Personal Ranking | Elsa (45 Voices from "Frozen 2")

Hello fellow Frozen-obsessors! I suddenly woke up this morning with the motivation & strong urge to FINALLY edit a ranking of Elsa's voices 🥳
I hope that you will peacefully enjoy the video irrespective of numbers, it's never been about that and never will be. I'm not here to argue with anyone's opinions nor diminish any of these lovely ladies' performances.

[@diokles]

The fact that your least favourite Elsa voice is actually staring at your ultimate favourite one at the final clip you used though 😭💀

[@Meirenyu]

This definitely deserves to be the top comment!

[@kidkrowtaylor.ৎ]

@@Meirenyu Well it is now lol

[@jakealcomendas9937]

Meirenyu: Something's missing from these Elsas Sami Elsa: Mun dás Lean!!! (Here I am)! Meirenyu: Oh yes!!

[@Meirenyu]

Jake Alcomendas’s comment: - Meirenyu: Oh yes!!

[@TOTO-5]

The comments are so well-written, you made all your opinions clear, this might even push into finally watching the movie! Well, I have to agree on the last few placements (adding Carmen to them) I don't think I'll ever grow to love those voices on Elsa's character, they sound so distant from her - but still, they're tremendously good on their own -. Some of the singers I would have put higher are Idina, Nataša (I know it's a rather unpopular opinion but, what can I say, she's my guilty pleasure) Takako, WILLEMIJN, but I know what it feels like to have, like, 30 Elsas you love😂. And we agree on many voices like Hanna (such a sweet comment you made💕), Ana (lately I've started to realize how much of her potential I ignored), Serena (though I think in F2 she's not as powerful as she was in the first movie, mainly in ITU), Sophy (I'm afraid the lyrics do reflect the sad situation Hong Kong was and is facing), Park Hye-Na (she understood Elsa's depth and feelings, she would be in my top 5), Hú Wéi-Nà (well, she is a powerhouse). And I won't even comment on Nesma, Anna, Katarzyna, Sía... I don't have the right words for their amazing voices, they're all my favorites! As much as I love Marianne, I still believe my perfect Elsa is Queen Maria Lucia, she IS Elsa, followed by Annika. BTW at 9:00 and 11:20 you used the same text by mistake

[@Meirenyu]

ohhh you haven't seen Frozen 2? It's certainly worth a watch, but you'll probably still come to the same conclusion as you already have now - which is that it's overrated (I agree 😂) I like Carmen more than the Lithuanian/Slovene/Slovak group because she sounds really youthful & beautiful in some parts! quite a lot of people have Nataša as their guilty pleasure, so you're not alone there, and I definitely think she improved in the sequel. Takako & Willemijn are ones that I want to put higher, but also have too many versions I like more 🥺 you won't comment on Anna, as in Anna Buturlina; so you're one of her fans too? Maria Lucia is still my favourite Elsa in Frozen, but Marianne just stole my heart here 💕 and yep that was a mistake on my part, it's meant to say "time for the top 10" at 9:00 🙈

[@elsasicekingdom8146]

Toto 5 disagree with hanna liina

[@blueberry-debil]

well well well, what have we here!! a cute eye candy of an editing, that's what 😍 also a few disappointments like Czech, Ukrainian, Croatian, Japanese, Turkish and WILLEMIJN being quite low, surprises like Russian so high and Slovak & Hindi not last 👁👄👁 but most importantly a lot of agreements, starting from top 20 💟 particularly happy to see Italian, Greek, Finnish, Telugu, Arabic, Korean, Swedish, Danish & Northern Sami all in there and of course, thanks a lot for Kasia's 7th place 💗 I'm always so happy to see her work appreciated 😭 amazing video as always, I'd love to see your ranking of Anna too but it's ekhem just a suggestion 👀

[@Meirenyu]

Your comments are always such word-candy 😌 thank you! I don't think I've ever seen Slovak or Hindi in last, but they are usually placed near the bottom. Glad to see you agree on Telugu, she is so underrated! as for Anna's voices, I came to the realisation that I've wronged Magda in my Polish ranking 🙈 not sure when I'll be able to edit an Anna ranking though, Frozen rankings are so exhausting lol 💀

[@AnnieFrozenHeart]

Speak of eye-candy editing! I really love the color of this video and that Elsa fanart is to die for! 😍 As for the ranking itself, your comment on Monika made me giggle haha, you don't need to apologize! As much as I love her, I understand the concept of "different opinions" 😂 I must say I really loved your analogies throughout the video! - Comparing Maria Lucia to chocolate, Hanna to cherry blossoms... Brilliant! Kinda sad to see Carmen on the bottom half, not because of my Latin pride (😂) but because I truly believe her to have improved for the sequel - but I guess so did everyone else :( - your top 10 is beautiful! Loved your comment on Hu Wei Na! And of course, such a gorgeous and well-deserved 1st spot ❤

[@Meirenyu]

This fanart of Elsa is probably my favourite out of all the fanarts that I've used for character rankings 😍 although Elsa does benefit from being a popular character and hence having more fanarts out there! haha for Monika, that's exactly why I mentioned you, because you respectfully understand the concept of different opinions 😅 sorry about Carmen, but you're right I like her here more than in "Libre Soy" but you're also very right in saying that most others improved too. I'm glad the comment for Hu Wei-Na made sense too! and as always, thank you for your lovely comment 🥰

