SHINee, f(x) VS Secret, B.A.P - 샤이니,에프엑스 VS 시크릿, B.A.P, KMF 2012

[@뭉먕뭄야양]

이땐 연말 가요대제전 가요대전 가요대축제 다 볼맛 났음... 막 청팀 백팀으로 나눠서 대결도 하고 그룹끼리 곡 바꿔서 하고 얼마나 재미있었다구...

[@user-yd9sq7jc2i]

ㅇㅈ해여ㅠㅠ

[@이휘-m8j]

그러게요ㅠㅠㅠ그때가 제일 재밌었죠

[@냥냥-b1j]

미스틱화이트..인어공주 개띵곡인데..ㅠㅠ다 들어줬으면 좋겠다..

[@wangx202]

그리고 그때마다 열리는 투기장이 그렇게 재밌었음ㅋㅋ

[@한마음-w9r]

ㅇㅈㅇㅈ진짰ㅇㅈ

[@Nic-g8s]

와진짜 부잣집애들끼리 모여서 겁나 큰 파티연거같다 진짜 에프엑스 샤이니 조합레전드인듯 ㅠㅠ 무대를 다 즐기고있어서 너무 예쁘다

[@임채영-g5h]

어어 하이

[@구피-n6f]

ㄹㅇㅋㅋㅋㅋ sm은 확실히 뭔가 세련되고 고급진 느낌남

[@헬로팬돌이-t9z]

부잣집애들 저러고 놀다 걸리면 재산 못 물려받을거같아용 ㅠ

[@멀바응]

하…또보고싶은 조합 1위ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@DohKyungSoo_Wife_xoxo]

스엠에서 우리엑소벨벳도🤍🧡 저걸 해줬으면 바램이 더 커서 지금 다시 보러 왔슴다😍🥰

[@cy3795]

0:53 무슨 하이틴 영화에서 남사친 여사친끼리 반갑다고 가벼운 스킨쉽 하는 것 같네... 저런 분위기를 무대에서 보니 신기하고 좋당

[@룰루룰라-s4b]

까앍 넘 설레유 ㅠㅠ 특히 웃는 거 ㅠㅠ

[@Rollercoaster18]

와...중2여서 몰랐는데 옛날에는 저런게 가능했구나..ㅎㅎ 요즘하면 진짜 난리나죠..같은 소속사라도

[@hu6500]

양손에두볼 저때도 난리났을건데 저걸 한 애들이 에프엑스랑 샤이니여서 그래요 ㅎㅎ

[@당신을사랑합니다-o1s]

양손에두볼 sm 팬들끼리도 샤이니랑 에프엑스 남매그룹이라고 여겨서 그런 것 같아용

[@눙-t1h]

하 저렇게 사랑스럽게 웃으면서 얼굴 감싸는거 개설레 미쳤나봐

[@킴라팡]

아 진짜 모든 영상에 댓글이 다 왜 이런 거임. n년전 샤이니 보고 싶어서 영상 찾으면 댓글에 다 저렇게 웃는게 예뻤니 어쨋니... 그 둘의 생애가 내내 우울했던 것도 아닌데 설리와 종현의 모든 영상에 그런 댓글 좀 그만 달아요. 둘의 인생이 전부 슬펐던 것처럼 만들지 말란 말이야.

[@지니-y9s5j]

이거 인정 ㅠㅠㅠ

[@알겠어-b3b]

쥰나 비웃김 관심도 없던 것들이 과거 찾아내서 굳이굳이 예뻐보였눈데 몰라서 미안하다느니...이제와서 신경쓰는척 깨어있는척 개역겨움

[@월월-m8u]

ㅇㅈ 진짜 팬이면 이제 거의 그런 소리 잘 안 하는데...우리가 추억 보겠다고 들어왔는데 지들이 지랄이여

[@숨-m7i]

이제와서 챙기는 척 하는 아가들 ㅜ 우쨜꼬

[@JENIN55]

진심 개공감. 찐팬들은 영상 보면서 멋있다...귀엽다...저땐 저랬지ㅎ 이런걸 먼저 표현하지 무슨 여기저기 즐거운 영상에서도 그립다, 보고싶다, 몰라줘서 미안하다 남발 안함 영상마다 10개 이상은 꼭 저런 댓글 있어서 기분 좋게 들어왔다가 기분 다 잡침..

[@vuanhnguyen1898]

Miss this era so much...the time when idols could still touch/interact with each other without netizens bashing them to pieces

[@nurulsyazlynbintimuhammadz8461]

ikr

[@fluidninja96]

+V Ng sorry but this comment isn't true at all.

[@vuanhnguyen1898]

***** Sorry but what do you mean it's not true? Idols were definitely way more free to interact with each other back then...and this is a prime example. Can't think of any young idol groups these days being allowed to act like this...hugging and kissing each other on stage

[@fluidninja96]

V Ng I just disagree. I've been into Korean music for a fair amount of time. There have always been boy/girl stages and interactions between guy/girl idols like this. There might be even more notice towards interactions like this now because of how much internet/technology has grown and started to play a part in the spread of kpop.

