Microsoft Recall: Security Risk or AI Game-Changer?

  Рет қаралды 2,047

Bright Ideas Agency

Bright Ideas Agency

Күн бұрын

Copilot for Microsoft 365 Adoption Package for small- and medium-sized businesses. Learn about our new all-inclusive plan - brightideasagency.com/copilot...
Need an AI plan for your business? Check out Nick's new book, "Who's in the Copilot's Seat?" - brightideasagency.com/book - And if you need more personalized help or advice, check out new engagement options that are available too - brightideasagency.com/engage
---
Is Microsoft's new Windows Recall feature a groundbreaking innovation or a privacy nightmare? In this video, we dive into the controversy, dissecting the headlines from major publications and examining the security measures Microsoft has put in place. I'll share my perspective on whether the fears are justified or just overblown. Join the discussion and find out if Windows Recall is something to be excited about or concerned about!
----
Sign up to receive Digital Spotlight, the Bright Ideas Agency monthly mailing mailchi.mp/7f5ac2e809a5/brigh...
Check out our website at www.brightideasagency.com
Connect with Nick on LinkedIn at / nickdc or the Bright Ideas Agency page at / brightideasagency
Links:
ComputerWorld article -www.computerworld.com/article...
BleepingComputer article - www.bleepingcomputer.com/news...
The Times article - www.thetimes.co.uk/article/bc...
Forbes article - www.forbes.com/sites/andrewle...
Copilot+ PCs launch event - microsoft.com/event
What is a Copilot+ PC? Microsoft's new AI hardware for Windows - • What is a Copilot+ PC?...
Chapters:
0:00 Introduction
1:40 What is Recall?
4:11 Did Microsoft consider data security and privacy?
6:06 What were the issues raised in the press?
13:10 Who's right? Microsoft or the nightmarish articles?
13:38 Why is this innovation key to the success of AI assistants?
This video uses video and images from Microsoft's Copilot+ PC launch event on 5/20.
Apart from publicly accessible information, all user data or other related information shared in this video is created for demonstration purposes only. User accounts, passwords, or other data used as part of any demonstrations shown in this video have been created specifically for that purpose and are not any individual or company's private information or data.
Bright Ideas Agency is an Ohio Limited Liability Company. The content of this video is for informational and entertainment purposes only. No guarantees are given in connection with the information shared and you should seek independent technical or business advice before implementing anything you see in this video. If you want to hire us for your project, visit www.brightideasagency.com and get in touch.

Пікірлер: 73
@MnemonicCarrier
@MnemonicCarrier Ай бұрын
"This data will never touch the cloud... for now" 🤣
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@Leto2ndAtreides
@Leto2ndAtreides Ай бұрын
The only vaguely awkward thing for me about Recall is that if your PC gets a virus / hacked... Or the governments gets its hands on your PC... They're potentially going to be able to get a lot more information. The core concern behind privacy has always been that you don't want your data in the hands of people who are actively likely to harm you... Corporations have little incentive to harm you - too much trouble for their profitability if they end up harming a user. Anyway, this is ultimately part of the question of how Personal AI agents should work... I'd personally consider your own agents as a part of your digital identity and deserving of legal protections against unwanted search and seizure, etc. And access to such systems should ideally be more strongly locked down, so that even if your PC is compromised, that too much isn't leaked outside... Which shouldn't be that hard to do. Although it does mean that Copilot should automatically not remember certain kinds of information. It might also be worth it to completely separate business context work from personal context... Like, you might only use Recall while your laptop is in business mode (depending on your preferences)
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@Aether-Entropy
@Aether-Entropy Ай бұрын
As an IT admin, I stay up to date with what Microsoft is pushing, that doesn’t mean I like it. Just started dual booting in Nobaru. This IS a security/privacy issue. Anyone who has local access to your machine can access this data. What about a library who doesn’t know how to properly deploy a system with group policy? The grandmas and grandpas who fall for scams where a scammer remotes into their system? Absolute insanity. Sure you can say the same thing about a password manager, but it’s not a screenshot of what you’re doing every day, every 3 seconds. This has personally put me off of windows in a massive way, and I believe many, many power users feel the same way.