[@SpinelSun]

Ahhhh such a beautiful ranking! I love the way you write your comments you're always so thoughtful and polite. Amazing job

[@Meirenyu]

awww thank you so much 🥰 Gisela just kept creeping higher & higher - I love her so much in the second movie! Ramya is so underrated! Dalma is pretty underrated too, she certainly deserves being in someone's top 3 😌 ugh yes it would be wonderful if the Hebrew version was mixed againQ

[@pakinyaisumpunpong9175]

Form Thailand Gam Wichayanee got her nickname "Gam the star" because she won the singing competition's called "The star"

[@ElsannaPL]

I love the comments, they hit the spot without looking like a drama invitation in the comments ;) And you're fast, you managed to include a version that was out literally 2 days ago and gotten in HQ like yesterday, congrats :D The saying about Asians definitely applies to you on the Asian part ;) 42nd - I respect it but I strongly disagree, the Karen thing is mood tho XD Icelandic tho is the one I don't take that excuse you take XD Her speaking is good, but as Elsa sings a lot here it's where a split voice comes in or finding someone else entirely... Interesting story on Yǒng-Chún, I already thought she's kind of personal favorite of the dub director XD I'm not a fan of overusing voices tho, especially when they are lots of other great dubbers around.... Tamil and Telugu thing, good I know I'm not the only one who had problems with distinguishing these XD Also, Ramya reminds me a bit of Polish voices XD 7th place, thanks so much

[@Meirenyu]

Thanks so much for your comment dear! sorry it has taken my so long to reply, I wanted to properly read & digest what you wrote 😌 "hit the spot without looking like a drama invitation" - that's exactly what I had in mind when writing the comments! I debated whether or not to include the Indonesian version, it helps that I roughly had an idea of where she was ranked in the first movie and familiarity with her voice already! if I didn't there'd probably be "where's Indonesian" comments 😂 haha that was not my intention at all with that joke about Asians, but awww thank you 🥰 yeahhh I'm so confused why the dubbing director loves Yong-Chun so much, I just can't hear it 😕 interesting, why do you think Ramya reminds you of Polihs voices? The chocolate metaphor was more of a subtle one lol but glad you understood 😀 I thought the same too, high-ley wish she also sung the Norwegian version! it's not like it can't happen, Willemijn sung two versions too. And wow that's such a sweet fun fact to find out, thanks for sharing!

[@ElsannaPL]

@@Meirenyu You're welcome

[@elzavilaga]

I guess I and almost most of disnerds totally agree with your ranking. What a great choices. Thanks for creating such a lovely video. I’m so happy to hear that you love Sámi Elsa, Marianne. She would be absolutely happy to have you. I absolutely love Marianne. ❤ However it’s kinda funny two of Norwegian women came the last and the first. XD

[@Meirenyu]

@@elzavilaga awww thank you so much for such lovely words 🥰 glad to hear you love Marianne too! and haha that was not intentional but it is ironic

[@AedeusLeonora]

I totally agree with your #1 - she is amazing! 💖

[@Meirenyu]

Amazing indeed 💞

[@carterhurd590]

@@Meirenyu can you please reply to my comment

[@PrincesseAley]

#1 is just simply breathtaking isn’t she 😍 also loved your comment on Katja - I completely agree! Also your #7 #6 #4 #2 are big favs of mine, glad to see them so high! And your design is beautiful as always, I love the colors and the overlay of Elsa looking away😍

[@Meirenyu]

As a Finn you must be so heartwarmed to see a Sami dub 😍 Katja was probably the biggest improvement and this opinion seems to be shared universally! thank you so much lovely 🥰

[@rishabhrox1]

Gotta say this is one of the most honest and well thought out rankings of Elsa, or in general here on KZbin! :D Coming forth is a long comment cuz, this ranking put forth a looot of interesting points! :D I'm SO GLAD you pointed out in your own politically correct way, the issue that fanboys/fangirls of certain versions create if their version is lower than they expect. People need to learn TOLERANCE and DIVERSITY of OPINIONS here on KZbin. Coming to the ranking itself, I'd start by saying your comment on Sunidhi was on point, she IS "rough around the edges"; I guess that sound is not for everyone, or in particular, for non Indians. Sunidhi actually has the same sound in most of her real life songs as well; it's her USP in an industry which otherwise was dominated by high pitched Snow White-ish voices since the 50s. :) Shruti was INDEED casted on basis of her popularity as an actress, in fact, all three speaking voices of Elsa in F2 were casted on the same basis, and many Indians echoed the same negative feeling against it as you do before the film released. At the SAME time though, I'd like to point out that Yong Chun, whether we like it or not, was ALSO casted, somewhere, because of her association with the dubbing director. That's a kind of nepotism if you look at it. In Shruti's defense, she just has one role owing to this celeb status; but Yong Chun had THREE MAJOR PROTAGONIST roles back to back because of this nepotism - and I'm sorry, but I don't think she deserved it either even if she's not a celeb. Another good point you made was in the Romanian comment - 'not showing off' doesn't immediately mean the singer is very genuine or humble or interpretative, sometimes it's just mediocrity and it should be pointed out as it is. Strong agreement! :D Beautiful comment on Finnish, except I do think she still shouts...but only in a much more controlled manner, it's almost like she worked on her belting technique these years and, it certainly seems to pay off! :D I am okay with the placement of Italian, but in the comment you mentioned 'daintiness' as a thing you associate with Elsa, which I don't agree with. For me she has a poise, a certain reserved enigma about her, but for me it doesn't translate as dainty. Not judging your viewpoint though, it's interesting how the same character can come off differently to different people! ;) I'm glad to know you like the Telugu singer that much; AND that you think she's different from Tamil HAHAHA (idk how I feel about this tbh, not singling you out, but maaany people lump Tamil and Telugu together even in cases like this where the singers are different ksks) I take it that because the discovery of these dubs was new, that's why it is happening, and I hope it changes, at least in cases where the singers in the two languages aren't the same. Lastly, I appreciate every voice in your top 10 even if not all of them would be in mine. *MIC DROP* ;)