[@vuanhnguyen1898]

***** Hmm I've been into Kpop for 7-8 years and I can tell you with certainty that the amount of this kind of interaction has gone down A LOT. A few years ago, boy/girl groups did special stage performances regularly and they displayed a lot of skinship...like Lee Hyori+Big Bang and 2pm+SNSD. But these days, it's rare to see much interaction between boy/girl groups. It's exactly BECAUSE there's so much media/attention that they have to be sooo careful about saesang fans and scandals. But I get what you're saying too ^^

[@me_you_me_you]

0:50 쫀득하고 야물딱진 크리스탈 발음이랑 밀쳐져서 나가 떨어질때 웃으면서 고개 뒤로 젖히는 태민 존나 발림:;; 오늘은 이거다

[@슬로야그거투로바]

후ㅠㅠ

[@새로운계정-z2b]

아 둘ㅇㅣ 넘 잘어울려 이쁘고 잘생긴애 둘이 있으니까 내가 다 행복하다..

[@user-bt6sp8eg3x]

미치겠네...

[@__________________________0101]

나만 그런게 아니구나..ㅜㅜㅜㅜㅜ 보면서 나도모르게 홀려버림..

[@papago325]

후....하...

[@user-d2e2d]

태미니 신났냐 왜케 광대뽕긋 진심웃음인 것만 같고 사랑스럽지...? 팔 방방 돌리는거도 카메라에 인사하는 것도 와방 신난 애기강아지같아서 너무 귀엽다

[@한마음-w9r]

ㅋㅋㅋㅇㅈ

[@fu11xuv36]

0:53 이제 케이팝 무대에서 이런 퍼포먼스를 다시 볼 수 있을까? 보는데 설레고 예쁘고 가슴뛰고 그런다... 샤이니 에프엑스 사랑해

[@마이웨이-b4e]

0:52 ㅅㅂ 존나 하이틴의 정석이다 .. 가요대제전이 이런 분위기일 때가 있었다니 지금은 상상도 못 할 분위기다 진짜 이런거 너무 좋은데 저때처럼 좀 해줬으면 ... 같은 회사 아이돌끼리 콜라보도 좀 하고 ,,

[@리수만-x4r]

@@user-ui1mc9ro4x 존나 좋은데 ㅠㅠ 요즘은 저런 거 안 해서 그런가 더 보고 싶어진디

[@쿼카-t1u]

요즘은 ㄹㅇ아이돌 다 유사연애아니면 안팔려서 저런거하면 여자쪽도 남자쪽도 팬들 대거탈덕함ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ옛날에야 대중성이지... 요즘은 걍 일본애니와 덕후들 현실판해둔느낌

[@이서현-b7z]

ㄹㅇㅋㅋ​@@쿼카-t1u

[@nangmanbutter]

뭔가 스엠 애들끼리 콜라보 하는 거 보면 다른 아이돌들이랑은 다르게 부잣집 애들끼리 공연하는 것 같음...스엠만의 귀티는 진짜 무시 못 한드앙...

[@jejubignose]

yg도요@!

[@pqjbrhdj]

@@나-u4c 제왑은 쪼매..보이그룹 솔까 막 잘된건 아니고 웰메이드 걸그룹 장인이지

[@pqjbrhdj]

@@jejubignose 와지는 개성쩌는 예술학교애들이 예술하면서 노는 것 샅음

[@user-riceee]

뭔가 스엠은 미국 하이틴 부자 학교에 끼많은 친구들이 만든 동아리로 학교축제에 오른 느낌이면 와이지는 부자들이 일년에 한번 모이는 클럽파튀 느낌이랄까유? (실력과는 상관없는 그냥 상상되는 이미지를 적었숩네다)

[@중기유]

얼굴이 상대적으로 잘 생기고, 아니고를 떠나서 다 이목구비가 뚜렷함. 스엠은 진짜 외모적으로 밋밋한 애들이 없음. 그래서 그런듯

[@user-qo2xy8mb1z]

저때는 남자아이돌 무조건 샤이니 여자아이돌 무조건 에프엑스 였어 둘이 남매그룹으로 인기 절정이였지,, 뭐가 그렇게 힘들었을까 두팀 다 5명으로 시작했는데 이제 4명 남았네 모두 행복했으면 좋겠어 서로 의지하면서 우리 곁에 꼭 있어줘 사랑해 얘들아

[@받고두배]

미안한데 그 정돈 아니였어... 물론 둘 다 2012년때 핫하긴 했지만 남돌에선 인피니트 비스트, 여돌에선 티아라랑 씨스타 등 더 쟁쟁한 애들 많았음... 특히 여돌 중 무조건 에프엑스란 말은 진짜 오바고. 아무리 좋아도 과거 왜곡은 ㄴㄴ해

[@user-oq5wq8po1c]

@@받고두배 ㅇㅈ.. 2012년 비스트 인피니트 인기 진짜 많앗는데.. 샤이니 인기도 많앗지만 압도적 1등은 아니엇어용

[@김유진-c9c1m]

무조건이어딧어

[@user-qo2xy8mb1z]

그래 맞아 샤이니 에프엑스가 제일 인기 있었던건 아니야~~ 저때는 아이돌 중에 인기 그냥 그랬던 때야~ 내가 틀렸어 틀려서 미안해 ~~~ 무조건은 없어 ~!

