Odyssey Club Tournament: Episode 1 - Simin vs Obsidius (RWBY Fan Animation)

[@Heisen2420]

So let me get this straight. Some of the Best Fan Indie animators got together to make a Tournament with their fan-made RWBY Teams to fight each other in the biggest crossover event since the Avengers. That's AWESOME!

[@l4v4nya]

Are there other videos?

[@mistressofdreams6031]

@@l4v4nya i’m looking for them as we speak

[@mistressofdreams6031]

@@l4v4nya no not at this time

[@l4v4nya]

@@mistressofdreams6031 ohhk thanks, I'll also tell if I find something

[@Marinealver]

Do we have the channels for the other fan animations?

[@catherga]

Team SLVR’s dynamic is so wholesome and refreshing. I’d easily binge watch a full series about them

[@maximusdebray6662]

They have a whole routine memorized and perfected to make their designated bakugo chill out and it’s amazing! And mark continues to to come up with so many creative and inspired ways for the oc’s to use their stuff within the boundaries that he already set up for them. It really feels like these characters have been training and using their powers for most of their lives. Great work Mark

[@neofulcrum5013]

Would’ve been cool if they were an Easter egg in the background of one of the rwby episodes.

[@enviousgaming3250]

​@@neofulcrum5013 i kind of hoped that would happen at some point

[@Iristhetvdemon1030]

​@@enviousgaming3250 would you like to hear my fan made rwby team?

[@longliveteambrnz7936]

Same

[@DrMDHyde]

Capturing that OG RWBY feel, love it.

[@mrekozack7817]

With the good fight choreography too, really hits home

[@msk-qp6fn]

The comedy style is very og rwby esque too

[@DuneDDog]

Love how it took the whole team to get Lycan a chill pill. I also get the impression that the club teacher is meant to resemble Monty, which is a banger way to honor him. Not to mention both the choreography and characterization were top notch. The torch burns bright; as you've been inspired, so too has your audience. Thank you for your craft and vision.

[@MoeHasubandoAbsolver]

I love how your MC's dust obsession mirrors Ruby's weapon obsession. Using a character's love for a world element to flesh it out better is such a natural method of exposition that goes so underutilized in the actual show. Love to see it, keep up the great work!

[@RenceAsANoob]

His love for Dusts also makes sense since it would benefit him a lot in battle as well.

[@Iristhetvdemon1030]

@azurie580 you wanna hear my rwby ocs?

[@Iristhetvdemon1030]

@azurie580 so you still interested?

[@369destroyer]

Imagine if Weiss had a dust obsession given her weapon and her family's business.

[@369destroyer]

@@jrpgplayer Yeah but it was purely exposition, rather than a character trait.

[@SuperGreenSmartie]

The way he kicks his big ass sword to change its trajectory while keeping up momentum at 3:32 is such a sick detail I had to rewind and watch it a few more times.

[@businesscat1521]

I just went back and watched this. It was so subtle but so cool once you pointed it out

[@armandomendoza7371]

I legit had to slow down the vid to see it because my brain couldn't keep up, i was simply amazed by what i was seeing, when i finally understood it i just had to kneel, so cool and well thought

[@kaled20001]

Reminds me of Beidou from Genshin Impact, the exact same move is used at the end of her normal attack combo string.

[@freemovies411]

0h 0h 0h that's c00l as shit

[@IceZone27]

They really paid attention to how the weight of that massive sword would (more or less) be used. Because of how heavy it is you can see the whole time the dude uses it’s own weight to swing it around and if he block with it he has it resting on the ground. A lot of shows will just have he swing it like a kid swinging a stick with no difficulty but they really made me believe how heavy and powerful that weapon is just by how he fights with it. PLEASE KEEP DOING A GREAT JOB AS YOU ALL ARE!!! I BELIEVE I CAN SPEAK FOR EVERYONE WAY I SAY THANKYOU!!!

[@weegee3917]

Simin throwing the fire axes first before slamming them resulting in an explosion was such a genius strategy, such a shame it got used against him. Really like the comedy and choreography here, thank you and all other creators for making this!

[@darthmarr4155]

Yeah he shouldn't have tried to use strength to overpower his opponent that's what did him in

[@qmchale5130]

It seemed like a good idea, but you know what they say about the best laid plans.

[@Iristhetvdemon1030]

@@qmchale5130 you wanna hear my rwby ocs?

