(ENG sub)[예능연구소 직캠] 에스파 1위 직캠 'Savage' (aespa No.1 Encore FanCam) @Show!MusicCore 211016

[@byuntaeyeonnie4251]

everyone is rewatching aespa's encore. the standard.

[@itsmarklee_lover]

Fact ..

[@08_birgittadiolitamandaria56]

... i feel attacked😭

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

Yup

[@btsismyoxyjin2013]

@@08_birgittadiolitamandaria56 why??

[@chaeberry3903]

yes

[@새싹뿅뿅]

이래서 데뷔를 했구나…… 아니 이래야 스엠에서 데뷔할수 있겠구나……너무 잘해서 신기………

[@yunheeflower5191]

에스파 미모와 재능의 정의~♥

[@overvieweffect]

부족해도 데뷔한 경우가 꽤 있음 ㅋ

[@Taevio96]

I think people don't give Karina and Giselle enough credit, their voices and tone are so good also their stable vocals while doing the adlibs while sounding exactly like the studio ver. is really impresive.

[@aeriuchinaga7233]

All 4 members are stable

[@noanbuenardo1364]

and they support!!!

[@sugar_plum_fairy]

@@noanbuenardo1364 not always.. but yes. They’re obviously phenomenal, especially in the panorama of the kpop scene. They truly stand out even considering past gg in terms of their vocals.

[@Bloomix_winx1]

Lipsync

[@mia-wp8hu]

@@Bloomix_winx1 okay then ??

[@soyeonvsveggies]

THEY SOUND EXACTLY LIKE THE RECORDING

[@lrnc4382]

there's a backtrack obviously

[@minecraftfox8678]

​@@lrnc4382 Lol, but at least the voices and highnotes can be heard. 😂

[@Katarine00]

​@@lrnc4382 Keep barking

[@kpopstertube3563]

The backtrack was actually loud. But all girls pushed through with their louder voice than the backtrack especially Ningning and Winter. 😂

[@meowsnyx]

@@lrnc4382 you can hear them over the bt dont be stupid

[@jy2666]

사람들이 에스파 라이브에 집착하는 거 서치왕 멤버들이 몰랐을리가 없는데 부담감 하나 안 비치고 이렇게 자신만만하게 즐기면서 하는 거 진짜 뽄새난다..

[@hwyh5392]

Lo

[@kiixiak]

왜 데뷔초 닝닝이가 글케 억울해했는지 알겠음 에스파 라이브 해요옹

[@user-pj4ju4su3b]

@@kiixiak 내말이 이제 알겠음 근데 스엠도 웃긴게 ar을 너무 쌔게 넘.. 애들 믿고 좀 안해도 될 것같은디.. 솔까 스엠땜에 더 논란생긴 느낌임

[@user-pj4ju4su3b]

와 근데 진짜 속 시원하다 진짜 블맘때부터 앵콜 ㅈㄴ 기다렸는데 ;; 의심했던 순간들이 ㅈㄴ 짜증남

[@흥입니다]

근데 라이브 보고싶은데 볼데가 없었음..ㅜㅜ 암튼 이렇게라도 봐서 넘나 좋은것...♡

[@minnieegg363]

There is a reason SM is known for their vocals, they are no joke.

[@hakunamatata1994]

FACT!

[@andshesayshesayshesayshefr1722]

periodt

[@mytreasure143]

Agree, I just like secret number but aespa no joke

[@cennssul2513]

What the hell are u talking about. It is purely LIPSYNCED PERFORMANCE. MY GOD...TOO MANY IDIOTS....

[@minnieegg363]

@@cennssul2513 i'm actually dying rn, bro this is an encore they r singing live, i'm sure they lip sync sometimes but this video has live vocals watch mr voice removed for their stages to appease your mind.

[@marinadc7540]

Finally idols who can sing real high notes : vibrato, control, power, everything is perfect, this isn’t just shouting. Aespa is on the next level definitely

[@sooyaself2411]

all sm idols btw

[@marinadc7540]

@@sooyaself2411 say it louder buddy, this is just so true !!

[@sooyaself2411]

@@marinadc7540 as you wish😔 ALL SM IDOLS BTW

[@marinadc7540]

@@sooyaself2411 love it 👍🏻🤩👌🏻

[@youshouldjustacceptthatfac2696]

finally? as if there were none before??????? there's many idol can do that, th?

[@nvnbzzz]

1:58 ningning made me goosebumps omg her highnote slayed the stage

[@lilieb59]

I get goosebumps when NingNing starts singing. And she has such a peculiar way of singing with an accent, I really like this moment.