[@버블티녹차]

엥 샤이니 인기 절정이었는데 ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 뭔 소리여 샤이니 비스트 두톱에 인피니트는 코어가 더 많은 느낌 이었는뎈ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@드드-d7u]

스엠은 진짜 스엠상이 존재해서 그런가 다른 그룹인데 느낌이 비슷해 좋다구요 연말무대 콜라보 대환영

[@한마음-w9r]

ㅇㅇ ㅇㅈㅇㅈ

[@User-smartperson]

진짜 개추억이다 이때가 진짜 좋았는데ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 그와중에 태민 개설렌다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ

[@로옹-s1i]

0:55

[@성은-y3p]

여기서 ㅅㄴㅇ 언급하면 안돼는거겠지

[@Dudufjxhs]

@@성은-y3p 여기서 걔를 왜언급해ㅋ

[@버블티녹차]

뭔 언제적 손나은이야 과몰입 망상 ㄴㄴ 제발 좀 둘다 냅둬....

[@Dudufjxhs]

@@오잉-n1i8o 그니까 걔를 왜 언급하냐고ㅋㅋ

[@manonjann5896]

Goddammit, I miss this era where idols could collab without getting bashed by delusional fans SO MUCH.

[@Primevalrules2009]

I'm so with you there!

[@mamatatskhellambam8588]

Me too.

[@amelliadamaiyanti]

Me too

[@arb5759]

And it still happens in 2019...

[@princesspeach6072]

Ikr

[@sussiboobear5083]

Why can't idols still do this these times were so much fun

[@doniafarahmaram6041]

because now there is those "stupid fans " ╥﹏╥

[@creze5126]

+Doniafarah Maram Agree! 😭😭 Missing those days

[@jeonso-e2028]

Doniafarah Maram "stupid fans"?????

[@shineetaemint6548]

Jeon So-E more like immature fans

[@mamatatskhellambam8588]

True.I missed thise old days.😭😭😭😭

[@이해나]

그래 이게 연말무대지 ㅠㅠ 0:50 이때 이태민 이런 능청+오빠 모먼트가 초면이어서 놀랐는데 엉엉 다시 봐도 좋구나 ••

[@Hxmsiiik]

올해는 가요대제전 제발 이런 갬성으로 해주세요 ㅠ 이게 힘들면 그 막 미스틱화이트 이런 거라도 해주세요 가요대제전 요즘 진짜 개노잼

[@ddongyu1128]

내 학창시절 아이돌이 없어서 그런분위기를 만들어도 재미 없을듯,,, 지금 아이돌 전맴버 아는게 하나도 없음 그룹당 한두명씩 알지 아예모르는 그룹도 있고

[@Seobin-e3h]

진짜 갈수록 쌉노잼임...연말느낌 안나고 스케일 쬐끔 크게 음중하는 느낌

[@__sks3284]

미스틱 화이트,,, 대즐링 레드,,, 드라마틱 블ㄹ루 진짜 딱 그때감성

[@o9i-f8k]

죠쓰바ᄅ ㄹㅇ ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 다이나믹 블랙 예스터데이도 개좋다구요 ㅠㅠ

[@seorinnaa]

와 미스틱화이트..ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@gelseymariejamilahescol6544]

I miss this era where shinee and fx are being paired up and this was also the ra where suju and snsd are so close this era was amazing like A M A Z I N G can we go back to this days?:(

[@qualityblood5651]

IKR!! its like the GOLDEN era. i want to go back too :(

[@wuwuwu6083]

The BEST era, nothing now can compare to things back then

[@greengreengreeeeeeen]

이 때 연말 무대들이 진짜 볼 맛 났었음 운동회 같이 청팀 백팀 나눠서 곡 바꿔 부르는 게 그렇게 재미 있었다고 타팬덤이지만 팀이 같아서 타팬인 애들이랑 같이 응원하는 그 기분이 진짜 째졌음

[@user-os3we9xc2x]

클쓰 음색 오진다.. 확 치고 들어오네 이런 선후배 콜라보 무대 개꿀잼이었는데ㅠ 아님 미스틱화이트 같은거나..몇년동안 연말시상식 진짜 노잼인듯 1세대 커버도 너무 우려먹어서 질리고 걍 특집방송같음 이런 특별한 연말 축제같은 느낌이 안남ㅠ 갑분싸 발라드 락 무대도 그만좀 피디가 다 틀딱같아ㅡㅡ

[@한마음-w9r]

ㅇㅈ

[@사라다빵-s2h]

틀딱 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@아이제이-o1k]

괜히 대한민국의 미래가 sm지하에 있다고 농담하는 게 아님. 스엠애들은 아이돌상이 아니라 나중에 연기를 하든 뭘해도 어울릴만한 찐으로 스타상이야.