[@brogrammerplus7683]

You have NO IDEA how much I freaked out when I saw this notification! I'M so happy! THE TIME HAS COME BROTHERS AND SISTERS LETS COME TOGETHER FOR THIS MASTERPIECE!

[@toshikikai9669]

Amen

[@tf2demon264]

Me to😊

[@EleanorVillanueva-s4n]

Hallelujah

[@sombraelerizo]

You have no idea how happy it makes me to see team SLVR again, and their interactions.

[@nealforreals2098]

Simin's tactics, dust combinations and mastery of different weapons is impressive.

[@Hinokami777]

Exactly he was even batched most of the fight. That shield is just too durable

[@nealforreals2098]

@@Hinokami777 yea if the earth shield could withstand blasts better, the Exploding Shield technique could've worked.

[@danzack900]

​@@nealforreals2098 I thought he dug his own grave when he used that move.Logically speaking his opponents custom-made shield would be more durable than something his own earth shield which he made in seconds right?

[@Fallensnowch]

@@danzack900What’s more the opponents semblance reflects force, so basically all the force from that blast was just reflected back to him. So technically Simin did dig his own grave when he tried to use the force of the explosion against obsidius

[@sagaositygamez785]

​@fallensnow8859 Yeah it's essentially a risky gamble on his part; it's stated in Obsidius' bio that Throwback does have a limit to that which it can reflect but Simin trying to overpower it results in one of two things happening (Bye Simin or Bye Obsidius). He doesn't know it has a limit but the only way to win at that point is to go for an all out push considering he's nearly at his limit too and has seen how defensively resilient the shield + stun baton combo is

[@catherga]

Love how Obsidius’ semblance, weapon choice, and fighting style all blend together to make one momentum-based battle strategy.

[@eliasochoa8880]

What is his semblance anyway?

[@sebas8225]

Obsidius would absolutely make it to Vytal festival finals with what he was packing, greatsword turned into Shield and lance on top of his semblance pretty much would likely allow the dude to easily win most mids of the tournament in a fight, only way I can see some losses is if he has to face Pyhrra, or his teamates cant pull their weight in the 4 on 4 or 2 on 2 match ups and he aint enough to flex the win.

[@gluttonousdragon635]

​@@eliasochoa8880 i think its something of momentum Acceloration/ energy transfer As he can use his aura to enhance his movments as well attacks that his him to enhance his own attacks as he takes them

[@catherga]

@@eliasochoa8880 there’s a link in the description with Obsidus’ bio, but I think it’s that he can take the active energy from attacks and redirect it as he would like. It’s kind of like Yang and Adam’s but the main difference being that they can store energy and dish it out when they want and he has to immediately redirect it.

[@danielramsey6141]

@@catherga There’s clearly a limit to this power. I’m guessing a REAL BIG Hit can cripple Obsidius’ Momentum!

[@TheGrayTy]

A fan OC tournament crossover is such a cool concept, and it's so nostalgic to see fight choreography where every movement feels important and fluid. Amazing job to all involved.

[@dudeguy1894]

I love how well you gave Obsidius's sword a feeling of weight. Like he's not just lifting it; he's using its momentum to *swing* it around.

[@ohmichael1348]

the old rwby vibes....so amazing!!! this was even the first time simin's earth dust was revealed to be a giant shield! obsidian's weapon was insanely cool btw.

[@msk-qp6fn]

I also love that the guy from 1:50 gives me monty vibes. He also sounds kinda like neath too.

[@businesscat1521]

I think Monty Oum would proud of this. The choreography was fresh, dynamic and fun to watch. Good Job!

[@spencerj18]

I honestly think he would hire him or work with him

[@freelancerthe2561]

@@spencerj18 I thought he did hired at RT?

[@TJCID22]

The new RT rwby fights suck.

[@businesscat1521]

@@TJCID22 100% truth. This guy should be directing choreography at RT

[@TJCID22]

@@businesscat1521 Wish he'd do a colab with Celtic Phoenix.

[@Shack11]

Wow, I love the *weight* of the animation. It really feels like Obsidius is wielding a small jet(and Simin's struggle in the fight is that he decidedly is not)

[@sebas8225]

Simin packing lightweights. Obsidius packing Heavyweights. This is a good reverse of Mercury vs Yatsu fight and I love it.

