Minecraft Bedrock: FAST Item Sorting Storage System Tutorial! Item Categorizer MCPE Xbox PS5 PC

[@silentwisperer]

8:22 you can use a regular rail there. just make sure its curved to the side into the water 👍 Thanks for watching! :D Drop a like n subscribe to help out the channel! This video has been in the works for a while! Huge thanks to Tgoodclay for sending in this design and helping improve it! If you've designed something you think I should make a tutorial on, you can submit it via our Discord:)

[@TgoodClay]

We gonna get the shulker unloader extension to it soon? 👀😜

[@kittyonmydesk5532]

Is this barrel compatible?

[@TgoodClay]

@@kittyonmydesk5532 The chests where you hold the items themselves, yes, but the memory slots must remain chests. Any storage unit (barrels, shulkers, chests) can be at the very end.

[@brightest07]

Could this style be used for a shulker sorter? As long as the shulker were filled with the same stackable item?

[@mozzie2729]

Just wanna say, that the stairs on the sticky pistons were still causing my carts to get stuck. I replaced the stairs with mud blocks and now it's working like a charm, I've been testing it extensively, and haven't had a cart get stuck again.

[@sebastianpellegrino3661]

Bro, you personally have made bedrock, and my Minecraft experience in general, literally the most memorable gaming experiences of my life. Thank you

[@LightningfoxxyMC]

I love your tutorials Silent. You always explain in detail about everything. Great tutorial as always, can’t wait to make this!

[@joeward1997]

Still my favourite item sorter :) . To anyone having issues change the powered rail that goes sideways at 8:20 ish to a corner normal rail and then have the water flowing towards it. Think the minecarts go too quick otherwise. Also the blocks he says to change to stairs next to the observers that push the minecart keep as normal blocks. Always been reliable since these changes and my go to item sorter. Hope this helps :) Also i chunk aligned it so all the chests are in one chunk and the redstone in the other.

[@MoistBrexit]

your amazing

[@joeward1997]

Glad it helped :)​@@MoistBrexit

[@williamprimozich2970]

I watch all your new tutorials even if I’m not planning on building them just to learn mechanics, idk what bedrock would do w.o you I love that I can always count on your farms to work.

[@marcusswingle8627]

Love how streamlined your tutorials are! I do wish you had a technical review explaining which things do what though. Maybe a separate video? Anyways, your tutorials are still miles above the rest. Great job!

[@Soumik_30]

That's what my world genuinely needed

[@adamlarussa5243]

My world genuinely needs a mangrove tree/cherry tree farm that silent promised like, 3 months ago. Lol

[@BetaDF3]

@@adamlarussa5243 were still waiting

[@MarMon24]

Same

[@brycewilson115]

PieIsTheBest!! This is amazing. I built your last one, the huge one with tons of redstone and iron needed to make it, but it’s starting to lag out my world. Definitely gonna give this one a try. Thank you so much for these hugely beneficial and amazing redstone builds! On BEDROCK even!! Much love.

[@TheFmac]

I noticed that the comparator in the slice for the storage system is missing from your item list in the description, otherwise everything is great! Love it. Thanks for yet another amazing guide silent

[@wisp37]

For anyone having problems where the minecart is getting sucked into the wall on the FIRST SLICE of the auto sorter, the easy fix is to have nothing in the chest. Do not use the first slice for any sorting or storage, and it seems to work fine. If it's already built, I wouldn't break anything. The reason why it's being pulled is because it's not fully in the water. So If your reading this before building it, add a 1 block space of water between the button and the first slice of the auto sorter. This should fix your minecart problem.

[@Zer010X]

Can you water log the stairs?

[@Zer010X]

No water logging the stairs didn't fix the problem. The minecarts will back up here. Going to try the other comment about replacing the stairs with a solid block first.

[@Zer010X]

Replacing the stairs fixed some of the issues, for some odd reason I am getting the shovels mixed in and I noticed some of my iron blocks made it into the dispensers in various places, any reason why that would happen?

[@RosalitaFGC]

This!!! Also in combination with a slime block instead of water/water source block under the button has been working fine so far

[@kylecoimbra6027]

@@RosalitaFGCthanks for telling us that! Helped a lot! Appreciate it

[@TheMrPWNGER]

I built it in creative mode and survival mode and it works great, I had an issue with mine carts getting stuck in the water but I replaced the stairs in the water with solid blocks and it is working well so far

[@saidelchuev5652]

@TheMrPWNGER do you have copy of world with this storage system? If yes can you please send it to me, I really need this

[@TheMrPWNGER]

@@saidelchuev5652 I do but I don't know how to send it. What issues are you having?

[@jamesarmitage5917]

If you're going to make more than 16 slices, where would you stick your chunk border? What about the chunk border tends to break the brain or first few slices?