[@송하영-q4d]

이제 대한민국 미래도 없는듯함.. ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ 엔시티까지가 딱인듯

[@honey_combo]

애스파..

[@lenakim8768]

하지만 이젠....

[@한마음-w9r]

.

[@000000ab22]

응 빅히트로 넘어갔어~

[@Oran9eeee]

1:46 와 첫소절 듣자마자 놀랬네 개잘한다 진짜

[@shawol1202]

f (shinee) is so iconic. I love their dynamics ♡ they did so well

[@mariapiakabakaki2251]

ikr...i ship them so hard

[@everythingisiconicifyoumakeit]

sad fact: performances like this would NEVER happen in today's kpop industry.

[@0.5uc97]

true :(

[@MA-nj1lu]

Yes because all these new kpop fans are crazy as hell

[@luxysamoyed3258]

I think it's depend on how the company create bonding amongst their group and i'm sure wm entertainment and cube is one company that can pulled this kind of interraction amongs their group.

[@heeheenats]

@@luxysamoyed3258 nah 3rd and 4th gen stans are mostly psychos

[@luxysamoyed3258]

Ryzyl Normyth Mangubat pentagon did this with clc and their fans are chill. yes 3rd and 4th gen stans are psycho but fandom and the company also has their part on opposite gender idol interraction

[@rrroo]

I want this f(shinee) collab to happen again at the gayos this year. View and 4 walls mash-up.

[@ziiro6982]

we would lose sanity if that'd happen tho

[@chizdognasunog]

Check out RYUSERALOVE 4walls and view mash up its amazing and it was seen by Amber!!

[@mirauwu4148]

id loose my life if that hapenned

[@tiyaobrien9869]

I'm watching this is 2019 and can't believe that two of the amazing kpop idols have passed away in a space of 6 years. 😭😭 I hope jonghyun and sulli are in a better place. God bless them. 😔😢❤️💔

[@putrihardina4767]

😢😭🌹

[@yasmenramdan9568]

😢😢😢😢😢

[@AiWaWawa]

Miss jonghyun and sulli

[@aerisrzkca]

I still can’t believe jonghyun and sulli are passed away, i missed them so bad 😢

[@shamilbinanam7667]

Sulli is in this video?

[@user-lovezuwon]

근데 진짜 이 시절만의 갬성 무시 못한다,,,미친듯이 그립다 샤이니 에펙 사랑해

[@v_v315]

데뷔초 비에이피네 ㅠ 진짜 한때 정말 많이 사랑하고 많이 울었었는데 그립다

[@dgchvz]

f(SHINee) I need this again. Ugh I wish f(x) could be 5 again for this to happen again. Rapper with rapper, maknae with maknae, visual with visual, main vocal with main vocal, leader with leader TT

[@aufak-live101]

djChives95 I Hate To Say It But. Since Jonghyun Death. This Is Never Gonna Happend Like Ever. Unless Its 4 way collab. Its gonna work

[@mariamohammed8825]

Aufa Live sulli left as well😩

[@boboihishawol8696]

Minho is visual

[@silentluvr]

Ayyy least we can do a 4 on 4 performance :"(

[@aamna321]

penny it hurts 😥

[@vita9589]

to tell the truth, that Rockerteer with Amber's "fly" just slay everything.

[@yamraihamahou]

0:12 Amber's voice really killed me!!

[@nicoleplaysxnebulous2174]

Same

[@janiahfluellen3905]

omg sammmeee

[@elisabethlisa7854]

same 😍

[@ivetheguanolique9152]

Amber is main vocalist

[@nicoleplaysxnebulous2174]

+IVETHE xoxo no shes not shes sub vocalist xD

[@야바위같은세상]

이거 생방으로 보고 내가 좋아하는 사람들이 내가 좋아하는 노래 해주는게 너무 행복해서 소리지르면서 봤었는데. 추억이다... 아직도 에프엑스 샤이니 너무 좋다.

[@LyunAvine]

The era of Kpop where there wasn't much delusional fans

[@hajarmdn4883]

I'm new to kpop. was there really a time where fans weren't so mad about idols from opposit sex interacting? because they're so annoying right now

[@LyunAvine]

+hajar moudni The era in this video was my favorite. Now fans get mad when simple things happen

[@LyunAvine]

+hajar moudni I can't say there were no haters about this vid, but there's a huge difference between the amount of immature fans in that era and this era

[@hajarmdn4883]

Lyun Avine Ooh I see

[@DidaxS]

+Lyun Avine I think is because now there are more fans (and therefore more possibilities of stupid people) and they are younger and less mature

[@user-gp2km6mh8f]

추억이다 옛날 가요대전 갬성...ㅠ 그립네

[@misdeukie4933]

This is heartbreaking to watch, to see their genuine happiness on the stage, now knowing two of them are angels who left too early 💔 rest in peace Sulli & Jonghyun

[@khone8801]

나만 한번씩 추팔 하러 오나 솔직히 물론 지금의 아이돌도 좋지만 한번씩 2015년까지 아이돌 돌아보기함...뭔지는 모르겠는데 그 당시 노래 들으면 괜히 그때의 나 생각나고 마음 아픈일도 있었네 하면서 들으러 옴...다들 흥했으면 행복했으면

[@mimizzangsang]

비에이피 얘기는 없네 내 인생에 반을 너희랑 함께할 수 있어서 영광이었어 아직까지 많이 사랑해

[@정호석-w8t]

저도 BAP좋아했어용!