[@aztrea8]

Youve really understood, captured, and put your own spin on Montys choreography, and your character design is no slouch either. It really feels like it belongs in the world and I think that's the highest compliment I can give. Love everything you put out and cant wait to see what comes next

[@exudeku]

Simin's Longsword is hella realistic on his stance and grounded attacks, straight outta medieval books

[@rai4119]

it feels like it EXCELS *beyond* rwby

[@aztrea8]

@@rai4119 Modern rwby i dont disagree. it feels like somewhere along the line they got so focused on the story monty wanted to tell, that they lost the way he wanted to tell it

[@Hinokami777]

@@rai4119 yeah you’re drunk go away lmao lacks the fluidity

[@rinnest]

@@Hinokami777 Of early RWBY? Sure, of Volume 4+ RWBY? Nah mate, just because they add some spinny weapons with no weight doesn't make them fluid. Fluids have substance.

[@randomlightning154]

I have been waiting literal years to see what the fourth dust type did, and I love every bit of this animation so much!

[@animefan-ji8rd]

those axes looked like just another fire dust construct though. there nothing saying each dust type is limited to one weapon (heck ice we already knew before this could be a sword or a shield.) Edit: ok i must've looked away for a second because i completely missed him pullnig out the earth dust.

[@louised2818]

I think they mean the earth dust, cuz I’ve only ever seen the first three types in previous videos

[@ace0318]

I liked how in the sword fight Simin is pushed back when blocking Obsidius’ larger blade, makes it feel like the weapons have weight to them and in general their moves have impact. I really enjoyed the choreography

[@n0ame1u1]

4:58 Interesting to see Simin go out of his way to pick up his weapon, even though he can make more. I guess he needs to preserve dust. Would be cool to see a kind of Unlimited Blade Works style attack, where he just throws a bunch of weapons at his opponent. With the added twist that throughout the rest of the fight he would be hopping around picking up all those scattered weapons.

[@CDV007]

Limited dust resources

[@CRIS_IS_ON_INFINITE_EARTHS]

I actually thought up a lot of head cannon based on this like maybe he gets all of his dust from smaller shops because doesn't support skeevy large corporations and that's the reason he was trying to buy the eruption dust from a small street vendor instead of a bigger dust dispensary like a one owned by the Schnee dust company, it would probably take months for a small business to get that type of rare dust in stock verses a monolithic industry like the Schnee dust company but since they abuse faunus for cheap labor he prefers to have less dust to work with for longer periods of time rather then buy any more accessable but Inhumanly sourced dust, it'd be kind of a cool thing for him to go out of his way to do in spite of how obsessed he is with dust since he actually has a faunus on his team, that and the fact that Lycan dresses kind of like a White Fang member gives them gives them a sorta more punk edge. Alternatively though it could just be a result of how Simin grew up, maybe he didn't have a lot and had to use anything he could get his hands on or it could just be a mindset brought as a result of his clumsiness, he never stumbles in battle and makes thorough use of every weapon he makes so that the dust it's made of doesn't go to waste. It could also be a whole combination of these ideas or none of em

[@tavianfloyd6589]

They should honestly just greenlight a spin off for you and give you a team with a budget. This was awesome

[@SwitchbackCh]

I seriously have my reservations about "them" touching Mark's work, but I'd love to see him collab with Dillon Goo's team someday.

[@DespianGrimmPaldea]

I dunno, I don't think he would have the creative freedom with "them" if he ended up getting a job there, especially in light of the allegations about the company. But if he did collab with other peeps who made RWBY Teams or just RWBY OCs in general, that would certainly be cool.

[@tavianfloyd6589]

Geez lol. I don't know much about rooster teeths situation, I'm just saying this person deserves more success.

[@DespianGrimmPaldea]

@@tavianfloyd6589 You're not wrong about that. His work is similar to Mounty Oum's, and reminds me of both his work and the fights in Season 4. Magnificent. So if he got more success, then it is more than well deserved given the quality of his work.

[@observer2484]

Better that he does it himself with unofficial funding. Takes longer, yet he can do it how he likes it.

[@Halepeno]

You’ve really captured what made rwby special in the first place I’m so happy you never stopped animating

[@nuzzkue9371]

Damn this made me feel like I was watching a Monty Oum Rwby fight, Damn Mark you're really skilled at this animation stuff. Hope you go far!

[@DDespicable]

I had no doubt the animation was gonna be top notch. What i didnt expect was the sheer amount of personality you packed into these 7 minutes. Bravo sir, you surpass my expectations once again.

