6 BEST Waterproof Mascaras-All Drugstore

[@S__Kay]

I came across this video while looking for the next waterproof mascara to buy and I see that a lot girls here worry about taking waterproof mascaras off. I've been using plain old almond oil to remove my eye make up for years. It works great and takes off every mascara. Trust me.

[@mas905]

Thank you for the two cruelty-free options Nyx and Essence. I no longer support any big companies like Maybelline and L'Oreal that still perform archaic animal testing. Thank you for the no-ads-during and the hints on how to remove! 💜

[@auntiedramey3855]

I'm a waterproof fan!!!!! My favorite is Maybelline Volum"Express the Colossall cat eye. I may try others but I always go back to cat eye. Love it!!!!

[@Bearcub599]

Thank you! Great reviews on waterproof mascaras which I wear all the time.

[@sandraherrera8351]

Great video ! I just subscribed to your channel. I am 61 years young with short, sparse lashed AND oily hooded eyes to make it worse. I recently started using waterproof mascara because they hold the curl better. I use PONDS cold cream makeup remover (with green lid) and follow with Neutrogena blue bottle remover.

[@marinouechat]

thank you for this video!! helped me choose a mascara ❤

[@jennifergoodwin2844]

Hi Bobbie. I was ready for a new mascara & after watching this video I chose to try the Essence Lash Princess. I am extremely happy with the product & the fact that it is affordable & that it really does NOT smudge in amazing! Thank you for your videos, they are greatly appreciated. (I'm planning on trying the Milani Stay Put Eyeliner next) xx

[@dianehiltz1193]

Another favourite video, thank you Bobby 💜

[@silvercurlszelda]

Thank you so much for these! I don't wear mascara at this point, but when I do I wanted to find something that was simple and waterproof.

[@Lisa-yg9tn]

Thanks, I’m always on the look out for smudge proof mascara. L’Oreal Bambi Eyes is also a great mascara. I would love a version about eyeliner. I have the hardest time finding a good eyeliner that doesn’t smudge.

[@MindfulMidlife]

I don’t use much eyeliner so I’m not sure if I would make a great video for that but I am starting to experiment a bit.

[@KylaRose2082]

This video was soooo helpful! Thank you! Also, you have beautiful eyes ❤

[@brilubread]

Thank you for this video I’m not sure why my go to mascara started smudging so much under my eyes all of a sudden, I think they changed the formula

[@evajawidzk2068]

looking for a new mascara and found your video . Some I tried and enjoyed clumps are annoying especially when it messes up your eyeshadow.

[@venust.4119]

Thanks for that, I'm always on a lookout for a good waterproof mascara myself. They just hold a curl better in a humid climate and smudge less. I like the lash princess one. The one i couldn't recommend enough is Maybelline lash discovery. I love it!

[@JanTownsend-mu1jz]

I have dry eyes and my eyes are are always watering. My eyeshadow on my mobile lid always washes off and several of the waterproof mascara’s have too. Thank you or giving me some new options.

[@martimar7181]

I’ve used L’Oréal Voluminous Waterproof Mascara for 30 years, and I’ve always used baby oil on a damp cotton round to take it off. Essence is my back-up. 🥹

[@Sbannmarie]

What a great video. I’m on hunt for a waterproof mascara.

[@catherineg9943]

Have you done videos for long lasting lip liners, and no budge lipstick/stain/gloss? What about “plumping” lip products? Thanks!!

[@nojones-d6s]

Which is best for bottom lashes and nooo flaking?

[@kellyburnett1833]

I have the same thing with my eyelashes, I always have to curl them first and I use the blow dryer trick to warm up my curler. I have to use waterproof or they just fall..I have used the Maybelline Rocket lash , I saw another KZbin video that said the curl bounce was good, so I plan on trying it. Love your videos. 😊

[@MindfulMidlife]

I’ve never tried Maybelline‘s rocket mascara. I may have to try that.

[@noemimatias3729]

Great video 👍🏼 Which one do you find the easiest to remove?

[@MindfulMidlife]

I find all of them pretty easy to remove with an oil cleanser like Clinique Takes the day off melting balm or elf melting balm.

[@sharonczalbowski457]

Bobbie that Colossal one looked really pretty on you. Probably cause it gave both length and volume. Which is what I like. I'm willing to try Essence again. Maybe waterproof will work for me better than the others I've tried from that brand. I recently saw a video on the Milani mascara I heard is good. Can't remember if it was waterproof. Anyway thanks for showing all drugstore. Happy 4th 💥🗽🎆

[@stephv1202]

thank you for this list. i have been using regular, waterproof elf for years but it is not always easy to find and i am happy to try something new. your market research is appreciated❣️

[@donnaalqassar1716]

Great video! I always have the problem with mascara even the waterproof ones smudging under my eyes...L'Oréal Voluminous is the only one this never happens with! I love it! I use Purity by Philosophy to remove it and all my makeup.

