MIXING FOUNDATION & WATER?? Pro MUA Reacts to TikTok hacks!

[@RobertWelsh]

PLEASE READ 🖤 !!! If a profile pretending to be me comments saying you have won something, it is not me! Please block them! I’m doing my best to delete their comments and block them🙏🏻🖤 all my social media accounts a verified with ticks (except tiktok).

[@BirgitBauhaus]

Oooh 😲...What a F...! But no...nothing like this was happening to me... Have a wonderful and happy Weekend with nice Weather, Sunshine and a lot of beloved and nice People around you - if you like 😍🤗❣💖🍀🍀🍀👍😉

[@binderkim]

They just commented on my comment about winning a prize. Lol.

[@joleneking5842]

Yes I've had it and deleted it

[@anario7415]

I got it too and blocked it.

[@Wwydn]

Thank you so much for validating how I feel about makeup. I appreciate you so much.

[@riatalukder8173]

I think the foundation in the water tactic, at least on the original video, is a marketing tactic used by Chinese influencers to help sell the makeup as 'waterproof'. Like 'oh its been dunked in water but it still works because they didn't mix'. And american tiktokers have gotten it mixed up thinking it was recommending people to put their foundation in water lol

[@riatalukder8173]

but yes agreed lol you dont need to do that

[@RobertWelsh]

Yea it takes me back to the dunking the face in ice water moment

[@Stilbe]

@@RobertWelsh what do you mean "takes you back" ? Its still considered a hack used by bella or gigi hadid😂

[@liliaricci9348]

US kids are just not being educated at all gf

[@rosiemcgurk279]

Does adding water to your beauty sponge make a difference or does the same apply x

[@MrFrankhdgs]

Robert, I am a man, who just turned 60. I grew up with all girls. I have kept up with all the current hair styles and makeup tricks, since the mid-70's. I helped all of the girls get ready, by helping with hair and makeup - I learned about contouring and bronzer in about 1977. So, yes, it has been around, and is not something new. (I 'did' both grandmothers' hair, for their funerals; I did nails and makeup on my maternal grandmother, for her funeral; I did nails, hair, and makeup on my mother, for her funeral; I helped with my mother's only sister's hair for her funeral; and I assisted with everything for my mother-in-law's funeral. I did their hair, makeup, and nails, in life, so it made since that I would do it for them, their very last times.)

[@hyararichielli]

I am crying, that's so beautiful, i hope u had a good time w/ them

[@MrFrankhdgs]

@@hyararichielli - thank you...I genuinely did. In fact, my oldest daughter had problems getting her really long hair into 'space buns', for work, yesterday morning; so I did them. I still cut both of my youngests' hair, and help with makeup and hairstyles, from time to time...it is nice they only trust me, for those things.

[@megkelly3361]

Wow I wish I had a father like you!!

[@MrFrankhdgs]

@@megkelly3361- thank you.

[@starbird3939]

You must have been really strong to be able to do your passed relative’s makeup. I was balling my eyes out from just seeing her and breaking down from touching her hand.

[@arkansaninva]

Robert, I'm so glad you stood up for those of us who use makeup because we want to. I rarely ever used makeup for the first 35 years of my life, and then I got cancer. Suddenly I had to learn how to draw on my face! I had no eyebrows, no eyelashes, and I was anemic a lot of the time so my lips were very very pale. I learned about makeup then (mostly from you!), and now I continue to use makeup a lot of the time because it turned into a hobby. It was great to be able to transform my face into whatever I wanted! Anyway, sorry for the long story, just wanted you to know how much I appreciate you!

[@BirgitBauhaus]

SORRY - NOT SORRY 😍😉💖

[@CherrrrBear]

Oh wow, you’re incredibly strong 🫶🏼 hope you’re doing well

[@arkansaninva]

@@CherrrrBear Thank you! I've been cancer free for a few months now!

[@cyanidecherrypie]

Coming from a stranger, I am so glad u beat cancer!!! I’m sure your makeup looked absolutely amazing

[@southbug27]

Becoming ill, made me dive into KZbin makeup videos as well because the medications dehydrate my entire body & have just ruined my skin. I also found the videos cheer me up. When I’m in rougher patches & stuck in bed, they make me feel like I’m doing something worthwhile because I’m learning something. The beauty of it, art aspect, also gives me an emotional boost. While I’m still trying to get an expensive skincare routine to be able to wear foundation without dead body looking dry skin, I can wear makeup again sometimes, & I think I’m pretty close to getting my system down.

[@Dubois_tada]

I thought It wasn't common to put on makeup and then immediately take it off. My roommates find it so weird that I would do heavy colorful makeup an hour from bedtime or when I'm just lounging around the house in pjs. I enjoy makeup so much and I don't understand how people don't realize its an artistic medium lol

[@paresseuxdesneiges]

Same tbh 😂

[@polly1141]

Totally agree, point well made!

[@Jigglypowerpuffgirl]

Thank you! I wear makeup for me. Most of the time men hate my makeup so I’m definitely not doing it for them. I hate when a man tells me “you don’t need all that” or “you’re prettier without makeup”.

[@therealladyk.hatake8400]

Before I figured out my sexuality later on when I got older, I literally had a jackass of an ex boyfriend who hated drawn eyebrows. He always criticized & picked on me from the way I drew my brows. He also said he didn't like women wearing makeup, so being a naive girl I listened to him & stopped. I felt ugly & like I wasn't doing anything right & that it was bad. Like the majority of the time it is always a straight man who would be the one to talk smack when it comes to makeup all the time & be the one to make you feel bad.

[@nollypolly]

This kind of man assumes everything a woman does is to attract him. It does not even enter his tiny brain that a woman would put effort into something that isn't specifically for the male gaze. Says so much more about them than anything else.