[@sagaositygamez785]

It would be fun to go in depth on all the detail in this fight but one thing I love about it in particular is actual back and forths between the two characters without needing to slow the pace of the fight 3:41 in specific is a really neat showing of how the advantage in combat actually flows between the two as opposed to one person dominating the fight, and it happens in just 10 seconds: Simin gets knocked down and recovers, goes on an offensive flurry of attacks after predicting the greatsword's movements which is Obsidius' weakness, and is about to land what would be a critical knockdown but Obsidius effectively uses his semblance to turn that momentum (haha) against him Stuff like that is really enjoyable to watch because then it isn't just someone showcasing how broken they are, rather it's a combination of using powers effectively and reacting to an opponent These things are amazing and I truly hope in the future it'll go well!

[@Raxacory]

Your blade-to-blade choreography is still impressive as always, very much worth the wait!

[@Shamshiro]

It's awesome to see creators bring their ideas together and feature them all in the same show. Here's looking forward for more SLVR and DARK, among others :3

[@shdig]

The humor and overall feel of this episode was very close to early RWBY, I loved it.

[@nmc3283]

I'm so shocked and happy this was released. I completely forgot about this. I was so into a couple years back

[@jondalarsexton5537]

same, but as soon as I saw this I was like time to rewatch every video again from the start. How far his work has come is amazing.

[@sunbrolq84i88]

You gotta remember that Obsidius here had a Semblance to take advantage of, and a very powerful one at that, while Simin does not. On top of his own natural prowess, the fact that Simin was still able to give him such a good fight is impressive enough on its own!

[@mlgsamantha5863]

I thought Simin's semblance was making those dust weapons?

[@BlueBlazeKing]

@@mlgsamantha5863that’s his weapon’s ability

[@mlgsamantha5863]

@@BlueBlazeKing Oh. I thought all it did was supply the raw dust for him to use, I didn't know it was what was actually forming it too.

[@NovaThorn]

he does have a semblance, but it isnt clearly shown in the animations, only really properly explained by the creator - Simin is able to make things more durable when touching them, which is how he makes his fragile dust weapons not break or explode in his hands

[@juicebox7372]

​@@NovaThornThe creator said Simin doesn't have a semblance where are you getting this information?

[@givemeaworkingname]

Wow. Just wow. 2.5 minutes of straight, solid fighting. Even RWBY fights are rarely that long. The animation "physics" here is better than some professional stuff by WB. And you understand fight rhythm so much better than most. Great job, and I'll be eagerly waiting for your next video.

[@code066funkinbird3]

Wb?

[@willeh1947]

@@code066funkinbird3Warner brothers

[@xrmatt7383]

This is exactly what RWBY is missing these days. Interesting, creative and well-choreographed fight scenes. Rooster Teeth, hire these people!

[@Domain0fDom]

Rooster teeth is cancer and sold out to woke ideology instead of good story Monty would be pissed off if he was still alive

[@aeonnova82]

They better not dude. Else, we lose this guy too

[@mca7314]

Dont forget good camera work to match with the fight

[@FixTheWi-Fi]

Have we been watching the same show?

[@daunyoku]

@@FixTheWi-Fi yeah, the new stuff is choreographed well but it is completely different in spirit

[@TheGamingSpartanA113]

Four Years later, we return to Mark's beautifully envisioned characters.

[@autumnfaraday5649]

You have no idea how much I’ve missed this channel. Fights like these were why I loved RWBY. I really hope to see a reappearance of the Charcoal character!!!

[@CRIS_IS_ON_INFINITE_EARTHS]

I love that this mf Lycan is just blowin' through everyone in his path to get to this fight club But as soon as one of his pals stops him to ask what his problem is he just politely and concisely explains the situation😂 That's pretty delightful ngl

[@zKite00]

I'm not sure if this is intentional detail, but at 4:24, the reason the fire sword breaks is because if you look back during the clashes Obsidius has been hitting the sword in the same spot over and over

[@blazingstudios7781]

This is why I love the RWBY fandom (for the most part), they inspire such creative and amazing OCs and fan animations that leave people breathless.

[@brogrammerplus7683]

Can't believe I have finally gotten to witness see Simin use the earth dust.