[@mabelgreciarocha8127]

YEAHHHH AND SHE HAVE A VERSÁTILE VOICE. Sorry my english

[@mansininixo1441]

@@mabelgreciarocha8127 Right.. She has different vocal colors

[@snemkxkd]

요즘 아이돌 걸그룹중에 저렇게 고음 지르는 보컬이 별로 없어서 그런지 사람들이 더 신기해하는거같음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 나도 너무 재밌어서 계속 보는중 ,,

[@maker820]

아 진짜 너무 신기함... 고음만 3번 하는데 잘하니까 너무 재밌음 ㅜㅜㅜ 몇번 보는 건지

[@월월-m8u]

요즘 아이돌에서 고음을 보다니 너무 행복…

[@user.uuwowo]

ㅁ무슨 동방신기 때 보는거같음... 너무잘함

[@tragedy5075]

1:47 윈터->닝닝 이어지는 부분 개죠음

[@박정애-x6k]

Sm은 원래부터 있었음

[@123-j4m]

아니 지젤 랩 라이브 왤케 잘함?.? 에알에 묻히나 안 묻히나 집중하면서 들엇는데 묻히지도 않고 음박 딱딱 맞는거 ㄹㅇ 소름돋앗쑴,,,,,,,,,,,,

[@이종운-p7z]

실력돌들은 다르다 진짜 데뷔 1년도 안될때 욕 먹고 말도 안되는 루머에 덮여 씌여서 고생많았고 수고했어 앞으로 좋은 곡많이 내면서 많은 인기 가로채가자

[@은네모]

다른 멤버들도 완전 기깔나게 잘하지만 이어폰 끼고 들으면 특히 윈터 라이브 목소리가 뚜렷하게 들려서 너무 좋음

[@hyo906]

아니 표정 하나 안변하고 고음을 저렇게 뽑는건 반칙이지;; 노래에 고음 파트가 상당히 많은데 이걸 다 라이브로 하네 대박이다

[@applerose3102]

Winter and Ningning calmly hitting the highnotes live is just so amazing. And I can't help but admire Karina's vocals for completely sounding the same whether it's studio or live version.

[@cuteaspuke]

Giselle too she has singing parts I was very amazed all of them are soooo talented

[@applerose3102]

@@cuteaspuke Yes, Giselle did a good job too on singing her parts.

[@luljk9630]

All four of them are incredibly talented

[@applerose3102]

@@luljk9630 Indeed, they are! :)

[@wonderfulrose477]

That’s…called lip syncing

[@moncheri5370]

You are keep coming here cuz you know this is best encore in 4th gen

[@moncheri5370]

Honestly not just in 4th gen

[@cashmoney8672]

Iconic

[@nurafrinamohdaziz9860]

I'm here after the spicy encore and honestly this is stiil their most iconic one you just keep coming back here

[@1675loof]

Cause it's lipsink lmao

[@sph.angelina]

hi im from 2024 n still amazed with their encore

[@imnameim_ood]

직캠이 뭔가 라이브 더 잘들리는 느낌.. Ar뚫고 나오는 윈터 닝닝 성량에 나 기절...

[@julie_0613]

저도 깜놀..

[@aespagirlsgeneration9897]

aespa rookie monster!!!!! aespa ready to blow up!!!!!

[@파시모늬]

@@ljaehyeon ㅇㅈ 이번엔 거의 가성

[@igs.0102]

Winter being so care-free while belting that high notes perfectly along with Ningning. And the lovely interactions between them and Itzy is gold.

[@사리-z8q]

1:17 Ningning😭

[@emma.b2109]

Winter's vocal range is fkin insane

[@fairyheartfillia3855]

@@emma.b2109 ikrr~

[@Analou13]

@@igs.0102 BRO HOW DID YOU PREDICT ITZYS COMEBACK THATS SUCH A COINCIDENCE THO ITZY JUST HAD A COMEBACK CALLED GOLD 😭 ("ITS LIKE GoOLD")

[@Naeomi-k4l]

Bro had a vision

[@Eunbichan]

윈터 고음 어떻게 저런 평온한 얼굴로 아무렇지도 않게 쭉쭉 올라감? 진짜 이건 유영진이 내린 목소리다.....

[@성이름-c5j6q]

@백구 편하게

[@funcutesexy]

유영진은 신이에요

[@어치-s2l]

They legit the best 4th gen vocalists. And that's on period.💀 The stability in their voice is mind blowing. And Ningning effortlessly hitting those High notes is chef kiss>>>>

[@aqsah14]

They’re standing still….. it’d be worrying if they weren’t stable when not dancing

[@MrRdlv]

Legit best lipsyncers

[@shujinko2944]

Stability has nothing do with vocal skill

[@kpopmaster40]

Lol is ur comment a joke this trash isn’t even live they have pre recorded encore stages😂 I guess having and AI concept means AI vocals! Also this is not their fault visual and and dance are becoming more important than vocal you don’t need to sing to be an idol anymore they just auto tune it that’s now KEP1ER was made KEP1ER is a nine member group with two vocalist that aren’t even very good. But people actually think that this is live so idol become scared to sing live since perfection is now the standard don’t you think it’s weird how now idols voices never crack or sound a little flat or are still smooth even when they jump in choreography. If you don’t believe me just watch the most recent survival shows you’ll see good vocals always come last. Companies are too focused on making their idols plastic perfect and the only reason they care about dance is because you can’t edit that. Not to mention the main vocalists of groups are now the most unpopular and visuals are taking the lead. Even rosé who has a passion for music says she misses trainee days because she got to sing live lots but now she covers music live while she’s meant to be asleep because her company continues to advertising their visual. It’s sad where the industry is going but eventually when the good vocals get too old for this like BoA, Taeyeon, IU and Somi go all will be left is plastic R.I.P real vocals may you rest in piece.