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@frederichardy8844
@frederichardy8844 Ай бұрын
Nothing is totally secured... so it is a privacy and security nightmare even if it is also an inovation. But for me, like the browser, it should be an application, not a part of the operating system. An operating system should be only a software layer allowing an application to run on a computer: a file system, a memory manager, a network manager, a GUI but nothing the user directly interact with. Of course you can have default application but I think that it should be explain during the installation and you should be given the choice to install them or not. And for the "Innovation" part: if we cannot remember anything without AI assitant, if we cannot make any innovation without AI assistant we're gonna end in idiocracy... limited to the innovation the IA was trained on... If you want your brain to work you have to make it work, not rely on AI assistant.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
I think these are fair points, but the reality is that this separation of roles is not how operating systems work. One direction those wanting to switch from Windows hold is Apple but that’s an even more integrated walled garden than Windows. As the completeness of systems out of the box has increased the complexity for users has decreased, little time saving additions like being able to open a Zip file in the OS rather than install a 3rd party app actually makes usage safer. Choice can be great and secure for those with knowledge, but for the average user it introduces complexity and the potential for making decisions that are less than optimal in terms of the security of their system.
@frederichardy8844
@frederichardy8844 Ай бұрын
@@brightideasagency "not how operating systems work" : well it was and and it still is for some. When you install Debian you have a lot of choices. I love the "politicaly correct" style of your answer. My translation is "let's assume that the average user is not so bright and don't want do understand how a computer works but just want it to work out of the box. Instead of trying to educate, let's impose the microsoft software and suggest that any other choice may be unsafe". Windows and MacOS are both software made to lock customers for profit with argument like: we known better than you what you want. Personaly I use a 14 years old HP workstation. when I bought it, it was running Windows NT. I updated it to Windows 7 but it was the end for me with Windows, Linux gave me the freedom I wanted . It can run Windows 10 but not Windows 11... not problem with the last Linux. Of course the storage was changed a few time (Came with SAS drive, changed to SATA SSD and now NVMe SSD) but I didn't need to buy a whole new PC to install the last version of Linux, need one if I want to install the last version of windows...
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
I think it's unfair to jump from installing Debian to "the average user is not so bright". The days of computers being solely for people who are interested in them are long gone, and if you're spending your time installing Debian either you work in IT or you have a great interest in IT as a hobbyist. I also enjoy technology for the sake of technology, but I respect the fact that a lot of people don't, and the desire the average person has for their PC to simply work without having to learn a great deal or tinker continuously is no negative reflection on their intellect. It's great that there are products to allow such a diversity of people, interests, and learning styles to gain benefit from technology in their life and business, and the same platform will not be the best choice for everyone.
@frederichardy8844
@frederichardy8844 Ай бұрын
@@brightideasagency The last Debian is very easy to install, using all the default options it's not more complicated than windows. "the same platform will not be the best choice for everyone" : I can't agree more! But a customer using GAFAM products usually don't understand how they work: they are easy to use and he don't look any further. A video like "Data Brokers: Last Week Tonight with John Oliver (HBO)" should be mandatory to watch before using any device connected to internet. And this video was before using AI. People need to be aware that if they use these products they take the risk of loosing any privacy. They should be because in many case it's written in the "terms of use" but who reads them? And no, don't expect big companies to respect their customers, you can find many example in the video of "Louis Rossmann".
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
This is the reason why everyone is moving to Linux. Linux golden age is coming.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
The Linux golden age has been coming since I was in college. The reality is that a large number of people already have Linux derived devices around them (Android, ChromeOS) but it seems unlikely a single Windows feature is going to move the needle on enterprise use of Windows. In many ways the recent years have shown the fragility of the open-source supply chain that Linux relies upon to a far greater degree than Windows, so I'm not sure either platform is without its problems. If some users want to move to Linux in response to Windows 11's development direction, then that makes sense, but I doubt I'm going to see it in too many offices soon.
@GingerBuffalo
@GingerBuffalo Ай бұрын
​@@brightideasagencyI've been hearing the same story since my college days....in the late '90s.
@Leto2ndAtreides
@Leto2ndAtreides Ай бұрын
Sounds like primitive instincts at work.
@erickanter
@erickanter 29 күн бұрын
EVERYONE is not moving to Linux. Stop being such a fan boy. Don't get me wrong i despise recall but a lot of people don't care.
