MEDAL OF HONOR: Leading the LAST Bayonet Charge in Vietnam | James E. Livingston

[@ramsnover3599]

My uncle, Glenn Ross Urquhart Jr, KIA Da Nang Vietnam 2-5-69, recipient of the MILITARY MERET MEDAL from South Vietnam ...only 22 American Marines received this MEDAL, basically the MOH of South Vietnam....a soldier in the South Vietnam military had to be in their service 13yrs. minimum, and the act in question had to be witnessed by 3 or more and one had to be at least a captain, so very few got this award...Glenn smothered a pop mortar walking point escorting some high ranking South Vietnam officers to an intelligents point...received it postumasly , made possible by an officer who witnessed his action, God Bless you all.

[@scenepointjudge]

"To be a Marine, you have to Marine every day." What a quote from this absolute legend.

[@treadhead]

DEVIL DOG LEATHERNECKS , IN COMBAT ----- MESS WITH 1 --- MESS WITH THEM ALL , BANDING TOGETHER FOR THE FINAL OUTCOME , *** AMERICA'S TIP OF THE SPEAR !!!

[@MarkusBracey-cs5rm]

Out of 180 Marines 30 WALKED AWAY. My Father was part of that 30. Sylvester Bracey Sr 2nd Batt 3rd div 9th Marine RECON I HEARD THIS STORY AS A KID. THE BATTLE OF DONG HA. POPS said no matter how much we shot THEY JUST KEPT COMING THEY WERE EVERYWHERE WE HAD TO RETREAT. But they didn't get dong ha base. We were out numbered but WON THE BATTLE. Plenty 100s dead and wounded body parts Everywhere

[@daviddixon1611]

Enlisted in the Marine Corps in 1980 and found myself at MCRD Parris Island I Company 3rd Battalion. The Marine Corps quickly indoctrinates recruits into its history and culture. ANY war veteran is revered. ANY citations for Combat Bravery are more revered. At the time there were a few, but not many, combat veterans from Vietnam. Lieutenant Colonel Livingston was our Battalion Commander. Our Drill Instructors, who seemed to be impressed by few things were in awe of this man. He was in possession of The Medal. The Congressional Medal of Honor is not awarded for showing up to work. On several occasions Lt. Col. Livingston would "appear" during Physical Training Sessions. He gave no speeches; he barked no orders. He just got in the dirt with the lowly Marine recruits and suffered. We all wore shorts during structured P.T. One of Lt. Col Livingston's legs were a mass of scar tissue. He ran with a limp. He was not the most fit guy out there, but he was far from last. We were all very young and didn't have a long list of combat injuries. Once we did a PT Test practice session. (Pull Ups, Sit Ups, 3 Mile Run). The "old guy" looked to be in pain while running on that leg, but he finished ahead of middle of the pack. Keep in mind this guy was in Command of the whole Battalion. He didn't have to do a thing. He taught many of us that day what Leadership by Example really means. I'm still in awe. What he did on the Battlefield is 100 times more impressive.

[@JulezWinnfield]

I used to work with a guy who served in the Marines in the early 80's. His basic training battalion commander at Parris Island was a then LTC Livingston. I remember him recounting their full dress uniform inspection and seeing his CMoH medal on his dress blue uniform and him being saluted by every senior higher ranking officer who was present.

[@alethiapotter9218]

That is stupendous to hear. Makes me proudly tearful.