[@denaemichele]

I love the conversation around makeup being forced vs self-care. For most of my life, I felt like I was required to wear makeup to appear "professional " or "put together " or "like an adult woman". I would wear as little as I could get away with because it felt like a chore. When I started working from home, I stopped wearing makeup (and started doing skincare) and got more comfortable in my own skin. Then I found this channel and started practicing the techniques and suddenly makeup became fun! Now I wear makeup when and how I want to - which is sometimes just creating eye looks in the middle of the night and then washing them off. 🤣 I never thought I would enjoy makeup but now I am building a small collection of eyeshadow palettes. Lol I'm also getting interested in makeup history. I recently bought the Pretty Boys book and I'm looking forward to reading it. Would love any other makeup history resource recommendations. ❤️📚

[@Jhud69]

Lol I'm kind of the same in some aspects. I personally always refused to wear makeup when I was younger for gender dysphoria reasons, but I did feel pressured into it because of my acne and well, appearance to put it lightly. I only started enjoying makeup when I got into watching channels like Robert's and now I just do my makeup for fun at home because it's a fun thing to do and practice. Wild how anything is better when you don't feel pressured into it.

[@sammyg4159]

Love this

[@WintrBorn]

I just didn’t. I was bad at it, so I embraced my tomboyish ways. Then lockdown and I got decent at it thanks to KZbin. Now I happily wear it daily, 15 minutes to go all out. I love it!

[@denaemichele]

@@Jhud69 Thank you for sharing! I can't even imagine how much gender dysphoria would compound on top of the general pressure to wear makeup. I'm glad that you have found a way to enjoy makeup and I hope you have found peace and comfort in your body. ❤️

[@denaemichele]

@@WintrBorn That is impressive! It takes me way longer than 15 minutes to go all out. 🤣

[@madisonhayes7332]

I agree with roberts opinion on the makeup scam thing. Literally doing makeup in the mornings is my FAVORITE part of my day. I adore doing eyeshadow and i HATE not being able to do my makeup. it’s practically therapeutic for me

[@BethaneyLilly]

Same! I enjoy the process of getting ready, it’s entirely my selfish “me” time ….the process is very much therapeutic for me too. I’ll wake up early and sacrifice sleep, that part of the day is often the best part of my day. Totally not a “scam”, sounds like that dude is totally “mansplaining” ….I don’t do anything to my face for anyone but myself, it’s for my enjoyment and to express my own creativity. Love learning different techniques and trying new products.

[@tinyazn]

Its meditation to me. If I cant do it for a couple days I don’t feel right. And i’m not talking about full face 2016 makeup, I’m talking about the makeup the suits me which is like eyeshadow and concealer or liner and lashes. Hell, if I have the time to do 2016 makeup I would LOL. It’s just my favorite part of the day and I don’t do it for men I do it for me.

[@binderkim]

Same! Every single morning!

[@pumpkite8998]

same makeup is like a theraphy for me and to also show my creativity, it's really fun and I do it for me and not to impress anybody. Sometimes I'll do a natural look if I'm lazy but I'll also do some artistic makeup. Makeup is art and art is subjective, if you like the look then go rock it bestie :3

[@thepineyapple]

I’m glad it’s a happy experience for some but it’s just plain old stressful for me. Like I feel like I end up looking worse and like I don’t know what I’m doing no matter how many tutorials I watch and information I get. Like seriously makes me want to cry because I feel like I look terrible and there’s nothing I can do to get myself to even a basic level that majority of women can doing their make up. Like what the hell am I doing wrong?

[@sm8733]

I'm honestly so tired of hearing the whole "You don't need that much makeup" "You wear too much makeup" "you're prettier without makeup" "if she wears this much makeup she's fake or insecure." And weirdly people think that they're helping by saying this, but it's gotten to the point where they're making people feel bad for their passion or even expressing themselves by going all out - like no Sandra I'm not trying to impress a guy, I just want to smother myself in glitter ok?

[@whatsup968]

As a woman and as a feminist who enjoys the self-expression and artistry that can be found in makeup, but who also struggles with insecurity, I'm gonna say the social effects of makeup are complicated I don't think we can totally simplify it one way or the other It's too individual and for many people they experience both sides depending on the moment

[@MrsRitchieBlackmore]

It's really interesting..."complicated" is the best way to put it. What's fascinating to me is that even though makeup is considered a "feminine, frivolous" sort of thing, there are studies that show women who wear makeup are perceived as more competent and sharp (ie. stereotypical masculine attributes) in a workplace setting than bare-faced women! So people CANNOT say that women wear makeup just to look hot for guys. However, the idea that we have to enhance our features just to be respected is problematic in itself. I dunno, it gives me a headache... I personally love makeup myself but it's weird to really think deeply about it.

[@SlothDaan]

It also really depends on someones skills. I am so terrible at doing make-up, that I just feel prettier without 😅

[@HT-pl8du]

While I enjoy putting on makeup at 2am just to immediately take it off bc it gives me a confidence boost, I think makeup as it is rn still reinforces a very narrow beauty standard. I have extensive knowledge of what parts of my face aren't conventionally attractive and I "correct" that with makeup to look "presentable" and "put together" to take advantage of the halo effect. For me, having decent makeup skills is another way to use my privilege of time and money. I agree, it's complicated

[@Kayla_P99]

@@MrsRitchieBlackmore it's partly a reward for conformity to social standards but yes very very complex.

[@Kaeracter]

I came to the comment section to talk about this same idea. I think if we were able to survey people who wear makeup, I think that most would agree that makeup is enjoyable and they do it for themselves and I think they would be truthful in that answer. However, if we were to test those same people and force them to go in public without makeup, there would be a lot of them who wouldn't want to or would feel uncomfortable doing so - because they are insecure without makeup, they don't think they look their best, it makes them uncomfortable, etc. That is the complicated part of this - I would want every person to feel comfortable in their skin without makeup. I know I only got to that point in the last few years, where I don't second guess leaving the house without makeup on. I do still choose to wear makeup I certain situations, but it's nice that I don't feel the insecure compulsion to do so anymore.

[@adafihj6439]

As a dark-skinned black girl I had to use eyeshadow for a contour and now I use this brown blush from Sasha Cosmetics. It's perfect

[@ggeemmiinnii]

Lack of inclusivity in the beauty world is utter bullshit. I also can't stand it when people say 'it's 2022, where's the inclusivity?'...EXclusivity in the beauty world NEVER should have been a thing, no matter the year.

[@Jhud69]

There are some good contouring shades made specifically for deep skintones nowadays but they're usually wildly expensive which is utter bullshit honestly

[@alicialynnette9889]

I feel products have come a long way! Growing up it was fashion fair and black opal. That was really it. Then Mac. Now I feel like I can walk into any store and find my shade. Although it's not easy for everyone it is so much better. I have been able to find affordable products to fit my needs!!

