Modi Govt Vs Raghuram Rajan, 1991 Finance Team, & India’s Brain Drain Challenge I A.K. Bhattacharya

[@bcramakrishnamaiya9972]

who constructed Bakra Nangal ? Nehru who was irrigation minister. i dont know who won Bangla war? Indira Gandhi. who was defence minister i dont know who did demonitation and gst? modi. who was finance minister? i dont know. who did liberalisation? FM Manmohan singh who was Prime minister at that time? i dont know this is called narration building.

[@sreedharreddyabbidi5374]

That's so dumb of you to say you don't know P.V. Narasimha Rao. Everyone who is smart enough to know Manmohan Singh was a FM knows Narasimha Rao was his PM.

[@lawanyaarvind2810]

Thanks to Mr Ashok Bhattacharya. He has shared his vast knowledge so lucidly in this podcast with us all .... There was so much to learn....he made it seem so easy to understand...

[@haridasshenoy8334]

Water crisis, ground water depletion, traffic jams, air pollution? Who is responsible? Any plans.

[@akilapranathi]

Enough of podcasts about past, these are some real questions and topics to be discussed on a podcast. Thank you for saying this!

[@arvindarora9220]

Nehru is. The most obvious and trendy answer today.

[@krishna-hindu]

So pv narsimha rao had nothing to do with indian economic boom in 1990s

[@AlorSharma]

Bhai Finance ministers ki baat ho rhi hai Tu har jagah politics leke aa jata hai This channel is not for binary and politics, thand rkh thoda....

[@NaamMaiKuchNahiRaka]

okay...PV Narasimha Rao was finance minster of India. Are you happy now?

[@Photon108-k4t]

He gave political support to FM at that time and absorbed all pressure from within Congress party.

[@vikramsudhakar]

Still now we didn’t have good financial ministers

[@kaushiksarkar7201]

PV Narshima Rao Manmohan Singh are legends

[@venkateshthangavel]

These Babu’s and congress has this craze for london is mind blowing When he explained that sanjay gandhi went to london to learn about automotive industry is crazy either its japan or Germany which is the world leader in automotive industry but these guys went to london where nothing is produced other than this fancy rollce royce or aston martin which is run by german industries now but for naam thae vaste these guys tell he went to london to study ( its just bhakvas) London was and is a marketplace never renowned for anything special other than this fancy loot history

[@murthybhagavatula3892]

A lot of credit for the Economic Reforms must be given to the then PM PV Narasimha Rao for the leadership support provided by him.

[@agsitaraman3270]

During upa there were many prime ministers .faya inidhi maran,A.raja ,lallu prasad yadav .

[@Unitedsyndicate]

Basically if Sanjay Gandhi alive that time India might be 10 trillion dollars economy but Indira Gandhi doesn't wants to think India people to not think again family conservative mind.

[@AKT-oc7ex]

What PV Narasimha Rao asked Manmohan Singh to do was exactly what IMF had demanded as a condition for bailout. There was nothing innovative on Manmohan Singh's part. As Prime Minister, he inherited a booming economy from Vajpayee which continued for some time in his first term because of good work done by Vajpayee. By the end of his second term the growth had dropped to 5% and inflation had risen to 10%. Even this happened with huge debt to be paid for by Modi Govt. The banking system was in deep distress. Even oil that was imported from Iran on credit because of sanctions had to paid for by Modi Govt. There were mega scams under his watch. He was a disaster as PM.

[@pawanrai8099]

Finally someone understood this, else rest of pepole just keep defending Manmohan Ji, no doubt he was honest and capable but UPA alliance made him "majbur". Same thing will happen to BJP if they won't get full majority, because you need to keep your partners with you at any cost. At the end of the day no one likes to stand down from prime minister chair.

[@dhruvpandya4136]

Knowing and execution are two different things. He is an expert in his field, so he executed it very well.

[@mohanv88]

Wah! BJP IT cell. Wah!!