[@은주-v7c]

저도 B.A.P 좋아해요 지금도💚

[@Shiiwata]

shinee and f(x) have a great teamwork, i hope the whole mess with sulli will come to an end soon so we can see them both perform again

[@pollypan5574]

Don't we all ^.^

[@riri03081999]

What happened ???

[@Shiiwata]

Marie Bahns sulli took a hiatus, almost everyone is blaming her because f(x) promotions got halted and it looks like she is just enjoying her time with her boyfriend etc. SM statement wasn't helpful at all, other think she is depressed or whatever, but nothing is clear right now...so yeah in short SM is a mess this year

[@설-y1j]

샤이니는 아이돌판에서 연하남컨셉 원조임 ㄹㅇ

[@user-ed4es5oy5e]

태초에 유승준님이 계셨습니다만

[@exo10anniversary5]

@@user-ed4es5oy5e 머리 검은 외국아은 빼

[@아이고내가이런사람은]

스엠상은 진짜 얼굴만 이쁘고 잘생긴게 아님... ㄹㅇ 스엠이 추구하는 분위기가 있음.. 딱 스타성있는 상

[@chloekingomg]

This was 3 years ago what the fuck When did I grow up? When did they grow up? What have I done with my life??? Where tf did the time go?!?!

[@dreaaaaaa_]

Ikr

[@chappyllama4445]

lol ikr

[@peylfries1920]

I feel you

[@sundaekyo6535]

The performance is from 2012, not 2013, but still: I miss those interactions, B.A.P's blond era, SECRET as 4 and F(x) as 5 ;.; PS: 9 years of SHINee ❤

[@nahomicervantes3181]

PenguinChloe I feel you x2

[@pristinefujimaki4174]

All the same positions are paired up together key and sulli (visuals) Luna and jonghyun (main vocalist) Minho and Amber (rapper) taemin and Krystal (maknae) onew and Victoria (leader)

[@MsYayMusic]

Pristine Fujimaki I thought the visual was Minho.

[@aliciarivers2235]

Pooh Bear he is lol.

[@blackblue0613]

Alicia Rivers everyone in shinee are visuals

[@shanadeize]

+blackblue0613 of course

[@pristinefujimaki4174]

Pooh Bear he's not he is the rapper

[@기년스]

왜 우리 밥돌이 애들 얘기는 없셔 ..... 그래도 우리 탑급 아이돌이었는데 .... 보고싶다 진짜 그리워

[@한마음-w9r]

ㅇㅈ

[@4llforus]

아 샤이니 에프엑스 조합 국룰이지........... 슈주 소시 & 샤이니 에프엑스 조합 너무 좋아함 얘들아 사랑한다아악

[@arizadnielle2270]

It's the first time i heard Amber sing and i was like "Woooooooah, i love her voice" she always rap in their songs, i prefer her singing than rapping.

[@sia-chan6374]

Omg...Bang Yong Guk...so cute. He didn't even touch her. At the end when he went backwards...omo. He is such a gentleman.

[@chris-rq2le]

"I like the blonde one from B.A.P" :D

[@itaintmeitsu]

Chrisalis Tangputri hahahahahaha

[@mariamohammed8825]

That's maknae Zelo!! Bias

[@onlytheflowerknow]

Chrisalis Tangputri ikrr hes so hot the blonde one is hotter than the blonde one

[@chris-rq2le]

Asli Rubin Oh my god, I know rightttttt xD What am I doing x"D

[@caryn2064]

+MariaAira “Ro” Amamiyah the point is that they're all blonde duh

[@user-bt6sp8eg3x]

샤이니 에프엑스 콜라보 개조음ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 존잘 존예들ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 스엠 고맙다!

[@shawol_love3217]

People it just doesn't get better than F(SHINee)...it's called having fun!

[@SHAYandBECKYinc]

Shawol_love Lmao F(SHINee) is soo damn hilarious when youve taken as many math classes as me XD

[@essennagerry]

SHAYandBECKYinc Ahahahahaha! The way SHINee function... makes the F(myheart) curve... I really hopes this sounds just as good in English as in my native... xD

[@SHAYandBECKYinc]

lmaoo i get it for the most part. Whats your native language?

[@essennagerry]

SHAYandBECKYinc Bulgarian. But I learned that material in German... :D And btw "hopes" was a typo. :D

[@delawarqaidy5753]

essennagerry me too

[@maryemerald9907]

Funny how a lot of fans ship Taemin with Krystal but then she ended up dating Taem's bestfriend,Kai HAHA! #RIPTaeStalShippers

[@nope4528]

+Mary Emerald Lazaga omg ikr.. what a twist.