[@Neenerella333]

Yeah. The shadow thing is nice, but complexion products come in much larger containers, making them more economical. I try to support black owned brands, in order to show that the wider shade ranges are economically viable. Uoma, Mented, Beauty Bakerie and even the Fenty matchsticks are proof that a big shade range, with multiple undertones are here to stay.

[@RubyBlueUwU]

I think it’s also important to remember that contouring *that* heavily is not going to look like a “snatched jawline” in person, no matter how skilfully you execute it, it’s going to look like you’ve drawn a darkened triangle on your neck. Very little contouring is trying to look “natural” and that’s fine, but I think more emphasis needs to be put on the fact that if you do KZbin/Instagram/tiktok contour to wear in everyday life it’s not gonna look slimming or snatched or contoured, you’re just gonna look like you’ve got lines drawn on your face and you need to be aware of that. If people can see you in 3D, you can’t fool them with manufactured shading

[@gpgp1841]

Absolutely...! I also can't wrap my head around the nose contouring (which makes me sad how much woman tend to hate their noses that are not Michael-Jackson-after-surgery-slim) and putting strong silver/gold highlights on the tip of the nose etc. It looks so off in person. I imagine people see it on social media but don't think of the natural light at all :(

[@BelArtist]

Boy nobody is expecting you to prime and highlight and contour etc, it’s just fun options that are available to us now 😆 Makeup is fun and beautiful and you can create a whole glam look if you want to or wear only a tinted lip-balm for the day if that’s what you feel like! ☺️

[@ileenroychoudhury3110]

Love how Robert touches on the point that Makeup is a therapy , self-care, an escape and mental-care and not necessarily to impress an ignorant lad . King

[@sarahwatson3192]

When I’m feeling down (i have depression and sometimes get into bad episodes) I make myself do my make up… because it makes me feel pretty, it makes me happy! If I can’t feel sparkly and shimmery inside imma be a disco all on the outside!

[@ASentientBlockofSwissCheese]

Yay you uploaded! I’m saying this in the nicest and least creepy way possible… you seem so sweet and I always wanna give you a hug. Your videos make me happy. Just wanted you to know.

[@RobertWelsh]

Thank you so much!!! 🖤🖤🖤

[@_Laura.Marie_Sierra.Destiny_]

Lmao I love your username

[@heather2301]

Robert doesn’t want to admit it because he’s lactose intolerant but he most certainly loves you 🤣

[@alanarafuse2998]

After having a baby three months ago, me putting on makeup makes me feel rejuvenated. It's a way for me to get out and feel like 'more than just a mum' because 99% of the time that is how I feel nowadays. One thing that has always been true is makeup can be tailored however you want it to be. Makeup is expression more than ever!

[@notkatieparry]

Makeup for me is therapeutic. I do agree brands are doing too much. Look…I love ColourPop. Their eyeshadows are so great and I have my fair share of their palettes. But they are literally coming out with a new collection every week and sometimes twice/week. It’s usually just their same shadows with a different and sometimes not so different color story.

[@polly1141]

I agree but to play devil's advocate clothing companies also release modified versions of t-shirts et c it doesn't mean we but then all, just our favourite. Our problem is we are more tempted by make up 😀

[@keturahnaomi]

10:56 I enjoy knowing how and creating. It’s literally coloring! Like my face is the coloring page and my makeup is the markers/crayons/pens/oils/paints I use to bring color into my world.

[@lisaduchateau]

I'm so happy you mentioned some of the many the reasons WHY people like to wear make-up. My ex asked my why I wore make-up and told me I shouldn't have to 😒.. I never stopped wearing make-up for anyone! I have loved make up since I was in 8th grade. Like you said, it's a form of expression. You can change it with your moods, & the possibilities are endless. When I was a teenager it gave me more confidence because I had acne, and I used it to cover it up. I also liked to play up my eyes to accentuate the color of them. I started wearing make-up in the 80's and I'd go to department stores like Sax 5th Avenue & Marshall Fields, go to the make-up counters to learn from the MUA's there. I learned SO much, and now thanks to videos like yours, I am still learning! I love how much variety there is now. YES people, wear ALL THE MAKE-UP!! As much or as little as you want. It's a great way to express yourself. Just like through clothes or hair, it's fun! And if something can put more beauty in the world, I am HERE FOR IT!

[@polly1141]

I agree, plus you don't see folk complaining about people who go to hairdressers or but new clothing. If we but more make up for a change it's seen as unnecessary. I know it can get out of hand but basically it's a hobby for most 😀

[@peachmylk]

Preach! Also, funny how most straight men's love of the "natural look" never seems to extend to body hair 🤔

[@maryann1ization]

That guy had a valid point. But I do feel that the community has grown in a good way in other aspects: color range for POC, and acceptance of trans and gender fluidity in the community are just two examples that come to mind.

[@JasminMiettunen]

Just the acceptance of creativity is so great, too. Before it was all about looking attractive and fulfilling the beauty standards. Now you can use colours and rainbow highlighters and heart shaped freckles! As someone with quite good skin, dark thick eyebrows, etc. I never felt the *need* to use makeup when other girls started wearing it, I thought it was just to “fix your flaws”, but I've fallen in love with the crazy tiktok e-girl looks. You don’t “need” makeup, you can just want to have fun! I also feel like the “you have to do all these steps and products and a ton of products” has started to subside in favour of more minimalistic looks, like the Glossier look. My personal issue is trying to marry the minimalistic, natural skin/base with the bright colors and designs on the eyes, cheeks or lips 😅

[@stinks7065]

@@JasminMiettunen honestly I think part of the rise in creativity is because things that were pretty underground to a majority of people, or things that were countercultural have now gained a wider audience through social media and certain reality tv shows. Like, I think drag has absolutely become more encouraged and accepted into the mainstream due to the effects of shows like rupaul's drag race - and with that comes more people embracing the wacky things you can do with drag makeup cause there are so many drag queens and kings out there who are doing incredible, out-there stuff with their faces! It's straight up art! Also countercultural movements with very distinct aesthetics, like the 'crazy tiktok e-girl looks' you mentioned have become more visible due to social media and people who proudly post their fashion moments online and I think that has encouraged a lot more people to experiment with their style, including their makeup! I do still think that there are a lot of pressures on women to look a certain way, and often makeup is promoted as being the thing that will get you looking that way, and I think that part has absolutely nothing to do with those eye-catching out-there looks. But I definitely also agree with the guy when he said we're made to think we absolutely NEED all of those products, and I know Robert has mentioned it before in some of his older videos where he reviewed youtube MUAs and the way they approach makeup. Like you don't need contour and primer and foundation and you don't NEED to bake in order to get a good look, those are just techniques that can be useful for certain skintypes and certain situations.