@Ninjutsu2K
@Ninjutsu2K Ай бұрын
The thing is, as me many people work on offices, and in my case, I have a particular workload where when its need I do my part of the work and some other time I watch video on KZbin or read things, and other things not related of my workload, but its because I don't have demand, I bet in the feature this Recall will be available for admins to check their employes and this sure will be a nightmare, I am not doing anything wrong, but if an admin check my Recall and see I am watching videos about games, how I should explain this?
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
We have seen before and will again that with digital tools to track or oversee work come new challenges in workplaces. For workers the question comes down to whether what you are doing that you want privacy for is defensible as reasonable and is being protected by you for reasons other than obfuscating how you are spending your time. For employers the question comes down to what balance of trust and oversight leads to the best results, not just in terms of productivity, but also in employee retention and morale. If you're working on a business owned device, then the best assumption is always that your employer can see 100% of what you're doing, we don't need Recall for that.
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@Stopreadingmyusername23
@Stopreadingmyusername23 20 күн бұрын
Commercial break at 12:07 regular programming resumes at 13:11
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency 19 күн бұрын
You're going to be busy with this real soon. techcrunch.com/2024/06/16/youtube-is-testing-another-way-to-combat-ad-blockers/ Thanks for watching!
@supergreenplays413
@supergreenplays413 Ай бұрын
Recall data is not encrypted on device, it's simply a SQLite database
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency 23 күн бұрын
Microsoft has responded to early concerns about this by implementing just in time decryption. This represents Microsoft’s insider software releases working. Experts have got their hands on the software, provided feedback, and Microsoft has responded to fix prior to general release.
@slurp50s
@slurp50s Ай бұрын
I really think that recall is cool. I would love an AI to do that personally. But not Microsoft AI that's built into my operating system. Plus Microsoft has proven they will 100% force this to turn on in the future with updates. If I used an AI like this, I would want it open source because I'd not touch any closed source AI that was so invasive without honestly being able to see the code. This is such a massive security and privacy issue. I was already really struggling to move to Windows 11 for multiple reasons. It was a hard pill for me to swallow, but when they announced recall, I bit the bullet and moved to Linux. I've used Linux for years, but always for server work. But as of a few days ago, I'm official on Linux! And holy cow Linux for desktop use has come so far since last I checked in! Games work pretty decent too! I'm setting up a Windows VM with Glass Panel for games that need Windows, but other than Adobe products and games, Linux is honestly superior in every way from what I can tell. Like legit everything else. And the gaming aspect has come a long way. I honestly wonder if in the next 5 years, Linux will have little to no issues with games. But I'm honestly kind of shocked Microsoft thought this was a good idea. Even if they back peddled from here, this is a Unity situation but worse. I am a Csharp developer. I am a Csharp die hard fan boy. But, after Unity pulled the stunt they did, I would be weary ever touching Unity with a 10 foot pole. Still solid arguments for it, but you now know the evil and desires of Unity and the direction they wish to go. What Microsoft is doing is 10X worse than that. This is such a horrible invasion of privacy and security. And they seem to have zero desire to back peddle. But even if they were like, "Woops, are bad, we pulled this from the shelf". Is anyone going to trust they won't slip this back into a future patch? Because if you think they won't. You're high lol. This spooked me off Windows completely. Damn do I miss the days of Windows XP. Windows 7 was also solid in my eyes. Windows 10 was a worse version of Windows 7 imo with a constantly crashing file system, but it was fine enough I guess. Though to Windows 10's credit, it did do a vastly superior driver support job. But near the end of Windows XP. But for many many moons Microsoft has been spyware and placing backdoors in their OS. But you could fight it, plus it wasn't always the biggest of deals the way they were doing it. But now, this is just next level. This is sooooo scary.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency 8 күн бұрын
If individual users enjoy Linux, great. There’s lots of places it’s useful. But it’s only been a few years away from takeover for two decades or more at this point and it still has practically no users in comparison to Windows. I might even try Linux again myself, but I’m pretty sure most of my small business customers have zero interest.