[@AKT-oc7ex]

@@mohanv88 That is an easy comment to make when you are ignorant

[@mohanv88]

@@AKT-oc7ex in 2014 when mms left, in 65 years since independence, our loan was 48 lakh crores. In 10 years modi raised to 160 lakh crores to feed adani. Our growth was 5% or more. But genuine & reliable figures. Not fake figures like 7.2 what debt did modi clear. He raised the debt. We got cheap oil in 2020 from russia saudi which was sold to consumers at 110 price. Adani's coal scam where he supplied cheap coal at 900% price. PM care fund?? Whose fund is that. Black money modi exorted was back to adani account through shell companies of moritious. And adani was buying his own stock without maintaining the sebi norms so his stock rise. Airports, roads, seaports, railways, food godowns, (farmers laws to capture farm lands). Adani in defence, buying our psu defence stocks. The anil ambani gets rafeal deal to manufacture without experience. Universities vacencies are filled with rss workers.. list is endless. Either u r obsssed with bjp with religion caste basis or an IT cell employee. Be broad and read/watch both sides.. best of luck

[@nansimishra256]

Amazing amazing Discussion

[@TheNeonShoww]

Thanks for sharing, Nansi. Be sure to also share it within your circle. :)

[@murthybhagavatula3892]

Wealth Creators should be respected and appreciated. General Public has to be educated on this. This is essential over and above tax policies to retain Wealth Creators.

[@rameshchandersharma2032]

MMS was a finance wizard but a very poor and a porus monitor to facilitate and compromised on mega scams😂

[@rapatel1642]

Too bad the wizard didn't bring in gst or a uniform tax across the nation. Wizard sure!!!

[@panchamin.r4449]

😂

[@proffshivramans5346]

Wonderful conversation

[@veerasinghamthirupathy4695]

Jai Hind. Vande Mataram. Om Shanti , Shanti, Shanti.

[@rechalgreen3047]

In 2004 , India was at 11th rank in largest economy. At the end of 2014 , India was still 11th position. So what is the meaning of Manmohan sigh was the best economist. Don't just interview any clown for more view

[@chaitanyavoolapalli1731]

During that time MMS was PM not FM 😄

[@chaitanyavoolapalli1731]

Don't ask me why this great FM / economist keeps mum when his political boss is rubbishing GST and threatening to undo it.

[@rameshchandersharma2032]

True, the posture and especially the moustaches of this oldie make him look a pucca clown darbari😅

[@keshav22453]

​@@chaitanyavoolapalli1731 many times mms took additional charge of fm 😂

[@neillman6809]

As per the hindu india became 3rd largest economy 😂 There was an economic recession in 2008 but it didn't even affect us under upa job growth rate was highest so was gdp growth

[@korathmathew]

MMS was the greatest Finance Minister who saved India and subsequently became the greatest PM of India.

[@navalfa7291]

He enabled corruption. Hence.

[@neillman6809]

Not greatest it's great

[@mohanv88]

Modi is most honest. No corruption at all. Not even single case in supreme court . Justice gagoi, chandrachud .. etc did there job so effectively..

[@kallachi729]

Best combination The great Narasihmarao (an economist in his own right) and MMS. It has to be a combination…. In a democracy it is always the combination…giving a freehand to a minister (dangerous) or controlling him/her (most dangerous) or working as team, which produces the best result. Let us get the narrative straight.

[@murthybhagavatula3892]

Improving Health and Education will benefit common people but won't help retain Billionaires! Modi ji is doing well to encourage New Gen Entrepreneurs. Policies should help retain them. However, dirty politics of Congress n Allies painting the Wealth Creators as devils poses serious challenges.

[@mohanv88]

Now a days , we dont have finance ministers. We have tax ministers.

[@Madmax-b3j]

Look like Dr.HC VERMA sir

[@sudiptakoleh5148]

Narrative is pushed that Manmohan Singh was the one who saved this country .People forget it was Manmohan Singh through his various capacity was the one among others who put Indian economy in the situation were it was in 1991.

[@hrp4566]

If Manmohan is so great. Why the performance of all indicators bad between 2004-2014? It's narasimha rao political will made that happen.

