MOHAMMED RAFI Aur TALAT MAHMOOD Jab Ek Doosre ke Aamne Saamne Aa Gaye

[@qalamkaar1984]

Bharat Ratna for Rafi Sahab Gulukaar-e-Azam❤…

[@bittusaini7750]

Mohd Rafi then comes all the singers n musicians ❤

[@30AMARJEET]

Rafi saheb se achha koi gaa hi nahi sakta Bhagwan ka ashirwad tha unke upar

[@agmemonagmemon1113]

All time great only mohmed rafi

[@mdhasanuzzamanmondal4509]

Very good baatein

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thank you

[@deepakmeshram9829]

All are greats

[@AshokKumar-vf7ve]

तलत महमूद साहब का भी कोई जवाब नही।

[@ustadafzaalzahoorahmedsolo8716]

Talat mehmood sahab ka apna andaz tha aur Rafi sahab ka apna andaz tha dono apne apne fan mein mahir they

[@sk.mujibarrahaman5269]

Eliet singer in the world Md Rafi sahab salute to God gifted voice is no compare other than. Talat sahab is very good singer.

[@dbhai6685]

I Love you Rafi Sahab ❤❤

[@mohammedsaleem3507]

Talat Sahib's song in film Jahan Ara is a masterpiece & Madan Sahib's music is eternal, 🎉🎉

[@javeedmd9907]

GOOD VIDEO SACH BOL APPNA JAI HIND JAI HIND AND GREAT MOHD RAFI

[@user-viralshortshub1122]

love talat mehmood respect for both

[@drjamilshaikh7308]

Very good presentation 👏

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thanks a lot

[@lallitasingh616]

Rafi Sahab me inshaniyat hai jo kishi bhi singer me nai hai❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@asifsongs]

Talat Mehmood and Mohammad Rafi are my favourite singers, they can't be compared at all. if Talat mehmood voice moves you , rafi saib's voice makes you excited.

[@suyashkaushal5766]

Itni meethhi hai ye dastan ke bayan karte nahin banta...!!!!!!

[@ejazkiawaz]

Rise and fall has come in the lives of almost all singers. No singer could escape from it. Even Muhammad Rafi, Hemant da, Manna Dey, Mukesh and some other female singers faced the same situation too. The only difference is that some faced it little earlier and some later. But making a comparison of one singer with another will be unfair. All singers gave their best when they were on peak. Every single flower has its own beauty. Talat Mahmood's tone was heavenly and full of pathos.

[@FactZone-v9o]

King Of The Ghazals TALAT MEHMOOD

[@anm4484]

One n only the great mohd Rafi sahab. Others were also good but Rafi sahab is unmatched!

[@pitamberduttsharma1713]

Aap ki aawaz bahut acchhi hai.

[@MKKNR]

Rafi sahab the Best all Round singer

[@binunair9356]

Thanks

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thanks a lot Sir Ji

[@shahidkarimkhan]

Both were super duper

[@AshokKumar-vf7ve]

आप द्वारा संगीतकार और इन दो महान गायको के महान गायकी का विश्लेषण बहुत ही अच्छा लगा।

[@FilmyFaraz]

Dhanyawad

[@yogendrasinghragi9952]

क्या है विश्लेशण हमें भी समझाएं प्लीज

[@DollySangha]

Beautifully narrated.👌🏻👌🏻🙏🙏

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thank you so much

[@anjaiahbathula6510]

Both Play back singers are the utmost in their work no comparison.

[@sunilduttbedar4675]

Nice presentation, to my knowledge “chal ur ja re panchi was first sung by Talat jee” and afterwards by Rafi Sahab. I met with Talat Sahab at his residence on 1st sept. 1988 and talked to him for one hour and 15 minutes. Also I sang a song before him “ Ashkon mein jo pays hai” and Talat Sahab commented that I am listening to my own voice is mein soz bhee hai Kampan bhee hai aap ne kahan se Seekha , I answered that as I grew with understanding your voice has looked after me motherly and transformed my life. Talat’ voice is a Voice of God. Talat Sahab further said if a single person is transformed then my singing is a great success. Thanks Faraz Sahab.

