MAYBELLINE LASH SENSATIONAL WASHABLE VS WATERPROOF MASCARA | 8-HOUR WEAR TEST & COMPARISON

[@noemimatias3729]

Thanks so much for your review and honest opinion 👍🏼 I love your videos ❤️

[@katecartermakeup]

thank you so much!! I’ll definitely be making an update on this mascara

[@janinem3280]

Thanks, Kate! I was looking forward to this video! The washable is my go-to for everyday. Like you, I do get a bit of smudging, but only under my right eye! I also use some FitMe or Wet N Wild translucent powder with my triangle velvet setting puff and it does seem to help. 🐈‍⬛💕

[@katecartermakeup]

omg really it’s your go-to mascara! that’s so good to know I’m definitely going to wear it more off camera and do an update then. I love a velvet setting puff, I notice that when I bake my under eyes I usually have less smudging. So I’m going to bake and then try this mascara again!❤️

[@janinem3280]

@@katecartermakeup I do really love the Sky High, but I have such a hard time getting it off 🙃

[@paolaruiz9261]

Hey Kate ❤❤ I was shocked that this was smudged so early I’m glad it stop smudging but still. I’ve had this mascara it was okay not my favorite though. I remember I didn’t like how watery the formula was. It was a very dark mascara and it would give nice volume too. If I remember clearly it did use to smudge on me too

[@katecartermakeup]

It is super watery! but I did love how black it was, I’m going to bake my under eyes and then try this mascara again in a KZbin short to see what I think. I’m glad you had a similar experience with the mascara though, makes me not feel alone!❤️

[@Billlieandbelllieves]

Hi Kate! I’ve been wearing this mascara lately and I do agree that it’s super wet, and it also smudges on me. I’ve got oily skin including oily eyelids but this mascara only smudges on my bottom lashes. Not my fave! Love your videos!

[@katecartermakeup]

thank you so much!!!❤️ and I’m glad you had a similar experience to me, it’s def not the best mascara you can find from the drugstore

[@noemimatias3729]

Give us an update, please.

[@swiftiepharbz]

hi kate, thank you so much for your review! the waterproof version was on sale today and i was ready to go pick it up when i caught your video just in time. it's such a shame that even the waterproof version smudges. i have a couple of questions: would you consider making a video on the most smudge-proof mascaras you have tried so far, and perhaps trying asian beauty mascaras such has the kiss me heroine mascara and the clio kill lash mascara? i have the latter and it holds up quite well despite my oily skin. both mascaras are available on amazon. thanks so much and i hope you have luck with the mascaras i suggested above :)

[@katecartermakeup]

Yes!! I’ve heard of those mascaras before, can you comment the links to both of them so I know which ones to buy, there’s a few options on Amazon but I’m not sure which is the right one. And yes I’ve been wanting to do a video about the most smudge proof mascaras and best curling mascaras but honestly I haven’t found more than 1 mascara that I would recommend to be not smudging lol so once I find a few I’ll def make a video!!❤️

[@swiftiepharbz]

@ i’d be happy to send you the amazon links! can i ask if you’re based in the US or canada?

[@katecartermakeup]

@ I’m in the US!

[@ridahbilal263]

Which one is best Maybelline skyhigh or fullfan effect?

[@katecartermakeup]

Maybelline sky high is the best drugstore mascara I’ve personally ever tried!

[@ridahbilal263]

@ thank you 😊

[@jooyyce]

Hi Kate can u try the great lash waterproof mascara❤❤ i know u tried the original one but maybe the waterproof will be better??

[@katecartermakeup]

Yes!! Great idea I think I’ll do a comparison between the washable and waterproof versions