[@waynefletcher9884]

I served from 1982-89 and I also served a tour as a Recruiter (8411) We didn’t have any inspections where we wore dress blues. Back then only the guide wore dress blues. Secondly the commanding officer, officers and DI’s wore Alphas that is it ….so why would the lieutenant colonel be the only one wearing dress blues?! Your story doesn’t make sense or you’re just embellishing and didn’t realize it didn’t make sense to those of us that are in the know. My bullshit meter is always on mind you. Semper Fi

[@JulezWinnfield]

@@waynefletcher9884 It's been nearly twenty years since I worked with the guy so forgive me if I missed a few specifics. Secondly, I'm an Army vet so I couldn't tell you the first thing about which Marine uniform is worn on what occasion and in what particular setting. I do know my co-worker stated the first full dress uniform inspection they had as a basic training company, LTC Livingston was present in his dress uniform with his CMoH worn around his neck. My co-worker shared this story back in the early to mid 90's and it always stuck with me. I have no need to embellish his story in the least. Seeing this video about Gen. Livingston immediately reminded me of my co-workers story, so I shared my recollection of it. Perhaps you should lighten up Francis and accept my story as the respectful tribute for which it was intended.

[@waynefletcher9884]

@@JulezWinnfield No harm brother! It’s ok my second oldest brother served from 1970-76 in the Army. My oldest brother was a Marine and I followed suit as you can see! I understand the essence as to what you were saying Dawg! Ooraah go Army! ✊🏽

[@JulezWinnfield]

@@waynefletcher9884 First you call me a liar and now you offer an "Oo-rah, Go Army"? I don't accept fake apologies.

[@WETHEPEOPLEUSMC]

At the time, Lt. Col. Livingston was my battalion Commander with 3rd Battalion MCRD Parris Island. What an honor it was to have this man do my final inspection before graduation from boot camp in Feb. 1983... 3rd Bat. H Co. Plt. 3016 OOH-RAH!!

[@thomclark7641]

LtCol Livingston was my Battalion Commander at 3rd Bn MCRD Parris Island in 1982. During our Final Uniform Inspection I froze when he stood in front of me as a mere recruit starring at a MOH ribbon was intimidating.

[@joeosman2629]

In 1970 at MCRD San Diego the officer in charge of the receiving barracks had an MoH. One of my junior DIs had a Navy Cross.

[@bannaxe7338]

@@joeosman2629 old timers like you need to do interviews so new marines like me can gain some knowledge

[@hawkgrunt4182]

H company, 3095 and my experience was exactly the same! Semper Fidelis brother.

[@billysheppard6091]

Brother I was in 3rd battalion also grad.oct 1982.i remember he joined our platoon on a run.and during the cool down when you go under the shower.he removed his t shirt..the man was rail road stitched scars on his back.i took a brief glance and didn't want to stare..

[@danielconniff5300]

@thomclark7641 I was in Platoon 3020 and graduated June 18th. I felt the same way with him in front of me. He led the Commanding General's 10 mile run just before graduation, and I remember seeing his legs. Huge chunks were missing because of his wounds. It was an especially memorable honor to have been under his command.

[@smellygoatacres]

The part where he points out that it was a political loss, not a military loss was so spot on. Nailed it.

[@michaelwallace7587]

We never stopped the sapper attack at US Bases and never kept the VCI away from the people. And most battles the Viets set they table they choice where, when, and how long the fight lasted.

[@YeOldeTowneCryer]

The damned communists used our own media against us to stir up protests. US won all athe battles, how do you lose a war like that? Congress shut off the funding. Without food, fuel and ammo your army can't fight a war. They had to leave.

[@loetzcollector466]

​@Michael Wallace Yes. For political reasons. You think the military didn't want to push into North Vietnam? Use your brain man.

[@TheVistaview1]

We lost.

[@berean77]

We were capable of winning that war. But there was no way we would be able to win the peace.

[@oldtruthteller2512]

Anyone who's ever been in combat will understand the absolute chaos that ensues when the lead flies. It's hell on everyone, especially the NCOs and Corpsman. Officers like this Marine are true leaders and trying to keep up with it all and focus on a fluid situation is a special hell.

[@davidsollinger8886]

Men that excel under pressure, I couldn't imagine but especially while being shot at relentlessly for hours in a situation of live or die, are men you respect and don't go poking at.