[@Mr.Monkey16579]

After many fixes, I can indeed say this works 100 percent. The Problem: To have all of the chests working look down below to my edit. Anyways, if you want to have all the chests working then the main problem is going to be the first couple chests. These don’t work because the Mine-cart is too fast and goes more than halfway the first piston before it can push it. Because it is more than halfway but not all the way through, it stops it and in effect, causes all the other carts to get stuck. And that is the problem I noticed, at least in my situation. Edit: To everyone building this in the newest version, it works but with a few tweaks. The main problem with this is the speed of the Mine-cart hoppers. The part where the Mine-cart goes into the water is the problem. The block across the button can be replaced with a fence and the water under the button needs to be replaced with a slime block. Of course there is a chance that you may have built it wrong. And if silent responds to this with a fix, I thank him. Otherwise this is amazing, very fast sorting. Also, if you are confused I will make a post on my channel of the fix when I have time.

[@InfiAaron]

Hi! Thanks for testing all this stuff to find how to fix it, I'm looking to build this in my world relatively soon. Let me know when you upload a video with all the fixes, that would be insanely helpful. :)

[@guilhermemartins3810]

Hey, thank u so much, just saved me here, I tried to send your comment to silent, hope he sees

[@guilhermemartins3810]

@@InfiAaron If you want I can send you a video in instagram or email. just put it here and I explain.

[@BillyHargrove]

​@@guilhermemartins3810why does it keep going in the note block chest every couple minecarts 1 item gets beeped in the note block and ends up going to the chest with the minecarts

[@Mr.Monkey16579]

@@BillyHargrovemight be because you built something wrong, do you have the comparators in the slices?

[@MrJaimie]

Here are two issues I'm seeing. 3:30 1. The minecart goes to the correct category chest. It takes the item out, but when it passes overhead it doesn't return the item. 2. The filler item doesn't get taken out. It ends up in the storage chests.

[@unfitmedia964]

same exact issue here i can not for the life of me to get the item to be returned into the correct chest

[@SuperLlama88888]

Very cool mechanic using minecarts in bubble columns! Prefer something more stable though as this will probably break... but good to use while it lasts!

[@AndrewBrownK]

I cant wait to build this! I look forward to upgrading from the item sorter that requires all slots filled on the user facing side

[@DriestApollo]

Are you kidding me? I literally just searched for an item sorter not 3 hours ago! Thanks silent!

[@Daelomin666]

I have built many of your redstone contraptions, and they are all fantastic. This one gave me a run for my money, though, with jammed minecarts filler items seeping into slices. It took a bit to troubleshoot, but once i got it working, it is a top-notch system. Minecarts just suck. Keep it up Silent!

[@Forced_Darkness]

Can i ask what you did to get it working?

[@Daelomin666]

@seddy1120 so basically I just put fenceposts next to the rails leading to the back of the machine. I ended up having a recurring issue though which caused torches (yes specifically torches) to break the machine. They ALWAYS ended up in the filler item chests also I replaced the powered rails there with regular. Another odd fix I found when it would act funny on only one slice is to break and replace the block that pushes the minecart out of the water. Just replace it in the same location. I also use blocks there not stairs.

[@nannimancini3088]

@@Daelomin666man can you help me? im willing to invite you into my world. i’m going crazy

[@christianavila7879]

Yep. Starting this project up now. Some sorta storage system in my world is desperately needed. Also I've built quite a few of your builds now, all work great. You do an amazing job with your videos! ❤

[@BrendenTLewis]

Could you show a quick example of how to make it in different shapes, like that U-shape room you flashed to briefly at 0:25 ?

[@silentwisperer]

take a rail line from one end of the water stream into the start of the next:) also connect the hoppers from the unloaders to the first sections unloaders ofc and the rail line at the top

[@robertwelch1453]

@@silentwisperer rail line on water stream is just regular rails?

[@TgoodClay]

Hallelujah! Congrats on making a tutorial. ❤️ thanks for letting me help out!

[@captnzap9588]

Awesome concept!

[@ThePurplePassage]

Awesome work goodclay! One of the commenters here (mozzie2729) said minecarts kept getting stuck on the water bubble columns, and using stairs to push them didn't always give them enough of a push to get out. Or sometimes the minecarts glitch into the stairs. Have you encountered this issue and is there a fix for this issue? Maybe a different block instead of stairs?

[@TgoodClay]

Working on a new system that is lag resistant, and used a new method so carts don’t get stuck.

[@DoctorMkoyXacqwri.]

YES! FINALLY: A person who actually uses Redstone in Bedrock... I was looking for one for a long time and tried many experiments on making a sorting system... Thank you very much on the help!

[@mcexile5185]

11:52 I was having problems with stairs,but leaving them as solid block work,thankyou for this auto storage!