[@amnakakakhel1181]

WHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAT

[@lynnalexandre9640]

she dated taemin tho......

[@amnakakakhel1181]

+Nadia Magdalena yes she was in drama with Taemin in which they were acting that they were dating

[@amnakakakhel1181]

+Nadia Magdalena actually they were acting that they are in a realationship

[@elvennss]

I love B.A.P but Shinee and F(x) just killed it there!!!

[@Blue-xu7sp]

새삼 진짜 크리스탈 목소리ㅠ

[@faeriechild75]

I really don't see anything to compare here. SM showcased vocals and TS showcased dancing. They ALL did an awesome job!!!

[@faeriechild75]

Oh yeah, and I was impressed with Amber's vocals. I hadn't heard much of singing before.

[@amywinx4648]

Amber always sings well~ ^^ I'm lot more surprised at Minho~ i hope it's really live >

[@sschiavone496]

Amy Winx haha of course its live Minho has such a beautiful voice it's just really quiet compared to other SHINee vocals due to only rapping in their songs he couldn't really learn how to sing loud since he focused on the rap

[@amywinx4648]

This I know. I hope he could sing more in the future. I think I can see the progress in EVERYBODY ;))

[@sschiavone496]

well I still think that Minho didn't get enought parts but I love the album anyway ^.^

[@yxwvda]

i like the fact that they paired in same thing like jonghyun and luna as main vocal, taemin and krystal as maknae, minho and amber as main rapper, onew and victoria as oldest member, and key and sulli as lead rapper.

[@dianislamiati1316]

How taemin can be so brave kiss krystal on the stage 😂

[@faitheden300]

Because fans of this era are not psychopaths 😂

[@teru5830]

Also, i’ve always seen them as a brother-sister group. For me it’s like Taemin’s kissing a younger sister 😂 (aside from having a non toxic kpop community back then)

[@teru5830]

I really miss this sibling group so much. I’ve always wanted to see them succeed at the same time because that seems natural to me. They compliment each other, even their music style. They’re like the boy/girl version of each other and they interact so naturally. But they did f(x) dirty. They could’ve continued promoting them as siblings group you know 😔 I wish they’re still complete.

[@ghaveeni7202]

They're bestfriend afterall 💕

[@faitheden300]

@@Rctm2003 omg you're right !! But i enjoyed watching taemin and naeun .. they look cute together

[@멀바응]

레전드 공주들왕자들 모임같아 무슨ㅠㅠㅠ 고급짐 그냥 이태민머냐진짜 설레미치겤ㅅ네 어울려 또 ….

[@artzala131]

I miss all these groups. The fact that all the four groups suffered so much makes me sad, however this video makes me appreciate the happy times too.

[@user-zcjdjksojqu]

슈주+소시 샤이니+에프엑스 sm국룰조합

[@00OO_00OO]

ㅇㅈ

[@백현알통L]

HOT+SES 티아라+엑소도 포함

[@이제노는거지]

@@백현알통L 티아라? 걔네는 에셈이 아니잖아

[@백현알통L]

@@이제노는거지 소연이 에셈어었어요

[@백현알통L]

@@이제노는거지 국룰조합은 맞죠

[@Pinkrevenge101]

I loved Amber and Minho's voices hope they'll do more collabs f(SHINee)

[@ajinmericancitizen8723]

Dude if 4th and 5th gen weren't so afraid of rumors we'd have more collabs like this

[@s4pphirecat292]

Minho's high notes.. GOD - and key and taemin.. those kisses... JESUS -

[@pebbles1101]

I seriously just, FAINTED looking at them kiss those girls, but i consider them as family for SHINee, i mean, they are right?

[@s4pphirecat292]

of course!

[@nickelleismert4154]

Wow. Amber's voice is beautiful! SM needs to let her sing more. I mean, she's a great rapper, but her voice is gorgeous. And Jjong looked so hot

[@justmaebee]

UGH AMBER NEEDS TO SING MOAR.

[@marshmellowcake2]

+saraloves tae i think that amber should be the lead vocalist cause I think get voice is stronger than Krystal's but I don't really care about positions

[@gongbaeelephant]

약간 bap 각 반 양아치들이 맨날 땡땡이 치고 학교 탈출하는거 보면서 대체 쟤네들은 뭘 하길래 맨날 땡땡이 치나 뭐 술이라도 마시나? 생각했는데 알고보니 지들이 ㅈㄴ 건전하게 춤추고 랩하면서 노는 얘들같음....결론은 사랑한다고

[@은주-v7c]

저도 아직까지 사랑해요ㅠ9년째 못멈추고있어요!