[@rainbowsubs2]

You really wish don't you

[@풍뎅이-t1l]

1:54 닝닝고음 진짜 좋다... 탄탄하고 쭈욱 뻗어나가는 고음 진짜 닝닝 최고

[@wuuuuuuuuuuuuu]

ㅇㅈㅇㅈ

[@뚜루루-g6y]

이렇게 시원하게 지를줄 아는데 평소엔 가성을 많이 쓰는거같아서 아쉬움..

[@됴됴-x9x]

고음부분은 라이브로 들을때 진짜 오진다..

[@성이름-t1n]

@@뚜루루-g6y 가성은 아니고 믹스보이스 쓰는 거에요. 진성은 맞는데 저런 고음으로 계속 노래하면 목도 상하고 에너지 소비도 장난 아닙니다. 그래서 믹스보이스 최대치로 써서 편하게 부르는 거에요. 저렇게 발성을 자유자재로 쓸 수 있다는 거부터 연습량이 상당했을 거라 봐요

[@hAnj1soo]

이어폰으로 들으니까 극락가네.... 에스파 너무 잘한다..!!!

[@yoshiology2.042]

Here before 1k likes.

[@정규원-y3y]

@ㅇㅇ 그래도 라이븐데 저정도면 칭찬할 만 하잖음 에셈이라고 보컬은 무조건 당연해서 칭찬 할 만할 정도는 아니다 뭐 이런 건가

[@연-w9r5k]

@ㅇㅇ 얘는 에스파 영상마다 댓글 복붙하고 다니네 열폭 추해 ㅠㅠ

[@vernonjc1818]

@@정규원-y3y ❗❗❗📢📢📢📣📣📣🌸Hiyyihlights 🌸!!ATTENTION!!!! NEVER STOP VOTING FOR ✨BAHIYYIH✨!!!! WE HAVE TO PROTECT HER RANK AT ALL COSTS....AND NOW THIS IS OUR LAST CHANCE TO PROTECT A WELL DESERVING GIRL'S DREAM WHO HAVE THRIVED THROUGH ALL THESE MONTHS DESPITE THE ENORMOUS HATE TRAIN!!!!! WE MUST PROTECT OUR BABY BAHIYYIH 📣📣📢📢🙌🙌 Please VOte on the UNIVERSE APP....3 DAYS LEFT UNTIL VOTING ARE CLOSED

[@댕댕구리-q7k]

애넨 진짜 발성이 엄청 트여 있는듯. 역시 스엠. 고음에서 불안하거나 음을 힘들게 쥐어짜내거나 앵앵 거리는 사람 이 없음ㅋㅋㅋ

[@yuri6582]

ㅇㅈ

[@eunjukim3917]

ㅇㅈㅇㅈ

[@omori00]

듣기 진짜 편함

[@Lueurx2]

역시 발성맛집 스엠

[@rmm8703]

And that’s how you deliver a flawless encore, BLESS YOU GODSPA

[@이다은-f6r]

진짜 라이브 구멍 하나도 없다. 몇년차 아이돌 안부러운 실력! 최고의 신인 진짜 ㅋㅋㅋ아 벅차오른다

[@user-tl7nv1nh7y]

하도 라이브 타령하길해 궁금해서 검색했는데 존나 잘 부름 ㅋㅋ 이게 라이브가 되나 싶었던 부분도 시원하게 긁어주네

[@bin3455]

윈터는 진짜 저런 귀여운외모면 다른팀이면 걍 입덕몰이멤인데 존나 실력캐 그냥 말도안됨

[@ddbdz713]

이러니 어케 안반해ㅠㅠㅠ

[@cxxn.moomin]

NINGNING & WINTER never fails to shock me. I love Karina's pre-chorus and Giselle's Ad-libs is my favourite.

[@wuhu-dw7ih]

FINALLY FULL ENCORE, they ate this encore thoo

[@JChris21]

Ningning’s vocal is really insane! Effortless queen!

