Marmite vs. Vegemite: Which one is better? - Decided by Americans

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Have you tried both Marmite and Vegemite, or just one of them? Which one do you prefer if you’ve had both?

[@isaiahhrenyk]

Sorry, never tried any of them. Since I live in a small town, there is not a whole lot of variety of food resources like you see in the big cities.

[@carolinegray3150]

I have tried marmite

[@jonallen8346]

Marmite wins hands down vegemite is just vile.

[@gblack108]

Marmite is better

[@samcad-ho3ze]

Marmite. You have to get about 3 parts butter to 1 part marmite and it’s just perfect.

[@jayweb51]

Having grown up with Vegemite, I tend to spread mine reasonably well over my toast; the trick is to ensure you smother your hot toast with butter, NEVER margarine. It is a great flavour enhancer for gravies, stews and casseroles; it is also good as a broth, especially if you are rundown by a cold or flu. I love cheese and Vegemite sandwiches, had that for school lunches; and for a snack, also good on buttered crackers(Arnott's Sao biscuit sandwich with cheese, the sharper the better).

[@davebirch1976]

I always thought they were the same thing 😂 Vegemite gets a mention in the song Down Under by Men at Work "he just smiled and gave me a Vegemite sandwich"

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

That’s a fun song! Apparently those two missing yeasts in the Vegemite makes it taste quite different from Marmite.

[@xymonau2468]

There is Australian Marmite which is sweeter than Vegemite, but of the same consistency. British Marmite is runny.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

This is the first we’ve heard of this!

[@Glenrsi]

I like them both. But have not had Vegemite for a few years. Bought some Vegemite two weeks ago December 2023. To my surprise it tastes different and so much nicer than i remember. Asked my girlfriend if she liked it and she told me she preferred Marmite. Told her to taste this Vegemite as it is different to way it tasted before. She had some and agreed that it's fantastic and tastes different. We are hooked..

[@GodlessScummer]

I'm from the UK and grew up on Marmite but since trying Vegemite I have to admit that Vegemite has grown on me.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

They both are good in their own right!

[@bananaslippers9]

I’m Australian and I have the same sentiment with marmite 😅

[@hollywebster6844]

I love Marmite! On toast or stirred into plant-based soup, stew and chili, it is delicious! I might buy some Vegemite when the current Marmite jar runs out.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

That’s awesome! Have you had vegemite before?

[@jillhobson6128]

I really appreciate you two for giving Marmite a try. Most Americans are prejudiced and treat it as a joke before they've even tried it. They also do not use it properly and spread it as thickly as they would peanut butter!

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Doing research and treating the food with respect is key to a good and open minded tasting video!

[@puzzledotgamer5461]

im british and I spread it thickly like peanut butter XD I dont know why but I love the strong taste like that

[@setokaiba.]

You guys gotta try a nice light spread of marmite on some nicely buttered crumpets 🤤 probably the most british sentence ill ever write lol

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂 we were given a recipe to make classic British crumpets!

[@jillhobson6128]

@@FromtheHobbitHole Never heard of anyone making their own crumpets. Buy Warburton's crumpets if you can find them over there.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

The recipe we were given is from Warburton’s website!

[@R0d_1984]

As an Aussie that's over 50, Vegemite went from an Aussie company to being brought out by Kraft, then brought back by Bega, an Australian company, and the "odd" bitterness is new, i'm pretty sure (99%) that they now use less salt (believe it or not). I'm impressed by both of you especially the lady/wife/partner/mother (yikes) in regards to the marmite/vegemite; We can get marmite made in New Zealand (i've heard it's different to the U.K), really have to find some U.K Marmite. Your Child is super cute an honorary Brit/Aussie Baby ;D Have a fantastic day.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We always try to be open minded when it comes to trying new things! The history behind some of these foods that have been around and are a staple of specific countries is always fascinating to us.

[@jonjayryzner]

I’ve bought and tried both. Sadly, I really didn’t care for Vegemite as much as I wanted to. Marmite wins it for me hands down… I’ve even tried it on plain pasta with some butter and it was a winner. I now order Marmite by the tub from Amazon and slather it on toast, bagels, etc.

