Mariah Carey Without you live in ISCHGL (Austria) 30/04/12

[@kenneththecompunerd]

This was very emotional. One of her best performances of Without you.

[@KR16D]

Sounds so 90's. So happy she's doing older songs like this and Emotions.

[@jjong4800]

She sounded so good it made me cry………

[@capcomfighter13]

What a wonderful and heartfelt performance! I truly hope someone has Underneath the Stars as well!

[@RomuloVideos2]

I can't believe she's singing her epic songs! I'm so glad for that!

[@potatosalad8]

she sounds amazing. im loving the huskier tones of her voice

[@pinklavender12]

Mariah Carey is the best. She's the greatest artist of our time. Thank God for her.

[@thinhvietnguyen]

OMG, she hasnt performed this song for decade. OMG How i love you MC. OMC

[@Mazra42]

This song was made for her voice. 20 years since her 1993 performance and she still nails it.

[@TheJan2988]

I don't know why u guys talk about insecurity, this was an amazing performance, one of her best lately, because her voice WAS THERE, no prerecorded vocals, just her voice as it is now. That's her new voice, she is not 25 anymore so she shouldn't be trying to sound like she used to. Now she has a lower and richer tone. And I'm loving it more.

[@PietArion]

IT MOVED ME TO TEARS!!! IT WAS SOOO GREAT!!!!!

[@154ant]

thanks buddy for uploading this.it's AMAZING!!!!!

[@randiparis]

and this is why i'll always love Mariah

[@MaluGJ]

TE AMO MARIAH CAREY!

[@CheersMusic]

MORE MORE MORE AUSTRIA! Thanks for uploading! We're still thirsty..

[@MrLeslita20]

Amazing!!!

[@njmc3851]

She s perfect!

[@sentfromupabove]

please upload more love these !!!!!!!!!

[@shanghaichica]

She had hundreds of amazing performances in the first 7 years of her career which are yet to be bettered by any other singer. She set the standard, she is the voice/songbird supreme so she can lip all she wants now. Incidentally, she sounded good on the live parts in this concert, and her voice is getting stronger.

[@DJQTUBE]

It takes quite a bit of mastery to have the breathing control that Mariah does, most notable in "We Belong Together". Was very impressed that she carried the whole note 2:27 - 2:44. Looking forward to her new album later in the year. Cheers from USA all!

[@ESPIE.OFFICIAL]

It's been a while! How are you? She had caution and all ❤️

[@Jave87Jave]

AMAZING as always

[@BrunoPushy]

Oh God! How I love this woman....

[@oksanamamba5341]

one of the best songs of my chilldhood

[@orlimg]

Funny how the haters are so interested that they find their way somehow. Love your enemies. We love you because you are giving Mariah publicity before her album drops. Thankyou muchly!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@gabrielebaldin]

very very good performance !!

[@simonesouza8877]

perfect... ken lee

[@Ahgwenas]

the queen is back!

[@TAI1992912]

so emotional .. i love her .

[@Danny_Blossoms]

I love her hair due and she looks so GOOD!!!!! Always :) Greta look :) THIN too :$

[@jameld55]

Wow you can feel the emotion when you hear this performanec

[@briobrandon911]

Her voice definitely waned through the years. But she does not need to prove herself, 20+ years in music, she had done greatly enough. She is merely enjoying her time on stage and releasing music for her fans. Lamb for life!

[@pastcineo]

are y'all crazy? she still sounds like an angel to me!!!

[@douglas_allvesz]

thank!!!!!!! MIMI love you divaaa in Austria!!!! :)

[@Lehcim04]

Wow toujours aussi magnifique que la premiere fois

[@CBLamb95]

Shut up daahlings. I was there, and she was GREAT. This was totally live, like all the other performances on that Concert. She was great.

[@jonmcsingee]

This woman right here. SIIIIGGGHHHH. Lover her.

[@Drowshy]

first! love ittt

[@WalkingLifestyleVlogs]

Haters always saying Mariah lipped when she sings well..My God Pls clean your ears..Its PURE LIVE!!!!.

[@Mariahcarey-b7e]

She is Diva All the time She is an angel She has great voice Whitney Too!!!!!!!!

[@mcolluci]

Que surpresa cantar essa msk..tanto tempo qe ela nao cantaava *-*

[@Lehcim04]

MERCI. THANK YOU AMAZING

[@mc1231818]

Thank you for correcting my mishap : )

[@Complexity00X]

she can still sing. :)

[@bixxius]

no, it's not the backup singers, it's easy to hear it's the studio version in a lower key, she's been doing that for years. She sang the verses and small parts in the choruses live.