[@Meirenyu]

Thank you so much for your long comment Rishabh! it's such a 'hidden' treasure, I always appreciate long comments, especially ones with discussions of points, as opposed to "this higher, that lower" - so here is an incoming long comment in return: I think there's lots of talk about ranking comments being respectful, and not discounting that in any way, because it is so important - being honest in comments is really important too! whilst still being respectful of course. Haha I'm relieved most people picked up on those politically correct comments, I wasn't sure if the chocolate analogy was too subtle for the point I was trying to make. As for Sunidhi, I didn't know that about her, but now it definitely makes me appreciate her more. Except as someone whose exposure to the Indian music industry isn't saturated, I actually love that typical Snow-White-ish voice. It's so iconically Indian & exotic! I remember as a child I loved this Indian song on Just Dance Wii called "Katti Kalandal" 😀 oh totally agree that it is nepotism involved in Yong-Chun's casting 😑 I suppose my comment came across as nicer than intended lol. She definitely doesn't deserve it. And I've already been that person who comments in every ranking "I'd put Yong-Chun lower" 😂 yesss glad we see eye-to-eye on the mediocre thing! and vice versa, just because someone is the polar opposite of mediocre, showstopping, it doesn't mean they're not genuine/humble. You're right, in retrospect "dainty" was not the term I was trying to express, "poised" is a much better word! I feel the same whenever I see the Tamil & Telugu versions lumped together, I don't care if you prefer the Tamil version more, as long as you have an appreciation that they sound different.

[@FlamSparks]

GOSH your sugary editing is always to die for Lol love your extremely politically correct comments on the bottom positions x) I was honestly afraid a reason like that was behind Jasmine's cast for *all* roles in 2019...recommended by her teacher _and_ dubbing director....it's so sad when such things happen, I find it even worse than casting celebrities (at least they have already proven their talent _somewhere else)_ ...is that a very bad spoiler at 8:59? For how much I like Marianne and am glad she is Elsa's _alternative_ native voice...she sounds a tad too inexperienced to me, there are many passages where she sounds a bit fandubbish...a bit like Charlotte, maybe

[@Meirenyu]

As much as I'd never think to describe editing as sugary - you are so right haha! and I'm also laughing at your comment about the politically correct comments 😂 I suppose the comment for Cai Yong-Chun came across as less 'aggressive' than intended, but yes totally agree and it's annoying to see that happen. I also agree with your comparison to casting celebrities, as least somewhere else they've proven their talent! and 8:59 it's a mistake, it's meant to say "time for the top 10" 🙈 though I don't think it was too much of a spoiler, because most people love Maria Lucia so you can have your bet she'll be high. I beg to differ for Marianne though, I think I her inexperience is just the right amount! I know what you mean by inexperience making it sound fandubbish, then there's also the inexperience that makes it sound more genuine & heartfelt. As opposed to the other end of the spectrum, when they're too experience & professional it becomes 'just another show'

[@meliae.]

It just confirms what we've been saying for some time now - we REALLY have similar taste! 🥰 I was nodding and nodding...until Nataša appeared, she's grown on me so much, I've got "indescribable feelings" towards her. 💀We need more Ramya appreciation, some people claim she's like Shruti's twin, but they're day and night to me. I knew you were a huge Anna Burtulina fan, but seeing her this high really surprised me (not negatively though). Your comment on Willejmin feels so accurate, she's such a gifted singer, but somewhat distant from Elsa at the same time. I might be the only one who was never really taken in by Marianne's charm, but on the other hand, I'm happy she's got her avid fans. Hu-Wei-Na has always sounded like an epitome of wisdom to me and the way you put it into words is so incisive! I absolutely adore that Elsa picture, that raised finger of hers iddicates "Hm, that's interesting" and it was literally my reaction throughout the whole video! ❤️

[@Meirenyu]

That's always me too whenever I watched your rankings - nodding & nodding 😂 Nataša to you is like Anna Buturlina to me, I know rationally she should be lower but I just love her regardless of logic. yesss love to see some Ramya appreciation! that's exactly it for Willemijn, I've sort of felt the same distance as Idina's Elsa, except she sings the songs much better. oh dear I'm predicting it now that in a couple months time you'll be falling under Marianne's charm, just you wait 🐷 this is probably my favourite fanart that I've used throughout all the character rankings - the raised finger is so poised!