[@abrar2240]

her and winter being one of the best vocal duo ever

[@사리-z8q]

Yes🔥

[@Macarena2300]

@@abrar2240 YAS

[@stopone00]

윈터랑 닝닝 진짜 개잘한다.. 음중 앵콜은 mr이 깔려 나오는데도 생목소리가 다 뚫어버림ㄷㄷ 이어폰으로 들으면 더 잘 들림

[@한-n9r]

they're so good it's scary. reminder that aespa is only a 1 year old group.... but they're this good

[@whatwhat591]

It’s weird because, for example, Little Mix started not knowing each other and didn’t want to be a group, but they connected since the first time they met and they made a really good stages and had really really good vocals since their first appearance in X Factor and it was only a week after they first met. So, it’s weird for me to read this kind of things when there are a lot of great groups that can do this and in a little time. Of course, Æspa is amazing and I am not saying otherwise. I am a MY and I love them so much and I am so happy that they are here and together ❤️

[@kenphan2690]

@@whatwhat591 U are comparing 2 different music industries LOLLL Consider the US-UK, One Direction is the same as Little Mix. But For Kpop Industry, it works differently because a group, which is able to be debuted, needs to pass a lot of tests, exams and training. Also, there is no guarantee that when they debuts, they will become a monster/beast/superstar. Literally, Aespa debut is a BOMB, like Blackpink before.(But to be honest, for me Blackpink went international with their Ddu-du-ddu, since Aespa already went international with their Next Level) But anyway, probably we need to wait for next GG in Gen 4 of YG too. Right now, we already see Gen 4 GG of SM(Aespa), JYP(Itzy); I'm kinda questioning if Blackpink will continue renew their contract with YG this year or not.

[@atthetop2712]

@@whatwhat591 I find your comment a lowkey hate or bitterness or whatsoever towards aespa.

[@whatwhat591]

@@atthetop2712 no, never. I freaking love æspa 😟

[@whatwhat591]

@@kenphan2690 But Little mix didn’t even had a trainee days… sorry, I don’t get your point, you just ended talking about BLACKPINK…

[@obang2389]

트로피를 대표로 한명이 쥐고 있는게 아니고 서로서로 한번씩 쥐고 춤추고 다들 기본적인 배려심도 있는거 같네요 응원해요

[@zz-xc2dr]

그냥 원터가 지 들기 싫어서 일본인한테 넘긴 거 같은데

[@eunjukim3917]

ㄹㅇ

[@eunjukim3917]

@@zz-xc2dr ?아닌데요?

[@eunjukim3917]

@@zz-xc2dr 한일혼혈임

[@슈앙-z7n]

@@zz-xc2dr 말을 왜 그딴식으로 하죠??

[@shakilaileanna5624]

우와... 윈닝의 고음 미쳤다...

[@헤헤-i5w]

역시 에셈 보컬로는 절대 못 깜 거기에다 비주얼까지 완벽한 에스파..

[@우희힁-x5y]

티파는?

[@월월-m8u]

거기다 칼군무 정석

[@이름-g5e4o]

보컬 실력은 좋은거 맞는거같은데 이 영상말고 춤추는 영상들 보면 다들 그냥 입만 벌리고 노래는 안부르는거같음. 아니면 노래를 불러도 그걸 방송에 안보내고 그냥 원곡 보내는거같음. 라이브처럼 안느껴지던데.. 이 영상처럼 생목소리(?)이런게 안느껴짐.

[@SS-me5fh]

@@이름-g5e4o 요새 음방 사전녹음 하거나 라이브 하고 후보정으로 숨 소리 같은 거 지우고 내보내는 경우가 많아서 팬들도 헷갈려 하는 사람 많음 그래서 유스케 나와서 라이브 인증해주는 거 너무 좋고 1등 하고 앵콜 쌩 라이브로 부르는 거 너무 짜릿

[@이서현-b7z]

칼군무는 아니더라​@@월월-m8u

[@mocha8305]

THE FYCKING HIGHNOTES WHEN THEY SANG IT, THEY'RE JUST REALLY CALM AND NOT GRASPING FOR AIR I LOVE IT WHY Y'ALL HATE AESPA???? WHAT IS THE REASON??? FOR ME THIS IS THE BEST GROUP IN THIS GENERATION AND I LIKE THEIR VISUALS AND CONCEPT

[@aestwitzypinkislife4042]

For having 4 members, similarities to other gg, not singing live, the issue with Giselle, toxic fans(they're actually trolls)

[@seulzhan2041]

probably because they're envy of what aespa have HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

[@mysoul1122]

because the loud backtrack was supporting their voice. that is why it sound flawless

[@RunnyBabbits]

​@@mysoul1122 Their high notes overpowered and are much louder than the backtrack. Also, if you watch their bts of Dreams Come True in the recording studio, they don't even look like they're struggling at all, especially Winter and Ning Ning in that song. Even Boa pretty much said that Ning Ning has loud speakers for a voice. They all have great projection.

[@mysoul1122]

@@RunnyBabbits yeah i know bout ningning power high note vocal. but the loud backtrack makes everytime they performing, it sounds same

[@hyunjinkim8981]

와 라이브... 에스파... 대박.. 올해 앵콜 무대 중 전율 돋는 앵콜 무대였음

[@lll3046]

와... 스엠은 스엠이네... 음원까지 틀어놨는데 성량이 걍... 개쩔음 단순히 성량만 좋은 것도 아님 걍 잘해...

