuinely feel so sad for you!! and you should be proud of yourself. im somewhat in the same situation, well but my parents have become more understanding after seeing my miserable condition due to academics. good luck to you 😊

[@mishalbaig616]

@@afraiqbal1019 I'm really happy for you ☺️

[@PancakeRights]

​@@mishalbaig616 You should change your career and reroute. It's your life. You should follow your heart and do what suits you. You're an adult and don't need their permission to get your own degree and start your own job! Your life your choice and your parents were so wrong with what they did to you :( I'm so sorry to hear that you attempted su1c1de and I sincerely hope you seek therapy and support from good friends and can move on in life! Education and grades aren't everything, you just have to be happy and a good person!

[@rizhas9008]

You guys were so right about Sabina Farook character, make up, attitude etc. Unlike Sajal, She is playing a very good role but her way is too polished for a village girl.Her make up should look like a village girl.

[@cabeekafarooq9789]

(99)chapter: *Calling the people by their father’s name.* Bukhari:6177 Narrated Ibn `Umar: The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "For every betrayer (perfidious person), a flag will be raised on the Day of Resurrection, and it will be announced (publicly) 'This is the betrayal (perfidy) of so-and-so, the son of so-and-so.' "

[@anonmous1284]

aamna apko apki saas ne noor jahan ki tarah naam badalne ka nahin kaha ?? 😂

[@illustrationsbysara]

😂😂

[@xeebfatimah4542]

good one 👍😂

[@aliciawayne]

😂😂😂

[@amna_islam]

I was literally thinking the same lol

[@Skin983]

Thanks amna a lot that you actual understand eman that she is geninue in show everybody please vote for eman she will entertains us in episodes

[@nkhan8933]

NJ: this drama is interesting and enjoyable because of its attention to detail like Aamna said. How Maha was shown as having cramps, and then the last scene which shows her pregnant. Amazingly executed.

[@seemamurad4576]

2:52 sounds like a Noor Bano, Noor Jahan moment😂

[@abdulrafaykhokhar7579]

What a catch 😂

[@saniak5262]

Lol i thought the same, and just dropped that comment

[@mangakuray8580]

You guys actually put Mann Jogi and Jafaa in the same sentence? Seriously?? Jafaa raising bar? A highly regressive parenthood concept where parents LITERALLY forces their daughter into a marriage, combined with a husband parenting a wife half his age, which we are to believe as the epitome of love, to a highly educated woman being harassed and imprisoned by her husband ..are you guys watching the same play as the rest of us? Mann Jogi, on the other hand, truly deserves the 'raising the bar' sentiment.

[@PancakeRights]

Thank you so much for saying this. Andaleeb's parents should go to jail and Andaleeb should take divorce and complete her studies! She should live alone as an independent and working woman, away from her toxic parents who stole her childhood love and forced her to attempt su1c1de. Furthermore, Zara should divorce Hassan and continue her job. Women don't need men and we're not responsible for putting up with abuse. Times have changed. Andaleeb is a legal adult at 18+ and her parents can't force her to do anything. If this was the west they'd already be in jail- children Andaleeb's age work and pay fees on their own or live out and get a loan.

[@naheedizhar9113]

Being a former teacher in USA I must say here education system is absolutely different relaxed and well structured easy for a teacher and easy to communicate students teachers make sure they GRASP THE CONCEPT SO YA I CAN COMPARE CUZ TAUGHT IN PAKISTAN BEACONHOUSE SO MANY YEARS TOO 😢😢

[@NayyeraKhan]

Amna. your name story is so interesting. Enjoyed it. ❤

[@annazaidi7197]

Amna brightens my day❤

[@Rorygilmore22]

It’s so fun to watch y’all review tamasha, please continue to do this

[@samihamoazzama8050]

OG something haute audience already knew the trivia about aamna's name and the story too😂

[@sabahshaukat8157]

Hi Hassan and Aamna, i live in UK and here until end of year 6 there are no exams like in Pakistan. There are few small evaluations throughout the years though. Kids barely bring books home. I remember studying in Pakistan in had everyday almost 8 homeworks, bag was so heavy that shoulders would hurt. Kids have a lot of opportunities when they are close to Olevels or A levels . Jobs and work experience is encouraged and definitely their confidence and social skills flourish

[@PancakeRights]

Same I have also been educated in the UK

[@maryamg4488]

Also she was wearing Apple Watch in jafaa. She could have just call and text from the watch because phone was right next to the room.

[@zainabchaudhary5933]

Hassan this hairstyle suits you a lot. The talk talk show look makes you look much older

[@alizakhan396]

Indeed Hum TV dramas always raise the bar.

[@vijayalakshmibalasubramani8670]

@@alizakhan396 true by every word about Bilal

[@Uno_123]

Thankuuu Amna for watching tamasha. You're reviews are more sensible than anyone.

