【TVPP】f(x) - Collaboration stage with SHINEE, 에프엑스 - 샤이니와 합동 무대 @ 2012 KMF

[@sarahjanegargarlaurie6098]

To think that we lost this 2 Angels.

[@anjalilama4796]

It's so sad

[@fredy7620]

I never thought that would happen when I watched this in my childhood

[@JJboy4Flower]

Hahahah

[@wiki0325]

@@JJboy4Flower not very funny, is it?

[@nithishanithi8712]

@@JJboy4Flower what the hell is wrong with you??

[@Maximusprime24]

I miss the days when companies had male and female counterpart groups: SHINee and f(x), Super Junior and Girls' Generation, BigBang and 2NE1. There was a real brother and sister bond between the groups and they were allowed to be friendly and close with each other without rumors of them dating or whatever.

[@nostalgia7465]

aside from hybe, everyone debuts too far apart now to even have a bond...

[@UrfavoriteOA]

Alongside sexual allegations, yeah

[@nisrina_nazihah]

I can’t watch this performance without crying over the two Angels that we lost. RIP Sulli and Jonghyun

[@zinccross9306]

Its so fucking sad😪

[@edenpffen]

and i can’t watch any performance without an idiot bringing up things that have nothing to do with it

[@ruse128]

@@edenpffen exactly. There's always someone waiting to make a happy video gloomy for no reason!

[@1106wu]

@@edenpffen i remember when i praised jinri and you dragged me for it just bc i added a “:(“ emoticon 😭💀

[@hdypynitgof]

I miss these collabs. Shinee with f(x), Suju with snsd, etc... (now even a single glance of a male idol to a female idol triggers a war 😒) but most of all, I miss Jonghyun. 😞

[@Lyf4rMusic]

It all started with BTS and EXO's teenage fans who can't control their Ovaries for their Idols and make them explode in jealousy every time they even see at another idol :/

[@rizkasr1928]

Ikr.. In my opinion, second gen group interactions are the best...

[@叶俊伟]

And now i miss sulli and jonghyun

[@harinjung1917]

back when THE CAMERA MEN WAS SANE AND THE LIGHTING WAS OKAY

[@KpopTrashSince]

HaRi Jung back when boy and girl Idols could interact with each others without getting hate..

[@sittiinastasia5430]

omg trueeee

[@mileycyrus201198]

so true

[@khelenadevisukham]

It's so true.

[@forgetfulstranger]

bwahahahaa omg this is true

[@J66-k1b]

종현아 설리야 행복해

[@wendys1733]

SHINee's Noona is Victoria Onew and Luna being duet buddies Jonghyun and Amber being "twins" Key and Sulli being friends since trainee days, Key and Amber english dudes Minho and Sulli in TTBY Taemin and Krystal in one day date in High Kick f(SHINee)

[@glizzie0731]

wendeopeul don't forget that TAEMIN dated sulli in the trainee days

[@fatyyyyall1663]

And Minho & Amber Llama song

[@zheycas364]

Minji Lee really?

[@trishacastor6784]

Minji lee, really? Omgggg

[@tiaralee1693]

Indrie Anggrainy no like wtf with this rumour. No guys no... Like seriously NO

[@imthebiggesthitfansofsnsda9289]

Back then kpop was relax, no hate, hmmm miss the those days~~~~

[@samsungradwa8414]

ILOVEyoN

[@khelenadevisukham]

Me too.

[@azyy6482]

IKR😭😭😭

[@jsshdyg1301]

Relaxed? Yeah sure... Idols getting poisoned by "fans" sure is relaxing

[@getem7640]

Um no, even in this era Sulli was being heavily bullied

[@noelles.9253]

Everything about this is amazing Amber + Minho’s swag Lovable maknaes Krystal + Taemin Infectious energy from Sulli + Key.. Sulli’s bright smile.. Jonghyun + Luna’s amazing voices.. And when our leaders Vic + Onew came out I was starstruck It’s so bittersweet to watch this now but I hope we always remember them having fun like this Jonghyun and Sulli you are dearly missed ❤️

[@ellenfreitas4806]

Sulli and Jonghyun, two angels 😇💞. Good moments 😭💔

[@alypuglover5]

I never thought I would come back and watch this in remembrance of Jonghyun and Sulli I still can’t believe that this is real life I miss both of them Both such talented and wonderful angels Rest In Peace