[@MindfulMidlife]

Try putting your eye primer under your eye and then lightly powder to set.

[@Cremidoe]

I was wondering about how easy these are to remove? One of the reasons I avoid waterproof mascara is because of how hard they can be to remove.

[@kellyburnett1833]

I have to use waterproof, and I hate removing it. The best trick I have found is to let the makeup remover sit a little before using any water, and then I gently swipe most off with my clean fingers and I use Almay makeup lotion. Then I just use a washcloth and gently swipe to remove the rest. If I still have some , I use a qtip to get the rest. I always use a lash conditioner after I am done. That is just my way of doing it ,and not losing lashes in the process.

[@debbyritchie2608]

Just use an oil cleanser or an eye makeup remover for waterproof mascara.

[@MindfulMidlife]

My favorite eye make up remover is Clinique take the day off. It works amazing! If you want a cheaper way of taking it off you can use elf make up remover balm or Clean It zero melting balm. all of those use an oil to get the make up off and it works great.

[@orosco97]

@@kellyburnett1833 Would you mind sharing what lash conditioner you use? Thanks!

[@kellyburnett1833]

@@orosco97 Hi..I use Select Lash Eyelash Serum...it goes on like mascara .it is clear .it has no fragrance and it never feels sticky or crunchy ..I feel it conditions lashes. I think Sally Beauty Supply store may sell it ?? I usually get it from eBay. Even if I don't wear mascara that day..I still use it before I go to sleep. I have really sensitive eyes and this has never burned or done anything to make my eyes hurt.

[@ccxcrazy]

Off topic but that eyeliner colour is so nice on you!

[@judytax9887]

I use maybelline full and soft waterproof and have for years. I don’t like a lot of mascaras that others rave about because they clump on me. Love your videos!!! Just recently found your channel and have been binge watching your videos. Your hair is beautiful!!!!!! I’ve been going through hormonal hair loss and it’s so frustrating. Using minoxidil and going to try a red light to see if that helps. Thank you for sharing with us!!! ❤️

[@MindfulMidlife]

I understand about the hair loss it’s so frustrating. I have been using a hair helmet from IRestore for the past 6 to 7 months. It has literally stopped my hair from shedding. I haven’t seen much regrowth yet but I’m not sure if I should at this point. It’s not a cheap thing at all but I am really happy that my hair has stopped falling out. I did do a video on the helmet a few months ago so you may want to look at that video to see what it is.

[@judytax9887]

@@MindfulMidlife I did see that video. It’s a little pricey for me but am going to try something a cheaper and see what happens. I have to wonder if I had Covid and didn’t know it since so many people are seeing hair loss as a side effect. Here’s to a full head of hair!!! 🥂

[@lorainemcgillivray77]

Hi Bobbi I tried the Essence and it was a smudgy mess on me lol - in fact the waterproof smudged worse than the regular which also smudges. I have rosacea and some eye involvement from that - causes dry eye (very watery eyes) when in a flare. I've been using some tubing mascaras which are working fairly well. They have to be removed with WARM water, so my normal watery eyes don't break them down and they last pretty well for me. Curl isn't really an issue, as I have curly hair and my lashes are never straight either. Tubing mascaras aren't overly volumising, but they lengthen really well and give a pretty fanned out effect on the lashes. Best wishes.

[@MindfulMidlife]

I’m glad you found one that works for you. The tubing kind don’t work at all for me! It’s funny how we all are so different.

[@Karlucci7]

Thank you so much for this video! I have to use eye drops every two hours and wear full face of makeup every day. Waterproof Mascara is a must for me.

[@heathmeizer9446]

Awesome video. I only wear waterproof mascara. Thank you 🙏

[@teamginger6359]

Yay! Thank you for doing this!

[@LenaSheppard]

Awesome! Thanks for sharing as I struggle finding one that won't uncurl my lashes. I like cg lash blast but it's a pain in the beehive to take out sometimes. I so appreciate you keeping us company !

[@MindfulMidlife]

Hey Lena, what do you use to remove your mascara? Have you tried elf melting bomb or Clinique take the day off?

[@LenaSheppard]

@@MindfulMidlifeI use the pf cleansing balm or the dhc cleansing oil & just take my time to work it in & it eventually all comes out.