[@markadams2907]

I am not a Vietnam veteran, but I have been saying for years that we did not lose that war; we just didn't win in the sense that the average mind views winning. It is such an honor to hear this hero describe what I've been saying ..US Forces NEVER lost a single solitary major battle of that war. And even with the inflated body count the NVA/VC lost more soldiers (with all due respect) and the US chose to leave Vietnam. The politicians did not get what they wanted...that was the loss. Vietnam Veterans: stand tall with your heads held high, I for one salute you!

[@joeldavis5546]

It was a pleasure to serve with you Sir. Sempre Fi General!!!

[@robertrice5703]

Twenty years, retired USAF. He is what a true Leader is. I salute you, sir!

[@stevenstrother7129]

I wish everyone in this country could hear those closing statements. Thank you for your service.

[@ramrod7922]

I know General Livingston personally. I met him while working as a service advisor at a car dealership and worked on his car many times over the years. One of the nicest people I’ve ever met, and so humble. You would never be able to guess he is a Medal of Honor recipient, if you didn’t already know before meeting him. He is the definition of a great man and I’m honored to have been able to shake his hand and speak to him on so many occasions. I look forward to telling my kids one day, when they are older and can appreciate what he did and what it means, about knowing a real-life hero. Thank you for your service/sacrifices, General Livingston. 🇺🇸

[@Vagabond_Etranger]

They were real men. Now we have soy boy drinking latte, keyboard SJW, beta simps.

[@BlueWaterSTAX]

God Bless our heroes. Those Vietnam veterans are tough as nails. Thanks again 👍

[@mattysee24]

This guy sent 145 young men to their deaths on a suicide mission. I'm sure he had no choice but damn

[@boxelderinitiative3897]

@@mattysee24 And most of them died for nothing

[@nychris2258]

They lost.. and it was a pointless war.

[@Voucher765]

Upmost respect and Semper Fi

[@cyclone8974]

@@nychris2258 It wasn't pointless. It was to stop the communists from taking over South Vietnam. Ho Chi Minh killed hundreds of thousands of civilians in North Vietnam a Million fled to South Vietnam. They went on to do the same thing in South Vietnam. Millions fled after the war.

[@codyhilton1750]

Once a Marine Always a Marine. Semper Fi!

[@mattk6719]

Semper fi

[@SSgt-]

James Livingston was my battalion CO when I went to Parris Island in the fall of 82.

[@brianwade8649]

Only 35 of 180 walked away. Was that considered a success? Seems like a very high loss rate.

[@SSgt-]

@@brianwade8649 a direct assault on fortified positions is high risk just look at many of the battles in the Pacific theater of WW2. I will not second guess MGen Livingston’s battle plans that day since I was 4 years old at the time. I never meet a Marine who had anything negative to say about him although they may exist.

[@bradr2142]

@@brianwade8649 you missed what he said they killed 500+ nva and Vietcong. 5 to 1 maybe ratio. We had alot wounded.

[@graciesdaddy3305]

@@brianwade8649 This takes perspective- The big picture. If we'd have lost Dai Do, the major and massive supply base of Dong Ha would have been over run by the NVA. This was the equivalent of losing the entire I Corps area which included the relatively new Air Base at Quang Tri. Losing Dong Ha Combat Base would have been a huge psychological victory for N. Vietnam, who was down to a matter of weeks from running out of resources to continue the war. And, it would have the opposite effect on the morale of our guys. Not to mention having 10,000 guys from the NVA's best battalion (320th) losing to 750 Marines.

[@graciesdaddy3305]

@@bradr2142 Yes, and the 500 NVA was just related to the bunker assault. Estimates of the total NVA loss was over 2,300 KIA's and who knows how many were wounded.

[@dootybop9750]

This is a true American patriot. Proud and grateful to be from the best country in the world. Thank you for your service James E. Livingston you will be in my and my families prayers.