[@nuruladlin5951]

N HXJXJ JXH NNX NJC JHD NFJC JC MJD. 🍻🍺🍹😘😍😎😙😚😊NX NX NC NC NX NNDCHC TS NS

[@malihachhoa9508]

Leaders : Onew X Victoria Vocals: Jonghyun X luna Rapper: Minho X Amber Visual : Key X Sulli Maknae: Taemin X Krystal Sucha perfect combinatio! Miss them together

[@caprisunlover4732]

Thank you

[@dubudibidibs8119]

Bring back the old good days please😭😭😭 when Sulli was still a member of F(x) and we still have Jonghyun i still can't accept the fact that he's gone💔

[@fightfannerd2078]

i'm still made about it i can't watch any videos with him in it

[@shootie2967]

Sulli 😭😭😭😭😭😭

[@nourai2954]

Sulli’s gone too

[@nadaranadia_]

Sulli also gone 😔

[@fijardim7]

;( poor angels

[@kisekigaarimasu]

I'm shocked to see Korean hosts amazed at Amber's vocals. I mean even Kangin was surprised in AS4U once, and they're labelmates, for crying out loud. This collab stage was early enough in their career for people to see that Amber killed that Rocketeer vocal.

[@mrjun3743]

amber's voice is so perfect. And Krystal and Taemin.....OMG, they so cute, i ship them

[@wonjiw0000nie]

I miss the old moments of Kpop When f(shinee) and super generation everywhere haha.. Kpop seems kinda boring nowadays, so many fanwar now

[@rafaeladural785]

the way onew holds Victoria's hand..... honestly ship them a little but okay can someone hold my hand as gentle as he does

[@Queen0192-h1e]

Rafaela Dural keke because Vic is Shinee's noona.... noona nomo yepeo!!!!!!! hahagagaga

[@constanzamm1678]

I'm gonna miss this SO MUCH. These 10 were the perfect combo, I swear.

[@randomjenn5004]

SAAMMEE. :(

[@TheMgp99]

Constanza Oh yes

[@caronce9280]

Ikr 😭😭😭

[@Lyf4rMusic]

Now it's even more sad... :( Jonghyun R.I.P !!!!

[@btstrasharmyexo-lbaekiesha2776]

And now it’s even MORE sad😔RIP Sulli too

[@yareosh]

THIS IS THE MOST BEAUTIFUL THING IVE WATCHED IN A WHILE

[@joannang8521]

hm didn't see you the last time I watched this though

[@krystaluvs3596]

the good old days and minho pouring out all his swag and the maknaes being so flirty flirty aaaahhh f(shinee)

[@nuruladlin5951]

NHC NX NXC JD JC JF JD JF JFJX ND. 😘😍😎😙😚😊🍻🍺🍹 NS J JX ND NX JX NN. NDNX NHTD NF

[@cnrhwhdnx4014]

2024에도 보러왔어요 이때가 진짜 티비보는재미가 있었는데 그립다

[@sourcandy9709]

I’ve never thought that i would cry while watching my fav f(shinee) video... YOU DID VERY WELL KIM JONGHYUN MAY YOUR SOUL REST IN PEACE...you’ll always be missed u and ur great voice thank u for all good memories goodbye

[@whatchadoin6070]

And now, it's Sulli

[@happyka4977]

We will never see this kind of collaboration again. 💔

[@turkey12345]

2:35 가사가 look into my eyes and i’ll own you인데 온유가 자기 이름이랑 발음 똑같다고 신나서 own you~! 부름ㅋㅋㅋ

[@anonymous3905]

Did someone give Taemin an energy drink or something before the show started? He looked sooo hyper during the entire thing, especially the ending. Lolz ^_^

[@LilianaVonK]

I was sitting here thinking, "Okay, who gave the maknae sugar?" :)

[@cellomozchaa]

Back then when they could do something like this and the fans were actually got excited and both fandom also felt like siblings to each other. No fan war. No bashings.

[@mochialessia]

Minho is so fucking underrated

[@ocean6825]

Alessia Ceccarelli IKR AND SOMETIMES ONEW

[@debbie.c]

I really like how they paired them together based on their roles in the group. :D

[@pinguflap]

Taemin seems happy there. lol. Love Onew's voice!