[@FilmyFaraz]

Most welcome sir

[@bubu345]

He sang lively song Tum tho dil ke Taar ched kar

[@asokrk7555]

Depth of voices of Talat & Rafi are no. 1 india film songs history ❤👍🙏💐👌

[@agmemonagmemon1113]

Ek plde me sabhi gayak aur ek plde me rafi saab fir bhi rafi saab ka plda bhari rahega

[@farhadsk7779]

Beshak

[@TahirRafi.u]

Apne bhut achchi khi rafi ji tlt mhmud ji dono apni jghe best hea❤❤❤

[@asokrk7555]

Great comment rarely Pankajroy sir 🙏👌💐

[@zafaralimaktedar7395]

Both singers are emperors of the cinema world.

[@zarinekharshiing2047]

I love Talat Mahmood sahab so very much ❤

[@alialbalushi1405]

Both legends of Bollywood

[@imranshivani2299]

Rafi sahab's voice was adaptable to every mood

[@razzaqrafi8106]

Mohmmed Rafi one

[@mehterazzam4507]

Very well compiled

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thank you

[@asokrk7555]

Talat begins, Rafi accomplished 🙏👌💐👍❤

[@mansoorkhan4822]

Both had beautiful and very attractive voices! Talat Mahmood, Mukesh, Mohammad Rafi, Hemant Kumar, etc. were all golden voices in that period. Each singer gave super songs, but Mohammad Rafi stood out because of his versatility. Late 40’s to early 80’s was the golden era of Indian music and Mohammad Rafi was the leader, and he was the best!

[@bubu345]

Mahendra Kapoor voice is better

[@binunair9356]

Superb Binu Nair Rafi Foundation Trust

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thank you Sir Ji

[@mushtaqahmad-ld7ei]

Both singers were best in their field.

[@FilmyFaraz]

Absolutely right ✅️

[@jawaidtariq3407]

@@FilmyFaraz Talat was a different type of singer mostly sad songs at slow pitch he used to sing but no match with Rafi sb he could sing in every pitch with a soothing voice which not any singer could match or no one in future will sing like Rafi he died in 1980 look now in 2024 if you hear his songs so refreshing soothing no comparison he was just unique

[@indubhatia542]

Both were good, but definitely Rafi Sahab is the Best, no one like him, na bhooto, na bhavishyati ❤

[@bubu345]

Hemant Da Manna Dey Mahendra Kapoor Mehndi Hassan Talat Mukesh equally good

[@ejazbaig681]

You are absolutely right we can't comparison among them. It is impossible.

[@sajjadhussain1573]

NYC ❤️

[@rameshkataria4769]

Good informative video. Please keep it up.

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thanks, will do!

[@kaleempatel]

Very nice information 👌👌👌

[@pondorinaique6335]

Among great no comparison is justifiable , the greats are great in there places ; we mediocre should avoid comparisons.

[@fkhan1732]

All yesteryears singers were good,

[@farooqansari4910]

فراز صاحب متفق ہوں آپ سے اور بہترین جانکاری کو عمدہ انداز میں پیش کیا ھے 🌹🌹

[@FilmyFaraz]

Bahut shukriya

[@talatmahmood2222]

RAFI SAHIB APNI JAGAH BUT TALAT SAHIB KA JAWAB NAHI WHAT A HONEY DIPPED VOICE TOTALLY DIFFERENT AND STILL UNMATCHED ....GREAT TALAT MAHMOOD

[@sherfazal288]

No comparison with M Rafi with any other singer...Rafi was the best .Talat has few gazals only.so Rafi is the best greatest singer of all time... May Allah the greatest bless him good place in Heaven...Aamin.

[@sheikhfayaz1258]

No doubt Talat ji was Legend... But Rafi sb was ultra legend. As his voice was suited for every genre gazal, sad, funny, loving, comedy, qawwali etc. ❤

[@KPRavi-ps1uu]

Just listen to" Chal ud ja re panchi" sung by Rafi sahab & Talat sahab. Even a person with poor knowledge of music will accept that Rafi sahab was miles ahead of all other singers put together.

[@shamsulislam3386]

I like your presentations. The personalities that you talk about are very admirable and your 'andaaz-e- bayaan is very likeable. Please keep up the good work.

[@FilmyFaraz]

Thanks, keep watching

[@tonyroy8123]

Both are legends.