[@frozenfreehand1997]

That fight between simin and obsidius was fantastic! You could actually see the weight behind every swing with Obsidius's great sword, using the momentum to his advantage! Very nicely done! I'm so glad to see stuff from you again. Your slvr animations are some of the best RWBY fan content I've seen!

[@DragonsandIcicles]

Love that Obsidian's weapon is basically an MH charge blade, but greatsword instead of greataxe. If im reading his combat style right, he's got a momentum reversal or transition semblance

[@MissdermeanerJ]

I thought I was gonna be in love with Lycan but here I am absolutely adoring Simin! He's so witty and fun, and a clutz to boot. But I can just tell He's gonna be a total hero. I LOVE Ragora's new outfit, too! This was so well done. I feel like I'm watching Monty's world and animation coming to life all over again. Awesome work!

[@arkossunset6947]

Awesome choreography! So much happened, loved the witch’s apparel and it’s awesome you collabbed! Great work!!

[@IntonerCaim]

Oh my god the absolute charm and not to mention the amazing animation for the fight scenes really just made me smile the entire time watching this!! It really reminds me of classic rwby with the cute yet hilarious interactions that really makes everyone just seem like they’re all having a good time. Amazing work yet again!

[@DinoCam1795]

Wasn't expecting this today. And it looks like Simin has Makoto Naegi levels of luck. Can't wait to see the other episodes.

[@lightthehodgehog]

Very well done! You did an awesome job selling the difference in equipment weight during the fight. I assume Simin's ice, fire and wind weapons are meant to have very little weight, shown by how quickly he can stop and start an attack, or change his direction compared to Obsidious who when going on the offensive had to keep a single motion going for a looong time to actually throw out anything. You also avoided a big pet peeve of mine at 4:07, where you handled a "bind" correctly. Obsidious hit with the very edge of his blade (AKA the weak of the blade) and Simin defended with the very base (AKA the strong), in that position, Simin has a great deal of control over Obsidious' weapon as well as being in a better position to launch an attack. Simin first forced Obsidious' guard open by shoving their weapon down, and then went on the offensive. Plus, it was a fairly fast exchange, as most binds are! I personally find it really takes me out of a fight when two characters seriously trying to win slam their weapons together and then just mindlessly push. They could at least try to trip the opponent or grab the weapon or just do anything XD Good work avoiding that!

[@Insomniaaron]

Odyssey Club, aka OC. See what you did there. Also a hearty welcome back to SLVR & NYON.

[@princeofqrow3181]

Oh 🤔😝 I see nice one mark.

[@adrianarballo179]

Mark is really stepping it up. I have to say this is good. One question still remains what happened after the end of the last character trailer?

[@noobartist6009]

they all went to a store and had chicken pizza, just like in Avengers.

[@adrianarballo179]

@@noobartist6009 yeah I doubt that.

[@erikroman1880]

​@@adrianarballo179maybe next video will show what happened

[@adrianarballo179]

@@erikroman1880 hopefully.

[@ObsoletePerson]

The helicopter was piloted by an AI and it picked them up and dropped them off at Beacon.

[@littleg5664]

I am absolutely ecstatic to see your incredible fight choreography back at it again.

[@messeduplogic]

I'm so glad you're crossing over with other RWBY fun animators like NYON

[@ChangedMyNameFinally69]

I'm not, he's much too talented and not tainted by fandom drama like the others. I lost a lot of respect for a lot of RWBY fan creators after they got mad about people's valid complaints about the oversexualized holiday art collabs.

[@manuelkfc7916]

@@ChangedMyNameFinally69 Holiday Art Collabs, what?

[@ChangedMyNameFinally69]