@wraith8323
@wraith8323 Ай бұрын
Thanks for solving the problem of what do I do with my last vestiges of digital privacy :/
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@SFAutor
@SFAutor Ай бұрын
If I hadn't switched from Windows to Mac since 2004 and owned one of those new Windows AI PCs, the first and only thing Microsoft's "Recall" feature would record on my PC would be installing Linux and saying goodbye to Windows.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
That would be a strange investment choice, but I hear you. Thanks for watching. 😂
@ogx-rz4jr
@ogx-rz4jr Ай бұрын
Every time I see someone crying about MS "spying" they're an iPhone or Android user who have no problems with Apple and Google recording every word they say, face scanning every photo they take, and scanning every document on their phone to upload to iCloud and GoogleDrive. Hypocritical virtue signalers pretending to care about privacy, when in reality they're just fanboys hating on their chosen enemy corporation while taking it up the *** from their favored corporation. 1984 already happened 10 years ago on iOS and android. Apple and Android users have already been arrested for photos they took getting misidentified as CP by their AIs and automatically reported to the police. Out of every "person" I've talked to that's flipping out about this ALL of them have been iOS and Android users, zero exceptions. Clown world.
@darcsentor
@darcsentor Ай бұрын
I think most of a fear mongering has been over the top. Recall at best is taking Random screenshots so most data will be missing, password fields on web sites don’t display passwords so they can’t be captured. If a hacker/malware has so much access to your pc to view the Recall data, then they will also have full access to all your files, web browser history and passwords etc. I would be much more worried about the full access at that stage. Most of the online fear I have seen has been based on things that haven’t happened yet e.g. MS sharing your data, but that’s a different conversation if that ever happens. For everyone using facebook and google/ chrome, you have no privacy, all your data has been sold. Recall in its current form can’t share anything about you unlike other popular services. If you are worried your parents/wife are going to view what porns site you have visited, don’t turn on Recall and clear your browser history :)
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
Thanks for watching. Totally agree. I understand there being concern, but a lot of people are behaving as if this feature arrived in a vacuum where this is the only potential risk that has ever been created.
@darcsentor
@darcsentor Ай бұрын
Thanks for putting up a balanced and well thought out video on this. I’ve had this debate on a number of sites about Recall and it hasn’t been pretty. Guess most commenters just want to bash Microsoft. As a software developer with 30+ years on the Microsoft platform, if I can get enough access to get to Recall database on your computer, Recall would be the least of their issues. Since at that stage it’s only a short matter of time before I have full access to all your banks, pensions etc via other better and more reliable attack vector’s. I think a lot of the ‘outrage’ is also a lack of understanding on the basics of how computers work and what your real security risks are. Also can’t help but wonder if Apple had released this product what the reaction would have been :) Anyway keep up the great content.
@MnemonicCarrier
@MnemonicCarrier Ай бұрын
"...password fields on web sites don’t display passwords so they can’t be captured..." - until the user clicks on the "Show Password" checkbox 🤣
@darcsentor
@darcsentor Ай бұрын
@@MnemonicCarrier even then the password isn’t guaranteed to be captured. It someone has access to Recall, then they also have full access to all your passwords via your browser or password manager and everything else on your pc.
@VJNEEF
@VJNEEF 15 күн бұрын
11:30 If you don't trust microsoft ... then the logical recourse is to not run windows, and while you'r at it, don't use microsoft 365 either. Exactly, I avoid microsoft as much as possible. But my children are not able to do this because their school demands it. And I imagine a lot of people need to use it at the workplace.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency 8 күн бұрын
In a business or education setting the organization needs to assess how the platforms they use meet their objectives. In the education sphere at least schools have had tech for a long time that makes it inadvisable to be using those shared machines for sensitive personal information.