[@StarsAndEmbers]

Oh yeah, knew Vegemite was better! If there's one you never want to try, it's Promite. I remember wanting to throw up after trying that one. And as I love Vegemite, that's something

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂 glad we didn’t disappoint you! Thanks again for sending it to us. Now you have us intrigued to try this Promite stuff… 🤔

[@traceyandrob13]

my mum put vegemite in a stew and taste yum and some people have put vegemite in hot water which some of them helps with hang overs

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We’ve never needed a hangover remedy, but that’s good to know just in case!

[@traceyandrob13]

@@FromtheHobbitHole no worries mate

[@vickytaylor9155]

Never ever eat Vegemite or marmite off of a spoon. It is a sin. Vegemite tastes very cabbage like to most Brits where as marmite is more meaty. Both should be spread thinly. If you haven’t tried Bovril drink next that is your next challenge. It is a beef broth that you add to hot water that tastes and looks a bit like marmite.

[@jonevans6446]

You beat me to it I was gonna comment about Bovril

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We know better than to eat yeast spread by the spoonful! 😂 We like to be tongue-in-cheek about it since so many Americans make the horrible mistake and then think it’s disgusting, but in reality they just ate it wrong! Bovril drink is on the list of things we want to try!

[@jayweb51]

Vegemite is made from brewer's yeast extract and malt extract from wheat and barley, as well as, added salt.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

So interesting!

[@kaylistrickland2962]

This was so cool you guys! I think my favorite part about this was how happy little Sage was to try both of these out! 💖 But that intro was really fun and clever too! I might have my bestie in the UK send me some Marmite to try now because I’m curious! 🤗

[@jonevans6446]

I am from the UK your not missing much I personally don't know many people in the UK that like the stuff

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Kayli, you have to give it a try and not take others dislike for it as a reason to write it off! We know that not everyone likes it, and that’s okay. If you have a Wegman’s Grocery store around you, check to see if they have it. They carry a lot of imported things like Marmite. Glad to hear that you enjoyed the intro!

[@kaylistrickland2962]

@@FromtheHobbitHole We don't have Wegman's here in Atlanta, BUT!! I am flying up to visit a good friend next weekend in Fredericksburg VA and there's a Wegman's right next door to her! :D I'll grab some while I'm up next weekend and then message you guys on Insta and let you know how it is!

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Sounds like a good plan! Though, after doing a quick search on the Wegman’s website, it looks like they only carry Vegemite…

[@SmartHomeHASHTAGS]

Turning the slice over is how I love to eat my Vegemite too.

[@LordandGodofYouTube]

As an Australian I can assure you that Promite is where it's at! Promite is better than both Marmite and Vegemite.

[@nordicvision1893]

That intro !! Nice work. :]

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Thank you! We had fun making it ☺️

[@peterjaro6804]

Totally unrelated, but if Sage's daddy has German, French and some Italian blood in him, and Sage's mom has Polish and Scandinavian blood in her, does that make Sage... well, Swiss? (European logic)

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂😂😂

[@NickiSixx1]

Don’t like Vegemite at all but my granddaughter loves it and she eat it with a spoon 😊 Yeah, she’s Australian but they live over here in Sweden now so friends coming up from down under always have to bring her some 😊

[@elizabethfromm7915]

The beginning of the video made me think that Nathan was back on the shire wooing Haley with his knightly charms lol

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂 only one more week until that can happen again 😜

[@elizabethfromm7915]

@@FromtheHobbitHole I'm hoping the hubs and I make it out this year. Probably towards the end of season though.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

If you do decide to come, let us know when so we can say hi

[@elizabethfromm7915]

@@FromtheHobbitHole definitely will do! I am friends with the shopkeepers at La Forge/Rook so please make sure you pay them a visit!

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Will do!

