Millie's 4th Birthday!! (And a Christmas concert! 🎂🎄)

[@dlford627]

Happy Birthday, Millie! She is so sweet! I can’t believe she’s 4 already. Seems like she was just a baby. I love how everyone says something positive about her and the kids give her a hug! You’re raising a loving family!❤

[@azedel7151]

Yeah. How did that fly by so fast?

[@karolynpieren5129]

Ok I can NOT believe Millie is 4!!! What? And she is so spontaneous and fun. Gosh I could say wonderful things about each child. I have always told my kids “ wait for your birthday”. It does work.

[@romanajakob]

You are like the family I always wished for but never had. Something heals inside me every time I watch your videos. Thank you so much for all the love you put out there and happy birthday Millie 🎉❤

[@TheCrosbys]

You're so kind, you can always be part of the Crosby family!! Thanks for watching :)

[@lisahause8705]

Millie is so adorable…she’s got that charm …such a happy little girl ! She shines like a bright star! Her smile is infectious!!! Awe….she’s just too cute!!!🥳🎂🎈🎉🙏🏻

[@LindaDavis-hi2un]

Happy Birthday Millie🎉. Your children are so precious and talented. It’s because of their wonderful parents.😊❤🎄

[@8cats3dogsafamily57]

River is having separation anxiety. Just get her a crate and crate her when you leave. Put her favorite toys and a few treats in with her. She will end up loving it after she adjusts because it makes them feel secure and safe. We can now tell our 1 year old Australian shepherd to go to the crate and he marches right in and lays down. It’ll be a game changer.

[@susangonzalez6200]

I can't believe she is already 4 years old. Time sure flies by quickly. Happy Birthday Millie. I hope you have a wonderful day.

[@TheCrosbys]

We can't either!!

[@devorahtiller3381]

Happy Birthday, Millie! This family is so beautiful

[@Terrx]

New guitar case for Dave's birthday!!! Happy Birthday Millie!!!

[@Terrx]

Wow, I was a little premature on my comment lol,

[@TheCrosbys]

It was seriously so crazy that we were just talking about it earlier in the video and then they randomly gifted that! Haha but I guess they were the ones that taped it the year before :)

[@jjkazakoff-eigen4662]

@@TheCrosbysYou guys are superstars. This is so amazing. I have to see your video of The First Noel.

[@Elizabeth_Rojas]

Happy birthday Millie I can't believe you're four already. You're getting too big too fast. We love you and hope you have a beautiful day.❤❤❤❤

[@juliemackenzie1978]

Happy 4th Birthday Millie! 👍🎂🎁🎊🎉🥳😊 Thank you for sharing this video with us. 👍🇨🇦😊 What a beautiful performance! 👍👏😊

[@Quarterflipper]

Happy Birthday sweet Millie! I can't believe it's been 4 years already. I look forward to watching you grow into an amazing young woman. CTR ❤

[@rondathiesen9317]

Happy birthday sweet Millie! Looks like you had fun.i remember when you were in mommy's tummy. Look at you now 4 year old. God's blessings for you.😘👍

[@anitabreakone]

Happy Birthday Millie! You are a very smart and pretty little girl. ❤❤❤❤❤ Thanks for sharing part of your big day with us.

[@PK-bh1ww]

HAPPY 4TH B-DAY MILLIE! This was a fun video. So cute what kids think up. Thank you all for sharing. Beautiful singing Claire. 💖

[@natashadealmeida3317]

Thank you for sharing the singing, the fun, the joy of Millie’s birthday and the family being together sharing love and laughter.

[@pearl4879]

What a lovely young lady Millie is! Part of a very lovely family! Thanks for sharing your joy to the world! Blessings to Millie and blessings to the Crosby family! Emmanuel!🙏🏽🕊️✝️🙌🏽✨👑❤️

[@judithmitchell4667]

Millie - It sounds like you had a great 4th birthday. I can't believe you are this old. Pretty soon you'll be a teenager. Enjoy being 4, little one. 🎉🎂🎁🎈 Blessings - Judith 🎭🎤

[@teresahope4678]

Happy Birthday Millie... Enjoy being 4. Hugs to everyone of you 🙂🫂😊

[@sandyr4656]

Happy 4th Birthday Millie🎊 You are growing up way too fast young lady😂 Love hearing you talk❤ You are so well spoken😊 Stay as sweet as you are and you'll go far!!!

