Metallica w/ Marianne Faithfull - The Memory Remains (Live in San Francisco, December 7th, 2011)

[@Mauti84]

She makes the song what IT REALLY IS. All my respect to this lady.

[@reallyking2528]

Mauricio Albano and idiot James laugh

[@SaucisseMerguez]

I found a version without her, so much better imo 😅

[@lecusz_2168]

@@SaucisseMerguez in my opinion the song doesn't sound good without her

[@jeepmanxj]

I wonder if she had any idea that her simple part in this song would be everyone's favorite part

[@shamicentertainment1262]

Shallex Well the tune she sings amazing, her voice is what people don't like. I've grown to like it though

[@clayjf]

I've never heard anyone hate her part

[@jamessuraciart]

Same here. Her voice sounds so fucking creepy in this song. I'm not even that much of a Metallica fan (there isn't one album by them besides S&M that I can bring myself to listen to all the way through). Without her vocal part, this song is pretty much just a generic sounding Metallica song, not bad, but not really that good either. Just wish they would have had her join during the S&M show instead of having the crowd sing her part.

[@Deanobucko917]

I think it is an important of the story the song tells.

[@zacharyg623]

Ya I hate that part honestly. I won’t say it ruins the song cause it’s a great song. But it would be much better without that nonsense

[@carlosruiz1656]

I just love how much Marianne is enjoying the audience feedback, you can see on her face she's having a blast!

[@musicmangm7572]

I've always loved her vocal. It's melodic but also sounds haunting. Love it!!!

[@rosiewhitfield123]

Yes, she's always had a beautiful voice. Such a good soul she is ☺☺☺

[@MiketheratguyMultimedia]

What an AMAZING moment at 3:55. That look between Marianne and Kirk says so much.

[@tombstoneharrystudios584]

Kirk's always had a sweet smile

[@MiketheratguyMultimedia]

@@tombstoneharrystudios584 It's super genuine.

[@danielarteta3775]

That's because... Kirk is g...

[@F34Rpantera1000]

holy shit its crazey how natural Marianne Faithful looks up their with Metallica. she even seems enjoy the music. this is the best

[@hotdoggravy]

she's a rocker from way back. I think she makes this song

[@rosiewhitfield123]

She's in her natural spot...performing and up on stage with music icons ☺😀

[@AFloridaSon]

WTF? *They* should be on their knees worshipping *her.* Do you even know who she is? She is a Rock Goddess. She was shooting up with The Rolling Stones, when these guys were still peeing the bed.

[@Jeb4100]

​@@AFloridaSon wtf

[@steevo211]

Poor Ladies.. The Nice Guys Know.

[@themorticians]

I sob like a baby at the end-- you can feel Marianne feeding off of the audience and feeling the intensity, the band quieting down and transforming a rocking anthem into a primal, religious chant. Like James says at the end, "do you feel the love?" That's what makes this footage so powerful. It captures pure (positive) feeling. Not something common these days.

[@sonyatiscareno2995]

🙋‍♀️SO DID I!!!❤❤❤👊👊👊

[@VioletFlame-f3g]

I didn't watch it to the end before saying my part. Yes I feel the love. Because this rocks. ❤🤘🏻🖤

[@Riatzi]

Big respect for Marianne Faithful and kudos to Metallica. Her part in the song is utter Genius. And look at her enjoying every second of it.

[@sidartha96]

Marianne Faithful is phenomenal. Having her sing her part to a live audience is truly incredible. This concert will truly be remembered in rock history. Kudos to Metallica for making her a part of the live performance. This is one greatest songs ever written by Metallica, it brought tears to my eyes and made me reminiscent of the first I heard it.

[@rbilleaud]

Great to see Maryanne Faithful still out there performing. She's like the female Keith Richards, probably taken every drug known to man and come through on the other side. It's sad that she's largely unknown to the younger generation, but she's had a hand in some pretty significant moments in rock history and sang with most of the all-time greats from the Stones to Pink Floyd and countless others. Awesome performer.

[@rosiewhitfield123]

Oh yeah Maryanne has admitted to doing some hard drugs in they 70's. Well she did date Mick Jagger so it really speaks volumes. Been in the company of Mick Jagger and Keith Richards back in the 70's you'd do all the gear that you could get access to. Women were always submissive to men when it came to drugs in that time in history. Janis Joplin was on the hard gear. She gave it up but then had the pinch to try some again. Her trying the too potent dose she had last, was what killed her, sadly. We're pretty lucky to still have Maryanne with us mortals. Don't know if you were aware of this but she developed breast cancer. She kicked the breast cancer, thankfully.