[@paulusmarshallius7315]

Firstly, love your intro's and outtakes. Secondly, I'm a true brit but prefer vegemite. Thirdly, Brit childrens TV show in '70's was called "The Herbs" - and one of the characters was "Sage" - available on youtube (just checked )

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Thank you! 💚💛 We put a lot of work into intros like this one here and it’s nice to hear when our viewers appreciate the hard work and creative effort we put into them. A Brit that prefers Vegemite? Never thought there was such a thing! You aren’t the first person to mention “The Herbs” tv show to us. We have never looked it up, though, but we should!

[@ikybaiiki]

Aww I like how she ate both and just walked towards the camera like “why are you recording?”

[@catones2868]

American here: I have Vegemite and Marmite in my cupboard. I like Vegemite more because it spreads on toast easier. Marmite is too sticky and stringy for me and I can’t spread it on the toast as easily.

[@shannonscott2694]

Finallllyyyy!! Someone who puts the marmite on correctly! A lot of these vids they put sooo much on and with no butter and wonder why they hate it

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We were warned and told how to do it correctly! For that, we are very much appreciative!!

[@sbd2331]

I grew up on both. In UK I'd have marmite often but my step dad lived in Oz and would get vegimite. I'll have either depending on my mood. But I do think marmite is slightly better. It's a bit more intense and stronger. Vegimite more subtle. So I guess it depends whether you want the flavour to be subtle or strong

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

It is nice that there are two slightly different options of essentially the same thing so one can pick what they prefer when it comes to strength in taste and even texture.

[@CriticalEatsJapan]

Your daughter was not phased in the least! But glad you did this comparison so I don't have to... ;)

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Haha…not at all! She surprises us at times with what she’ll eat and not eat. Out of all the strange and interesting foods you’ve eaten in Japan, you’re telling us you won’t try either of these spreads? They’re nothing in comparison!

[@mrnobodytheuser2950]

Marmite hits harder Vegemite is my go to, but I like both

[@robinfrank6501]

Hey, guys! I just watched a clip the other day where they tried Marmite or Vegemite with pasta. It was a split decision, 50/50. Crazy or brilliant?! I think I would like it. It can´t be bad, because I even saw a recipe by Nigella...

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

If she has a recipe for it, then it must be good! We’ve had it suggested to us to try marmite in pasta. It probably is delicious!

[@bertkilborne6464]

I just got a jar of Vegemite from someone who tried it once and never again. I'm still experimenting on what to do .. Definitely an adult tasting stuff . Possibly a substitute for anchovies on pizza ? It tastes good paired with maple syrup .

[@nicholaskarako5701]

Limited editions like Guiness, Dynamit (marmite with chili) extra old, champagne, blended with gold coloed flecks. A brand called Bovril similar to marmite/ vegemiteSwiss version (Cenovis) Brazilian version (Cenovit) German version (Vitam-R) other Australian version AussieMite, OzeMite

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Those are a lot of different spreads!

[@bubble7518]

this Vegemite spread is so good if you put it on the thick bread then it taste so delicious

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Balance is everything! …hmm…maybe Thanos was right? 🤔

[@c.o.694]

classic Corelle ware pattern. nice.

[@jeansteele6586]

Excellent start 😊 disappointing results, I’ve seen both in the stores in Canada and now a long time Marmite eater is tempted to try Vegemite 😢

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Glad you enjoyed the start! Both marmite and vegemite are honestly really good and it was hard to say which one was better. It really is up to everyone to decide on which brand they prefer, and it our opinion, you can’t go wrong with either!