[@TRockett55IRISH]

Im the son of a Canadian USMC Vietnam veteran who served two tours 67-69 with the 1st Marine Division I have the utmost respect for that generation and hearing this gentleman's story was just humbling to listen to him .

[@jameswells554]

Your Father is an unsung Hero; as are all our Canadian brothers who served in Vietnam. Sadly too few know of their bravery and sacrifice.

[@TheProdigalCat]

Trevor, smokes lets go

[@TRockett55IRISH]

@@jameswells554 appreciate that comment Mr. Wells unfortunately what you said is so true its never talked about just how many Canadians fought and died alongside their American brothers and sisters in that war . Sir I've always been proud and honoured to be his son but I never knew what he truly went through until I enlisted and deployed 4 times myself I understood at a higher level what it was like for him and yet I still wont compare what I went through to what he did . Again thank you sir for that comment.

[@jameswells554]

@@TRockett55IRISH my Dad is a Nam Vet, and I always made sure to tell those old guys "Welcome Home" when they greeted us when we returned from Deployments. They would just give a shy smile, nod, and say thanks; sometimes we'd even hug. Those Men deserve better than they received.

[@mgunny05]

I was a SSgt in 1984-April 1985 I served with Colonel Vargas at the 7th Marines, the other MOH awardee of the battle of Dai Do. Down to earth superb leader of Marines he was. And I heard about General Livingston from Marines who had served with him. Another superb leader of Marines they all said..”he cared about his Marines”. Listening to Colonel Vargas at the “Mess Night” we had Dai Do WAS a ferocious close quarter battle. And General Livingston was right, the military did NOT lose that war. The POLITICIANS/POLITICS did. The Vietnam Vets are STUDS, answered the call to their country whether voluntarily or drafted, they fought like the MEN and WOMEN they were. They all were HONORABLE and HEROES. 🫡🫡🫡👏👏👏🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺🍺!

[@runtoth3abyss]

Look man ignoring the politics of a situation is a key way militaries have started wars with failing strategy from the beginning. Same thing happened with Bush starting the war on terror. We learned nothing from Vietnam

[@clarencelafuentes5331]

Just as with the Rhodesian Light Infantry. Similarities are numerous.

[@augieb4610]

Semper Fi Staff Sargeant !! I was a Corporal Bravo Co. 1/7 .....

[@phil4483]

This man is a well-known Marine Corps legend.

[@2dAnglicoSix]

Greetings General Livingston! Among his few staff assignments, Gen Livingston was the Deputy Director of the Joint Staff , the Pentagon , J-3 (Operations) within the National Military Command Center (NMCC). I had the unique honor of serving with him and having him promote me to to the rank of Lieutenant Colonel of Marines. Gen Livingston is ‘spot-on’ in being the best Marine you can be on a daily basis. Semper Fi, General! LtCol Regan, USMC(Ret)

[@XHollisWood]

Thank you for sharing this experience along with your courage, bravery, sacrifices and service to answer the call to serve. 🇺🇸

[@mehmedii7594]

Seen him here in Charleston in his awesome red corvetter with MOH plates. Right behind him in the starbucks line.

[@grobsop6688]

The epitome of a role model

[@Zeekstuff]

I've had the pleasure of meeting General Livingston a few times. My grandfather lead the attack on Dai Do and was wounded. If you want to see a complete documentary on this battle look up the show Against the Odds: The Bastards of Dai Do.

[@ferallion3546]

What an honor that must have been. I’ll check out that doc. Thx for the lead.

[@alethiapotter9218]

Thank you for the information about the history.

[@antonkrieg3708]

I'll have a look at that.

[@kevinnummi3154]

Great book by best Vietnam War author, Keith Nolan

[@Zeekstuff]

@@ferallion3546 yes, my grandfather is Brig General Weise and is interviewed in that show I mentioned. We have been trying for the past 15 + years to get a movie made about this. They essentially stopped a second Tet offensive. This battle was 10,000 NVA vs 750 Marines.

