Minecraft Bedrock: EASY Item Categorizer Storage System Tutorial! MCPE Xbox PS5 PC

[@silentwisperer]

*update:* if your hopper cart is picking up 64 items, try making the repeater at 9:13 1 tick instead of 2 :) Do you prefer item categorizers or multi item sorters 🤔Multi item sorters have higher sorting density but also much more expensive and kinda tedious to deal with. Lemme know your thoughts :D Subscribe and share for more bedrock tutorials! :D BTW: if you only put 1 item into the input chest, sometimes the cart will take it before the system can read it. put another item in and it'll fix it tho,. or just put a minimum of 2 items in:)

[@HaraldHD]

I'm just filling up my multi item sorter, i might expand it, with this🤗

[@tried5736]

Please pin that guy below you

[@everclear3021]

I prefer multi-item sorters as most of those designs don't have noisy minecarts :D. But Ive noticed since 1.20 the redstone animation updating bugs out (dust and components, appear to freeze), although the system appears to continue working. Nice design, like the arrangement for the category chests.

[@randomconfusion2922]

I have literally been scoring the internet for a compact item categorizer for bedrock! THANK YOU! I'll combine this with your shulker loaders to make my ideal storage room! THANK YOU AGAIN!!!

[@sambuma]

Anything that doesn't require pre-filling every slot in the receiving chests since that defeats the purpose of having something to group and store items easily really. I realize QC and a couple other Java mechanics give an advantage to these systems, but I definitely figured it was possible to make proper multi-item storage systems on Bedrock as well with some reconfiguration. Before this one, MaddHatter had the only such system so glad to see more options coming out. Thanks for explaining the mechanics as well. Also, did they fix the original Impulse Filter on Bedrock or was that just for demonstration purposes?

[@randomconfusion2922]

I have literally been scouring the internet for a compact item categorizer for bedrock! THANK YOU! I'll combine this with your shulker loaders to make my ideal storage room! THANK YOU AGAIN!!!

[@Flare7832]

He said Scouring meaning to search and not scoring

[@DarkReality911]

Possibly, one of SW's *most useful builds* Unfortunately, one of the most time-consuming and frustrating when something goes wrong. It literally eats its own intestines. *TOP TIPS* A➧ Use 10-15 slices → 6 is NOT enough: even if not building them initially, leave enough space B➧ Minecart too fast? → if using more than 6 slices, send the cart on a 10-20 block detor, a U-bend after it drops down. C➧ Too Fragile or Laggy? → build it in the side of a cliff, keep it safe and not visible when outside. Run hoppers from a drop-box on the outside of the cliff into the loader. D➧ Be Gentle! → when testing a new setup, use a single type of item, ensure the repeater by trench triggers and the unloaded items flash the correct comparator on the roof. Only then risk spamming the input. Keep an eye on overflow, and abort if errors are noticed. E➧ Rename Fillers → ensure the flesh (or whatever) in category chests 11:02 is renamed and none get fed into the system. Give the minecart fillers a different name (0-42-1-1-1). F➧ Too many overflow items? → rotate overflow chest 90 degrees and run hoppers into a stack of chests. Maybe even feed a single-item sorter for each. G➧ Minecart never moves? → check you left a hole under the piston on left of cart 10:05 H➧ Minecart takes all 64 items? → make the repeater at 9:13 into 1 tick I➧ Minecart not moving when 1 item added to chest? → it occasionally happens, add a button on the block behind the cart J➧ One slice does not work? → ensure there is only ONE of each item in category chest K➧ One item does not work? → ensure it is not duplicated in another slice L➧ Machine ate all category chests? → detect overflow before it digests your whole setup, add an observer to the overflow chest feeding redstone lamp with a couple of note blocks, at least you can stop things fast! M➧ Need easier access to setup? → Build a curved staircase in front of the first chest, going directly to the right of the minecart to join with the existing trench.

[@wdjh3434]

THANKS SO MUCH I WAS HAVING PROBLEMS WITH THE MINECART TOO FAST I WROTE AN ENTIRE ESSAY JUST DESCRIBING THE PROBLEM BEFORE READING YOUR COMMENT

[@kvn6542]

Hello, 2 Items from the Hoperminecart are allways ending up in the Chest. Do you know a fix? thank you for the Help

[@violakuso2007]

ugh, this is so annoying. i made mine with extra categories. i think 10. and it doesnt move at all. the chest loads the item into the minecart hopper but it never moves. i left a hole as mentioned in the tips. i dont know what I did wrong. it's going to suck to have to tear it all down and rebuild. any suggestions????? :(

[@kvn6542]

@@violakuso2007 Just take a quick look in the video if the minecart doesnt go it should be an easy fix. Just compare your build with his. Do you have placed an powered rail under the chest where the minecart stands? maybe thats the Problem

[@DarkReality911]

​@@violakuso2007 try adding a button on the block behind the cart. Sometimes the first movement does not happen, but then upon return it loads next item and goes automatically.