[@norrielcelario5374]

That outro is one of the most sweetest moments in Rock'n Roll history.

[@drygon98]

You can see her turn her head at one point and looks at kirk and goes "omg" when the crowd is singing XD

[@Randomeris1]

@Aaron Morgan Man, Kirk looks so Pretty here

[@FlyWithAdrian]

And Kirk is like “I know, right?” This was such an historical moment!!

[@ceilingdad]

She was so adorable, how she clung to Rob, when she came on one of the first things she said was "Where's Robert?" It was so cute. This made a great memory.

[@TigerSuede]

im 16 years old and discovered Marianne Faithfull a few years ago. I just cant get enough of her, shes incredible. Ive researched her backstory and I did a school presentation on her in the topic of Sexism in rock n roll. Im glad that a band like Metallica still includes her in the scene because she deserves to be known!!

[@Sacrer]

Metallica makes The Memory Remains great, Marianne Faithfull makes it amazing

[@stevenpappas3753]

That’s one cool Mamma.

[@Osmostrix]

This song becomes something else entirely in a live concert!

[@orion1981]

4:44 Haha James had to intervene otherwise the na na's would have gone on all night. Love it.

[@dougpittman8074]

You could totally tell she was enjoying herself up there! Awesome.

[@neoneherefrom5836]

Oh man what a special moment. I would have drowned her out myself if I had been there! Thanks, Marianne! Glad she made it through COVID!

[@Motorsheep]

This is one of the best non-professional Metallica live recordings I've ever seen. Everybody is having SO much fun!!

[@lemmybon3100]

Her voice is only one they coulda used. Love her. 🤘🏻

[@Mr.FranciscodeMiranda]

Metal extremist - "Meh, Load and Reload aren't metal. Only pussies like those albuns bruh" James - "Fortune, fame Mirror vain Gone insane But the..." Metal extremist - "MEMORY REMAAAAAAAINS!!!!"

[@stevenbaksh5545]

de Sales so fucking what if it is not metal

[@ThierryRocksTV]

Those types of Metallica fans are morons anyway

[@bscheryms]

I freaking love Marianne's voice

[@TurmoilBrump]

She is absolutely beautiful, back then & right now.

[@s2ths2]

Metallica introduced me to Marianne's music. This is amazing!

[@patrickmelhorn793]

Marianne seems to love Kirk

[@Riatzi]

Who doesn't love Kirk?

[@Benjawin6671]

The other way around

[@coldvoid]

She really makes the song something even more special

[@nameless76mozwhaz9]

Ever see marianne in her younger days? Drop dead gorgeous. Check it out.

[@eacar]

+nameless76 mozwhaz holy shit

[@nameless76mozwhaz9]

Did u check her out back in the day?

[@nameless76mozwhaz9]

Ikr. Smokin hot. Some of the footage I saw she was 18 or so and just beautiful.

[@justinthymes5680]

Yup she was bangin' hot.

[@nameless76mozwhaz9]

Yes she was a gorgeous young woman. I swear I should have been born in my parents generation.

[@altaclipper]

I keep watching this and I can’t believe how all their faces are lit up like kids on Christmas morning. They are all enjoying it so much.

[@ItsTimeIDisappear09]

Wow she's so taken away at how the Metallica fans keep singing it. I love it

[@MrPhantomLord11]

Who noticed around 4:03 Marianne Faithfull looks at Kirk with face which says: "What the hell?! This crowd is fucking awesome! You're great guys! "

[@AlexandrosMpothos]

The thing is that she says "I sing dada-da-daa but they keep going ho-oooo-o-o" hahaha! But still awesome

[@huntergant6518]

So fucking cool they got Marianne faithfull to come and sing everyone's favorite part

[@hamzabaamel721]

this band will never die , respect i listen to this when everymorning , when am on my way to the school or to work energie + 1000

[@nechastivi3187]

Imagine whole crowd singing your simple line in Metallica song, that's a goal!

[@hexen100]

THANK YOU Tallica!!! Marianne sooo deserves to be on stage and be loved once more!

[@dalelike9036]

say yes, at least say hello

[@CaseyWinehouse]

I had no idea this was someone’s unaltered vocals before tonight, let alone Marianne Faithfull. I’d just never googled it before. Absolutely blown away. I thought it was a heavily compressed male’s voice all this time.

[@williamvandergrift9741]

I thought James had helium and started singing

[@tomerengel]

Every time I need a true smile with amazing music - I put this video on.

[@satanshallbetormentedetern7871]

This is one of the gems of KZbin that I pray more ppl may feel. Jesus Christ loves you!