[@Anon-greyman]

I will forever skip the Intro, NO SPOILERS! thank you guys for the important content.

[@pedromunozdones7869]

Courage and Strength in the person, and character of this Gentleman Warrior. A true Professional Officer, and Leader of US Marines. An example worthy of emulation. Thanks for sharing your experience, Sir.

[@Gunsandfun1961]

Balls of steel..... thanks for your service....

[@aaaht3810]

"I wasn't worried about myself". Great leadership exhibited by this man.

[@rn2cro03]

That man is sharp as a tack. Semper fidelis!

[@Edward.Rippett.]

These are the type of men our youth need to look up to, not toxic rappers

[@aaronstolz9936]

Imperialists?

[@zq7142]

Yes your right but that ain’t gonna stop me from listing to gunna

[@Edward.Rippett.]

@@zq7142 I didn't say you have to stop listening to them. But when people start modeling their lives off of them then it becomes a problem

[@da90sReAlvloc]

Or demonic politicians like trump

[@stevearkie5722]

Cowardly rapper would dare enter hell like a Marine .

[@harleyshoaf4916]

Semper Fi,if we keep our tradition of training our recruits tough and well , we will always be respected .

[@colleenmonfross4283]

Love this man, totally exemplifies the best of the Marine Corps and the best of America!

[@toddwheeler1526]

Dear sir, your closing statement was so well put. Thank you sir for your leadership and the staunch support and care of all of the troops on and off of the battlefield. God bless you all.

[@wb6162]

Medal of honor winner. That's hard core man. Respect.

[@DarylW426]

"I always wanted to be a Marine." You certainly achieved your goal General, and then some. American Hero and forever a Marine. God bless you sir. Thank you for your sacrifice. Thank you to Americans Veterans Center for this interview.

[@rsa9082]

To whom ever is responsible for capturing the stories from these men. Thank you from the bottom of my heart I during my life took care of some of our “boys” as a home health aid. I got to hear snippets of their experiences from a different world. Thank you to all the men and women that hold the pride of our flag 🇺🇸 dear. Thank you for ALL you did and went through. Most of all thank you for sharing your experiences. I pray for all of you and I thank God you were where you were when you were needed. ❤❤ From ; a grateful American lady 🇺🇸

[@janlindtner305]

Nothing like hearing the story from the horse's own mouth. Semper fidelis. Well done, keep documenting.

[@KCODacey]

It was my 2nd year out of medical school when I met then LCOL James E. Livingston, USMC. I was assigned to be the Battalion Surgeon of Headquarters Co, 2nd Marine Division at Camp Lejeune, NC. One day I walked into my office & LCOL Livingston was seated there, waiting for me. Apparently I was late because he shot out his arm & very purposefully looked at his wristwatch. I was a wet-behind-the-ears Navy LT. I didn't know anything about the man except this: this guy was a no-nonsense Marine. I addressed his concerns, all the while profusely apologizing for my tardiness. I saw him a few more times after that. He was always a ram-rod straight Marine except for a brief few seconds when I once asked him to explain what he had done in Vietnam to earn his MoH. He softened ever so slightly & I swear I saw a tear briefly form in one eye, & then LCOL Livingston was back in the room. A few decades later I received a package from the WW2 Museum in New Orleans. It was a purchase from their gift shop & they used a recycled box. On that box was MGEN Livingston's name and address. I still have that box & cherish it as a highly valued memento.

[@michaelshanahan4042]

I love listening to the old veterans. I am watching from the UK i hope you are proud of this gentleman because I am proud of them for you

[@timp3035]

At a loss for words! Gods speed to our Vietnam Vets!

[@boxelderinitiative3897]

They lost

[@nicholaswilson2761]

@@boxelderinitiative3897 One day you won’t be 14 anymore and you’ll look back on making comments like this one and be embarrassed for yourself. Either that, or you’re just an asshole. Not even going to get into the “they” lost argument. Military loss =\= political loss.