[@eunjukim3917]

ㅇㅈㅇㅈ

[@user-uc6df7jd2]

음원을 틀어놨으니깐 성량이 더 크게 들리는거 ㅋㅋ

[@vernonjc1818]

❗❗❗📢📢📢📣📣📣🌸Hiyyihlights 🌸!!ATTENTION!!!! NEVER STOP VOTING FOR ✨BAHIYYIH✨!!!! WE HAVE TO PROTECT HER RANK AT ALL COSTS....AND NOW THIS IS OUR LAST CHANCE TO PROTECT A WELL DESERVING GIRL'S DREAM WHO HAVE THRIVED THROUGH ALL THESE MONTHS DESPITE THE ENORMOUS HATE TRAIN!!!!! WE MUST PROTECT OUR BABY BAHIYYIH 📣📣📢📢🙌🙌 Please VOte on the UNIVERSE APP....3 DAYS LEFT UNTIL VOTING ARE CLOSED

[@melodies_memoryofexy1006]

SM JJANG

[@애옹애옹애옹애옹애옹]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 음원을 틀어놨는데 저정도로 뚫고 들리는게 대단한거지..

[@이-s5o]

여러분 이어폰 끼고 들으시면 더 대박입니다...

[@norainiibrahim3272]

👍🏻

[@이슬민-i8q]

음향 요샌 이렇게 나오나요? 너무 신기하네요

[@Clara.97]

진짜 라이브 짱!!!

[@박소현-y8y]

@@이슬민-i8q 앵콜을 당일에 올려주던 엠비씨가 하루 뒤에 올린 것을 보니 에스파 실력 논란 때문에 수만리가 애들 목소리 따로따로 좌우 음성으로 해달라고 부탁한거 아닐까요?

[@중지발가락-i8v]

@@박소현-y8y 아주 소설을 쓰세용

[@roperttt_]

Ningning's high notes OMFGGGGGGGGGG.

[@madoskee]

I must admit. Aespa has four strong members who can sing, dance and rap like no others. It's scary because they are extremely steady even when live. Indisputably the best among fellow 4th generation female groups.

[@melisaeds]

they have 8 mmbers actly

[@niki7159]

YES 👌

[@miyaact]

SO TRUEEE

[@hudsonbruno8543]

but we never got to hear them live while dancing to a hard choreo, and i've never seen them in a radio station, ik they're amazing vocalist but SM is hiding them and idk why.

[@wonderfulrose477]

Their rap sections are horrendous and an insult to rap, their dances are incredibly easy, and they’re pitchy on the prechorus parts (the only semi difficult vocal parts).

[@JN-oe6qk]

닝닝 보면 옛날 바다보는 기분임 노래 너무 잘해 ㅠ

[@웅웅-o3f]

닝닝 개자래ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ기요미

[@lienkcirtap7985]

SM is without a doubt has the best idol vocalist. Harmony, adlib and vocalization, and even a bit rap.

[@심정명-b2t]

윈터 진짜 기가막히게 잘하네..

[@user-vv4nk5kq3n]

윈터가 무대 아닌 다른데서 가성으로 불렀던 이유를 알겠네,, 진성으로 부르면 건물 무너질까봐였음 ;; 성량 미침

[@hoatrinh7881]

Haha you so funny 😄

[@h_zii]

ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ막힌 귀 뚫린 기분이에요 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@hyjin126]

아 개웃겨 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@옥소페이트]

ㄹㅇㅋㅋㅋ 땅갈라질까봐 못 부른듯

[@hannah.1]

진짜 엄청 시원하게 부름 ㅜㅜ

[@ndas5480]

Winter and ningning's vocals are on another level

[@Jalmcorp]

They are in… next level 🎶🎶🎶😆

[@laisonme9539]

Their vocals are resonating! They don't even sound like a rookie.

[@soull6714]

Fr

[@airflyer5238]

If im not wrong for music core's encore, the artist are singing with the actual backtrack.. like it's a mixture of the studio recorded vicals and raw vocals! Gonna wait for other music show encore to hear the real raw vocals

[@airflyer5238]

I just know they are gonna slay! Can't wait

[@heypal8222]

@@airflyer5238 when it comes to aespa you guys are never satisfied with anything 😅 always find another excuses

[@03_ie_dimasgalihsaputra3]

the actual backtrack more loud, i hate that

[@sln0782]

I keep coming to this video after a couple of years and still can't believe how ningning is this talented...

[@vadenginyourarea]

Winter and Ningning hitting the high notes is so satisfying yasss girls give us everything!

[@danifromj]

에스엠 연습실에는 천재 양성소 있다는 거 찐이다,,,,,, 트레이닝 하나는 진짜 제대로 시킴

[@eunjukim3917]

ㅇㅈㅇㅈ

[@아유-m1r]

노래 왜이렇게 잘해

[@ghaidaalsh2987]

ورررىىكمههءيتبتذذتءظظزغعً زذانا فاعتالففغ

[@ttyongs6525]

가수니까 ㅎ

[@먕먕이-n7m]

와 닝닝 진성으로 고음 뽑는 거 진짜 미쳤다...