[@verminvaporizer1394]

i swear, the running gag with this show is that every time I see a new clip from it, it's ANOTHER legend. This is like the 10th time

[@williamvandergrift9741]

I’m pretty sure this was their 30th anniversary show but I could be wrong

[@leocolle9239]

love this video, specially the end, when they stop playing and get all around her. They all just seens to be really happy, big smiles. have a good life my friends

[@j9154]

She still got it Marianne Faithful is the legend

[@mainakmaiti1534]

with kirk's lead line and marianne's haunting vocals plus the crowd participation its just goosebumps....

[@sminno]

I bet Marianne was amazed at how powerful her part of the song really was.

[@cityofkorn]

Love it. James ended the audience participation at the perfect time.

[@rockarolla3199]

chills the whole time...best band ever!!!!

[@ilyalead4blade897]

this grandma was hotter than hell in her youth

[@neonknees]

She was Mick Jagger's missus for a few years.

[@Outlawtorn29]

Yes she was 🤘

[@vizcondem0ntuen431]

She was a Mick Jagger's girlfriend...

[@sonyatiscareno2995]

She still is...A Hot Grandma!!🔥

[@LZJoZ]

Sometimes,musicians do more for us with one song than what anyone else ever could do with all their efforts.

[@waywolfjones8127]

Idiots take

[@BrightSixx]

Marianne is an icon in her own right. I am so glad they have her on this song. Her music is still very relevant to this day. Love this lady 🥰

[@merciless2032]

01:54 the cutest thing I've ever seen.

[@350zgr33n]

Playing it fast here. Love it!

[@fannycraddock99]

Marianne rocks. Happy Birthday girl. XX

[@MusicZombieGirl]

Marianne is badass 💟

[@nefariousdesert]

Indeed she is a legend

[@a.t.3192]

The ending is so wholesome, I bloody love it

[@ourfamily4185]

Marianne is awesome!

[@rosiewhitfield123]

She's beautiful and always will be such a star. She sadly was diagnosed with breast cancer but she kicked it's ass!!

[@theevildrummingsithlord1492]

​@@rosiewhitfield123 She kicked breast cancer's ass? That's amazing! Sadly, cancer always has a tendency to get back when you least expect it.

[@rosiewhitfield123]

@@theevildrummingsithlord1492 yeah she did kick Cancers ass. Sure is amazing. Oh absolutely right...as I had a cousin in remission but 9 years later his cancer returned with a vengeance. He passed away in October of 2000 if I remember correctly. It's why I get checked out...Cancer is an issue in my gene pool.

[@theevildrummingsithlord1492]

@@rosiewhitfield123 I'm sorry for your loss. Does it terrify you that cancer is in your gene pool?

[@rebelvictorsofthecornucopi1727]

It’s everyone’s favorite Metallica band member!

[@robisaacm]

flawlessly beautiful

[@ranksouls]

Insane! Thank you for these videos. Highly appreciated.

[@synyztahkillah09]

That was a really simple, laid back performance all around, but it was pretty freakin' cool!

[@jjjay999]

Absolutely incredible! Thanks for sharing!

[@JackDaniels267]

Absolutely love this. ❤️❤️❤️

[@kylewilliam487]

That’s so freaking awesome. I wish I was there dude!

[@alexnoriega9836]

If You've been to a 'tallica concert and didn't get the chills when you sang this... Well, shame on you, you unsensitive monster!

[@rosiewhitfield123]

They played this at my first Metallica concert and for sure I joined in when it was time for the audience to sing. That was over 21 years ago but now I can almost match her singing her input to the song. I'd sure loan my voice on stage to Metallica as a female voice for it to be performed.

[@KAT86]

If James hadn't stepped in, I don't think she would've ever gotten off that stage! 😆❤️🤘🏼

[@nefariousdesert]

Same 😂😂😂😂

[@ShroomMasta2009]

I think this is the only song they have with a female vocal lol...

[@ThierryRocksTV]

...And then Lady Gaga happened

[@ItsTimeIDisappear09]

Demon Rantz but this Marianne was on an album...

[@NoxWyatt]

Smoke YaSs What the fuck are you going on about?

[@utterdisaster603]

AgentOfOblivion epica

[@riffmaniac8627]

Enter sandmann with Girl :D

[@ku70mar]

Marianne Faithfull n Metallica..........memory will remain for ever....♥

[@itsjustmethatsall3163]

I didn't replay Marianne's part 500 times, you did.

[@tombstoneharrystudios584]

Love her, love Metallica!

[@kevinnelson2472]

Simply iconic every time I watch.