[@buddyatiny]

Gosh...as always you're edit is amazing👏💜 and Elsa voices are wonderful😍

[@Meirenyu]

Merci beaucoup 🥰

[@Elysianyt]

GORGEOUS editing! You literally outdo yourself with every video ❤️️ Your comments are so kind and unique, and your anaology game is truly on point here lol. I liked the remarks you made on both Latin American versions, as long as they please the target audience, who cares about what others think - though some people do get extremely sensitive unfortunately :/ I loved the comment on Sophy, and although she'll never beat Jobelle in my ears, I still appreciate her Elsa a lot 🥰 As for Idina, although I'm among those who really enjoy her Elsa, I totally agree with her placement and comment :D Your number one was truly unexpected but I love that Marianne is getting the recognition she deserves 💕

[@Meirenyu]

awww you're too kind, thanks so much 🥰 haha I'm constantly using analogies at work to explain stuff to people, so I think that rubbed off here 😂 yeah can't relate to that feeling of being very sensitive about certain versions, I don't even mean that in a bad way, just I wonder what it is like. I'd forgotten for a moment there that Jobelle was your favourite Elsa, but thanks for the reminder, I'm glad she is 😌 I really wish I could enjoy Idina's Elsa more, I love her Broadway performances, especially Defying Gravity! Wicked is such an amazing musical

[@Anna2001]

Wow! Thank you so much for 5th place! Anna usually turns out to be among 20th or so places, in just "okay/good" category. And, generally, I can understand why. Her "icy" delivery scares some people off. But she's dubbing the ICE queen after all, isn't she? XD

[@Meirenyu]

You’re welcome! I’ve always been a huge fan of Anna Buturlina - despite what many say about her 😌 and you’re exactly right, “icy” is the perfect word to describe her!

[@raneemacintosh6842]

I'm glad to see a sequel-only rank. I plan to do one someday. Usually I'd be sad for Monika, one I used to love, but she tumbled in the sequel. I'm glad someone else is pointing out Nuška and Girmantė are twinsies. I never realized Nataša and Jolante are similar but you're so right....hah I very much agree with putting Idina as the 'official border' between the versions you like and the versions you don't. Finnish glowup seems an almost universal opinion. I think I'd put the Indian versions in reverse order compared to you. Nice inclusion of Iduna in polish. Love her.

[@Meirenyu]

I absolutely cannot wait to see your Frozen 2 Elsa ranking! though I hope this time there won't be a WW4 (your Moana ranking was WW3) but stay true to your opinions and don't let a temptation to please get in the way 😄 two sets of twinsies there, may I also add Kasia & Wei-Na! in my opinion they sound very similar too! I've finally been able to place Idina in the 20s, she improved in Frozen 2 for sure

[@movieslover9094]

Where to start? I won't comment on my deesagrements or agreements this time, except that you have some different choices and that made this ranking much more interesting ! I specially love your comment on Cantonese and Korean versions, you commented those with such honesty and knowledge ^^ (even though some things are only a matter of taste). Maybe this is the first time I saw Sami at first and that was a nice surprise. Beautiful ranking, keep doing the good work :D

[@Meirenyu]

Thanks for all your lovely words 🥰 for Cantonese, I just felt the imperative to make that comment! I'm glad everyone is pleasantly surprised and not shockingly surprised that Marianne is in first - she certainly deserves it! are we going to get a updated Elsa ranking from you at all? 😀

[@movieslover9094]

@@Meirenyu It will take a bit unfortunatelly, I have the list already but I have no time these days to make the ranking. I'm hoping that in 3 week I'll have it done! :D

[@carterhurd590]

Elsa is watching herself singing and hearing her different versions of her, I bet she is like "WOW, I have so many countries representing and being me, incredible

[@storymaker1004]

The editing is sooo pretty💞. Thanks for Dutch/German, even tho I'd place her higher but I'm probably biased (I respect your opinion tho). Also thanks for French, she's my favorite Elsa of both movies.

[@Meirenyu]

Thanks so much 🥰 even though Charlotte & Anaïs sound really similar, for some reason I prefer Charlotte!

[@YHTheGamer]

I wouldn't mind watching those repetitive Elsa rankings since yours is probably my most relate one! Taryn if were to be ranked by singing instead of the cast fitting then she would be probably be in my Top 10😆 I am surprised to see Ramya that high, she does have a unique feel to Elsa and I myself can't differentiate her and Shruti but if I have to choose 1, it will be Ramya by a little. I honestly starting to like Indonesian dubs and the 'Newest Elsa' is the reason😊 Can't wait for my neighbouring country to dub Frozen 2 songs! I do have to agree on your Kazakh comment, she does sound powerful like Maria Lucia yes but uh isn't she a little too far off? I kept thinking that this is a different song tbh:/ Thanks for 22nd(My Favourite Elsa), she is the Elsa I can most relate with especially the 2nd chorus. Ahh yes the Cantonese lyrics, I absolutely like their creativity in these lyrics that's for sure😀 I really like your taste in your top 10, majority are my favs especially Annika and Maria Lucia but maybe your first isn't my cup of tea but still she's a phenomenal singer:) Your layout, comments and editing is as always aesthetically pleasing to see and thanks for reading my long pointless comment xD

[@Meirenyu]

Good to know you still enjoyed it despite the flood of Elsa rankings 😂 I used to be indifferent to Indonesian dubs, probably because it was Beatrix all the time - but I LOVE their latest voices Moana & Jasmine 2019! and same here, can't wait for Malaysia to dub these songs 💕 you're right, Gulsim is an amazing singer, but it doesn't feel like she's singing the songs as Elsa. ohhh I wouldn't have guessed Jelena is your favourite Elsa! despite 22 seeming 'low' I honestly do really like her too! don't think I've seen her in 1st ever though, so maybe it's time for you to finally make a ranking 😍 thanks so much for your kind words, as always!

