WHAT IF DRAGON BALLS COULDN'T RESURRECT PEOPLE? | A Dragonball Discussion

[@PlagueOfGripes]

It makes me wonder if you can use the Dragonballs to go back in time, to before someone died. Boy would that open a new can of worms.

[@crimson5pider]

Would make for an interesting xenoverse plot

[@blackice7050]

that would lead to a timeline paradox and it would only create a bigger problem You can ask future Trunks

[@AuracleOfBacon]

Chronoa: “Alright, stop that train of thought RIGHT NOW”

[@darkbeetlebot]

*[Madoka Magica intensifies]*

[@Blapedred]

@@AuracleOfBacon lol she's not canon

[@Hurricanelive]

imo the threat of death would have meant all the fighters would be at most 10-20% stronger through out after finding out the DBs don't bring you back. Power / Strength would have been far more important, so the first few deaths wouldn't have been avoidable, but after that they would probably be as strong or stronger against threats, not weaker. Yamcha and Tien would be at Piccolos original level and Piccolo would have been just shy of resurrected Goku. I just think the hero power scaling drastically shoots up at least 10-20% with Bulma / Capsule Corp creating kinetic energy shields that can take at least one or two medium-heavy blasts, ki enhancers, and other defensive gear, ala the tuffles, in Bulma's eyes it lands on her that the future is also going to be a technological one should Goku and the others die. Just imagine the earth forces breaking out a small civil service corp in Ginger Town and holding Cell off at least for 5 minutes, they still die but Cell is like WTF? Lasers man! It's all about the lasers!

[@JaxBlade]

The show would be a 200+ Series very similar to the History of Trunks, It would get very FMA Clannad style very fast xD

[@ericpuhala7914]

Team SMSD Also guren lagaan has pretty shitty animation

[@nonconvexgreatrhombicosido9435]

Eric Puhala No it did not.

[@lloydchristian936]

Eric Puhala it was that one Episode

[@leonnewkirk1713]

You might be giving Super a lil too much credit haha

[@drago_excalibur]

Leon Newkirk You give Super a little less credit

[@themansami]

What if Krillin is Nappa's son who was sent away like Goku?

[@jackwilson9572]

You I though krillin's forehead dots use to mean something to the dragon balls. Instead it was just a practice for monks to feel stronger.

[@PhillyTheKid]

SamiDaOne ok

[@nickp484]

Well then considering how many times krillin got his a🤬s kicked he’d pretty much be god

[@pengudiegu]

BILLYBOBJONES 79 ass

[@____________838]

BILLYBOBJONES 79 isn't he though?

[@naruotsutsuki4423]

I disagree with the whole Goku dead, because i personally believe that with Master Roshi and Krilin dead, Goku will be training with more ferocity with Mister Popo and Kami because all he had left is Bulma, and he will truly understand that he had to be the absolute strongest and beyond to protect his last friend. So yeah, i do believe that Goku will be stronger than in canon when he faced Piccolo Jr. The same thing can be said about his time with Chichi and Gohan, his drive to train (and so protect friend and family) will be stronger than ever and so will continue to grow, and finally will be so much stronger than in canon. But not only Goku, Tien as well, i personally believe that having Chaotzu dead forever plus his inability to defeat both King Piccolo and Piccolo Jr, plus the fact that Goku is (at the tournament) so much stronger than him will kinda drive him mad (in a good sense, not Vegeta's mad) to become more powerful and maybe seek out Kami after said tournament to become his student. I can't imagine Kami refuse since Tenshinhan is a great warrior, so can help Goku protect the world from the threat that represent the still living Piccolo Jr (I imagine Kami using Tenshinhan as some plan B if Goku fails). So yeah i can totally imagine Tenshinhan meditating in the Lockout when Radditz arrive on Earth and so Kami tells him about it, and Tenshinhan goes help Goku and Piccolo kill him and they did it since Tenshinhan and Goku are stronger than in canon. With Radditz dead, and Goku not dead, Piccolo Jr will not be able to kidnap Gohan. And... i'm tired right now lol. No seriously, English isn't my first language so... it's kinda dificult to continue my reasoning here. But just to say, that Goku will not be the only one affected by this What if scenario, i believe that Goku WILL train harder than ever to never let his last friend to be killed by whatever threat them, same logic goes for his family later, and Tenshinhan will be stronger as well since Chaotzu is dead and Master Roshi (who he respected even more than his own master) is dead too, will be a great factor for him to be stronger as well (plus his own rivalry with goku).

[@vazak11]

Well said, very much agreed there, and neat idea with Tenshinhan as well, he is well utilized! I could actually see Tenshinhan being prepared to replace Kami, Yamcha stepping up to replace Master Roshi as well.

[@Hektols]

Agree, without the Dragon Ball acting as a cushion I can imagine Goku and the remaining Z Fighters doing very intense training and kicking Raditz's ass when he arrives.

[@Morlun91]

Simpler to say that Goku would not have been so reckless around Raditz knowing he is not immortal

[@lucasfelipe8349]

I know this is from 6 years ago, but couldn't they also... You know? Used the Dragon Balls? Make so Earth is never in danger again or either make Goku or Tenshihan stronger by unlocking their potential or recovering Goku's tail so he can use and master Great Ape? There's countless ways to do so. Also, Goku's trauma could've started with Tao Pai Pai and the village, which would be accentuated by the death of Krillin and his friends.

[@WilfredCthulu]

What if for this what if: Freeza's conquest eventually leads him to Earth. Him and his army face off against the majins.

[@WilfredCthulu]

Oh yeah, and if Imperfect Cell is still around, what if Freeza recruited him while on Earth? This would be so awesome.

[@ashkangh4577]

well why would imperfect cell work for friezer when friezer is so much weaker than him...and besides, majinn buu can easily wipe the floor with friezer and his army...in like less than 30 seconds! majinn buu wont even see them as a threat!

[@seelcudoom1]

well to make this scenario work you would just need for frieza to face someone like goky earlier but come out on top, but its enough to push him to realise his inborn power might not be enough and train, nto qutie to the point of golden, but still much stronger

[@Deimos0VI]

It would be a what what if if

[@abfabfabab8356]

Ashkan gh freezas would rage and then train and then go golden

[@rahuhe4102]

What if Bulma made an Iron man suit that could keep up with the likes of Goku, Vegeta, and Piccolo?

[@RJALEXANDER777]

Then we get the highly successful series known as Dragon Ball Gundam.

[@SinHurr]

Gundamballz

[@Licjr]

The Blu Spy For real though. They've had access to Saiyan armor, scouters, and the technology that made Android 16. But I don't see Bulma being the one to utilize it, I think it'd be a better fit for Gohan since he's also really smart and has experience in combat. It would have been cool for him to make an improved Great Saiyaman suit that helped compensate for his lack of training

[@JulioMelissaIsrael]

A Saiyan Buster Suit

[@sinoroman]

Bulma as Samus :)

[@Sp33dster96]

Wait a minute. If Goku dies and can't be brought back, it could mean that Dr. Gero would not have woken up Android 17 and 18. At least not for a long time. With Goku out of the picture, Dr. Gero and 19 would have been the androids that destroyed the cities, but not looking for Goku. No, they would have been trying to rebuild the Red Ribbon Army. Terrifying thousands with their revival. And maybe Android 16 would be fixed to help serve in the conquest along with Cell.

[@Sp33dster96]

But then Cell could have eventually longed to be perfect so he could have snuck around, found 17 and 18, absorbed them and become Perfect. Gero would have been angry at him for this and would have tried to force him to stop. Cell would have ignored him so he would send 19 in to try and teach him a lesson. Cell swiftly kills 19 and then either kills Gero or just takes his place as the leader of the Red Ribbon Army. 16 gets upset at this and tries to challenges Perfect Cell but ultimately fails. Desperate, they could have gone to Bulma saying the Cell has gone rogue and needs to be stopped. Bulma refuses at first but eventually complies. Now begins the battle between the New Red Ribbon Army and The Two Scientists with 16.

[@zettovii1367]

@@Sp33dster96 Then Majin Bu happens with a completely different context that it is a world ruled by Red Ribbon Army with Cell as the lead... And eventually Beerus wakes up.