[@matthewmarsigliano3613]

Happy 4th Birthday Millie, feels just like yesterday you were born.

[@robynhigginbotham6468]

Happy birthday, Millie!🎉. Great job singing, y’all! Merry Christmas!

[@jefftompkins52]

Happy Birthday Millie! Have a Super-Sparkly day!

[@lucidon1141]

Happy Birthday Millie hope your day was wonderful and you got everything you wanted. Also it's truly amazing to see how much Claire's voice has matured over the years. You guys are awesome

[@allybrenneise7726]

Happy birthday, Millie!! 🎉 I love your family birthday traditions and even though my kids are grown adults, I'm stealing some of them for their next birthdays. 🙌

[@TheCrosbys]

Please do!

[@camiburchett9602]

Happy Birthday, Millie! I love hearing Claire sing & enjoy watching your kids grow up. You have an amazing family!

[@susansaunders6899]

Awe River wants to go with you! Dogs are pack animals! They don't like to be left alone! She needs a friend! Happy Birthday Milly! Clair you are so grown up! I love your voice! I been watching you since you first started singing!!!

[@kspang656]

Happy birthday, Millie!

[@milsteven03]

Happy birthday Millie! You are so adorable! Awe.. I love the Crosbys! ❤

[@raelee1588]

AWESOME !!! Happy 4th B-day Millie !!! THX for Sharing !!! GOD Bless Each of You(s) !!!

[@berenicereyesg.7895]

Happy, Happy Birthday Pretty Millie! I love that she´s very funny, the way she answers back with a smile, her patience and joy, and as Ashley said, she´s so reasonable. I love everything in this video, beautiful Christmas concert, great party and gifts, amazing cousins, awesome parents, awesome kids, and lovely River. Infinite love and blessings always dear Crosbys...

[@Rachel_lyn]

Happy birthday Millie. You are a beautiful young lady now. 🎂🎉🥳

[@jeaniescreations3377]

What a beautiful family you have created those kids have the strongest foundation well done

[@elizabethnewell1689]

Thank you Crosby Family for sharing Millie’s 4th birthday party with us 🥳It feels only yesterday that Claire was 4❤ HAPPY BIRTHDAY MILLE🎈

[@AyeshaMowlana-p9m]

Happy birthday Millie❤🎉 Hope u had a fun day🎉 Have a blessed year ahead ❤❤🎉🎉

[@sharonlouise8459]

Happy Happy Birthday Millie 🎉 Glad we share the same Birthday, much love to you and the family! Yeah...

[@melissadooley7475]

Happy birhday Sweet Millie Crosby ❤🎉🎂🍨💜👣🥰love Missy Dooley from Pennsylvania and i love all your family Ashley, Dave,Clarie,Carson,June ,Millie ❤❤❤❤❤❤😮😊

[@melissadooley7475]

Love Rivers your dog❤💙🐾

[@Sue-ef7pk]

🎉🎉🎉🎉happy birthday Mille 🎂 🥳 🎉 🎈 🎁 🎊 🎂 🥳 🎉

[@marshabearden]

Happy Birthday Millie!🥳 Enjoyed the video seeing all the kids! Beautiful singing! Merry Christmas!❤️💚❤️

[@lisatreaster8948]

Happy Birthday Millie. Love this video all of it. What a great birthday she had by what i seen here. What a big cute adorable big girl she has become. Also loved the part where Clair was singing also love her dad playing along on the guitar. What an amazing voice Claire has. Love to everyone.❤❤❤

[@margaretbuckley2624]

Happy 4 Birthday Millie.. you have grown up so quick.enjoy your big day. AND merry Christmas to you all xxxoo

[@marycook1644]

Now Dave won’t have to wait for his birthday for a new guitar case !! 🎯 Unlike Millie !! 🧸❤️ Beautiful music ! 🎶 Happy Birthday Millie ! I thought I was seeing things when you said she is 4 !! 🍧🍰Blessings everyone from California !! ☃️🎸

[@terridavis6712]

Happy birthday, Millie!! 🎂🍨🎁🎈🎉

[@lorettaandreatta2919]

Happy birthday, Millie 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@KCBABY21986]

You guys have the sweetest family! Millie completes ya’ll so well!!

