Modern Music's Death By Auto-Tune

[@angelines29]

Its like plastic surgery. Always striving for what we think is perfect, not realizing that the imperfections are what makes us/music/basically anything interesting and unique and real.

[@wokk9543]

nah you have old ears

[@j.m1928]

❤️❤️❤️

[@danielbentley7117]

Plenty of singers can sing perfectly in key without autotune. Using the word "imperfections" sounds like you enjoy out of tune singers.

[@footos8511]

@@danielbentley7117 yes actually. That’s EXACTLY what they mean. Human imperfections, mistakes, are what make music have feel. Why do people double track instruments? For example, why do you double track a guitar? Why not just duplicate the track in your DAW? Because all’s it will do is make it louder, even if you modify certain parts of the copied track, it has no big, grand dangerous feel.

[@danielbentley7117]

@@footos8511 Double tracking doesn't disprove my point. Doing multiple takes actually hides mistakes in timing and pitch because your brain hears the average of all the takes together, instead of the bad notes or phrasing of each individual take. Similar to how a chorus effect works, by shifting the pitch above and below the performance.

[@italianhockeywall]

"The better the singer's voice, the harder it is to believe what they are saying. So I use my faults to an advantage" -David Byrne

[@ragnus78]

68

[@cybrinternational3391]

Nice handle by the way, Sudo! ;)

[@ZodiacEntertainment2]

TAKE A LOOK AT THESE HANDS Byrne's voice is great. Totally gave Talking Heads most of their character.

[@NorthernKitty]

Your pseudonym has the subconscious effect of giving system admins an overwhelming urge to backup all their servers.

[@robdoran1156]

@@NorthernKitty Honour your mistakes as hidden intentions - Brian Eno Oblique Strategy cards

[@RevStickleback]

"The only people who got record deals were people who could perform live" - that's a statement that goes so far beyond just singing.

[@Dayandcounting]

Van Halen with DLR, hold my Whisky. Terrible live band musically speaking.

[@mercaloops]

You can get a record deal as a writer instrumentalist producer or even mixing or mastering engineer

[@levigoldsteinbergowitz7391]

@@Dayandcounting dlr was never about vocal prowess, hes a front man and a showman and fronted the best work VH did, also a decent lyricist, they arent supper deep but its catchy and you can sing along to dozens of his songs which to me is the mark of a good songwriter

[@vegasdad]

@@Dayandcounting Van Hagar was a bad ass live band though. Sammy is simply an amazing singer.

[@Reno_Slim]

@@Dayandcounting I saw Van Halen in 1980 and they were the exact opposite of terrible.

[@theloniouscoltrane3778]

Auto-tune is one of the products of a fast-paced society. Everything is rushed. Music is passion. Creating music requires patience.

[@joejones9520]

no it doesnt! It requires whatever it happens to require at that moment. Hard work and patience doesnt equate great music. It's not like building a house.

[@alangeorgebarstow]

Thelonious Coltrane. Agreed in full. It is also one of the products of a plastic society; one where the average IQ of humans - all over the planet - is halving ever day.

[@Anonymous-mn3td]

@@atta1798 "progress", the word people use to ignore their moral compasses...

[@Anonymous-mn3td]

@@atta1798 There's more than one logical fallacy in that reply - and sadly nothing else. Check yourself before you wreck yourself.

[@Anonymous-mn3td]

@@atta1798 Deflect more, buddy. It's hard to miss just how unhinged you are.

[@RhettShull]

Anytime I’m in a restaurant or a store where they play some generic “pop” playlist, all I can hear is the pitch corrected vocals. There’s lots of modern music made with little or no autotune, but it seems you can’t have a top 40 hit these days without over use of autotune.

[@AndyWarren]

I hear a lot of added vibrato these days as well. Listen to Billy Ray on Old Town Road or a lot of newer Bieber tracks.

[@tamarahhabib]

agreed. also congrats on the verification!!

[@jongarzamx]

Can you give us examples? I haven't heard a wide release record without autotune in 20 years, metal, rap, folk, etc they all have it, noticeably.

[@papo_parra]

oh man, how i hate the overuse and abuse of autotune. just a little bit is fine, but nopes... they put the whole jar of autotune on everything

[@t.sewell1513]

Truth. And it’s a damn shame.

[@ramseyvoicestudio]

"Your imperfections in your playing or your singing is what gives it character." Truer words have never been spoken. As a vocal coach, I'm always amazed at how many of my students come in expecting for AT to solve all their problems. I have to remind them that by the time they get to the studio, it's too late to become a good singer. That AT should be a LAST resort, not the first move you make. Not only because you'll have to hold your voice together live, but as you mentioned, pitch correcting takes away what makes you sound like you. Great video my friend! Keep it up!!!

[@neilmeadowcroft7569]

My playing has lots of character. 😄

[@jtollefson1973]

Check out any Motown recording to feel what humans were doing on the level. …or Kind of Blue…in three recording sessions of probably 9-10 hours total. Daft Punk is cool too, but a different creative approach as mentioned.

[@barrywerdell2614]

Early painters used to purposely put flaws in their paintings because only God is perfect.

[@Timliu92]

@@barrywerdell2614 Word mate.

[@ke6igz]

Even most popular music is void of real people playing real instruments. With midi you can quantize and go back and correct notes.

[@marshsundeen]

When Believe came out, it was considered a cool effect that gave the song a dance music vibe. Everyone knew Cher could sing. Now while some use auto-tune for effect, others use it as a crutch for poor vocal skills.

[@toddbernstein3407]

Bon Iver is another example of someone who can really sing, but has used Autotune as a cool effect.

[@Durwood71]

The thing with Cher is that they didn't try to hide the fact that it was a vocal effect, and it really made her clean voice pop in the chorus. The way Autotune is used today, they essentially try to trick the listener into thinking the performer is a perfect signer.

[@amtlpaul]

yes, on "Believe" it was an effect, much like the vocoder was in the 1970s and 1980s

[@calliopeshif7581]

@@toddbernstein3407 yessss!! The song "Woods" on the early Blood Bank EP is actually one of my favorite examples of this!!

[@marshsundeen]

@@toddbernstein3407 same with Billie Eilish.

[@MartyKeil]

My favorite use of Autotune is as a sort of vocal assistant. I recorded a vocalist who had trouble with pitches. I took the first take, and autotuned the heck out of it. Then recorded a vocal take using the tuned track as sort of a guide for the vocalist. Afterwards, muted the tuned track, and the second track without autotune is perfectly acceptable. I find that even I can sing better with my own voice as a pitch reference.

[@heliboy8762]

I would suggest that someone who can't sing on pitch when required is not really a vocalist.

[@MartyKeil]

@@cjay2 The vocalist is a good friend who used to be a fantastic vocalist and entertainer, but due to a series of tragedies and health issues, needs help and a confidence boost. Just trying to help.

[@jean-lucbersou758]

A " VOCALIST who had trouble with pitches " ....HAD TO STOP and shut up .!!!!!

[@Joetime90]

I can see it being a good tool for learning. I play bass but can't sing, but wanna find my voice more or less.

[@eltemplariodetierrasanta7234]

@@jean-lucbersou758 Stfu dude, read his other comments before spouting nonsense.

[@aquadime3336]

Everything we call ‘character’ is the deviation from perfection. So perfection to me is characterlessness. - Brian Eno

[@treetopjones737]

If you make a mistake, do something creative with it. - Eno

[@screamingjefferson]

My daughter and I were listening to a teen pop "artist" (used to date Justin Bieber) several years ago and she said to me that she wished she could sing like that. I told her, "So does she".

[@Reno_Slim]

@@hal2098 I think you meant he doesn't understand soul sucking overproduction.

[@KnivingDispodia]

Breaking news: local man thinks he’s super cool for dunking on his child daughter.

[@mhm3766]

@@KnivingDispodia it's only dunking if you ignore the fact that she can totally sing and autotune is mostly just an effect

[@NotJoegoldberg]

I mean u are right lol. Selena Gomez is a very average singer, her live performances are trash.

[@intensi_t]

​@@hal2098 this comment section is full of bitter failed musicians looking to blame someone for why they haven't made it

[@ricktrenkler3254]

I miss harmonies in music. People like The Beach Boys, CSN or the Beatles. Beautiful stuff when people work together to make a sound.

[@eallison9]

Fleet Foxes first EP and album is probably the best harmonies I’ve heard in recent years.

[@brushstroke3733]

Have you discovered Larkin Poe yet?

[@DirkvanBoxtel]

It's part of why groups like System of a Down worked for me :)

[@MattMcConaha]

I was under the impression that most modern vocals were layered and harmonized. Something like the beach boys might have more acapella style harmonization with the addition of instrumentation, which isn't a typical modern sound. But just because most vocals aren't harmonized in that style doesn't mean they aren't harmonized. It's usually done subtly where you mostly hear the main melody and there's just some extra layers to fill it out.