[@AshokKumar-vf7ve]

रफी साहब और तलत महमूद साहब की मैं तुलना नही करना चाहता हूँ। दोनो ही अतुलनीय है।

[@himmsingz]

Talat had an exquisite voice till the early 60’s. Then it deteriorated quickly. Rafi maintained his voice quality till the mid 70s. In the 50’s Talat sang some of his best songs. Rafi’s voice doesn’t compare with Talat’s 50’s voice quality. Rafi had a very clean, versatile voice but Talat’s had that tenderness and silky feel and subtle emotion that Rafi couldn’t equal during Talat’s best days.

[@Foxboye10s34]

The exact fact was superbly explained. Thanks Sir.

[@snigdhachakravarti2647]

Very nice program

[@asifsongs]

I am big fan of Talat Mehmood, but would accept that Talat voice was not made for high notes and that was the only limitation in his voice, otherwise his voice was addictively silky and melodious. On other hand Rafi's voice was equally melodious on Low as well high notes and from the day 1st Rafi Sahib voice was extremely melodious and always had a bola bisra effect which u won't see in any other voice during late 40 and early 50's singers. Muhammad Rafi voice was superbly used by the ultimate Maestro Naushad in 50's and that was the only voice who could do justice to music composed by Naushad especially in high notes i.e. O dunya ke rakhwaley, bedard ko a dil yaad na kar, Insaaf ka mandir hai ye, meri kahani bolney waley and many many more. I personally prefer Rafi Sahib 40's and 50's voice than his late 60's or 70's voice.

[@abdulsheikh9455]

Well done ❤

[@AlexanderAlexander-os9bq]

I like good vary good song A Alexander

[@supermmast]

Janab Haji Mohd Rafi Saheb, the best singer of all time and the most humble human being. No comparison. The Master was so much more versatile as compared to other singers.

[@bubu345]

Not fair to ignore Hemant Manna Dey Mahendra Kapoor Mehndi Hassan Hemant Da Mukesh Talat equally good

[@mohdafzal-cb8dn]

Dleep Kumar aur rajendra Kumar hit flof show plece

[@suranjanchaudhuri5574]

Fact is, HMV took up a project of recording one hit song of an eminent singer by another big one. Hence TM singing Chal ud jaa. It was before the cassette era. The project was soon shelved.

[@babamalik9059]

Comparison is not logical as ghazal is domain of Talat Sb and Rafi Sb,s versatility is unmatchable also Talat,s voice was very special and meant for special people and Rafi,s voice was meant for the world over listeners

[@KhalidMehmood-yt1yw]

Both are great legends but the voice of Jnab Rafi Sahab is unique voice

[@ghulamqadirghulamqadir6035]

Both great singers but talat sahab voice heart touching voice

[@MuhammadKhan-fx6wg]

Mr. Talat Mahmood Sahb

[@fehmidabegum4866]

Good

[@mohammadsalimsayyed5164]

Half of 50's i.e. 1950-55 belonged to Talat Mehmood. All top heroes had Talat Mehmood's voice during this period like Dilip Kumar, Raj Kapoor, Dev Anand Sunil Dutt etc.

[@ejazkiawaz]

Talat Mahmood's period upto 1960.

[@bharatbhumi101]

Chal ud ja re panchhi ...wali baat aap sahi bole. Ek do jagah Mai is baare me logon ki jankari kam hi hai.

[@AshokKumar-vf7ve]

मदन मोहन और नौशाद साहब जैसे संगीतकार युगों-युगों में कभी पैदा होते है।

[@bubu345]

CHITRAGUPTA Roshan Sali Chaudhary Khaiyum

[@dipiti8739]

Talat time songs were soft, sort of Ghazals. the music/tunes too used be soft, all changed with time. By the time Mukesh came and Rafi came, intensity and variations started as there were more films, more actors, last powerful singer was KK. We should be happy to have a wide spectrum. k.L. Saigal, Manna Dey had their great contributions.

[@lallitasingh616]

RAFI SAHAB BAHUT ACHHE INSHAN AUR ACHHE NO.1 SINGER HAI

[@shakeelrufaie993]

Chal ud ja re panchi was recorded first in the voice of Talat sahab, but the producer and director of the film Bhabi insisted to have the song in Rafi' Sahab's voice.Later the song was recorded in Rafi Sahab's voice .Same thing happened in film Aadmi where Talat Sahab's voice was replaced with Mahinder Kapoor Sahab's voice .

[@sedimbiramakrishna3960]

Dont compare thier voices.Just enjoy thier melodious voice.

