Marian the librarian 01.1

[@jeffmacht7559]

I saw this show in August. I have seen many shows over the years, but I have never seen a show where the two main characters, Jackman and Foster common have such amazing chemistry. This may be best show I’ve ever seen. It was obviously entire cast was having a great time.

[@ybcarlebach266]

They were having their little jokes that don’t belong in the shows. Thats where you may have seen ‘chemistry.’ We saw no chemistry. Foster was miscast. She did not do a good job as Marian. We were disappointed. We paid a lot of money for up close tickets. My family knows every line of the show as we have seen the excellent movie dozens of times. And this show did not succeed or come close.

[@ojj75]

HJ got COVID a few days before the performance I attended, so I didn't get to see him in this. 😭 At least now I know what it would've been like with him as Harold Hill. Thanks for uploading the video! That said, understudy Max Clayton was absolutely marvelous. He reminds me a lot of Seth MacFarlane, and the audience gave the cast a well-deserved standing ovation that night. 👍😊

[@thecutehuey]

Owww so sorry about that😭

[@broadwaymike92]

I saw the show twice!!! The first was actually with Max during the week Hugh had COVID after the Tonys. He blew my mind!!! Then I went back again in January before it closed and I saw Hugh. Both brought different takes on the role. Both fantastic and amazing chemistry with Sutton Foster!!!

[@Multifandom04]

Wish u had the full show. The quality is so good

[@oliviawilkerson2801]

Was the first Broadway Show I ever attended. Sutton was out due to Covid, but her understudy was exceptional! Pretty sure Hugh Jackman got COVID a few days after, tho.

[@jacksonhoopah]

I saw this show about a year ago, it was fantastic. I thought that Hugh Jackman was a PHENOMENAL actor and a good singer, but Sutton Foster was the best part of that entire production. She was miscast, but she committed to the role and made the best of a role that didn't play to her strengths. There was a period in the scene by the footbridge right before Till There Was You when Harold Hill cracked a joke, the whole audience roared with laughter, then Hugh started to crack. He had to walk away from Sutton for a second. They both returned to character, and continued on with the show. All of this is to say, I enjoyed the show tremendously. Everybody did a fantastic job! It should also be noted that I saw Max Clayton go on for Shuler Hensley as Marcellus Washburn, he did an amazing job, and thank you to all understudies and standbys!!

[@EddTaylorandBlake]

funny he cracked the night I saw it too, but we had the understudy for Sutton ( who we came to New York to see). he was trying to get the understudy to crack and she did. Hilarious

[@jacksonhoopah]

​@@EddTaylorandBlake That's amazing! It was my first Broadway show ever, and it was so special to me because I live in Alaska, and Broadway is so inaccessible to me. I've heard of a lot of reports from people who also saw the show, and a lot of them have said that Jackman fully cracked, while Sutton just stood there smiling. I love Sutton to the moon and back, I think she's such a talented performer.

[@carolbounous636]

Saw it last October and can find no fault with anything or anyone. Glorious and lively cast. What a beautiful memory!😂❤

[@FionaSmith-ct7si]

I'd love to see seth mcfarlane do this too. He'd be perfect. Hugh is incredibly charming too ❤ xxx

[@LatvianElina]

May I just say, person on the internet I've never met in my life, I love you! ❤️

[@thecutehuey]

Ahah 🫶😂

[@bridgetd3643]

I'm thankful for these too! What day was this from? Hugh looks huge lol I heard on a talk show day he had to keep getting resized costumes since he was bulking up for Wolverine.

[@katherinepollock]

I think this was taken on the first of the year.

[@thecutehuey]

January 1

[@rubywojcik]

His little commentaries are hilarious

[@ybcarlebach266]

You thought his dumb little insider jokes were good commentary? We found them and him annoying. Play was a disaster.

[@ronniemueller5772]

❤Thank You so much for this. I was not able to see the show so this is most appreciated!

[@westminster860]

I'm not sure I agree with their set decisions here. Drop loos cheap although I'm sure it's not. And was the Wells Fargo wagon really a stage coach and not a wagon by the early 1900s ? The other scenes they had spent more on.

[@monicagerretse-werleman]

I keep laughing 😂

[@joannapinto4640]

I just wanted to know if you have any other clips of the show

[@ybcarlebach266]

We thought this show was pretty bad. My family knows every line by heart. Sutton was miscast. And we didn’t appreciate Jackman breaking character with his (dumb) little jokes.

[@lucindaarmour7422]

I think Jackman is a really charismatic actor and very good natured man but his voice seems damaged. He has lost his vocal strength - especially the strength he had when he first did Oklahoma. It would have driven me insane if he broke character. It's not 'an evening with...' it's The Music Man. And yes Sutton is miscast. In fact if you were to ever flip the show and cast the lead as female she would be perfect casting!

[@poodook]

Hackman really screwed this one up

[@ybcarlebach266]

Count yourself lucky and you saved yourself money.

[@claddagh1826]

is the guy in the maroon shirt gino cosculluela??

[@TheTradge]

Might well be, he was definitely in the production

[@joannapinto4640]

Love the video. You don't happen to have the opening number recorded?

[@thecutehuey]

Sadly I don’t , sorry😩

[@jessicatripp5129]

Why is everyone saying Sutton is miscast?

[@stevehinnenkamp5625]

A pale reflection of original in all regards. These actors are play acting. In film Preston and Jones are living in the moment.

[@ybcarlebach266]

Exactly. They were terrible.

[@MNBluestater]

I felt the same way as well. Sutton’s screeching didn’t help.

[@BookshelfQBattler]

Counterpoint. Preston and Jones are long dead and Hugh Jackman was bringing new interest to the musical that inspired his career. He has said in interviews that the original inspired him to try out for his high school drama club and the rest was history. Then a new generation go back and watch the original.

[@et5246]

Thank you for posting this!!! Unfortunately couldn’t see it live so it means a lot! 😭🫶🏽❤️

[@katherinepollock]

I was lucky enough to see the show once! The great thing about this video is that it was taken at the same performance I was at! It's fun to rewatch exactly what I got to see in person :)

[@et5246]

@@katherinepollock that’s so cool and ironic! Glad you got to see and enjoy it! 😁

[@florenceoram]

My god I can’t thank you enough for all of these videos 🥹

[@thecutehuey]

aww my pleasure ❤