Mel C's astounding rendition of "I Don't Know How to Love Him" | Jesus Christ Superstar

[@evelyngarnham6152]

She always had the best voice of all the Spice Girls. Love her voice.

[@carolesmith2619]

Her voice was my least favourite 😊

[@ASW-kk7yz]

Rubbish! 😂 her voice is awful!!

[@kiwiang983]

Agree, imo, mel C had best voice, then Mel B, then Geri and then Emma, in that order.

[@shelleyphilcox4743]

Well done Mel...this is the first time the emphasis is really telling the story of a woman thinking through what her life is, her thoughts and experiences, her relationships with men and the idea of a different kind of love and what that really means for her. Previous renditions say the words but always seem detached from the personal deep reflection.

[@philipowen3370]

Mel was always the best singer out of the spice girls ❤

[@annestill8388]

Was just going to say the same thing. Brilliant voice

[@tonyhamid802]

A real change of style for Mel C. Love the tremolo in her voice and the sheer power. A voice made for the stage. She has such a natural sound full of personality. Thank you, Mel.

[@mojobag01]

Young Mel has put in a lot of hard work and it has paid off beautifully.

[@johntaylor9988]

Wow. Astonishingly good. Emotional. I didn’t expect that. Great job.

[@Rianewjob01]

This song is for an older woman and Mel C pulls it off wonderfully.

[@gerardhall603]

She has a power house of a voice. Her style is unique. Anyone doubting her vocal skills should have seen her in Blood Brothers as Mrs. Johnston. Acting and singing on point.

[@Teresa-ch3og]

I like this version of the song. It's more emotional than some versions I've seen.

[@mckengineer5727]

The best Spice, the most talented, also loved her work with Bryan Adams, a real talent

[@pibbitybibbity]

This one of the very best versions I’ve ever heard. The emotion, all the feelings were there. I never cared much for this song or this moment in the show, it always felt forced. But this felt true and real.

[@Teresa-ch3og]

I've always liked the song. I didn't like some of the softer sounding performances I have seen. I always thought it should be sung more powerfully and emotional like this.

[@SJ47668]

You haven’t heard many then. This was ok - kinda like an amdram version - she has a pleasant enough voice, but no belt, no passion, and no presence on the stage.

[@pibbitybibbity]

@ Well, I’ve been alive long enough to have heard everyone since Yvonne Elliman originated the role so I’m 100% sure I’ve heard enough to have my own opinion. So, thanks for your input, but run off now and save your gatekeeping for someone who gives an actual f*%k.

[@niram4107]

​@@pibbitybibbityAlive long enough but lacking skills in communication ettiquette.

[@helzie74]

Listen to the Kate Ceberano, John Farnham, Jon Stevens version. It's unbeatable.

[@amandaphillipson4408]

That’s a great performance.

[@alexfletcher5192]

She was always the natural talent. And she can prove it over and over again because she has it. Once you have your own voice, that's it really.

[@PeterLGଈ]

Breathy tremollo? Nice. Very nice. And so much power while sitting. ❤

[@NondualChristian]

I LOVE this song, in fact the entire musical. This was an unexpected treat when it popped up in my feed. Now I’ll have to go an watch Ian Gillan’s version of Gethsemene….

[@katieromano]

Love this rendition of this song. Go Mel C.

[@williammackay3321]

Oh my absolute goodness , absolutely the best version of this song I’ve ever heard ….. the realness and humanity and humbleness from Mel is untopable !!!! Fucking perfection !!!

[@camera2painting]

Mediocre at best. No depth to her voice.

[@Debbiesdilemmas]

Well done Mel.👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 You did this job the justice it deserves.🥰🥰🥰

[@sherylrawson2592]

Wow.. that was amazing Mel... you have grown into a beautiful soul ❤ xx

[@lieslnew8247]

Saw her in this in Melbourne with Tim Minchin in 2012. She was great. 😊

[@ddraigmafon4725]

I’ve always loved Mel’s voice, this version is stunning.

[@emmahowitt241]

Mel Cs voice was always the strongest when she was in the Spice Girls. But now her voice has matured further and has a finer tone now too, and a great vibrato control. Lovely

[@JudyArroyo-uo4sg]

Simply beautiful ❤️

[@juddshelton]

I love her, and I love her version.

[@juliegriffiths4272]

Just amazing. Thank you Mel C. You voice and rendition is so moving and authentic ❤

[@kenkowaluk2225]

So amazing! Brought tears to my eyes! The second time this has happened! That was long ago and we don’t talk anymore?

[@mikesimcox7932]

Beautiful in every aspect ❤ brilliant performance ❤

[@Annie.C.61]

Outstanding. Absolutely beautiful!

[@peterbedford380]

Beautiful what emotion she brings

[@soniaeldridge257]

Wow didn't realise what a beautiful voice she has

[@AustenMerritt]

Beautiful rendition!

[@carolclarke5839]

Always loved Mel she was the best singer out of the Spice Girls ❤❤❤

[@helenb8505]

Amazing. Just perfect. She ate this.

[@Andy-c3n]

Of all the spice girls Mel c was and still is the spiciest, what a voice 😊😊😊

[@bernadettewoodsmilliesmum]

Wow …..beautiful

[@LynneVarvell-d9m]

Saw her singing this live in the show. Goosebumps.

[@janetstephens6678]

Amazing Mel

[@MikeKingTheGlosterBirder]

Outstanding!

[@5356polaris]

October 1st 2013, I seen this version at the Hydro in Glasgow. A phenomenal experience. Mel C was at times mesmerising but Tim Minchin stole the show. On another note, this production's 'Could we start again please' ranks right towards the top of my musical theatre moments.