[@lloydchristian936]

Here's a good what if. What if android 17 and 18 just decided to team up with the z fighters when they were activated or bulma went with her original plan killed Gero and reprogrammed 16 17 and 18 as well and cell so the z fighters had more allies

[@lShadowdark]

Dragon Ball Super/ Heroes then?

[@chronosite]

Good enough

[@sansigtonthetwentythird9899]

As long as oolong gets his stuff

[@stproducciones9140]

My man!

[@thecake6635]

If the dragon balls couldn't resurrect worthless maggots, krillin would still be dead from tambourine

[@michaelwesten5330]

You dare disrespect Master Popo?!

[@princevegeta1752]

it's a joke from dragon ball abridged

[@cubsfan8293]

looks like someone needs to learn the pecking order.

[@thecake6635]

MouseMan same as all the other maggots

[@Airgearzx]

Mr Popo Master Roshi and Chioatzu would also been dead by the end of Dragon Ball

[@soijinruiz9492]

Yamcha died because of protecting Krillin, with him dead there is no reason to have him die to a Saibaman, al least let him die with dignity.

[@kyuubinaruto17]

Yamcha died because he was careless. It had nothing to do with 'protecting' Krillin other than that he took his turn first.

[@n.m.4138]

@@kyuubinaruto17 well he did originally mention how he wouldn't be able to get wished back a second time.

[@bobkolterjahn4266]

@@n.m.4138 In short, he probably saved the Krilldog.

[@Alice_Fumo]

regarding the cyborgs, would they even have been built in the first place, seeing as their main purpose was to just kill goku, which he is already dead at the point in this scenario?

[@pmpveras1965]

Snowyiu exactly =D

[@alqu6375]

Cell would also be weaker as Freiza never came to earth, for Gero to get a DNA for Cell. I personally think Babidi would recruit Vegeta and Cell into his ranks.

[@pn2294]

Let's not forget: the reason dr. Gero and by extension the Red Ribbon Army's hated Goku was because he got in the way of their plans for world domination. He probably would still build them so that he could take over the world.

[@jordanread5829]

@ al qu, I think imperfect Cell would still have Freeza's DNA considering that the main Cell we see did come from another timeline, and if MasakoX is saying that Trunk's timeline is unaffected by the what if scenario, it is reasonable to say that Cells timeline isn't changed either Baby Cell that is still within Gero's lab in the main timeline won't, but that version gets killed off very quickly anyway

[@alqu6375]

Jordan Read hehe, I forgot. 😄

[@morerog3108]

what if goku never kill his grandfather gohan

[@TheAutisticBrony]

I can't imagine much would change but it would be nice to have him around

[@alcadgamer4648]

if dragon balls couldnt bring back ppl me:ther would be no story after radditz

[@Rain593]

alcad gamer Would be focused on Gohan

[@alcadgamer4648]

Ryan Pawelko oh yeah i forgot about him cuz hes useless

[@ape7119]

alcad gamer cough cough ss2 cough cough

[@pmpveras1965]

Andrew Ely probably not cuz c17 and c18 would have been destroyed so no Perfect Cell= no ssj2 gohan neither any ssj

[@devilsummoner7814]

Which he only managed to achieved after being both trained by Goku and after throwing a tantrum, also he was still a fucking moron and his father had to die for his stupidity, cough super perfect cell and not insta killing him cough, should i mention super Buu and how the stupidity of both Gohan and Gotenks escalated that situation ?

[@Lancor84]

Yajirobi only got a jumpstart up the tower. He still had to climb most of it by himself.

[@jayministry5643]

Don't you think without the dragon balls people would've been more rational about their lives.

[@gelusvenn5063]

I think my major issue with this one is that with the fact that nobody can be revived by the dragonballs but they *can* grant immortality, nobody has with the natural fear of death or even just because they purely desire the ability to protect the earth, wished for it.

[@DLBread]

I feel that during the fight with Vegeta, having more powerful allies like Piccolo and Tien would have changed the outcome more drastically. 1. Vegeta was able to escape because Goku instructed Krillin to spare him, a more hardened Goku likely wouldn't have objected to such a high threat as Vegeta. 2. Even if Goku had requested that he be spared, someone such as Tien or Piccolo (who would be the ones in Krillin's position, standing over a beaten Vegeta) would not have listened to Goku given the inherent dangers of letting Vegeta live.

[@Crow_Rising]

Here's a few I can think of right now: What if the Ginyu Force sided with the Z fighters on Namek instead of Freeza? What if Raditz arrived on Earth earlier? What if he arrived later? What if Grandpa Gohan survived Goku's Oozaru form? What if Super Saiyan God was a strong enough form to surpass Beerus in the BoG Saga? What if Gohan went Super Saiyan on Namek instead of Goku, and did so much earlier? What if Goku went Super Saiyan 2 on Namek instead of just Super Saiyan? What if Babidi was a good guy? What if Whis refused to train Goku and Vegeta? What if Freeza killed Goku on Namek right away instead of toying with him? What if Future Trunks didn't go back in time far enough and arrived after Goku died of the heart virus? What if Piccolo didn't shield Gohan against Nappa's attack? What if Goku never befriended any of his former enemies like Yamcha, Tien and Piccolo? What if Goku never bumped his head, but still remained a hero somehow? What if Future Trunks still couldn't go Super Saiyan when he arrived from the future?

[@RusticFederalist]

Grandpa Gohan survives and takes Goku straight over to Master Roshi. Maybe Roshi and Gohan get curious enough they go over to Fortuneteller Baba to get a read on what this kid is. Then things really get spicy.

[@incognitotamizhan9679]

wait, babidi comes to earth since he detects high power levels on earth, if goku died and vegeta was training in outer space.. why would he even come to earth in the first place? would he not take buu away when he knows there isnt any worthy power level?

[@incognitotamizhan9679]

buu saga might not have happened at all

[@ashkangh4577]

android saga wont happen either...remember doctor gero made all those androids to kill goku...but if goku is dead then whats the point!?

[@chrishall3847]

uhh cuz buu is on earth dumbass?

[@k-bobkid6866]

Also, Gohan is still born. Chichi never dies before Buu saga, so Gohan is born. Gohan probably would've stepped up to face most of the threats Goku would have faced. With Piccolo as his mentor, he would definitely become a strong fighter and maybe even hold his own against the likes of Frieza, Vegeta, and Dabura. Who knows, he might even unlock the power of the Super Saiyan transformation!

[@incognitotamizhan9679]

i dont think without android saga gohan would have been that strong, so there wouldnt any power level high enough to be harvested.. i can see babidi packing his bags and leaving earth along with buu

[@GeminiDark]

4:21 I'd argue that having those deaths be permanent might make Goku go SSJ. 9:15 I'm sorry, but Vegeta wouldn't be leaving earth. Piccolo wouldn't stop like Krillin did. Vegeta would be killed. 12:21 I don't think that Bulma would kill 16, 17, and 18. I think she'd try to reprogram them at worst, causing them to probably kill her and things turn out like in Trunks' timeline, or just let them go and tell them that Gero and Goku are both dead so they have no reason to be bad guys, potentially letting them skip the Android Saga and go straight to their Super lives, sans Krillin. And remember that even Imperfect Cell was on par with Piccolo, if I remember right he could fight him even after he became a Super Namekian. Cell alone might have gotten so powerful from humans and the remaining Z Fighters that he could either defeat Babidi or fuel Buu's revival, assuming he hadn't absorbed 17 and 18 and destroyed earth already. Then either Buu or Cell would end up killing Freeza someday, and maybe Vegeta would be strong enough to beat them somehow, but probably not since he'd not have had Goku as a rival to try to surpass. Though it's also possible that Freeza would survive a first encounter with either of the much stronger villains and decide to train into Golden Freeza, making him strong enough to kill them and take over the rest of the universe.

[@RusticFederalist]

If Piccolo has the strength to kill Vegeta at the end, he probably would.