[@Tonyator]

I was having trouble with the minecarts randomly slowing down in the water, getting stuck and causing a pile up of carts in the water. In the end to fix it i had to; Use full blocks on the underwater pistons. Replace the water under the button with a slime block. Replace the glass opposite the button with a fence. I already had the turned regular rail before into the water. Now it works flawlessly, I also added detecor rails and note blocks on the track before going up and into the water and the output track before the cactus so i can hear its still outputting carts and they are returning and arent getting stuck. Thanks Silent!

[@zachariahorland5071]

Trying this right now, fingers crossed :)

[@jackchapman2373]

@@zachariahorland5071did it work?

[@sandroc.1738]

it did work for me, thank you! @@jackchapman2373

[@SanguineFire]

I have a rather major problem with this system. The carts don't go in the slice they're supposed to go to. Instead, they overshoot, going to the next one. I've tried to fix this problem by switching the rail order but it didn't seem to work. It'd be a great help if you could post a fix video for this. Edit:I found a great fix and it works perfectly! Credits to user-td8mm1sy3j in the comments who worked really hard to get the problen solved! 1. Of the three rails placed right before the minecart enters the water channel, switch the top one to a regular rail turning into the channel. 2. In the same place, change the powered rail on ground level right where it's elevating to a regular rail. 3.Break the glass block opposite the button placed to hold the water in and swap it with a fence post 4. Finally, replace the water under the button with blue ice. This solution worked perfectly, slowing down the minecarts yet keeping the timing right.

[@Bluhcops]

100% fixed it. Thank you two for your help. Edit: Enderman broke it by standing in the way. RIP

[@rednecktwins1862]

None of these fixes are doing anything tried them all and nothing seems to work

[@Bluhcops]

@@rednecktwins1862 did you also make the stairs in the water mud blocks?

[@Bluhcops]

@@rednecktwins1862 powered rail at bottom with lever and regular rail as first elevated rail. So it goes, powered rail, regular rail, powered rail, then regular rail to the turned one.

[@xpacerx]

@silentwisperer @TgoodClay There is an issue with the hopper minecart when it grabs the category item but floats a little past the piston pusher so it never get pushed to the track properly and gets stuck. I have a video showing the issue if you're interested. A few people are having issues with this and were not sure how to fix it.

[@klay53]

I'm also having this problem

[@xpacerx]

Apparently the issue only happens every other slice. if you test your system I would bet every other slice works fine all the way down.

[@christianavila7879]

am also having this problem.

[@xpacerx]

@christianavila7879 put a slime block underneath where to button is.

[@therealofficialcaz1900]

Looks cool! I love that you can just throw stuff in and fast sorting!

[@LaceworkDreams]

Wow! This is great! I cant wait to build this in my survival base. My goal for the end game is to be able to sort every single survival-obtainable item in the game.

[@jonathanpeters4240]

So Silent finally started making categorizers, awesome!

[@silentwisperer]

this one and a simpler one a few weeks ago:)

[@jonathanpeters4240]

@@silentwisperer I like the simpler one, the concept isn't new to me. haha I think it's been a few years since I've started watching your videos, and you really have a knack for making complex systems concise and compact

[@GreyLightning]

would it be possible to do something similar using block push mechanics with chests to improve reliability over minecarts? and how much would it hurt efficiency?

[@maryjanecompton8458]

I love all your tutorials @silentwisperer but this one has so many issues for me. The minecarts get stuck at the bottom rail(right next to the bubble colomn, they get stuck at the top (last colomn on the stairs) and they get stuck on the top ramp (right after the glass line for the levers. Ive tried replacing the stairs with mud blocks which works a little better but when I try to test it by putting multiple items in it breaks.

[@ColoMinn]

Very cool. Strongly considering upgrading the storage system in the world my kids and I share. Please, though... don't forget about the cherry wood/mangrove farm you teased a while back. Still waiting on that one. I would like to think I'm good enough to create my own, but I'm just not there yet.

[@Irondrakeshield]

Cherry farm isn't possible

[@Irondrakeshield]

Yet

[@MatthewBurn-n2d]

My minecarts are returning the item from the category chest to to next slice along. All items are making their way gradually towards the final slice. Any ideas? The carts are moving through the system fine - it's a thing of beauty.

[@onixonix3942]

I have the same problem

[@27patq]

I switched the powered rail that launches them in the water to a regular rail curbing at a 90 degree angle (hope that makes sense). It slows the cars down and keeps them in their respective slot.

[@k-shin3920]

​@@27patqthanks man, my carts either got stuck or went to the next slice, switching the rail fixed it

[@mayorjames]

Edited 12/2023: I made another attempt, and was more discerning while troubleshooting simply trying one comment suggestion at a time. Realized that while working on the water entry I had washed away some redstone making the carts stuck at the input chest. Ultimately got it working without needing to slow carts down, and it is humming along!

[@Jeranh]

After some issues, i finally got this working perfectly. Thank you so much!