[@quinnjackson9252]

I swear that Silent is in my head. Years ago, I am sitting at home thinking about how much I missed my pre- village and pillage iron farm. Half an hour later, a Silentwisperer tutorial comes out for a new super iron farm. I talk with my friends about how I wish that bedrock had java edition guardian farms, and the next day a guardian farm that's better than anything java has comes out! I tear down my old broken raid farm, and sure enough, Silent had just released the new insane 50 villager super stacked raid farm of doom the day before! Now, for the first time in months I open up my world to build a new storage system, and 25 minutes later I see a brand new storage system design!!! Seriously, Silent's skin may be a zombie pigman, but he's the GOAT!!

[@aaggroberlin19]

Lol most of "his farms" are not his farms though. Same goes to stuff like the iron farms.

[@quinnjackson9252]

@@aaggroberlin19 You really gonna be that guy? Comments section police using "quotes" to make yourself extra condescending. They are his because he makes the best tutorials and usually edits designs, even if someone else actually designed the original build. However, Silent designs a great deal of his stuff, including the one which this tutorial depicts.

[@aaggroberlin19]

@@quinnjackson9252 No, they are NOT his. Most of them are from people that made another version BEFORE he made it (from discord for example). Please inform yourself before you spread misinformation. I am pretty sure others made "his" categorizer before him.

[@quinnjackson9252]

@@aaggroberlin19 Okay Goebbles, settle down. 1. If you bothered to watch the video, Silent says that the design is his. He always clarifies whether or not the builds are his, and they are usually his designs. Please inform yourself before spreading misinformation. 2. Even if a build is not originally his, Silent puts in huge amounts of time and effort making them as compact, efficient, and minimalistic when it comes to resources. 3. Designs are given to Silent for the sole purpose of him making tutorials on them, spreading his knowledge and helping other Minecrafters out. He is not some sort of thief, and he is the best redstone tutorial creater on Minecraft Bedrock edition. I have never seen someone freak out so much about something so trivial! 🤣

[@punisherclassic8006]

@@quinnjackson9252 dude you did a 20 lines text for a random person in the internet who disagreed with you just to defend a youtuber + used emoji at the end to look confident, and he is the one freaking out? Right lmao

[@davidwestwood1459]

This is incredible, exactly what I've been looking for. The perfect middle man in the item storage field. The multi-item sorter is just too large, and leaving behind an item can be rough

[@yundaz]

If you could add a section near the end where you go through the system and what each thing is doing would be great! I'd like to understand what each section is doing and why it works a bit.

[@gavinlee1577]

Agreed! That would help me understand what does what and see it actually do it :)

[@samparkins6268]

i have been waiting for a video like this for 3 years. The only one for bedrock that i found was by a random youtuber, and it was barely stackable. This is AMAZING

[@evanwhite2845]

Thank you so much! I’ve been waiting for a good design like this since I started playing bedrock edition. Recently I’ve tried to stop following a lot of redstone tutorials in my world, challenging myself to design stuff, but I’m definitely going to be making an exception for this

[@J_Freak]

Last time you asked for what machine we'd want to see built in a survey I voted for this and am so glad to finally see it! The Java ones don't seem to work on Bedrock and I've seen very few well-functioning item categorisers for bedrock besides the one by Maddhatter which was very expensive, required multiple of the items in the categorizing chest and a tedious design. I'm so happy to see you've made such a simpler design. Thankyou so much Silent!!

[@SeanRa77]

I built a giant bank a long time ago with the plans to have a deposit chest that would auto sort the items into specific categories in a vault below, but the item sorter solution was going to be too massive and I ended up dropping it. Wish I knew this was a thing back then, would have made that task trivial. Bravo Silent, you always amaze me.

[@TedTheFatCat]

This thing has some very clever redstone ideas i haven't seen before. The way you put your filter items back in the filter box is so simple, and the burnout timer is very nice. Great job. Thanks.

[@masonaut0]

Silent yet again casually releases a new design that will completely change the meta.