[@glanguish9390]

Marmite Peanut Butter; two worlds collide. Its like spreading dry roasted peanuts.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

That’s a good description! The combo is quite tasty

[@ianmelonie6440]

Although I live in the UK my wife loves Vegemite but it could be she lived in Australia when she was younger

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

At least you two don’t have to fight over the jar! 😉

[@terrynorman9622]

I first learned about vegemite in the rock metal video with the Australian rock group Twelve Foot Ninja -Over and Out feat with Ukrainians metal singer Tatiana Shmailyuk. 😂

[@tonyclarke7151]

Vegimite .. No contest can use it in soup etc. Australian kids start on it at about the same age , no problem

[@vitusdoom]

You crossed the streams!! Never cross the streams!!! 😂

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂🤣😂👻🔫

[@sosarai]

TOTALLY unrelated, but you guys should cosplay as Lokis from the tv show! (Not giving away spoilers in case some haven’t seen it) Really enjoyed the video! Don’t think I’ll be trying either soon, but it’s neat to see your takes! Also Sage’s little cameo 😍

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We talked about doing those cosplays with Melissa and Eric, but we have a different epic one planned for this season!

[@sosarai]

@@FromtheHobbitHole I can’t wait to see!!!!

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We will be vlogging it and taking lots of pictures! But you’ll have to wait until mid October…

[@sosarai]

@@FromtheHobbitHole Renaissance Fair goodness? 👀 I’ll be waiting patiently! Love your guys’ cosplays, especially when you do so as a group! And I can’t wait to see more with Sage, too!

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Thanks!! All of that is coming very soon!

[@mitsy40uk73]

I love watching your videos, but I have to say I always look forward to the outtakes 😆 and of course your adorable daughter Sage 😊 ( is outtakes even one word ? ) lol

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Outtakes comes up as one word and autocorrect doesn’t correct it, so apparently it is! Thanks for enjoying our content!

[@AndrewwarrenAndrew]

As both are made from the end products of brewing, i should imagine one has a more english beer deliciousness the other is australian bathwater lol

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂 quite possibly!

[@bubble7518]

If the Australian bathwater is Vegemite then you have no taste buds as an Australian I might be biased but still

[@xymonau2468]

Arrogance is its own reward.

[@evilgerman788]

Thats why we germans dont eat this both of your countries beer tastes like pis*

[@jennigee51]

I’m just watching this for the first time! I’m catching up on quite a few, and have been enjoying them, gosh Sage is growing quickly, and as beautiful as ever! I heard you mention Bovril, it’s not a spread, it’s to make a beefy drink or gravy, it’s not pronounced “bowvril”, it’s a hard “o” as in hot. I haven’t had Bovril in so long, I can’t remember! Has anyone told you that there’s Marmite chocolate? Since I can’t abide Marmite I haven’t tried it, my son is a fan though 😃

[@BigC1290]

The intro 😂😂😂💯👌🏾

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Thank you! We had fun making it 😁

[@elliotgeorge999]

various supermarkets here have their own label yeast spread, very similar tasting and consistency of marmite but cheaper. ie asda yeast spread is 74.6p per 100gms, marmite and vegemite are 99.6p per 100gms. I get various ones depending what's on offer but prefer the vegemite, it is not quite as harsh as the marmite and stores own.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

It’s nice to hear that brand doesn’t always matter to some. Sometimes you gotta save your money so the supermarket label has to do it for ya!

[@TSharon400]

I always buy the Asda version, so much cheaper and just as nice.

[@bookloverholic]

My husband only will have Marmite, says the others are very different

[@Jacob-Vivimord]

Wonderful job on the spreading. I was expecting something foolish. :p

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We were told in advance the proper spreading amount/technique. 😉 It saved us from lots of “you did it wrong” comments! 😅

[@HayitsTay]

Amazing intro 👏👏👏

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Thanks! We had lots of fun making it, so it’s nice to hear when something you put a lot of effort into is appreciated 💚💛

[@HayitsTay]

@@FromtheHobbitHole it looks like it took quite a bit of work!! kudos for all the effort, its very entertaining 😎

[@norathecatwitch3601]

I've not had marmite but I just might will always be superior I've eaten a big spoonful of it before and scared my Australian friend it was delicious

[@dcamnc1]

I prefer Vegemite personally.

[@vickytaylor9155]

There is also a low salt marmite.

[@jim634]

Marmite is what Vegemite wants to be when it grows up...