[@Psychic-01tube]

여러분 무려 저게 에스파가 데뷔 후 처음으로 앵콜라이브 하는 거랍니다 ㅠㅠ 진짜 우리 에스파 애들 너무 고생 많았다 앞으로 꽃 같은 광야 길만 걷자!에스파이팅!사랑해! Everyone, that's the first encore live since our debut. Our aespa members worked so hard. Let's only walk on flowery paths!aespa fighting! I love aespa!

[@mariabell8496]

@Bonana J.G nope.

[@유스마]

@Bonana J.G first encore live

[@oranjiblue968]

@Bonana J.G they get their first win with their debut song(black mamba) but it's when their promotion ended so there is no encore stage.And also this the 3rd win of Savage but they rarely attend music shows so this is their first encore.

[@노두훈]

근데 에스파가 그럼 이번에 처음으로 1위한건가요??

[@노두훈]

@심심이 감사합니다

[@yercharmanti]

아니 근데 표정 하나 안 변하고 몸도 막 구부리지도 않고 가만히 서서 되게 쉽게 노래를 불러서 너무 신기하고 대단하고 멋지고 라이브 지린다...

[@vuanh5428]

SM never makes us disappointed at their idols's vocal

[@akariii878]

SM's artist are legends

[@user-YJH0526]

에스파 노래 못한다는 애들이 봐야하는 영상

[@가범-h3d]

가수치곤 못한다. 아이돌 치곤 잘하네

[@jaredtzp7466]

Jaja a quién iba esa indirecta

[@은빛여우-j3k]

에어팟 필수 영상!! 고음이 ar뚫는 쾌감 느낄 수 있음!!!

[@s2yippy]

라이브 자신감 있게 하는거 진짜 발린다...

[@율쓰-g2n]

저리 어려운 노래를 라이브로.... 대단해

[@overvieweffect]

자세히 들어보시면 에이알이 많이 깔려있음 ㅋ 그래도 보컬의 고음은 인상적임..

[@중지발가락-i8v]

@@overvieweffect 미안한데 음중은 원래 에이알 깔음ㅋ

[@overvieweffect]

@@중지발가락-i8v 어찌됐든 백프로 라이브는 아니니까..ㅋ 그냥 그렇다고

[@훟-e4f]

@@overvieweffect 실제로 만나면 만족하려남

[@overvieweffect]

@@훟-e4f 뭔소리야 ㅋ

[@nx2_777]

Just to remind you, don't ever underestimate SM artists vocal abilities because they will always prove you wrong.

[@yookeri5510]

Yes louder please!

[@naotokki699]

!!

[@jknm1777]

2024년..... 갑자기.. 에스파에 빠졌다.. 윈터 닝닝 라이브 대박... 얘네들 이렇게 잘하는 애들이었다는 걸 영상보며 매일 느끼고 있는 중... 와..

[@user-hs8mi3xb8t]

윈깅이 노래 쉽게 다올라가네.. 흔들림이 없어... 성량 미쳤다ㅠㅠ

[@user-uc6df7jd2]

음원을 틀고 부르니깐 흔들림이 없지

[@서현-p2f]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 엠알제거 듣고오세용~

[@성이름-c5j6q]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 성량 커서 에이알 뚫고 잘만 들리는구만,,,

[@user-pf5ns1dm6t]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅂㅅ이 타자만 잘 치누 넌

[@tjrkgus7032]

4:44 이걸 그냥 지를줄은 ㄷ 진짜.미쳣음

[@yes960228]

우리 짱스파 첫 앵콜 라이브도 미쳤잖아❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥❤️‍🔥

[@박예림-k6g]

카리나 첫 1등해서 앵콜 노래 나오는거 신기해 하는것 봐ㅠㅠ 넘 귀욤미ㅠㅜㅡ 닝닝 저게 라이브로 가능 한거였다니…

[@veryveryhappy1]

4명다 춤은 기본에 노래도 잘함 괜히 SM이 아님.

[@mmieki7430]

기냥 음원 아닙니까..? 멤버 전원이 라이브 이렇게까지 완벽한 그룹은 진짜 처음본다ㅠㅠ 특히 윈터 닝닝 고음은 소름 쫙

[@연세밴드걸]

ar깔려있어요

[@성이름-c5j6q]

@@연세밴드걸 우짤래미 깔려도 잘만 들림

[@0lia-h5j]

@@연세밴드걸 깔려도 잘 들리는데ㅋㅋ

[@user-uc6df7jd2]

음원을 깔고 부르니깐 음원같지 ㅋㅋ

[@성이름-c5j6q]

@@user-uc6df7jd2 엠알제거나 쳐듣고와라 인이어 없이 음정 잘맞고 고음도 잘만함

[@aaryeahhh06]

NingNing's vocals??!?!?!?!?!?!?! OMG... I love them all but she really caught my attention

[@fatinibrahim6748]

stan them please don’t be shy hehe

[@aaryeahhh06]

@@fatinibrahim6748 omw learning about them :-)