[@Yorbelize]

They need to give Amber more singing roles, I knew she had a good voice but wow her voice is amazing

[@서랑민]

난 다른 소속사는 돈 주고도 못 사는 넘사 스엠만의 분위기와 친목이 너무 좋음ㅜ 그래서 내가 스엠해ㅠ

[@nethu6577]

So there was a time when idols of opposite genders could interact, touch, hug...no pschyco fans controlling their idols like puppets. Wish we could bring this back...the internet would explode with good music if artists collab

[@heeheenats]

This is kpop's golden era fans now are psychos

[@nethu6577]

@@heeheenats yep, Even kn 2016 when I started listening, there were many interactions. But now smh

[@heeheenats]

@@nethu6577 i think that was the time interactions slowly decreased. 2016 2017 until now we barely see them unless it's on a variety show

[@tokismth319]

please don't think that this era was special people are ignoring that the girls still got death threats for these collabs. Just because I-fans were calm doesn't mean that was the norm whatsoever. Companies just didn't care as much about idols receiving death threats for being on stage with opposite-sex groups/collabing with them because as long as they brought in money it didn't matter. I-fan's (and even then this only applies to some I-fans) being pretty chill about this didn't reflect the reality of what these idols were facing in Korea/Asia.

[@nethu6577]

@@tokismth319 I i DINT KNOW...I mean that shouldnt happen..normalise male-female idol interaction honestly

[@S.A.A.00]

I miss this time Idols chemisty together No toxic cyberbullying No many psycho fans Two angels were happy here 💔💔 Rip sulli rip jonghyun

[@AyaYasmin]

OMG DAT AMBER AND MINHO DUET KILLED ME

[@이예원-x5e]

쫑 보고 싶다ㅠㅠㅠㅠ이거 생방송으로 챙겨볼 때 진짜 좋았는데ㅠㅠ...잘지냈으면 좋겠어요 정말

[@katelinvidal9913]

I bet no one in the 3rd and 4th Gen could do this. Like how Taemin kissed Krystal at the top of her head. 2nd Gen idols will always be the best! 3rd and 4th Gen fans are so sensitive when it comes to their idols.

[@Ajhpanpan]

True

[@yeizebaamgames4579]

True

[@yeizebaamgames4579]

@Nia me too. They too toxic

[@bachizai]

ikr

[@beatrizsampaioaucelio8704]

TRUE ! But... remember how some fans treated Naeun when she was with Taemin WGM in 2013 too ... but I’m glad the psychopaths fanatics fans didn’t came here ... !

[@pau4315]

I don't know what I miss more, this type of collabs or the groups themselves. But to be honest it's really both. Miss you most Sulli and Jonghyun, you won't be forgotten.

[@123afridah]

SHINee and F(x)= WINNERS

[@mindream1701]

Amber has a beautiful voice ^^ I love it

[@Jasmine18601]

Indeed, her voice is amazing !

[@ghadasyrine7341]

Zaynab Jasmine yes

[@demakclaudia7360]

*_^

[@올라잇-z2s4y]

진짜 이해할 수 없는 알고리즘 ,,

[@moonlover6782]

이태민 웃는 거 너무 예쁜 거 아냐..? 그리고 수정이는 목소리가 너무 보석임 ㅠ

[@parkshi8175]

Woah amber's voice... I did not know she can sing

[@nooptopia]

park shi check beautiful by amber

[@kede849]

She actually auditioned and got into SM by singing :)

[@apurplegoldfish]

Its sm dude everyone cas sing

[@caronce9280]

I miss this era 😭😭 GHAAD 😭😭 WHEN WILL OTHER IDOLS CAN COLLAB AGAIN LIKE THIS WITHOUT GETTING BASHED?! 😭😭💔

[@unknownanonymous_]

I miss these kind of collabs where girlgroups and boygroups get to perform together without getting any hate from stupid possessive fans. They look happy and are having fun. But now, just standing 3m away from each other on the same stage and people are like "OMG THEYRE DATING BEHIND OUR BACKS" "UGH I SHIP THEM SO HARD MAKE BABIES PLS" "THAT SLUT HAVE THE NERVE TO TOUCH MY OPPA" "BITCH I'LL SLAUGHTER U I HOPE U DIE" "STAY AWAY FROM MY OPPAS!!11111!!". I just cant with stupid immature netizens and fans these days can't we all just chill and enjoy collaborations from girlgroups and boygroups without starting scandal rumours and shipping?

[@rarasatiprameswarimanoto1634]

Tbvh.. i guess f(shinee) will never get bashed😂

[@unknownanonymous_]

***** boygroups who collab with with f(x) will never get bash bc queens 😏

[@fateeeeeeeeema]

Preach

[@unknownanonymous_]

***** all of them are immature delulu idots who think they can date their oppars or their oppas have to be with another oppa lol

[@ashellie]

F(x) is suppose to be SHINee sister group but I hate how f(x) is SOOOO UNDERRATED

[@ssyeinah]

This actually makes me so sad, the fact that nowadays an idol could literally just hold the arm of another idol for one second and people get mad... but everyone was so chill and happy about this, like Taemin even kissed Krystal. It was so fun, seriously, why can't idols do this anymore... netizens istg

[@Emma-fw9nt]

Though I like B.A.P and Secret more I have to say that SHINee's and F(x)'s performance was better (or I think) It was awesome!