[@mariebarrett8774]

Happy Birthday Millie 🎂🎁🥳looks like you had a wonderful day xx🎂🥳🎁

[@Adri-oj3yt]

Happy birthday Millie❤🎉. She wants to grow up to be a teenager 😂. Millie is so adorable ❤.

[@darksorrow1321]

Happy Birthday Millie, i wish you a great day with your Family

[@linnylim728]

Millie she is so cute, specially the way she talks, full of joy ❤❤❤! Happy birthday Millie🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤❤❤❤❤!

[@marycasey9404]

Happy birthday sweet Millie🎉🎂☃️❤️

[@Sketcher93]

You guys have great patience with your children.. I believe that comes from your parents having great patience with you. I wish we had all been given patience from our parents so that we could have had that to give to our own children.

[@jeremiahalexander7550]

"Happy 4th birthday to my sweet friend, Millie! Wishing you a day filled with sunshine, laughter, and all your favorite things! You're such a bright and beautiful little girl!" ✨️

[@JG4689]

River is on the couch because it smells like you and gives her comfort. Maybe try leaving a worn jumper of her main person in her doggy bed to see if that comforts her.

[@julielevine2812]

Happy Birthday Millie!!!❤🎉😂

[@raelynchavez7983]

Happy birthday beautiful girl!!! You are amazing!!!❤❤❤❤❤ We all love ya!!❤❤❤

[@alro11]

you guys should not have a dog- way to busy

[@stacysornee]

I suggest confining River to a certain area of the house when you leave.. She doesn’t need the whole house. Happy Birthday Millie!

[@pameila5412]

Happy, Happy Birthday Millie!!🎉

[@tammyhargis2429]

Happy Birthday sweet girl. 🎈🎈🎂🎂🎉🎉🎁🎁❤️❤️

[@sharongoldberg681]

Happy birthday Millie! I hope that you had a wonderful day! 🎉🎁🎂🎈

[@theresarusso3835]

Happy 4th Birthday Millie 🥳The guitar case is cool

[@christa526]

THIS is the music our Claire is called to sing! Praise God. Thank you, Crosbys. Merry Christmas and love to you all

[@scotttovey]

Happy Birthday Millie! 🎂🎁

[@bigjonswife]

I can’t believe she is already 4. Have a very happy birthday Millie.

[@eveseldercare]

Wow....time has zipped by so fast... soon the family will have a new big house to move to. Mom and Dad now has a brood between ages 4..to 12... In the new house in 4 years, it will be a brood from ..8.years...to 16...yikes... So much to look forward to ..with a WHOLE FAMILY OF MUSICAL FUN.....AND LOTS OF LOVE.......and many ..many videos of the kids growing up....yes...I always think of this movie...when her name is mentioned...".Thoroughly Modern Millie " a 1967 musical-romantic comedy... and old film...kid friendly..

[@badeds100]

Happy Birthday Millie! Claire’s dress is so pretty! I love you guys so much! God bless you all!

[@laurafoote214]

Awwww, Happy Birthday Millie! 💜

[@jvtv1234]

Wow, she's growing up so fast! Happy Birthday, Millie🎉

[@Molly-ec8ec]

Millie is such a cute mouse! She is so vibrant and laughs all the time. - And I think you two are such loving parents staying up half the night to make everything perfect for your little one.

[@TheJlleyba]

Happy happy birthday, Millie! 🎉 you are so adorable as are all of your brother and sisters. Adorable family thanks for sharing.

[@kellyangelo3412]

Happy 4th birthday Millie...I can't believe you're 4 already. Millie has grown into an adorably cute 4 year old who is not afraid to speak her mind I hope she never loses that. All the kids are getting so big and grown up so fast. Beautiful family ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@jimgilmore6294]

Happy birthday Milly. I can’t believe you’re already four years old. I love your cute little song.

[@Laura-q7m4h]

They grow up so fast enjoy your family time with everyone Love ❤️ your family Happy birthday Millie 💕 congratulations Claire your voice sounds amazing

[@maggiemacha5552]

Happy 3rd Birthday dear Millie 🎉🎊🥳 wishing you a happy and healthy trip around the sun ☀️

[@Adri-oj3yt]

Your children are so beautiful ❤. God bless you all.