[@danicee]

I agree with all your points regarding your breakdown of that guy’s video. I don’t think makeup has ever been forced on me, I just like the artistry and the routine of putting on makeup. It’s something that allows me to take the time to center myself and feel more confident because I have a bit more control over my image. Also, I think there are too many brands atm and a lot of people - brands are owned and operated by people, they don’t simply exist - are releasing items just to compete with other brands & not actually introducing better formulas with more sustainable packaging. We need to focus on improving and not over-consuming products - and idc if I don’t buy something, product that doesn’t sell is most likely being thrown out and creating more waste so creating products that are more effective and have 100% recyclable packaging would definitely help the makeup industry as well as all other industries.

[@paresseuxdesneiges]

I agree

[@richardwright9292]

There is SO much ridiculous disrespect towards women MUAs and women who enjoy makeup. I remember on first day of college a faculty member said to me "it's different, *you* want to be an actual artist and half of them just want to doit on themselves." Gross and offensive. Firstly, so what if they did?? Secondly, there were SO many immensely talented artists there and everyone deserved equal respect/treatment. Being a boy or man is not a flippin' qualification!! Not in any job or hobby! Ridiculous. And every problem with "over-consumption" of makeup/beauty products is just a symptom of a capitalist society based around consumerism and infinite growth. It applies to *every* product and *every* hobby but makeup and traditionally "feminine" things are singled out every time. There are people with walls full of vinyl records, Funko Pops, or football team merch scoffing at makeup enthusiasts! World is not on fire because someone bought a new lip gloss. We should all aim to be conscious ethical consumers but it is no substitute for structural change.

[@zionmommy]

I love that you mentioned the artistry. Before, long long ago in the 90s (I'm so old) only magazines and runways had interesting and artistic looks. I love the way that makeup is being used as a medium. And some of these artists are incredible. Also, the shift of gender has been exciting to observe. I love seeing makeup normalized for all genders. 💜

[@rvanderjagt5944]

I saw a makeup tutorial from (I think Cosmo) in the late 80s, by an artist who is still practicing now. I was surprised at how much advice was still pretty solid and still used, and how subdued and versatile the look was. It just went to show that underneath all the trends and gimmicks, the sound advice has always been present in certain places. Also why I ignore influencers who pay too much attention to what is and is not trendy.

[@MrsRitchieBlackmore]

@@rvanderjagt5944 Yes I have the same experience getting very good advice from older sources..some concepts, like working with one's bone structure, light and shade, drawing attention to the right areas, etc. are eternal! Just swap in the latest shades and formulas.

[@wombatlittle1]

People wore interesting artistic looks in clubs and on the street in the 80s and 90s. I know because I was there

[@DianaFlores-og8zv]

I totally agree! I was in high school in the 80s and college in the 90s and I learned makeup watching my mom and my sister....my sister then worked at the clinique counter and she gave me tips...or I would look at the pictures of the supermodels in magazines....and even then it was foundation blush lipstick eyeliner and a bit of mascara...then I kind of gave up on makeup....for years....then KZbin came along and people like taxi and Wayne goss...and Robert!! Got me excited about putting on and CREATING LOOKS!! ABOUT REALLY GOOD TECHNIQUES AND COLOR COORDINATION AND THE RIGHT TYPES OF PRODUCTS FOR MY SKIN! I'm 49 and have never been more excited to get ready with makeup whereas earlier in my life it was almost a chore that I HAD to do....now I love doing pink and purple looks for church or black shadow with sparkle for going out to dinner with the hubs and I deaf what anybody thinks cuz I love it!!! So yes do u what u want...or dont...do what makes u feel good....and then feel good about yourself and your own beauty!!!

[@tinytaz6668]

I get in from work, take my makeup off, then sit and play with my makeup, while watching KZbin. It's my happy place 😊

[@rojo3779]

I don’t know what Robert said because I was mesmerised by his beautiful make up the entire video. Absolutely stunning

[@angelagalvez4956]

Robert you’ve literally saved me so many times from buying the wrong things and for like saving my face from looking bad!! Simplicity is always everything and following the right method in doing makeup!

[@mari-bella]

same!!

[@JP-rx2zu]

I couldn’t agree with you more about using makeup for mental health purposes! I can’t tell you how often I do my makeup when I know I’m not even going out, because it helps greatly reduce my anxiety. There’s something so soothing and meditative about having quiet time, where you’re just able to light a scented candle, grab a glass of wine or a coffee drink, listen to some music, a podcast, or watch KZbin, while just being able to play with your makeup. It can be very calming, therapeutic, and joyful for me, even if I know I’m just gonna wash it all off when I’m done.

[@SquintyBubbles]

I hardly ever wear makeup anymore but I still want to stay up to date with the new technology, new techniques and purchase new products for when I do decide to wear makeup. Just like all the other interests in my life, please don't let people restrict my joy!!

[@Frakkyfire]

You mentioned that you're really into makeup history - I would love if you made a series on different makeup eras (from all different places too)!

[@charlottemac3290]

He has one on The Welsh Twins channel 😁😁

[@sebumpostmortem]

That woman in her 50’ s replying to the guy with the 📢 summarizes perfectly what make up should be about🙌🏻 Nobody questions people who love drawing and painting as a hobby, right? I have the same hobby in its facial 3D slope. PERIOD. In my fantasies, make up and art stores are unified✨ 🧛🏻‍♀️🖤

[@Kayla_P99]

Additionally I have put makeup in my paintings to add sparkle so...