[@diokles]

FINE now the real comment; Just like everyone's saying, your commentary skills are just splendid, and I love how you pointed out the fact that Latinos & Brazilians love their respective Elsas while they're not that popular overall in our community, their audience is what matters after all 😌 Why does Shanis actually sound like a Karen omg, talk about brilliant comparisons lol. Elsa's voices definitely show themselves in low notes, and that's kind of sad because these songs lowkey require the opposite, which also explains my overall disappointment in this sequel's performances. They still did deliver emotionally anyway! I literally smiled at Japanese, such a cute little story 😭 My thoughts exactly on Italian! It's just that she's not that powerful in this sequel imo either ... LOVE your comment on Cantonese so much, I hope civils in Hong Kong get to see the light & be free & independent soon 🥺 Ironic that we have the exact opposite opinions on Tamil & Telugu hah, but boy do I appreciate your unique top 10 ❤ (Even if a couple of them are not my favourites, but you still manage to persuade with your sugary & straightforward comments aghh) And last but not least, the layout of your rankings is simply timeless, love it so so much. ❤

[@Meirenyu]

awww thanks for saying that you enjoyed the commentary 🥰 I didn't spend too much on consolidating my opinions this time, just wrote down whatever first came to mind - maybe some comments are a bit too honest 🤷🏻‍♀️ on the Karen part, it had to be that scene too, I just picture her barging in to a shop demanding a refund or something 😂 interesting how you thought most Elsa's are better in Frozen, I think the vast majority improved! at least vocally. I lived closed to a Disney Japan merchandise shop in Japan and spent SO MUCH money there! I should show you all the Rapunzel stuff I have 😂 as for Tamil & Telugu, I think it's not so much who you prefer, but as long as you recognise there's a difference between them! haha that's the second time someone's commented "sugary" - I suppose I'll take it as a compliment 😌

[@ClaudiaBronte]

It's great to see a new ranking from you dear! As always I really enjoyed eveything, from the peaceful and graceful editing, to your respectful and interesting comments!

[@Meirenyu]

awww I'm flattered that you think my editing is peaceful & graceful 🥰 by the way I don't know if I've ever told you this, but despite what my channel's videos are, I'm not that big of a Frozen fan either, in terms of plot/characters. The part that I do love is the songs! and when you make videos it's just taking that into consideration. So you're not alone there 😁 I'll forever love the Renaissance movies more! Elsa got a bit annoying in the second movie lol - I think Disney tried too hard to make her seem selfless & don't want others to sacrifice themselves for me that it ended up being the other way around. Anyway, sorry too if my comment is messy - yours certainly wasn't I understood it all 😌

[@ClaudiaBronte]

@@Meirenyu Your editing is always beautiful, love it ❤ Well, I'm glad I'm not alone thinking that about Frozen plot and characters (especially in the second movie, as you said)! The songs are the best part of Frozen in general, I totally agree! Ahaha, no worries, I understod everything dear ❤

[@aemieiei5604]

I agree with Icelandic, her speaking for Elsa is so soft like snow ❄ awww Romanian, why they are so forgettable, I like their dubbing, especially Elsa!! Bulgarian is opposite for me, I didn't care her at first but now she is in top 5, she has grown up on me so much haha 😂 oh I really love Chinese Mandarin Elsa, she gives me so much queen vibes (she's my number 1💖) and ooooh THAI???!! thank you so much!!!!!! (Her nickname is from the singing competition she won, which is called "The Star"😊. But now we call her Gam Wichayanee instead of Gam the Star😂) Swedish and Danish are... amazing, seeing both of them again after 6 years is so nostalgic because I really liked both of them when I was a kid and now I still 😂😭 and ooh your number 1!!! I clap my hands for their casting, both of Elsa and Anna are so great🥰💖 And your editing is so beautiful and magical💖🌟!!

[@Meirenyu]

Thank you so much 🥰 I'm glad to hear Nadezhda is in your top 5 wow, a rarity but she certainly deserves it! and double-yay for Hu Wei-Na! ohhh that makes sense for The Star, so is her given name Gam or Wichayanee? And yes your Elsa's always been one of my ultimate favourites 💕

[@aemieiei5604]

@@Meirenyu Gam is her nickname and Wichayanee is her given name >

[@mona_disney]

What a wonderful personal ranking, thanks to the 35th, 15th and 6th place💖

[@Meirenyu]

Thank you! aw nice to see another Chinese person around here 😊

[@arjunabetta4572]

Totally agreed on your number 1. When I listened to her for the first time, I thought that she was quite normal but my love grew after listening to it for so many times. She is really Elsa! She might sound shy and introverted but in Show Yourself, she is really confident and powerful. She totally embodies the characteristic of Elsa. Well actually I hope that Shila would be Iduna but let the time decide :)