[@user-xu3wl3hn7b]

Zara should leave , he's dangerous the level of anger they have he couldve killed her. Being traumatised is understandable but not justifiable. Hassans recovery is his responsibility and she could support him but from distance

[@SAMINAHASNAIN-ft5vj]

Yes exactly I don't understand why Zara is not traumatized after being locked up in a room all night or running for her life at this point

[@safiyasiddiqui9545]

I like when you discuss indian politics. Jaya Bachchan was right as the speaker was giving very strange look like teasing her that's why she reacted.

[@fatimajabeen9828]

In Australia, School Education is free in public schools, a child goes to school at the age of 6. And till grade 6 the schooling focuses on life skills and communication. Better than any top private schooling in Pakistan.

[@Peace-nq2nz]

NJ: guys! Why isn’t anyone mentioning that NJ has made a big fuss thrice to call Noor bano only bano. And then in the next scene they are all calling her Noor bano again. Including NJ herself. Throughout the drama she is calling her Noor bano and asking other people to call her bano. And nobody is calling her bano. Big error.

[@tulsibhatia2823]

Schools can only be redundant if parents can devote quality time to kids to train them in skills,values.

[@tulsibhatia2823]

Teach them right from wrong and give them a direction for life.

[@delhibellyful]

Guys I am liking Radd drama in spite of its getting dragged further. I was annoyed by Tere bin extended where I stopped watching that drama.

[@FatimaHasan-pp4ny]

Hasan you must carry this look, it looks way better than yojr other hairstyles

[@aditichoudhury1520]

Home schooling is in vogue these days. There is a separate home school board too.

[@shiningglory5414]

My prediction mind doesnt buy dado’s story in jaffa What i feel is that hassan murdered his own mother Theres a scene in OST where zara looks absolutely stunned and her head is bandaged Maybe when she gets to know this

[@keertishetty237]

I feel dado has fed Hassan with wrong story regarding his mother.I think dado is the main culprit

[@Alisha_Khan2001]

Okay, Hassan, and Aamna! You guys are my favourites! I resigned a week back. So, to gear myself up for my next job, I will watch your next video and all the pending ones (also AHI) when I get a new one to celebrate. Till then I will miss you! And, my fellow fans, please make dua!

[@SomethingHaute]

Good luck! May Allah give you a new job sooner than you're expecting -- Hassan

[@MAbd-pt8dv]

Tamasha: I totally agree about Agha-he can be really annoying, especially during the tasks. And as for Saima, I can’t believe you didn’t notice / mention how she age-shames everyone! She’s already done it with Mahi and Ayaz. Plus, she really acts like a drama queen, often taking things too far, which is so annoying. That whole situation with the word "jealous" was a perfect example; she just couldn’t let it go. OMG! what a terrible word "jealous" is! 🤨😅

[@knmhs]

I love watching noor jahan with my husband !! Its so real and greatly written and directed

[@mawishzafran7319]

4:20 I thought you would be called by your father's name on the day of resurrection, people will be called with their names and with the names of their fathers; The Messenger of Allāh (peace and blessings upon him) stated, “You will all be called on the day of judgement by your names and your father's names, so therefore keep good names for yourselves” (Abū Dāwūd)

[@Sehri58]

im just as OCD about bathrooms as you are Aamna so watching this was very encouraging LOL people think i am crazy! but I have to say cleaning bathroom isnt a big deal if its just your own. Living abroad means we do have to do that, but yes I would never wash one used by many people!

[@talta1000]

Aamna and Hassan perfect duo. I love them. Both are so sensible ❤ xxx

[@urvashiverma9585]

I agree with hasan. Kids need to be taught more practical skills at school along with the standard subjects.

[@mxhsvn_b7866]

guys homeschooling exists

[@bilshanian]

In the cycle falling scene in Mann jogi actors were replaced but still Mann jogi isn't disappointing

[@Kanzaidi]

Maan jogi: I havent watched the epiosde yet but heard alot about it .. the idaadh period is 4months n 10 days. you both are saying 3 months n 10 days ... its actually 4 months n 10 days

[@user-xu3wl3hn7b]

In case of death it's 4 months 10 dayz but in case of talaq it's 3 months

[@nayyerqureshi1295]

In talaq it's 3 months, khula 1 month , husband's death 4 months and 10 days

[@medinafaizy-hashemi4759]

Hasan and Aamna! Can you guys add Kaffara to review even though it’s daily??? Ali and Laiba’s chemistry is tooooo good

[@shahidanisar1525]

Now the young girls are keeping their father’s names. Which is encouraged.

[@sadafkhan2509]

Hassan and amna why are u guys not doing any podcast ? Plz bring that back.

[@fatemakhan1871]

Yes enjoying mann jogi the direction n writing.