[@EduardoCefas]

Que mulher linda, que perfect.

[@g20938]

Mariah carey wow love you, your music makes me happy.

[@pumaschivas1475]

simply the best......

[@lc0309]

@xtinasdisciple ikr? I feel so sorry for her. But i have faith in her producers i'm sure they will fix the mess and then eventually create an amazing set of pre-recorded vocals for her to lip-synch while being on tour. That's what i hope as a the devoted mimi fan that i've always been

[@cahh_azevedo]

the best diva of all time

[@brandinj]

so for all yall who say she lost her voice this proves she did NOT lose it I love her and I am a lamb

[@KAYYBEESOUS]

I still love her.

[@sentfromupabove]

Epic strong D5 belted growl :3 i like the sustained note she did at the end her voice sounds so beautiful here I loved the improvisations :) I would love hearing a rerecorded version of Without You 2013 version for valentines day or w/e, like she redid hero in 2009 :P

[@saphyn]

i missed this mariah

[@josecontatocontato7936]

Diva! Te amo! Forever❤

[@mc1231818]

I give her props for singing in the cold and not canceling because I wouldn't want to to sing in the cold.

[@OKzs]

VIVA MARIAH - great performance and classy outfit

[@benburgess8063]

For all the people claiming this is lipped I have 2 words for you, prove it ?!?! No I thought not :) she is Mariah Carey for god sakes !

[@TheVortexologist]

that was actually really good!! can't wait for new album!!!!!!!! xD

[@LucVitin]

OMGGGGGGGGGGGGG

[@TheMCLamb4ever]

OH MY GOOOODDD!!!!!!!!!! MARIAH'S VOICE!!!!!

[@Danny_Blossoms]

@yanz21 Exactly! plus! she went to France prior to this for a getaway with her family, she didn't rest enough. And plus it was cold up there, snow and she was 2,300 up and she still sounded great!:)) she did say on her twitter that "tonight was difficult sining as much as giving birth" because she was high up there

[@mc1231818]

Just to let the Lambs know, she performed more.. 1. Emotions 2. It's Like That 3. Shake It Off 4. Obsessed 5. I'll Be There 6. Make It Happen 7. Without You 8. Always Be My Baby 9. My All 10. Touch My Body 11. Heartbreaker/Love Hangover 12. We Belong Together 13. Underneath the Stars 14. Hero They just haven't uploaded : )

[@heartshapelocket]

not at all, backing track contains backing vocals, this means she's singing along with the track, and you can still listen to her voice, by the way, check her performance of hero in plot your escape, no backing track at all, just normal backing vocals in some parts, but you can hear her voice well.

[@Dam112]

She sounds so good, there was no real need to lip any of this though

[@aries2785]

OMG forget all the other performances i just need to see Underneath the stars and My all asap like in the next 5 mins would be great

[@kenneththecompunerd]

So heart felt, so emotional... I wanna get drunk and sing along. The Queen is back!!!!

[@PietArion]

she had to sing this song - because it was a Nr1 Hit here in Austria!!! and a lot people expected to hear that song ;)

[@initochanchan]

Did you hear Hero from the beginning? I think the low note she did at the beginning was amazing. I'm always shocked at her capacity to improvise new vocal arrangements for songs she has sung a thousand times. I don't think she should pre-record high notes because when she's well rested she still kicks ass and her voice has NEVER been as deteriorated as Whitney's was. She was tired after celebrating, not enough sleep prolly and ad to that the altitude and cold. Some songs she did great. Emotions?

[@sodade21]

omg i want moreeeee!

[@drewtaylor5613]

Remember we all love mariah for her meslimatic, acrobatic musicanship and she never disappoints. She had years of vocal training and practice so she knows what she is doing. Think of it like this. Say you were a bodybuilder and you worked on your arms everyday and they were huge, But Unfortuantly you got ran over and both your arms were paralyzed.well your brain would send messages to the muscle fibers the move but the would be unable to do strain, trauma. damage. same with her woice

[@MegaJuanchon]

MARIAH ERES LA MEJOR. ;-)

[@MCLAMB4LIFE1]

Jimmy Iovine a major producer said on American Idol its one of the five hardest pop songs to sing and I agree. You need to have great breath support and the way the the vowel in the belted "I CANT LIVE" C#5 note is placed is difficult to sing. You need great control and power. In this performance Mariah lowered the key from the original studio recording to be able to sing it more comfortably.