[@Meirenyu]

I love how everyone who loves Marianne's Elsa pretty much uses the exact same phrases to describe her! couldn't agree more with "shy & introverted" as well as "confident & powerful" 🙌 Shila & Marsha... wow that would be a phenomenal duet combo 😍

[@josefine7095]

I might be biased but I too love the nr1 spot version. I think her voice fits incredible well considering their non existent dubbing history in the past. She may lack the acting, but she more than enough catches up with it through the effortless rendition of the song. She feels so incredibly sincere, kind, maybe a bit naive, but also powerful where it counts. She does not sound too old either. I love her so much

[@Meirenyu]

When you say you're biased, do you mean you speak a Sami language, or you're from Norway? I love your description so much, it really consolidates everything about Marianne's Elsa and I couldn't agree more with literally every point 🥰

[@josefine7095]

Meirenyu I am Norwegian and have sami relatives. However, I do not speak the language myself. It is a beautiful language, just a shame that noray treats it so unfairly when it comes to entertainment and media. Hearing these songs in sami literally brought tears to my eyes. It made me so happy for them to finally have a disney film in their own language. It also made me happy seeing how their cast is sooo much better than the norwegian cast.

[@FeliciaGoldfire]

I actually haven't been listening to Elsa's voices that much this time around and from what I've seen in rankings and one lines I don't really like most of them :/ I feel like most of them grew up more than Elsa did. But your number one is definitely one of the best, I love her! ^_^

[@Meirenyu]

You don't have to feel bad about not really liking most of them 😌 definitely can see where you're coming from - as I wrote, many of Elsa's voices simply aren't suited to belting high notes in this Broadway-style that only caters for a very niche singing technique! glad to see you like Marianne though, it's always that tiny bit more special when a Nordic person says that 🥰

[@abeda.7692]

I love this editing layout you've been using for rankings so much! We see eye to eye on so many of the low-placed versions, and the comment on Taiwanese was an interesting piece of info. I don't appreciate when irrelevant factors such as knowing the directors directly are involved in the casting decisions -.- The result of it is not impressive more often than not. Totally agree about Romanian and Turkish! The latter has improved a lot in this film imo. That's an interesting viewpoint you have about Willemijn 🤔 Even though I haven't formed an opinion on Nadezhda in F2, she's one of my favs in F1 too :D The top 15 have so many gems 😍 I love this "an innovation not an imitation" phrase you use to describe Nesma! I think it sums her up neatly, and could work for those who don't like her too x) Kasia is such a diamond

[@Meirenyu]

To add to that, the dubbing director himself is actually the voice of Kristoff - so it's kind of strange, almost like Disney Taiwan has contracted out the official authority to an independent studio 😐 but yes totally agree, I also don't appreciate this kind of behaviour, even if the voice cast was really amazing. Even in the first movie, I loved Begüm! as with the comment here, whenever she says "Aldirma" it sounds like she's casting a spell. I know right, "innovation not an imitation" are the perfect words to describe Nesma! I actually discovered that phrase when watching a video about why Disney live-action remakes are awful - and the problem is that they only imitate and not innovate. Well, Mulan 2020 was an innovation but still failed 🤭 oh you're allowed to dislike chocolate for the taste itself, whereas disliking chocolate because everyone else loves it and you want your opinion to seem unique - haha hope the subtle message came through there 😅 awww "close to the heart" now that's the perfect phrase for Marianne! thanks for inventing that one 😍

[@abeda.7692]

To be fair I haven’t seen Mulan yet, but I’ve seen mixed reviews about it... but it says something if you think it has failed, for I remember you were quite excited about it! Haha I’m glad you approve of “Close to the heart” about Marianne. It is a phrase I use for only one other singer, Hisham Nour, as Hercules and Quasimodo in Arabic 🥰

[@ToLeNam]

It's intetesting to see your opinion as I followed you long ago amd saw your comment on so many ranking but still don't know your Elsa rank lol xD This is indeed interesting to watch! I was surprised with Telugu tho, she's not my favourite tho as I prefer Tamil more, also, I think they are quite different tho. Thank you so much for Quynh to be that high 😍 I know you love Yen more tho, but I glad you also feel the same as me with the replacement. Your top 5 is definitely interesting and reallu amazing (and funny for ur 1st and last are in the same footage of the video u included lol xD).

[@Meirenyu]

Thanks! it’s taken me months to whip out this ranking, but I’m glad it’s finally here 🤗 ohhh so her name is Quynh, I didn’t know which of the 4 it was. Both Quynh & Sophy are actually good replacements, if you give them a chance instead of only be sad that that Yen & Jobelle didn’t return. oh my gosh haha I only realised that while making the video - it’s SO IRONIC 😂

[@ToLeNam]

@@Meirenyu Well VNese name is just like Chinese name, surname first - then forename :p

[@Meirenyu]

I figured it was either Nhu or Quynh by that logic, but does that mean she has two surnames & two firstnames?

[@ToLeNam]

@@Meirenyu Well, for 4 character names, her surname is Tiêu, middle name is Châu, and first name is Như Quỳnh but we can just call Quỳnh.