[@ambryyyy]

SAMEEE

[@pedrovictorsantos6658]

Ningning supremacy 🛐🗣️✨🦋

[@exoshidae801]

I can say Winter is super confident with her vocal

[@callado8359]

all of them should be. they're sm artists after all

[@exoshidae801]

@@callado8359 yesss that's why i love all Sm artists, their vocals win my heart

[@lalisabby4160]

@@callado8359 twice cant relate

[@bexhndz]

@@lalisabby4160 neither can blackpink lmfao

[@emysan3960]

@@bexhndz why you both hating tho? Don't bring anyone down just for your pleasure. That's so toxic from both of you

[@지수-r9p7g]

에스파는 에이알 위에 불러도 목소리 되게 잘 들리는 편이네

[@지수-r9p7g]

@@Psyxho_KalguksuBunny 음중은 다 깔려있옹 ㅋㅋ 타 아이돌에 비해 목소리 훨씬 잘 들려서~

[@weenydol8723]

겨울아...너무 잘한다........ 애들 다 라이브 미쳤네..걍

[@이상한사람아닙니-c9f]

고음 들으면들을수록 미치겠다 진짜

[@somethingwonderfulhappens]

직캠으로 보니까 현장감 더 쩌넹 직접 가서 라이브 보는 느낌 에스파는 무대를 찢는다니까

[@hwyh5392]

Nj

[@sugsyta6961]

And now i know the reason why SM choose ningning as the main vocalist her technique is insane and smooth, her vocal is so stable too damn ningning is so prefect! lucky SM!!😻👌🏻

[@adysyady5527]

Winter and Ningning vocals are AMAZING!! 🔥

[@ningning-oq6yf]

THIS GIRL'S JUST PROVED HOW TALENTED THEY ARE

[@쥬쥬-h6w8g]

SM 보컬 짱짱한 거 누가 몰라 라이브 잘한다

[@공이-x3v]

진짜 보컬 쾌감 쩐다...

[@yumyum9902]

They got so much hate for not singing live and look at them now, they sang live and all of them are such amazing singers, yall keep hating for no reason but Aespa always proving yall wrong

[@채현-t5s]

와 진짜 잘한다 최근 들었던 앵콜 라이브 중에 제일 깔끔해

[@Jobduk-d2l]

아 윈터랑 닝닝이 노래 너무 잘불러..... 잘부를줄 알았지만 성량이 진짜 크구나

[@moonmuk11]

에스파 라이브 진짜 잘한다

[@giwon0000]

아 ㅅㅂ 후보정 했다고 지랄하니까 현장감 있는 버전도 바로 이어서 내버리네 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 여기서 훨씬 더 잘 들림 쩌렁쩌렁하누

[@이지은의고구마찜기가]

앵콜 안뜨니까 망해서 스엠에서 막았다고 ㅈㄹ하고 앵콜무대 뜨니까 후보정해서 직캠 안뜬다고 ㅈㄹ하고 이제 직캠까지 떠버렸으니 다음에는 뭘로 깔지 슬슬 궁금해짐 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@sion511]

아 진짜 겁나 잘하네 잘하니까 자신감이 있는거지 캬

[@richikoko1481]

Did u hear those higth notes?? The vibrato is crazy, this is what u call a higth note , not just push straigth and sounds like shouthing.they all are so good, congrats aespa and aespa fans for ur hard work.

[@abril976]

my eyes are bleeding

[@daisies667]

@@abril976 don't be rude, probably it's not their first language and were trying their best

[@spicybiryani2617]

@@abril976 you need to go to a doctor for that, and a therapist

[@abril976]

@@daisies667 it takes literally seconds to check your spelling and grammar if you’re speaking a language that’s not your mother tongue (not to mention that they’re saying other kpop singers “push straight and sound like shouting” 😭)

[@abril976]

@@spicybiryani2617 thank you for the advice but you’re suffering from literalism 😕

[@oikawaiitoru1949]

still they are singers and they can sing SING. haters keep barking, aespa keep winning

[@phoebe1926]

YASS

[@phoebe1926]

@@inseungwoonamewestan1196 lmao i found a hater keep barking

[@aespasol9577]

@@inseungwoonamewestan1196 wtf HAHAHAAHHA

[@ohwayowayo]

@@inseungwoonamewestan1196 It is live tf

[@laufeyisgood]

@@inseungwoonamewestan1196 it’s an encore 😭

[@이수만이네꽃밭속작은]

역시 자기 가수에 대한 응원의 보답은 실력임

[@솜이-l4h]

와.... 걍 음원이랑 똑같은데 고음이 충격적이다 너무 잘ㅈ부르는데

[@곤약감자구이]

와 여기는 라이브 못하는 사람이 없으니까 듣는 내내 귀호강 하는 기분임 특히 윈터 고음 듣고 광야 다녀옴..

[@aespagirlsgeneration9897]

aespa rookie monster!!!!! aespa ready to blow up!!!!!