[@silentwisperer]

you know it 😎😎😎

[@tupik-yc3ze]

I first thought it's too complicated to fit into my house and more importantly - for me to understand, but in the end it turned out to be so so easy and I now feel like I know redstone. Thank you for your tutorials

[@dendriedefrancia7848]

Great video! I just finished making it on our server, and it works wonderfully! I had only one problem: I made this with 50 slices. Everything works fine, but the minecart returns before the system could finish sorting the items, resulting in the minecart not being able to pick up the specific item in the category chest. As a result, the item ends up in the output chest. My solution for this is to stop the minecart for a few seconds to allow the system enough time to finish sorting before the minecart returns and brings more items to the sorter. I tried hooking up a hopper clock to the powered rail on the minecart's drop-off point. The logic is that the minecart lands on the unpowered rail, and after the timer is done, it will power the rail to send off the minecart. However, I don't know how to do this in a compact way, and I can't seem to make it work.

[@lovethemguitars]

did u ever figure it out? im having the same issue

[@shimmyjim011]

@@lovethemguitars I've been having the same issue, I replaced a few of the tracks on the return section for the Minecart to regular rails instead of powered and it seems to slow down the Minecart enough to allow it to filter through all the items first. You mau have to tinker with the timings of the farm to as you need to make sure that the minecart is only picking up 63 items so it allows for the 1 items from the chest to be picked up Hope this helps :)

[@Introtoknowledge]

I put 2 cobwebs above the powered rail. And it seems to work!

[@shilasarkar6003]

You have no idea how long I have been waiting for this

[@azazel261]

bro just carries the entire bedrock community on his own. keep up you amazing work. btw my sorter broke :( but after i understood how it works it was easy to fix

[@judsongreenwood2636]

Dang it. I just built a massive version of the simple multi item sorter because i didnt think that these were possible. Time to tear down and build this one

[@bryantiede6763]

This why testing phases happen. With the two redstone repeaters at 9:26 I have the first one he placed on 1 tick and second one on 2 ticks. This is how I figured out how to load the chests without the hopper minecart taking the whole stack

[@hubby_oida]

Thanks for the hint. Changing the first one to three ticks is all it needed for me.

[@casparvonhollen8519]

Having the first one on one and the second on two worked for me

[@pomps9056]

Ur a lifesaver bro

[@tronalddump3649]

Thanks so much for this silent! I’ve been waiting for your item categorizer design ever since you said you were making one in you latest multi-item storage system video. Can’t wait to built this in my world to solve all of my storage needs lol

[@Xenon_177]

I was gonna start making a multi sorter this week, perfect timing for you posting, definitely gonna make this

[@Tylerbruce-bf8rp]

This is pretty insane, its just all the items are put messily into the chests but that's no different than what my storage system is right now anyway. Incredible!

[@DefinitivamenteONalbe.]

I'm Brazilian, and here you are very recognized, congratulations for always revolutionizing several farms and systems

[@Plant-Man]

Hopper minecart won’t take the items from the input chest. It will do it one time and then deactivate itself. Along with that, whatever block you have first in the category chest, it will only take that block and put everything else in the overflow chest.

[@airareginaputri8178]

Yes, same

[@Toastedriceballs]

Likewise!

[@MasterOfJackShizz]

Anyone find a solution for this? I appear to have the same issue on my Realm

[@ghoulish_Fenrir]

Same here and still no reply!! Silent please help us!!!

[@deriksiphone]

This works so good! I still don't know if I fully understand how it's working. I get the idea but knowing bedrock Redstone, surprised it works so well! Thank you for this. Almost built a much larger, more complex design. Categorizers make more sense to me. I like the idea to be able to sort whatever I want without taking up space in the storage except for what I actually have. You can always organize the chest as items fill it up to make it look nice.

[@Foefii]

i have seen many weird redstone mechanics/creations in minecraft over the course of its existence but i have to say this is by far the coolest i ever stumbled across

[@felixbeaulieu852]

Wait, I just realized this was the 999th video on the channel, I think? Anyway, next one is 1000th, that's pretty impressive, good job SW! Thank you for your tutorials and sense of humor, always fun to watch

[@silentwisperer]

omg i almost forgot :0

[@brandonciesielski8952]

I was having errors with my wood item category, where I had 1 of each wood item per tree (not including saplings or leafs) and the repeater wouldn’t switch off. My solution was to use 2 non stackable items and 62 renamed items in the bottom right spot.