[@Richa_]

omg,, taemin kissed his best friend's girlfriend!!

[@whdld]

i thought i was the only one😏😏🤔

[@l0uderthanbombs]

hahaha first taemin 😁

[@areyoukirringmeirriyaa]

lol

[@teetitabuariki1297]

+xx zoiee of course u are the only one...fighting 🙌🙌🙌

[@EmbracedAngel]

lol In 2012.

[@sofeels_]

This will forever be one of my fav collab stages in kpop

[@lets_kkikki_3]

와이거 생방송으로보면서 태민이랑 크리스탈 개설렜는데ㅅㅂㅅㅂ개추억

[@onehundred1302]

2020 and i'm here Rest in heaven Jonghyun and Suli I miss you f(x) and Shinee

[@user-pw6zi6yd2y]

아 추억ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 샤이니랑 에프엑스 이 무대 진짜 좋아했는데 오랜만에 보니까 좋다

[@jessedaniels5849]

This is when Secret had been in a car crash so they couldn't do they're best because they were still recovering from the accident.

[@MV-vw1jf]

I'm sorry for the late response and all but that still doesn't put off from the fact that they were really bad.

[@jessedaniels5849]

Ellie James Kinda makes sense because Jieun and Sunhwa are not dancers, if Hana was there they would have killed it ^-^ At least Hyosung did good as usual xD

[@KYO1997]

와 이무대 진짜 식상하지도않고 좋은것같음.. 키 무대진짜 잘한다 👏🏻이제 이런 여유있고 재밌는 무대는 없는거냐 ㅜ

[@시현-h4m]

혹시 키 어딨는지 탐라좀 찍어주실 수 있나요?ㅠ 못찾겠어서ㅠㅠ

[@KYO1997]

@@시현-h4m 0:46 🔥🔥🔥

[@시현-h4m]

@@KYO1997 감사합니당 김기범 역싀..👍

[@jingletaem]

shinee and f(x) is always my favourite combination 😍 and can i just say that onew and jjong fucking owned the stage?

[@infinitely9998]

you guys gotta admit SMFAMILY OWNED IT

[@memescrayfish9632]

Seeing Sulli and Jonghyun makes my heart break😭. I miss them

[@hongariacunha8985]

I'm too

[@n0un0ursTube]

me too 🥺

[@alya8887]

Im telling you.. SM artists are different! SNSD,SHINEE,F(X) AND SUJU. they are like the best of the best

[@alya8887]

And from the same generation .. BIG BANG , 2PM, BEAST AND THE REST... 2ND GENERATION ARE THE BEST😭😭😭

[@mintaeek3549]

when u dont know bap so ur lik: I like that dude with the blonde hair! ...

[@gamer_girl99_]

+Llama.Is.Sweg xD

[@susybriones6167]

+D.O IS MY BAE OKAY hola .como estas

[@xkodochax1]

+Llama.Is.Sweg until u saw that all the bap members has blonde hair or close to blonde shade LOL

[@shanzfendi]

me too LOL

[@auanor9236]

واو جدا حل

[@jenniferjung8549]

... B.A.P and Secret all the way... But why is there so much hate for Secret... They danced really freaken good...

[@AutumnRiver23]

If you don't know anything pls, don't say that coz secret had a car accident

[@KpopTsentBapsecret]

Hana had a car accident and that's why she is not in most performances

[@Enoislex]

Alyssa Nguyen Well they all were in the car accident, just Hana was the one most severely injured, but I understand what you meant lol

[@빙빙-p5i]

이때 가요대전, 연말 시상식 진짜 재밌었는데... 주작도 있었는진 모르겠지만 확실한 건 지금보단 덜했고, 상 몰아주기도 없고, 쟁쟁한 아이돌 그룹도 많고 콜라보 무대도 많아서 진짜 좋았음 ㅠㅠ

[@clowncity8259]

coming back to this after 8 years unlocked some crazy childhood memories. back then this f(x) and SHINee's collab was literally everything for me... seing this now is just something else. those were the good times... fans were supportive and logical with their idols... now its a bundle of koreaboos, delulu solo stans and unreasonable fanwars... the music definitely got better, but the fans just got worse and toxic. new stans can come for me all they want, i stated facts.

[@IAM-yj6xr]

B.A.P golden years (2012-2014). Ahh time like this should restart again 😭

[@serendipiasubs4731]

A Guy Oh yes please 😭😭

[@gunesyerindeherseyyolunda9212]

Yeah :(

[@파도-l6e]

영상에 나오는 팀들 모두 다시 완전체 무대는 보기 힘들겠지만.. 그대들이 내 추억의 전부였다.. 비에이피 사랑해ㅜ

[@슴덕-s3z]

저렇게 사람들 모여서 찐으로 즐거워하는 거 보니까 너무 부럽다 ㅠㅠ 그리워질 줄 몰랐던 일상..

[@xtm3490]

0:11 and 0:21 showcases how much of an amazing vocalist amber is. her voice has such a distinct color, no wonder she was casted to sm because of her vocals.