[@defoperator7993]

Most people can’t understand the harmony of the spheres they just want a marching beat to help them mindlessly grind through the day back then people with money and taste actually had the sense to invest in actually masterful interesting music but now it’s just corporate bottom lines no extra money for experimenting with a risky band

[@sara505sings]

How did I manage to stumble upon this genius? Rick, how do you even sleep at night with all of that knowledge in your brain? The names, the words, the vocabulary, the theory, the notes, the chords, the genres. Amazing.

[@heysolley]

If we could save people's brains in a jar to keep their knowledge, Rick's brain would be one I would choose.

[@sara505sings]

@@heysolley not if I get to it first

[@heysolley]

@@sara505sings : That sounds like a challenge LoL

[@dharma404_]

@@heysolley No need to save it in a jar, Rick is sharing it openly here for everyone's benefit :)

[@Flippokid]

I'm not against autotune, I'm against people getting famous because autotune will compensate for their lack or absense of talent.

[@stepankrikava5449]

Excellent comment

[@danielj26]

They got famous because the fans like the sound. If they didn't they wouldn't get famous. Hate the fans not the artist.

[@Flippokid]

@@danielj26 No I hate both.

[@danielj26]

@@Flippokid I'm saying you are the minority or they wouldn't be top 40. You also hate Hollywood makeup and driving cars instead of horses too?

[@ahmadmasood4148]

You can have talent and still use autotune, there are many aspects of music that aren't vocals. People who usually use autotune as a tool in electronic or ambient music still have talent.

[@JC-rb3hj]

Amen, say it again. When I go out shopping or to dinner with my wife I can hear this stuff being played constantly. It's like having a rash that won't go away.

[@guitarado]

yeah, hard to avoid that crap. only headphones or earplugs

[@flowoodpiano717]

And here's where we acknowledge that Neil Peart was more than a drummer and lyricist - he was a prophet. "All this machinery making modern music can still be open-hearted. Not so fully charted, it's really just a question of your honesty."

[@nicholashylton6857]

Can't go wrong with Rush. The lyrics of "The Spirit of Radio" re. the music industry, ring true to this day.

[@grogueQ]

coldly

[@flowoodpiano717]

@@camk6566 The way I interpret NP, he's saying studio technology is a good thing when used to enhance creativity, but it's a bad thing when it's used as a substitute for talent and skill -- 15+ years before AutoTune existed.

[@RJs_CC]

Great side note. Indeed. Neil was possibly as good A LYRISIST as he was a DRUMMER. Wait a second … Is that even possible?? Mind-blowing talent, that's it. I think.

[@Islander2112]

From the same album: "Computerized clinics, for superior cynics, who dance to a synthetic band. In their own image, their world is fashioned; no wonder they don't understand" ~Natural Science

[@areallemone]

This isn't only informative, it's also entertaining. Great storyteller, and teacher. Keep it up, Rick! Cheers

[@baldpaulstudios7023]

Hey Rick, I'm a 35 year musician and now recording/mixing in my own small studio. I learn something new, something I'm doing wrong or something I could be doing better in almost every video you make. I appreciate you!

[@RadCenter]

I sing with two choral groups, and the amount of effort we spend perfecting our pitches is considerable (think 30 hours of rehearsal for a 90-minute concert). Ans we're not even soloists! If I were a recording artist, I wouldn't be able to respect myself if I didn't put at least that much rehearsal in before a recording session. Pitch problems are caused by one of two things: a weak ear or a weak work ethic.

[@TheLinuxYes]

i'm always in perfect pitch in the shower with all that water and echo effect. giggle

[@hounsdjentlow3074]

@@lovemusic324 young musician and producer, some of us still practice ❤

[@stephenadamsmusicalinterpr4203]

Preach

[@AdAstraCan]

Yes, pre-COVID I sang with a symphony choir and we probably put in a similar amount or more in terms of rehearsal time together, not counting self-practise at a piano and with sound files. I also took over a hundred lessons with a voice coach before I auditioned. The upside is that I learned how to sing and appreciate great singers (I have even more appreciation for the Beatles now - or contemporary singers like The Good Lovelies) but the downside is that autotune and poor pop singers bother me even more.

[@hounsdjentlow3074]

@@AdAstraCan yeah -_- that tends to happen :/

[@Julian-yd5uk]

There's something about hearing an artist straining for a note and then finally reaching it that gives me goosebumps

[@MrFusion]

That's what I love about singing. If it's a really hard note, like a Bb4 and up, getting that note is so satisfying for me because of how much work I had to put into getting it. Autotune just kills any satisfaction in singing.

[@BigHenFor]

Not strain, reaching for it. Straining for a note means poor technique which will damage the vocal cords. One of the singing technique channels does a series on how the voices of singers like Mariah and Whitney for example, changed over time. Both of them did damage to their voices - Mariah through bad technique and Whitney through her addictions, and even they started to strain. So, straining is a sign something's not right.

[@PFDarkside]

One… twenty one GUNS! Oh, not like that.

[@johngavin1175]

A good example would be Judas Priest and Iron Maiden for the metal genre. There are instances in their songs where the singers are doing as you described. Its awesome.

[@Dana-wq5tp]

I was the lead vocalist of a band back in the 80's and all I had at my disposal was simple reverb. If you sucked as a singer, reverb was not going to save you. You either had the ability or you didn't. I miss those days.

[@Weyland_Yutani_Corp]

Just makes me appreciate Karen Carpenter all the more -- she had such a beautiful and angelic voice that was naturally breathtaking and way before autotune.

[@SteveBonario]

I adore Karen Carpenter. One of the most naturally pitch-perfect singers ever to live. But even she and Richard weren't immune to the desire to make choruses pitch perfect (and thus "small"). If you compare their early 1970s multi-track vocals (Close to You or Rainy Days and Mondays, for example) with their latter work (Good Old Dreams, Touch Me When We're Dancing), the earlier recordings are warmer, richer, fuller, deeper, and bigger. The later songs (which I still enjoy) sound thinner and smaller and "airy" -- not just because Karen's voice changed a bit and she was using her upper register more (or head voice) -- but because Richard was overlaying only the most pitch-perfect of overdub tracks, robbing them of the slight variations that made them sound more natural and bigger.

[@fearitselfpinball8912]

I always sing along with as much psychic sincerity as I can muster with calling occupants. I'd like to make 'a contact' with them but still nothing.

[@wolf335599]

Absolutely. And Olivia Newton John is the other one, perfect pitch.

[@fullclipaudio]

@@SteveBonario She played the drums on those early albums. Singing was secondary to her drumming and it was these later albums where they forced her to just sing and that is why they are weak.

[@TheLinuxYes]

her voice had real depth to it. she didn't have to force anything to sound good. no adorning with her singing. natural

[@Kipperbob]

Quantized drums are a real peave of mine, I started playing drums by learning Hendrix tunes, tempo variation to me is just as important as pitch variation for adding emotions to the music.

[@EphemeralTao]

All forms of quantization strip the real organic humanity from music.

[@mustakahmed9094]

@@EphemeralTao exactly they just lack that human touch

[@jerkerjansson386]

Absolutely! I thought about this a few weeks ago when I listened to Deep Purple's Fireball record. Would it sound as good if it was recorded with a click and locked to a grid? Hell no!

[@brushstroke3733]

I had a friend who used to scream at me for not playing like a metronome all the time. He was a lifeless soul.

[@ryanmalin]

@@brushstroke3733 sounds like it. Real bands dont stay perfectly in time 100% of the time.

[@jordel2010]

As one youtuber once put it about the overuse of CGI in flims: "Convenience devolved into laziness". This is yet another case of that.

[@jeremybean-hodges6397]

Yes! The major issue I have with autotune is that it allows singers to get away with being ordinary and not actually practice.

[@doctordong8088]

"You may not have noticed... *but your brain did* "

[@rumpvirus7393]

However, the lenny song is one of the best mix downs ever. Part of getting a mix to blow everything away is compression without destruction of the highs and mids so natural compression or in that Case compressing the background vocals to focus the lead is brilliant. The real-time compression unit reacts after the fact no matter how fast it starts pulling back its not before the do do happened with attenuation. That auto tune is a form of frequency band compression rather than volume compression. Cher used that effect appropriately for her purpose. There is no such thing as cheating... just if its in your face all the time. Im sure they did multiple tracks to thicken it again in chers case the engineer doesnt want you to put your finger on what's going on. Its just weird is a good thing. I'm sure do whop whop was ok on the first record too except in the Italian district. Ten years later, it was grounds for assault. There are a few things that make you want to kick the radio... auto tune is one, but its usually in combination with fake falsetto some dude who got it from the Stinkin Lincoln Continental Americaz got talent ? Then there is the warm up vocal sort of fake tape echo chant nobody used until someone made the judges cry, then everything music copy frenzy started swirling around the drain. No, it didn't sound like that and he had a better writer and that fad wasn't a fad only singers who havent worked with a band much. You don't need to sing heart attack yak yak yak. I think that was Billy Joels first over use of slap back on vocals and we can let it slide, it may have even been an effects unit. Im not as curious as Rick. However the recent trend is... Wow, you were in a small room and then suddenly you are in a Fake cave and can't afford an effects processor. My other problem is cover tunes that are worse than the original. Why ? Elton John doesn't need your help. You are reading the milk carton wrong.