[@ammocache6879]

@@boxelderinitiative3897 nope

[@boxelderinitiative3897]

@@ammocache6879 Yep

[@ammocache6879]

@@boxelderinitiative3897 I would suggest you read "A Bright Shining Lie: John Paul Vann and America in Vietnam" by Neil Sheehan; Little hard to get into for the first couple of chapters, but a good read. My father served in Vietnam and most of leadership figures (boy scouts, church, explorers, and friends) were vets. Why do you think it took so long to take Saigon after the peace accords? The NVA and Viet Cong were decimated. It took years to rebuild their army.

[@PhD777]

General Livingston, thank you for all you have done for our Country. God bless and keep you and yours.

[@laurenced2916]

E. Michael Helms was a Marine in the battle of Dai Do his book is called Proud Bastards

[@KenHelms-uu6vv]

My brother E. Michael Helms was one of the Marines there, wasn’t one of the 35 Marines to walk away. He did survive but was very seriously injured.

[@mwhitelaw8569]

An absolutely inspirational generation of men to be trained by. The depth of first hand knowledge passed down was intense. Thank you general for your accounts of battle.

[@BlueWaterSTAX]

God bless you Sir. Tough as nails

[@Bill-yy3ck]

I can't say any words that haven't already been said. I wish all our officers had the focus that this man had. Welcome home brother.

[@donaldsmith6814]

Semper Fi! My salute to you, from a Sgt. E-5 who was there (Vietnam) a little earlier ( April 66 to Dec. 67). God Bless you & all the Marines who were with you in that terrible battle.

[@Ripper0352]

Oooh-rahh Sir, you're a great inspiration

[@allenjones2450]

Every time guys like this tell their stories, they are seeing the whole event in their head. It must take a lot to tell it over and over, and you can't blame the guys that avoid the subject.

[@seancronin4010]

He's a reminder of how great we can be.

[@Me2Lancer]

Thank you General for your honorable service and the sacrifices you made. Your dedication to duty could not be clearer. Our nation owes you a debt of gratitude.

[@stubaker2574]

Im an army vet(101st Airborne) and this man I would never call a "Jarhead" that was for barroom dancin'!! but Leatherneck maybe, but he knew to go toward the fight and not go back and let them deal with it..nowadays if a unit comes under fire they want to retreat before anyone gets shot..not everytime but much to many times..makes me wonder who taught it to them...the media is an enemy sometimes...I salute this man...lost to many but war is hell..

[@johnathonmullis4234]

What a great marine and tough sob. He accomplished so much after his medal that it was recognition for just one of many great accomplishments.

[@anlerden4851]

Thank you so much for your service and lovely dedications to Our Beautiful USA Dear American Sir. Semper Fi usususususus......🙏❤🤍💙🇺🇲💪🏻👍

[@globaladdict]

So why do you support a draft dodger?

[@georgemcadoo8546]

Rusty Megowan Which one, Clinton, Bush, or Biden.

[@maxannis9277]

The selfless sacrifice of themselves to protect their brothers against overwhelming odds drives me to tears. Thank you for your service marine.

[@ecleveland1]

You can still see the metal in his eyes, and hear it in his voice.

[@stevepeppers560]

My battalion commander, 3rd battalion indigo company. Shook my hand during our graduation. I hadn't a clue at the time. Semper Fi sir.

[@georgemcadoo8546]

Indigo company???

[@seanpadgett3053]

So glad these are still getting uploaded. We need their stories documented and even more so in their own words. These are examples to follow.

[@rjust2297]

Thank you for your service sir 😘 outstanding work.

[@rrussell9731]

16:17 To be a Marine means to improve yourself every day.

[@richardpittman5291]

Sir Thank you for your service to our country General.