[@randomfeat1743]

its not pure live ,lol.I wanted to hear their voices without background vocals.

[@caining5382]

@@randomfeat1743 All encore stages are live

[@크크-k4c]

@@randomfeat1743 너 진짜 귀가 막혀있냐? 1:53 1:58

[@Saphaemg]

@@randomfeat1743 are you deaf lol?

[@여기-k3n]

미친 웰케 잘해……?🫥

[@shivonne]

Winter's vibrato is just amazing

[@oosk4163111]

이어폰으로 들어야 찐이고 에스파 라이브 맛집이네요

[@ChinJung315]

Ningning is crazy… She’s super steady, sounds exactly like the recorded vocal, or even better!!!!

[@louisehan1137]

winter too😍😍

[@caitlynmarg0812]

@@louisehan1137 yesss, they’re both so good. reminds me of seulgi and wendy.

[@ChinJung315]

@@louisehan1137 Yes, this is like a double-main-vocal group. But there are only 4 members, this means half of aespa is main vocal!!!!! The remaining two are also good vocals. I’ve seen Karina singing in Knowing bros, she’s really good in singing as well.

[@orbitcircle6025]

a girl group with actual good technique huhu aespa truly saving 4th gen

[@sieun5459]

even their sub vocalists , karina and giselle have better vocal techniques than other 4th AND 3rd gen main vocalists out there..

[@ivy2267]

@@sieun5459 Like Karina with Rosé both are D+ but Karina is a sub vocalist and Rosé is a main vocalist

[@scorpiooctagen1844]

@@ivy2267 why are you comparing her with the Rose` Rose vocal and note may not be a better technique , her way of singing and voice is so unique

[@ivy2267]

@@scorpiooctagen1844 ok? voice is not everything technique is

[@suewhat]

Coming back for Aespa's vocals especially Ningning's part at the end for the 19th time😩✨

[@Rio-lp1bs]

For me, it happened to be the Nth time

[@sarakimjonghyun4648]

😍

[@aeripsalms9942]

Ikr. She proved that she is the SM's 4th gen Main Vocal periodt

[@kartunanimasi7440]

@@aeripsalms9942 yes

[@jl-ij2ci]

아니 역시 명불허전 SM돌..... . .. . 넷다 이게 라이브로 되네ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅌㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋ 특히 윈터 닝닝 성량 지린다

[@overvieweffect]

이제 씨제이돌임 ㅋ

[@overvieweffect]

@@wwhjww 그냥 레이블이 되는거라...

[@so-youngbae5991]

네 닝닝 가성이요 mr제거보고오세여

[@뇬뇨-g4l]

@@so-youngbae5991 진성으로 내질러야만 잘 부르는거라고 생각하는 사람이 아직도 있네

[@111-t5i2f]

@@user-fx9tb1lr7w 혹시 잘 모르겠어서 그런데 여기서 닝닝이 가성으로 부른 부분이 있나요?

[@Sonar_125]

I know winter is labeled as just lead vocal but for me just like seulgi she is a main vocal material for me. SM was right about winter when they didnt disclose much about her during their debut teasers in 2020. She is an ace. Period. SM please make two main vocalist next time.

[@genalynpelayo6067]

SM must have been seen and tested their vocals and put them in their respective positions in the group. Ngl though winter is an ace.

[@stanme373]

There is no official positions though

[@stella_urfavociel0857]

Aespa already cleared the confusion about position when they check their profile on k-web. when winter saw that they put her as lead vocalist they laugh because according to them there's no official position in aespa.

[@NelleBear]

SM chose their positions for a reason. Ningning is main vocal and nothing Winter stans say will change that. Go cry about it.

[@takenononsense]

@@NelleBear I think you should go watch aespa QnA on 1thek channel. THEY said that they have no certain position. There's no lead vocal, main vocal, sub vocal, main rapper and such. you are welcome

[@katelynns4887]

4:44 this combination of every member singing was perfection.. and the note battle between winter and ning ning 😩😩😩😩

[@saintgold2503]

이렇게 빨리 성장할 수 있는 원동력은 보컬능력인거 같네요. 멤버들 모두 안정적임.

[@zz120-t7q]

닝닝이 그랬지 우리 라이브 잘한다고 드디어 보여 줄 수 있어서 속이 시원하네 ㅠㅠㅠ

[@Nana-lg9dr]

I think winter is one of the best idols in terms of vocals I’ve heard in a long time

[@estebanr1807]

NEXT IU

[@melodym.453]

@@estebanr1807 i prefer winter.

[@ljneztos472]

Absolutely, she doesn't even have to breathe to sing a high note 😍

[@ivy2267]

@jsooooo Ningning is more the Taeyeon of the group since she has a more powerful voice and does the harder parts of the song but Winter still gets highnotes a lot too so she’s like the Tiffany of the group

[@daydream10.18]

@@ivy2267 not really. Winter has better support on her high notes. Tiffany tends to push a lot.

[@hyewlsk]

헉... 역시 닝닝이 진짜 노래 개잘함.....