One of Silver's criticisms also applies to the Camp Bighoof mini: When you introduce new characters, GIVE US THEIR NAMES!!!
@vanoskuro-ponyform17149 ай бұрын
As for Tracey being a descendant of the Apple family; I'm still head cannoning the royal family of Zephyr Heights are descended from Flurry Heart (and maybe Pound Cake).
@IDWPublishing9 ай бұрын
Thanks for the love, Silver Quill! ❤ Wait until you see the Seaponies in Set Your Sail! (On sale this April)
@tommoore20129 ай бұрын
Awesome!
@timwoods28529 ай бұрын
Shoo-bee-doo, Shoop, Shoo-bee-doo!
@nightflame3899 ай бұрын
Tracy Tailspin looks like a descendant of Big Mac and Sugar Belle, especially when you see that little foal they have in The Last Problem
@Gamebits_The_Unicorn9 ай бұрын
It's amazing seeing one of the artists from the Sonic Comics also work on MLP, though maybe that's because Sonic and MLP are the only IDW comics I read so far, plus I've fallen behind on the Sonic ones anyway, and I've never known where to start with MLP. when I first got into Sonic IDW comics, MLP IDW had been going on long enough that there's a lot. I try to use the app but while buying them through it is easy, reading these digital versions is a lot harder because the app is .....let's just say less than perfect, so hopefully I see this comic at the bookstore I been buying these from.
@williamcrowe25769 ай бұрын
I might tend to look at the Slammers as something akin to Cobra Kai from The Karate Kid; all about arrogance and reputation. They're sabotaging Sunny's efforts because they want to be the *only* roller derby team in town. We may yet see this to be their downfall as it was with Ms Cinch in Friendship Games.
@8nicopink8689 ай бұрын
I'd loooove to see you talk more about G5, especially the shows. I'd sure you'd bring in a lot more intelligence and good faith critique than a lot of G5's critics have.
@vanoskuro-ponyform17149 ай бұрын
Not sure what the Slammers think they are going to get out of tormenting the girl who can turn into a demigoddess. But its their choice if they want to burn in the flames of... whatever you would call a corrupted Sunny... Nova Starqueen?
@mini22398 ай бұрын
Always thought Vanguard would be a good name, playing on the scout part of Sunny’s name
@vanoskuro-ponyform17148 ай бұрын
@@mini2239 Nova Vanguard. I guess that could work.
@claypigeon70639 ай бұрын
Welcome to 2024, Silver Quill! Sadly, my car got totaled a few days ago, so times have been difficult as of late. Þank you for making my day a little bit lighter. ☺️
@hannahlamagna9 ай бұрын
0:50 g1 😍 0:51 g3.5 newborn cuties 💗g4💕 0:55 g5 💞 2:17 2:22 2:23 thank you for mentioning the other generations because I love them all
@coolkermit95419 ай бұрын
The comic designs of the main six is a bit different from the movie and show but it’s good to see Gen 5 expand into comics like Gen 4
@jetragnarok20758 ай бұрын
Are these comics official and cannon?
@coolkermit95418 ай бұрын
@@jetragnarok2075 I’m not quite sure but I don’t think it’s cannon to the show
@timwoods28529 ай бұрын
Always good to see a Sliver Quill review.
@gren8te3199 ай бұрын
1:07 silver spittin those 300 iq metaphors
@selectordetector65739 ай бұрын
Wow I'm surprised he didn't get hurt in this video in one way or another it really is a new year.^^
@claypigeon70639 ай бұрын
“New Year, new me”, right?
@NobodieZ269 ай бұрын
Cool to see you reviewing comics again.
@autumbreeze11299 ай бұрын
I'd seen images of Tracey Tailspin floating around a little recently, not knowing who she was. Now I do... and I'm definitely going with the headcanon that she's a descendant of AppleDash. As for how the two produced a foal? Well, even ignoring whether it's possible through regular magical means, they ARE friends with Discord, remember? All it would take is him to simply mention the idea of Applejack (I think she'd be the most likely to want to carry the foal, so Dash doesn't have to take too much time off from the Wonderbolts, since they've got plenty of help at the farm thanks to Sugar Belle and her and Big Mac's son (I'm sadly having to decide they chose to have a foal AFTER Granny Smith, Grand Pear and Goldie joined Bright Mac and Pear Buttercup in the afterlife (unless their foal was among the Wonderbolts Dash flew with during The Magic of Friendship Grows)) having a bun in the oven after the two talk about wanting a foal and, poof, AppleDash baby without any questions as to how two mares could produce a foal.