[@Sadieapprecaandslaydaday]

Happyest birthday silly Millie you are so adventurous and beautiful and ice 😚😚😚😚😚🧡🧡💛💛💛💙🩵🩵😛😛😋😋 always sing and do your thing 😗😊

[@patricialora5692]

Lovely family tradition! Happy birthday Miss Millie 🎉

[@ridingtheroad185]

Happy Birthday Millie!!! All of our camera's and plugs are Wyze! Thank you for the best products!

[@doriamoreira158]

Happy birthday Millie!!!🎂👏

[@franyamashita7780]

Happy Birthday , Millie❤

[@weez5987]

Millie is adorable!🥹 happy birthday 🎉🎈🎂

[@karenkoroscil9568]

Happy Birthday Millie! I can’t believe you’re four already! Wow! 🎈🎈🎈🎈

[@Carolbearce]

Happy birthday Millie, it looks like you had an amazing day.

[@monikastuckey8737]

Happy birthday Millie! Cannot believe you are 4 already.

[@Sweetie67]

I love how you celebrate your children on their birthdays.

[@straightarrow372]

Inculcating joy. Unheard of in my family.

[@sallylengyel9916]

Happy birthday! 🎁🎈🎂 Great singing Claire! ❤❤

[@johnhenstock9668]

Delightful! Glad Millie had a happy birthday! Lovely video!

[@Iren2086]

С днем рождения, Милли! 😁

[@sarahrabe3397]

Happy 4th Birthday Millie 🎂

[@MackBell723]

Millie can't be 4 already.... well happy 4th Birthday to Millie, looks like a fantastic day. I love how you guys do the "best part about..." on their birthday... so sweet. 🥰

[@raderanneke]

Happy Birthday Millie!!

[@cathy0954]

Happy Birthday Millie!❤❤🎉🎉

[@bethkelsey1]

OMGoodness. I must have read The Monster at the End of the Book every day for six or more years! More than once a day! Maybe 5000 times in all. My daughter (now 45) loved it! Happy Birthday Millie!

[@NanaCooks247]

Happy Birthday Millie!!!🎉🎉🎉 🎂 🎁 🎂 🎁

[@treskrever8590]

Happy Birthday, Millie! You're such a sweet girl, and you have a beautiful family! ❤

[@kimleahy940]

Happy birthday to Millie💝💝 beautiful singing Claire and a great version of that song.. your voice just gets better all the time … happy Christmas to you all 🎄🎅… god bless 🙏

[@Viola_Fields]

Happy birthday Millie 🎈🎁🎀💕Poor River. Dogs are not meant to be solitary beings. They need a companion, just like their hooman siblings. 🐶

[@Jadyn_Sage]

@@Viola_Fields It's not like River is home alone all day. Ashley & Millie are home all day with her. They were out for a few hours on this particular evening

[@patriciadean5452]

AMEN ​@@Jadyn_Sage

[@cher-ker]

A Blessed Happy and Joyous 4th Birthday Millie🎉🎉🎉🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻You are just A Smart ,Cute and Precious Soul👌🤗 I Pray, Declare and Decree GOD'S Abundant Blessings over You in all aspects of life in JESUS Mighty and Precious Name AMEN and AMEN 🙏🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼Sending Lotz of Love ,Blessings and Prayer from South Africa ❤🇿🇦

[@tammycampbell112]

River is obviously much- loved. She's just being a rebel.

[@karenedmonds1728]

U😢p

[@katelinthomson5249]

Can’t believe how big all the kids are getting. Beautiful family, love watching your videos 🥰💜🩷💙🩵

[@dandeliondreamer3365]

Millie is sooooo adorable 🥰 my favorite thing about Millie is that she is the cutest just the way she is, before she is a teenager 😉, Happy Birthday Millie ❤🎉🎂!!!

[@abigailvan-JGV]

Wow!! She is talented. The Lord keep you Claire and family!!❤

[@maryannlee4751]

Happy 4th Birthday Sweet...Beautiful Millie ..You are such an Adorable Doll❤

[@frankgustafson1905]

Happy Birthday Millie. ❤👍🥳😃

[@AlisonYoung-yw5wb]

Happy birthday Millie. She is so cute. Love your family adventures. Lots of love from Alison in Ireland