[@arielruby13]

You are so right about it, i see makeup and painting as arts and i would love to be able to buy stuff for both at the same store. But i would possibly risk putting paint on my face because i thought it was a bright lipstick or something lol, as most of what i wear is not "basic" colors

[@sebumpostmortem]

@@Kayla_P99 @Ariel Ruby Not Juno Birch dotting her stooninng face with white acrylic paint 🤦🏻‍♀️😅 🧛🏻‍♀️🖤

[@hyararichielli]

@@arielruby13 yes! There is different types of paint for different superficies, like paint for wall, for wood, for glass, for paper, and paint for skin, which is called makeup!

[@cyntheknitter9927]

You are so right about makeup being expected in the past and has been elevated to an artistry that is much more accessible to more people

[@trumpgirl1018]

I love his giggle and his laugh, it is so infectious and when he pairs with his twin, they are amazing together…I love this guy’s personality, you know he is a genuinely nice person

[@Selene_Rosara]

I've been into makeup most of my life. It was never forced on me. It was something that I wanted in my life. I would never tell someone else that they needed makeup though.

[@appetitefordeconstruction]

I learned to contour doing photography make up in a studio. When it became a "thing", I was pretty shocked because I always felt it was something only necessary under a certain type of light etc. But really, people can do what they want with their makeup, there are no laws. I did have to agree with that guy on the blatant greed/consumerism in the celebrity make-up industry.

[@cheekofeather6310]

I'm a huge makeup fan, it's my hobby-I collect, learn and love it. So much so, I'm running an extra curricular makeup course at my school for my students, from September - it's a creative outlet 100%. Xxxxx

[@DiMagnolia]

I agree about the makeup as a “scam” thing, I can see how some brands and influencers push products but as an artistry it’s grown. Culturally, it can be forced on you or gatekept from you. Makeup is much more accessible for all genders and ages and ethnicities, formulations have improved, shade ranges have improved, more brands are cruelty free and vegan, the price range has expanded, and the education to learn about techniques is FREE on youtube and social media. Yes, capitalism or cultural expectations can take it too far, but it’s definitely not a scam.

[@sarahtownsend621]

I’ve been binging your videos today and wanted to leave a comment about the modern day scam guy. I completely agree that makeup-wearing people have more agency and choice than ever before. I do want to add that the whole women and femme presenting people are considered more professional with makeup is not gone. I was told to wear makeup to a job interview just last month. I am also someone that has found so much help in mental health and self expression with makeup. I love makeup and love your videos! Humans are complex and so are the issues we face. Lots of love xx

[@AJ-hc8rk]

I had a bad mental health day today, and after work thought I'd sit down on my bed and do my makeup watching Robert to feel better, I FEEL SO SEEN 💛 You cannot tell me makeup is just for the male gaze, it is 100% self care!

[@votepurple]

I relate to this! 💯 Hope you have a better day tommorow ❤️

[@AJ-hc8rk]

@@votepurple ♥️

[@polly1141]

I can honestly say my love of make up has nothing to do with trying to attract a man. I use my personality for that.

[@rvanderjagt5944]

To me, in addition to makeup being artistry and a relaxing experience, makeup gives control over my appearance that I did not have in the past due to lack of access and education. There are features that I am no a fan of, like dark circles or redness, but now I can choose how or if I present those things. We do the same thing with clothing choices; most people don't wear the same stuff to a night out as they wear to the gym or Wal-Mart.

[@arielruby13]

exactly!

[@taylorrspeaking]

Makeup being a scam I don’t necessarily agree with but the mass consumerism in the beauty industry bothers me a bit. I fell into it big time in the height of beauty KZbin and just had way too much. I try to be very selective now and have really trimmed down my makeup collection because I have so much more than I could ever practically use.

[@Laura_Lawson]

Love this! I’m glad you covered that TikTok about makeup being a scam. I remember when I watched it a while ago I felt bad because I enjoy makeup and how it makes me feel. It’s bad enough dealing with all the toxic masculinity around “I only like natural girls with no makeup” when you’re a makeup lover without adding another layer of negativity onto something you enjoy. 💜

[@simplybri3608]

Why would you feel bad about enjoying makeup? And why pay attention to men who say that? One thing I hate about social media is how we internalize people’s opinion when they’re just that an opinion and these ppl don’t know it’s personally and we don’t know them personally.

[@Laura_Lawson]

@@simplybri3608 social media really is the worst I’m with you there!

[@candzbrad]

And even more frustrating is those men who say that don't know that the "no makeup" look is generally still makeup 🤦‍♀️

[@Laura_Lawson]

@@candzbrad haha totally! 😆

[@cheezeandbunnies]

Can we please talk about how stunning your eyeshadow look is? 😍 And if you’ve already created a tutorial for it, could you share? Thank you!! 😊

[@notam6071]

Yes! Incredible eyeshadow! Any chance Robert would tell us the palette used? 😊🥰❤️

[@katherinehickey1305]

I was coming to say the same thing. LOVE this eye look 😍

[@sophieh6674]

It’s sooooooo lush, I can’t even describe the colour he’s wearing.

[@rchankelly]

Yesss please drop the purple smoky eye routine 💜

[@asterv843]

Me too, couldn't stop thinking it's such a romantic look!

[@donnareed73]

I hate when ppl tell me I’m already pretty and I don’t need makeup nobody NEEDS makeup I wear makeup because I like it and your absolutely right in saying some use it for an escape that’s me I’m some lol I love putting on makeup to escape when I’m putting on my makeup it’s just me a mirror and lots of beautiful colors and I can get caught up for hours. When I was going through depression a chance to apply my makeup was sometimes the motivation for getting out of bed. So yes for me it’s an escape and At times therapy.

[@kat_likemeow]

That "water hack" drives me crazy lol the original wasn't even a hack 😩 it was a gimmick to demonstrate that its water proof

[@maiganmattson5836]

I just love the way that you explain things. I am literally one of those people who just play with makeup and go and wash it off. It is totally an escape/self care moment for me. It feels like art and self expression rather than being vain. Totally agree with you that people get caught up in thinking all make up is vain because it's associated with image but that's just simply not true. Just because it can be used in a vain way doesn't mean it always is. Love ya Robert! Hope all is well for you, your family and your pups!

[@a.harrington1634]

I really appreciate the idea of makeup for self-care and fun, and your focus on "need vs enjoy." I, as an adult, have the right and access to add sparkles to my face, so I do, but I don't have to (and don't) contour with contour. Also: Thank you for reminding a out not setting the under eye. I have always had dark circles and thin under eye skin, and I can NEVER use setting powder. Edited for added content.