[@InfernosReaper]

The Goku who let Vegeta live was a Goku who was going to live to fight another day. This Goku would be going back to the other world and didn't have the luxury of a rematch What's really interesting is what happens with Kami & Piccolo inevitably go to Namek & how that shapes their development as well as whether or not they end up going back to earth. That's a big game changer

[@AlanLiebheart]

DarkwolfX37 The first complain is totally fake, because one of the condition to turn into a Super Saiyan, is having a high power level in base from (said by Toriyama in the s-cells interviewed), otherwise, Goku would have turned super saiyan in the first DB when Krillin dead.

[@futuregohan4837]

Piccolo Could've Talked Goku Out Of It

[@herooftheherd3721]

i know that this is not very important but because that Indian guy died i think his son would stay with goku that doesn't mean much but if he trained and stuff he could have been a good ally and maybe with one more strong person things may have changed, unlikely but still always a possibility.

[@AltoRosei]

You forget about in the buu sage how one of the kai gave up his life to come back to life. I think King kai would have given up his life for goku. I aslo don't see yamcha dying. Since goku can blitz everyone but vegeta with easy

[@orealz]

AND RULE NUMBER 3!!!! I can't bring people back from the dead. it's not a pretty picture... I DON'T LIKE DOING IT!!!!!!!!

[@clericofchaos1]

HA! No. Here's how it really goes. The saiyans never find out about the dragon balls. And none of the other sagas happen. The end. The saiyans never go to earth as neither of them liked raditz enough to avenge him. Which means frieza never learns about the dragon balls and never attacks namek. With goku dead the aa saga never happens. As the whole reason for gero doing all that in the first place was to kill goku. Obviously the cell saga never happens as cell is never created. With all that said and done, the buu saga is also unlikely to happen as babbidi needs the power of stronger fighters than earth can provide to resurrect buu so he just skips our planet entirely. Obviously super never happens because there are no super saiyans, let alone ssg's.

[@MyToonsAnimates]

Thank you.

[@k-bobkid6866]

clericofchaos1 Gohan is still born, kidnapped by Raditz, and kidnapped again by Piccolo for training. A child beating Raditz would pique their interest, as it is news about another Saiyan alive in the universe. Goku would fight Vegeta and Nappa, then Gohan would continue to train with Piccolo. After that, Gero probably doesn't build the Androids, so Trunks never had to come to this time. Frieza could come to Earth because of Vegeta's defeat. Someone would probably die (most likely Piccolo) and Gohan would go Super Saiyan. That would attract Babadi, and Buu might end up released.

[@acceleratingfiction2959]

Cell saga would happen due to cell being from a entirely different timeline.Super could possibly happen as nothing's stopping beerus from having that dream then being disappointed

[@CrispyB8con]

Dragonball Z becomes the adventures of Goku while dead in the other world, reuniting with Krillin and going on adventures

[@swagnostic132]

clericofchaos1 or beerus comes to earth to find the ssg, cant and then destroys the earth because he doesnt meet bulma to finally try the party foods

[@HellGrimo]

What if zenkai boost wouldn't exist?

[@piotr5261]

HellGrimo Then everyone dies!

[@flamingterror]

Simple. Everybody gets killed by Freeza

[@katxiii3660]

Didn't Goku get a zenkai boost after he was nearly killed by King Piccolo? If so, Piccolo would've killed everybody.

[@NanobanaKinako]

Dragon balls would've been less useful since reviving people is the most common wish used at the magical orbs.

[@sammcguire3798]

Wait...we can't bring Yamcha back? UNACCEPTABLE MASAKO!!! HOW COULD WE HAVE THE CELL SAGA WITHOUT YAMCHA!!!!

[@TheFettuck]

They could bring Yamcha back with the Super Dragonballs. Because the Super Dragonballs can grant any wish.

[@luckpup2766]

WE CAN'T!

[@SynchroPlays]

I'm upset MasakoX, because I thought that since the Native American died and he can't be revived; Goku would take his son and have him stay at Master Roshi's place because Goku felt bad that the son was going to live all alone like how Goku lived after his Grandpa died. Which is the main reason why Goku revived his father so he wouldn't be alone, but if reviving people couldn't happen he would probably send his son to live at Master Roshi's then the Son would want to train to become strong to fight people like Mercenary Tao.

[@MegaRay220]

Masako, please name Raditz' and Launch's kid Ranch

[@devoncollins9924]

That's what I put! Also you should keep comments like these to their relative videos. Also I named their kid Raunch as first choice. Toriyama has a shtick where he doesn't always give them the food name directly 'cept for Bra, Rice, and I guess Yam-cha?

[@MegaRay220]

There was no way Masako would see my comment on the old video and I didn't feel like waiting till the post Super episode discussion so I decided to do it here. I see your point though

[@sinoroman]

if its ranch it better be a girl

[@LordFerrok]

Devon Collins gohan the bento box boy

[@X3n0nLP]

I'd Say either Bardock or Gine depending on the gender (since goku named gohan after his grandpa)

[@denstruction]

an interesting variation on this would be "what if the earth dragon balls couldnt resurrect people but the namekian dragon balls could?" this would keep the sense of consequence since they cant just undo the deaths of thousands of people. also another interesting idea within this what if would be if krillin joined goku when he got to king kai's planet.

[@BriggSnipes]

Okay I know there is a Multiverse but why would Future Trunk's DragonBalls still work in bringing people back to life? I understand for other What Ifs that his universe is different but still similar enough to happen in conjunction with the hypothetical timeline. If we get *META* with this The DragonBalls not resurrecting people seems more like it would be a Writer's change than in a verse change so if we were following this story fresh from when it came out Trunk's Dragonballs resurrecting but not in the main timeline doesnt make sense in my opinion.....But its just a what if I guess so no reason to take to seriously I reckon lol

[@dassadec]

BriggSnipes simple solution is that Future Trunks jumped to the wrong timeline. Mechanical error and he came to a universe where no rezzes work.

[@carlrood4457]

Keep in mind Trunks had ALREADY arrived in a past that was different from his in that Imperfect Cell was already there. Also, in his timeline there was no Android 19 & 20. Since his 17 & 18 were weaker than the main timeline's, it's probable they rebelled earlier and never got whatever upgrades made the MT versions stronger.

[@Yoseqlo1]

In Trunk's timeline, Kami saw all the destruction that King Piccolo did and used all his power to make the Dragon Balls' able to bring people back with the rules of the original DB.

[@cantthinkofaname1990]

That's not how time travel works in Dragon Ball. There aren't an infinite number of timelines, there's only 3 when Trunks goes to the past (6 after the events of the Goku Black arc). If the dragon balls could resurrect in Trunks' timeline then they'd be able to do it in the past as well. Unless Kami altered the balls later on to resurrect, but then that would defeat the point of Masako's "what if" idea. Masako never mentioned Kami doing that so the balls shouldn't be able to resurrect anyone in Trunks' timeline either. Actually, Trunks' timeline probably would have never happened, so him coming back to the past is just a bad story idea. The rest of the "what if" scenario is good though.

[@mardy3732]

Yoseqlo Yoseloq This couldn't have happened since both the main timeline and Trunk's timeline were identical untill Trunks traveled to te main timeline. Which caused events to play out differently there. That is where the timelines split apart for the first time.

[@HybridAngelZero]

To my brain, this seems like an amazing opportunity for an insane Freeza vs Cell vs Buu battle, and Piccolo, Gohan and Tien caught in the middle to protect the earth. hey, this is a cool idea xD

[@golammorshed2007]

Would'nt any of the Z-warrriors grant for emortality instead? So that they can take on threats withiout dying..

[@carlrood4457]

Immortality isn't invulnerability. They were still far weaker than any of the threats they faced. They don't get a Zenkai boost and by the time Vegeta gets there, they're already dealing with planet destroying levels of power. At best they'd be a bundle of broken bones floating in space.

[@devilsummoner7814]

Vegeta knew full well that even with immortality frieza would be an issue even then, and he was right considering all frieza has to do to stick it to vegeta is blow up the planet, sure vegeta wont die but it would suck since frieza just has to run away leaving vegeta in space. Honestly i would just ask for clairvoyance and a know it all device similar to the guy in super who knows errything but less annoying. Maybe a much better body like say gee i dunno that of Frieza but to be honest the limits of the dragonballs do not get explored all that much last time i checked, all i know about earth dragon balls is u cant do planetary level bs or higher and u can only revive the same person so many times.