[@KawaiiCat2]

As someone who worried in vfx and film, half of the time they just go..post will take care of it.. post can’t fix everything. It can but it’ll look somewhat fake. Do it well live. I was taught in film school, production is for making the shot and getting things right and post is for making the creative stuff you can’t do in real life. Not a bandaid for production’s laziness or mistakes. Although sometimes it is needed due to unforced circumstances but can’t be used as a crutch everytime.

[@jordel2010]

@@KawaiiCat2 True words indeed. I've been there as well, the "we'll fix it on post" approach to things some have 🙄

[@WickedScott]

I was amazed recently to discover that many young people can't hear it. I was complaining that everyone sounded like robots and they have no idea what I meant.

[@blueg8731]

Shocking and yet... not surprising.

[@rikpeol3612]

It's like extreme face lifting to the point of deformed ugliness.

[@gregriddle3042]

Perfect description!

[@renejean2523]

Are we talking about Cher again?

[@leonbusjes5794]

@@renejean2523 :-)

[@m.c.ruckus2032]

...& with that, Michael Jackson was guilty of both- he used plenty of "auto-tune" for his sound AND look. Some instances more obvious than others.

[@patdickenson1793]

@@m.c.ruckus2032 I think back to all of the big MJ hits - I don't think they used AT on them? Now I definitely think his face had a-lot of auto something.

[@ryanhallwrites]

"...when I do my video on Bohemian Rhapsody." That's a WMTSG I've been waiting on for a long time.

[@micheleparker8123]

YES!!! I loved that slip...

[@mark314158]

Music Co. Rights Holder: "When hell freezes over ..."

[@GreyMatterStew]

@@Markothunder Oh that would be loverly... May seems a decent fellow. He 'May' be up for it. See what I did there? 😊

[@ryanhallwrites]

I figured Pink Floyd would be an instant block. We shall see.

[@testodude]

@@ryanhallwrites Pink Floyd demonitizes, but does not block. They want that cheddar.

[@johnplunkett2004]

Don't get me started on "Fly Away." The lyrics read like poetry from 12 year old school girl: "I wish that I could fly, into the sky, so very high, just like a dragonfly." You know it's bad when the best lyrics are: "oh, oh, oh yeah!"

[@rumblehat4357]

Those lyrics are awful. I would have been embarrassed by them. They sound like temp lyrics.

[@lulimas]

Everything in this song sounds so derivative yet i still like it

[@ricardojorgeproenca]

@@rumblehat4357 who cares man, he is a successful artist and millionaire, he just don't fkn care for others opinion or whatever.

[@LCA84]

This is something only native english speakers notice. To a foreign non-anglophone audience, these primitive rhyme and the no-rhyme get away/fly away sounds pretty natural - and I say that as a portuguese native speaker. However, these first verses are really annoying to anyone with a basic comprehension of english.

[@rumblehat4357]

Ricardo Proença true, he probably doesn’t care but it’s amazing what Hollywood connections can do for people.

[@davidanderson4091]

Rick. You commented that the slight imperfections in someone's voice gives it the character that makes it almost unique to them. Recently I commented on the video of another music analyst KZbinr (Wings of Pegasus). He was comparing the waveforms of Karen Carpenter's vocals from both a Live version and a recorded version of _"Close to You"_ (of course, no autotune in 1971!). It was fascinating to see how close she gets Live to the way she sang it on the studio album. They were similar, but the waveforms don't lie, and they are proof to debunk those who say Karen mimed or lip-synced and never actually sang Live. The waveforms also made it clear that she almost always sang her vibrato ever so slightly flat - I wonder whether that flatness is what gave her voice the characteristic sound that you immediately recognize as Karen the instant you hear it.

[@CindyBarg]

Someone I know would say that she sings "blue", which I love and is an art in itself.

[@pysgodfish]

Love this Rick. As a vocal coach,and producer, I get them to sing it right. My mantra….our vocal imperfections, make it sound perfect

[@Nobddy]

Just listen to William Hung

[@ke6igz]

Music is a human expression. It's not supposed to be perfect. Perfect is void of the human aspect of musical expression

[@ryo-kai8587]

I've said for a while now that "nothing is perfect, but moments can be" This applies to music as well - the performance, timing and pitch may not be perfect, but the synergy, feel, and experience of the moment it creates can be perceived as perfect and profound.

[@Nobddy]

@@ryo-kai8587 very true. Great insight.

[@MrStupidHead]

Sure teach them to sing it right. Thats what vocal coaches do. That is what they get paid for. But when you are in the studio, and the clock is ticking, engineers get paid to bring in great tracks. The NOW sound. Autotune it Baby! Got bills to pay.

[@daf827]

Adam Levine is Mr Autotune. And to think he coached singers on “The Voice.” Rick, I share your sentiments about Maroon 5.

[@prabhatgautam7888]

Adam Levine is actually a weak vocalist, and what's worse is that ge has got shitty musicality and goes off the pitch often. Contrary to someone say the lead vocalists of the beatles who were actually weak vocalists as a whole, but they had excellent musicality and great projection. (edit: sry for my English)

[@realasadoughnut]

I honestly would be the last guy to defend Adam Lavine. But when I heard his cover of "Seasons" which is one of my favorite songs by my favorite singer C.Cornell , I was sold and convinced the dude can sing.

[@colintraveller]

Crap band ... Everything they released is and was Crap ..

[@itsme9679]

Wait he coached ? I don’t think he can even sing a complete song without auto tune. It’s 100% because he is popular that he coached in my opinion, for the marketing

[@sbeve6559]

@@realasadoughnut Yes. It's all about the type of song he is singing. He has the perfect voice for soulful jazzy types of songs. But the high power belted pop songs are not suited to him unfortunately.

[@glengamble526]

I remember doing sessions and band recordings in the late 90’s-early 2000’s where AutoTune was used as intended: to clean up one or two notes in an otherwise stellar vocal take. The singer would nail the part, or section, but one or two notes were off-so you go in and fix the little mistake to not lose a great performance. This is what it was basically meant for…not to be a crutch for bad singers! As with most tech developments, it became abused and taken out of its context. The sad part is, it’s completely changed (destroyed?) modern music.

[@Alpha_7227]

Lazyness on the part of producers, just seeking attractive people to make an image with no talent let alone musical or singing ability. eg K-Pop, and most music on the charts at the minute.

[@Alpha_7227]

@@IncredibleGoliath Massive time saver, ie lets make some money. What about making music that means something, that will stand the test of time - that is art.

[@ofdrumsandchords]

And now, a lot of drummers play with a click during concerts. No more problems of tempo, they don't need to listen to the other musicians. That also is taken out of context, I understand you do that for a recording, or in a show with many things happening, but to play with a band ?

[@deltab9768]

Of course, once it becomes an accepted option to edit one or two bad notes, now the competition is on. Who can have the most perfectly tuned recording? Who can do it fastest and cheapest? Before you know it, you're not even sure which artists are actually good singers, especially since it works on live performances in real time.

[@Alpha_7227]

@@deltab9768 Unless it's used as an effect like a vocoder, sparingly it's B.S. Now that I think of it, there is one recording of K.D Lang where she struggles to hit the note on record. On a compilation it was fine. They must have cleaned it up. I appreciate the rawness, fraility of the first recording.

[@JohnnyRedvers]

I always viewed Auto-Tune as like athletes using PEDs. Also, it takes uniqueness away from what made artists special in the past. I don't think someone like Bowie or Sting would be able to make it these days because of the push for "perfect" voices by producers and labels, yet Bowie and Sting were amazing. These "perfect" voices are uninteresting. Live music used to blow me away. Not so much anymore because of auto-tune. I know someone who auditioned for The Voice. She had a beautiful unique voice but was told by a producer "no thank you, but we're just looking for certain types of voice". And pretty much all we end up with are carbon copies that can be "perfected" with auto-tune. maybe that's why it's hard to tell the difference between modern artists. Just my point of view.

[@edwarddejong8025]

I was watching a clip about Doris Day, and because she was so well trained singing with a big band as a very young woman, when she had a solo recording career almost all of her songs were done in 1 take.

[@RaymondHng]

Same think with Karen "One Take" Carpenter.