[@krishughes4003]

The “modern day scam” dude is off base … there are still a lot of women who choose not to wear makeup. His semi valid points are that it does seem like everyone has a makeup line or collab. I’m fine with it as long as it’s good! Also we need to teach girls that they don’t need to “fix” anything; they are fine how they are and makeup is for fun! 😁

[@cerity]

I can't stop staring at Robert's eyes in this video! So much depth.

[@katiekilgore6319]

I rarely wear makeup but when I do I'm doing it because I enjoy it and I get a sense of pride about how well I can apply it and how creative I can be

[@briannabrooks6806]

love love love this eye look on you

[@bonemeringue9464]

Definitely agree with the history of makeup being forced on woman but many now using it as a form of expression or self care. Men also have their own rituals and little things they enjoy, some like to get haircuts every few weeks for that fresh fade look, some like to go the gym, some are really into their colognes, beardcare etc. It's a rough world out there and you don't know how long you have in this life, why not dress up, do your hair, take some time to do your skincare, play with colour and apply makeup if that makes you feel good?

[@ktd2002uk]

I used to collect revolution products. Started when they first launched. I was a die hard supporter and went to a lot of their events. It was nice that they were a brand with affordable products. Then prices went up, quality went down and it was all about the money to them. The consumer didn't matter anymore as long as the owners were getting richer. I'm glad that a professional such as Robert gives a voice to what us old revoholics have known for a long time.

[@BlindBabeBeth]

I use makeup as a kind of therapy. It's dedicated, blocked out time during my day where I solely focus on this one thing and not overthink and worry. I get creative, play with colours, textures and scents. It's fun. It's not for someone else's approval of me. 🖤

[@Vivezbien]

There's something about this eye look that is just fabulous!

[@emilychilds9551]

Sorry but that eyeshadow makes your eyeballs literally sparkle I've never seen anything so beautiful

[@Brandi1823]

My fiance and I watch your videos together and he has often told me that my makeup and watching makeup videos help me with my mental health stuff. I have been with him since 2018 and he just went see he understands you too. 💜 I have severe anxiety, depression, PTSD, ocd, and sensory issues along with attention stuff. He says thank you for telling me what he's been trying to explain for years 💜

[@rachelwhittington937]

I’m so glad you are covering the water one! I tagged 👍🏼🙏🏼🙏🏼

[@RobertWelsh]

Sooo many people are doing acting like it does so much 😝

[@susanhorn6401]

We did it we just never called it contour. I'm 58 years old and still learn new things but have never changed what they call contour now. 🖤💜 Oh and I have never baked!

[@hadesisbaby]

Anything Robert says is immediately fact in my mind and idc what anyone says lmao 💜 Anytime anyone asks ANY question about makeup I immediately point them to the makeup bible…aka Robert 🤠💜

[@RobertWelsh]

😂😂🖤🖤🖤

[@Ninjakimmy]

Same! And when someone else says something that's the opposite I don't trust them anymore. Why am I like this. Lol

[@hadesisbaby]

@@Ninjakimmy EXACTLY LMFAOOOO I look at them like 🧐🤨🫠🤥 BYE

[@hadesisbaby]

@@RobertWelshnot me fangirling 😭 looking gorgeous as ever Robert ILY 🥲🤎

[@graceful1537]

"Makeup Bible" lmao 🤣

[@iusedtowrite6667]

Any tips on sweat proofing the make-up?. Especially for a humid weather. I feel like you give such indepth and understandable solutions which are realistic. Love your channel

[@janis2633]

I like to use a setting spray. Like UD All Nighter on a makeup sponge as a final step. No cakey look like a powder gives and it really does help to keep makeup in place during sweaty, humid conditions. Hope that helps.

[@paresseuxdesneiges]

Im interested

[@iusedtowrite6667]

@@janis2633 will definitely try that. Thank you

[@WintrBorn]

Green marble selr is my go to. I do factory work, and the place isn’t climate controlled, and has hit temps of 130F on the floor. I do dab at my face with a rag, but I still have a good face on 8-12 hours later. The green is very alcohol forward, but there are other versions.

[@cheezarose]

I definitely use makeup to "look good". I have issue with a lot of hormonale acne, sometimes severe for around 15 years now and the only thing that somewhat helps is the pill. As a result of that my sink as marks,severe dullness,huge pore etc Adding to that my health issues that ultimately also reflect on my face and the lack of sleep that results from it,on a daily bases I just look ill and in bad shape and makeup makes me appreciate my face because it makes it go from reminding me of my skin issues and illness to what it kind of would have been like if didn't have all of this. It's sad to say but it also makes people be nicer because they don't see me as this person who is ill or has something wrong with her.

[@cube435]

Also- setting undereye concealer with a sponge dampened with setting spray works wonders! Press the spray into the skin- you'll love it.

[@ronpo3798]

Not related to the video but i just wanna let you know. Last year was kinda tough for me, my mental health got worse to the point i had to drop out of college and almost lost my life. Watching your videos was one of very few things that keep me going during that tough time. Now guess what, I finished makeup school, started working as pro MUA & my life has been much happier! I wouldn’t be here without you Robert 💜💜

[@deborahdillon2722]

late 70's early 80's we used multiple shades of blush to do what is now known as contour and highlights. They even sold powder blushes in palettes

[@ansanasutheskumar1589]

Honestly I agree with the makeup scan part of your video and what you said. Makeup and fashion are both things that have such a special place in my heart because I love to express my self and show who I am. Especially Makeup is important to me because it was one of my favourit things to do in the morning before I went to work. And for some time ut litarly was the only thing keeping me going in a time if my life where everything seemed so hopeless. So yeah I dont need a man tell me I look pretty without Makeup I know that.

[@danh950]

As an adult who grew up with a 'you are a straight boy so no make-up' dad I now love to play with it. Thanks to my therapy (depression) I learned I pushed that side from me out. First just tried some things at home but went out once with just some shadow and mascara under my sunglasses. My inner diva came out and I felt strong (fierce? yeah lets go with fierce) and was just shocked. Now I just do whatever I want, so many people are 'normal' why not be a black sheep and brighten things up. So glad my girlfriend supports me and loves to see me do what I love. Loved the fact that you mentioned the artistry, the confidence and brought up how much positive things make up can bring. The whole scamming thing is just a little bit of fallout in a bright look. You need to be critical with 'Do I realy need this?' but that goes for most things in life.