[@silentwisperer]

glad you got it working 😊💙

[@christianavila7879]

what issues were you having?

[@bencalver3370]

Looks like I'm making my 4th storage room in my world now

[@silentwisperer]

this is the way 😂

[@bencalver3370]

​@@silentwispererfinally made it in a new world, for my massive underground base I'm working on, to find it's not functioning as it should 😔

[@koen804]

@@bencalver3370 Do you have another sorter that does work flawlessly? cause I'm looking for some good options.

[@MrOut4astroll]

I have a sorting system that this would be perfect for. The only drawback is I would have to figure out how to on the opposite side. I can take out my overflow and feed this directly in but it would need to go from right to left instead of left to right. How would I go about changing that

[@toxemic2345]

I was wondering if you could create a new block breaker for tree farms as your old one is broken maybe something similar to slaclizards concrete covertor pls

[@diegomelgar5866]

😅 i love this channel he made me see that bedrock doesn't need a ton of mods to be awesome also his pillager farm made my life so much easier with villagers 😅

[@Chimchar_03]

my pistons are firing late so the mincarts cycle thru all the chests. how do i fix it. (Edit someone in the comments said to put a slime block under the button it works🎉. only took a year but now i can use it thank you.) PS after some testing seems the slime block or water is directionale

[@silentwisperer]

make sure all the water and bubbles are installed correctly. shouldn't be possible for them to fire late 🤔

[@y2to807]

Same problem

[@caliberrubix7463]

Same problem here too

[@DisambiguatedClarity]

same!!@@silentwisperer

[@mukpocxema]

Same

[@TheBedrockMaster]

Hey, it seems to be messing up a lot recently, has there been any changes or patches? If so could you make an update or a community post on how to fix?

[@viniciuscperoni]

Could you make a video showing how to make an extensive piston? Double, triple, quadruple, quintuple and so on. And also a potion creator with just one click makes the potion directly. And free downloads of these maps and projects

[@idroppedmyphoneee]

I have a problem with minecarts getting stuck in the brain and stone shovels placed inside of the storage system when it shouldn't. How can I fix this?

[@LanceMiller87]

After many hours of pulling my hair out, trying to get this to work reliability, and trying all of the suggestions in the comments, I think I may have found something that works. Long term testing still needed, and some of these changes may not actually be contributing to success, but it appears promising: • add an extra block of space between brain and first slice • use 2 regular rails instead of 1 powered rail • replace water under button with slime block • replace block across from button with another button • water-log pistons before adding stairs Again, I have no idea what combination of these things are actually making a difference, or if it will work long enough to empty out an entire double chest of items, but it seems to at least be more consistent...

[@TheSilentPr0tag0nist]

Can you update on your success by now?

[@LanceMiller87]

@@TheSilentPr0tag0nist it was a lot better, but still not perfect. Using waterlogged mangrove roots instead of stairs made the biggest difference, I think. It ran for a very long time, but eventually did back up again.

[@SWEEN154]

I've found using trap doors flipped up is best @@LanceMiller87

[@Hashy68]

Pls update to 1.21. Cause there are lots of tuings wrong. It only automaticcaly sends the first minecart and I have to push the rest to get them going. They get stuck in the bubbles on in water on rails on the first 4. It puts everytuing in the last chest. When the minecarts are supposed to go to the very top they get stuck. If they make it to the top they just fall on the glass and stay there. Its really great but REALLY needs an update. Ur vids are awesome bye.

[@thelegendarybarlowe0727]

I just built this and I had a few issues and reading the comments I noticed some people had the same. Here are issues and my fixes. The mine carts entered the water to fast and was past the sticky piston when it fired. This caused the item to taken from the category chest, and the minecart being sent up the wrong line, or to stop in water and create a mine cart backup. To fix this I slowed down the minecarts by swapping out the powered rail just before the water with a curved regular rail. And adding 2 slime blocks. One under the glass block with the button, hoping the cart rubs it on the way up, and one at the top of the turn. This fixed the issue but somehow slowing the carts caused the timing to be off as they unload and get pushed toward the powered cart return line. So some carts would go left some would go right and they would bump sometimes with no issue but sometimes getting stuck. To solve this I just made the return line longer and curved back on it self. This fixed everything and now it’s working beautifully. Hopefully I explained everything well enough. But if anybody is confused and interested I’d be willing to post pictures of my fixes on Reddit.

[@Forced_Darkness]

I'd be interested in a picture. Thanks!

[@RosalitaFGC]

I’ve been hesitant to build this because of all the issues but this gave me some reassurance. Did you end up posting some pics?

[@makgor3794]

Can you please make a more reliable design even if it's similar to the easy version cuz I tried both built multiple times in creative and they don't work

[@NightQuestSample]

I know what I'm making next in my world. Thanks for the video!