[@ashkangh4577]

what about wishing for something like a *10k power boost! that would jump you from raditz level to perfect cell level in a single wish...aint that good enough?

[@devilsummoner7814]

I can see where you are going with this, your thought process is imma go obtain the power of someone else and honestly that could work but not sure what the limit would be, technically at the very least you should be able to add Kami's powerlevel on top of your own since you are agreeing to the wish and thus u can be altered. Honestly i would prefer something like the body of a superior being like say Frieza o even an angel, again not knowing the limits of the dragon balls is soo fucking annoying because if you take what the rules say you would think technically kami cant give you immortality or revive you but for some reason the dragonballs can. But if you go off too much into it, what is keeping the likes of your typical human to create a perfect replica of Frieza's body and then insert your memories and soul inside of it. and this is the tip of the iceberg in a sense.

[@acceleratingfiction2959]

+Carl Rood Depends on the type of immortality. See zamasu's immortality and compare with the various other immortality in dragon ball.

[@PlatinumYuri]

What if Gine went to Earth with Goku?

[@DeadLight63]

Brian Jimenez Thwt would be interesting actually, she's weak, but only compared to normal Saiyans. She could probably have gotten Goku's power level around 700 by the time King Piccolo showed up, and Raditz probably wouldn't have tried to attack his brother.

[@JMandJJ7797]

I can imagine Bardock telling his wife all about the visions and stuff and goes off to die fighting for his people but telling his wife that she must live. For this scenario to work though Freeza must be occupied long enough for Gine to steal an Attack Ball to go to Earth.

[@Miki-cm3sd]

PlatinumYuri earth would be destroyed because they didn't go with him cause the scouted would find them because they can't hide their power

[@girlybabyhedgehog]

Miki actually it could be possible for gine to hide on Earth as though it's rare there are a quite a bit of humans who have triple power digits and she is a very weak and kind heart girl maybe grandpa Gohan teach her how to hide her power level as well so she extra safe

[@youraveragemachine1013]

Good for you,it came true

[@joonaspenttila201]

i think yamcha wouldn't be so cocky if he know that goku was dead because of them and trained hard..... and i don't think z fighters wouldn't sacrifise themselves

[@LupineShadowOmega]

They don't have to. Most of them are still dead from Dragonball. Yamcha, Tien, and Piccolo are like the last men standing at this point.

[@Potato-Dono_and_Molasses]

That's my only criticism with this What If, I feel that the Raditz fight would've been more cautious, Piccollo might've still killed him but I'm not sure. He did kinda wanna keep fighting him. Well that and I feel Vegeta would've been killed, Goku spared him cause he wanted to fight him more, but in his scenario, he's dead and can't...

[@devilsummoner7814]

If they cannot revive people with the dragon balls the series would certainly end. Honestly given how OP the dragon balls are, you would think someone would fucking wish for something useful that is not reviving people for once, seeing the future, some bs device that does something really useful like teleport fuckers across galaxies i dunno but this is a kid's show so maybe that would be a bit too contrived.

[@joonaspenttila201]

Connorrules1 or they wished vegeta and nappa do die

[@LupineShadowOmega]

+Joonas Penttilä If it didn't work on the Androids, I doubt it would work on the Saiyans.

[@siliarba]

With Freeza still existing, don't you think Babidi would more likely go to Freeza for energy to awaken buu, after all, he's evil so can be easily controlled, and he has access to a gigantic army that he wouldn't hesitate to sacrifice even if he wasn't mind controlled so ton of free energy.

[@JaydonVRC]

JUST SAW THE TITLE MY MIND IS EXPLODING WITH IDEAS HOLY SHIT SO MANY

[@imveryangryitsnotbutter]

Find my comment. I list lots of ideas. Do any of them match yours?

[@ProfessorChimpYT]

I love these scenarios Masako! I got two scenarios for you that I believe would be good topics for a discussion. 1) What if Cell had killed Hercule/Mr. Satan during the Cell Games? 2) What if Grandpa Gohan survived his encounter with Great Ape Goku in Dragon Ball? I'd think it'd be fun to talk about these topics and, again, thank you for all these videos! Keep up the good work :)

[@TrueAmericanReject]

This may be an odd imput but what about Borra's son? After finding out his father isn't coming back he'd either be alone or come with Goku to get stronger so no one like Tao could hurt the innocent again becoming one of the super humans in DB... Am I thinking too much into this?

[@PokeHokage]

I think Most of this is right up until Trunks. In this scenario Trunks timeline is changed because he doesn't exist. Let's say Piccolo and Gohan train some more and even get their power unlocked by Guru and manage to kill vegeta (Or tien and Piccolo aren't having Gokus excuse to fight him again and kill him there) and then because Trunks doesn't exist Bulma comes back in time to warn them about the androids. Without Vegeta Piccolo and Gohan go into the room of spirit and time (Via Piccolo remembering it after fusing with Kami) come out before Cell can find 17 and 18 (Because he found them only because of Piccolos fight) They then destroy cell and peace is restored until Babidi and Dabura show up, Without Goku and Vegeta Buu doesn't wake up but Gohan would lose to Dabura and would have to retreat to learn how to use the Z sword. He would then come back stronger than ever and defeat Dabura and babidi before Buu is revived. Beerus can't get pissed off without Buu and Zamasu never meets Goku therefore no Goku black. The end

[@brandonmedina9527]

PokeHokage No, Zeno would blow up the universes because no Goku to start a Universal Tourney

[@InfernosReaper]

Trunk exists in his own timeline because their time travel is multiverse theory

[@RedRhythm_1]

Piccolo would be dead

[@joshwoofter4789]

@all Multiverse Theory.

[@Raptor_Ren]

Beerus wakes up, Kills Frieza like he considered, finds vegeta while looking for the SSG, and kills him because he's annoyed he didn't find one. Shin may have begged him to stop Buu's resurrection too. So Basically: If the Dragon Balls didn't resurrect people, Beerus would have actually been forced to EVENTUALLY do his freaking job for once.

[@godzillaisbetterthenyou9762]

Plot twist:yamcha survived but didn’t care any more

[@anupamjaiswal5927]

Bad News for Krillin and Yamcha.

[@PhillyTheKid]

Anupam Jaiswal yes

[@SuperDodger64]

I'd suspect that if the dragon balls kept all their powers except resurrection and the threat levels faced remained the same then there would have been a lot more pressure for characters - even heroes- to preemptively become immortal before facing threats, which would become really stupid really quickly.

[@kadindarklord]

I think Yajirobe could have climbed that tower anyway. He climbed most of it with Goku on his back. So, logic says he can do it. He would just need a bit of encourgement.

[@RavenHunterDubz]

So in other words this would be "Dragon Ball ; Dragon Ball Z ; Dragon Ball Super Nuzlocke Edition"

[@yunanasnakewoman5150]

I think Piccolo would've proably killed Vegeta on Earth, cause Goku couldn't say no let him go So I can beat him up next time cause their wouldn't be a next time.

[@Zeromaru42]

What if Gohan became a super saiyan early? Like when he was kidnapped by Raditz? Or possibly when he sees his Dad being beaten by the androids? Would Gohan be stronger than goku at that point in time? Would he possibly achieve SSJ2 early? I'm kinda interested in this question and I would like to see it happen sometime in the future. Keep up the good work!

[@fred2995]

Do a video on what if vegeta came up with his zenkai boost idea while piccolo fought second form freeza, so when freeza went to his third form, vegeta destroyed freeza.

[@SinHurr]

No Super Saiyan Androids kill everyone Cell is angry The end.

[@naruotsutsuki4423]

I don't think thing will change that much, all Frieza have to say is "oh Vegeta, you are stronger now... but are strong enough to fight me in my final form?". In Namek, Vegeta is a freaking vulture and will not take that risk BUT at this point, he will be like "I'm the legendary super saiyen, bring it on Frieza!". And fuck me sideway, Final Form Frieza appears and decides to "play" with Vegeta... you know the rest.

[@channelnumber52]

It's not in Vegeta's nature to do that. He'd have gotten cocky and demanded to see his final form before killing him. Remember, Vegeta is the one that told freeza to transform into his second form before he decided to. Saiyan blood requires them to want to fight full power opponents.