[@Meirenyu]

ohhh that makes sense now - I didn’t know in Vietnamese there’s middle names! in Chinese we don’t have such a thing 😔

[@tilney8467]

Beautiful vid!! I generally agree, even with Czech which I loved in the first movie... Here this is too much. Seeing Norwegian this low, even if I do agree, is truly a heartbreak when they brought so many haunting & unique voices to the dubbing world. They failed the one role that was made for them, it really is a heartbreak! Entirely agree with your comment about Slovene, and God knows how great she was in the first movie - I blame the songs, they were so Broadway-like that it kind of killed the diversity of Elsa's voices... Your comment about Taiwanese was so intriguing, like they really did choose her for her personality rather than her singing skills? I love it! I like Kazakh for the same reason you pointed out as a flaw, I don't know, it gives a "sassy" side to Elsa. When it comes to Idina, this is so weird! They created a character for her, but the character slipped out of their control and became something else far from Idina. Same for the songs, when they are clearly made to show off Idina's vocal abilities, some of them still manage to slip out of this goal and so, Idina ends up being far from them when they were made for her.. it really is weird. Yes for Romanian, I like so much her unrefined, weaker Elsa, it balances well the songs. Agree about Willemijn. Your comment about Serbian made me laugh, even if I can't see a queen bee in Jelena's voice, she has something too "scary" in it, but I must be the only one freaking out :D Nice to see many favorites so high, we really have a similar taste. Glad for Charlotte, and 100% agree with your comment about her, but this princessy Elsa is truly endearing. Nice comment about Arabic. i see your point about Russian, but this stressful Elsa can be hard to rely on (I wouldn't rely on her to be the ruler of my country, if it makes sense). So glad for Danish, she is priceless, probably the biggest Disney dub ever. Glad to see Northern Sami on the top, she is amazing! Well, it was an amazing ranking, a true delight both for the eyes and the mind ;)

[@Meirenyu]

awww your comment was so sweet 🥰 it's the first time hearing "delight for the mind" - that's always more important than aesthetics & editing, as much as I do love that part too! I'm touched by that compliment 😌 yep agree, I can't think of any other native voice that didn't do as well. Not only are the songs so Broadway-like, they are Idina-aimed. Whilst I do find it cute that she was chosen for her personality, it's still annoying that she was every single voice in 2019, and others didn't get a chance 🙁 yesss agree about what you said for Idina - sometimes I wonder what it is about Idina that Disney thought was perfect for Elsa. If you think about Kristen Bell, even if you aren't a fan of her Anna (though I'm yet to meet anyone who doesn't) she just screams Anna! haha I know what you mean about Jelena, some parts I absolutely adore her - she sounds beautiful & gentle, but other times not at all! as a French person, do yo prefer Anaïs or Charlotte? 😀

[@tilney8467]

I wonder the same about Idina, but it scares me a little as I fear the Disney company will perhaps do this again - choosing a famous Broadway star and making big loud songs for her rather than for the character... but well it can work anyway, such as Kristen Bell as you said 😊 I like much much more Charlotte, I struggle since 2013 with Anaïs' vibrato and her weird accent when Charlotte is much smoother + has such a tender and humble sound! I'm really glad she became our Elsa, and she certainly became mine 👌

[@TokageSan]

Hey! Lovely video! I was wondering if you knew where I could find the Putonghua dub of Aladdin (animated) it's been difficult finding it anywhere

[@oklah8201]

I think malay will use “serlahkan” or “tampilah” or maybe same like indonesia “tunjukkan/tunjuklah”..but in into the unknown “yang tak dikenal” will never use in malay lyrics cause that sound weird and strange..btw mikha in HQ sound so powerful same like marsha because her vocal sound strong same like marsha..but the lyrics sound out of tune urghhh Im frusted

[@Meirenyu]

So it’s confirmed there’s a Malay dub?

[@oklah8201]

Meirenyu yes but maybe in summer 2021,December 2021 or in 2022 same like moana..

[@Meirenyu]

yay! but 2022, that’s such a long time to wait 😭

[@zahraofficial8411]

I like Indonesian voice by Mikha Sherly so beautiful voice

[@daffaloudy7639]

Good ranking !!! Thanks for 31th place. By the way, Elsa's voices in Czech has reminds me of Jana's Pocahontas, Turkish Elsa has reminds me of Otilia Radulescu Ipek, Icelandic Elsa has reminds me of Selma Bjonsdottir and Portuguese Elsa has reminds me of Anabela Pires !! Be a good youtuber !! I'm respect you're opinion too !!!

[@Meirenyu]

Thanks! I agree with most of those resemblances, except Augusta sounds nothing like Selma lol 🤨

[@seunghansshi]

Fun Fact: people who like the Telugu versions a lot are special to me bc I think she's super underrated hahahahahaha The comment style is very new to me. Its not the typical "polished" style but rather a raw, unscripted and as you mentioned "rambling of my mind" kinda thing. I like it! Its not something you always expect in a ranking ;) I'm surprised you didn't say much about Tsai Yong-chun's performance for F2 but placed a trivia instead XD I'm really meh with her. She's good but she lacks a lot of elements. I wish they cast the Iduna voice instead for Elsa. I mean some of the 2019 Jasmines were literally cast as Iduna (Sunitha Sarathy, Ding Shuang, and etc..) and she makes an exception! To add, Rishabh's comment below does make it sound like nepotism, but I won't delve much into that... Your comment for Russian is actually somewhat true...there's just something about Anna's performance that makes it addictive to listen to. Yes, not the most polished, but there's something about her vnov za gariZAAAAAANT that draws you to it lol. Kinda interesting to see Willemijn in a lower spot, since out of the musical singers, she's often placed high. I like her German version more as always...since she sounds more humble and less powerful. Glad to see Marianne take home the gold!