[@ghale91281]

I have been waiting to build a sorter in my world cause I couldn’t find one to do what I really wanted! This was it and my world will finally have an item sorted soon!! Thanks for the build!!

[@anujchintamani]

Aah... An OP redstone Tutorial after months.❤

[@mozzie2729]

Cool design! The biggest problem I'm having with it is that the carts keep getting stuck in the water section. Sometimes they'll make it up and sometimes they won't; I then need to go into the water in order to nudge them along. I am within a chunk border but I'm not sure why my carts keep getting stuck. Edit: Some carts are still glitching into the stairs when the piston pushes them and sometimes it won't push them far enough on the tracks so if I nudge them to get them going, they'll float to another track. Any other recommendations for blocks to use? EDIT: Hot diggity dog! I got it working using mud blocks instead of stairs, works like a charm now!

[@ThePurplePassage]

That's sad. The designer, tgoodclay is here in this comments thread - I've tried asking him. Maybe you could find his comment and add to the issues. If there are more glitches with this design then I'd like to know the fixes before eventually building it

[@yasufumithebest]

Same, 90% of time stuck.. wasted time doing this and end up not work well.

[@mozzie2729]

@@ThePurplePassage I got it working finally using mud blocks instead of the stairs! I've been testing it for the last hour and so far no more getting stuck.

[@mozzie2729]

@@yasufumithebest Finally got it working using mud blocks instead of stairs. I've been testing it and so far it's been working without an issue.

[@yasufumithebest]

@@mozzie2729 oh, really nice.. I will try change it. Appreciated.. luckily I didn’t tear it down yet.

[@insqane9889]

I had issues if them not going on the track and also having too much momentum and missing the first segment. The way I've fixed these is replacing the stairs in the water with observers and leaving the first section empty

[@twistedcables2675]

Anyone else having an issue where the minecrart completely skips the first chest? Its going straight to the end with the overflow. Not even removing the category item

[@naughtaegames234]

It’s going too fast so you should replace red stone rail with regular rail

[@RhynoJoe]

I just finished hollowing out a cavern for an item sorter, excited to give this a try 🤞

[@xGRASHOPAx]

March 1st 2024 Built this in Creative tonight and it works Perfect north-south facing. SILENT Can you show us how you bent your line to east-west facing, like I have a square room with 15 slices one the south wall and then I want it to continue on the west wall. 0:24 do you have a rail way to the next slice can you do a short or something to show me what's behind your walls. When I need to bend mine I put a button on the block right after the soul sand and make the cart drop on to a powered rail that will push it about 5-7 blocks and then turn right and go about 4-5 blocks then I raised the block up so that the cart would go up and then drop onto a powered rail that will shoot it into the bubble column just like the first slice has. It seems to work! But I will take any advice as well @Silent

[@VoresKanal]

I also need help to Bent it

[@koen804]

I just did the exact same thing as you and the carts system works, but for some reason the filter for the shovels doesn't work on the side after the turn so the shovels also get mixed up in my chests 🥲

[@aidenbryant2441]

I’ve built this in 1.21, wasn’t working for a while b/c my my hoppercarts would get stuck on the underwater powered rails, if anyone else has this issue just switch the staircases that push the hoppercarts back to a solid block and it should work fine

[@user-td8mm1sy3j]

FOR THOSE WHO IS EXPERIENCING ISSUES WITH THIS BUILD: I had an issue where all the carts were going too fast under water and all categories was getting shifted, as someone mentioned in the comments partial fix may be replacing top powered rail that launches cart into the water with regular cornered rail, but some carts will still go too fast. rearranging powered rails in the cart loader system can make carts go slower, but after that another issue will appear, it’s when cart go too slow, so the first layer will “eat” all carts and piston will just pull it into blocks, even placing stairs instead of blocks didn’t help. I figured out that it was caused by cart not being able to be pushed because of block of glass on its way. So, the complete solution that works like a charm: 1.) replace top powered rail with regular one cornered into water 2.) replace first powered rail on carts way up with a regular one 3.) replace glass block (which button that holds water placed on) with fence block and place button on block in front of fence 4.) and finally replace water under the button with blue ice block Really hope that will help, because I spent couple hours fixing all that

[@anandadarsh4354]

Great help thanks a lot man ❤

[@anandadarsh4354]

It works 100% perfect

[@corymbush]

Questions for clarification 2)are you referring to the slanted up rails in the water or the first one on the upper level rails? 3)fence post or fence gate?

[@corymbush]

I did all the suggestions and that 100% fixed my waterway issues including the first slice. Now I’m having a problem where the carts aren’t draining items fast enough before being pushed to the cat us and alarm keeps getting triggered

[@user-td8mm1sy3j]

@@corymbush 2.) none of, I meant the rail part that leads cart from input chest into water, here you have 1 powered rail on top and 2 pieces of powered rails below, you should replace top one with regular one cornered into water and the bottom one with regular piece of rail. Again, you should have something like this (from top to bottom): piece of rail cornered into water, powered rail, regular rail, everything else leave unchanged. 3.) fence post

[@aaronMinceRaft]

Is there a way to connect this to another set of slices without recreating the brain? I want each set to be a few blocks away from each other.