[@indycrafter678]

Hey silent! Great system. I'm Implementing it on my multiplayer server. I've been testing it with the 16 item stackables. I don't think it works with those at all because the double chest at the beginning will take all 16 and then there won't be any room left to drop the item from the filter chest into the minecart. Once the minecart reaches the top, it sends the items in the minecart directly to the overflow chest. Not sure if you addressed this in another comment, if not, much help would be appreciated. As for now, I'm just going to send them via the overflow chest to a section of unsorted items with 16 stackables and unstackables. TIA!

[@emmekappa00]

I’m having the same issue :/

[@cptCrax]

Hey silent, just wanted to say I really like and appreciate your recent convention of showing the build area laid out with three axes of alternating wool blocks!

[@SuperLlama88888]

WOW!!! I have seen categorisers before but this one takes the cake! It's so small yet works perfectly! Well done!

[@that70sgamer]

Thanks again for this video Silent! I'm currently making this in my world. Minecraft version 1.20.15 Two things noteworthy. - Target blocks needed only when stacks are touching side to side. - For single stacks, the lower comparator needs to go into 2 blocks with redstone on both. Not sure why yet. The repeater was staying on all the time. (That's also with or without the target block) After I'm done I'll post a video about my experience. I didn't exactly understand how it worked until I started building it.

[@yasufumithebest]

bro, can you make an video for your build?

[@that70sgamer]

​@@yasufumithebestYes, I want to post a video of my experience. This system is kinda strange. Doesn't work 100% but saved a bunch of time sorting stuff. This weekend is Canada's thanksgiving weekend. I'll finish video next week.

[@yasufumithebest]

I appreciate it, really looking forward for your new video.

[@Austin-rn2py]

Great categorizer only one problem “DO NOT LOG OUT IF IN USE. IT WILL LEAD TO A LOOT OF PAIN”

[@Sanyrhs]

I've been waiting for these kind of storage sorting system for bedrock edition for a long time. Thanks a lot @silentwisperer. I hope it won't lag my phone😅

[@silentwisperer]

it shouldn't cause any lag :D its really just a minecart!

[@redfire826]

This is the best item categorizer I have ever seen for bedrock edition! All the other ones I have found have always needed to have full chests of items which I never liked...

[@ItsAlreadyRendered]

I was having trouble with not all of the items being sorted and it was specifically slices that had more than 1 item that can only stack in groups of 16, like signs or eggs. The solution I did was I continued to take out 3 of the filler items in that slice per 16 stack item. So let's say I had a slice with all of the mangrove items which would include signs and hanging signs. I would take 3 named filler items from the last stack then 3 additional filler items. The space left in the chest did not seem to cause any issues and I have a 24 slice wide categorizer.

[@Idk71568]

about this thing. I have found some critical issues. sometimes the powered rail next to the observer turns off dispute being hooked up to other powered rails that are powered. And sometimes the block does not go back into the chest and leaves it open leading to many problems. Please help silent

[@creedworks2797]

Make sure your place holder item in your minecart and chests are different

[@AnonymousNocturne]

Same for me please help someone

[@irishhoney22]

My hopper cart won't take off.

[@daevski]

@@irishhoney22I had this issue and I found that the repeater next to my minecart was backwards. Look for anything like that which might be wrong compared to the video. Best of luck!

[@irishhoney22]

@@daevski I had left a block under the observer to the left of the loader. This prevented it from being pushed by the piston. HOWEVER, the whole thing kept failing to sort properly. I tore it down. 🥺

[@NateThurlow]

Oh thank god this is what I've been looking for. Nornal sorting systems are massive

[@Kyle-pz1yj]

Hey to everyone who still have issues with the minecart picking up 64 items, i got it to work by leaving the repeater at 9:13 with 2 ticks and changing the repeater at 9:38 to a 2 tick instead of 3. Hope that helps!

[@mahir_m01]

Hey, thanks for this. It now takes in 62 items instead of 64. :)

[@DaBeeasssst]

Thank you!! It wouldn't organize it correctly if I had more than one item in my chest. This fixed it!

[@cronix6028]

This worked for me 9/14/2024

[@Bob-xz4gg]

Slinet is soo good that he released something I didn't know existed.

[@Liamself]

slinet😭💀

[@adean5707]

Can't tell what's worse, the Slinet, or the fact that bro didn't know about item categorizers

[@irishhoney22]

Can you do a troubleshooting episode on this build? It keeps pulling items from the categorizer chest.

[@javahart007]

Same issue

[@milanvujcich]

Does it eventually go back? I think it’s meant to do that as said near the start of the video

[@Ekipsogel]

literally just looked this up, good timing.

[@tarond57]

We need a fixed version of this please !!