[@Jo-razz]

I agree, I have fun with makeup. I love to Experiment different looks & colors, it is fun. There are some nights, when I have to relax, I take out what I have & just try different things with it. It's so relaxing for me There is certain makeup techniques I am bad at. There are certain makeup products , I have no idea what it is for & how to use it. With that said, I never felt pressure or bad about myself because I don't know how to do everything you can do with makeup. Lol, my husband never told me to go back & put more makeup on. Side-note- only one thing I will say that stress me out just a little. There is too many products & brands to choose from. I'd rather have that problem than not enough to choose from😉

[@Erana-Quesada]

Yes…for many of us, make up is self care! Thanks Robert. Btw, I love your eye MU in the video. 😍

[@goodenurseV]

Makeup is my ONLY self care. And thank you Robert, for helping me to start creating with it. Love you, Boo. 🖤💜🖤💜🖤💜🖤

[@Persefone94]

Thank you! Thank you! I am 51 and I laugh when people think makeup ”tricks” are recent! Yes, they are on social media now, but for crying out loud! I started wearing eye pencil on my water line in 1982 (aged 11) and used lipgloss to get a dewy face when I was in my early 30ies. Blush has been used to contour forever and I have been putting a radiant silver, gold, pink or lavender ”dot” close to my tear duct since the early 90ies! Many were we that never did the total matte and powdered face, but high lighted our cheek bones with irridescent shadows! We mixed those shadows with Cover Girl foundations and Estee Lauder foundations. We used fake eye lashes (but not the utgly last extension ones trending a few years back that are so obvious it hurts) usually a few on the side of our eyes to get the now so trendy cat eye look. We used smokey eye techniques and fixed our brows. So there. It’s not new for us having been inte makeup since we were pre-teens!

[@jessicaawesome-sauce1268]

Growing up when my mom wore makeup I’d hear my dad say,” where are you going?” Like she had to be using it for a special occasion or have a place to be. I use makeup because it’s fun and it’s a form of creative expression for me. I tell my daughter that we don’t need makeup to be beautiful but if she would choose to use it because it makes her feel good go for it ! Yes that man had a point on what young people are exposed to through media but hopefully they have an adult in their lives to guide them to make their own positive choices for their bodies.

[@blendofdays]

As someone who indeed uses makeup not only for my mental health, but as my form of self expression & a creative outlet, I truly appreciate that you took so much time to touch on that one dudes vid. He definitely made some valid points but the whole "you have to do this, you have to do that" & him just not understanding that makeup is not just for "women" nor do people do it to look better for others? Grated on my nerves! Very old school line of thinking!

[@emmaeriksson7155]

Mina le has a great video on all the celebrity makeupbrands btw with a deeper analytic on why we moved on from celebrity perfumes to celebrity makeup!

[@Vicky-dh9yg]

I love how polite but straightforward you are!! Thank you for the amazing content as always 🥰🥳

[@Starfirahs]

Absolutely love your eye makeup! 😍 Love when you do these videos, definitely thankful for your professional feedback. Hopefully some of the people that watch these hacks come across your channel so they can get real information 🤞 Thank you for the video! Looking forward to the next 😇💕

[@brookley0504]

I loved what you said about people using make up and artistry and mental health. I can tell you that my "me" time is doing my makeup. It's like therapy for me. I love doing it and it's relaxing. Has the makeup industry blown up a bit? YES but also i like that I have so many options to chose from and it allows me to do all kinds of different things. 3 years ago makeup was just something I had to hurry an throw on to cover my red cheeks and under eye bags before I went to work but over the course of being isolated because of covid I really discovered the beauty world on you tube and it turned something that was a pain in my ass every morning into something I couldn't wait to play with everyday. Thank you Robert for always being genuine and honest and keeping makeup a journey for me! ♥

[@ohsobee]

I have been mocked my whole life for wearing makeup. My family members constantly encourage me to not wear make up or to wear less of it but I couldn't be happier putting my makeup on everyday. I enjoy the artistry of it, I find it therapeutic, and I genuinely enjoy the whole process as well as the end result. I hate that so many people are still holding onto the idea that everyone does their makeup for others when makeup is an art and a lot of people just do it for themselves or for the artistry. Also, why do so many people shun others for wearing makeup due to their insecurities, shouldn't we be mad at how unattainable beauty standards are?

[@domsmom88]

You are so right about the self care side of makeup! I don't wear makeup for anyone but myself. In fact my husband tells me I don't need to wear makeup. I am 46 yrs old and I lost 60 lbs in the last year and I am working on feeling good about myself and battling depression. When I am happy with how my makeup looks I just feel better. I am by no means an expert at applying makeup but I am learning at my old age. I don't know if I will ever be ready for contouring. I am also starting to take my skin care more seriously as well. Feeling good about yourself is so important. I love watching you Iearn a lot from you and you and your brothers crack me up!

[@Amber-79]

I used to always use too bright of a concealer and I was basically highlighting my darkness. I thought there wasn’t a concealer pigmented enough to cover the darkness and it really wasn’t as bad as I thought it was either. But then I got a good undertone concealer with a little salmon or a little yellow and whallah!! Magic happened, so it is always good to see people pointing this out for others who struggled with their under eye darkness like I did for so many years.

[@sammiepittman3130]

Robert you should do a make up history series!!!!!! I’d watch that like i’d watch a Netflix murder documentary series. You can do it based on type of product like blush, mascara, highlight ❤️☺️

[@crystalriley7451]

I LOVE your explanation and education in response to that guy who was pretty anti-makeup. I’m in love with makeup because it’s fun to me to design different looks and to have fun with matching it with my outfits. I do it for me, not because of pressure to look a certain way or because a man told me to. I have bipolar depression and days can be really rough for me. Watching your videos though and being inspired by your looks and teaching brings me to a really positive place because now I’m having fun! I really enjoyed this video (and loved loved loved your purple eye look. Purple is the best!!) 😊💜

[@NotAdultingToday]

A possible video idea or maybe a series would be a history of makeup? My ears perked up when you said you are really into the history of it. I think that could be fun for a lot of people. Just the couple of tidbits you shared were interesting.