[@neillman6809]

Mohak mangal , nitish rajputs and even druv rathe >>>>>

[@akshaysood1667]

Good interview Informative Both Mr Bhattacharya and the interviewer are good .

[@TheNeonShoww]

Glad you liked it and were able to take insights from the conversation... Please let us know who we should bring on next on the channel! 🙏

[@ramdasmadhiyalla4058]

You were so good till you try shield present government under the pretext of covid. Government was disaster in tackling covid.

[@manujohn99]

I don't understand what this Channel is trying to do for the viewers........all the talks till now are simply falling dud. 😒

[@jaisankarmishra5502]

👍

[@TheNeonShoww]

Thanks, Jai. Please let us know who you would love to see next on the Neon Show. :)

[@suppiahmurugesan8343]

Flaw of democracy causes start and stop in economic development in Bharat, unlike like Singapore or China. That's why we need for the BJP government to remain in power for at least 10 years.

[@sharathiyer6366]

😂 what a joke!. Persons under him were scamming the taxpayers and he was silent and he is the best? Is someone a best husband and remains silent when someone is outraging the modesty of his wife? According to me he should not have headed any department. As PM he degraded the dignity of the post insulted the chair. He may be a good person but when taking responsibility of constitutional post or public life he is answerable to public. What about imports from china? Did it not kill local manufacturing? The channel needs to be careful who it is interviewing. Pl do not degrade your position.

[@mintusaren895]

Sir vs sir via amed kar

[@rajan5608]

Manmohan Singh is not such a great economist to receive so much of praise and acknowledgements. He was just carrying what PV Narasimha wanted. If he was such a great economist, India would not have been on its knee as "FRAGILE 5" after 10 years of his remote controlled government. All he achieved was a long list of corruptions and also brought the banks to bankruptcy. He was neither good in governance or developments. It was during his government, China was rising at a tremendous speed and he was not able to bring in investments. One of his biggest failure was the CWG, it portrayed India internationally its incompetency in organizing major events when smaller countries had demonstrated better organization. In conclusion both MMS and Raghuram Rajan were worthless in their field.

[@DishanthJ]

Powerful woman of India,,our Finance Minister,,Smt.NIRMALA SITHARAMAN 🔥🔥

[@hina1960]

Knowing exactly manmohan singh has actually destroyed indian economy this guys has still praises for him

[@galaxyRoger_1]

Whats so special about MMS ‘s contribution ? He was educated in finance and WB gave directives in tasks which he dud being a good dopamine employee !!

[@surendra1990]

So they blatantly blame Modi for selling government companies and also want the glory for having raised a slogan that the government has no business, running a businesses. SO VERY CRUEL AND SELFISH.

[@mohanv88]

There is something called strategic disinvestment. Disinvesting mere 5% 9% than selling 99% 100% accounts to privatisation. MMS is educated wheras Modi is a crude directionless , visionless & selfish bussiness man.

[@Sush812]

Never trust Harsh

[@arjunm6866]

Even if you are a fool speak in English and do english costume. You will be defined as economist who will make india bigger than china and America. Raghuram rajan was an example of that.

[@Inndjkaawed2922]

Wrong. Wrong. You can disagree with him but he is very good at what he does

[@Brahman-ology]

Such a terrible speaker. Full of "aahhh"s and "uuuhhh"s. Nothing new or of any significance except some political gossip around finance ministers. And this advocacy for Manmohan Singh is appalling.

[@ChitBits]

What’s this new attempt to elevate MMS? He’s done and dusted. His sweet smile to A Raja was a tell it all. Silently watching the country burn and get destroyed should be sending MMS to the confinements of history with no parole 😡😡😡

[@jvarsani7090]

Whos this clown ? Tax collection and bank account for the masses....!?

[@allamarajuchakrapani4032]

Don't say he is not morally responsible? Do you think only FINANCE minister did not respond till Sucheta dalal unearthed the scam in indian Express ,when Stupid N ram of The Hindu ( Anti Hindu) did not allow to publish in his news paper.