[@jefferybeams145]

My friend and I are about to start a new Bedrock world, so I'm really looking forward to trying this for my storage system! Thanks for yet another awesome tutorial!

[@JoyfulEngineer2024]

I like to think I have a clue with redstone. That being said, the locking repeater stays on after putting the first item in the categorizer chest. (1 item gives a signal strength of 1, which powers the repeater)

[@JoyfulEngineer2024]

So… I’m leaving my comment here in the hope that it helps someone. While *if* you test this arrangement with one slice wide, the repeater will be activated with only one item, as soon as you add a second slice, the side-by-side redstone dust on the back no longer points to or powers the block leading to the repeater. Thus, the dust on top of that block is required to power it & thus the signal strength required is 2 vs. 1. I withdraw my critique/question.

[@joshuaplatt1967]

Thank you soooooo much for doing this!!! I had the same issue.. you Safed me!!

[@ChrisBreederveld]

Thank you! I've been literally searching for this for weeks, trying to implement Java systems and eventually cobbeleing together my own solution. But this is more elegant and cheaper, so thank you for this design!

[@Kiwizs177]

The only downside to this system is that it doesn’t incorporate a Minecart breaker to unload items faster. While there are bedrock design that have this feature there not really versatile in the way you arrange it. Overall if speed isn’t a concern then this design is great. It’s more mid game casual playing. Overall great design.

[@silentwisperer]

the next categorizer i show will have advanced minecart useage 💪💪💪

[@nousername8818]

​@@silentwisperer Do you know when the next categorizer system is coming?

[@skycraft9278]

Just a quick note. This system will NOT sort 16 stackable items. It also will NOT sort unstackable items. I’ve tested this in v1.21.31 bedrock and here’s what happened. So you set up your chests with whatever you want sorted, 3 shovels, 5 items renamed. Hopper cart has 45 items renamed. You got a bunch of 64 stack items in the categorizer chest and maybe an ender pearl in there like he showed in the video. Doesn’t matter if it has 2 or 5 items in the bottom right it will NOT work with it because the hopper cart takes a full stack of pearls and there’s no room for it to pull the one from the categorizer chest. Thats why it wont work with it. Now there is a work around. Well 2 really. First option is only put at most 15 of the 16 stack items in the drop off at a time and it will work with them now. But if you don’t want it to be a pain to have to manually load it then you should build a filter to remove the 16 stack items before it gets to this part of your build. Also wouldn’t hurt to build a non stackable item filter before items end up in this or you’ll have items going into the overflow. Depends on how sophisticated you want your sorting to be lol. But silent has tutorials for both on his channel. I’ve tested them as well with no issues on bedrock edition. Now to address the issues with the cart pulling all 64 items. This happens because of a timing issue usually on heavier played worlds/realms. So when your watching tutorials always keep in the back of your mind that it happens so you might need to play with the delays of repeaters to get things working as they should. What should happen is the cart should leave just as it gets the 63rd item. If it’s taking 64 it stayed there longer than it should’ve. So the delay from the repeater behind the chest beside the comparator on 2 ticks of delay might need 1 tick instead of 2 or just a piece of redstone if it is still picking up 64. Another issue that I have seen a lot of is the repeater doesn’t turn off to filter items. This happens when you do not have a correct signal strength in the chest. Usually caused by multiple items in the slots your trying to sort or an incorrect signal strength with the named items in the chest or not enough shovels in there. The correct amount is 5 named items and 3 shovels in the bottom right corner. If you have 2 as mentioned for the 16 stackable items you’ll end up having multiple items somewhere in there eventually thus breaking the machine. I hope some of any of this helps some of you. Also Silent your a beast man. Keep up the cool builds 👍

[@laezartom726]

Silent is back with the tutorials !

[@Wishkeirs]

This is something i actually really needed because my Little brother is too lazy to sort his own inventory and this will save me lmao

[@silentwisperer]

fair 😂

[@yeahboied]

Ngl I need a new storage system. My old one gettin real unreliable 😂, tysm silent

[@Herbu21]

Last time I did a item sorter (one of your tutorials, one of the biggest I think from like 2y ago) it made my world become "LaggyLand" like everytime I went to my storage room (had the great idea to make it right under my main base/village, under a secret redstone stair that appear from the ground) everything was soooo laggy lol. My PC wasn't powerful enough and I stopped playing on that world, like it took 30s open one chest, and created a lot of lag and input lag.

[@secretsuperspy13]

Yooo! Thanks for the sorter I needed this for mc world!

[@BwsBlizzard]

Thank you I been waiting so long for this. Thank you

[@The_King_Smitty]

this is going to work perfect!!!! i needed this so bad, now i can categorize and then filter everything! so much less complicated with this!