[@coolestgyever531]

interesting what If! I really enjoyed the take. I'd like to offer a couple of observations that might change things. 1) with the dragonballs no longer having the properties of resurrection, there would be a plethora of unused wishes. I do think that without the ability to wish people back, bulma and the others may see the growing threats of enemies and consider making wishes that would bolster their defenses. perhaps immortality for their strongest warriors? 2) without resurrection, goku 's motivation for training would change, as would town's and even piccolo's. We know that emotional triggers play a huge role in dragon ball. You even did a 3 part series on it! these deaths of krillin, chioitzu, roshi, etc and the realization that they could not be resurrected could have led to a larger power increase by goku. if goku got stronger faster, it would stand to reason he'd have a shot at surviving. with this, an enhanced goku couldeventually be involved in training gohan, who would in turn grow stronger at an increased rate, as we have seen from all of the children in z. In general the stronger the master, the stronger the student becomes and the faster the rate of improvement this could all really impact the end results in the regular Dragon Ball Z timeline, and with these details we may end up with sufficient reasoning behind trunks timeline remaining similar to the one that we know now. I'm rambling a bit but I hope that this makes sense and adds to the discussion. Thanks for reading!

[@yoavbenclaudia3073]

Uh... Yajirobe was thrown to give them a head start. He still climbed with Goku on his back, and even ran up the tower at one point.

[@SchazmenRassir]

I love theories like this. There's just so much potential for different scenarios to happen!

[@golammorshed2007]

Thats why kids, the show is called DRAGON BALL Z

[@TonyRead31]

Amazing video please make a part 2 of this! :)

[@HellGrimo]

What if King Kai teached Kaioken and Genki Dama to other earthlings? Would Krillin and others be actually usefull?

[@franicman_6829]

HellGrimo They didn't learn any techniques but the did grow stronger than the Ginyus

[@PfcSoup]

That was anime only so i dont think it counts. They would probably only be about as strong as Goku was during the Vegeta fight

[@lloydchristian936]

HellGrimo krillin never meet king Kai.the second time he died he was in a different part of the galaxy that king Kai doesnt watch over and the first time he was young and not really ready for training

[@HellGrimo]

You are probably right but... there was other Kais right? Maybe he could get training from other Kai? I know it's a stretch I just wish Earthlings wouldn't be so underpowered :/

[@triggeredguy9863]

Yamcha would kill him self Kaio ken

[@RequiMog]

Sequel scenario: Bulma adapts Dr. Giro's research for her own purposes.

[@bubba1718]

what if you wished that the DragonBalls could bring people back

[@ianrodz5435]

That the best idea

[@o_o888]

Thats as stupid as wishing for three more wishes

[@Morgil27]

"Also, Frieza's still alive. You know, that whole _chestnut_." Is that a reference to Kuriza?

[@imcintyre01]

I was going to say, if goku didn't kill Vegeta, pretty sure tien would think about it to long only to have piccolo blast him to the NEXT DIMENSION! I think frieza might grow a bit curious as to why Vegeta the strongest of his little toy monkeys happens to have disappeared out of existence. Assuming piccolo is only partially heartless he won't try to take over the planet.....yet. Assuming thing carry out the same frieza may send apool to check up on Vegeta' last location to see if their is someone to recruit to his army. Assuming piccolo, kami, bulma (because she's bored and thinks she could learn a lot by visiting other races in the universe), Gohan (because he's still kinda being kidnapped) and tien go to namek (tien because he doesn't trust piccolo still and wants to look out for Burma and Gohan). Apool shows up on earth only to cause a little trouble and then leave the planet not finding anything. I think piccolo would train with nail and grow his heart to being a bit easier than what it would have been. Guru unlocks tien's and Gohan's power. Assuming that the training here with the only masters they know of tien would probably stay and train for a while and perhaps get wished back home. Piccolo trains with tien and lets bulma and Gohan head home back to earth after finding out these dragon balls don't let people get wished back to life either. The two arrive home only to find things ruined slightly as part of a town here and another part there is blown up and trashed. Gohan is whith his mom now and bulma goes to find out from her dad what had happened. Assuming apool got the info he makes it to namek only to fight a charged up tien and piccolo. Only to be defeated though possibly not killed and returns to Lord frieza. Either way apool makes it to frieza. If apool is beat up frieza is slightly amused and sends dadoria to take care of the pests. If apool doesn't know where the strong fighter is he continues on like it was nothing. Mean while, bulma meets trunks who warns about the androids. Taking the dadoria route the frieza member arrives on planet namek and finds the two fighters tien and piccolo only this time they are joined by nail. The three of them doom it out. It's a close battle that reminds the z warriors about Vegeta. They question whether or not to let this stranger live. If they do, they aren't sure who will come fighting next, perhaps someone much stronger. Against the judgement of the 3 warriors Guru shows compassion and let's the pink warrior leave. Dadoria returns to frieza only to have frieza annoyed now and sees that the job will be handled personally. Guru senses frieza approaching and that this being is far more powerful than the three could handle, unless piccolo and kami were to fuse. The two do not like it, but since they have no choice, they agree. The fusion takes place just after the battle with zarbon. Frieza is finding it interesting once more that 3 warriors could defeat some of his finest group of soldiers, but if they don't comply he will eradicate the entire planet. Guru is concerned as is kami, so the two agree that kami and piccolo should fuse once more. At this point though it is unnecessary Guru would probably give piccolo the unlocked potential power up. While that power up is going on, frieza sent the ginyu force to fight tien and nail. The fight begins with Recoom and guildo. Tien remembered his training with Chautzu and how to best handle psychic powers. Nail is able to defeat recoom. Then jeice, burter and ginyu all 3 decide to fight. Nail is a bit worn down and tien would have a difficult time fighting all 3 by himself. Then piccolo shows up in his newly powered form with dende. Dende heals nail and it's now a swift and easy victory against the 3....until ginyu desires to change bodies. The switching continues for a bit and assuming everything turns out alright dende then heals tien, Neil and piccolo back in shape. Piccolo sense frieza is now no problem and can easily defeat him on his own. Frieza calls the bluff and piccolo lays a smackdown on frieza The following path is as follows piccolo man handles frieza in any form until frieza decides to blow up the planet and piccolo stops it. He then obliterates frieza securing safety for namek. Tien thinks that training on namek has been good for him but he really misses launch and is thinking of starting a new gym in order to train and prepare the rest of earth for whatever threat may come next. Piccolo stays on namek and guru dies and is replaced by Mori. Piccolo then trains with nail and maybe piccolo has a new warrior clan (I don't know just spit balling here) Tien is back on earth, bulma destroyed dr.gero's things and the few friends including chichi and Gohan meet up at capsule corp. Gohan has been studying almost non stop and has gotten kinda weak since having been with mr. Piccolo but chichi still teaches him some things from here earlier training as well as the oxking teaching Gohan the kamehameha. He (may or may not perform it but may just show what his master would used to do). Gohan like his father watches it and then does a pathetic version of it but soon gets the hang of it thanks to the little he remembered from piccolo's training. Tien then offers to train Gohan for the martial arts tournament in order for the family to help make some money (even though bulma still helps from time to time) chichi reluctantly agrees and now Gohan trains with tien on how to get stronger for the tournament. This is all for now I'm getting tired, but I hope you've enjoyed so far :)

[@simoncrann9430]

MasakoX, great summary! I would add the following: Trunks does not return to his own future to squander, instead he returns to the time where Son Goku is about to sacrifice himself and helps him and Piccolo to beat Raditz. At this point, he tells Goku about the Super Saiyan form. This encourages Goku to train hard, albeit he does not meet King Kai now (or even ever?). Goku is able to achieve the Super Saiyan form but never learns the techniques of the Spirit Bomb nor Kaioken. Wow! This is fun and somewhat confusing! Haha! Well done!