@crumblingsanity6455
@crumblingsanity6455 Ай бұрын
It's a problem for a simple reason that you have to ask yourself, "How well do you trust Microsoft or any other company to not push the boundaries of what they're able to get away with." For one, Microsoft doesn't have the best track record as is, knowing this, the biggest problem is having to take their word for things, they say "This data will be stored locally on your computer and not be sent to the cloud," I can tell you right now, I don't believe that for a second, a tool like this is obviously meant to be invasive, cause most of the pros are so minimal, but the down-sides are just off the charts and this entire feature is literally just spyware that is just being disguised with the whole AI craze nonsense and there is no way something like this is just going to be stored locally at all or if it is, it won't be that way for long. Add to the fact that this is already half-baked with their lack of content moderation where all your credentials and everything are going to be on display, I even watched a video where this is also going to include stuff that's on your browsers (including edge, even though they mentioned that browser was going to be exempt from the recall feature, which was clearly a lie it seems), he put in some credentials of his own (of course fake to try it out) went to recall and all the information was right there for everyone to see, oh but guess what? I also heard that if the recall feature has anything related to the company themselves, any other company, or some special interest groups, that information will be disregarded immediately and maybe to some extent could be censored somehow, so "If" this is going to be the case, then that really shows you that even Microsoft knows that this is a really invasive feature so much so that they have to exclude themselves from it so there is no sort of liabilities on their end, but oh! The customers get to deal with this "great feature" and we're just exposed to the wild, fascinating. With the whole hacker thing as well, sure you could definitely argue that they do have other ways of obtaining your information that doesn't have to go through recall, but the problem here is that, now they just have a 1000x easier way to get CRAZY amounts of information about you all at once, and it's all packaged nice and neatly where they can just search through whatever they want, how is this "not" a problem? And this is even worse if the person has gotten remote access so they can just grab what they need and split and you're done for. Also, let's keep in mind that the government and others will likely have a field day with this feature now and considering how bad censorship is these days, now anytime you type anything on your browser you have to be super wary of, made a joke that might be seen as offensive and recall captured it? Could get you in trouble, are you a journalist and there are going to be people out there that want to take you down? Recall captures it. Are you an anonymous figure online that makes KZbin content like for example "Vtubers" where this is their strongest asset, well now recall can have all that information right there for everyone to see, and again they "say it's going to be stored locally' but we all know its not or at least for long, and if some kind of data-leak happens when it does get stored on their servers well, your fucked and they won't have any liability over it either. Then, let's add on top of all of this where, this feature is going to be turned on "automatically" by default, so a person that doesn't even know about this feature could have all of their information just shown to the world without them even knowing, certainly isn't creepy at all, and then to make matters worse after every update, they turn this back on, so if you happen to forget to turn it off after each update and you just go about your regular day searching through stuff then you're kinda done for, and sure you can "delete" these snapshots, but it does it literally every 3 seconds (someone said 5 once, but I'm pretty sure it's 3) so it's kinda useless. And sure you can toggle this feature off going to settings>privacy and security>recall and snapshots, but how long is that going to last? And how do we know that even when you toggle this off, it's not still working in the background? This is one of Microsoft's biggest feature yet, do you really believe them to let you just be able to turn it off that easy? No way. This entire "feature" is just a surveillance camera for your computer to monitor your habits online 24/7, and while it's true that this won't be rolling out for every system out there, cause of the requirements are going to be quite extensive to run this and there is a certain processor you have to have being something called the "SnapDragon" so most windows 11 PC's won't have to worry about this "for now", (although they do already have it where you can download some feature or whatever where it allows you to run recall with minimal specs requirements and seeing as they've already done this, you know they have this planned to be rolled out at some point for EVERY windows 11 PC and future PC's down the line). Seriously though, the fact that these guys haven't gotten some kind of class-action lawsuit at this point is kind of baffling to me.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency 8 күн бұрын
Clearly this feature needed more work, but I think some of the commentary is overblown. To my understanding no one demoing the limitations of Recall was actually doing so on a system approved for it to run on. That’s like misconfiguring your router on purpose and complaining when someone gets into your network. I’ll be interested to play with this in an insider build.
@crumblingsanity6455
@crumblingsanity6455 8 күн бұрын
@@brightideasagency At this point the Copilot+ PC's have already rolled out and there have been people that have tested it on those systems and it's more or less what I've already described. Although, word has come out that Microsoft is dialing back the feature (not completely getting rid of it sadly) and going to polish it up, cause they got so much back-lash not only from the community, but cyber-security experts, but considering they didn't even bother to do their due diligence a feature like this was made to be thoroughly secure from the beginning, I don' t have high hopes there will be any massive improvements and while of course you are going to have a very niche amount of people that will have a use for this feature, this is something that should have never seen the light of day really. But, have fun testing out the feature, if there's any interesting bits that you end up finding out about it, I'd definitely like to know.