[@minatashiranui2755]

Thank you so much ! I have been wishing for something like that for 2 years now but my redstone skill isn't really the best 😍 I'm so happy I will be able to make a multi sorting system without fulling all the chest like usual 😍 my eyes and brain will be so please ! (I may have to rewatch the video multiple time tough to understand how this all work 😅)

[@MaxGuides]

Damn, I did something similar but built a stack separator at the front & immediately sent the single item off to get the category it belonged to so that by the time I had the rest of the stack or the hopper stopped pushing it could be sent off to the relevant themed room. Took a signal off of the category to flip rail lines so the cart would be sent off to be emptied & another would start filling before it was back. …people really don’t use rails enough in this game…seems more alive than just having hopper lines running all over your storage room for each category. All rail line junctions are simply set off of two comparator gates that it gets from the encoded output of the sorting system. Which is just sending two timed pulses down a single line to get converted to signal strengths. So just one rail line & a redstone line is all that’s needed to expand.

[@Deadlykharma12]

Nice! I’m probably not gonna replace my whole system with this but I may add it into the line. My current system is the single item sorter style with space for 3 double chests of almost 250 items but I could probably add this in someplace to sort my valuables into a separate vault instead of throwing everything into the public storage

[@seanalexander4238]

This design will stack in the hoppers behind the chests before it fills into the chest above. My categorizer has the same system so this one will have the same issue.

[@dynamicesk8771]

did you manage to solve this? Im having the same issue with mine and havent been able to figure out how to solve it yet

[@seanalexander4238]

@@dynamicesk8771 best I got is add another row of hoppers before you bring them down and place levers on the backs of the hoppers so you can manually lock them when the chests fill up. A copper flopper will probably work in that small space but I haven't had a chance to test it yet

[@nerussor]

Hey Silent! Thank you so much for doing the item categorizer, I've really been waiting for this one! For the materials list, please could you change it to 4 glass instead of 2 and activator rails to detector rails?

[@silentwisperer]

updated:)

[@michaeleyler2788]

To anyone that has built this, is there room to alter the overflow chest so that it maybe goes into a separate hopper line off into like a dropper system? I would like to combine this with a regular item sorter for mass quantity items like sand while trying to keep a single item drop off location

[@DarkReality911]

Yes, spin overflow 90 degrees and take hoppers off to the left.

[@samadkins6727]

But I would put the bulk before this as you'd have all those items flowing through for nothing 63 at a time

[@marctrainor7681]

This is the first category sorter that worked for me thanks !!!!!

[@Staestc]

This is just brilliant! Thanks very much for publishing this. And your video builds are the most thorough and most clearly presented of any that are out there. Just very well done!

[@silentwisperer]

glad its working for you:)

[@TroyLaurin]

Finally got around to building this and it works great! Managed to break and fix it a few times so I must say I appreciate the straight-forward design. It also definitely works with multiple 16-stackable items in the filter chest, you just need to replace one of the non-stackable filter items with a stack of the stackable named filter items, then reduce the size of the stack until the repeater turns off when one item is removed from the chest. Just one question - when the bottom chest in the slice fills up, the hopper behind it fills up before adding items into the next chest in the slice, meaning that a lot of items are potentially hidden in storage. It's moderately easy to fix, if the chest is full then removing items will cause the hopper to push its contents into the chest, then you can manually put the extras into the next chest up. But is there a way to do this automatically?

[@davidwestwood1459]

How did you handle 16 stackables in the input chest? My issue is I put 16 signs in, and the hopper minecart will pick up all 16 (since it's less than the time limit for 63) Then it won't pull the sign out of the filter chest, and all 16 stackables go straight to the overflow chest

[@TroyLaurin]

@@davidwestwood1459 yeah, the 16 stackables are annoying. The only real way to handle them is to never put a full stack in the input chest :/

[@that70sgamer]

Finally setting up a storage room. This will be awesome. Thanx Planning to use a combination of this and filters.

[@jeffersonbrito9016]

Descubri esse canal a pouco tempo mas estou simplesmente abismado com a qualidade do conteúdo, você é demais cara

[@mecamjc04619420]

if you change the repeater coming out of the comparator facing the input chest to 3 ticks it will sort 1 item no problem

[@overdynamic164]

Another certified soilent classic

[@leafblazor]

Attempting to combine this with the indicator silos. Should make a pretty badass storage 😁

[@Stk-m3rcenxry47]

Could u perhaps make a video on the calibrated skulk sensors and how to use them ? Much appreciated and keep up the content 👍

[@jameshudson2659]

Okay I’m so frustrated I’ve been in these comments for an hour, watched the video dozens of times. No matter how many items are in the sorter chest, it takes them and the stack and puts it in the overflow chest. No matter how many items I remove from the chest, the repeater never turns off. I have no duplicates, all stackable items, timers are right….