@Manuel kfc So a bunch of RWBY fan artists, a good chunk of which were porn artists started doing art collabs mainly around holidays, they started with a Christmas collab and predictably they couldn't control themselves. And people had pretty reasonable complaints, mainly that they invited porn artists to draw sexualized art for a SFW holiday collab, and that art amounting to nearly all the female characters wearing tight skimpy clothing with pornstar bodies that their male counterparts didn't (one or two male characters were shirtless or wearing shorts and an open shirt but it's not nearly as sexualized and they all had vaguely canonical body proportions). Also there was other cringe like Sytokun drawing art of Tyrian abducting Fiona with rapey vibes and trying to excuse it as a Krampus reference or the fact Fiona and Robin were the two Happy Huntresses that got art and coincidentally are the two conventionally attractive ones versus Joanna the masculine black woman and May the trans women. And of course they tried to call people that think that female characters don't always need to be drawn with vacuum-sealed clothes prudes for calling out blatant misogynistic double standards. Because NSFW artists are fragile as fuck. And sadly all the HTDM, roaches they are and a good chunk of the FNDM took their side and I lost a lot of respect for artists and other creators like Aestheticc-Meme, JumpinJamz, A.G. Nonsuch, and the guy that made NYON that either contributed to the collab and defended the sexual art or weren't part of it but still defended it. And it only solidified my hatred for people like Syto or Keith Montalban, who was one of the main organizers and whose OCs are in this video. Didn't help a good few of the artists were in the HTDM anyway so they were never gonna take criticism well and get asspats from their circle but also probably did this all to be spiteful at least somewhat. They then did a Chinese New Year collab that was less horny but still pretty horny, and while I don't know if I can agree with the cultural appropriation accusations considering some Asian people worked on it (most weren't Chinese though), moreso it's kinda shitty how often anime sexualizes traditional Chinese clothing. But that's a bigger issue than an art collab. Their more recent art is less sexualized as a whole but still. Basically I lost a lot of respect from most of the fan artists and fan creators and I feel Mark dishonors himself associating with them and in general he's just so much more talented than everyone else here and you can see from how better designed his OCs are in comparison to say Keith's cringey self-insert that dates Weiss. People are of course gonna act like the fans were solely overreacting here because the HTDM thinks they're prosecuted.

[@MrLabo]

If the actual RWBY series have characters likes this. Damn its so good.

[@vinndiesel7132]

Hot damn, badass as always. Aside from the big moments and the overall quality of the animation and choreography, I also love the little touches. Like Obsidious kicking his weapon while swinging it to give it a boost when he brought it upwards 3:31, or Simin slightly spinning when his legs were swept 3:39 and having an extra bounce when he leapt back 3:42. Just the attention to momentum makes it so much cooler to watch. Also, Lycan continuing to just run even with the familiar clamping its jaws on his head gave me a good chuckle.

[@robertcurley8406]

I’m no longer interested in RWBY Canon, but I’m ALWAYS down for awesome fan-made shit like this, that fight was intense

[@Cally_bbykid]

Same!!!! Been bummed ever sinced the creator passed away and the later stuff all felt different

[@Marinealver]

if only it was more often than every 2 years

[@LumenFox777]

I kept up for awhile and fell off too and Rooster Teeth has it's own questionable practices but I love seeing fan work like this too! It's awesome some of the stuff the show inspired people to make.

[@andresmarrero8666]

They do seem to fill the world of Remnant more than the actual show which is strange.

[@sebas8225]

@@LumenFox777 Vol 9 was kind of a breath of fresh hair, but the missed potential going forward is just too much to bear, Vol. 10 wont be as great now.

[@howlingfang3215]

I’ve seen all kinds of 3D animation, and you have a whole bunch of potential. I honestly hope one day I can be able to create something similar to your projects

[@Nylnezz]

camera work, pacing, weight, choreography EVERYTHING is perfect just like i remembered you're a legend mark !!!!!

[@malikoniousjoe]

And yet again someone other than the actual creator of the show understands the classic pacing, humor, and appeal in RWBY. Cool gadgets, snappy wit, and fights that are exciting to watch.

[@bigocelot4002]

This had one of the cleanest sword plays I've ever seen. You did an amazing work

[@gnomed6154]

I don't want to sound presumptuous, but this is making me feel RWBY Red Trailer levels of obsession, impressment and awe. Incredible work, cant wait to see the rest!

[@merikmalhads1676]

Ahhh after so long. I'm so glad that people still exist who care and can. I think we've all lost so many fandoms over the years, it is good that people are keeping an ember of hope alive in these dark times

[@hotwheee1s]

the fight choreography was really well done, i REALLY enjoyed this.

[@jackjohnston5710]

AHHHHHH this is amazing! The animation, the fights, the banter, the humor. This reminds me of what I loved about RWBY and why I got into it in the first place. Glad to see you and other animators coming together to create this, it’s turned out really god so far!

[@michaelmorales1602]

OH MY GOD THE CROSSOVER AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH I was SO hoping something like this would happen someday, but I was not expecting it anytime soon!!!

[@badowner]

After 10 years, I have finally found a fan work that rivals Monty's worth my commenting, and I don't say this lightly. Great camera work, no wasted movements, great flow, weights on the attacks, slow mos, lines are all superbe. I wonder though, how much time did this take you? Signed up to your Patreon to support your work.