[@Meirenyu]

yesss Ramya is SO underrated! I think it's because she's a newcomer (same with Northern Sami!) I didn't write anything else about Cai Yong-Chun because there was no space left 😂 also I've commented on lots of rankings, especially Jasmine 2019 that I'd put her lower lol 🙈 oh my that "vnov za garizant" line is such a perfect example! and I love your way of writing it, that's exactly how it sounds! I like Willemijn's German version better too, especially because German Iduna is my favourite 💕 I don't know when I'll be able to do Anna's ranking - I feel like I need a mental break from editing Frozen rankings 😂

[@landry61]

Finally, a rating where Finnish is high

[@cassidyh5021]

7:02 my favorite voice from Frozen 2. My all time favorite didn’t reprise her role. Who can guess which one is my most favorite?

[@natasaarsic3718]

Marsha Milan Londoh?

[@cassidyh5021]

@@natasaarsic3718 No but she’s one of my favorites.

[@natasaarsic3718]

​@@cassidyh5021Jobelle Ubalde, Anais Delva

[@cassidyh5021]

@@natasaarsic3718 you got it! It’s Anaïs. I do like Jobelle especially in the reprise of For The First Time In Forever.

[@natasharomanov7565]

I've not even watched that movie! 😄😄 I am not really interested on Frozen as a film, as you know, so I haven't a specific opinion about the characters voices. Your number 1 though is totally bewitching, she has something really ancient and elegant, sometimes that counts most than any power or passion for me. Thank you for Sia, though I can't say that I like her on Disney characters, she is so theatrical for a queen/princess. She has a special voice to say the truth

[@Meirenyu]

awww I think you should definitely give Frozen 2 a watch if you have the time! it will be worth it 😌 I'm glad to hear you enjoy Marianne too, ancient is really a good word to describe her! I wish I'd thought of it in the ranking. But sad to hear you don't like Sia that much, what about Vassia then?

[@natasharomanov7565]

@@Meirenyu I like Vassia, she has this elegant element which I adore in some characters, I like her more as Mary Poppins than as Anna, because she was more classic. Sia is vocal beast, she wants to roar and I can't imagine Elsa like this, generally I like Sia.

[@Meirenyu]

I agree that Vassia is one of the most elegant Anna’s 💞 agree that both her & Annika are better as Mary Poppins!

[@natasharomanov7565]

@@Meirenyu Absolutely! 😍

[@fan_332]

Thanks 16

[@landry61]

I feel like Willemijn sounds much better in the Dutch version rather than German because at some parts in German she kinda sounds like she is speaking instead of singing

[@coldgirl538]

Nice video , Thanks for the 9# , i'm Arabic and I love you so much

[@Meirenyu]

You mean 9th 😜 but you’re welcome, I love Arabic dubs so much!

[@coldgirl538]

@@Meirenyu that's so nice to hear !💜

[@ravenmc7021]

What do you think of the Malay version that just came out?

[@repentbeetch]

Oh mah god, thank you so much for Russian 😘😘❄️

[@zuzanna5460]

Thanks for 7. I thought that Polish would be rated lower.

[@bakersgirl1]

Why isnt Malaysia dubbing Frozen 2 :(

[@แมวโขมยหัวใจ]

ชอบมากคะ

[@오길석-m5c]

9:17

[@fandedisney1020]

I was thinking that in this sequel Taryzn Spilzman will be more loved but now is even more hated. Hey, in the multilanguage of Something's never change all people vote a Ranking of Anna before Elsa but, well, I don't care. By the way, I see that your favourite character is Jasmine, so what do you think about the Jasmine of 2019?

[@Meirenyu]

In no way does Taryn being ranked in the 40s mean she is hated, or anyone else for that matter. I assure you I truly don’t hate any of Elsa’s voices, and I am certain that applies to many other people as well. I don’t think I’ve ever said that Jasmine is my favourite character, but I suppose you assumed that from me having Jasmine as my profile picture. Anyway to answer your question, Jasmine 2019 is portrayed as totally different to Jasmine 1992 - she’s such an inspirational character, especially in this feminist era. Her personality is one of my favourite out of Disney princesses! oh and Lara Suleiman is my 3rd favourite voice 😍

[@fandedisney1020]

@Meirenyu I personally think that Taryzn is a miscat, good voice in bad role for she, it's clearly that she sing better in the jazzy songs. For me the Jasmine of 1992 was very forgettable, they make shine more Aladdin and Jafar more than she. You think that Disney will give a Sami people a licence to dub more of Disney? It will be perfect a new Nordic version to rank

[@sourcandy2338]

0:53 :(

[@YHTheGamer]

I know how you feel... But you still have to respect her opinion tho

[@sourcandy2338]

Of course I will ^^

[@fan_332]

Yes:(