[@EK-gr9gd]

The same with A. Franklin etc..

[@Leftatalbuquerque]

Same with Donna Summer.

[@christopher8116]

She was insane in another way.

[@zarlok5294]

Imagine auto tuning Elvis, Jerry Lee, Chuck Berry, The Temptations, The Supremes, Aretha, Frank Sinatra, The Beatles, the Eagles, or Celine. Auto tune? Nah! It’s just another step towards soulless emptiness in my worthless opinion. I’m just a fossil. I grew up in the fifties when singers could sing or they didn’t make records so what would I know about good music? Oh!!’ Sorry! I used the “G” word. How pretentiously judgemental of me. Don’t worry though young folks. My generation will soon disappear into oblivion along with our antiquated values and the world we destroyed with our disgusting meritocratic tyranny and you’ll all be truly “free” to soar to new heights of “inclusivity”.

[@KerTon4]

Rick: "you want it to be out of tune a bit". Me: "my time has come"

[@karashimaoficial]

LOL

[@geoffrey4513]

I feel ya brother

[@maddruid840]

I've trained my whole life for this...

[@DarrenMiddletonMusic]

Ha!!!!

[@fallinginthed33p]

50 cents is still fixable, a few dollars isn't.

[@bopeep8205]

"So what did people used to do before auto-tune? Well, they would sing it until they got it right." Such a simple, grand observation.

[@larrylindgren9484]

It was easier to because most of them could sing. Today when you can't sing. It wouldn't matter if you sang it a million times it would be bad. So you have to look they get the machine behind you and write your music and auto tune your terrible vocals.

[@john-zwaan]

Freddie Mercury was capable of double tracking his vocals so perfectly that it started to fase/chorus. Brian talks about that during an interview.

[@notaspeck6104]

He's a great example of an amazing vocalist with great accuracy who still had tons of imperfections. To me imperfections add character and aren't always a bad thing. If singers like Freddie didn't try cover their imperfections up I don't see why the industry nowadays wants to.

[@blueg8731]

Because he didn't cheat. He was a true artist, a genuine singer. He did the hard work and it paid off.

[@christiaanrabie6508]

Alanis Moresette's Jagged Little Pill album is a great example of great vocals. The imperfections gives it character.

[@grumpymechanic2692]

The imperfections and her anger made that a great album... And maybe some Chili Peppers...

[@megatop412]

Excellent example. I wasn't a fan of it but man, could she sing

[@shayxtreme]

I had this album when first released but I cant stand her voice anymore. Does she sing awesome? Yes and the music arrangement is good. But I cant change the song quick enough now when it comes on. Lol

[@shayxtreme]

Adam Levine music is awful

[@michaelhignight1239]

You are preaching to the Choir!!!!!!!!!!!Alanis the best

[@Zack-xv2yc]

To me, AT is *only* great when it's intention of usage is to actually sound inhuman, not just to "make your voice better". It's kinda like the difference between an acoustic and an electric guitar. We don't say that an electric guitar sounds like a distorted acoustic because that's not the point. Both don't sound "better or worse", they just produce entirely different sounds.

[@MyMotherTheCar]

Auto-tune is also great when you have one or two bad notes in an otherwise killer vocal take.

[@hillie47]

@Taezakny They can also be very distracting. You can still keep the uniqueness by just lifting it a little closer to pitch, instead of "snap to grid" of course. It obviously depends on how bad these "bad notes" really are and how detrimental they are to the performance. If it adds character, I agree, keep it.

[@hillie47]

@Taezakny Yeah, I don't think one should iron out every tiny unevenness and make it sound smooth and fully unnatural, but just patching up a mistake or two, I don't see a big issue there.

[@neofox2526]

I agree. just look at hyperpop

[@UnchainedEruption]

Still sounds awful even as an effect to my ears. And I love distortion, fuzz, synthesizers, vocoders, you name it. But this isn’t an effect. It just sounds horrible.

[@unaphiliated5090]

When the producer told Neil Young that he was a bit flat on one of those charity songs, he just said "That's my style man".

[@deanjonasson6776]

Not surprisingly, that producer was David Foster and it's on the "making of" video for "Tears Are Not Enough". Classic moment. The same video also has another sequence where Foster makes Anne Murray sing her part over and over again. She finally says something like, "I think I got it on the first take, David." He later admits she was correct.

[@lexusls4305]

@@deanjonasson6776 Foster is an ass. I was at a songwriting workshop where he said, without irony, that you should take the chorus and make that the verse and write an even better chorus - and then replace that verse with your new chorus and write an even better chorus. The circular, endless and ultimately useless logic in that escaped him.

[@kolumbijcan]

@@lexusls4305 sounds like an interesting technique, to make better song, but for me personally, i often get a good verse and then making even better chorus is hard work, or long time waiting for idea to come by itself. but then usually the chorus is too good to be used as verse and it wouldn't work as a verse. guess every songwriter has their techniques

[@rodschmidt8952]

"Artists don't make mistakes, they make choices"

[@CindyBarg]

Omg... the first thing that happened when I clicked play was a horrid commercial came blasting out volume 11 straight away a perfect example of the auto tune that has, indeed, killed the soul out of modern music. Great episode Rick, as a session vocalist I have never needed auto-tune and am not interested to use it in my own productions.

[@nicholashylton6857]

I was just listening to Queen's, "Love of My Life" on KZbin. A gentle and romantic ballad with Freddie and Brian on his 12 string guitar... And then it was immediately followed by a commercial with a uber-loud, crazily AutoTuned version of "Jingle Bells." The dissonance was jarring! (Did KZbin just give me 'the finger' or something?)

[@CindyBarg]

That stuff is offensively rampant.

[@electric7487]

And this is one of the reasons why I absolutely refuse to ever turn off uBlock Origin on KZbin.

[@djee02]

I want to see more of that black haired Rick Beato interview!

[@OhNoNotAgain42]

Yes! I can’t believe that none of the other comments mentioned that!

[@crazierthan-u7571]

Me too!

[@Jbv236]

Rick, I’m 22 and grew up so entrenched in the pop auto-tune world that I barely knew a charting song WITHOUT auto tune. Your video has made me realize how much it is used as a crutch, in my opinion, at the expense of a sincere and real sounding vocal! I hope as a culture we can get back to a point where we can have great music that doesn’t involve the excessive use of auto tune! 🤘😃

[@TheSilverGate]

If you want to detox go check Superstar by The Carpenters, Karen had the voice of an angel

[@danielschaeffer1294]

Start checking out the many “first listening” channels. They’re a blast! There are plenty of people in your age bracket who are just discovering the classic tunes from the fifties through the nineties. It’s especially fun if the listeners are black, have been raised on rap, and just figuring out what The Beach Boys could do with close harmony on “Don’t Worry Baby.” Or for that matter watching SRV’s fingers while playing “Voodoo Child” at El Mocambo. Good hunting!

[@mvp019]

Good for you - if music has a chance to "recover", it will be because of young people like yourself realizing that there is an organic quality to music that touches peoples' souls and striving for that sort of natural excellence. Good luck to you.

[@jimh3267]

@@TheSilverGate easily one of the best ever in pop.

[@johnmqueripel2367]

If you want to hear an astonishing natural voice go listen to some Elvis studio recordings, they kept going till it was 'right'

[@clemcadiddlehopper5706]

Plays himself singing: “Terrible right?” My favorite Rick is self deprecating Rick.

[@BillPeschel]

I laughed when he cut himself off on the second track.

[@fl00d69]

My favourite Rick is Pickle Rick.

[@MrReasonabubble]

I don't know whether Rick got himself some vocal coaching, but I would say his singing has improved a lot in the time that he's had this channel. In his early videos, I did think it a shame that such a talented multi-instrumentalist had such a terrible voice - but in the more recent ones I'd describe his singing as, at worst, 'average'.

[@stevesloan5935]

Rick, you articulated the state of auto-tune very well. I'll personally take the Freddie Mercury, Joni Mitchell vocals every time.

[@htb4611]

Steve Perry harmonizes with himself on "When the lights go down in the city" by journey. His pitch is so spot on that it SOUNDS autotuned, but it's not. He is just that good.

[@trillrifaxegrindor4411]

one of the best,period

[@AnimatedSquirrel]

Cool that you mention Steve Perry...when Rick was talking about the three part harmonies and the variations of them I had to stop the video and play "Girl Can't Help It." (The live one from 1986) The acapella harmony at the end is just that freakin' good. :D (Aw heck, the whole song rocks. XD)

[@davidmarles9409]

Autotune didn't exist until 1997.

[@Panglos]

Auto-tune exhibits a characteristic robotic sound that vocal double-tracking (including Steve Perry’s) does not, and cannot, have.