[@nightblade3709]

I think we're missing a huge player in all this: Gohan. Gohan potentially could be much stronger than his father, and under Piccolo's watchful eye, would've grown a fair amount after Guru unlocks his potential (having gone to Namek). HOWEVER, it would be Trunks from our timeline that would tip the scales. Trunks, who was trained by Gohan in his original timeline, wouldn't give up so easily on Gohan and would likely train him after Bulma deals with Gero. He'd teach him how to go SSJ and, when he is ready, would train with him in the Hyperbolic Time Chamber. I also think Piccolo would work even harder to get stronger without Goku around, and would likely bridge the gap to reach at least his power level in the original timeline. But there's one technicality that we haven't considered: Goku. Goku might be able to train in the Hyperbolic Time Chamber since one year in there is technically one day outside, solving the 24 hour time limit issue. In this 24 hours, he could pass on techniques to Gohan, including the Spirit Bomb and the Kaioken. AND Goku can also be summoned by the Dragon Balls to fight larger threats alongside the Z fighters and would dedicate his afterlife to training with King Kai. I think this would become Gohan's story, and with a little help, he'd be able to stand up to more than you'd think. And let's not forget that Vegeta might return to earth to get his revenge, only to see Gohan achieve SSJ and would be motivated to stick around to get stronger as well. And just imagine a fusion between Vegeta and a Gohan who never stopped training. Then Beerus blows up the planet because no SSG (and even with Goku temporarily revived, there's no Goten to complete the ritual, unless they use the Dragon Balls to make Videl have twins, lol)

[@jessicafrost7579]

I think you missed an opportunity here. The interesting question to ask in this scenario is: if the Dragon Balls can't revive people, what do Goku and the gang use them for instead? But instead of replacing the resurrection wishes with something else, they just kind of... don't make wishes at all? I think this scenario deserves a revisit!

[@seandobbins2231]

I always found that there was still peril in Dragon Ball, even with the power of the series' namesake. My reason is that even though people could be wished back there still has to be an ally alive in order to do so, not to mention that the dragon balls still need to be active. When King Piccolo killed the dragon we thought that was the end for fallen cast members and when Piccolo died we thought the same. Also, consider what would have happened had Goku lost against Freeza. Everyone that was still dead would still be dead and Freeza would have eventually conquered Earth, killing the rest of the population. Overall, the peril isn't about permanent death possibly not being a thing, it's about being able to overcome adversity in order to allow it.

[@devilsummoner7814]

To be honest, most of the peril that happens in dragon ball is self inflicted to the point i cannot sympathize with the characters. There are a few cases where i can legit sympathize with them because i know full well the dragon balls cannot save them, Battle of the Gods is one such case, Goku black Arc the dragon balls would not really help in the late game of that arc but that whole thing excalated due to saiyan retardation. Also if memory serves one can ask for immortality, sure it wont work vs Buu or a god of destruction or Cell or Frieza, would work on Vegeta however because he lacks Hakai, absorption or the bullshit powerup rates . But yeah i agree that peril is in there and i love frieza saga for not allowing saiyan retardation to go as high as it does later on. Also had Super Saiyan Goku somehow lost to Frieza depending on how long it takes him to lose, the dragon balls would be a thing once again and goku could be revived, it would just be quite painful to pull off(considering goku would had died on a nonexistant planet) on top of the fact that Frieza is salty and is coming for earth, which he does either way. All of this is not even taking into account Trunks could simply be a dick about it and go back in the past and beat frieza but his existance is less likely without goku.

[@seandobbins2231]

+Devil Summoner I wouldn't say most of the peril is self-inflicted. They were legitimately captured by Pilaf and Goku had no control over his transformation. The Red Ribbon arc wasn't either, nor was King Piccolo or Piccolo Jr. To be honest, anything prior to the Cell arc couldn't be considered self-inflicted. For Cell and Buu I would say was self-inflicted, but the circumstances weren't caused by every single person. Krillin was dumb for destroying the remote and Vegeta for allowing Cell to become perfect, but Trunks tried to stop him and Goku and Gohan were training. In regards to Buu, that was all Goku so I would feel bad for everyone else having to deal with Buu. The BoG arc was all because of Beerus, the RoF arc all Freeza, though I do wonder why Piccolo and Gohan didn't rush to check things out, esp. after they noticed the dragon was summoned. The Zamasu arc was a weird one, but I think ultimately it wouldn't have mattered whether or not Goku wanted to fight him the first time or not since Zamasu was just bad and would have eventually started shit, anyway. The current arc is all Goku. Overall, most of the characters are just trying to do their best when things get messed up and it's not their fault. If Goku lost to Freeza how would he be revived? Goku can't be wished back with the Earth dragon balls and had Freeza got his way during the fight Piccolo would have been dead, meaning that Guru wouldn't have been brought back to life for the 3rd wish. It still revolves around characters surviving for the dragon balls to be used. Also, if Freeza won he wouldn't have been so badly damaged and would have made it to Earth before Goku would have been revived since they saved him for last.

[@devilsummoner7814]

The self inflicted thing refers to DBZ and Super not so much DB considering DB does not have nearly as much bullshiet nor easy access to dragon balls. I will concede on the if Frieza won thing. Namek saga was self inflicted because it was the aftermath of the stupidity of the shit that happened in saiyan saga. here is why, if Goku had not let go of raditz's tail, he would not have had to die like a moron(this puts him at a disadvantage against nappa and vegeta however) lets say raditz goes on like normal and errything else happens just like in the Anime except the Z warriors do the sensible thing and gee i dunno, wait for goku given how useless they were against Nappa(also wishing for immortality OP on this point of the anime).Vegeta and Nappa certainly would had done enough damage to the world but not blow up the fuck up that quick(this one i am not so sure on if they can actually blow up earth this fast but i am working on the assumption they cannot), in any case saiyan saga had some dumb casualties(almost all of them but specially piccolo's) which is good for character development but still dumb on his part. This would had landed an easier victory against the saiyan Arc and Namek would had never happened. The Series would however end at Cell saga most likely however. We might disagree a bit on what self inflicted means given i am coming off as nitpicky but i believe this is how things would had turned out hypothetically. Either way thanks for taking the time to respond.

[@seandobbins2231]

+Devil Summoner yes, Goku could have kept holding Raditz's tail, but Nappa and Vegeta still would have come and Goku would be significantly weaker than he was in the original story. To be honest, I don't think they would have had any way of winning in that case, at least against Vegeta since Goku needed the Kaioken to keep up with Vegeta. Was Goku stupid for not letting go of Raditz's tail? Yeah, but he didn't really cause anything that wouldn't have happened otherwise, in fact him dying gave him the abilities he needed in order to make it through the rest of the arc. They did try to wait for Goku, Vegeta even gave them 3 hours to allow them to do so. Also, none of the Z warriors would wish for immortality because they don't want it and would just be an example of the dragon balls taking away from the peril. Even if Goku became immortal he still wouldn't have been able to stop Vegeta from blowing up the planet without having the Kaioken or the Spirit Bomb and being as weak as he would be. I would say that Vegeta could destroy the planet because that was what he meant to do with his Galic Gun and I think Vegeta would know what he is capable of. The deaths in that arc aren't really dumb, though. First of all, had Chiaotzu not blown himself up he probably still would have died because he was the weakest out of all of them. Tien died by putting all his ki into last attack. Piccolo's death, while it was a sacrifice and seems dumb to you for some reason, if he hadn't that would have just meant that Gohan would have died instead. Even then, it still would have been possible for Piccolo to die and even if he didn't the death of Chiaotzu would have meant that Namek would still need to happen because the Earth dragon balls couldn't bring him back. To be clear, in this paragraph I'm assuming that Goku died and came back as normal since I concluded previously that everyone would have been screwed had Goku not died. No, I think we agree on what "self-inflicted" means, I just don't think that the Namek arc was self-inflicted.