[@elizabethle2237]

jinki literally murders me in this performance it doesn't matter where i am or what time of day I will always be slain by his entrance

[@real_lampcap]

These were the days of kpop. Seeing Sulli and Jonghyun hurts my heart so much.

[@sunithabhasker3397]

Anyone else here in 2017 who miss the old days 😣😭😣 (Even jonghyun was there with us)😢 R.I.P jonghyun oppa ❤⚘🌹

[@zheycas364]

sunitha bhasker me :(

[@emilanapanus6828]

Rip sulli too

[@fyeqian8673]

SM sibling group. Truly missed them like this, carefree and happy

[@trishaann2497]

F(shinee) is the best😍😍😍

[@aira738]

SHINee 'BOY' and SHINee 'GIRL', i love'd them so much combination. especially, Jonghyun with Luna and Jinki (Onew) with Victoria.

[@ParichRon]

0:01 Rocketeer 0:41 My First Kiss

[@Nada-zd1ve]

Now I cry to my favorite video of them or last when all them together 💔

[@evangeline6074]

This is such a precious memory for Shinee and F(x) fans. Jonghyun and Sulli, rest in peace my two angels :(

[@SaraDaisyHerrera]

f(SHINee) i will never forget you❤❤

[@vacayvlogs4587]

Amber and Minho’s vocals tho… I am deceased. Bye

[@TheMadlyMady]

Amber is just... Ugh so hot and perfect!

[@lindamartinez3838]

SHINee & F(X) hmm I love them also Super Junior & SNSD & from YG BigBang & 2NE1

[@greteltan8386]

KRYSTAL AND TAEMIN KISSED

[@szein8251]

Jonghyun😭😭😭

[@bo301095]

2 groups... from the same agency... debuted almost right after each other... have the same number of members... and also lost 1 member with the same depression issue :( Jonghyun hyung, Sulli noona you all have done your best.

[@kid-ava]

2nd gen seems like it was such a fun time for kpop. even though I was just a little ass girl then, I kinda wish I was into kpop at that time so I could witness it lol

[@davestridr]

same if only i was born a little earlier 😣 we dont get silly collab stages like this anymore

[@forgetfulstranger]

Watching this years later is making me really emotional, not only do I miss this era but I just miss being a kid and bumping it to SHINee and f(x)

[@Stayyy2020]

Onews wink kills me

[@cherry-hv9ty]

omg yes when he winked that was the moment i died😭

[@lz738]

Whew! Onew winking when he sang "kiss me till your drunk!" Supah sexy!

[@muryamkhalid7460]

taemin kissing kai's girl

[@Clausita26preciosa]

Muryam Khalid lol never though of that

[@vita1596]

But in this case even Kai not yet debut lol

[@mileycyrus201198]

@@vita1596 he did debut that was in 2012 and exo debuted in april 2012

[@exoisloveexoislife6653]

KyungSoo be like: 😏

[@arnav8606]

@@exoisloveexoislife6653 jennie be like 😏

[@sisitmae]

I remembered when I was super excited for this stage because... How time flies....

[@BeatifulStranger91]

I hope for a f(shinee) collaboratioooon!please SM!>.

[@ocean6825]

Val De san still waiting on it :-(

[@TheMgp99]

Val De san yes ;-;

[@gkcmspalzn]

Amber sounds like an angel

[@thedarkshawol]

I miss those times so much 😢😢😢

[@lwtgrey1019]

jonghyun's aura is unmatched... i forgot how to breath for a sec 😭

[@harshinishankar4683]

I started crying when I realized these 10 will never be together like before. Literally f(x) and Shinee were so close, now do they even meet up?

[@abc_jv_xyz]

Minho and Amber Key and Sulli Taemin and Krystal Jonghyun and Luna Onew and Victoria

[@five952_]

내 청춘의 전부이자 나의 전부의 청춘이다.

[@Daisyar5]

f(SHINee) slay~

[@AneShiroo]

I MISS THESE TWO GROUPS ‼️‼️‼️‼️

[@rmd9439]

Me too

[@ommywijaya6693]

Kalo gen sekarang mana bisa begini, fan nya baper'an... Miss you, gen ke-2 K-Pop

[@lorena_erm]

Forever five in our hearts. F(x) and SHINee. Jonghyun and Sulli are now an Angels. I hope they are happy wherever they are now, I hope we will be able to see their genuine smile someday. We love you always 💕😭

[@apspaa8785]

Best sibling groups ever..