[@ACottageGirl]

I’m terrified of waterproof mascaras… I don’t know how to remove them without tugging on my skin, using a ton of makeup remover that ends up stinging, and losing eyelashes. I’ve been experimenting with tubing mascaras… no smudging, mostly no flaking and {should} remove easily with warm water and no tugging. Downside, most cause my curl to droop unless I have a lash lift. Would love to see how you remove these. Happy 4th!

[@MindfulMidlife]

I remove my mascara using clean it zero. I get it at Ulta. I also love Clinique take the day off melting balm. It works amazing on waterproof mascara‘s.

[@scarletthegreat]

Remember, WATERproof products aren't going to be removed with water-based makeup remover. You want to opt for oil based removers, and once your makeup is all off you can then use your regular face wash. ❤

[@eli4delmar]

What about flaking? Which is the least flakey?

[@user-hm6xy8ii1o]

ty!

[@palpak06]

Which one is the easiest one to remove ?

[@abigailmorales5949]

I have problem finding a mascara that doesn’t smudges under the eyes. Do this ones work?

[@beverlydenton1425]

I love waterproof but I have a difficulty in removing it what would you recommend

[@janes8863]

Just remember a lot of mascara says waterproof be sure to check the list of ingredients if WATER is listed it is NOT waterproof.

[@stormyweather2773]

I so needed this ! I also can only wear waterproof mascara…and I’m always in search of the holy grail 💞

[@nitsirkroy]

Curious as to what u think of the ilia mascara. I love how it just glides on lengths no clumping and a natural volume BUT it’s not waterproof 😭

[@MindfulMidlife]

I have not tried it. I've heard good things about the brand, but I don't think I've tried any of it yet.

[@sarahdoanpeace3623]

Lash Princess is my new mascara obsession!! It’s truly spectacular!!! I use it everyday now! Maybeline is always great, too! Always a joy to see/watch you Bobbie! You’re so beautiful! Hope you had a fabulous 4th of July! Thank you for another wonderful, helpful and joyful video!

[@pamelawolf313]

My eyes night and day, so I NEED waterproof everything. My problem is, my lashes are so short that I can’t use a big bristled brush. Good luck 🍀 finding that. (Plus waterproof and brown, forget about it) lol makeup struggles. Lol 😊TY for this video

[@melissanelson1975]

Do you like the sky high mascara?

[@Sheislove144]

Your eyes are stunning

[@stefaniabella8156]

Thank you! Very informative video! Happy July 4th 😁👌🏻🌺💛👠👜💟💜💚☀️🌷

[@mariad7915]

I always find the mascara videos interesting, especially the waterproof. I only wear waterproof because I'm such a cryer, happy or sad. :D What I find most interesting is how one waterproof is great for one person and not the other when it comes to flaking or smudging. Also for me, I'm sensitive to the bristles and find CG and Essence hurt. :P Essence Lash Princess, any Essence doesn't work for me, neither does L'Oreal's original wp Voluminous or Maybelline's Falsies Lift. I really need to try Maybelline's Bounce. Maybelline's Colossal 36hr WP works great, but must be the 36hr. Also I found these to hold up to my tears and a give me a lash I like, sometimes thick and full and sometimes more natural/easier to remove mascara: Maybelline's Full n Soft, Snapscara, Revlon's Volumazing, L'Oreal's Lashlifting and Air Volume. Buxom is my favorite. First time a higher end beat out a drugstore. However, not enough to buy unless half off. :)

[@MindfulMidlife]

It is so weird how we all are so different. I’m glad you found ones that works for you Maria.

[@miscedezshaw86]

Thank u for that, I brought that princess because everyone talked so good about it. But it transferred and smudged under my eyes.

[@lintej]

Thanks for this review! For whatever reason, I've avoided waterproof mascaras. Now I find out that maybe it's the reason my lashes won't hold a curl. Go figure! LOL! Much appreciated!

[@MindfulMidlife]

I wish so much that my lashes would hold a curl but sadly they don’t. Try out some waterproof ones and see if it works better for you.

[@wendybrown3502]

Wonderful video Bobbie! I have used some of these and love them too! I want to try some of these great suggestions. I absolutely have to use waterproof also. I'm currently using a combo of Loreal Lash Paradise, and Maybelline Sky High. They work great together. Love your channel! Happy 4th!❤💙🇺🇸

[@sandraherrera8351]

Hi I am curious as to both Loreal and Maybelline you mentioned you use are both waterproof or you put the waterproof as your second mascara!

[@wendybrown3502]

@@sandraherrera8351 yes! I use both in waterproof. The Sky High is excellent for the bottom lashes and to go over the Lash Paradise on the top. Separates the lashes beautifully! Hello! Hope you are doing well!!🥰

[@sandraherrera8351]

@@wendybrown3502 thank you for your quick response. I would like to know what you use to remove TWO waterproof mascaras?