[@parvezansari1522]

Talat mahmood ke hit gane ko aap ungli par gin sakte hain magar rafi sahab ke hit ganon ko ginna na mumkin hai

[@afzaalsiddiqui4392]

No comparison of great verstile Rafi

[@bharatbhumi101]

S D Burman ji had crafted the tune of "JALTE HAIN JISKE LIYE TERI AANKHON " (Sujata) keeping in view Rafi sahab. But Bimal Roy ji laid stress on Talat Mehmood sahab. And Dada Burman had to give in. Even though the song became so popular (it's my favourite too), Dada wasn't happy with that development. He was so unhappy that never ever did he mention this song. (You may make a programme on it.)

[@FilmyFaraz]

Sure

[@jalaluddinqureshi1949]

طلعت صاحب غزل گایک تھے گانا گانیں والے رفیع کشور تھے

[@waismalik]

Both were unparalleled... so no lion vs tiger here pls.. as in who is greater... who cares ... enjoy them n remember they are FREE GIFT

[@FilmyFaraz]

Absolutely right ✅️ 👏

[@biswadiproychowdhury7126]

Two greats cannot be unparalleled at the same time or in the same profession.....then......it is obviously Rafi saab who surpasses all his contemporaries...👍😏

[@shahidhamid962]

No comparison. If you put all the male playback singers from the Sub Continent on one side and Rafi on the other , Rafi wins 99.999 % to 0.0001 . Rafi's voice is unparalleled.

[@waismalik]

@biswadiproychowdhury7126 yes .. both unparalleled meaning also they were very different in style and delivering 👌.. Talat sahab had an unique voice which he rendered..whilst Rafi sahab had the depth and reached further.. but do not demise one whilst praising the latter...

[@waismalik]

@shahidhamid962 @biswadiproychowdhury7126 yes .. both unparalleled meaning also they were very different in style and delivering 👌.. Talat sahab had an unique voice which he rendered..whilst Rafi sahab had the depth and reached further.. but do not demise one whilst praising the latter... to all Rafi sahabs fans

[@Hubby41972]

Very very sad to say that Madan Mohan has not been considered for Filmfare award. It is a very sad and shameful act done by the film industry.

[@babamalik9059]

Choice of the judges is something else and underlying prejudice and discrimination deprived not only Madan Mohan but also Talat Mahmood and it is a black spot on the face of film fair award.

[@mrizwanjahangir6316]

Two types of singers are there, 1. Rafi saab, 2. All other singers.

[@shamkantchaudhari9085]

😢😢😢😢

[@multimediaalquresh114]

Jb Rafi SahAb Filmo me gaa rehe the to Talt SahAb radio per Gazlen gaa Te the Talt SahAb sin 50 me aaiea the film line me

[@anwarahmad1752]

Jab Talat sahib Bollywood me chhaye hue the, tab Rafi sahib ki shuruaat thi. Rafi sahib Talat Mahmood sahib ko apna ideal maante the. Unhone Talat sahib ki copy kiya phir baad me dhire dhire apni ek alag pahchan va maqam bana liya. Lekin ab aisi dosti kahan jo purane zamane me hua karti thi.

[@ulhasphadtare4083]

Konse gane jo rafi sahabne talat s coppy kiyele jara batana aur 50 ke pahele talat s famous gane batana

[@anwarahmad1752]

@@ulhasphadtare4083gaane to yaad nahi hai, lekin kisi magazine me ye interview padha tha aur maine ek gaane me mahsus kiya hai wo gaana film Aakhri daanv ka - Tujhe kya sunayun mai dilruba tere saamne mera haal hai- - - is gaane me Rafi sahab ki style Talat Mahmood sahab se kafi milti hai

[@ulhasphadtare4083]

Bhaisahab tuzhe kya sunau mai deel ruba bahot bad me ka gana hai usse pahle 10 sal rafi sahabka nam hogayata rafi s use time zarurat nahi thi kisiko follow karneki aur isme main baat dhoon ki hai music directorne jo dhoon banayee usme gana padta hai phir bhi talat sahabse bahot alag gaya hai rafi s ne jada famous bhi hua hai aur ye hawa ye chadani rat bhi bhahot accha hai chalo chodo aisee batome dil nahi lagana sab singer great the sabka anand lete rahena yahi aapna kam hai aur jo aaj nahi hai unke liye bhagwan ke charnome prarthna karna unki aatma ke shanti ke liye

[@anwarahmad1752]

@@ulhasphadtare4083 ok thanks jankari ke liye

[@pankajroy5124]

*TALAT MAHMOOD'S VOICE - HEAVENLY MOHAMMAD RAFI VOICE - EARTHLY*

[@FilmyFaraz]

Both were good singers, but the earthly Rafi Sahab could easily sing the heavenly Talat's song, whereas Talat Sahab couldn't sing Rafi's song with ease

[@tanvirakhtar7704]

​@@FilmyFarazYou have rightly said. Rafi Saheb had been beyond comparison.