[@Tindecasterodeordenezafransisc]

It happend my to over and over again

[@cabbage64]

Finally, a categoriser i can build...another super silent build. You sir, are a legend.

[@silentwisperer]

always happy to help :D

[@B463L]

I set up three multi-item sorters and I'm just not willing to do the work to maintain their sorting capabilities. This is a perfect solution!

[@tecace5762]

This is the perfect balance of cheep with resources but good quality! I feel like you always have to go with a huge crazy storage system or a cheap, not very versatile one. But not any more!

[@donttrustabroom]

You are doing amazing work Silent

[@silentwisperer]

Thank you so much 😀

[@azooztheblade7948]

I just built your older version yesterday this one looks soo much better

[@ShinyMooTank]

Great video but I wished you showed us how to lower the timing for the right repeater, so the Minecart doesn't grab a full stack because of realm/server lag.

[@davidkingsman2533]

Wow actually was just watching the other ones on the channel. Worked out lel.

[@oceandawgz]

Really cool, can't wait to build this.....As usual, great video and excellent explanation - thank you silent!

[@Germsrosolino]

Bit of a necro, but for those having issues with this build, I have a couple tips that helped me fix it. 1. MAKE SURE the filler items used in the Minecart with Hopper are NOT THE SAME as the fillers used in the category boxes. You can just use different names if you like, but make sure not to mix them up. The minecart will fill that stack of 45 with random fillers from your category boxes and break it 2. I know he mentioned balancing it for 16-stack items. But until you have a working system, DONT MESS WITH THIS. Do NOT use 16-stack items, nor single stack items. Literally only use items that stack to 64. No armor, weapons, eggs, buckets, ender pearls, honey bottles, signs, hanging signs, or any others I missed. Also saddles, horse armor, etc (things that don't stack at all). Important Note: He briefly mentions it in the video, but it's pretty much the most important part of the whole build. If you remove an item from your category box, that slices' repeater should turn off. If that isn't happening, then you have at least 1 item in that box that stacks to 16 or is single stack. If you check all this and your cart is still pulling things it shouldn't be, that means you have a duplicate item in two or more category boxes. Hope this helps. Once I addressed those things, It works like magic

[@jameshudson2659]

Yeah it still doesn’t work and I did all of that

[@mrzAR-365]

Anyone know why is it that when item going to the chest, instead of looking for a place in the top chest, it looks for a place in the bottom chest, and if there is no place, the items accumulate in the hooper?

[@TheHellis]

Up to the point when you started with the rails I was following, but then it just became a mess. I have no clue what all that redstone does. But great work!

[@raphael7882]

Hey, I tried building it but on 3 sides of a room, but it only works on the side where the minecart is deload. The 2 other side only filter 1 block and the rest go in the overflow chest. Is there any reason why it does not work?

[@LlenniLlenni]

Looked for a system like this for so long! I am having the same problem some others are. If you put in more than one stack of an item, the first one goes into the correct place, the second into overflow. I have 30 something slices. Seem to have solved it by slowing down the rail at the back enough that that all items have gone where they're meant to by the time the cart is back and unloading more. Obviously slows everything down, but at least it works!

[@YamIdoingThis]

I'm having the same issue, even with just 6 slices and it seems to only want to fill the bottom chest, but if there is even a single item of the same type, it goes right to overflow.

[@YamIdoingThis]

Found my problem, it was with the timing system, the hopper was grabbing a full stack of 64 items, so it didn't have room for the filter box item to be removed. Went over the whole build and found one repeater was off by 1 tick and that was all I needed, timing is super critical to this build. Works fantastic now.

[@Pern-pe6cy]

You do not understand how good the timing of this video is my god

[@silentwisperer]

😊💙💙

[@karlwithac95]

Wooo time to upgrade my storage system that I literally just finished building ❤👍🔥

[@7shingle]

This is sick! I love stuff like this, especially because I know it’s reliable as it’s made by silent!

[@budgie_]

Silent, please post your mangrove/cherry wood farm! If I have to manually plant/cut down another mangrove tree I might cry.

[@Ididthisforfunlolz]

Built this and it works great! Is there a way to hopper items into the input chest, or do you have to manually do it? Thanks! Great tutorial!

