Mike Tomlin: Steelers QB battle is an "incomplete study," did Russell Wilson lose QB1 job? l SPEAK

[@SpeakOnFS1]

Check out and subscribe to The Herd on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@theherd

[@AustinNickolaus-m2r]

Shady don’t want fields to start so bad

[@tonyd7582]

Is it wrong of me to want Fields to win the starting job just to see Shady’s head explode? 😂😂😂

[@AilmanF2P]

Everyone knows Fields will be the starter by the end of the season. Thats like going home with a 3 then bragging about game.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

It will make him and me laugh. We know better

[@lfjwatt]

@@AilmanF2Pyou know what they say, game is game 🤣

[@shishiodun]

shady would be laughing every week at his 120 passing yards while the excuses for why it is never Fields fault continues

[@kyloren-cd8dk]

Just wait until every nfc qb gets injured and DJ becomes a pro bowl alt by default😂

[@Ireggilar]

Justin smashed Shady chick. Theres no reason for this level of hate😂

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

He sucks. Should he lie because he's black? JF is not a starting NFL QB> Shady is right and so far you look silly

[@Rome183]

We're not supposed to speak on that🤫😂😂

[@soda8736]

Looks at Fields like Mac Jones, Zach Wilson and Trey Lance. He in their same boat. You would have no problem if he bashed Mac Jones , Feilds is the same just has a delusional fan base because he can run

[@tiyalewhitehurst338]

Hilarious imagine if that's true

[@fwkira864]

cringe

[@welcomefamilyhustletv]

Now it’s the o-lines fault that Russ got sacked 3 times, but last week they killed Fields for taking 2 sacks make it make sense smh

[@reinhart114]

It does. Fields has the tendency to hold the ball for too long. Russ on the other had 1.5 seconds to release.

[@josephbanuelos5802]

Bro imma bears fan he couldn’t read defenses he had a game with less then 150 yards passing come on man

[@vincentrayyoung3676]

Watch the film.

[@demetriusdouglas-davis3552]

​@@reinhart114same o line don't make excuses for one not the other when in the same situation

[@MikkiChavez]

Alot of ignorance in your post

[@thetarheel2010j]

I noticed when Fields took sacks last week, it was his fault and nothing about the bad offensive line… this week, y’all are discussing the horrible offensive line play…

[@vincentrayyoung3676]

Watch the film.

[@demetriusdouglas-davis3552]

​@@vincentrayyoung3676film showed same oline

[@welcomefamilyhustletv]

@@thetarheel2010j exactly!

[@thetarheel2010j]

@@vincentrayyoung3676 I did.. they were awful in week 1 and dating back to last season

[@Boneduprn]

​@@vincentrayyoung3676 you say that bt im watching the texans steelers game last week and they looked slightly less terrible than this weeks game. You people say nonsense so casually

[@user-yh3gb7cc8o]

Shady dogging out Fields last week just to make excuses for Wilson is hilarious

[@thetarheel2010j]

😂😂😂😂

[@CandyCane23049]

It has to be personal for him when it comes to Fields. I don't understand his disdain for him at all.

[@jamesfetcho6315]

Or maybe unlike every one else on the show He saw the 2 dropped ints, the fumble that he got back, the illegal passing procedure, and the missed td by a mile.

[@scoesixtray2457]

@user-yh3gb7cc80 McCoy is a straight up clown.

[@TheGoldKing]

I think shady be objective it just comes off like that because he doesn't do the prerequisites like everybody else needs before they criticize someone

[@scoesixtray2457]

Uh, the Steelers 4th string WR STOPPED RUNNING on the end zone pass. 90% of NFL Receivers keep running & that's a TOUCHDOWN pass from Justin Fields.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

It went over his head. What is wrong with you people?

[@xjhkx]

The WR is an undrafted Division 2 player who has never played a NFL game. Fields is expecting a Pickens or a Moore level play at the end of the pass. It is a TD all day with them. Saw those TDs last year from Fields against Lions and Broncos.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

@@xjhkx NONSENSE

[@Boneduprn]

​@@PatriotWatchUSA no you are nonsense.