[@Geezer-yf8hv]

Didn’t they use some device in the late ‘70s - ‘80s called “vocal harmonizers”? Usually for the back-up vocals? I could swear that Journey and Van Halen used it for the back-up vocals, (Especially like on Journey’s “Feelin’ That Way/Anyway That You Want It”).

[@timothydaniels504]

I remember watching a video of the making of We Are The World. David Foster, producing the record, cuts in and tells Neil Young that he’s kind of off pitch, to which Neil replies, “that’s my thing man”.

[@steveclements5783]

That was "Tears Are Not Enough", the Canadian version of We are the World. But yeah, Neil just doesn't compromise!

[@mupicap7927]

Lol

[@Maltloaflegrande]

"A man needs a maid" is pretty near the knuckle but then again, he can sing alongside CSN and fit in perfectly. Then again, check out "Don't be denied" where his harmony singers are Ben Keith and Jack Nitzsche - hardly the world's best sets of pipes - and yet it really works.

[@dave2132]

"Sounds small." Dude, that is a perfect description.

[@kunipeg8706]

More like "sounds thin"

[@Niccks]

Small pipì

[@khersy]

I was just think about that lol

[@leomilani_gtr]

Also sounds silly

[@bobbrown5951]

Rick, so happy I came across this video to hear about this topic from a true professional. I absolutely hate auto-tune and I think there are way too many no talent singers out there making millions when I've seen better vocalists in bars pulling in a couple of hundred dollars a night. A couple of years ago I tuned into one of the award shows where one of the opening acts came out, sat down on a step and started to sing. It was auto-tuned to death. And I believe he was up for an award. It was embarrassing and I changed the channel. Years ago Leonard Cohen won a Juno award (sort of a Canadian Grammy) and he joked that only in Canada could a guy with his voice win an award for singing. He knew he wasn't perfect but that's what made him so interesting. Love your channel.

[@jimclarke8260]

I went to a live concert last weekend with no auto-tune. It was perfectly not absolutely perfect and filled my soul with joy!

[@Dlazybeatbox]

yes, the perfect imperfections!

[@chuckcrunch1]

i went to a club gig and the singer was using some kind of auto tune/ harmonizer .sounded perfectly boring

[@lbr7897]

@@l.t.w8985 REO is a lot of fun live! I saw them before Covid.

[@ronbryant2905]

As a working musician, I've had venue owner's or staff ask me to let a friend/relative sing, and am always assured that they are very good. They then get on stage and sound horrible and then sometimes they will turn to me and say "turn the autotune up" it sounds bad.. "I don't have autotune sister girl. I've been singing all night! Get the hell off my stage!" Very few modern singers can actually sing... Sadly there are very few Steve Perry's out there.

[@robinvegas4367]

I always felt that Steve Perry was the result of a studio doing what studios do. Man was I wrong. When I saw that guy live it was unbelievable. You know someone else who gets left out is Steve Walsh of Kansas. His live performances (before he smoked and coked himself out) were just incredible.

[@daro9582]

How did Freddie Mercury tune his vocals? He went into the studio day after day, week after week for months, that’s how it’s done

[@tabularasa0606]

Hard work and passion.

[@footos8511]

Instead of pressing a couple buttons on a computer, he poured time and effort into training his ears and mind to pitch, to understand, but not to rely upon what’s at his fingertips, to learn and not to be done. To sing, and not to be sung.

[@chuckrogers5077]

In live shows, Queen used Eventide Vocal Harmonizers. I don't know what they did in the studio, probably just multitrack.

[@footos8511]

@@darkprose that’s not auto tune or pitch correct, thats dozens of takes until you get the right one. Pitch correction wasn’t available in the 70’s and 80’s

[@benkleschinsky]

The amazing part is we have digital recording now. Back in the day they had tape and limited resources. Today we can literally take as many takes as we want and it's easier than ever to hit the record button. Yet it's made us lazier.

[@fedortrofimovich9192]

Rick, honestly, it is a blessing having such a channel on KZbin! You speak out what we - true music lovers - always thought))

[@Terraceview]

@@PureHoney_ASMR Nonsense.

[@alexbowman7582]

It’s just a pity they don’t have an auto talent effect.

[@orlock20]

That's what session singers and musicians are for.

[@stylis666]

@@orlock20 LOL XD I laughed way too hard at that XD

[@conan5885]

Bahahahahaahaha.... 😂🤣 That was bloody brilliant mate... 👍

[@Matt_Houlihan]

ROFL

[@58BURST]

You have obviously never seen the Boss brand "talent simulator" pedal for guitarists! 😂

[@allendean9807]

This video takes me back to Steve Perry..... his imperfections WERE perfection.... I am anti auto tune. Enjoy the rough edges.....

[@Gargvarr]

I remember hearing the Cher song for the first time and thinking it couldn't get worse. How wrong was I?!

[@BTheBlindRef]

I like that song just fine. Cher can sing great in pitch. Listen to her old stuff. She is spot-on. On Believe it was done simply for effect, not because Cher needed to have her intonation faked. The problem was when it became the new cure-all for everything rather than an occasional creative tool.

[@SyntheticFuture]

T-Pain be like: hold my beer

[@Ryan-kc5pl]

They played that damn song constantly on the radio. Like everyday going to school it would be on the radio. Same with coming home, lol

[@corychang3901]

This is so true, though I couldn't quite figure out how to explain it to people. I used to play fretless bass slightly sharp during fills to make the licks pop out over the guitars and keys (which I discovered you can do on accident because my intonation wasn't always spot on). Thank you Rick, for always encouraging musicians to be themselves and play the best you can be!

[@KeyOfGeebz]

Man, I love this channel! "Your imperfections in your playing or your singing is what gives it character." - If I may add, IMO, this goes the same in the way of overly engineered projects that clip off the front and tail nuances for intense riff clarity, nudging audio (not midi quantize) performances to lock tighter performances. Though it sounds fantastic, I wouldn't mind hearing the occasional string buzz just to give it that hoooman element.

[@kingcrimson2168]

Hello verified KZbinr

[@CitizenSniiiips]

Geebz on Rick's channel. Must be in heaven

[@KateStantonSings]

Key Of Geebz!! Love your reactions to TOOL. Subbed!

[@stevencouch5691]

Love your page, Geebz

[@chukka215]

hello fellow hoooman

[@jonthomas8569]

I take voice lessons for fun, and any time I've obsessed over how a note sounds, my teacher usually says something like this: "The note was there. I heard you do it. And frankly, it doesn't have to be flawless. Perfection has no place in art."

[@JK-g62]

Well said sir!

[@granthambeard]

Awwwww mine said the same when I was a kid! A good teacher stays with you forever

[@truthfirst1893]

Dimebag said it best. He said that the little imperfections in music are what keep music honest. I think that those same imperfections are what keep music human as well. Great video! ✌🏼

[@johngavin1175]

@@hal2098 Awesome. Do you always get things wrong?

[@johngavin1175]

@@crankfotton So since some of these comments were made while ago,supposedly what was I arrogant about exactly? Because whatever comment I was arrogant about seems to have been erased,so tell me why you would be mad that I was arrogant,without knowing what I was being arrogant about?

[@Ynotchila]

I love your explanations and insight. I’ve recorded original songs of my own and other artists also many years ago and I feel paralyzed starting again. I feel sooo out of the loop. I haven’t used any of the new technologies. Wow! Your videos are inspiring me again.

[@RobertLBarnard]

The autotune "effect" initially creeped me out and continues to until today. It reminds me of the sadness I felt when, as a child, I met a man who needed an electrolarynx to speak.

[@torbjrnlund903]

I hate it. 😫

[@tommunyon2874]

The Mamas and Papas burned the midnight oil to get everything as near perfect as possible-- the difference between commitment to art, rather than to profit.

[@WhizzRichardThompson]

Some of their vocal harmonies were sublime

[@stephenrivera4382]

But you do have to cringe a bit when you listen t the harmonies on “Monday, Monday…”

[@terrybennett4700]

Bluey

[@joellebrodeur1015]

"Gimme Shelter" background vocal by Merry and that vocal crack she hits would have been autotuned out or rerecorded if it were done today. That raw character of her vocals on that track is what made that song great.

[@thesundog8833]

Great example. One could write a thesis on this

[@mrwaterghost]

Perfect example. Greatest back up singing ever. Autodumb would pour bleach all over it.

[@dashphonemail]

@Jugizet Good point. Gimme Shelter voice crack was one of those perfect happy accident musical moments. Usually, voice cracking doesn't sound that good because it's off pitch. "Imperfection" in music can be great and necessary, but most imperfection is bad. Great music is still 99% perfect

[@michaelcarper2185]

Very good example!

[@williamcampbell7387]

And The Stones knew that and left it in.

[@tuckasamms]

What I would give for a fraction of Rick's musical knowledge. Genius.