@GA_JoJo
@GA_JoJo Ай бұрын
I’m very excited about recall and copilot in general. Actually ordered a copilot+ laptop as a long time Mac user.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
From the number of times Microsoft mentioned the MacBook Air in their announcement presentation, this is exactly the response they are looking for!
@erickanter
@erickanter 29 күн бұрын
Naive sheep.
@ferdievanschalkwyk1669
@ferdievanschalkwyk1669 Ай бұрын
This product would not need to exist if Microsoft did not break windows search from win7
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
That's like saying a Tesla wouldn't need to exist if we made better saddles for horses. Windows search has never given you insights inside the content of apps or the semantic meaning of what you're seeing on screen. This is foundationally a different experience trying to align with how we think about the content with how you find it. That said, it is a fair point to make that the search experience for many users has degraded, particularly with on-device content.
@r3dtext
@r3dtext Ай бұрын
If the supporters of this ...feature are so cock sure about microsofts commitment to privacy im 100% certain you would be just fine with an MS employee taking snapshots of your monitor every 5 or so seconds, whilst making notes to "learn" about you to help out...if you believe the biggest software provider in the world is not going to use BILLIONS of user AI harvested infomation to train their models because they promised they wouldnt i have a bridge to sell you. Sure its going to be optional FOR NOW (and that phrase is even in the presentation i believe) in the future it probably wont be!. Everyday the over reach of big tech companies into the lives of its users gets more brazen. We are the product and im tired of it 😢
@ferdievanschalkwyk1669
@ferdievanschalkwyk1669 Ай бұрын
@@brightideasagency I don't quite agree. It's more like turning a car into a boat car, when what people want is a car. Sure it can be a boat, but it makes for a much worse car in the process.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
@@r3dtextI think this would be a fair point of concern except for the fact that if you are already using Windows, you are already putting a lot of trust in Microsoft. The days of buying a CD and that’s your last interaction with the software’s maker is long gone. Windows, whether we like it or not, is in constant contact with Microsoft services, and so if you trust their communications and telemetry today, I’m not sure how this changes anything. Recall will be on your machine locally, but if you don’t trust your operating system, it might be time for a different platform.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
@@ferdievanschalkwyk1669I agree that search needs to be improved, especially for those who do not pursue a Copilot+ PC or who choose not to turn on Recall. But I do think these two products serve two overlapping but substantially different needs.
@geraldabeyawardena5606
@geraldabeyawardena5606 Ай бұрын
Wrong solution to impose on people however well intentioned it is. Should have been an option.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
It is an option. First, if you don't want it, don't buy a Copilot+ PC. Second, if you have a Copilot+ PC and you don't want it, don't activate it during set-up. Then, if you've turned it on and change your mind, turn it off. 100% optional.
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@erickanter
@erickanter 29 күн бұрын
I don't want that garbage on my pc.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency 23 күн бұрын
Definitely your choice as it will be an opt-in feature
@deckard5pegasus673
@deckard5pegasus673 Ай бұрын
0:12 yeah Unix lalready fixed that over 30 years ago, every heard of the commands: grep, find, locate, recoll, history,etc.. Heck if those at microsoft are so computer illiterate at least they could learn to press ctrl-H to search their browser history. And what about Rover the dog in windows XP from over 20 years ago!! Rover found any and all files by name, content, date of of last modification, etc.etc.. so you can't remember what document you were using yesterday? pop up Rover on windows XP and bam! you have it instantly and with less than 1GB of RAM. Remember only one word inside the document but don't remember the name of the document, Bam! Rover found it instantly! Why did microsoft screw up their search and just about everything on windows since windows XP?
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
I appreciate your input on this, but I think you are focusing in on a very limited aspect of the feature set that has been displayed in Recall. AFAIK there is no similar search capability in any major operating system that indexing content based on the semantic meaning of what is displayed in a document or on screen versus just indexing the text in the file. You may well be able to find a file based on remembering a word, but you most definitely have not been able to find a file based on a "graph with purple text" in Unix/Linux for 30 years. It's a fair criticism to say that Windows search has degraded, I don't think it's fair to not recognize the innovative experience in the Recall solution.