[@thebeachguy6697]

This man is a USMC legend. When I joined in 1995 we heard a lot about him. When I retired in 2015 he was still referred to. The leadership that I had in the Marine Corps was top notch and you really do not realize it until your gone. I had the privilege of being under the command of General Mattis another USMC legend. The times I had I wouldnt trade for anything in this world

[@wovfm]

"Oh, I was right in the middle of it," he said matter of factly after fixing bayonets and going hand to hand. There is little more admirable in this world than the steel eyed courage of this man. His measured telling is mesmerizing. One brutal heroic story. Thank you sir for your service above and beyond.

[@theallseeingmaster]

Wow! What a wonderfully capable man to have on 'your side'.

[@bradr2142]

Thanks General. All your experience in the marines is what makes our country and marines so great. A b ig thank you.

[@markrowley8073]

As a Marine myself I can’t feel any more pride for our Corps this is once again a testament as to why there will always be a USMC 💪

[@mattk6719]

Good lesson to learn at the end there

[@badcornflakes6374]

Est. 1775

[@Mtlmshr]

Hardcore Marine through & through!

[@matthewford937]

Wow. Amazing leadership and combat instinct! Thank you for your service sir! 🇺🇸🇨🇦

[@markshaw3219]

I respect all who have and are serving in the US military! Over the years, I met some humble people who made good soldiers/marines. Then comes along individuals like Gen Livingston who perform as highly trained warriors and have a keen demeanor to inspire/lead personnel to accomplish their set mission. On top of this, there is a deep character of care for those whom they lead. Listening to the man, I couldn't help but think that I would submit myself to his leadership. Class act! Much respect! God's blessings Gen Livingston.

[@skimmer8774]

Talk about overwhelming odds. God almighty. Thank you for your service sir.

[@g3ultra]

Awesome interview! I met Livingston when he was my base commander at 29 Palms in the early 90s.

[@dimasgarcia-ut8fy]

Proud to have served with (at that time) Col. Livingston, 6th Marine Regiment. Heck of a Marine!!!!

[@rikijett310]

He is the perfect model of a modern major general, for real!!! Thank you endlessly for your service Sir and may God bless you always!!! ✝️🇺🇲✝️

[@nailedt0thecr0ss]

Thank you so much for your service sir. God bless.

[@Steven-jf4cs]

General Livingston was my first Commanding Officer from 1977 to 1980. Straight out of MCRD San Diego to Marine Barracks London, UK. A favorite memory was that when he had time he'd take any Marine who wanted to run and we'd go out into the woods near the HQ. We'd run off trail and truly a fun/memorable time. Before I departed London I was lucky enough to have him promote me to Sergeant. Semper Fi Sir!

[@johngrogan7585]

Love this man. Thank you for everything. I really like his last comments

[@Shea8Queens8]

Served under him in MCAS KBay Hawaii. At the same time he was our MOH Commanding Gneral our Base Sgt Major was also an MOH recipient (Kellogg). General Livingston loved to PT and would never ask you to do something he wouldn't do himself. I remember inviting him to BOSSES night at the E-Club. He thanked me for the invite. I was surprised when he actually showed up. He went to every table and talked to all of us and bought each table a pitcher of beer. It was great. He looked so happy to be among us NCO's and Non NCO's. One of my favorite officers I had the honor to serve under. Semper Fi.

[@danielreichert2025]

Men like this are far and few between. This marine is a human tank to withstand a hit from a.50 . Bravery asks him for advice.

[@haroldmclean3755]

High Kudos & Much Respect 👍 Thankyou for Your Service

[@johndiblasi4803]

Thanks for the series and the important documentation from those who made a difference

[@j1st633]

WOW! Unbelievable story. Great channel.

[@aaronjohn6586]

His last words say so much and are so eloquent.

[@Onlyusemesuede]

Every day this channel gives me a brand new account of a battle ID never heard of. Never stop doing what you’re doing and please continue to display the greatness of these men. God bless the American Veterans Center!!!