[@paulembleton1733]

Advice to anyone with a crap voice: Use an autotune plugin, listen for a while, turn off autotune, guaranteed your voice will then sound better.

[@keard558]

It's great to teach you how to sing if you put in a bit of effort

[@thelendalrock8675]

Lemmy sounds like he’s done every drug at least 100 times and he still makes it work

[@DarthFetid]

also invest in some vocal coaching sessions if you can.

[@jonathancarpenter399]

Agreed. It can be a helpful teaching tool for a home producer that's getting into singing. Just tell it chromatic[every note] and have it halfway goin.. it helps show you what flat or sharp sounds" like

[@keard558]

@@authorpowell4285 to me that's such an outdated opinion. I like to believe that anything is possible in life rather than you're born with a talent you can't change.

[@crazy_diamond9874]

The saddest thing about this is we are so used to hearing the "auto-tune sound" as a people nowadays that even the singers who do not use it often unconsciously try to imitate it and we end up with all of these similarly perfect, characterless voices.

[@heliumtrophy]

I think it speaks to how soulless music has become as well. Not all obviously but when humans are imitating a device that lets other humans who can't sing, sing, then it's a flattery that we could really do without.

[@angelol2877]

@@heliumtrophy How does a human imitate a computer program.

[@amylaw3416]

I'm not used to it. Just like I'm can't ever get used to artificial sweeteners. My kids are in the music room noodling around on their guitars on a pink Floyd song right now. Like Rick's kids, my kids HATE that fake vocal sound.

[@davidadamsmusic]

One of the challenges is that today’s listener is now “trained” to listen to only music that is perfectly in tune albeit by production techniques vs. organic singing. With auto tune now made available live it changes the game and makes it more difficult for the true vocalist to stand out from the crowd. Sadly- it’s often now about marketing and brand image more than talent.

[@windsofmarchjourneyperrytr2823]

Not really new, tho. That's been going on for decades.

[@deldridg]

Mate, it's becoming the norm everywhere. Eaten a truly organic apple lately? They often look deformed and lacking the perfect shine of the artificially enhanced apples that you get in the big chains. We are becoming coerced into a plastically perfect world in many ways. As many agree, this has been happening in the music world for decades.

[@NootalieWalf]

Amen

[@davidadamsmusic]

@@deldridg I agree! My international business friends talk about how Americans have perfect teeth because every imperfection is fixed. Seems this “pay for perfection” trend is ubiquitous and visible in many areas of life as you so eloquently pointed out in your comment above. Seems I have become like my parents who often lamented the “good ole days” …

[@deldridg]

@@davidadamsmusic Hi David - you made me laugh. At the ripe old age of 53, I too find myself becoming more like my parents in my horror at certain modern trends! Thank you for your kind words - it is sad but true that increasingly the general message is to be beautiful on the surface and be less concerned about the inner beauty or substance below. Hard work to develop any kind of skill also brings with it character, purpose and a good deal of satisfaction. All these things interplay with the output of the skill regardless of what it is. My kids (and I) work very hard daily on our musical skills and in the sharing of them with others, there is a deeper meaning which I like to think comes across beyond being more 'polished' - if that makes sense! Cheers from Sydney - Dave :-)

[@jimmydoolitle3764]

This was great. I always wondered how auto tune worked to this level of detail. This was a PERFECT explantation and demonstration. You are the man Rick. You are the king of KZbin in my book.

[@gatesurfer]

My uncle was a professional musician in Hawaii, and when he passed away, I was able to go through his stuff. One of the things he left behind was an accordion. I had no interest in it, but I could tell it was playable and so I decided to put it up for sale on eBay. That got me started researching accordions, and I found out that there is something called "dry" tuning and "wet" tuning. An accordion is a reed instrument, basically a bunch of harmonicas, with three reeds tuned to each pitch. "Dry tuning" is when two of the reeds are tuned the same, resulting in a tighter sound around the fundamental. "Wet" tuning is when all three reeds are out of tune with each other. Interestingly, wet tuning tends to sound brighter, richer and "happier." You wanna Roll Out the Barrel, get an instrument with wet tuning. But something more romantic, maybe dry tuning would be easier to sing to.

[@nirfz]

Everyday there is something new to learn...I learned to play accordeon as a child, but i had never heard about that.

[@tonyperiphoto]

Dry tuning is no tremolo. Wet tuning is a heavy tremolo. But you also have diatonic accordions tuned to play harmony chords and chromatic accordions tuned to equal temperament. A well tuned accordion can make a big difference to an out of tune one, as a number of reeds are played for each button/key across 2, 3, 4 or 5 reed blocks. This leads back to Rick's video. You can auto tune, but if you dont auto-tune harmony correctly, it sounds wrong. Sing a major chord with the 3rd -14 cents flat and the 5th +2 cents. Its better. The barbershop quartets did it. The Beach boys did it. Hohner Harmonicas did it for the Blues. And diatonic button accordions do it.

[@p39483]

Additive synthesis with sine waves has the same issues except more extreme. I quit doing it and now look to recording IFFT results into a wave table. What you typically want is a smooth bump (maybe gaussian distribution) in the spectrum around a pitch rather than a zero-width line, and then harmonics that are also smooth bumps. So a natural sounding 440hz has some 439.825 Hz mixed in as well as thousands of other frequencies between that and 440 Hz as well as above. This creates timbre and helps us hear chords vs harmonics of a single voice. It also smooths out mathematical problems in equal temperament tuning whereas pure sines require perfect just intonation to avoid dissonance and low frequency beat notes. Adding a second detuned reed is basically the same concept. It does sound tremolo of course since there are only two. But if you had 30 or so slightly detuned reeds that would be a very rich sound.

[@sharmatime]

Thank you for sharing.

[@krissymarklewis1793]

also one of the hardest instruments to play so im told.

[@gtartrek9453]

What is said here about vocals also applies to other elements, like guitars and drums. Perfection robs us of beauty.

[@paulyguitary7651]

When everything snaps to a grid (vocals, drums, rhythm guitar etc) you don’t have music, you have a graph.

[@andyp7449]

@@paulyguitary7651 Yes when you have perfect copy paste guitar tracks... why bother with guitars to begin with?

[@truefilm6991]

Yep, well I love on those older recordings when I hear some human effort, such as a crash cymbal that comes in very slightly off after a crazy fill, that high note on the Bb trumpet that wobbles just a bit, that high violin note that's just a bit off after a huge leap up, that awesome jazz piano lick that's not perfectly clean.... So much better.

[@Palefirecreative]

Agreed

[@atomiccritter6492]

@@andyp7449 indeed as many industrial groups do just that

[@scottpatrick8645]

It's stripping the soul right out of the music. Many of these young artists might actually have decent, unique voices, but we will never know.

[@fl00d69]

I'd wager most of them are actually garbage.

[@TigerRogers0660]

@@fl00d69 I'll bet if some of them actually tried - & the producers forced them to sing it many times - they would improve.

[@anonymousee716]

whenever i hear something "new", my feeling is nearly always the same: this is music made by and FOR machines.

[@wildbill7267]

Sky net likes its own music! lol

[@electric7487]

See: "Prolefeed"

[@terrypeck3948]

That's why songs like "Helplessly Hoping" by Crosby, Stills and Nash, and "Seven Bridges Road" by the Eagles, will always be classics...sheer pure unadulterated talent.

[@seed_drill7135]

The Eagles were just copying Ian Matthews arrangement of Seven Bridges Road. Our local classic rock station has taken to playing the Matthews version.

[@redensign1757]

both songs, the harmony is just amazing. great examples of a 'bigger' sound.

[@troyundroy1]

I haven't even heard those songs, but I know those bands & exactly what you mean. Their harmonising emboldens the sound so much

[@whatskraken3886]

ok boomer

[@RG-ja34sep]

Isn’t it amazing that Rick is so knowledgeable about anything to do with music? We are so fortunate to have him dissect a song and analyse all the incredible parts of the song.

[@livingthehardlife]

it's literally his job... so... not really surprising but wonderful nonetheless.

[@zachary963]

Meanwhile I’m listening to Talking Heads, and David Byrne acts like pitch is a general vicinity, not an area. He’s sometimes really all over the place as far as pitch is concerned, but his rhythm is amazing.

[@brentwalker3300]

Yeah, but I mean Byrne was a "talk singer" who was able to convey his lyrics' meaning more because of this naturalness. It's a feature, not a bug to be auto-tune eradicated.

[@jfo3000]

And that is exactly why I cannot listen stand listening to him.

[@JohnLnyc]

There are more elements to singing than pitch and range. Phrasing, timbre, etc.

[@paavobergmann4920]

Or Tom Waits. Pointing into the general direction of where the pitch of the melody is supposed to be, but completely melting you.

[@simonjhudson7378]

Massively under rated rhythm guitarist too.