[@marquistucker8733]

@scoesixtray2457 correct. It definitely wasn't a great throw but if he trusts himself and keeps running, he can make that catch

[@glenosei3351]

Excuses for Russ, but they be shaming Fields who looked better

[@Joel_Aleman]

Looked better? They both looked bad due to the o line and other factors. It's preseason so Russ should still be the starter.

[@chikushodiz91]

@@Joel_Alemanare you blind fields looks 100% better

[@welcomefamilyhustletv]

When Fields got sacked twice last week they mentioned NOTHING about the offensive line smh

[@cedricsanders8362]

Russ was sacked 3 times. When fields got sacked they went scorched earth on him.

[@thetarheel2010j]

@@welcomefamilyhustletvyou notified that too huh???

[@northside4767]

Shady letting his Fields hate cloud his judgement. A Russ lead offense clearly doesn’t has as much juice.

[@send6pray]

💀😭😭😭😭

[@scottcooper444]

It’s going to be a long year for Shady lol

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

Going to be long year for Steeler fans. The Khan Man tricked you all.

[@Gungadin0112]

I could care less about shady, it's us fans that are gonna suffer through a long year.

[@send6pray]

You mean for fields?? 😂😂😂

[@CandyCane23049]

What did Fields do to Shady? He got them to the red zone, and Russel never sniffed at that end of the field. He's dismissing everything James is saying. He can't be objective at all.

[@Ireggilar]

Get ready bro Shady absolutely HATES Justin Fields. It seems personal.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

We have watched Fields for three years. He is absolutely terrible. His job is to call it the way he sees it and so far he is 100% correct

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

@@Ireggilar Could it be Fields just sucks?

[@jasonjamieson1690]

His takes are wack.

[@Boneduprn]

​@@PatriotWatchUSA 2 things could be true. Fields sucks and russ also sucks lol

[@rusty4265]

"Russ ain't gonna lose you games" .... tell that to Broncos fans.

[@w00deey12]

how many games did JF personally lose for the Bears?

[@dtrelzmusic]

Tell that to seattle in the superbowl, they seem to have amensia when it comes to that! Mf like living in the past but is selective

[@sabishiihito]

@@dtrelzmusic he didn't lose them that game, Pete did by making that play call and Butler just recognized it from the tape and made a great INT. We really out here blaming the QB for doing what the coach told him to do??

[@brandyc3559]

Broncos lost those first 5 games because their defense was horrible allowing 30+ pts and in the Miami massacre, a whopping 70. Russ led 4 or 5 game winning drives last season. He was able to close out those close games with his off script plays. Can't rewrite history.

[@send6pray]

The 30th ranked defense and coach bounty gate lost them games

[@AustinNickolaus-m2r]

Shady hates fields and he hates to be wrong but fields looks better

[@jamesfetcho6315]

What part looked better.....the 2 dropped ints, the fumble that Fields caught back, the illegal passing procedure, or the missed td by a mile???

[@Monsterdamage12]

That's not saying much

[@AilmanF2P]

@@Monsterdamage12 Thats basically saying a 3 looks better than a 2. Technically yes but you didn't win.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

"better" hilarious. JF is a terrible QB

[@AustinNickolaus-m2r]

@@PatriotWatchUSA and so is Russ and he’s old he won’t win a game

[@renecarteir8092]

I like how they don't mention the receiver stopped running in the middle of the route 🤦‍♂️

[@Bmbg155]

💯💯💯💯

[@AnotherChaptersEnd]

That deep pass wasn't on Fields tbh. If you watch the tape the WR slowed down, lost all his momentum then decided to jump for it. Had he just kept running and not slowed down that's a TD right in his arms.

[@Knick_Z_Red]

Cris Carter on X pretty much confirmed it was on the WR for the route. They must've pretended to not see it

[@K.DatBamaBoi]

Man, I got blocked by like three famous people for telling them that it was not Field's fault. It was the wide receiver You can clearly see the wide receiver jumped unnecessarily for no reason. If he would have kept running he would have been under the ball. Touchdown that was not Justin fields fault

[@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m]

@@Knick_Z_RedThat’s the difference between a HOFer reading and watching film and former players just running their mouths and running with a narrative.