[@88WarPath]

I wish I could've seen these 4 legendary shows!! I hope they release this to dvd! (Also James needs to wear that bullet belt more!)

[@rkuriakis4972]

Whatever little left of my mind, officially blown after this.

[@TheLovedrug13]

Best thing Metallica has done in 20 years....G-d Bless Mariannne Faithfull!

[@facundotissera8320]

I love this fuckin video Metallica whit Mariane Faithfull! Heavy as shit!!!!!!!!!!!

[@Kontkane]

Goosebumps..

[@jorgeaureliosf8090]

its nice to hear it with 0.85 speed

[@machachaist]

Thank you somuch for posting all those videos man. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU

[@ericmeredith4022]

Marianne Faithfull is literally a life on records

[@emtae8005]

She is a legend!!

[@stevenpappas3753]

Queen Marianne HayOl Hail Thank You Old Girl. Thanks Mamma’s From All Over The Globe This Week We Get / Got This . Not counting out the Boyz, but we know… We’ve ALL Been waiting too long for Equal.

[@Limpmania]

2:50 until the end -> I love this part. The Solo.... crazy!

[@tramer76]

Thank you Mathias for posting all of these great Metallica vids, From an old school fan that goes way back.

[@isaacmontoya9636]

Marianne Faithful had nothing and I mean nothing to do with metal, she was a pop singer in the 60’s with a lovely voice with simplicity. Then comes the mighty thrash legends Metallica who picked her out of a hat and made one of the most beautiful rock masterpieces with her leaving a memorable melody that I never ever forgot especially the first time I heard it. I get teary eyed just talking about it 🥲

[@legendaryskulls]

That awkward moment when Marianne Faithful caresses your arm 1:50 Aww she didn't do the "at least say yes, at least say hello" part

[@cowsaysmoo51]

LOL I thought James did the "da dadada da da da" part...

[@Bendova215]

Nah lol just listen to it you can hear the differences that's why on all the live shows kirk plays this part to sound like it which I like more

[@rosiewhitfield123]

No he didn't on the single or the studio album. My best friend from De Land fla told me about Maryanne Faithful featuring on a song on the album before the release of the track as a single. I brought I think all I could that were sold in Australia.

[@ivonahora]

@@Bendova215 the guitar lead is there in the studio version too

[@tinadeburiet8086]

Me too

[@Rosequartz033]

I thought it was Kirk lol

[@patriciastewart2239]

OMG I never imagined this!!

[@VladimirUnique1]

Люблю и периодически переслушиваю только одну песню у металлики и вот это она. И из-за этой темы на-нанана и вокала Марианны Фейтфулл.

[@brandonguindon7455]

What an INCREDIBLE moment for both her and METALLICA.....I never even knew that was her! I always thought it was one of the band members 😆 I read about her and she's got quite a bit of Rock history to her name! Great job Marianne.....you still got it

[@justinthymes5680]

Thanks for the share.

[@TheAttyjace]

How I wish that they release an official dvd/ blu-ray of this event. So cool \m/

[@christianhafer9819]

Fantastic. Absolutely awesome.

[@ronaldedwardututaonga8254]

I loooove Marianne!!..... small, part to play but her riff is most definitely memorable .....I like to sing her riff while rocking in my lazy boy chair ...😍😍😍

[@ederfigueroa9492]

Que momentazo, espectacular, y la señora es el alma de la canción, buenísimo 👏 ❤❤❤

[@AIetheia]

AMAZING !!!!

[@МаксимШевелев-в6д]

это соло Марианны можно петь бесконечно) шикарная композиция

[@chichonpelotas]

Best perfomance of this Song!

[@worlds14320]

They tend to play this song a little faster live. It only took like four minutes when I saw them in Dublin a few years ago. but it was the best four minutes of the whole show. this song is greatest live.

[@supersmellyglove]

Man. Seeing Metallica in a "club" would be massive. The smaller the better. I googled The Fillmore and it seems like it's a 1300 cap venue. That would be fun as hell, close and intimate as hell for a band this size. In this song her voice is the main event. Stellar.

[@_K3v_]

... I could be singing that part like, forever.

[@Rammnails]

Wow, this is amazing! What a powerful statement on the influence of music, man...this shit is moving! Course they lost a lot of fans over the napster problems, but I don't know how anyone could hold a grudge on the "thrashers" after this (if they are a true fan, anyway.)

[@queenofno6055]

so weird to think I been watching their videos for over THREE WHOLE DECADES now! they formed before I was in 1st grade though I think lol. Idgaf what anyone says about how they changes, they're still a staple in American Hard Rock and Metal 🖤

[@isosthenie8271]

she looks so happy :)