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@metaidentity
@metaidentity Ай бұрын
This is such a terrible take, I really expected better from you. Journalists are pointing out real practical concerns that have nothing to do with the integrity of the operating system, and everything to do with the operating environment that computers currently work in. They are not always locked. Passwords are not always secret. They're not always using individual user accounts. Not all developers have all their API keys hidden all the time. If you're not thinking about the practical implications of such a large change in the security model of an existing product ecosystem, and instead only pointing out the technical aspects, then what even is the point of an agency? You might as well just redirect to Microsoft's marketing. Seriously, I would reconsider this perspective, look at it from a real-world, human situation, and perhaps consider taking this video down. It's not all journalists and all industry that are stupid, it is in fact Microsoft that have done something so obviously bone-headedly inhuman here, that the technical aspects are not the point.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
Thanks for watching, I appreciate your considered response to my perspective. I think you make fair points on the range of concerns a feature such as this may interact with in a negative way, but I still think it reasonable to highlight a counterbalance to much of the reporting in this issue that both neglects to highlight the real potential benefits of this innovation and the fact that this does not sit alone and isolated as a solitary attack surface. Ultimately, I expect Microsoft will take feedback on this preview product and improve it, but we should remember that initially at least this will be on a vanishingly small number of PCs, owned by those who have selected a device specifically to get access to AI features such as these.
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
@Czardd
@Czardd Ай бұрын
As a cyber security professional this a privacy no go
@Czardd
@Czardd Ай бұрын
This is why the place I work for is swapping its info structure to an Ubuntu based Linux server
@TOSStarTrek
@TOSStarTrek Ай бұрын
Scam. They change the A.I. info. Seen it myself. Asked a question one day and asked the same question the next. It was changed in favor of the mega companies.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
Can you elaborate here? I'm unsure what question you are referring to with the change in AI?
@TOSStarTrek
@TOSStarTrek Ай бұрын
@@brightideasagency We can start with A.I. It can not learn only programed.
@brightideasagency
@brightideasagency Ай бұрын
Sure. AI does not "know" things in the way humans do. I recently released video on this topic, check it out if you haven't already: kzbin.info/www/bejne/aJzXip6Nn6iimq8
@TOSStarTrek
@TOSStarTrek Ай бұрын
@@brightideasagency I said learn. A book knows things.
@joshuahernandez-th6ov
@joshuahernandez-th6ov Ай бұрын
Stop using Winblows and start using Linux.
Strategic Selling for Authors
27:22
Write Learn and Earn with Kim Vermaak
Рет қаралды 38
Мы никогда не были так напуганы!
00:15
Аришнев
Рет қаралды 5 МЛН
The day of the sea 🌊 🤣❤️ #demariki
00:22
Demariki
Рет қаралды 102 МЛН
THEY made a RAINBOW M&M 🤩😳 LeoNata family #shorts
00:49
LeoNata Family
Рет қаралды 23 МЛН
Tom & Jerry !! 😂😂
00:59
Tibo InShape
Рет қаралды 64 МЛН
AI Deception: How Tech Companies Are Fooling Us
18:59
ColdFusion
Рет қаралды 1,7 МЛН
Avoid these Microsoft 365 Copilot adoption mistakes
13:15
Bright Ideas Agency
Рет қаралды 834
Inside Microsoft AI innovation with Mark Russinovich | BRK256
56:48
Microsoft Developer
Рет қаралды 18 М.
100+ Linux Things you Need to Know
12:23
Fireship
Рет қаралды 81 М.
Copilot Studio Build 2024 Updates
23:56
Parag Dessai
Рет қаралды 1 М.
Windows 11 AI The Good, The Bad, and The DANGEROUS!!!
19:27
CyberCPU Tech
Рет қаралды 36 М.
What is SharePoint Premium and what does it do?
20:27
Bright Ideas Agency
Рет қаралды 485
Will Apple Intelligence beat Copilot for personal AI?
18:09
Bright Ideas Agency
Рет қаралды 476
About 50% Of Jobs Will Be Displaced By AI Within 3 Years
26:26
Fortune Magazine
Рет қаралды 263 М.
Как слушать музыку с помощью чека?
0:36
Main filter..
0:15
CikoYt
Рет қаралды 15 МЛН
Игровой Комп с Авито за 4500р
1:00
ЖЕЛЕЗНЫЙ КОРОЛЬ
Рет қаралды 1,9 МЛН
Собери ПК и Получи 10,000₽
1:00
build monsters
Рет қаралды 2,2 МЛН