[@mikeb1902]

Hi i have just built this on a massive scale (140 slices) and was wondering what i need to connect when going around corners(my storage is U shaped) and also if anyobe knows how many minecarts and shovels i would need. Thanks

[@ScottReid-b7e]

This is the best system I’ve come across. It’s taken a bit of tinkering and yes, I had missed comparitors from the unloading hoppers on 2 rows but we’ve now got a huge 28x28 square with storage on all sides. I’ve linked the sides using corners, extending out the bubble elevator channels until they meet, then using a powered rail and a one space non bubble water block to slow the minecarts. System appears to be performing flawlessly, and is going to be the central storage area for our next megabase on bedrock. Changes we’ve implemented: Changed the stairs pushing minecarts out the water channel to smooth stone Removed the glass block opposite button on entry to water channel, replaced with button to stop minecarts catching on the edge We have also added named blocks into each empty filter slot to prevent any potential glitch items picked up from getting sorted incorrectly as a further fail safe.

[@nicokrieger957]

Hey, i have problems to bring the minecarts around the corner. So you build the bubble elevator channel up to the point where the bubble elevator of the next side is? And how do you bring the minecart around the corner? Just a single powered rail at the end of the first bubble elevator facing in the direction of the next bubble elevator channel? In this case the powered rail has to be under water, or? And after that just a normal water collum and then starting the bubble elevator again? I hope you can help me, in all my attempts the last days i got problems with the timing after the corner... :(

[@ScottReid-b7e]

Yes, the powered rail has to be under a source block, I’ve elevated mine so the bubble elevator path remains 2 high like the slices, covered by solid blocks in line with the chests, then on the corner where the change of direction is required a powered rail pointing in the new direction, with a solid block behind it (not glass) and a lever on the block underneath to power. Then the next block round the corner will be a water source block on the lower of the 2 high channel and an air gap with a button on the top level so the cart splashes into the water source prior to hitting the next bubble elevator channel. This is similar to how the carts initially enter the system from the brain side.

[@Arrowounds]

could you perhaps send a vid of your design? im curious how it came along

[@CineZoneYT]

@@ScottReid-b7e Do you have discord? I would like a picture of how you have the corner set up 😃

[@koen804]

Hey I've also made this system in a U shape and made the corners working but now the filter on the second and third side of chests let's the shovels trough. Also if you look at the back of the build you got a row of redstone torches that should be turned off, but this is only the case at the first side/row of chests and once I take a turn the row of torches isn't turned off anymore. Would it be possible to see how you've build it?

[@jeffbrander2690]

Just built this on realm and just doesn’t sort correctly at all, minecarts either get stuck in water path or get pushed down to over flow

[@hiss.98]

I have a problem with the timer the minecart drops the shovels to the hoppers and 2 items , I cant make it drop just the shovels, I had the problem just when I did it east /west.

[@imc1t6]

I’m having issues with items getting pulled out of the chest but then being moved over to the next one messing up the organisation, so the minecraft will pull the correct item out of the index chest but then go to the next rial over moving the item to the next chest not the same as the index chest rial line.

[@Robert-ug4ub]

The only improvement would be a shulker box unloader e.g put shulker boxes into a double chest and it sorts the items within them. But other than that it's great

[@deannewatson1939]

I'm having an issue where the cart in the water stream sets off the piston but doesn't make it on to the rail and just gets stuck in the water. Tried replacing the stairs with mud and still having an issue. Any ideas why or how to fix it?

[@christianavila7879]

me too. searching for solutions now.

[@anandadarsh4354]

Same hear

[@christianavila7879]

So I may have a solution. Try switching the powered rail line to a regular rail line curving into your water bubbler. This method worked for me when I tried it with mud blocks instead of the stairs.

[@kyletang1524]

8:26 I cant get the powered rails in the same orientation because the top rail always connects back to the slanted one.

[@no.longer.aproxioi]

Okay, what am i putting in these chests? How do i make it just do one item per row, or 2 items per row, what’s the difference in how much the chest is filled??????? 17:43

[@silentwisperer]

those are your filter chests. whatever item(s) you put in there is what will end up in that slice of your system. I explain this near the beginning. i explain filter chests in more detail in this video kzbin.info/www/bejne/nGjOlp2NipmFm8U

[@no.longer.aproxioi]

@@silentwisperer I just built that one instead, thanks

[@ShadowLogic3253]

can we all agree, silent does an amazing job selling his creations.