[@devilsummoner7814]

Ah good its nice to have a proper conv for once. Well the reason why i think Piccolo's sacrifice for Gohan was dumb in piccolo's part was because if he dies, the dragon balls would not exist since he is linked to kami and in my head Gohan < dragonballs since immortality can still carry you in this arc specially if you are goku, the one counter argument on this is that they would take too long but this i think might be able to turn the tides against the saiyans. It is dumb from the logical stand point considering that you are giving up the dragon balls(Mcguffin that allows from immortality to revival) for Gohan, but character wise and as far as development i can understand it since Gohan practically sees Piccolo as a surrogate father of sorts and down the line this leads to the hilarious goku is terrible father and piccolo is best father joke. And yes Namek could had been avoided but not necessarily self inflicted since i might have generalized a bit much nothing particularly stupid was done to lead up to it(goes to show everything right with the saiyan saga).Maybe i have been exaggerating the power of the dragon balls too much but the wording for them is weird considering that they allow wishes within the power of the creator(immortality and revival but for some fucking reason no insta killing things that arent as powerfull as say the saiyans or freeza) and also i kinda blame Toriyama for not really getting creative with the wishes on them, although i guess if he did everything would be too easy but that is an annoying contradiction at times, you could argue they encourage lazy writing in a sense but not getting into that can of worms. PS thanks for reminding me they actually tried everything to stall the saiyans on that saga.

[@JnGArtimation]

I think the resurrecting could be effective if there were some kind of "trial". Something like, "if you die and you want to return back to the mortal realm; you'll have to prove it" with some kind of burden-like challenge set by the Kai's/King Yemma. And, if you meet expectations, they can grant you life back to the mortal realm. Spit-ballin' here.

[@Seetiyan]

I'm with you up until Trunks. I love Trunks, but he CAN'T EXIST in this what-if. Remember, his timeline is just the future of "our" timeline, until he and Cell changed it. And in our no-resurrection timeline, Vegita and Bulma never get together, therefore, Trunks never comes to exist. So either the Androids destroy all humanity, then Cell combines with them in the future, or Dr. Gero never makes them at all after hearing that Goku had died already.

[@thedepressedguy602]

Seetiyan It could just be a 4th one.

[@lShadowdark]

Most of the Trunks timeline is pretty fucked up for the simple paradox of "you cannot kill a time-traveller", its really hard to explain but in resume, i can say this: "Who killed Cell to get the time machine if Trunks is alive to travel back?" The multiverse is pretty much unavoidable here.

[@Sploack]

I commented for the first time under your last video, saying that your what ifs rarely end in tragedy, that butterfly effect is absent and that you tend to stick to the main plot points, like the namek ark happening. Next video I see, there is a tragic story, the plot goes offroad, there are no super saiyans or namek ark, and most evil guys "get to win". I don't even know if you read my comment or if it was just a common request, but good job! I loved this scenario. Only thing that would have been very different, in my opinion, is the trunks's story, because I don't see dragon ball time travel working like that. But anyway this was great. Thanks masako!

[@OnEiNsAnEmOtHeRfUcKa]

TBH I think Yamcha would have survived the Saibaman encounter if for no other reason than the fact that Goku is there at all means the group could very easily claim victory without any losses.

[@jimmypanda3738]

what if the farmer with the shotgun was the one to receive the super sayain god transformation?

[@DragonflyRei3]

Funny this what if scenario appeared. I was actually talking with my friend about a what if scenario with the dragon balls too only with a different dark twist to them just for fun. This'll properly be long an I apologize for it X_X We were talking about what if the dragon balls the normal ones had the same kind of consequences to using them... an I don't mean they make the world blow up in GT. But the consequences of such wishes could be vast an different things, simillar to 'something wicked this way comes'. Such as wish for eternal youth and beauty but then become completely blind being unable to enjoy it ...which could make the Z fighters a lot more reluctant in using them each time there is a major threat an they have to get rid of this threat as soon as possible before more damage is done. Along with having them to be that much more cautious for their survival within the battles because these wishes are so risky... So it's a matter of them fearing death giving it consequences again even though you can be brought back to life due to another fear that the dragons power would do something to screw you over in return....ok your'e brought back to life...but your now in a rotting body like a Zombie... or ok your back to life but at the cost of the life of someone close to you instead. That would be how to make Death somewhat matter in DBZ again....you can't have such wishes without sacrificing something in return... kind of method.

[@wulfulk1000]

Underated

[@ryudragon7]

I get the feeling that if the Dragon Balls could not revive people, there would be a lot of wishes to enhance the Z fighters strength. Or maybe wishing away a lot of their problems.

[@McFazzer]

Huh... if Trunks finds out that in this timeline Dragon Balls can't resurrect people and he feels the Saiyans are needed, would he instead go back to the Raditz fight and prevent Goku's death? Which in itself would raise the issue of no King Kai and no Kaioken or Spirit Bomb

[@alexanderthedead5]

Interesting, but this would just create a third timeline. Trunks doesn't know this would create a third timeline, of course, but I don't think there's any point in discussing solutions via time machine.

[@marcussmith7409]

Ah see that's because it's not accurate to call it time travel, they're really alternate time lines which you can travel to one or the other, they both move forward at the same speed, you can't spend 2 years in your original timeline then take the time machine back to seconds after you just left their timeline it'd be 2 years later in that timeline as well. That's why the only thing Trunks could do for his timeline is become strong enough to beat the androids and imperfect cell on his own.

[@McFazzer]

I get that, but if Trunks wants to get stronger, but in this particular timeline wouldn't joining the Z Fighters from Raditz on perform the same function?

[@joemalbe]

An option would be to travel to another timeline collect their dragon balls and load them into the time machine or make a wish across timelines if possible.

[@Jack_Donovan]

Thanks for your guys answers I was curious of what would happen and maybe MasakoX has his opinions on this and maybe a future video?

[@nightmareking1697]

wait doesn't piccolo die in the saiyan saga by the hands of Nappa in an attempt to save Gohan?

[@katxiii3660]

With Goku arriving on time for the fight, Tien and Piccolo survive.

[@juliusdepravedprince7104]

Until Dawn flashbacks*

[@danieldishon688]

I think you should return to this what if and get a little more in depth with. You treat the deaths of Krillain and Roshi as if they wouldn't affect Goku at all or the course of his adult life. Would Goku being going to the Kame house for a reunion if Roshi and Krillain were dead or would he, Yamcha, Tien, and Bulma meet somewhere else like his place or at Bulmas when Raddits comes to earth? Or would they still meet at the Kame house because with Krillain and Roshi dead, Goku feels somewhat responsible to carry on the Turtle style legacy as the only living master of the school that can teach others? Would Goku have young pupils in the story that were not their before? Would all the irreparable death motivate any of the surviving cast like Tien or Yamcha to walk away from fighting forever or would it motivate them to push themselves to be stronger than ever before and not waist time playing baseball all those years. Or darker yet does it send any of them down a dark path, looking for the power required to take revenge against all demons? Maybe Tien trains with Babbas fearsome 5 and learns the devilmite beam from Devilman and easily defeats Raddits with it when he comes to earth. Perhaps Goku does some training with fallen charachter Babba brings back to learn the demon sealing technique from Roshi, perhaps Krillain teaches Goku Destructo Disk that he perfected in otherworld. Maybe Krillain is the 1st warrior to go down snake way and train with King Kia. Or maybe even Roshi is. What if at least one Ressurection does happen the way Goku got ressurected in the Buu saga if King Kia thought it was important enough to give up his life to bring one warrior back. In the Raddits battle would Goku even put himself in a sacrificing position if he didn't believe Dragon Balls could save him or would he prolong the battle to find another way? If they aren't using the Dragon Balls to ressurect people all the time what have they been using them for all these years? To get stronger? To access powerful techniques and transformations? Immortality? Knowledge? Travel through time for training or to fix things? Does anybody think to use them to replace the absolute Dog King monarchy with themselves as a governing power?

[@vazak11]

Great insights here, this was a great read!