[@lnasilva1]

Amor da minha vida....eternamente irei te amar e não saberei viver sem você nunca......obrigado por existir e trazer alegria pra minha vida......Mariah, não sei viver sem você...te amo...ASS Leandro Almeida Belém Pará Brasil...............emocionado muito.

[@Aleeshaee]

she actually performed this during the E=MC2 era :)

[@Polylovelingo124]

ooohhh okay hahaha I was a lil offeneded(I don't know why) hahahahah thanks for clearing that up!:D I gotacha:D

[@justicem0119]

i remember this.... this was after Nick was in the hospital and they found out he had Lupus... awww.

[@mc1231818]

0:59-1:06 her facial expressions are beautiful !

[@MegaJuanchon]

amazing

[@iLoveTreySongz94]

I love her makeup and hair here :O

[@adalbertozamudiovertty4456]

EXACTLY!!!

[@Danny_Blossoms]

@kaiyno She was VERY not insecure at Gotham hall . She was pleasantly well here. Looked great,skinny etc

[@CHARLESJOYDJ]

omg humilhou ao vivo , calou a boca de muitosss .... kd a cantora q tinha perdido a voz no passado...

[@benburgess8063]

For fuck sake I wish people would give this woman a break ! I do not think that this is lipped personally there is clearly a recorded version playing in the background but I think she has done this to make her voice sound more full, if you listen carefully to her tone you an hear the imperfections and raspyness , come on she is MARIAH CAREY for god sakes give her some credit she is the best singer alive ! Oh an for the record the 4 people that disliked this videos are seriously smokin somethin

[@Danny_Blossoms]

@XTINASDISCIPLE She was at very high altitudes. And it was cold . Pplus she does have to preserve her voice. who cares at least she was there and DID perform and I really love 3:00 and on. So fresh and emotional. She's 42 not 22 . She don't need to prove. She performed a lot live of not all at Gotham hall

[@lc0309]

I could not agree more with you. I've been a MIMI fan ever since my grandmother talk to me about her but all that is gone. I get that she's not the young girl she used to but i just wish she would stop faking and pretending we as fans don't deserve respect from her.

[@StarpeemReturns]

WOW

[@MCLAMB4LIFE1]

Your Welcome! but have you ever tried to sing the same note for example c#5 using different vowels certain vowels are easier to sing. The "ee" and "ih" vowels are harder to sing than the "ah" and "uh" vowels. try it and you'll see what I'm talking about. :)

[@CBLamb95]

I am a Lamb and i was at this Concert (Front row) but STOP BASHING Christina! Shes amazing!

[@MrEricrockinout]

Okay, That was a throwback, and she killed it... Talk all the shit you want.. That WAS NOT LIPPED! HAHA SHE IS BACK! CANNOT WAIT FOR NEW ALBUM! I agree with the person at the end.... WORKKKKKK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@RomuloVideos2]

How come? She have at least two G5's. One in Hero Tokyo Dome and another one in Vision Of Love (live in London).

[@Polylovelingo124]

I think she did hit it in her most recent shake it off performance. I mean she belted that whole prahse out, why not go for the G? Plus it was scratchier than usual(in a good way hahaha). I also think the chorus in this song is live. Cause if you listen to Shake it off, her mid register is basically still like how it was in her prime. I think that's what throw people off. They think her mid has changed tonality, when it really hasn't all that much.

[@JamieCleaton1]

incorrect, it actually sounds like they pitch shifted the vocals :/

[@honeyteom]

woooooooow,she still can sing the lower keys

[@mc1231818]

Don't say that it's lipped cause you know it is not. While she is singing those big notes, her back up singers are singing also.

[@eusouoleli]

I LOVE MARIAH s2 n_n

[@SpringerBoy1000]

Mariah looks good wit her lonq hair !!!!

[@Polylovelingo124]

Because, at the end of the day, no matter how many accolades she has, no matter how many hit singles she has garnered, no matter how successful she is, she is still a human being. On top of that, she's her worst critic, not to mention she's not the type to just go all out for it. I'm sure if we're patient we;ll get what we've been waiting for. I't sonly a matter of time.

[@MCLAMB4LIFE1]

The parts that are live sounded good! She needs stop doing those awkward moments where she hides her face at 2:37. But I'm glad that shes trying to sing some of her old songs. This is one of the hardest songs to sing in pop history.

[@viniciusmartinho6985]

💕💕💕👑👑

[@VictorUeberbacker]

Well, she did sing very well in NY last month.