[@252MIC]

Facts they just talk to talk lol

[@dtrelzmusic]

@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6mbingo!

[@prideofalion]

I don't think any of these ppl actually watch the games. They're speaking based off highlights. Justin Fields didn't miss that bomb, the receiver stopped running. Go back and watch it. If that's Pickens or even Jefferson that's a touchdown. Gotta love how these guys get paid to sit around and speak on things so confidently that they're clearly very ignorant on.

[@gatorbite9816]

Go rewatch the Broncos game go watch the Washington game go watch both Lions games . Justin can make those throws I've watched it many times.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

He's terrible. This is his final year in the spot light. ENJOY

[@gatorbite9816]

@PatriotWatchUSA My team has Caleb so don't care what happens

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

@@gatorbite9816 Not what you said

[@gatorbite9816]

@@PatriotWatchUSA I said go watch those games where Justin balled out troll

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

@@gatorbite9816 What those three games in three years? He's terrible. He's backing up an old washed up vet. Nobody wanted him. 31 teams said NO

[@Ireggilar]

Bringing up Fields record while ignoring the circumstances is low effort. He played through a rookie season and a rebuild season. When we got him DJ Moore, career year for Moore. Give the man some weapons and let him work. These dudes get paid to yap about nothing.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

DJ had a career year by 60 yerds. He was the only JF threw too. You have no idea what youa re talking about

[@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m]

Need I remind you he wasn’t supposed to start his rookie season.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

@@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m He shouldn't start now

[@dtrelzmusic]

Facts! Big Facts! This is why I hate chicago sports media

[@dtrelzmusic]

@@PatriotWatchUSAyou sir are an idiot

[@df6148]

RUSS has one job. Pre Season Leadership and Guidance. Then he will pass the reigns to Justin. His entire appeal wasn’t to be the starter but simply to lead the team and show them how to prepare and be a pro (As a champion players will respect his preparation a little more than randoms).

[@CKC298]

Lolol no they won’t. The players in Denver mocked him and his “holier than thou” attitude endlessly. The only reason it stopped was because eventually everyone in the media jumped on to it too and the players started to feel bad for him

[@illy_ocean]

nah…they moving the goalposts for russ. that’s corny. keep that same energy you had for justin.

[@cekz5199]

Justin honestly needs to be a 2 progressions QB and then just scramble and look to pass or find a lane. At this point telling him to get through all his progressions is like telling me to do trigonometry just not gonna happen right now. If he could just get decent at the first two progressions and force the ball in with accuracy and power he will easily win this job. Maybe in a few years that could be built upon.

[@eliasgarcia4980]

How can a qb go into the hall of fame if he can only use a rookie level playbook in year 11 or 12?

[@TezIsHimTv]

That’s insane to think about ngl 😭🤦🏽‍♂️ and your not wrong 💯

[@AJB2333]

Lol fr.. Wilson should be sending half his massive contract $ to Pete Carroll. Since he left Seattle his fall-off's been crazy

[@MYBUHAY]

Why is Tomlin so respected when you have HOF got fired? Bill, Andy, etc. They accomplished way more and this is coming from a Steelers fan. But it's okay because he'll have another NON LOSING season. LOL FML.

[@soda8736]

Complexion for the protection

[@giffondhall9214]

Mike Tomlin should be on the hot seat

[@andrebryant5081]

He should've been fired years ago

[@marquistucker8733]

I feel like the "overthrow" they keep talking about really wasn't that bad of a throw. The receiver let up 🤷🏾

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

It was ten feet over his head. What is wrong with you Steeler fans

[@marquistucker8733]

Lol I'm not a steelers fan, not a Fields fan either . It wasn't a great throw but the receiver did let up. Go back and watch what the receiver does

[@vonswelllathan2154]

Shady is bias

[@joewhitaker2839]

James on point Justin Fields is going to Ball out for Mike T and the Steelers

[@plushxi]

I’m glad James Jones mentioned the choice to not kick field goals. Boz doesn’t need to be kicking field goals all pre season game. That said, no TDs out of those drives is concerning.