[@JasonA74]

I have the worst timing. I was looking at a different tutorial for an Item categorizer as an addition on our Realm's main storage system. It needed more space than I had available so I went with building 3 of your Multi-Item sorter systems, making a room of storage. This would have fit well and saved on materials..and saved my sanity a bit. Next storage system this is going in.

[@bettyrodriguez1150]

Isn’t working for me. Please help. Cart takes 64 items and doesn’t start. I already changed the ticks for first repeater to 1 after your suggestion to another commenter. Also if after placing less than 63 items in first position it sorts and comes back for second one it stops, even if next stack has 63 items or less. I’ve made other of your farms successfully.

[@BeastCoast8581]

i made this design and ive checked it over several times but i cant find any mistakes. but when i use the system, it occasionally doesnt put an item back into the catagorizer, and then it sends everything of that item into the overflow chest. i have no idea if its because its on a realm or whatever. it works great as a temporary solution to my storage, as i just need to go fix the filter every so often, as long as it isnt just self detonating. . i dont know whats wrong with it though. Edit: i looked into it more, turns out if the chunks happen to de-render is kinda busts the system, otherwise its been working fine.

[@Tarox_0]

So it wouldn't actually work if it's in multiple chunks?

[@marcofelix4388]

Not working in my realm

[@YamIdoingThis]

Triple check all your repeaters are at the right tick. The hopper should be grabbing 63 of a single item when it collects it, if it's grabbing a full stack, it has nowhere to put the filter item to activate the correct hopper and will send it all to the overflow instead. If that doesn't work, try to play around with the timing, maybe have it send the cart a bit sooner at the cost of sorting speed, maybe it'll grab most of a stack and come back to grab the rest. Also make sure you don't accidentally have something in any boxes that can only stack to 16.

[@gwmanas9046]

Every thing is going in overflow chest any solution 😢

[@pomps9056]

Same here, were you able to fix it?

[@duende_7075]

Only half of my items go Into overflow. While the other go where they need to go. Only got 2 chest set up with items while I was working on the third I noticed everything went into overflow chest instead of the correct hoppers

[@mr.ismail50]

Are you playing with aternos or anything like that

[@DeviateSquirrel]

Need to get the minecart hopper to never take a full 64 - something to do with repeater changes

[@johnpfeilsticker5870]

Been working on this. I logged out once while it was running, and ever since this thing picks up full stacks. I adjusted the 2-tick repeater at 9:12 down to 1-tick, and now the cart doesn't pick up full stacks on its first run, but still does on the second. Seems like the redstone in the "brain" here needs some tweaks. What's interesting to me is that my sorter only started doing this after I logged out while sorting. Now it'll happily sort any load less than a full stack, and it'll sort the first full stack in a fresh dump, but the second always gets sent to overflow. If you or anyone has found a better way to wire this thing, I'm hoping to not have to tear it all down. I like the design and I'm starting to understand the details of how it works, but the timing circuit is just not quite right. There's gotta be a way...

[@coltondonahue3]

Love this sorter, but when i leave the area it takes a full stack of items and puts it in the over flow chest and doesn't get sorted from there. is there a fix for this or do i just need to stay in the area for the time being?

[@Harpskygem]

Read through some of the comments but didn't this issue brought up. If I dump a bunch of a single block in (like Netherack after I come back from the Nether), it will dump it will correctly sort the first stack, but then dump the rest in the overflow chest. Any way to fix that? Built it on Realms.

[@LlenniLlenni]

I have the same issue!

[@volvomodus]

Thank you, just thank you for making this

[@Crystalelements182]

I'm the type of player who wants to understand the purpose of each part before building it. Makes it easier to troubleshoot. How does the timing system work? What is its purpose and why does it need the pistons and observers? It just looks overcomplicated

[@jeremiepigeon]

Thank you! Did a 20 row of theese and it works perfectly, but there was a glitched redstone at the back so the items always went in the same chest i had to break it and check again hope this helps semone!

[@xzwarchildzx6957]

Just a tip if you name the 45 item in the chest to silentwiserer then you will always remember who built it incase it breaks

[@subhankabir100]

This is incredible thanks for making video on this can you a video on chunkloader on bedrock edition

[@tysonau6888]

which of your tutorials for storage systems do you recommend for your raid farm? the item filter, categorizer or sorter?

[@CMWF82]

Question, why does my items get filtered into the correct slice, but will always filter into the bottom most chest, or if the bottom most chest is filled, than the bottom most hopper?