[@magebabe7613]

I don't know if this is just my personal journey or a shift in the world (honestly I think it's both) but I really have felt a change in the way I view makeup. For reference I'm 31. Growing up as a teen I always felt obligated to wear makeup (foundation) to the point I would not go out without makeup on. Even if it looked like crap, I HAD to cover up my face. Now a good part of that was self consciousness over acne, but it really felt like you needed to cover up to some degree. It lessened a bit as I got older, and the natural look started to become more popular. Then covid hits and I stopped wearing makeup all together. It was incredibly freeing, and my skin was happier. Now I'm starting to incorporate a bit more makeup back into my routine, and it's purely because I want to. It's a little sprinkle of fun to add in more things to enhance myself. It's not obligatory, society isn't pressuring me to buy more makeup. I just now have access to better and better tools and products than we used to have. Makeup isn't a scam, so long as you have the right attitude about it. Of course young girls will always be pressured to look a certain way, but look how much more natural a lot of trends are these days.

[@WhisperingHearts4]

You said everything I was thinking about the makeup scam thing! I agree/disagree with some points he said and you hit every one perfect! Thank you for sticking up for us that do makeup as self expression and for mental health🖤💜

[@brandimunguia]

Tati did that foundation in water hack on her channel and she said it actually made a huge different in the way it performed and looked on the skin overall and she said she would be using that hack again for event days.

[@adafihj6439]

I've been watching the foundation in water thing for a while and I was waiting on your take on this. Hi Robert 👋 👋 👋

[@stormbourbon8379]

Something about this smoky dusky purple really brings out the beautiful brown of your eyes, darling!

[@jsully8076]

The thumbnail you used is killing me. To be so beautiful and self-deprecating is a rare quality indeed. We love you Robert! Sending Good Vibes and love from the states!

[@jenniferherbert5956]

This thumbnail also slayed me. If you can’t laugh at yourself, what are we even doing?

[@christinascheuplein8063]

Please please please do a tutorial on this look you are wearing! Omg it is gorgeous…you are gorgeous! Please share your steps on your eye look! Much love from California 💕

[@jacquelinealbin7712]

As a goth chick, I guarantee that society isn't what encourages me to put on makeup lol. Like, you don't do black lipstick and graphic liner just so you "don't look tired" or what have you.

[@rebeccaxo1218]

I really _really_ love your honest, no BS advice. You don't get that much these days. Plus you're a Brit which makes it 100x better (being a fellow Brit). Also, you have subtitles (I'm deaf in one ear) which makes my day! 🥰

[@shananananara]

Hi Robert! Thanks for the video! I would really appreciate a video about makeup for people with facial scars. I really respect your opinion, so I would love to learn from you. I have heavily scarred skin from teenage acne, and I know people talk about "texture" in videos but I rarely see it actually addressed with its own content. My makeup is so much prettier and more enjoyable since I started following you, but I still struggle with the scarring and pitting. My makeup will look so beautiful, and then the moment the wrong product touches the scars I feel like the Joker.

[@hollidanielgarnett1046]

Definitely contoured and highlighted as a goth kid around the 2000. Just didn't use the word or products made for it. My favorite "highlight" was a white eye shadow from L'oreal. Makeup is accessible to more shades of people and more budgets now.

[@msSweeTae]

I had a long discussion with my mother the other day. She still has this old fashioned view on make up. Women (we specifically talked about women) wear it, because they aren't confident about their looks or because society forces us to wear make up... I feel like a broken record, because I keep telling her that yes, some women may feel like they have to wear make up ot they feel forced, because someone expect them to wear it. But most women wear make up, because THEY want to. I love make up, I love playing with make up even when I don't go anywhere. As Robert said, it's therapeutic, it's art, it's fun! The boyfriend of my cousin is a beautiful example. I told him that I love make up and his reaction was the BEST. It was something like this: "Really?!? The make up in drugstore always makes me want to try everything out! Especially all these beautiful eye shadow palettes." I was quite shocked, which I told him and he then said, that make up is yet another way to express art. He's an artist and he used to be a freelancer for a long time. That's why he understands that not every eyeshadow palette is the same. He acknowledges the difference in colors and quality... he then proudly told me that he used to wear nail polish when he was younger...I hope my cousin keeps him for a looong time. Best family addition, yet xD More straight men and unfortunately women as well need to understand why people love make up.

[@10velyBanana]

I love your comment about using make up for self care and mental health, I do that! I love my eyeshadows and I enjoy doing my make up in the morning - I live with severe chronic pain and I struggle with mental health so for me waking up and getting ready for work is often a challenge (both physically and mentally) but I sit down and get ready, I enjoy experimenting with different make up, it helps me look 'healthy' and helps me feel better (not that I hate myself without it or anything, gotta love yourself haha). I also enjoy watching your videos (and the Twins channel as well) - so relaxing and amazing advice! Thank you, Robert xoxo

[@ananyaneralla5382]

I love how some men think everything we do has to do with them. You thought I beat my face to impress you and your dude bro friends? Aw! How cute!

[@SlothDaan]

I honestly hardly wear make-up, maybe mascara once a month, but I find Roberts video's so calming 😊

[@katymaurer388]

Can you do a series on makeup history? Techniques, cultures, trends, products, etc. That'd be so cool!

[@krystylafloof7537]

I love this idea

[@np-gi6vz]

I definitely get that makeup can be a creative outlet and also empowering for certain people (if you had cancer or if you are gender fluid and feel more comfortable with makeup on). But I'm just going to be honest...I've been insecure and self conscious since I was a little girl and I'm 28 now. I use makeup to "fix" myself (for work mostly). My deep dark undereyes, acne marks, my ethnic nose etc. Playing around with eyeshadows and stuff is fun..and even putting on makeup in the morning can be relaxing..but I use makeup mostly because I think I need to look better.

[@zisgurl]

I stopped wearing makeup for almost 5 years and was totally fine, I picked it back up this year for FUN. I love it now and am doing it for no one but myself. I still wear nothing but lip balm 80% of days and I'm perfectly comfortable. But when I have the time and the inspiration hits I Love to spend time glamming up my face😁