[@perryellis1423]

Chris Carter said that the wide receiver ran a poor route when Justin Fields "overthrew" him. Thats not on Justin Fields

[@brandyc3559]

I'm not sure why people are making this a who gets more excuses argument when the media loves to dump on Russell. The majority of national media are rooting for Justin Fields to be the starter. The national media openly hates Russ. Ryan Clark, Dan Graziano, Greenburg, Louis Ridedick, etc are all Pro Justin. Don't let anybody give an objective analysis and suddenly theyre making excuses for Russell and "hating on" Fields. Only one of the two has a legion of apologists online. The media IS blaming the sacks on Russ on other shows. They are saying he shouldn't start and for years they've been openly rooting for him to exit the NFL. This segment was the most objective perspective I've seen which is shocking actually.

[@ashleythomas1001]

😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣

[@victoryasher1729]

This is the first time I’ve watched national sports media, giving a FAIR and INTELLECTUAL assessment of the Steelers situation on my Steelers. Even though my Steelers have a tough game (to say the least), all these commentators gave honest and fair assessments without obsessive negativity. Man, I love this show.

[@Mmrraazz]

Fields didn't miss the throw, the WR messed up the route. I'd expect these guys to know this kind of stuff.

[@gorillasquadelite]

They blaming the o line like we wasn’t watching Russel play out there 😂😂

[@parrionmiller6307]

If you actually watch the coaches tape, you will see that the reason Justin Fields didn’t hit the play action bomb down field was because the receiver didn’t run through his route. He pulled up way too soon to jump for the catch instead of running through the route.

[@Ljay_TheConservativeTruth]

When he played for Denver he didn’t get none of these excuses lol

[@kevinsingler9554]

really good segment

[@juice14oj]

They been throwing shade on Fields ever since he helped out Kapernick with his foundation.

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

I figured it was a race thing

[@soulsimplistic]

Field's could give Shady 1 mil, and Shady would complain that the money wasn't in the preferred denominations....

[@vincentrayyoung3676]

Fields almost threw an INT and almost lost a batted pass.

[@MichiganHendough]

and russ couldnt get in the red zone

[@JuanUpper]

You almost made a point

[@wade2xx552]

And Russell took 3sacks in 1 game & couldn’t move the ball

[@vincentrayyoung3676]

@@wade2xx552 too bad he can’t play RT as well 😂

[@PatriotWatchUSA]

@@MichiganHendough It took JF two games to get there. Wait till the regular season,

[@kingdawg5830]

Fields did something to Shady but Shady really speaking facts about the Steelers sweeping the Ravens and Bengals last year. They were 5-1 in the toughest division

[@kingjames361]

Like I been saying Joy and Shady get so touched when it comes to this topic Russ has not close the door and this is why there is a QB controversy they act like this isn’t the Russ we’ve been seeing the last few years

[@hockeyfan1799]

I needed Molly on this episode to either hear her walk back her Wilson endorsement or continue to defend it somehow 😂😂😂😂😂

[@jarvissledge2530]

They put mike Tomlin in a tough spot

[@cedricmoore8053]

Joy, they are talking about the Steelers today. I don't blame you. I would not have shown up either. Cedric

[@dutch6668]

Why don’t they show the plays when the pop the picture up there they just show a pointless picture

[@deliliankramo7520]

Oh now it’s the OLine? Or the WR dropping passes? Or it’s the injury.. I see Shady always making excuses for people and QBs he likes huh..

[@jctslice]

Russ is rusty. That's to me what it is. Russ is a HoF. There's no way he's truly that bad as a qb

[@arthurzeer753]

@@jctslice he has been rusty since he first joined the broncos

[@jasonjamieson1690]

They keep blaming that throw on Justin, and it was totally on the WR. The bias is sickening.

[@tonishacapri377]

Chiefs fan here. Lol their OL is HORRIBLE LMBOOOO you have to start there

[@ivanramos1415]

Bengals only had 3 points? Buffalo only had 6 points? Both teams held to that by Chicago by the way. Doesn’t mean anything

[@williambreeze2659]

James and Dave held it down on this clip! Fields is the player to start, and on the Bears he was set up for failure!