[@suffocated]

Love marmite, hate how difficult it is to spread, went for vegemite for that reason.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Oh, interesting reason to pick one over the other! 🤔

[@swiftgames5382]

Vegemite is sweeter and marmite is stronger . I prefer marmite . Vegemite has a funny tang to it .

[@8catmom]

But you have to spread butter on the bread first and a thin layer of marmite

[@qwertyTRiG]

Next up, New Zealand Marmite. I think it's a different company and makes a different style.

[@qwertyTRiG]

There's Promite, too.

[@lisamb4269]

I know this video is old. I just got some vegemite for my best friend that lives in Australia. I'm scared. She did so good!!! I think i'm going to upload my reaction on my YT channel. Thank you for this!!! I want to try Marmite cause my friend lives in Kiwiland.

[@peterjaro6804]

There are 3 things you need to protect Sage from when she is growing up: Drugs, Gangs and Marmite, and she will turn out just fine!

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂 well….sadly we introduced her to the last one and she loves it! 🙃

[@jillhobson6128]

@@FromtheHobbitHole You're bringing her up properly, she likes Marmite!

[@CaboWabotv]

i like the Vegemite

[@RL-ck8zk]

Shout out to my fellow beaky brother. Nice honker m8!

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂👍

[@-sandman4605]

Marmite is sweet compared to Vegemite. 🙂👌🇦🇺

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

True!

[@StaffanSwede]

I know you have already tasted Kalles kaviar, but how about trying messmör (translates as "whey cheese" when using an online dictionary) as a spread? Not salty, rather sweet with a hint of vanilla.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We’ll have to look for it. Thanks for the suggestion!

[@carryonrobmeg596]

Try marmite with peanut butter 👌🏽

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

We have! 👌

[@NickiSixx1]

I actually got her a jar of Marmite from a English shop here but she didn’t like that

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Not everyone does

[@elliotgeorge999]

I prefer vegemite.

[@Korea4Me]

Have you tried Bovril?

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

No we have not.

[@jillhobson6128]

@@FromtheHobbitHole A beef extract, makes a good hot drink. Obviously no use for vegetarians! Marmite is vegetarian.

[@tcphll]

Bovril isn't a yeast extract. It's made from beef.

[@corvettesbme]

Lol! Im still confused!

[@paulprice7482]

They are both evil iin my book, so well done

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😂 thanks!

[@carolinegray3150]

Marmite looks better

[@lanfear63]

Absolutely no contest, Vegemite is poor man's Marmite. Disgusting stuff.

[@8catmom]

Marmite is way better

[@carolinegray3150]

Good video

[@radixreuel7631]

Lost me at “like most Americans”

[@danielinserte9814]

I know its not marmite or even close but if you pm me I can send alot of different spreads I know.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Shoot us a private message on whichever social platform you follow us on and we can chat about your kind offer!

[@maurice720]

Marmites much nicer

[@ladyJustis]

Marmite has B12 ..Vegemite doesn't

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Oh really?

[@jennyfayeuk7342]

Traitor traitor traitor 🤣🤣 only kidding lol I can't stand marmite it's disgusting, at least you still like it.. You just have a new favourite 🤣

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

😅😅😅 we honestly think both have their place in the world depending on what you’re making with it or craving.

[@jennyfayeuk7342]

It's the smell I can't stand 😬 but yet a like beef crisps which get their flavour from yeast extract lol

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

The smell is definitely different and knocks you back at first, so that’s completely understandable!

[@xymonau2468]

Way too much Vegemite.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

For some reason it was harder to moderate the amount of vegemite spread compared to the marmite… 🤷🏻‍♂️🤷🏼‍♀️

[@xymonau2468]

@@FromtheHobbitHole Vegemite is gluey but British Marmite (there is an Australian one that looks like Vegemite) is runny. With the vegemite, you take the tiniest bit on the tip of the knife, then mix it in with the thick butter until you get a slightly beige tinge. It's like mixing those two part glues.

[@FromtheHobbitHole]

Ahhh…now that makes sense! Wish we knew about the mixing detail when we did this video. We had no idea!

[@jettstream2886]

Vegemite first, daylight second