@vanoskuro-ponyform17149 ай бұрын
I'd rather we not have the idea of a baby making magic. There are some fanfics not meant to be in children's stories.
@jonbilgutay29 ай бұрын
Hope to see more of your videos that aren't live streams.
@GreycatRademenes8 ай бұрын
8:30 Suddenly, the sky above Silver's display has split X3>
@RadiantBlazeVA9 ай бұрын
Would love to see you talk more about G5 in general, whether it be Make Your Mark as it has concluded or Tell Your Tale as the new main series for G5. Love your vids!
@davidharrington48289 ай бұрын
When’s your next G4 review coming out? We haven’t had any since aug. 24 2022!
@aztec6139 ай бұрын
Instant Silver Quill video
@Sun_D._Striker9 ай бұрын
I liked the reference you made about vegeta’s “mustache” from dragon ball abridged,
@beng16039 ай бұрын
I had the idea that Tracy might be a descendant of Applejack's from the moment I laid eyes on her. Not by her appearance, by her similar personality. Never got the idea that she might also be descended from Rainbow Dash. Her and AJ's relationship is just a theory as far as we know. Even if they did get together, there's no way they could make babies together. More like Tracy could Big Mac and Sugar Belle's great-great-great-great granddaughter or something.
@snow22679 ай бұрын
Never clicked on a vid faster!
@Rixec29 ай бұрын
An easy thing to do on names is, even if you don't want to do exposition with them, just have name bars underneath the characters to apply that sense of identity. And the Slugger's attitude, which you said you agreed with at the start before they started getting really hostile, reminds me of what Joshscorcher/Commander Firebrand said: You can be right, but wrong at the top of your voice.
@sethcarlow83639 ай бұрын
cool,video,wow.
@hannahlamagna9 ай бұрын
Awesome
@AJPiersonToonParadise9 ай бұрын
Huh. You haven't used that nepotism gag in a while.
@sherminatoranalysis34299 ай бұрын
I’ve missed this
@BrandonCroker9 ай бұрын
Respect for this awesome birb
@codebreaker48669 ай бұрын
Nice.
@BrandonCroker9 ай бұрын
Yay Comics!
@komodrasteel80199 ай бұрын
Sunny Scowl + Fluttershy Stare = Doom us all
@MrMarinus189 ай бұрын
I greatly prefer the static look over the smooth one. The smooth one just looks fake and like bad animation. With static sprites it looks far more natural.
@renamon56589 ай бұрын
I wonder if griffins abd hippogriffs will appear in the g5 comics
@connorthompson83769 ай бұрын
I’d like to request a review of #TheOwlHouse .
@komodrasteel80199 ай бұрын
Gotta go fast
@joelbarraclough66899 ай бұрын
Hey Silver any chance you can do a video on what if the Mane 6 ((with some acception of Starlight)) are secretly metaphorically tied on the 7 Deadly Sins ((here are what I think of like say Twilight = Lust / Rarity = Greed / Rainbow Dash = Pride / Applejack Sloth / Fluttershy = Envy / Pinkie Pie = Gluttony / Starlight Glimmer = Wrath))
@daedric-persona9 ай бұрын
how is Applejack sloth
@joelbarraclough66899 ай бұрын
@@daedric-persona well Applejack is a hard working pony so I'd there was a alternative universe where they embody there deadly sins perspectively Applejack would be lazy and not be able to put energy or effect into anything or help anypony
@RyanPainter9 ай бұрын
Hey Silver, have you ever thought about having your OC reclassified as a griffon? Because we now have hippogriffs in the official mlp universe, and they don't look anything like your OC.
@RaphaelRavenwing9 ай бұрын
Wait, it's been a thousand years since G4, how are you still alive?!
@Longma19 ай бұрын
Well, Elder Flower's ramblings in MYM Ch5 did make us question the timeline yet again, so it's likely been around 200-300 years between generations, though feel free to ignore that in your fanfics. 😅 (Heh, I remember when we first got the implication that that first three seasons of FiM happened within one year.)
@simba3429 ай бұрын
looks like a really good comic.
@mikechicago62009 ай бұрын
Sup 2024, and man im sad MLP G5 is doing bad and now its only TYT and man im not a fan of them!
@callmethecommentcountess93299 ай бұрын
OK
@komodrasteel80199 ай бұрын
blue Pegasus = Valkyrie Pink Earth Pony (aka an Arion) = Griffur Yellow Earth Pony (aka an Arion) = Captain Buck White Pegasus = Cinder Feather
@hidochung78339 ай бұрын
Its nice to see a new silverquill video but having it about g5. Not a good way to start mlp in 2024.