Meem Se Mohabbat | Tan Man Neel o Neel Review | Drama Gup with Sadaf Haider | Mahwash Ajaz

[@SurprisedSurprised]

Meem se mohabbat best review🥰

[@crazybird786]

Great discussion ladies! I really enjoyed TMNN. It was extremely well done. I wish Farhat Istiaq scripts wouldn't be wasted on nepo/well connected actors. This is Dananeers 4th outing, and she has been getting author backed roles since her second project, whereas many talented outsiders are still grinding it out. Ahad is fairly talented despite the "nepo" tag, but he often walks out of projects in Pakistan last minute to pursue work outside, eventhough it is the Pakistani audience that has given him whatever fame he currently has, so this leaves a bad taste in my mouth. That he takes his work in Pakistan for granted, yet always has top notch projects waiting for him when he decides to return.

[@MahwashAjaz]

Sigh

[@nabilahkhan1271]

I feel the differences in Zard Patton, Faraar and Tan man is the no of episodes to be aired. Tan man is only about 8-9 episodes so there are less no. of characters, less subplots and they are strung together better to be able to be completed within the specified no of episodes. Faraar and Zard have the luxury of a larger no of episodes so they are able to add more subplots and characters. Faraar is a multi POV and will come together when the main protagonists actually go Faraar and IMO that’s when the story will come full circle. I absolutely loved Zard Patton and despite having a a large cast, it didn’t feel disjointed, every character had an arc and all the subplots culminated in shaping the story of the main protagonists. Additionally, barring a few initial scenes, the majority of the drama was shot in a village and Qaiser Qlan was a character in itself.

[@sadafhaider8419]

Fair point & we have acknowledged it was aimed at an audience which isnt necessarily “ us”

[@mustafaandwaniyasadventure8966]

Seher khan and nadia Afghan was amazing, brilliant

[@sadafhaider8419]

I agree love them

[@mahirasaiyed1618]

Good discussion. TMNON was absolutely fabulous. Mustafa Afridi wanted to make sure we get the message and also not get bored and that is exactly what happened. I found myself smiling ear to ear at Sehar and Shuja's meet cute, felt deeply when Rabi's mom tells her about her husband's "thank you" after so many years of marriage, shocked and cold at the Se**al Assault depicted. My point being - there are so many good and bright things portrayed along with a portrayal of the realistic abuse and gundagardi that all the pieces fit together. It works - this is what a drama is supposed to be. Portrayal of some amazing and some evil/frightening relationships - Rabi and her mom, Sonu and mom, Rabi and sonu, Sonu with his friends, Kaami with Rabi, Kaami with Bhau ......I just cannot wait for the second episode. MSM I enjoyed it too - highlight for me was Ahad and Mohit's relationship. I liked Dananeer - she is super cute but at the same time it felt that I have seen this type of character again and again. And also she is shown as a 18/19 yr old (her family wants her to study engineering/science BA/BSc) and yet again we will see an age gap in the story with a 30+ Ahad's char with Dananeers. However - to be very honest - I was skeptical about KMKT in the first few episodes too so maybe the story will pick and will make sense. Farhat Ishtiaq did say that this is her first light hearted drama so lets see how her maiden venture into romcom is .

[@engineering-madness-dev]

A good example of not being OTT even if the character is written that way is Friends. Phoebe, Rachel, Joey were so believable that they never felt out of character even if they said the most absurd of things.

[@HeroHero-h6s]

Meem se mohabbat great drama🌹

[@mustafaandwaniyasadventure8966]

Tan man neelo neel was amazing

[@AliRaiz-wh7wq]

Seharkhan best actress seharkhan ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@MunizaTariq]

I agree with Sadaf about Sun Meray Dil. Why is such an idiotic drama being aired is beyond me!

[@MahwashAjaz]

How did this get approved????

[@sadafhaider8419]

Im glad there are more like minded people understanding that Sunn Mere Dil is a very flawed story

[@TashaKhan-b3j]

Seharrrrr❤❤❤😊

[@AkazaUpperM3]

Suno Chanda was majorly watched and hyped due to Nadia Afghan's character and nothing else. Had nothing to with Farhan Saeed lol.

[@MahwashAjaz]

See this is how i know you have an agenda. Farhan Saeed was brilliant in Suno Chanda.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz So if I say Bushra Ansari's Saima Chaudhary was the only best part of Baraat Series it means I have an agenda? Even Iqra Aziz was more relevant in that show than Farhan Saeed. Its Shahnaa's reels and shorts that still go viral on Insta, Tiktok or KZbin to this day...

[@MahwashAjaz]

It only means you don’t understand talent.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz Or it could also mean u had a bigger agenda where you plug in ur personal faves whenever an opportunity arises when better examples to make a stronger point and argument do exist?

[@vgm3067]

Meem si muhhabat looked very disconnected. It looked more like Ramzaan drama and I would have preferred if Dalaneer would have toned down her performance. I hope it gets better. I agree with the argument about neurodivergence but I guess the my don’t want to audience doesn’t want to be burdened with the science. TMNON was a good watch. The main lead actor’s performance was weak. And if they were to show the lead as a dancer, I would have preferred a better dancer in the cast. Story line is dark, lots of nuances. It will be a good watch for sure. Friend’s acting was brilliant. His pain, humiliation, anguish was portrayed very well. It’s a sad reality of life that most often we see mismatched couples like Sehar’s parents. A lively mom is stuck with a stoic spouse. I must say it was a lot of development for one episode. You two ladies were outstanding as always. Your

[@sadafhaider8419]