[@oldschool72]

I been listening to iconic singers and bands since the early 50's. My 78 RPM of Jerry Butler from 1963 finally gave out so I ordered the same album on Amazon.. was so excited until I played it. It sounded like some one else was singing. It sounded almost robotic and certainly did NOT sound like the original album. The vibrato was not there etc. Then I read the album fine print.. REMASTERED.. I just thought it meant cleaned up, made clearer like brand new. I din't realize they were using Autotune to actually adjust the singers voice.. It sucks and I returned the album. I refuse to buy any NEW music made today. Its all fake..I will stick to my old school real music.

[@varsityathlete9927]

you should be able to buy another 78s on discogs (usually way cheaper than ebay) or an lp, if its 50s/60s there won't be much remastering that really took off in the 80s and esp 90s with cds.

[@heliboy8762]

Yeah, kind of like Autotuning Joe Cocker, Tom Waits or Mick Jagger. Imagine how ridiculous that would sound!

[@thomascasey8171]

Auto-tune is the high-fructose corn syrup of music.

[@JasonTHutchinson]

At least high fructose corn syrup has good taste.

[@pearcy5206]

@@JasonTHutchinson but try downing the bottle

[@mm-nyc]

I was listening to Baby Love (Supremes) just the other day at it was like eating a plate of fresh vegetables after a month of eating fast food.

[@Resol26]

Only Daft Punk can makes A-T tracks masterpiece.

[@JasonTHutchinson]

@@pearcy5206 like Auto-Tune, is only good in small doses.

[@TinHatRanch]

You need to do the Lenny Kravitz backing vocals both ways, sung autotuned and then naturally.

[@Brew78]

Or at least a second version showing the difference in sound with one or more of the tracks being autotuned slightly out of tune

[@chaos.corner]

I want a Milky Way

[@shayneoneill1506]

@@snapascrew Or have access to the original recording stems. Which weirdly he often seems to have access to somehow.

[@billhart9832]

@@chaos.corner ever try singing after eating a Milky Way? Sorry for the suggestion.

[@iancook7109]

And 1 slightly pitch edited manually

[@242-f5u]

This reminded me of the documentary, "Sound City," and a snippet featuring Tom Petty. He talked about missing the days of cutting tape and literally recording live over and over until they got it right. He said it wasn't perfect but in a way it was because that's how it was supposed to be.

[@markflapper6001]

Always love it when one can get back on their own favourite saying and turn it around. Couldn't agree more: 'Pitch is not a place, it's an area.' Beautiful :-)

[@sidilicious11]

I’m just a listener, not an expert, but I part of the goosebumps factor when listening to a singer can come from them reaching perfect pitch after being slightly off, it’s part of the color and emotion that comes from a natural human voice. When you were playing Seal’s vocals without instrumentation I heard a few off notes, but that gave him humanity and character and me great satisfaction when he was back on point. I agree auto tune is good for effects but can be way over used. I’m a boomer who appreciates good singing.

[@thekitchenfreak]

THIS.

[@Walperion_Music]

I just hope in the age of robotization we'll eventually get tired of perfect artificial things and human imperfections will become really fashionable!

[@thekitchenfreak]

@@Walperion_Music Same here!

[@gustabartok]

That's absolutely true. Sometimes "not perfect" is a quality that fits really good in some musical moments. Obviously we're not talking half-step misses, but you can find this "almost in tune notes" effect in many popular and folk music around the world. It´s human, you're absolutely right.

[@xxxaragon]

seriously, that "Kiss from a Rose" episode was crazy. like, I knew that the vocals were great. but hearing those without the instruments further made me recognize just how amazing they were.

[@therickman34]

Autotune is part laziness, but mostly "this artist is hot but can't sing in key. Eh, we'll make them a star anyway. Just autotune it."

[@bryscorpio]

exactly this

[@purplemicrodot58]

Video Killed the Radio Star.

[@jennypai1776]

Sounds like Katy Perry

[@UncleKennysPlace]

I love listening to old recordings of imperfect human voices, missing notes and timing. Precious.

[@joemartucci4786]

Me to I can pick out bad bass notes slightly off harmonies the Hollies...little screw ups Rod Stewart Maggie Mae Hendrix Hey Joe etc...but you can’t beat old 60s & 70s music. Most of those bands can play & sing way better than anything that’s come out recently.

[@dkimuk]

One of my favourite recordings is Ella Fitzgerald singing Mack the Knife and she forgets the words. She throws in a Louis Armstrong impression, scats like a trumpet and makes a bunch of lyrics up. The band play on, safe in the knowledge that she'll think of something - and she does. It's a joyful ride. A masterclass in improv and a demonstration of her talent and experience. I wouldn't trade that for almost any live recordings of today's performers.

[@patpogoallroundguitarist5814]

I love perfect human voices in perfect time without autotune.

[@padarousou]

I grew up listening to old rock music with my dad who was born in NYC in the 50’s. I never appreciated until about 2015 when I noticed how unauthentic modern music is, and at 22 all I listen to is old music because it encapsulates a genuineness and talent that you just don’t get with today’s music

[@militarymisfit]

I'm a professional music critic and the sheer number of autotuned demos I get is incredible. Maybe it's my age, maybe it isn't. But, I grew up without this mess of an effect. It's colored my view of today's industry and not for the better.

[@WXManPhil]

"Now, is it going to sound interesting 10 years from now?" Hard to say, but I'm guessing it will sound dated. Think "gated reverb" drum sound"

[@maccagrabme]

Its never sounded interesting to me. Vocoder, Akai timestretch and voxbox yes but autotune sounds terrible when overdone.

[@thankyouforyourcompliance7386]

Most 200x songs have not stood the test of time

[@WXManPhil]

@@maccagrabme In Body of Song Bob Mould used a vocoder-style digital effect that I liked. But when it comes to my personal taste, I agree that autotune isn't something I'm into.

[@Durwood71]

Except gated reverb drums are awesome. Autotune is not.

[@michaelpal7641]

100% agree-the test of time will tell. As an aside-why does B.B King, or Albert King or Eric Clapton's music stand out over the years? I know you know the answer to that:)

[@OctoberMusicIsLife]

that was a great breakdown. I remember when Neil Young say in an interview that they would make him record over and over again because they said he was out of tune and he said thats my voice. And you know what that is why Neil Young has such a distinct sound. Same with Perry of Janes Addiction

[@J_Trask]

That’s what makes music great to listen to. I hate hearing music that has vocals that sound absolutely perfect. Music is art. IMO subconsciously, you lose the human connection when the music is pitch corrected, you cant hear the emotion in the music. Imagine if Willie Nelson’s music used auto tune. Auto tune is why new country music is so awful sounding.

[@1mlb704]

I got absolutely blasted on another KZbin page by other rock musicians/fans for saying I refused to use autotune on my voice for my band's album we just put out. It's nice to know other people aren't into the idea of constantly "fixing" imperfect human vocals

[@fl00d69]

Can you point me to those people? I'd like to go tear them a new one.

[@half-arsedmusic]

I'm the same as you. Many years ago an ex bandmate of mine was studying sound engineering and needed a band to record, so he asked me to do it. Which I did, but when all was done he told me he'd used autotune to correct some parts of my vocal. It instantly rendered the recording useless to me.

[@dylanadams1455]

In the fantasy of my deluded mid 40s mind, where I somehow get a recording deal for my muck around band that barely exists, I would stipulate no autotune, no quantising.

[@StudioLodge]

I sent my new single out to an engineer for mixing. All recorded here. No autotune on any of the vocals. Except one really high part I wanted in the chorus. Was going for that Mutt Lange thing. I gave it a shot. Anyways... He sent it back saying he autotuned some little bits here and there. I was "sigh.." but became ok with it. I couldn't tell where. So if it was minimal, all good. I started thinking that maybe we just hear things that maybe aren't really there nowadays. And throw on the autotune just in case we doubt what we're hearing. Just a thought. But to use it for the whole vocal track? That just defeats the purpose, doesn't it? Personally, I'll sing it till I'm blue in the face and hit the note. Unless it just ain't happening that day. Then I'll rest and come back. But I'm old school that way.

[@1mlb704]

@@StudioLodge that's totally fair. I really don't have an issue with tweaking something here and there, especially if you're tight on studio time. At the end of the day the artist should be able to have their song sound the way they want. My guitar player sang lead vocals on one of the songs for our album and he didn't love how his voice sounded, so he had our engineer touch it up with autotune. I opted to keep redoing my vocal takes until it was at or close to what I wanted. Like Rick mentioned, we've reached the point where a lot of these singers sound like robots because they're so autotuned, as a listener that does nothing for me. I like hearing the singer sing with the least amount of effects as possible. A little bit of slop in the instruments or a hint of flat/sharp pitch in the vocals is good for me, it makes it sound more real.