[@w00deey12]

When the defense knows exactly what you are going to do on every play..... it doesn't matter how good your offensive line is.

[@tiyalewhitehurst338]

The Offensive Line didn't block anybody at all in basically both Games that's Coaching

[@RB-.-]

No Joy = like

[@markjantz6177]

Just use them both. Maybe some extra coaching but more effective. Treat it like baseball with pitchers.

[@LeetraviusMcKay-q6m]

It’s just the preseason and I don’t take anything into account until the regular season starts.

[@RunEmDownTony]

They say Najee is not it, maybe not, but when your OL can't pass protect, then they can't run block either. It goes hand in hand, and it shows. And that throw down field to the end zone by Justin was an ok throw. The receiver stopped and hesitated at the end of his route. Justin tried to place it up and over the defender. I'm not saying that it was an accurate pass, but I think Justin was trying to lead him in the middle of the end zone where he would've been if he didn't pause in his route. He may have had to reach out a little, but it would've been catchable. The receiver paused just before he got to the goal line and then made that jump attempt. He misread the ball in the air.

[@69Savageee]

Shady shouldn't be on TV

[@marvellis6762]

Off the hook yet again.... Tomlin the Untouchable!

[@Ash-lf6to]

As a Saints fan, I get more and more happy that we ended up with Fuaga than Fautanu.

[@PNWLiving1725]

i like the way Shady actually Knows football. Respect. Russell all the way!

[@larwskhayann2645]

I love when media discredit the Steelers… keep the same energy when the season starts

[@chrisphillips9247]

I'm so glad Shady stayed on this show and didn't go to Undisputed. This is my favorite sports show

[@Wolf_Vizion]

This show so much better when it’s ocho, James and TJ

[@ChuloVeniVidiVici]

Everybody looking at the QB's but lets focus the attention on the OC Arthur Smith. Before anybody want to talk about his successful run game in atlanta, lets remember that same OL coach stayed in atlanta. Arthur Smith can't draw up a passing scheme, blame mariota, blame ridder. His stint in with the titans surrounded arpund a good rb and good offensive line. Justin fields talent or russell wilson talent won't overshadow arthur smith oc playing calling deficiency...

[@robindevily9182]

Yea everyone knew they were running that rpo at the goal line it was stupid let your mom lie qb throw and let him decide if he’s gonna take off

[@GodLikeMikeLive]

Shady really has something against Fields. HOF Cris Carter and a few other players said the WR slowed down after his break. The practice squad WR was at fault for that play.

[@Jack-Whitaker]

Can we not forget that Justin fields played with the Steelers 2nd team offense and the bills 2nd team defense. And I’ve learned since last year to take the preseason with a grain of salt, how do you go 3-0 with Kenny Pickett and Matt Canada

[@shootermike65]

Talking about that deep ball by fields being a miss but don’t mention the receiver slowing down on it

[@marquismurphy5644]

It's hilarious because the WR literally stopped running at the top of the route. But the QB literally will get the blame lmaoo😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@marquismurphy5644]

George Pickens that's a TD

[@jonathanmuldrow8458]

Dave Helman was Headpool in Deadpool & Wolverine

[@jaywil0914]

I get that the more captivating conversation is Russ vs Justin but nobody mentions that the OC isn’t that great. Arthur Smith’s track record in Atlanta was abysmal. Do we really trust him to utilize his weapons correctly?

[@huntermoore5464]

Them blaming fields on the deep shot is not his fault at all. If you actually watch the film the WR slows way down for no reason. Blaming him is BS.

[@bigdap100]

09:20 That WR was overthrown b/c he stopped Running, he Hesitated. 🤣😆

[@user-sy3th5vl9h]

I think that deep pass was also on the WR looks like instead of running to the back of the end zone he jumped. I wonder if Pickens tracks that ball properly.