I think I needed more information to latch on to the story

[@muhammad_saad_bin_thaiyib]

do you know as a critic?🤨 pakistani dramas to reach 100 crore views of total episodes in youtube with their production house 1 tere bin - 2.8B 7th sky 2 khuda aur muhabbat - 2B 7th sky 3 kaisi teri khudgharzi - 1.7B idream 4 jaan nisar - 1.8B 7th sky 5 mayiri - 1.5B big bang 6 kaffara - 1.4B 7th sky 7 ishq murshid - 1.4B moomal 8 mere humsafar -1.4B six sigma 9 rang mahal - 1.1B 7th sky 10 siyani - 1.1B 7th sky parizaad - 0.96B maybe in future 1B kabhi mein kabhi tum - in future 1B sun mere dil - in future 1B if total view reaches the same point whether it be a good drama or drama of long format with significant view like jaan nisar, mayiri, kaffara, rang mahal what producer will think, maybe we will see it's effect in future dramas which he will prefer? quality or long format and dramas like zpkb, nadaan, man jogi is not getting even view of 10M(1 crore) for a episode

[@MahwashAjaz]

Not everything is abt views. I’m telling you this as a “critic”.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

So, maybe u both should also have the heart to respect others opinion and views instead of calling "ghatiya" 'wahiyaat" "baqwas" and "hot takes" and childish. And Very Filmy was a flop and brought no ratings or trp...its the most disastrous ramadan drama from a channel that is the pioneer of this particular genre.

[@MahwashAjaz]

A childish hot take will be called as such. Deal.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz Dakiyaanusi tropes will be called as such and not masterpieces or classics. Deal?

[@MahwashAjaz]

Who is deciding what is daqiyaanoosi? You? Fan girls? Anon twitter trolls? Or journalists who have studied psychology and written and worked and talked abt Pakistani dramas for decades?

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz I studied psychology as minor course in university and cleared with 96percent credit score on it. Have cleared HR rounds in many job interviews and gotten said job as well. I think I can decide a little bit. Also notice how u brought in decade of experience in my face to make point and yet in KMKT they literally made a useless loser with no professional experience a 50-50 partner in a company just because a baby was on the way?? But for u back then it must be classic masterpiece poetic writing right?

[@muhammad_saad_bin_thaiyib]

always talk in a tone that actors are just puppet so critize from start to end for writer but when it comes to acting then you can but generally i notice only things when they show their talent and do extra ordinary things

[@AkazaUpperM3]

We all saw what a "keystone" Sharjeena and Khirad both have been lol...Dusri teesri episode mein Shaadi kro, 15 epis baad ghar se nikale jao, phir last episode mein muu utha k wapas ajao. The End. Sharjeena literally had nothing to do instead wearing Mustafa's taraki hui t shirts for half of the drama.

[@MahwashAjaz]

I strongly suggest you stop watching Pakistani dramas.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz And I strongly suggest you to not take everything personally Ma'am! Cuz nothing I said is something that didnt happen or is false?

[@sadafhaider8419]

Ok so you disagree but Again for me Farhat’s heroines are pivotal Sharjeena made Mustafa .

[@MahwashAjaz]

Your comments are super personal and offensive, I suggest you check your tone too and return when you are less angry.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz Your reviews are super personal, biased and condescending as well? Why am I the only wrong one here? You refuse to even listen to criticism of your opinions and viewpoints?

[@AkazaUpperM3]

I doubt a writer who still writes such dakiyaanusi pregnancy tropes in which she makes the women bedridden 24/7 or else it will harm the baby when there are countless research studies done that prove otherwise, and age old miscarriage tropes where she blames the father to show "nuance and depth" of human relation or "badchalan badkirdaar aurat tropes" to throw the bahu out from house has enough intellect to write such severely complex clinical conditions such as neuro divergencies or ADHD. She is good in writing stuff that just happens in her la lal land far away from science and logic. She cant even write a solid and convincing doctory wala track without involving delusions and romance and "poeticness".

[@MahwashAjaz]

Why are you still watching then?

[@sadafhaider8419]

When a pregnwoman is under stress her Blood pressure can become high . Pregnancy makes women sensitive & at the mercy of hormones Ive seen people to whom it’s happened Khirad & a lot of other heroines in the PTV world ( for me its Mannu of Mannmayal) seem to trigger extreme reactions I love Farhat Ishtiaqs heroines , what we love & hate about a character can help us understand a lot about ourselves- for me Khirad showed me the supreme power of patience & forgiveness

[@mustafaandwaniyasadventure8966]

Plz interview Bilal Abbas

[@AkazaUpperM3]

You two are worst than fangirls of actors and actresses even when it comes to Farhat Ishtiaq.

[@MahwashAjaz]

Is that why we criticized Meem Se Mohabbat? Make up your mind.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz You are assuming that director ne bhand maraa hua hai? Is it so hard for you to believe that she might have actually copied pasted Fairy Tale or any other romcom?

[@sadafhaider8419]

No1 Farhat Ishtiaq is not an actress She is a writer No2 Yep We are fans of Talent & good Work .

[@MahwashAjaz]

Farhat Ishtiaq does not need to copy Fairytale, astaghfirullah.

[@AkazaUpperM3]

@@MahwashAjaz and yet she did?

[@UsmanKhalid-fi7yd]

Mehshar itna bhi bura nhi hai

[@MahwashAjaz]

Kafi bura hai

[@FaiqButt886]

😂😂😂​@@MahwashAjaz

[@sadafhaider8419]

This is the problem with Mehsar it is not bad , direction is reasonable & actors are as I have said really good . For me its the stilted old fashioned style & glorification of toxic one sided mohabbat