[@dillonbrown2507]

Word of advice, I tried multiple methods with dealing with stuck carts under the first slice. The only thing that has worked reliably is removing the stairs under the observers and replacing them with solid blocks. In other words completely disregard the advice he gives at 11:52 . KEEP THE SOLID BLOCKS THERE!

[@emberspirit1696]

I built the first version for all the items and it works perfect, thank you so much

[@Mysticblaze132]

I’m having issues with the minecarts not being pushed onto rails out of the water bubble columns quick enough, they pick up the item from the item encoded chest but the piston that pushes them out the bubble Column just misses it and it breaks the whole farm, is this a known issue or have I done something wrong?

[@glorock]

I am having the exact same issue. Are you on a server by chance? I am on a server and wondering if its some weird latency

[@Mysticblaze132]

I’m on a realm yes, but I’ve also built it in a creative world that’s not in a server and it’s still braking the same way 😢

[@mozzie2729]

I got mine working, I replaced the stairs with mud blocks on the sticky pistons and so far all of my carts haven't gotten stuck and have been able to keep going on the tracks.

[@Mysticblaze132]

@@mozzie2729 alright thank you I will try that!

[@Mysticblaze132]

@@mozzie2729 just tried and still hasn’t fixed the issue, minecart gets pushed up doesn’t snap to rail so just stops in bubble column😢 EDIT: I’ve built a 19 chest long system, the mud fix has worked apart from the 15th slice, that one just will not work, no idea why as it’s built the same as the rest, gunna have just keep that slice empty. Thanks for the fix again!

[@kyletang1524]

i might've skimmed through this but i did your other categorizer that also uses minecart hoppers at the beginning how much improvement is there

[@AAbattery-pj9nm]

Is there a way I can make this go around corners so I don’t have to make multiple of these

[@josiahayres9065]

16:42 how do i get the rails to go toward the cactus

[@ANDREIbr__KFPS]

Muito legal esses seus tutorias, mesmo em outra linguagem da pra entender!!🤩

[@lastxagr5716]

Very good 👍 but when I finished and wanted to try the minecart didn't move can you tell me why ( I've build it with you step by step didn't miss anything) please tell me how to fix it

[@anandadarsh4354]

Built everything exactly the same but my hopper minecart gets stuck in bubble column and it's messing the whole system

[@trooper-8]

I've been looking for this for so long thanks

[@Jonas.Nilsson]

The two fixes I made to this farm was to slow down the Minecraft by removing some of the powered rails and added a regular curved rail at 8:22 I also changed the glass block he placed at 8:32 to a button, otherwise the first slices would break the farm then you slowed it down. (So two buttons right next to each other) I also made it longer,I think I have 14 slices, and one of the slices is modded so the minecart travels to an other singel-item-sorting-system so that I have 54 items that can get sorted into bulkstorage with chulkerloaders. The best sortingsystem I ever had!!

[@ImDogPoo]

Anyone know how to "customize" it and make it turn?? Tried using rails/ bubble columns but can't get the speed right and the minecarts keep getting stuck in the water. PLEASE HELP IM LOSING IT

[@speedyktm94]

This works perfect for me thank you so much silent this is the best storage system I have built ever!!

[@JeffreyLongII]

This is an awesome build! I made it but am having trouble with the first storage slice though. It always stops the minecart instead of pushing it onto the track like it should. I can't figure out why.

[@christianavila7879]

me too. find any solutions?

[@JeffreyLongII]

@christianavila7879 no. I ended up tearing it down and going for a different design. It's not as fast but much more reliable since it doesn't depend on minecarts being pushed around. I really wanted this one to work though.

[@aidenbuchholz3257]

@@JeffreyLongIIdude i just spent so much of my time just for this design not to work😭 its clever but shitty in practice

[@JeffreyLongII]

Yea. I built a different one, but ended up tearing them all down and just manually sorting my items.

[@rocketbuilder]

What is the mechanics behind using an activator rail? Does that allow the minecart to drop off the rail more reliably?

[@silentwisperer]

a powered activator rail disables the hopper minecart so it cant pickup items anymore, super niche mechanic but really helpful:)

[@paqshet4648]

What are the chances of breakage when unloading the chunk? If it's easy to fix then it might be worth it anyway

[@deepanshusharma2527]

Heyy silent....can you provide the structura pack for your tutorials if possible.....that would be so helpful!!!

[@MRSpencer-nu6bj]

Oh, that's fantastic, at 8:22 you put down a bit of track that seems to be orientation sensitive... Mine just doesn't want to go across the top and just joins to the sloped tracks. 😮‍💨

[@silentwisperer]

place a rail to either side of that top rail, then place in the lower slope rails, then remove the extra rails to either side at the top :)

[@onlyone0rion]

Possible bug, I tweaked the rails a bit entering the bubble columns to get things consistent. Which it is now for everything except for non stackable items. With one in the last slot of the hopper minecart now, the minecart does not have enough momentum to fully enter and move through the bubble columns like everything else. I have to scrap an allay sorting system I was going to attach to the end of things.