[@marklumar2034]

I feel like we really gotta stop calling russ a future HOFer. Hes got one ring and no MVPs or all pros and at no point of jis career was he considered the best at his position. He was really good and maybe on a HOF trajectory but the last 3-4 years have hurt that case a lot and i think people underestimate just how hard it is to make the NFL HOF

[@HG22Times]

Fields has a 40-30 td int ratio… let that sink in. He is not lamar (68-18 first 3 seasons). He is kenny pickett with straight line speed

[@That0neChanne1]

Fields didn't overthrow him, WR just stuttered at the top of his route then tried to make up for it by jumping to the moon. It's been called out several times, but do they not rewatch plays to double-check before speaking on tv?

[@marcdobbins4302]

Shame on all of you, especially the former NFL WR, for blaming Fields for the missed TD throw. None of you mentioned that the WR stutter-stepped at the end zone instead of running through the ball. If he does that, it is a TD. It is a WR's job to TRACK THE BALL!! Pickens would have caught that ball. BE FAIR!!

[@jayfromcali7091]

Colin said Steelers have the hardest final 1/3rd of the season he's ever seen.. Burrow twice Jackson twice Hurts mahomes and Watson😬+QB Heisman trophy winner 😐

[@dionellwalker9762]

James Jones sounds ignorant when he said he saw the same Steelers offense with Mason Rudolph. Rudolph has been the only serviceable qb for the Steelers since Big Ben's prime. The Steelers went 5-1 in their division last season. James Jones shouldn't even be on the show, Mason Rudolph saved the Steelers season last season and looked like a competent NFL QB and he should have been resigned

[@quentinwagner8221]

I say let those 2 go series for series in the final preseason game.

[@chocboywunda]

McCoy didn’t give Justin a pass like this

[@chrisbrown5037]

These guys need a KZbin podcast not a tv show 😂.

[@jeremybstudentpilot5315]

Both QBs are needed for the Steelers to be successful. Fields has his feet and Russel can throw the ball deep.

[@robindevily9182]

Justin can throw the deep ball there’s even clip of dj noore running the exact same route against the lions and running through and catching fields pas

[@nathanhundley5347]

Fields will win the job

[@FaceFamous]

I hate when Shady and James do that high pitched whine with the last word of their sentence when they get excited and start talking loud

[@nicholailewis3448]

I thought the unwritten rule was to go with the talented young guy and hope his ceiling is higher than the vet on the downward spiral.

[@terencesims366]

I think they keep the same rotation let fields study the game under Russell, he needs to get two more players on the wide out develop the line and it should be good

[@ronnniebuchanan1814]

Its simple. If you want young go with fields and live with the results. If your looking to do something, go with Russ. One is 35 and the other is 26.

[@vibinwithdadawgz]

*25

[@MrOhioPlayer]

KEEP THAT SAME ENERGY JOY AND SHADY!!!!!!Joy took off because she didnt want the heat. These mf excuses for Russ is insane. If Fields looked like Russ looked this game Shady would have lost his mind." All of them Sacks is Fields fault, the steelers dont have a chance with him starting. " Smh were seeing Hate in 4k.

[@CThomas-wg4gc]

Sounds just like what they said about him during his starts with my Broncos….

[@matthewdaniels709]

James is the only one who ever talks like they actually have any ball knowledge...

[@D0NNY-JAMES]

Fields throwing the fastball every time isn’t cutting it.

[@peaceofkake1085]

If I was the owner of the Steelers I would be screaming at Arthur Smith to get the ball into the endzone next game. I feel like the new OC should be held accountable as well.

[@Brawlstriker89]

Acho is the epitome of corporate world talk. Meaning, so inauthentic. I wish they let these people talk like they want. But instead Acho has to talk like he’s a preacher preachin to the choir every episode. “The most controversial, biggest topic this offseason!”

[@sundrelstriker7513]

Idk what Tomlin and the GM was thinking. Acquiring 2 qbs that have timing and in structure issues to the max. He better try and trade for someone.

[@arron-oz9vb]

Russ has to get going the season has started!

[@HardKoreCasual.]

The WR slowed down and didn’t run his route all the way through. Not Justin fault. Cmon yall.

[@BillDozer316]

Bro they got Artie Smith for their OC and y'all expected a cohesive offense?

[@dredrosa]

You talking sense today shadyyyy yeaaaa