[@ssharp6729]

I was at MCRD Parris Island from Aug 82 until Oct 82. I was in 3rd Battalion H company and he was my Battalion commander also. I stood his inspections and ran beside him on Battalion runs. He ran with a very noticeable limp. I was in awe of him like everyone else. I paid attention to the rest of his career and I tried to read or watch everything I could find on him.

[@patrickfurlong9169]

The tactical decision this guy had to make on the fly were remarkable.

[@Gunshinzero]

He's definitely sharp.

[@mitchellculberson9336]

Thank tou for tour service to a FREE and grateful nation!

[@burkejones8277]

I met this man back on the 1990’s at a Mardi Gras ball in New Orleans. I didn’t know who he was, but I saw the Medal of Honor and went up and said hello and probably something stupid after that. But I was starstruck, being a former Marine myself.

[@snake_ize136]

Much respect, sir. 👍🇺🇸

[@davidpage4994]

A great Generation that answered the call to duty and their service and sacrifice should never be forgotten. Thank you Vietnam Veterans.

[@ColonelEmpire]

Major General Livingston was my Regimental CO as a Colonel in 1986. He is an outstanding Marine. He ran many miles for PT Sgt-Major Wade was our Regt Sgt-Major at the time. Both outstanding Marines. Oh the memories.

[@nathanashley5260]

Hell yeah sir. I’m sick the narrative that Vietnam was lost. Like Sir said” we never lost a major battle…” Thank you Sir!

[@MrBUBBAKY]

It was lost before we got involved, strategic misconceptions, political corruption in South Vietnam, and then a Failure by our Presidents and Generals to Follow the Science and Basic Principles of War.

[@brunogingras798]

Major battles or not, we lost the war even if we kill more with momentum. We call that history facts. And if you're sick with that, just consult a good psychiatrist.

[@nathanashley5260]

@@brunogingras798 OK let’s use another metric then. What was the purpose of the war?

[@brunogingras798]

Conquering and submitting, killing and sometimes: defending things that have value. But we fight more for corporate interests. G. Smedley Butler: war is a racket, told us about that. Rarely are we fighting for any rights or justice. And the biggest battle is not abroad, look at our level of violence here and our degree of inequity in that nation...

[@brunogingras798]

Why do we have such a hard-on in front of our military? Are they the truth incarnated over everything else? This guy is surely courageous like no one, but that doesn't make him a genius or a guide. Only a man with a point of view

[@richardross119]

Just hearing the way this man speaks. He builds belief. Belief in his intelligence, knowledge and abilities. He is a born leader.

[@Gunshinzero]

He's definitely sharp. Your can tell his answers are ready before the interviewer is finished asking them. No hesitation. This made me realize I really need to work on my decisiveness.

[@donnamarsh3474]

Unbelievable that not only is he still alive, but he is so coherent and such a sharp memory. Thank you for your service, Sir.

[@FightFightFight4547]

I was a Marine in Vietnam from May 1967 to April 1968, and assigned to Hq Co 4th Marines. I was at Dong Ha, Camp Evans and Camp Carroll in the Quang Tri Province. General Livingston was in the area with 2/4 (2nd Battalion, 4th Marines). He’s a Marine’s Marine. Semper Fi.

[@xipingpooh5783]

I had the privilege of attending a speech delivered by Brigadier General Livingston in the fall of 1988. He is and always will be one of the finest leaders this country and the Marine Corps ever produced. Semper Fidelis 🇺🇸 1983-1989

[@fancyultrafresh3264]

What a sharp man. It was like being debriefed by him in the 70s.

[@staynsaddle]

Unbelievable! Giants! Thank you to all veterans! If I could just b half the man .Lions! Welcome Home you have all my gratitude always.

[@lch7876]

This story is Movie Worthy

[@mineown1861]

I've read a lot about the battle of dong ha as this series of actions was called , a terrible fight against the odds . Great to hear the voice of one of the marines that fought there .