[@wendybrown3502]

@@sandraherrera8351 I use Ponds Cold Cream and Makeup remover. I've used it for years. It's so affordable and removes everything!😊

[@sandraherrera8351]

@@wendybrown3502 I use Ponds makeup remover too and follow with the Neutrogena blue bottle eye makeup remover. It works amazingly well!

[@glencoco7559]

Can you link the lash comb you mentioned?

[@MindfulMidlife]

Yup: amzn.to/3Jxd242

[@glencoco7559]

@@MindfulMidlife thank you!

[@deborah3912]

I have sensitive eyes and even waterpoof seems to smudge, which one would you recommend?

[@MindfulMidlife]

Where does it smudge-under or on your lid?

[@tericoulter4426]

Pick ONE!

[@rosemarygomez6393]

I bought EyeKo waterproof and it’s amazing but I find it vert difficult to get it off! I have Clinique and Lancôme removers and still incredibly difficult . Anyone have a better solution?

[@MindfulMidlife]

You may wanna try a melting balm instead of a liquid make up remover. You definitely want to use a remover that has oil in it but sometimes waterproof can be difficult to get off.

[@rosemarygomez6393]

Mindful Midlife any melting balm in particular that you like? Thank you!

[@lyric8529]

Do they all TRULY not flake? I have a favorite mascara that I've loved for years BUT it flakes like crazy so for that reason I hate it. Clumps I can comb out but flakes 😩

[@MindfulMidlife]

The only time I have flaking is when the mascara is getting older. It starts to dry up and the flakes start. Since we are all so different, you will have to try and see which work well for you.

[@Becky_in_Tucson]

I have not found the Essence waterproof mascara to be waterproof AT ALL. It smudges and smears on hot days. Very disappointing. Thanks for the other suggestions!😎

[@MindfulMidlife]

Hmmm, do you more oily skin? I’m always so curious how one works for some and not others. Which ones work for you?

[@Becky_in_Tucson]

@@MindfulMidlife I'm actually pretty dry at my age, but still get a shiny T-zone. I hadn't tried waterproof mascaras in a very long time since they had been so hard to remove. Everyone else seems to love this one, so I tried it without any luck. Oh, well! Everybody's different! Thanks for your helpful videos!💖

[@susjon1]

Can u check a eyeliner and a mascara that does not transfer on under eye if u wear a concealer like Bobbi brown creamy concealer w no powder?would make my wish come thru

[@MindfulMidlife]

I always wear waterproof, but I also use powder. You may want to try using an eye primer under your eyes.

[@susjon1]

@@MindfulMidlife could u try it for us who can't wear powder

[@eellaanndd]

I wish you would have included the best way to remove waterproof mascara

[@MindfulMidlife]

Yes I probably should have included that! I will tell you that the best way to remove it is with A melting balm like Clinique take the day off, or ELF melting balm. Both of those work really well! I also like clean it zero, I find that at Ulta.

[@kannn777]

The non waterproof Lash princess is the worst on me . I’m scared to wear water proof bc I don’t want to have to scrub my eyes. . I wore the voluminous for YEARS and loved it. It always looked pretty dramatic on me (but I have pretty long lashes)

[@MindfulMidlife]

You are sooo blessed!

[@Lúthien_Tinúviel89]

Which of these will hold up to crying? I have to go to court next on Thursday to testify against my abusive ex husband & I can’t have raccoon eyes if I cry, I have sparse eyelashes & so I want to wear mascara. I only have a very crappy stocked Walmart & Amazon (if it arrived by Wednesday) available to me.

[@Hannah.1201]

Came here because I’ve been using the essence one for years but after a few weeks it dries out and flakes all over my cheeks😭

[@GeminiJonson]

You have beautiful eyes.

[@milo5157]

❤

[@mildredbc5425]

💕

[@martijobarrett4527]

😅You're KILIIN' ME, KID! You were doing SO well showing the afters! What about the last three! ... Ugh.😜

[@-alyssa-marie-]

I tried the essence waterproof mascara and it FLAKED all over my face. It was also not black black, it had a grey cast. Very disappointed because I remember the formula being better years ago

[@jeanettesmith765]

I find Essence Lash Princess to be very flaky.

[@MindfulMidlife]

It will flake on me when it starts to get dry or old. Of course, I find that with most mascaras. Otherwise it doesn't flake on me.

[@triciabuenaluz6438]

Maybelline lash lift is not waterproof. It smudges wonderfully. Don't waste your money.