[@deepamahesh4302]

You did well Sulli & Jonghyun 💔

[@livvyyates8089]

I screamed when Minho and Amber started singing Rocketeer! I love that song.

[@이름-v2e5g]

아 미친 개설레 그냥 이 분위기가 너무 좋다 ㅜㅜ

[@devinaxxi]

I miss this Era.. Our 2 angels are in heaven now and I'm crying rn😢😭😭 #Jonghyun #Sulli i will never forget all the memories and happiness you give us.. Thank you and Saranghae.. ShineexFx forever 💙❤

[@annw99]

When I used to watch this in the past I would never imagine 2 of those amazing human beings wouldn't be here anymore in the future... and a future that isn't this far Goosebumps..

[@xuxuminkook4397]

Its the time when theyre having fun,no fanwars,no stress no depression no sadness no loneliness. You can definitely see Jonghyun and Sulli having the best time of their lives with this performance.😢

[@debbie.c]

amber with long hair! :) haha 1 of the only times ive seen her with long hair, even though it is tied up ^_^

[@ZenoTee]

MISS JONGHYUUUUUNNN :'(

[@kurseyv5698]

Two of them is now in heaven :(

[@nuruladlin5951]

B. JC HC JX JS. JJDV JJD NND JD C. 🍻🍺🍹🍹😘😍😎😙😚KD. VK 😊NXJC JC NX JD JDVMD ND. NF

[@dingdong4439]

my fav collabs ever

[@vacayvlogs4587]

Dang, Amber’s vocals!

[@lovejapan60]

Perfection !

[@EminaHimeSama]

It melts me when Onew sings "Kiss me 'til you're drunk and i'll show you" while he smiles, winks and holds Victoria's hand--like--- THE MAN. OMGH JINKI.

[@denuevojonghyun3211]

Amber's voice is so pretty she suits the song ~~

[@akinsayabe8850]

omg i just still belive for jonghyun is gone bcs this perform always taking me to his smile n he is happy huh RIP

[@haylstorm6]

OK BUT ONEW LEANING FORWARD TO HAMMER IN THE PUN WITH "OWN YOU" @2:37 IS EVERYTHING TO ME

[@yunyunnie]

i miss this era of kpop SO FRIGGIN MUCH

[@prakharagrawal153]

Amber minho start is so clean

[@fullsun4508]

how i miss the old days

[@ruse128]

f(SHINee) collabs always so fun!!!

[@impyerno]

2:19: okay this is the noona we’re talkin about in our debut mv

[@caronce9280]

I miss f(Shinee) so much 😭😭 ot10 💔

[@shxbndc]

Still the best collab ever. I miss this era.

[@lucasepifanio4306]

6 년이 지난 지금도이 프레젠테이션을 정말 좋아하고 여러분에게 충실합니다. 샤이니와 에프 엑스에게 영원히 감사합니다 I love this presentation so much, six years later and I remain faithful to you. I am eternally grateful to Shinee and f (x)

[@sitisarah2946]

I miss this kpop era so much. Now, they don't do things like this anymore.

[@notwerkinginthishouse8634]

M2 Now they all go in West...

[@husnulhotimah4237]

Queen and King Legend in the world always and forever f(x) and Shinee.

[@salfarcouple.8028]

Shinee love fx

[@RookiesCAT]

One of the best collab f{shinee}

[@자몽-v4v]

아진짜 다 너무 이쁘다ㅜㅜㅜ

[@cuiikrystal4858]

the best callaboration ever

[@ritaerlitasari1293]

Miss them ... We lost 2 angel jonghyun oppa and sulli eonni ...

[@kiara16only]

My two kpop group i love the most together

[@yxwvda]

i love this Leader Couple, Main Vocal Couple. Lead Rapper Couple, Main Rapper Couple, and Maknae Couple.

[@nobodyspecial2160]

Am I the only one who foucused on Minho and Amber and kept thinking about the Amber is a llama thingy?

[@lalisacult5839]

I miss shinee and f(x) collabs omg tae and krys + insert kai reaction. ;)

[@vanishaa2890]

i miss this days..

[@ilovenoodlesandshinee7063]

F (SHINee) is a blessing