[@dantemainyu]

exactly

[@princeofqrow3181]

Hell yeah!!

[@BigB173]

I’ve literally been praying for this day I’m so happy you decided to continue this👍

[@xonicallstar9951]

Me too i waiting for a long time. I hope Team Rwby have some cameo in one of these days.

[@jackharrison8232]

I can appreciate how this piece perfectly captures the jankiness of seasons one and two

[@msk-qp6fn]

I honestly liked season 1,2, 3's jankiness

[@wasonceavengefuldemonbutno4176]

Probably one of the best-choreographed fight scenes I have ever seen and I'm sad no one else is talking about this. From Simin checking Obsidius' sword in one of the exchanges to keep his pressure and flurry of attacks going to Obsidius torquing his body after getting swept by Simin and using the giant shield he had planted beneath him to save his fall and the boosters from the shield to carry on and boost the momentum into a spinning kick to the ribs- all of that and MORE. Words can't even begin to properly describe this masterpiece

[@redgodzilla8348]

i like the act they used a modified charge blade with the moonblade semblance vs a dude who can turn dust into a physical weapon that also contains the elemental properties

[@shadowyghost2330]

Holy hell is it good to see you post RWBY content after years.

[@farriez-3119]

Great animation, Mark, and with more new characters, I just can't wait to see the possible outcomes you're about to put in, new semblance, new location, new plots and more.

[@davalious5107]

That fight was awesome, but I'd also like to add that the conversation at the start is another thing you dhod be proud of. The characters felt really natural with each other, like they're actually friends. Plus, I love how they each had a hand in stopping Linen, like they have to do it all the time

[@steponetolegend9443]

How did it take me all these years to realize the pun of Simin's weapon... A flame-berge....damn it

[@7760jackjack]

Dunno if youve seen this video but a KZbinr named shadiversitu tackled idea of how u can functionally use a fanstasy giant greatsword in various combat situations. This video almost seems like a perfect realization of that conceptual fighting style he talked about using the momentum and weight of the blade as linking points into other moves and keeping the blade on the shoulder for block attacks and moving to other strikes. Amazing animation 👏🏽👏🏽

[@javiervasquez2942]

It was worth the wait! :) Edit: Obsidian reminds me of a Beyblade, A Pokémon, or a Yu-Gi-Oh Character

[@stupogo0]

the return of the king! love the bit where Lycan was pinned down between the two glyphs like that wasn't the first or last time really love the thought and care put into how our two fighters would move attack and use their weapons as extensions on themsevles and the humor is sold too! hope we'll get to see some more from this fight club!

[@BrandonYates]

Mark lives!

[@aleviahwolfe]

I saw this in my recommended and literally squealed...the animation somehow keeps improving and I get completely memorized by the fight choreography. Absolutely spectacular!

[@lol_Ozma]

mesmerized

[@Aaerkos]

THIS IS SO COOL MAN , with how RT has handled rwby im so glad there’s still people who care !😊

[@kdroz]

The fight scenes are so frickin smooth and I love the humor as well. Amazing job to everyone involved in making this

[@emilianomerendino3311]

Incredible work, guys, I'm very happy to see Mark back and this time alongside other talented animators. The fight was truly majestic and the dialouges spot on, that trough had to be the most exxaggerate sword and shield combo ever( not that is a bad thing). Best of luck with the rest of the project.

[@DarkCircles698]

Love the way you incorporated wind and earth dust into combat. We never really see much of that in the show.

[@inalatumarianna5510]

OHMYGOD, they need to make this a series. This is so cool and so good. I'm loving the characters already!

[@fightmanx]

Im not gonna lie, this animation with Simin had Unlimited blade works vibes of emiya. Like I can feel him seeing Simin fight, was so good I was at the edge of my seat just hearing there blades crash together.

[@code066funkinbird3]

Emiya from ?

[@princeofqrow3181]

​@@code066funkinbird3 Fate/night.

[@princeofqrow3181]

​@@code066funkinbird3 fate/night

[@peaveejay2700]

@@code066funkinbird3 Emiya Shirou from Fate franchise

[@wolfwing5602]

I was already completely overjoyed to just get to see these characters hanging out, being themselves outside of the fight, I was having so much fun with the dialog and voice acting and quirkiness. Then you reminded me that you're also an unbelievably skilled fight animator with an immense pool of talent and a tendency to improve by leaps and bounds every time. Amazing stuff, Mark, can't wait to see what you pull off next.