[@jezcartner4104]

Love this version

[@shelleyhobill4630]

Brilliant 👏

[@AnnaBellaChannel]

The Mary and Jesus can be seen here power-dressing as a couple. Love the outfits and the soft singing is awesome.

[@ItsMe-fs4df]

Just to balance out the comments, I love Mel's version 😂 Rough but with a heart of gold underneath

[@thomascuddihy2933]

Rough Unbelievable Comment It’s yours too have But you are wrong I’ve heard this song sung by many women Over fifty years And this is up there with Helen reddy Evonne Elliman And others It is magnificent

[@chris-4566]

Most “musical” singers have a trained stage musical voice. Mel’s voice is refreshingly different and bridges the gap between pop and classical. She was a good choice for the gig.

[@heatherdoherty5973]

Love it ❤

[@amangogna68]

Amazing musical ! ❤

[@melanietravers3139]

Amazing, well done mel❤

[@KW-K985]

Awesome Mel. Such a talent for Musical Theatre

[@kickthespike]

I saw this live in the O2 she was fantastic

[@laurapardoe5347]

That was absolutely stunning Mel ❤

[@HelenCharnock-x8s]

Talented girl.

[@SharonThomas-s8u]

ABSOLUTELY F,ING AMAZINGx

[@janetpaget]

Simply beautiful

[@keire2]

Go Mel ❤

[@Jim-x4q]

That was beautiful

[@heathero007]

Beautiful NZ

[@irenedavo3768]

Amazing!

[@Meli_Moondragon]

Goosebumps!!!

[@sharonjack8582]

Beautiful. USA

[@terereynolds698]

I remember Jesus Christ Superstar, Yvonne Ellerman was the original singer, she played Mary Magdalen.

[@Trident22]

Mel had best voice by far in group.

[@simonbrown6441]

Please listen to Kate Ceberano from the Australian production about 20 years ago. On another level.

[@natanpierce495]

Best version I like. But not just because of her voice, which seems less "put-on" and has more feel than the other versions, but when she sings, "I've really changed" the way she changes while singing going from a hard cynically "maybe-he's-the-one" to 'Yes, I love Him so.' Brings a real redemption to what this is all about...through the eyes of Judas of course. Great performance.

[@DJC819]

Cmon dynamics

[@GemStar79]

Margaret Urlich from The Cats Away in NZ had the best version of this song ❤❤❤

[@dawnandresen4615]

She did a good job, but Yvonne Elliman was always the best

[@MayorofDipshittery-lq7if]

One of only two singers in the spice girls, the others were making up the numbers.

[@fiham4407]

Can't beat the Helen Ready version.

[@ernestwakefield]

Good effort 😮😮

[@benbernard9135]

🖤

[@garcia207]

Way to go Sporty Spice

[@julierowles6429]

I love Mel’s voice she was the best singer in the spice girls.

[@Mali-D1]

Kate Ceberano- The ultimate Mary M.

[@bikerian5346]

The only one of them that could sing.

[@JulieGraham-u7b]

Emma Bunton can sing too but agree about the others.😊

[@jedionboard1233]

Mel c IS the voice of the Spice Girls.. she's got more talent all of them put together. great voice.

[@stevenrichardson7882]

I’ve never thought she had a good voice and this version proves it unfortunately 🤷‍♂️

[@katrinalassberg5649]

Micaela Diamonds version is absolutely gorgeous.

[@dtulip1]

I always thought Mel C had the best voice

[@SketchFlygirl]

When I was a kid, I wanted to be her.

[@christya2488]

Whenever a big star does something crazy, I always think to myself, "Jesus christ, Superstar! What's wrong with you?" It changes the whole meaning. Anyone else? Anyone? No, it's just me? Okay then.

[@MountainBeagle]

Ummm ... So nobody's going to comment on her crucifix tattoo? ... Spoiler alert!

[@AnnePatriotic]

A relationship with Jesus Christ will have the "What's it all about?" question in mind at various points in a life, but the total and complete answer to that question won't come until the next life, when we see him "face to face". I can't wait for that, but wait, I must.

[@cesarpimenta2008]

That's it. No need to say anything else.

[@tonytcb4504]

The only one who can sing the others were terrible ❤

[@rogerprice7704]

Beautiful performance but ruined by poor audio quality

[@michaelwilkinson9382]

A scouse Mary

[@damiengreenwood7378]

Obviously her voice, but I think she's lip synching to a pre recorded version..

[@joey.3200]

Almost as good as Kimberly Diane Craig (née Day).

[@asavannah7439]

I love her song, Northern Star, but her voice doesn’t suit this song at all

[@jeffreypulley2701]

Not bad but dose not compare to the Australian version

[@Paulad39uk]

It's not astounding unless you mean in a bad way.😭

[@SJ47668]

The description - “she belts out” - where was the belt? She sang it like she had to keep it on the down low - quite amateurish - not bad, but no belt and no passion.

[@ymkeene]

Well, Yvonne Elliman still the best!

[@carlobi]

I guess we can now confirm the rumours about one of the spice girls not having any talent. It was Victoria.

[@johnkitchen4699]

Not the best - a bit squawky on the high notes (her voice is quite strained).

[@kumada84]

The autotune is really disgusting.

[@catherinewoolf504]

Thank god it wasn’t Victoria Beckham

[@angelaregan475]

Bitchy comment and totally unnecessary.

[@Fergus20124]

Not good for a big production like this……much better singers out there , but being a Spice Girl obviously got her the job .

[@SJF15]

Miming.

[@Debbie76]

Her voice always hurts my ears. It's like nails on a chalkboard 🙉