[@LanceCampeau]

I have always liked Lenny Kravitz's work ("Circus" is an incredible album) but too this day I can't stand "Fly Away". You can be repetitive.... but you can't be robotic AND repetitive. That's what makes the song so grating to listen to.

[@Bernaeumesmo]

Therapist: dark hair rick isn’t real and cannot hurt you Dark hair rick: my name is rick beato

[@DTrecording]

I wish he would grow out his hair just for a single reprisal of that beautiful intro

[@No1KCfan6]

he was a babe.

[@DTrecording]

@@No1KCfan6 110%

[@alexinthemix00]

best comment hahaha

[@jsnell126]

I don't know why this is so funny.

[@Granaldigirl]

As a vocalist for over 40 years, I appreciate that you made this video on auto-tune. I've worked with people who are not vocalist, but (because of auto-tune) the listeners believe this is what they sound like. It infuriates me.

[@alexbowman7582]

For a great example of a natural vocal, flawed but beautiful in it’s imperfections, look to Merry Clayton’s backing to Gimme Shelter. It wasn’t exactly improvised but she was hired late and turned up in her pj’s. She sang her heart out, her vocals cracking a few times.

[@erikwashburnmusic]

Yes !

[@tonybates7870]

She sort of squeaks on the third "murder!" and you can hear someone, Jagger, I think, shout "woah!" or similar. It's a great moment.

[@lesterunwin]

her backing vocals elevate the song from 'good' to 'great', in my humble opinion.

[@alecr666x]

Heard the isolated vocal in the documentary "20 feet from stardom" and actually cried. Don't know why, just did. Phenomenal vocal and a phenomenal film. A must watch.

[@alexbowman7582]

@@alecr666x there's a KZbin video of all the songs tracks isolated can't remember what it's named though but you should be able to find it.

[@varsityathlete9927]

Believe is a really good dance song, the autotune at the time was completely novel and sounded like nothing else. She also had a well known and recorded voice so it was obvious there was an effect on it.

[@Timliu92]

Agreed, and besides Cher is a good singer without it. She can reproduce her parts live without trouble. AutoTune will not make a bad singer sound like Freddie Mercury.

[@chrismarple]

@@Timliu92 if you’re a good singer then why use auto tune? That’s part of the problem.

[@electric7487]

@@chrismarple It's used as an effect to spice things up.

[@rhythmandblues_alibi]

Exactly. It was obviously an effect, just like you'd use on any other instrument.

[@NeverSickAtSea]

Imagine if they realise what they've done and come up with an Auto-De-Tune - a plugin on top of the Autotune plugin - that will take the Autotune track and then use an algorithm to insert preprogrammed errors and inconsistencies into it, supposedly making it sound human. Boy will we be in for a surprise.

[@andycizek]

I have thought about this, a lot. It’s more plausible than it sounds.

[@medusa6491]

@@andycizek The G.O.A.T. is here !

[@TobyIKanoby]

Something like that already exists I believe for Google assistant and the likes, to make it sound more human.

[@nolanvarner7529]

Do some research, you might be on the way to an invention that will change your life....

[@chrisaugustin2985]

Some auto tune programs like melodyne actually have a have features exactly like that lol. Slight variations in the pitch and timing among other slight tweaks designed create imperfections after removing them in the first place. Its cool, but why are we like this??

[@nathanmarshallmusic]

Very interesting. Always have been anti-autotune. For years I've made the statement that, "I miss the times when rock/pop stars were good musicians." We celebrate mediocrity in modern music. Much like giving accolades to the teams that comes in last just because the spectators aren't able to make it that far.

[@AzureSky_Music]

Sat around a campfire on vacation and tried to make this argument to a group of people, mostly my family, and everyone acted like I was talking out my ass.

[@nathanmarshallmusic]

@@AzureSky_Music if I'd been there I'd have had yer back. This whole thing, I believe, is due to less people learning to play an instrument and believing that if they got a computer they can make "music".

[@nathanmarshallmusic]

@Soy Orbison you'd think, but I'm not a boomer. I just appreciate instruments played by people who have spent time learning and appreciating music that's not digital. And I'm not completely against digital either. In mostly small doses...

[@nathanmarshallmusic]

@Soy Orbison so true. I went to a big enough school that we had orchestra and brass band starting in 6th grade. Where I currently live the school only has brass band starting in highschool. My cousin teaches at a school with no band at all. Playing an instrument is worth more than just the skill, history, culture or some way to pass the time. Music lives between worlds.

[@musicantd]

A big part of it is that people are reconciled to mediocrity in their lives. They don't expect to break out of their conundrums. The music they're listening to underscores it. Unless they know better, some do.

[@MarioTorre]

Fun fact: in the A Night At The Opera documentary, Brian May said that Freddie Mercury was doubling the takes and they had a problem that he would phase with himself so close he would sing each take :D

[@oldnelson4298]

I heard this when I was a music student, but I'm pretty sure it is apocryphal. No matter how phenomenal his voice was, he was still human, so I don't think it is possible to purposely sing in phase with a recording of yourself for any length of time. Certainly not an entire take, a melodic line or even for more than just a split second.

[@GuitaristInProgress]

I always assumed that that Lenny Kravits backing vocals effect was just mixing a keyboard vocal pad in with the vocals. I'll tell you what killed me, was trying to watch "Glee". They didn't make the vocals sound "computerized" but they autotuned them to death for sure, every held note was straight as an arrow. It drove me nuts.

[@RogueError617]

You're actually right, they used to have a glee karaoke iOS app where you could get the same effect

[@williama.walker2287]

Autotune is a large part of what bugs me about pop music today. It is more than just perfect vocals, or vocals that are meant to sound like Autotune. It is the perfect drums, perfect guitars, and other perfect instruments, all put on the same song, but never sounding like a group playing together. There is something missing that should bring all of the different elements of a song together. I just hear parts separated from each of the other parts, but being played at the same time. It is particularly annoying in genres that have always relied on emotional playing or singing. Whenever I try to add some jazz to my playlists, for example, I cannot listen to current smooth jazz because it doesn't sound right. Everything is too perfect and distinct to be jazz. Give me the old big bands and combos any day.

[@atomiccritter6492]

Autotune is a large part of what bugs me about pop music today - so avoid pop music then! Theres a shitload of stuff out there to listen to. I think I will release a series of videos where I rant that jazz is just random notes played together and opera is just ott screeching. Instead I just accept I find those genres terrible for me and find something I DO enjoy

[@Kaptain13Gonzo]

See Ricks video on 'gridding'. He uses a John Bonham drum track. Compares 'as recorded' with modern gridding. Amazing how the process sucked all the life out of the track.

[@reputablehype]

I always come back to the painting world when I think about music. We went from realism to impressionism, we went from abstract expressionism to pop art. There is always a swing of the pendulum, I'm actually excited for the next swing of raw artists who rebel against technology in music. For every Warhol there is a Basquiat around the corner. :)

[@JBMDCreations]

Yeah, I think this is right on. We'll rubberband back in the other direction as we're certainly hitting the limit of how far we can stand stretching in this direction.

[@romancultist6089]

There's been plenty of that. It just doesn't usually chart. The 20th century concept of popular music is dead. These days it's just models who dance, sing, and take on whatever personality their fan base wants to see. It's not about the music anymore. This is why I invest zero time looking at top hits or charts. Just listen to whatever you like. It's not worth lamenting over. 1950-1995 was a great moment for music. Things have changed too much. I don't expect to see something like that again.

[@JoeyBongas]

"One more time", is still, twenty years from when it came out, a perfect example of how to use auto tune properly.

[@5roundsrapid263]

Daft Punk were masters of vocal effects. That’s really more of a vocoder, BTW.

[@fran6b]

Agreed! That song is a masterpiece! But the thing with Daft Punk is that they actually want to sound like robots. Acting like they are robots is in their DNA. But as Rick states it, the problem is when you a human character sound like a robot. That's not great. It's intellectually, and emotionally dissonant.

[@5roundsrapid263]

@@fran6b Autotune has always been a huge part of EDM. It’s kind of obligatory.

[@fran6b]

@@5roundsrapid263 Yes. And it makes sense as electronic music emerge to echo the predominance of industrialisation, and specifically the sounds of the industry, if I'm correct.

[@pigknickers2975]

@@fran6b well put. This is the problem. Fine if you are pretending to be robots....

[@crazykittenvideos855]

I loved Puddle of Mudd’s debut album and got the chance to se them in the UK. Singer could not hit the notes as they are on the studio version which was a real shame. I know you are a big Chris Cornell fan. I was lucky enough to see both Soundgarden and Audioslave live and they were always amazing! Keep up the fine content, love the channel

[@BloominOnion1]

was he doing a Nirvana cover?

[@rhythmandblues_alibi]

Dude I am so jealous! RIP Chris Cornell, legend 🖤