[@nintendoswitchbrit4201]

You didn't mention comparitors in the slice part of materials list

[@grape3587]

Did some tinkering on the design for my own world and there is actually enough room in the loading system to have a shulker loader replace the chest even using the systems auto shut-off for the hopper minecarts. Just barley fits but you can def get the redstone in there. you do need to move that lever on the block under the repeater going into the powered rail but other than that the existing design doesn't need any other adjustment

[@Arrowounds]

could you post a video of your design? i would love to see! :)

[@jonathasqntjonathas]

The Power rail placed akward on 8:34 is Just not moving the way you placed. He always goes straight...

[@TheBedrockMaster]

Read the pinned comment, if thats it?

[@jonathasqntjonathas]

I read, thanks! Now it turns to the right side, towards the water, but I'm still having some carts congestion @@TheBedrockMaster

[@TheBedrockMaster]

Me too, I’ve even done some fixes suggested in the comments. I’m just going to leave it until Silent says something about it :)@@jonathasqntjonathas

[@captnzap9588]

Love seeing new tech come out. Nice

[@Jules_123]

I was just making one but this one seems much smaller and simplerer, thanks alot

[@jamesrbushjr9610]

Ok, I've been working on the storage area of my base for the past week and a half and after building and trashing three different item categorizers I am going to try to use this one. I have built many of your builds in my survival world and want to say thanks. My world would be much less easy to use if you were not putting out tutorials. How many total stackable items are in the game? I would like to know how many chests I need to store anything I throw in the system. So far I have a huge system and this build will be the crown. I will send you a screenshot when I'm done. I hope it works. After reading some of the comments I'm prepared for a little tweaking but the other systems I tried didn't work for what I needed. Anyway, thanks again.

[@christianavila7879]

HELP! So I built this system to the tee and double checked everything. Somehow my minecarts arent getting pushed by the pistons onto the rails after pulling the sorter item. I saw here someone tried mud blocks and that worked for them but it has not worked for me. Whats even crazier is I built this system in a test world and it works perfectly fine using the stairs on this pistons. I dont get it and could use some sort of explanation as to what might be causing this. UPDATE: I realized that the minecart was moving too quickly for the piston to activate and push it. To fix this I replaced the powered rail line that launches the minecart into the water stream with a regular rail line curving into the water stream. After changing this the pistons would push the minecart onto the proper rail line but then it would need to be nudged a little to continue through the system. To fix this I replaced the stairs with mud blocks like some people suggested and now my system works A1 100% of the time. Hope this helps out the bedrock community. Much love

[@Sloth_Quest]

Thank you so much for this fix! I've spent 3 hours in survival building this then when I tested it and was like "noooooo"

[@christianavila7879]

Glad I could help someone! I know how devastating that feels. I just couldn't give up though. I really wanted it to work.

[@bkpaguy]

Mud blocks was my fix as well. Thank you

[@TarynMrsTalzynBrown]

Why are my items moving from my categorised chest and then all blocks are going to my overflow chest?

[@yourname1372]

And I'm also having problems with the mine cart getting stuck right were the water starts.

[@glenbuckley1663]

This ie so epic thank you looking forwards to seeing the super all type tree fram can't wait

[@Mr.Monkey16579]

Just asking, but how do you make it turn without breaking it? Building this in survival and I’m kind of scared to waste resources and time. Thanks!:)

[@luminitechrome9371]

If your carts get stuck on the glass pane, swap the last rail up the top with a powered one to force it to line up against the trapdoor, tbh not sure why its not one in the video

[@deriksiphone]

Stairs didn't work for the block glitch 😭 (running latest beta). I'll play around with some other options. I was looking forward to seeing this in action. Edit: I couldn't find any other block to prevent the sticky piston from eating my minecart but I accidentally found out that the next section was working properly and tested the next one after that and it was working too. I made sure to chunk align. I built facing west, looking at it, which made the rails ~fun~ but not sure if it plays any part in this. Swapped out the glass block with the button on it to a solid block to see if that had any different outcome. It did not..

[@silentwisperer]

vertical trapdoors (closer to the water than the pistons) seem to avoid that glitch

[@deriksiphone]

​@@silentwispererthe trap door just gave me easier access to my swallowed hopper minecart 😂 After further testing, appears to be only affecting the first slice, while all others work perfectly and are so fun to watch. Maybe I just use first slice as junk/temp storage until the bug is fixed. 🤷

[@lilsul5986]

My minecraft keeps getting stuck

[@lilsul5986]

Minecart *

[@mozzie2729]

@@lilsul5986 I have the same problem but found the solution. Replace the stairs on the sticky pistons with mud blocks. Mine haven't gotten stuck since.