[@SwitchbackCh]

I absolutely love the idea of OC tournaments. Ever since the Velvet outfit contest I have always wished the show would feature fan OCs as characters in Remnant, and this is the first time I've seen it fully realised. Thank you so much Mark for keeping these dreams alive. EDIT: Also you mentioned 4 episodes, so this means a member of Team SLVR is each gonna fight a member from the different OC Teams?! I'M SO HYPED Y'ALL

[@darvellcox5731]

It's bout time we saw this team again in action.

[@dhantefranklin336]

There ya go! The camera work, the weight, and the little attention to details. That's the og RWBY style!

[@areszeudion5153]

Bruh, you inserted Zeref into the story (talking about the guy with the black hair, probably an instructor) that's just so cool!!

[@TVHead003]

I love how “Cordo” acts like a familiar and not just a construct.

[@gamerk1058]

Dude, I’ve been a fan of yours since the first charcoal trailer. The animation and the characters are slicker now it’s amazing to see how well your animation has gotten. I think the feeling Simin has issues with luck, I love your characters and I can’t wait for the next one

[@ArdenDemonic]

Mark uploads- I drop everything to watch. It's a simple life

[@diurnalwinter945]

This felt great, fresh, nostalgic, simple, enjoyable and passionate! I love the effort put in! Its almost like watching RWBY for the first time again from the beginning.

[@roemexicanninjavr]

This is really cool. I enjoyed the throw back to the old animation. Hoping you make more, and would love to see you all flourish.

[@bluecheese7447]

Ok just finished. The animation came so far omfg. The movements were so fluid and the effects were on point. Love Simon’s arsenal per usual but seems like he got some additions. The fire axes were cool and we finally got to see his earth weapon. Obsidius was great too, his weapon is awesome. That big ass sword expanding to a rocket shield was badass. I was jumping with excitement when I saw the rest of SLVR, and damn near fainted when I saw the other characters. Like be fr, SLVR, NYON, & DARK all in one place???? The other OCs are great ofc but that’s literally 3 of the most iconic fan teams??? I cannot wait to see where this goes. Good work to everyone who worked on this, and thank you for carrying the RWBY spirit. Monty would’ve loved this collaboration I know it. Here’s to Volume 10+ and more amazing fan work like this!!!!

[@n.k.central8279]

Not gonna lie this has a lot of the things that I miss from the older RWBY series. Really well done animation and VA.

[@andrewdowns3673]

This was awesome!!! Good story and, as always, stellar animation and fight choreography. Can't wait for match 2!

[@imgvillasrc1608]

Seeing Ash and Dawn from team DARK in a nice and peaceful environment is just too funny.

[@Kopenich]

The fight choreography is the realest of real. I feel the soul you put into it, you're doing Monty proud with this!

[@Iristhetvdemon1030]

You wanna hear my rwby ocs?

[@acgearsandarms1343]

The use of momentum for the heavy sword was good and well animated.

[@Loama]

This was so dope, can't wait for episode 2

[@dragon_ninja_2186]

HE HAS RETURNED! And with multiple of crossover no less!

[@tyshawnstubbs9315]

Just the Little details being applied. The expression, the character's small movements to not make them stiff, the way they fight. *The fact Obsidius uses his LEG to kick the Greatsword!* It of itself is such a clever way to increase the momentum of the swing. I've seen very few MMORPG games actually use that in they attack combos but when it appears, its glorious. Let me not sleep on Simin, bro packed up some new toys and I won't let it slide. *Man came clutching up and he got my respect. I didn't see the stone shield coming. I thought he was gonna win when he plop that up but Obsidius yeeted him back!* Yeah it's cool to see your OC win but the to see them Lose is actually quite satisfying. A lot of animes and such will always have they character get a Power Up and Win the fight and that can be boring if repeating over and over. Simin going on the Defense at first and then going onto Offense makes sense as if he himself is analyzing his opponent. Ik we ain't gonna get Episode 2 in a good while but... *Man this COOKING*

[@msk-qp6fn]

Symin kinda reminds me of Ruby with them both being nerds for certain things, but Mark did Symin better in my opinion because we saw him going deep into explaining about dust and even having a conflict over dust.