[@kiranbegari]

Yes, Rafi could sing a ghazal, but could never create the same impact that Talat created in that genre. He could sing sad songs, but Mukesh was far better. He could sing classical, but Manna Dey was far better. In short, Rafi was a jack of all trades but not king in any.

[@venkateshbelur4742]

Kiran begari

[@venkateshbelur4742]

Kiran bagri your knowledge is limited. I have been listening both singers more than 65 years. Talati mehamood was a great singer limited to only gazals. Whereas Rafi Saab has sung excellent gazals, tragic songs, romantic songs. Qawali and devotional songs.No singer on earth has achieved this feet. The expression he he could produce is unimaginable.

[@anuragmalhotra5054]

chal ud jaa re panchhi was originally sung by Ghantasala, the famous South Indian singer

[@rdkkokm]

No comparison for rafi sahab.Talat Mahmood had smooth voice

[@madhukrishnan1567]

The decision on singer is best left to the music director

[@zaheerjaffery6174]

Ghazlon ka badshah Madan Mohan? You meant Talat Mahmood, right?

[@milindjharkhandi5499]

Kahna kya chahte ho? Kaha shuru kaha khatam😢

[@farhadsk7779]

Abtak duniya me koi singer paidahi nehi hua jo Rafi sahab ke sath comparison kiya ja sakta hai . Talat Mahmood bhi achha singer hai lekin Rafi sahab ka substitution impossible.

[@AslamKhan-q4d]

Bhai jan ap ne guide film ka zikar hi nahi kiya is film main mohd rafi ke gane hain jo dev anand pr filmaye gaye hain music director sd burman hain

[@tarsemmalik.USE-LESS]

That’s the reason Yash Chopra used his music in the movie VEER ZARA even 30 years after Madan Mohan’s demise🙏

[@truptibhale8393]

तलत, मुकेश,मन्ना डे,महेन्द्र कपूर इनकी एकही प्रकारकी स्टाइल थी। लेकीन रफीसाहब की स्टाईल व्हर्सटाइल (बहूरंगी) थी।इसलीए वो ज्यादा पाॅप्यूलर हो गये थे।

[@yousufhussain2659]

Aap pehlay apny zaban main salam keejay doosry zaban main keekay

[@syedmahaboobbasha9652]

Rafi sahab already reached the pinnacle of singing .The comparison with one to another is not good and advisable

[@rocketshoot3027]

Good sermon😅

[@ad.bharatkumar8082]

No comparision between mohd.rafi saahib and Talat mehmood...both are great singers..but it is the only public that places the person on the kingthrone..mohd.rafi saahib's voice quality is totaly uncomparable...

[@MrSahilrizvi]

Mr faraaz bhia baat ka batangad mat banayiye please

[@haiderhussain1311]

AAP KI AAWAZ MEIN FLUENT NAHIH HAI.2QADAM AAGE JATE HAI ,1QADAM PEECHHE AA JATE HAIN

[@FilmyFaraz]

Shukriya batane ke liye

[@harihardutttrivedi3804]

No doubt,Talat was a known Ghazal singer, but lacked in high pitch singing. Rafi had a very wide range. He could sing all types of songs. I don't mean to demean Talat, but none should attempt a comparison between the two. Without any disrespect to Lata ji, I think that Rafi was even a better singer than Lata ji.

[@maqsoodshaikh9417]

Talat Mahmood hero banne ke chakkar me pichhe reh gaye kisor kumar bhi jab tak acting karte the playback singer ke torper itne hit nahi the

[@sanjaymisra815]

Kishore Kumar mahaz acting nahi karte the, wo hero hua karte the tamam top ki heroines ke saath. Fursat nahin thi unke pas.....playback singing karne ki. Sirf Devanand ko chhod kar, Jo unke jigri dost the.