[@drallelgaming]

you forgot that Goku's body isn't normal in this scenario meaning he can use above the 4x kioken he could probably go up to x20 without even trying

[@drallelgaming]

also babidi would have had no reason to go-to Earth with no Vegeta or goku there and gohan just became a scholar and most likely never met videl

[@DarlCron]

13:40 Dabura: So, you say your name is Imperfect Cell? You would make the most wonderful of minions for my master. Imp. Cell: Yeah right. Listen, I'm not here to talk. I sensed your power, and I'm here for one thing. Dabura: What's that? Imp. Cell: *Sticks his tail into Dabura* You! *Imp. Cell proceeds to drink everyone on board babidi's ship, saving earth. Vegeta returns, Imp. Cell does the same, and Cell becomes the hero of Earth*

[@QuyenH]

-No more Gokq&a???- *SAD*

[@gr8lakesdiver1]

LegendGamer7 he needs to do more GoQa

[@zarcthesavage9079]

LegendGamer7 t

[@cheesygoodness8243]

L

[@Lazalatin]

First of all, love this episode, especially the multiverse-twist with Future Trunks! But hear me out: the moment Trunks finds out about Goku being dead and all, wouldn't he turn to the next best fighter he knows of: Gohan? Trunks at this point knows how to go Super Sayian, so teaching Gohan would be possible for him. Sure, Bulma can carry out her plan as she does in this "what if", but maybe Gohan could put up enough of a fight to defeat Cell and Dabura, effectively stopping the resurrection of Majin Buu, because there aren't this many Sayians alive anymore who can pour out their energy like it's happy hour

[@alanpoet183]

well trunk wouldnt of existed cause vegeta and bulma would of never become a thing so they couldnt get warned. nor would buu of been resurrected since it was all the energy from fighting that helped bring him back.

[@thedepressedguy602]

Dark Poet It's the multiverse theory, Trunks comes from a timeline where he exists.

[@alanpoet183]

Mr. Piccolo true but then my theory on building should still be valid

[@thedepressedguy602]

Dark Poet What do you mean building?

[@sbq92]

This one was interesting. One issue I had with it, though, was the idea of Goku sacrificing himself to help Piccolo kill Raditz. I guess I'm not necessarily saying he WOULDN'T sacrifice himself, but I think he had no real problem with doing so in the original story because he knew his death wouldn't be permanent thanks to the dragon balls. In this scenario, however, he knows his death would be permanent, so he might not be so willing to sacrifice himself but instead try to keep fighting Raditz as much as he can and try to win another way. If he and Piccolo could have managed the win without the sacrifice, it's possible things could have gone very differently. Though I suppose things could have gone even worse, since Goku wouldn't have met with King Kai and therefore probably wouldn't have the strength needed to fight off Vegeta and Nappa (i.e., no Kaioken and no Spirit Bomb).

[@Basher.G]

Hold on a second, Masako. I'm a bit confused about Future Trunks's relevancy. If the timeline you described is different than the original one where Trunks was born, why would he appear in a timeline he wouldn't exist in?

[@lShadowdark]

It's more of an alternate timeline that is normal (remember that there are 3 trunks and 2 cells in that saga: Dead trunks, Baby Trunks, Time-traveller Trunks, capsule Cell and Time-traveller cell)..

[@Basher.G]

Sorry but that doesn't help me to understand. Originally there was only 1 timelune. An alternate timeline was created when Future Trunks traveled in time. There's no reason for the time machine to take Trunks to a timeline that is already alternate to his instead of his original timeline like it did in the series.

[@alexcasillas4508]

Basher Theories He just usually likes to keeps Trunks's timeline intact even though it wouldn't be possible . He does change it in What if Nappa turned good though

[@bananatree2527]

0:48 When MasakoX tries to keep you in suspense while the title of the video already spoils it.

[@alihussain1183]

I don't think Yamaha would die if Gokal was their

[@AshBlossomWorshiper]

Ali Hussain Agreed, but he would've died to either Nappa or Vegeta

[@heartofvanillaice7443]

Ali Hussain YOUR GRAMMAR, ARE YOU SANE?

[@neoshenlong]

I don't think Gokal could've saved Yamaha, maybe Gohome would've fought Napalm for a while, enough for Yamaha to avoid battle but then Gohome and Pick Ollie would've been dead. Oh, maybe that could allow Gokal to turn into a Super Saying, thus inspiring Vegetables to try to turn into a Super Saying himself and destroy Freezing?

[@imveryangryitsnotbutter]

[involuntary eye twitch]

[@twiztid6977420]

Neoshenlong Archivo 2008 - 2011 Haha! That's great.

[@RaffiMiah]

When i saw the title i was like ooh noo...

[@spyrofan9681]

Wait why would Trunks' timeline be the same as in the original series that's just confusing things

[@carlrood4457]

Trunks comes from a alternate timeline, anyway. He came to one that was similar to his past, but was already diverged when Cell arrived two years prior. That means, he'd already crossed timestreams. This scenario has him cross into a timeline that's much more different than his.

[@karls-g5458]

I like this what if the best, as it removes the possibility of all the bad decisions Goku and Co. make, leaving the possibility open for some interesting fights: imperfect Cell vs Babadi / Dabura, or if Majin Buu were to be resurrected and in search of a good fight, the only being on his level would be Freeza.

[@BlackThane]

I think Zeno-Oh should destroy all "normal" dragon balls and leave Super dragon balls scattered across random 7 universes, that way death/destruction of earth would matter again if more people would hunt for wishes/it would take god know what effort to gather them. BTW: anybody else thinks it was grand priest who created super dragon balls? (I mean he is that dragon god but in disguise)

[@diodesu]

Ancient Namekians from Universe 6 & Universe 7 did so.

[@NocturnalNugget2]

the fat know it all guy told it was some god that made the super dragon balls and I think the grand priest is a angle

[@diodesu]

I'd say the GOD's & ancient namekians made it.

[@jacobytes8720]

Noticed that skull in that thumbnail, nice one Masako.

[@Ow33e]

So what about Namek's Dragon Balls? Can they resurrect? If so, would they have resurrected Goku and Krillin and everyone else who died? Also the "What if?" ended at Z but why not take it further? If it went to Super, Beerus would kill Frieza (Freeza?) and Goku would be alive (Namekian Dragon Balls) so BoG would happen. Resurrection F wouldn't but what about Vegeta? He'd be mad that he was beaten! After intense training he would have come back to kill Gohan and anyone that helped beat him that was still alive. I was surprised he didn't come back in the scenario. After BoG I imagine Super would have continued as normal. Except maybe Super Saiyan God Super Saiyan... I dunno, that's for you to work out Masako! Can we please have a Part 2?!

[@tylerroach928]

Gohan may have been trained by Piccolo his whole childhood though because Chi-Chi would allow it because Goku isn't around like she did with Goten so eventually he would be able to handle Cell with some help from Piccolo and by the time Babidi shows up Gohan could already be SS3 level if he never stopped training with Piccolo

[@makito106]

What if Toriyama didn't get bored with tails and adult saiyans could grow back tails?

[@Chris-nu5bk]

Super Saaaaaiiiiiiyaaaaan 4

[@fullmetalfoley9058]

10:12 "Technillogy" I'm dead 😂

[@annemarienimbere1045]

what if its the same scenario but instead of goku dying maybe piccolo could have given him a signal and he would of gotten out of the way and raditz could still stayed there and took the special Beam cannon and died?.

[@nightdrivenen7909]

Anne Marie Nimbere At that time Piccolo and Goku were still enemies. Piccolo taking a long hyatus to get stronger so that he could still defeat Goku. That was when he came up with the Special Beam Cannon in the first place. Now here presents Goku holding a stronger enemy that the two mutually want to defeat. Piccolo takes two birds out with one stone: the invading force and his ultimate target Goku. Why would he warn Goku in any scenario if he is getting what he wants all along? Goku dying is almost like a fixed point because there is no logical reasoning unless goku specifically befriends Piccolo before raditz shows up.

[@MatsuyoRific]

"New form of technilogy" MasakoX- 2017

[@yazanhamdan84]

How would Future Trunks exist if Vegeta never goes back to Earth and make his business with Bulma? Doesn't that mean that Future Trunks can't warn them about the androids since they were made to kill him, but he is dead already? And Cell wouldn't be as strong as he was since he doesn't have Frieza's cells. Also Gohan won't achieve ssj2 against Cell and goten wouldn't have been born in the Buu arc, so no gotenks would exist at all. Wow the series would've been really boring with all of these changes compared to the series we know and all that is because of the dragon balls. 😀

[@marcvillarclaramunt6830]

The most interesting part of this "what if" is "what would they wish?" Maybe there's a way to solve the plot without resurrection.

[@snowyinferno]

Dragonball Z *Classic Mode*

[@Rikoyasha15]

9:00 wouldnt Piccolo or Tien kill Vegeta? Goku would have no reason to ask them to spare him since he won't get another chance to fight him.